Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
DATED : 27th MAY, 2020
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH :
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bail Appln. No.04 of 2020
Petitioner/Accused
:
Raj Kumar Gupta
versus
:
Respondent
State of Sikkim
Bail Appln. No.05 of 2020
:
Petitioner/Accused
Achhay Lal Gupta
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
Bail Appln. No.06 of 2020
:
Petitioner/Accused
Lila Bahadur Chettri
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
Petitions under Section 439 read with Section 482
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Tarun Choudhury, Advocate for the Petitioners/Accused
Persons.
Mr. Yadev Sharma, Additional Public Prosecutor and Mr. Sujan
Sunwar, Assistant Public Prosecutor for the State-Respondent.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
These three Bail Petitions are being disposed of by
a common Order, emanating as they do from a common FIR.
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
2.
vs. State of Sikkim
The FIR, Annexure 1, registered as Melli P.S. Case
No.11/2020, dated 24-04-2020, under Section 7/9/14 of the
Sikkim Anti Drugs Act, 2006 (for short, “SADA, 2006”) read
with Section 7(1)(b)/7(4) [sic] of the Sikkim Anti Drugs
(Amendment) Act, 2017,
was lodged by Sub-Inspector Melli
Police Station before the Station House Officer, Melli P.S. on
24-04-2020, upon information from Assistant Sub-Inspector
Durga Prasad Gurung deployed at Melli Check Post, that on
routine checking of incoming and outgoing vehicles at Melli
Check Post, a truck bearing registration No.SK 04 D 0794 was
intercepted at the check post. The vehicle was carrying poultry
feed for which the driver furnished the relevant bill.
Further
checking of the vehicle led to the discovery of some boxes of
medicines for two medical Stores at Melli Bazaar, namely, M/s.
Jawahar Lall Gupta Medical Store and M/s. Achhay Lal Gupta
Medical Store.
On opening one of the boxes, controlled
substances being Cough Syrup was suspected to be in the said
boxes.
Thereafter, a search of the vehicle was conducted by
the SI in the presence of two independent witnesses and the
Sub-Divisional Police Officer (SDPO), Jorethang in terms of the
provisions of Section 22 of the SADA, 2006.
36 (thirty-six)
bottles of Rexdryl Cough Syrup each containing 100 ml. were
recovered from the truck on such search pursuant to which the
FIR came to be lodged.
3.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner advancing his
submissions for the Petitioner Raj Kumar Gupta, in Bail Appln.
No.04 of 2020, contended that although the truck was
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
vs. State of Sikkim
authorised only to carry poultry feed, yet the Petitioner who
runs a duly licensed medical store at Melli had requested the
truck owner to instruct the driver to bring some medicines
which were urgently required in his shop. That, owing to the
pandemic and the
restricted
movement of vehicles,
the
Petitioner was unable to procure the medicines which were
required by the public at large or any other vehicle to ferry the
goods.
On the day of the search and seizure of the vehicle,
i.e., 24-04-2020, 36 bottles of controlled Cough Syrup were
found in the truck along with the other medicines in 24 cartons,
requisitioned by the Petitioner and co-accused Achhay Lal
Gupta, duly supplied by M/s. Sunrise Distributors, Siliguri.
That, the driver had forgotten to carry the bills prepared by the
said supplier when he had picked up the said medicines along
with the controlled substances which were also included in the
bill. That, Annexure 8 to the Petition is certified to be a true
copy of the bill, dated 23-04-2020, furnished by M/s. Sunrise
Distributors reflecting the name of the 14 other medicines,
besides the Cough Syrup listed at serial no.15 therein with
payment made. That, although the bill could not be furnished
on 24-04-2020 the Petitioner sought time from the Police and
furnished it on 25-04-2020, the very next day.
That, this bill
was duly verified by the I.O. from the Distributor and found to
be genuine.
That, the Licence, Annexure 5, issued to M/s.
Jawahar
Gupta
Lall
by
the
Health
and
Family
Welfare
Department, Drugs and Cosmetic Cell, Government of Sikkim,
under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940, permitted sale of all
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
vs. State of Sikkim
categories of drugs including Schedule “H” Drugs of the Drugs
and Cosmetics Rules, 1945, except the drugs listed at Schedule
C and C(1) of the said Rules and covered the requirements of
Section 7 of the SADA, 2006. Consequently, on the bill having
been furnished, it is evident that the Petitioner had committed
no offence as booked and deserves to be enlarged on bail.
That, the Petitioner is a permanent resident of Melli Bazaar,
conducting his ancestral business therein besides being a
respectable citizen with no criminal antecedents.
Hence, the
question of him absconding does not arise. That, the Petitioner
undertakes to abide by any condition imposed by this Court
should he be enlarged on bail.
4.
In the case of Achhay Lal Gupta, Petitioner in Bail
Appln. No.05 of 2020, it was submitted by Learned Counsel
that he is the owner of a medical shop by the name M/s.Achhay
Lal Gupta Medical Store at Melli Bazaar, licensed vide Annexure
5 to sell all drugs including Schedule “H” drugs under the Drugs
and Cosmetics Rules, 1945, excluding Schedule C and C(1) of
the said Rules.
That, the Licence, Annexure 5, was issued to
the Petitioner by the Health and Family Welfare Department,
Drugs and Cosmetic Cell, Government of Sikkim. The Petitioner
was arrested by the Police only for the reason that the driver,
Lila Bahadur Chettri, of the truck (Petitioner in Bail Appln.
No.06 of 2020), had stated that the medicines belonged to Raj
Kumar Gupta and Achhay Lal Gupta. However, the medicines
ordered by the instant Petitioner Achhay Lal Gupta and
transported in the truck, had the requisite bill indicating the
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
vs. State of Sikkim
purchase of all the medicines for his Medical Store and there
were infact no controlled substances in his consignment.
bottles of Cough Syrup belonged to Raj Kumar Gupta as duly
admitted by him to the Police for which the bill was also
furnished the next day by Raj Kumar Gupta.
The Police on due
verification released the medicines pertaining to the requisition
of M/s. Achhay Lal Gupta Medical Store, however despite
release of the medicines on due verification of the bill, the
Petitioner Achhay Lal Gupta was taken into custody, sans
connection
between
the
Petitioner
substances carried in the truck.
and
the
controlled
The Petitioner is also a
permanent resident of Melli Bazaar, South Sikkim, running his
business of medicines, has no criminal antecedents and
therefore the question of his absconsion does not arise. That,
he will abide by all conditions imposed by the Court should he
be enlarged on bail.
5.
So far as the Petitioner in Bail Appln. No.06 of 2020
Lila Bahadur Chettri is concerned it is admitted by Learned
Counsel for the Petitioner that the truck which the Petitioner
was driving was only authorised to carry poultry feed but out of
magnanimity and in consideration of the ongoing pandemic and
the directions of his owner and the Petitioner himself being of
the belief that the medication was required for the general good
agreed to carry the medication for the stores of both Raj Kumar
Gupta and Achhay Lal Gupta.
That, he had no mens rea
whatsoever and was unaware of the contents of the cartons. In
any event, 36 bottles of Rexdryl are duly accounted for and
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
vs. State of Sikkim
were brought to be sold by licensed medical shops in Melli as
established by the bills furnished by the other two Petitioners,
in Bail Appln. Nos.04 and 05 of 2020, who had been summoned
to the Police Station on him having informed the Police that the
consignment
Petitioners.
of
medicines
belonged
to
the
other
two
That, he is a permanent resident of Melli, South
Sikkim and will not abscond nor does he have criminal
antecedents and is willing to cooperate with investigation and
all conditions imposed by this Court.
6.
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor while opposing
the Petitions filed by the three Petitioners admits that the
medicines ordered by Achhay Lal Gupta were found to be duly
billed and the medicines and the bill released to the said
Petitioner.
However, the involvement of the Petitioner in the
instant matter is clear as the driver had mentioned his name
and stated that he had been requested to carry the controlled
substances by the said Petitioner Achhay Lal Gupta. That, so
far as the Petitioner Raj Kumar Gupta is concerned although the
bill pertaining to
36 bottles of Cough Syrup containing
controlled substances was furnished it was only after the FIR
was lodged and the recovery and seizures made, indicating
mens rea on the part of the Petitioner, besides it cannot be
ruled out that the document is a false one. That, on account of
the pandemic, the Investigating Officer has not been able to
verify by going in person to M/s. Sunrise Distributors, Siliguri
as to whether Annexure 8, being the bill issued to M/s. Jawahar
Lall Gupta Medical Store is a genuine bill or not. So far as the
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
vs. State of Sikkim
driver, Lila Bahadur Chettri is concerned, the Petitioner was
well aware that he was carrying the controlled substances
besides being unauthorised to carry the said medicines the
permission only having been granted to carry poultry feed.
Hence, in view of the involvement of all the Petitioners in the
matter under Section 7/9/14 of the Sikkim Anti Drugs Act,
2006 (for short, “SADA, 2006”) and Section 7(1)(b)/7(4) of the
Sikkim Anti Drugs (Amendment) Act, 2017, the Petitions for
bail filed each of them be rejected.
7.
The submissions of Learned Counsel for the parties
were heard in extenso and given due consideration.
I have
carefully perused all documents on record.
8.
The FIR, Annexure 1, indicates that the Petitioners
were booked under Section 7/9/14 of the SADA, 2006 read with
Section 7(1)(b)/7(4) of the Sikkim Anti Drugs (Amendment)
Act, 2017.
Pausing here momentarily, it is necessary to clarify
that Section 7 of the SADA, 2006, reads as follows;
“CHAPTER III
PROHIBITION, CONTROL AND REGULATION
Prohibition of certain operations
7.
No person shall –
(a)
sale, stock for sale or trade in any
controlled substance; or
(b)
transport either inter-State
intra-State any controlled substance,
or
Without a valid license under the Drugs
and Cosmetics Act, 1940 or Sikkim Trade
License Act:
Provided that, and subject to the other
provisions of the Act and the rules made
thereunder, the possession of verifiable
quantities, as prescribed in the rules of
controlled substances for medicinal purposes
with a valid prescription, or for a legal use of
the substance, shall be permissible:
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
vs. State of Sikkim
Provided further that the amount of
controlled substance in possession shall not be
beyond the limit prescribed in prescription
slip/card, or in cases of other substances other
than drugs, the amount permissible shall be
proportionate to its purported use.”
9.
By the Sikkim Anti Drugs (Amendment) Act, 2017,
in Chapter IV pertaining to Offences and Penalties, Section 9
which deals with punishment for contravention of controlled
substances, of the SADA, 2006, came to be substituted by the
following;
“Substitution
of Section 9
7.
In the Principal Act, for Section 9, the following
Section shall be substituted, namely:“9.(1)
Whoever, in contravention of any provision
of this Act or any rule or order made
thereunder, manufactures, possesses, sells,
purchases, transports, imports inter-State,
exports inter-State or uses,(a) where the contravention involves small
quantity, with rigorous imprisonment
for a term which shall not be less than
two years but may extend to five
years and shall also be liable to pay
fine which shall not be less than
twenty thousand rupees but may
extend to fifty thousand rupees;
(b) where the contravention involves large
quantity, with rigorous imprisonment
for a term which shall not be less than
seven years but may extend to ten
years and shall also be liable to pay
fine which shall not be less than fifty
thousand rupees but may extend to
one lakh rupees;
(c)
(2)
where the contravention involves
commercial quantity, with rigorous
imprisonment which shall not be less
than ten years but may extend to
fourteen years and shall also be liable
to pay fine which shall not be less than
one lakh rupees but may extend to
two lakh rupees.
……………………………………………………………………..
(3)
……………………………………………………………………..
(4)
Where the contravention involves a person
using a mode of transport or any other form
of conveyance, either inter-State or intraState, such person shall be liable to
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
vs. State of Sikkim
imprisonment for a term which shall not be
less than ten years but which may extend
to fourteen years and shall also be liable to
fine which shall not be less than one lakh
but may extend to ten lakhs rupees and the
conveyance as used, shall be liable to be
seized and confiscated, which may be
released on payment in the following
manner:(a) Heavy motor vehicle – Rupees two lakhs
(b) Light motor vehicle – Rupees one lakh
(c) Two-or-three wheeled –
thousand
Rupees fifty
(d) Any other form of conveyance
Rupees twenty-five thousand
(5)
–
……………………………………………………………………..”
During the substitution of Section 9 made vide the Act of
21 of 2017 with effect from 19-09-2017, it is seen that the
number 7 appears a little above the substituted Section 9.
In
this regard, it appears that there is some confusion in the FIR
pertaining to the provisions of the SADA, 2006 the Petitioners
having been booked under Section 7/9/14 of the SADA, 2006
and
Section
7(1)(b)/7(4)
of
the
Sikkim
Anti
Drugs
(Amendment) Act, 2017. The numerical 7 appearing a little
above Section 9 does not denote a Section but is the serial
number, inserted to indicate the substitution of Section 9 by
the said amending Act. Infact, there is no Section 7(1)(b) or
Section 7(4) for the reasons enumerated hereinabove and
ought to be read as Section 9 and its Sub-Sections, the
amending Act of 2017 having substituted Section 9 and not
Section 7.
The air having been cleared on this aspect, I
proceed to examine the matter at hand.
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
10.
vs. State of Sikkim
The FIR, Annexure 1, is dated 24-04-2020. The FIR
records inter alia as follows;
“9.
Particulars of properties stolen/involved
(Attach separate sheet):
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
36 bottles of 100 ml REXDRYL cough syrup
batch no.04320-5MB2.
Truck SK 04 D 0794 (Ecomet).
160 bags of poultry feeds.
24 Nos. of boxes containing medicines with
respective bills.”
The Prosecution case is that 36 bottles of Rexdryl Cough
Syrup of 100 ml. each are controlled substances transported
into Sikkim in violation of the provisions of the SADA, 2006.
On perusal of the portion supra of the FIR, at this juncture, it
cannot but be remarked that the FIR itself appears to contradict
the Prosecution case since admittedly the 34 boxes containing
medicines had their respective bills and thereby were accounted
for. Infact, the FIR also reflects inter alia as follows;
“………………………………………………
Subsequently, the involved vehicle was searched
as per the provision laid down u/s 22 of SADA
2006 in order to avoid any further delay in action.
The
search
of
vehicle
in
presence
of
aforementioned witnesses and SDPO Jorethang
who arrived at the PO consequent to the
information relayed to him led to the recovery of
36 bottles of 100 ml REXDRYL cough syrup batch
no.04320-5MB2 (sic) from the cabin of the
aforementioned truck which was seized along with
the truck b/r No SK 04D0794 (Ecomet), its
document & key, 160 bags of poultry feed and 24
Nos. of boxes
respective bills.
containing
………………………………”
11.
medicines
with
[emphasise supplied]
It is the Prosecution case that the Petitioners Raj
Kumar Gupta and Achhay Lal Gupta were summoned to the
Check Post requiring them to furnish the valid bills for the
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
seized controlled substances.
vs. State of Sikkim
It is admitted that Achhay Lal
Gupta furnished the required bills consequent upon which his
consignment was released to him by the Police. Despite such
steps having been taken by the Police on due verification of the
required bill, the Petitioner Achhay Lal Gupta was taken into
custody by the Police revealing a bizarre situation.
The
Petitioner Raj Kumar Gupta admittedly sought time and
furnished the computer generated bill Annexure 8, dated 2304-2020, which revealed the requisition of 36 bottles of Rexdryl
from M/s. Sunrise Distributors, Siliguri, duly paid. Serial No.15
of the said bill indicates that 36 bottles of Rexdryl had also
been ordered by him from the said Distributors.
The FIR as
already seen was lodged on 24-04-2020, the bill, Annexure 8,
was generated on 23-04-2020 and furnished on 25-04-2020 to
the Police.
12.
The Licence, Annexure 5, respectively of both the
Petitioners, Raj Kumar Gupta and Achhay Lal Gupta, have been
perused duly by me, wherein it is indicated that both Petitioners
have been authorised to sell all medicines
except that in
Schedule C and C(1) of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945.
A month has elapsed since the date of arrest and confinement
of the Petitioners in judicial custody, yet it is the case of the
Prosecution that the authenticity of the bill Annexure 8 is yet to
be verified by the I.O. The Prosecution case is that due to the
prevailing pandemic the I.O. has not been able to travel in
person to make the verification from the Distributors. There is
no clarity from the side of the Prosecution as to whether the
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
vs. State of Sikkim
verification has ever been made telephonically by the I.O. and
if the answer is in the negative, then why is it so? Learned
Counsel for the Petitioners has contended that the bill was
found to be genuine on such verification by the I.O. from the
Distributors.
13.
The Petitioner Lila Bahadur Chettri and the owner of
the truck, I find are guilty of having flouted the provisions of
the permission granted to them for carrying poultry feed only
and no other materials. Suffice it however to state here that no
steps have been envisaged in this regard by the concerned
authorities so far as facts before this Court disclose and thus
require no discussion.
The said Petitioner is oblivious of the
contents of the cartons and has followed the directions of his
employer in transporting the goods in the cartons.
At this
juncture, no mens rea has been made out against him.
14.
Consequently, on consideration of all facts and
circumstances placed before this Court, I am of the considered
opinion that the Petitioners can be enlarged on bail.
It is
accordingly ordered as follows;
(i)
The Petitioners, Raj Kumar Gupta in Bail Appln.
No.04 of 2020,
Achhay Lal Gupta in Bail Appln.
No.05 of 2020 and Lila Bahadur Chettri in Bail
Appln. No.06 of 2020, be enlarged on each of them
furnishing PB&SB
of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees fifty
thousand) only, each.
(ii)
They shall report to the I.O. of the case as and
when required until completion of investigation.
Bail Appln. Nos.04, 05 and 06 of 2020
Raj Kumar Gupta and Others
(iii)
vs. State of Sikkim
They shall not make attempts to contact any
witness pertaining to the instant matter.
(iv)
They shall not directly or indirectly make any
inducement, threat or promise to any person
acquainted with the facts of the case so as to
dissuade him/them to disclose such facts to the
Investigating Officer or to the Court.
(v)
They shall remain at Melli and may leave station
only with the specific written permission of the I.O.
of the Case.
15.
The observations made herein are only for the
purposes of the instant Bail Petitions and shall not be construed
as findings on the merits of the matter, which shall be
considered at the time of trial, if any.
16.
The Bail Applications stand disposed of accordingly.
17.
Copy of this Order be made available to all the
Special Judges (Sikkim Anti Drugs Act, 2006) for information.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
27-05-2020
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review