Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
HCP No. 124/2025
Reserved on: 12.02.2026
Date of
pronouncement:19.02.2026
Date of uploading: 19.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced Full
Liaqat Ali @ Liaqatu, Age 34 years
s/o Sharief Mohd. R/o Korepunnu,
Tehsil Marheen District Kathua
presently lodged in District Jail,
Udhampur, through his mother Mst.
Balo Bibi, Age 55 years w/o Sharief
Mohd R/o Village Korepunnu Tehsil
Marheen District Kathua.
….. Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Usman Salaria, Advocate.
q
vs
01. UT of Jammu and Kashmir through
Principal Secretary, Home Department,
Government of J&K, (UT), Civil
Secretariat Jammu/Srinagar.
.…. Respondent(s)
02.Divisional Commissioner, Jammu,
Rail Head Complex, Jammu, J&K.
03.Superintendent District Jail,
Udhampur.
04.Senior Superintendent of Police,
Kathua.
Through: Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SEKHRI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
The petitioner through his mother has invoked writ jurisdiction of this
Court for the quashment of detention order No. PITNDPS 12 of 2025
dated
15.03.2025,
passed
by
respondent
No.2-Divisional
Commissioner, Jammu, vide which, he came to be detained.
02.
Background facts of the case are that SSP, Kathua, vide his letter
dated 25.02.2025 submitted a dossier whereby four criminal cases
under NDPS Act were elaborated against the petitioner. Though, he
was bailed out in said cases, but it was alleged that he was a habitual
drug trafficker and was still active in Drug trafficking in district
Kathua. Case was examined on the basis of various parameters and it
was found that his continuous illegal activities of drug peddling were
detrimental, as such, SSP, Kathua recommended for appropriate
orders under Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988 (PITNDPS). The respondentdetaining authority on the perusal of this dossier and recommendation
of District screening committee has come to the conclusion that
detenue was engaged in repeated Drug trafficking, which posed a
great threat to the health and welfare of the people, therefore with a
view to prevent him from indulging in similar activities, he passed the
impugned order, whereby petitioner was directed to be detained.
03.
Petitioner has questioned the impugned order, inter alia, on the
following grounds:
a. That the Detention order passed by the respondent No. 2
deserves to be quashed on the ground that the detaining
authority while passing the detention order has not applied
its mind and has passed the detention order against the
petitioner dated 15-03-2025 in a casual manner, the
detaining authority has in his detention order stated in para
HCP No. 124/2025
Page No. 2
No. 3 that the dozier submitted by the respondent No. 4 that
a case was challaned before the District and Sessions Court,
Pathankot on 19-06-2023 in FIR No. 5/2023 under section
15/29/61/85 of NDPS Act which is incorrect, in fact, on the
date of passing of detention order dated 15-03-2025.
Petitioner was already acquitted of the charges under the
offences as stated in FIR No. 5/2023. As such, the order of
detention deserves to be quashed and the petitioner
deserves to be set at large.
b. For that the other offences in FIR as stated in the dozier
submitted by the respondent No. 4, the case is still pending
before the court of learned sessions judge, Kathua and the
case vide FIR No. 259/2024 of P/S Rajbagh, Kathua which
is under investigation, as such, trial/investigation doesn’t
mean that the petitioner has committed the offence and his
detention is in the interest to public. Moreover, the
principle of “Innocent until proven guilty” should have
been followed, as such, the detention order deserves to be
quashed.
c. For that the respondent No. 1 has been approached by way
of representation but the respondent No. 1 has neither
communicated nor decided the representation pending
disposal before the respondent No. 1 since 01-08-2025 and
no consideration of the representation of the detenue dated
01-08-2025 by the respondent No. 1 is infringement of
Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India, as such, the
detention order passed by the respondent No. 1 is vitiated
and deserves to be quashed. Copy of the representation and
postal receipts is enclosed herewith and marked as
Annexure-V. The respondent No. 1 is duty bound to
communicate the reply and decision taken on the
representation pending disposal before the respondent No.
HCP No. 124/2025
Page No. 3
1, the respondent No. 1 has pigeon holed the representation
which is against law. A citizen who is detained for the
period of more than 5 months has the right to know about
the decision taken by the respondent No. 1 in his
representation nor communicated to the petitioner in the
language he understands and the detention order is also
vitiated as the material relied upon by the respondents has
never been furnished to the petitioner which clearly shows
failure on the part of detaining authority and is also
attracted by section 13 of the J&K Public Safety Act, as
such, detention order deserves to be quashed.
d. For that the respondents are duty bound under law where
civil/personal liberties of a citizen has been curtailed to
take all precautions that the law of Natural justice and
fundamental rights of a citizen are not infringed but in the
instant case the respondents have not adhered to all these
norms and have violated the principles of Rule of natural
justice and Fundamental rights as enshrined in Article 14
and 21 of the Constitution of India and have also not
adhered to the provisions of Section 13 of Public Safety
Act.
e. That rest of the grounds as may be available to the
petitioner under law will be urged at the time of arguments.
04.
The respondent-detaining authority in its counter affidavit is affront
with the contention that none of the constitutional, legal or statutory
right of the petitioner has been infringed and they have complied with
all the statutory requirements and constitutional obligations before
issuance of the impugned order of detention against him. It is
contended that petitioner came to be detained after due compliance of
HCP No. 124/2025
Page No. 4
constitutional guarantees and keeping in mind the object of preventive
detention, which is not punitive in nature. The dossier submitted by
SSP, Kathua was carefully examined and on the basis of relevant
record attached with the dossier, it was found imperative to detain the
petitioner under the provisions of PITNDPS Act because ordinary law
of land had failed to deter him from indulging in similar activities.
05.
It is further contention of the respondents that at the time of execution
of impugned detention order, the executing officer provided 145
leaves of all the relevant documents along with detention order and
grounds of detention to the petitioner, those were read over and
explained to him in the language which he understands. He was also
informed about his right to make representation before the Home
Department and detaining authority. The detenue filed representation
dated 31.07.2025 against the impugned order, which was considered
by respondent No. 1-Home Department, but it was found without
merit and was disposed of which was forwarded to SSP, Kathua by
the detaining authority- respondent No. 2 for onward service upon the
detenue.
06.
It is thus contended that since detenue was continuously involved in
illicit trafficking of Drugs, even after getting bails from various
Courts, the impugned detention order issued by respondent No. 2 was
confirmed by the Home Department on 01.05.2025 after opinion of
the Advisory Board dated 25.04.2025. Respondents have prayed for
dismissal of the petition.
HCP No. 124/2025
Page No. 5
07.
Having heard rival contentions of the parties, I have given my
thoughtful consideration to the facts and circumstances obtaining the
case.
08.
From a perusal of the grounds of detention, it is manifest that
impugned detention order traces its origin to four criminal cases
under NDPS Act against the petitioner. Admitted position of fact is
that he was bailed out in all the cases. However, the detaining
authority is of the view that detenue was a habitual drug trafficker. He
is still active in illicit Drug trafficking in district Kathua, which poses
a great threat to health and welfare of the people, therefore with a
view to prevent him from indulging in similar activities and to secure
health and welfare of public at large, it had become imperative to
detain him.
09.
The petitioner, at the outset, has questioned the impugned order on
the ground that it is bad for non-application of mind on the part of
detaining authority because in one of the cases he had already been
acquitted by the competent Court. A copy of the judgment passed by
Special Court, Pathankot reveals that detenue stands acquitted on
21.02.2025 in FIR No. 5/2023, much before impugned order of
detention came to be passed on 15.03.2025. Pertinently, this ground
has not been disputed by the respondents in the counter affidavit.
10.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dharamdas Shamlal Agarwal vs. Police
Commissioner; AIR 1989 SC 1282 has held that failure on the part
of the sponsoring authority to place the material fact regarding
HCP No. 124/2025
Page No. 6
acquittal of the detenue in a criminal case amounts to non-application
of mind of the detaining authority and vitiates subjective satisfaction
rendering the detention invalid. It was held that if a vital fact, which
would have bearing on the subjective satisfaction of the detaining
authority and influence his mind, is withheld or suppressed by the
sponsoring authority or ignored or not considered by the detaining
authority, before the issuance of detention order, the requisite
subjective satisfaction, the formation of which is a condition
precedent to the passing of detention order gets vitiated rendering the
detention illegal.
Relevant excerpt of the judgment captured in para 12 for the
facility of reference has been extracted below:
“12. From the above decisions it emerges that the requisite
subjective satisfaction the formation of which is a condition
precedent to passing of a detention order will get vitiated if
material or vital facts which would have bearing on the issue
and weighed the satisfaction of the detaining authority one
way or the other and influenced his mind are either withheld
or suppressed by the sponsoring authority or ignored and
not considered by the detaining authority before issuing the
detention order. It is clear to our mind that in the case on
hand, at the time when the detaining authority passed the
detention order this vital fact, namely, the acquittals of the
detenu in case Nos. mentioned at Serial Nos. 2 and 3 have not
been brought to his notice and on the other hand they were
withheld and the detaining authority was given to
understand that the trial of those cases were pending. The
explanation given by the learned counsel for the respondents,
as we have already pointed out, cannot be accepted for a
moment. The result is that the non-placing of the material
fact – namely the acquittal of detenu in the above-said two
cases resulting in non-application of minds of the detaining
authority to the said fact has vitiated the requisite subjective
satisfaction, rendering the impugned detention order
invalid.”
11.
If present case is approached with the aforesaid principle of law, it
appears that either acquittal of the petitioner/detenue was suppressed
HCP No. 124/2025
Page No. 7
by the sponsoring officer-SSP, Kathua or he was ignorant about his
acquittal in one of the cases against him, which renders the impugned
detention order illegal.
12.
Another ground urged by learned counsel for the petitioner is that
petitioner approached respondent No. 1 with a representation but
neither said representation has been decided nor any decision is
communicated to him, which is infringement of Article 22(5) of the
Constitution of India. Per contra, it is contention of the respondents,
that representation dated 31.07.2025, preferred by the petitioner,
against his detention was considered by respondent No. 1-Home
Department and was found without merit. The decision was
forwarded to SSP, Kathua by the detaining authority for onward
service upon the detenue.
13.
It is settled proposition of law that in cases of preventive detention,
appropriate Government is obliged not only to afford the detenue an
opportunity to make effective representation, but also consider it
without unreasonable delay because it involves liberty of a citizen
guaranteed under Article 19 of the Constitution of India. It is also by
far crystallized now that unreasonable delay in consideration of
representation submitted by a detenue amounts to infringement of
Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India.
14.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in K.M. Abdulla Kunhi and Anr. V. Union
of India & Ors.; AIR 1991 SC 574 has held that though there can be
no hard and fast rule regarding the timeline within which a
representation is required to be considered by the Government and
there is no limitation provided under the Constitution or PSA within
which a representation is required to be considered and decided by the
Government, however, it is manifest from the words “as soon as may
be”, occurring in Clause (5) of Article 22 of the Constitution that
unexplained delay in disposal of representation would amount to
infringement of Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India. Relevant
excerpt of the judgment for the ease of reference is extracted below:
HCP No. 124/2025
Page No. 8
“……5(a) The representation relates to the liberty of the
individual, the highly cherished right enshrined in Article
21 of our Constitution. Clause (5) of Article 22 therefore,
casts a legal obligation on the Government to consider the
representation as early as possible. It is a constitutional
mandate commanding the concerned authority to whom
the detenue submits his presentation to consider the
representation and dispose of the same as expeditiously as
possible.
5(b) The words “as soon as may be” occurring in clause
(5) of Article 22 reflect the concern of the Framers that the
presentation should be expeditiously considered and
disposed of with a sense of urgency without an avoidable
delay. However, there can be no hard and fast rule in this
regard. It depends upon the fact and circumstances of
each case. There is no period prescribed either under the
Constitution or under the concerned detention law, within
which the representation should be dealt with the
requirement however, is that there should not be supine
indifference slackness or callous attitude in considering
the representation. Any unexplained delay in the disposal
of the representation would be a breach of the
constitutional imperative and it would render the
continued detention impermissible and illegal…..”
15.
It is evident from the exposition of law by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
K. M. Abdulla Kunhi (Supra) that unexplained delay in disposal of a
representation amounts to infringement of Article 22(5) of
Constitution of India. The detaining authority is not only obliged to
consider the representation of the detenue, as soon as possible and
practicable but also communicate the decision without further waste
of time.
16.
Consideration of representation on the part of Home and/or detaining
authority is not an empty formality. The constitutional imperative
within the meaning of Article 22(5) of Constitution of India imposes a
dual obligation on the authority propounding the order of preventive
detention; viz, (i) he must, as soon as possible, after detention order is
passed, communicate the detenue the grounds on which order of
detention has been made and, (ii) he must afford the detenue earliest
opportunity of making a representation against his detention. In other
HCP No. 124/2025
Page No. 9
words, the detenue is to be furnished with sufficient particulars to
enable him to make a representation.
17.
Consideration of representation and consequent communication of the
decision taken by the concerned authority cannot be allowed to be
pigeon holed for indefinite period of time. Since respondents in their
counter affidavit have not furnished any detail with respect to the date
of disposal of representation preferred by the petitioner and its
onward conveyance to him, it amounts to infringement of Articles 14
21 of Constitution of India.
18.
For the foregoing reasons, impugned detention order is found illegal.
Hence, present petition is allowed and impugned order is quashed.
Petitioner is directed to be released forthwith from detention,
provided he is not involved in any other case.
19.
Disposed of.
(Rajesh Sekhri)
Judge
Jammu
19.02.2026
Sushant
Whether the judgment is speaking?
Whether the judgment is reportable?
HCP No. 124/2025
Yes
Yes
Page No. 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review