Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
A Revision Petition under Section-19 of the Family Court
Act.
--------------…
Lingaraj Samal
…
Petitioner
…
Opp. Party
-Versus…
Ritanjali Bisoyee
Advocates appeared in the case:
For Petitioner
: Mr. Kadar Mohammad,
Advocate
For Opp. Party
:
-----------------CORAM:
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRUGANKA SEKHAR SAHOO
JUDGMENT
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------Decided on 13th February, 2026
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------MRUGANKA SEKHAR SAHOO, J.
1.
The petitioner-husband in the marriage has filed the
revision
application
challenging
the
judgment
dated
14.05.2025 passed by the learned Judge, Family Court,
Berhampur.
2.
By the said judgment, Crl. No.47 of 2022 filed by the
wife in the marriage under section 125(1) of Cr.P.C. (since
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
repealed and substituted by the parimateria provision
contained in section 144 of BNSS, 2023) came to be allowed.
The learned Judge, Family Court, Berhampur granted
payment of monthly maintenance @ Rs.10,000/- (rupees ten
thousand only) per month from the date of filing of the
application on 08.02.2022, though the amount prayed for
was Rs.20,000/- (rupees twenty thousand only) per month.
Litigation expenses of Rs.2,000/- (rupees two thousand
only) was directed to be paid instead of Rs.15,000/- (rupees
fifteen thousand only) as prayed for.
3.
The petitioner has opted to remain in default of the
direction of payment of Rs.10,000/- (rupees ten thousand
only) per month which is due to be paid from the date of
filing of the application i.e. 08.02.2022.
The total amount due till 08.02.2026 comes to Rs.10,000 x
48 (months) = Rs.4,80,000/- (rupees four lakhs eighty
thousand only).
4.
After the learned counsel for the petitioner has made
submissions, he was asked whether the petitioner is willing
or has secured the amount due that is in the nature of a
money decree for issuance of notice.
In response, learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that as per instructions received from the petitioner, the
petitioner is not willing to pay, he disputes the marriage.
5.
In response thereto, the learned counsel was asked:
while considering an application under section 125 of
Cr.P.C., what is the scope of going into the aspect of
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
marriage if disputed by the husband; the learned counsel in
response refers to section 125 (4) of Cr.P.C. which is
reproduced herein:
“(4) No wife shall be entitled to receive an
3[allowance for the maintenance or the interim
maintenance and expenses of proceeding, as
the case may be,] from her husband under this
section if she is living in adultery, or if, without
any sufficient reason, she refuses to live with
her husband, or if they are living separately by
mutual consent.”
6.
Upon such submission being made, learned counsel
was asked to show before this Court the written statement
of the petitioner disputing the marriage and the evidence
adduced
before
the
learned
Judge,
Family
Court,
Berhampur for consideration by the said Court.
In response, it is submitted that copy of the written
statement has not been provided to the learned counsel for
which he cannot reflect upon the written statement to
answer the query whether the marriage was disputed before
the learned trial Court or not.
7.
Perusal of the impugned judgment indicates that the
issue regarding existence of marriage has been dealt with by
the learned Judge, Family Court, Berhampur in paragraph
10 of the judgment which is reproduced herein:
“10. So far as the entitlement of the petitioner
for maintenance is concerned, the petitioner
being the legally married wife of the O.P. and
when she has proved her inability to maintain
herself and the O.P.- husband who on the other
hand is proved to have neglected to provide for
her maintenance in spite having sufficient
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
means, the O.P. cannot be excused from
discharging his legal obligations only on the
ground of non-consummation of the marriage.
As evident from the evidence of the petitioner
that after one month of her happy married life
she was subjected to torture and harassment
for further dowry. The O.P. and his family
members were not satisfied with the dowry
presented at the time of the marriage. At the
instigations of his sisters, brothers and father
she was subjected to torture by the O.P..
Finally, she was forcibly removed from their
house. Finding no other alternative, she placed
her grievance before Odisha State Commission
for Women. The evidence of the petitioner is
corroborated by the evidence of her mother, who
was examined as P.W.2.
On the other hand, denying the allegations
of torture and harassment, the O.P. advanced
his specific evidence that only two days after
their marriage the petitioner left the matrimonial
home voluntarily deserting this O.P. However,
he has admitted that the petitioner had
approached the Odisha State Commission for
Women and as per the notice from the
Commission he made his appearance and as
per their direction he had pay Rs.3,000/- (Three
Thousands) towards the maintenance of the
petitioner for 25 months. He further testified
that at no point of time the petitioner was
subjected to any torture and harassment and
she was never forcibly driven out from the
matrimonial home. The O.P. has also adduced
the evidence of one of his cousin in support of
his contentions, who was examined as O.P.W.2.
The evidence of the O.P.W.2 corroborates the
evidence of
the O.P.
The Section.125(4) of the Cr.P.C. puts an
embargo on the right of the wife to seek the
relief of maintenance if she is living in adultery,
or if without any sufficient reason she refuses to
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
live with her husband or when they are living
separately by mutual consent.
From the rival contentions it is evident that
the main challenge to the entitlement of the
petitioner is that she has voluntarily left the
house of the O.P. without any sufficient reason.
However, no such plausible reasons are
advanced by the O.P. as to why the petitionerwife would raise false allegations of torture and
harassment against her husband keeping her
marriage and entire future at stake. Further, if
the petitioner-wife had indeed been allowed
with one, conducive atmosphere in her
matrimonial home, she could not have
approached the State Commission for women for
redressal of her grievances. The available
materials on record rather lends credence to the
statement of the petitioner. Hence, it can be
assumed that the separate living by the
petitioner-wife is not by her choice but under
compelling circumstances created by the O.P.
and his family members. So, the petitioner is
absolutely entitled for her claim towards
maintenance.”
8.
From the judgment of the learned trial Court, it can
also be seen that the learned trial Court has relied on the
following evidences:
“Witnesses Examined on behalf of the
petitioner:
P.W.1.
Smt. Ritanjali Bisoyee.
P.W.2.
Smt. Namita Bisoyee.
Witnesses Examined on behalf of the Opp.
Party:
O.P.W.1. Sri Lingaraj Samal.
O.P.W.2. Sri Rajendra Kumar Samal.
List of Exhibits marked for the Petitioner:
Ext.1.
Marriage Invitation Card.
Ext.2 to 2/6. Marriage Photographs of
both the parties.
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
Ext.3.
Joint Photographs of both
the parties.
Ext.4 & 4/1.
Net generated copy of Pay
Slips of the O.P. for the
month of October, 2023 and
November, 2023 respectively.
List of Exhibits marked for the Opp. party:
NIL”
9.
Taking note of the exhibits marked before the learned
Judge, Ext.1- Marriage Invitation Card, Ext.2 to Ext.2/6Marriage Photographs of both the parties and Ext.3-Joint
Photographs of both the parties, the learned counsel was
requested that how the petitioner had disproved or had
made any effort to disprove the said exhibits.
In response, learned counsel for the petitioner has no
immediate answer.
10. From the judgment, it is apparent that no material was
brought before the learned trial Court to disprove the
marriage.
The
statements
of
the
P.W.1
and
P.W.2
substantiated the claim for maintenance. The statements of
O.P.W.1 and O.P.W.2 produced by the petitioner before the
learned trial Court did not enure to his benefits to deny the
claim.
11. The learned trial Court has relied on the Ext.4 &
Ext.4/1, those are copies of the Pay Slips of the petitioner
for the month of October, 2023 and November, 2023
downloaded from the official website to arrive at the source
of income of the petitioner who was the Opp. Party.
12. In Rajnesh v. Neha: (2021) 2 SCC 324, it has been
laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court that the amount
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
directed to be paid in proceedings under section 125 of
Cr.P.C. is in the nature of money decree. The paragraphs of
the said judgment relied upon and applied by this Court for
consideration and adjudication of the case at hand are
reproduced herein (from SCC Print):
“12. Given the backdrop of the facts of the present
case, which reveal that the application for interim
maintenance under Section 125 CrPC has
remained pending before the courts for seven years
now, and the difficulties encountered in the
enforcement of orders passed by the courts, as the
wife was constrained to move successive
applications for enforcement from time to time, we
deem it appropriate to frame guidelines on the
issue of maintenance, which would cover
overlapping jurisdiction under different enactments
for payment of maintenance, payment of interim
maintenance, the criteria for determining the
quantum of maintenance, the date from which
maintenance is to be awarded, and enforcement of
orders of maintenance.
Guidelines/Directions on maintenance
13. Maintenance laws have been enacted as a
measure of social justice to provide recourse to
dependent wives and children for their financial
support, so as to prevent them from falling into
destitution and vagrancy. Article 15(3) of the
Constitution of India provides that:
“15. (3) Nothing in this article shall prevent the State
from making any special provision for women and
children.”
Article 15(3) reinforced by Article 39 of the
Constitution of India, which envisages a positive role
for the State in fostering change towards the
empowerment of women, led to the enactment of
various legislations from time to time.
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
14. Krishna Iyer, J. in his judgment in Ramesh
Chander Kaushal v. Veena Kaushal [Ramesh
Chander Kaushal v. Veena Kaushal, (1978) 4 SCC
70 : 1978 SCC (Cri) 508] held that the object of
maintenance laws is : (SCC p. 74, para 9)
“9. This provision is a measure of social
justice and specially enacted to protect
women and children and falls within the
constitutional sweep of Article 15(3)
reinforced by Article 39. We have no
doubt that sections of statutes calling for
construction by courts are not petrified
print but vibrant words with social
functions to fulfil. The brooding presence
of the constitutional empathy for the
weaker sections like women and children
must inform interpretation if it has to have
social relevance. So viewed, it is possible
to be selective in picking out that
interpretation out of two alternatives
which advances the cause — the cause of
the derelicts.”
xxx
xxx
xxx
38. Proceedings under Section 125 CrPC are
summary in nature. In Bhuwan Mohan Singh v.
Meena [Bhuwan Mohan Singh v. Meena, (2015) 6
SCC 353 : (2015) 3 SCC (Civ) 321 : (2015) 4 SCC
(Cri) 200] this Court held that Section 125 CrPC was
conceived to ameliorate the agony, anguish,
financial suffering of a woman who had left her
matrimonial home, so that some suitable
arrangements could be made to enable her to
sustain herself and the children. Since it is the
sacrosanct duty of the husband to provide financial
support to the wife and minor children, the husband
was required to earn money even by physical
labour, if he is able-bodied, and could not avoid his
obligation, except on any legally permissible ground
mentioned in the statute.
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
39. The issue whether presumption of marriage
arises when parties are in a live-in relationship for a
long period of time, which would give rise to a claim
under Section 125 CrPC came up for consideration
in Chanmuniya v. Virendra Kumar Singh Kushwaha
[Chanmuniya v. Virendra Kumar Singh Kushwaha,
(2011) 1 SCC 141 : (2011) 1 SCC (Civ) 53 : (2011) 2
SCC (Cri) 666. This judgment was referred to a
larger Bench.] before the Supreme Court. It was held
that where a man and a woman have cohabited for
a long period of time, in the absence of legal
necessities of a valid marriage, such a woman
would be entitled to maintenance. A man should not
be allowed to benefit from legal loopholes, by
enjoying the advantages of a de facto marriage,
without undertaking the duties and obligations of
such
marriage.
A
broad
and
expansive
interpretation must be given to the term “wife”, to
include even those cases where a man and woman
have been living together as husband and wife for a
reasonably long period of time. Strict proof of
marriage should not be a precondition for grant of
maintenance under Section 125 CrPC. The Court
relied on the Malimath Committee Report on Reforms
of Criminal Justice System published in 2003, which
recommended that evidence regarding a man and
woman living together for a reasonably long period,
should be sufficient to draw the presumption of
marriage.
xxx
xxx
xxx
II. Payment of Interim Maintenance
62. The proviso to Section 24 of the HMA (inserted
vide Act 49 of 2001 w.e.f. 24-9-2001), and the third
proviso to Section 125 CrPC (inserted vide Act 50 of
2001 w.e.f. 24-9-2001) provide that the proceedings
for interim maintenance, shall as far as possible, be
disposed of within 60 days from the date of service
of notice on the contesting spouse. Despite the
statutory provisions granting a time-bound period for
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
disposal of proceedings for interim maintenance, we
find that applications remain pending for several
years in most of the cases. The delays are caused
by various factors, such as tremendous docket
pressure on the Family Courts, repetitive
adjournments sought by parties, enormous time
taken for completion of pleadings at the interim
stage itself, etc. Pendency of applications for
maintenance at the interim stage for several years
defeats the very object of the legislation.
63. At present, the issue of interim maintenance is
decided on the basis of pleadings, where some
amount of guesswork or rough estimation takes
place, so as to make a prima facie assessment of
the amount to be awarded. It is often seen that both
parties submit scanty material, do not disclose the
correct details, and suppress vital information,
which makes it difficult for the Family Courts to
make an objective assessment for grant of interim
maintenance. While there is a tendency on the part
of the wife to exaggerate her needs, there is a
corresponding tendency by the husband to conceal
his actual income. It has therefore become necessary
to lay down a procedure to streamline the
proceedings, since a dependent wife, who has no
other source of income, has to take recourse to
borrowings from her parents/relatives during the
interregnum to sustain herself and the minor
children,
till
she
begins receiving
interim
maintenance.
xxx
xxx
xxx
(c) Where wife is earning some income
90. The courts have held that if the wife is earning,
it cannot operate as a bar from being awarded
maintenance by the husband. The courts have
provided guidance on this issue in the following
judgments:
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
90.1. In Shailja v. Khobbanna [Shailja v.
Khobbanna, (2018) 12 SCC 199 : (2018) 5 SCC (Civ)
308; See also the decision of the Karnataka High
Court in P. Suresh v. S. Deepa, 2016 SCC OnLine
Kar 8848 : 2016 Cri LJ 4794 (Kar)], this Court held
that merely because the wife is capable of earning,
it would not be a sufficient ground to reduce the
maintenance awarded by the Family Court. The
court has to determine whether the income of the
wife is sufficient to enable her to maintain herself, in
accordance with the lifestyle of her husband in the
matrimonial home. [Chaturbhuj v. Sita Bai, (2008) 2
SCC 316 : (2008) 1 SCC (Civ) 547 : (2008) 1 SCC
(Cri) 356] Sustenance does not mean, and cannot be
allowed to mean mere survival. [Vipul Lakhanpal v.
Pooja Sharma, 2015 SCC OnLine HP 1252 : 2015
Cri LJ 3451].
90.2. In Sunita Kachwaha v. Anil Kachwaha [Sunita
Kachwaha v. Anil Kachwaha, (2014) 16 SCC 715 :
(2015) 3 SCC (Civ) 753 : (2015) 3 SCC (Cri) 589] the
wife had a postgraduate degree, and was employed
as a teacher in Jabalpur. The husband raised a
contention that since the wife had sufficient income,
she would not require financial assistance from the
husband. The Supreme Court repelled this
contention, and held that merely because the wife
was earning some income, it could not be a ground
to reject her claim for maintenance.
90.3. The Bombay High Court in Sanjay Damodar
Kale v. Kalyani Sanjay Kale [Sanjay Damodar Kale
v. Kalyani Sanjay Kale, 2020 SCC OnLine Bom 694]
while relying upon the judgment in Sunita
Kachwaha [Sunita Kachwaha v. Anil Kachwaha,
(2014) 16 SCC 715 : (2015) 3 SCC (Civ) 753 : (2015)
3 SCC (Cri) 589] , held that neither the mere
potential to earn, nor the actual earning of the wife,
howsoever meagre, is sufficient to deny the claim of
maintenance.
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
90.4. An able-bodied husband must be presumed to
be capable of earning sufficient money to maintain
his wife and children, and cannot contend that he is
not in a position to earn sufficiently to maintain his
family, as held by the Delhi High Court in Chander
Parkash v. Shila Rani [Chander Parkash v. Shila
Rani, 1968 SCC OnLine Del 52 : AIR 1968 Del 174] .
The onus is on the husband to establish with
necessary material that there are sufficient grounds
to show that he is unable to maintain the family,
and discharge his legal obligations for reasons
beyond his control. If the husband does not disclose
the exact amount of his income, an adverse
inference may be drawn by the court.
90.5. This Court in Shamima Farooqui v. Shahid
Khan [Shamima Farooqui v. Shahid Khan, (2015) 5
SCC 705 : (2015) 3 SCC (Civ) 274 : (2015) 2 SCC
(Cri) 785] cited the judgment in Chander Parkash
[Chander Parkash v. Shila Rani, 1968 SCC OnLine
Del 52 : AIR 1968 Del 174] with approval, and held
that the obligation of the husband to provide
maintenance stands on a higher pedestal than the
wife.
(d) Maintenance of Minor children
91. The living expenses of the child would include
expenses for food, clothing, residence, medical
expenses, education of children. Extra coaching
classes or any other vocational training courses to
complement the basic education must be factored in,
while awarding child support. Albeit, it should be a
reasonable
amount
to
be
awarded
for
extracurricular/coaching classes, and not an overly
extravagant amount which may be claimed.
92. Education expenses of the children must be
normally borne by the father. If the wife is working
and earning sufficiently, the expenses may be
shared proportionately between the parties.
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
xxx
xxx
xxx
Discussion and Directions on Enforcement of
orders of Maintenance
125. The order or decree of maintenance may be
enforced like a decree of a civil court, through the
provisions which are available for enforcing a money
decree, including civil detention, attachment of
property, etc. as provided by various provisions of
the CPC, more particularly Sections 51, 55, 58, 60
read with Order 21.
126. Striking off the defence of the respondent is an
order which ought to be passed in the last resort, if
the courts find default to be wilful and
contumacious,
particularly
to
a
dependent
unemployed wife, and minor children. Contempt
proceedings for wilful disobedience may be initiated
before the appropriate court.
xxx
xxx
xxx
(c) Criteria for determining the quantum of
maintenance
130. For determining the quantum of maintenance
payable to an applicant, the court shall take into
account the criteria enumerated in Part B — III of the
judgment. The aforesaid factors are however not
exhaustive, and the court concerned may exercise
its discretion to consider any other factor(s) which
may be necessary or of relevance in the facts and
circumstances of a case.
(d) Date from which maintenance is to be
awarded
131. We make it clear that maintenance in all cases
will be awarded from the date of filing the
application for maintenance, as held in Part B — IV
above.
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
(e)
Enforcement/Execution
maintenance
of
orders
of
132. For enforcement/execution of orders of
maintenance, it is directed that an order or decree of
maintenance may be enforced under Section 28-A of
the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955; Section 20(6) of the
DV Act; and Section 128 of CrPC, as may be
applicable. The order of maintenance may be
enforced as a money decree of a civil court as per
the provisions of the CPC, more particularly Sections
51, 55, 58, 60 read with Order 21.
xxx
xxx
xxx
134. A copy of this judgment be communicated by
the Secretary General of this Court, to the Registrars
of all High Courts, who would in turn circulate it to
all the District Courts in the States. It shall be
displayed on the website of all District
Courts/Family
Courts/Courts
of
Judicial
Magistrates for awareness and implementation.”
[underlined to supply emphasis]
13. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that though
the petitioner is not willing to secure the amount awarded
by the learned trial Court, notice by this Court to the Opp.
Party in the present revision application can be issued.
The said submission being untenable in law in view of
the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Rajnesh v. Neha
(supra) has to be and is rejected. For sustaining the
challenge the petitioner has to do his part and secure the
decree as mandated by law and precedence.
14. In the judgment rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Shamima Farooqui v. Shahid Khan: (2015) 5
SCC 705: (at paragraph 20 of SCC Print), the scope of
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
interference by the High Court in exercise of revisional
jurisdiction has been delineated which are reproduced
herein:
“20. In the instant case, as is seen, the High Court
has reduced the amount of maintenance from Rs.
4000 to Rs. 2000. As is manifest, the High Court
has become oblivious of the fact that she has to stay
on her own. Needless to say, the order of the
learned Family Judge is not manifestly perverse.
There is nothing perceptible which would show that
order is a sanctuary of errors. In fact, when the
order is based on proper appreciation of evidence on
record, no Revisional Court should have interfered
with the reason on the base that it would have
arrived at a different or another conclusion. When
substantial justice has been done, there was no
reason to interfere. There may be a shelter over her
head in the parental house, but other real expenses
cannot be ignored. Solely because the husband had
retired, there was no justification to reduce the
maintenance by 50%. It is not a huge fortune that
was showered on the wife that it deserved
reduction. It only reflects the non-application of mind
and, therefore, we are unable to sustain the said
order.”
[underlined to supply emphasis]
15. Though the case is listed for fresh admission,
in
considered opinion of this Court for issuing notice to the
opposite party-wife, this Court has to apply the tests laid
down in Shamima Farooqui (supra) and has to satisfy itself
prima facie the order dated 15.09.2025 should indicate that:
(i) whether the order passed by the learned Family
Judge is manifestly perverse;
(ii) whether there is anything perceptible which is
to show that the order is sanctuary of errors;
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
(iii) whether the
order is based
on proper
appreciation of evidence on record;
(iv) even if all the above three points are answered
in favour of the petitioner who is challenging, the
revisional Court should not interfere because the
revisional Court would arrive at a different or
another conclusion;
(v) whether substantial justice has been done by
the learned court which has passed the order.
16. Now considering the case at hand the answer has to be
and is ‘no’ for all the propositions enumerated above.
Rather, it is found that the order passed by the learned
court which is impugned is based on proper appreciation of
evidence on record and substantial justice has been done.
Further the petitioner is not inclined to secure the
amount directed to be paid to the opposite party-wife and
the child from the wedlock during pendency of this petition.
17. Applying the said parameters as laid down by the
Hon'ble Apex Court in Shamima Farooqui (supra), it has to
be held that this Court cannot interfere in the judgment,
prima facie there being no material to do so.
Further, the unwillingness of the petitioner to honor
the decree without any reasonable ground or cause and also
the unwillingness to secure the amount awarded before this
Court for prosecuting the revision comes in the way of the
matter being entertained.
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
The judgment that is being rendered does not affect
the rights of the Opp. Party in any manner for which notices
are not issued to Opp. Party.
18. The petition is dismissed being devoid of any merit.
19. Copy of this judgment shall be forwarded to the
learned Judge, Family Court, Berhampur to be kept in the
records of the Criminal Proceeding No.47 of 2022.
(Mruganka Sekhar Sahoo)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
The 13th February, 2026/Rajesh
Digitally Signed
Signed by: RAJESH KUMAR BADHEI
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 07-Mar-2026 19:13:27
RPFAM No.406 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review