The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
31. 10.2022. The representation was disposed of after due application of mind and intimated Page 4 to the detenu vide letter dated 07.11.2022. It is stated that there is no lapse on the part of the State Government in forwarding the detention order to the concerned authorities. In the reply filed by respondent No. 3, it is stated that the detention order dated 16.09.2022 was forwarded to the Ministry on
22. 09.2022. The Representation dated 29.09.2022 made by the detenu along with the parawise comment was received by the Ministry from the State Government through e-mail dated 01.11.2022. It is further stated that the representation was addressed to the Chairman, State Advisory Board (PIT- ND & PS Act) and not to the Ministry and hence, the respondent No. 3 has not passed any order on the representation. [6] Mr. N. Jotendro, learned senior counsel for the petitioner, submits that the Central Government has not passed any order on the representation submitted by the detenu only on the plea that the same was addressed to the Chairman, State Advisory Board (PIT – ND & PS) and not to the Central Government. It is submitted that the stand of the Central Government is totally wrong, illegal and it is against the provisions of law. The learned senior counsel draws the attention of this court to the decision of Bombay High Court in the case of Sohinidevi Mohanlal Jain –vs – Union of India and others reported in 1995 Legal Eagle (BOM) 302: 1996 (3) Bom. C.R. 328 In the above cited case arising out of Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act (COFEPOSA Act), the representation was addressed to the Detaining Authority and Advisory Board and not to the Central Government. Only on this plea, the Central Government stated that it has no obligation to consider th…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (Cril.) No. 4 of 2023
1. Lheineikim
Khongsai,
aged
about
years,
W/o
Tongkhothang Khongsai, a resident of Yaolen Chepu Village,
P.O. & P.S. Ukhrul, Ukhrul District, Manipur - 795142
…... PETITIONER/S
- Versus 1. The State of Manipur represented by the Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Manipur, Old Secretariat Building, Babupara, Imphal
West District, Government of Manipur – 795001.
2. The Special Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur, Old
Secretariat
Building,
Babupara,
Imphal
West
District,
Government of Manipur – 795001.
3. The Union of India, through the Deputy Secretary (PIT-NDPS),
Department of Revenue, Near North Block, Room No. – 26,
Church Road, RFA-Barrack, New Delhi – 110001.
........RESPONDENT/S
B E F O R E
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
ORDER
07.02.2023
[1]
Heard Mr. N. Jotendro, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Murtaza Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. A.
Vashum, learned G.A. for respondent Nos. 1 & 2 and Mr. Boboy
Potsangbam, learned CGSC for respondent No. 3.
Page 1
[2]
The present writ petition has been filed by the wife of the
detenu Mr. Tongkhothang Khongsai, who had been detained under the
Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
Act, 1988 (in short, PIT-ND&PS Act) in pursuance to an order dated
16.09.2022 passed by the Special Secretary (Home), Government of
Manipur in connection with FIR No. 9(07)2022 Litan PS u/s 18(b)/29/60(3)
ND & PS Act. It is mentioned in the detention order dated 16.09.2022 that
he had filed Cril.Misc.(B) No. 8 of 2022 under the Special Court (ND & PS),
Ukhrul and that “......the accused on release from jail on bail will continue
his illegal activities including illicit trafficking of drugs which are prejudicial
to public order.” Vide letter dated 19.09.2022, the State Government
intimated the detenu on the grounds for detention under sub-section (3) of
Section 3 of the PIT-ND&PS Act, 1988. It is stated that the detenu is a
habitual drug smuggler arrested earlier by Assam Rifles in c/w FIR No.
9(11)2018 LTN PS u/s 18(b)/29 ND & PS Act and after being released from
jail on bail, the detenu resumed drug smuggling and arrested while
transporting opium and it is also stated that the detenu is an associate of a
drug racket operated by a syndicate which supply illicit drugs in the State. It
is also stated that there is a possibility of the detenu to be released on bail
and if released on bail, he would indulge in the same activities of illicit
trafficking of drugs which are prejudicial to public order and hence in order
to curb the illegal activities, an alternative preventive measure has to be
taken up.
[3]
The detenu submitted a representation dated 29.09.2022 to
the Superintendent of Prison, Sajiwa Central Jail, Manipur for forwarding
his representation to the State Advisory Board
for Prevention of Illicit
Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances, Manipur. In the
said representation dated 29.09.2022 addressed to the Chairman, Advisory
Board for Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances, Manipur, the detenu stated that the detention order is illegal
Page 2
as the detaining authority passed the order mechanically and without
application of mind and further his detention under section 3 (1) of the
Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substance
Act, 1988 is punitive in nature. It is also stated in the said representation
that there is no FIR registered against the detenu except the present FIR
No. 9(7)2022 LTN PS U/S 18(b)/29/60(3) ND & PS Act and he had no
criminal antecedent.
Vide letter dated 31.10.2022, the Deputy Secretary (Home)
Government of Manipur, forwarded the representation of the detenu to the
Deputy Secretary (PIT- ND & PS), Ministry of Finance, Government of
India. Vide letter dated 07.11.2022, the Deputy Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur informed the detenu that his representation dated
29.09.2022 addressed to the Chairman, Advisory Board (PIT-ND & PS),
Manipur has been duly considered by the State Government and regretted
as being devoid of merit. It is also stated that a similar copy of his
representation addressed to the Deputy Secretary (PIT – ND & PS)
Department of Revenue, New Delhi, has been forwarded. Vide order dated
05.12.2022, the Special Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur in
exercise of the powers conferred under clause (f) of Section 9 of the said
Act, the Government of Manipur is pleased to order that the preventive
detention of Tongkhothang Khongsai (46) S/o (L) Jamkhokhei Khongsai of
Yaolen Chephu Village, PO & PS Litan, Ukhrul District, Manipur vide order
No. H-3301/62/2022-HD-HD dated 16.09.2022 is hereby confirmed and
further fix the period of detention for 12 (twelve) months from the date of
his detention.
[4]
The main grounds for challenging in the present petition are
that;
(i) the detention order dated 16.09.2022 and subsequent
confirmation order dated 05.12.2022 are without any cogent
Page 3
materials and have been passed arbitrarily, mechanically and
in a routine manner without application of judicious mind.
(ii) there is no cogent materials that the detenu was involved
in the FIR case and that the respondent No. 2 forwarded the
representation dated 29.09.2022 to respondent No. 3 only on
31.10.2022 after a lapses of 31 (thirty one) days and the same
has not been considered by respondent No. 3 till date.
(iii) there is an unexplained and inordinate delay of 39 (thirty
nine) days by respondent No. 2 in disposing of the
representation dated 29.09.2022.
[5]
The State Government filed an affidavit-in-opposition and it is
stated that the detenu is a habitual offender and after his released in
connection with FIR No. 9(11)2018 LTN PS U/S 18(b)/29 ND & PS Act, he
resumed his illicit business of drug trafficking till his arrest on 19.07.2022 in
connection with FIR No. 9(7)2022 LTN PS U/S 18(b)/29/60(3) ND & PS
Act. It is stated that he is required to keep under detention under PITND&PS Act as ordinary criminal proceeding cannot prevent him from
commission of prejudicial activities. It is stated that the detention order and
the confirmation order are passed in good faith and public interest as
preventive measure for effectively preventing him from indulging in illicit
trafficking of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances. It is also stated
that the detention order dated 16.09.2022 had been forwarded to Ministry
of Finance, Government of India vide letter dated 22.09.2022 through email within the prescribed period of 10 (ten) days as prescribed by section
3(2) of the Pitt’s Act. Further, representation of the detention order dated
29.09.2022 was forwarded by IG (prisons) vide letter dated 05.10.2022 and
received by the State Government on 06.10.2022 and had been forwarded
to
the
Government
of
India
vide
letter
dated
31.10.2022.
The
representation was disposed of after due application of mind and intimated
Page 4
to the detenu vide letter dated 07.11.2022.
It is stated that there is no
lapse on the part of the State Government in forwarding the detention order
to the concerned authorities.
In the reply filed by respondent No. 3, it is stated that the
detention order dated 16.09.2022 was forwarded to the Ministry on
22.09.2022.
The Representation dated 29.09.2022 made by the detenu
along with the parawise comment was received by the Ministry from the
State Government through e-mail dated 01.11.2022. It is further stated that
the representation was addressed to the Chairman, State Advisory Board
(PIT- ND & PS Act) and not to the Ministry and hence, the respondent No.
3 has not passed any order on the representation.
[6]
Mr. N. Jotendro, learned senior counsel for the petitioner,
submits that the Central Government has not passed any order on the
representation submitted by the detenu only on the plea that the same was
addressed to the Chairman, State Advisory Board (PIT – ND & PS) and not
to the Central Government. It is submitted that the stand of the Central
Government is totally wrong, illegal and it is against the provisions of law.
The learned senior counsel draws the attention of this court to the decision
of Bombay High Court in the case of Sohinidevi Mohanlal Jain –vs –
Union of India and others reported in 1995 Legal Eagle (BOM) 302:
1996 (3) Bom. C.R. 328
In the above cited case arising out of Conservation of Foreign
Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act (COFEPOSA Act),
the representation was addressed to the Detaining Authority and Advisory
Board and not to the Central Government. Only on this plea, the Central
Government stated that it has no obligation to consider the matter. It was
held that non-consideration of a representation not addressed to the
Page 5
Central Government at an early point of time would not affect the order of
detention or the continued detention of the detenu. The relevant portion is
held at para 13 and is reproduced hereinbelow:
“13. As far as the controversy at hand is concerned, it is
undisputed that the representation in question is not
addressed to the Central Government and is addressed
only to the Detaining Authority and the Advisory Board.
As far as the petitioner is concerned, he has contended
that the representation which was jointly addressed to
the Detaining Authority and the Central Advisory Board,
ought to have been promptly considered and decided
by the Central Government. This is disputed by Shri
Agrawal, who appears both for the Detaining Authority
and the Central Government. Accordingly to him,
Central Government was not obliged to consider the
representation not addressed to it, up-till the stage it
received the report from the Advisory Board. He does
not dispute, rather he concedes, that there is a duty
cast upon the Central Government to consider the said
representation while performing its functions of either
confirming the order of detention or revoking the same
under section 8(f) and section 11 of the Act and this is
only after it has received the report of the Advisory
Board. According to Shri Agrawal the obligation to
consider the representation at this stage by the Central
Government is statutory. As far as the representation is
concerned, the same form a part of the proceedings of
the Advisory Board. After the Advisory Board opined
that there was sufficient material to pass an order of
detention against the detenu the record in respect of
the proceedings was sent to the Central Government
and the Central Government was required to pass its
orders in the light of the provisions of section 8 (f) of the
Act. In view of the opinion of the Advisory Board that
there was sufficient cause for the detention of the
detenu the Central Government would proceed to
confirm the order of detention and provide for the
period during which the detenu was required to be
Page 6
detained. Despite the said opinion, it was still open to
the Central Government to revoke the order of
detention. For deciding this issue, it was necessary to
consider the representation of the detenu which forms
part of the proceedings before the Advisory Board.
Hence, it was only at that stage and at no prior point of
time, that the Central Government was obliged or called
upon to consider the representation. Non-consideration
of a representation not addressed to the Central
Government at an early point of time would not affect
the order of detention or the continued detention of the
detenu.”
[7]
Mr. N. Jotendro, learned senior counsel, submits that the facts
of the present case is squarely covered by the decision of the Bombay
High Court in the above cited case and it is prayed that the detention order
be set aside as it is in violation of the settled proposition of law and nonconsideration of the representation submitted by the detenu affects its right
to live and liberty enshrined under Article 22 of the constitution.
[8]
Mr. A. Vashum, learned G.A. submits that the State
Government have done everything in time and there is no lapse from the
State Government and it has complied all the statutory requirements
except for some time taken in parawise comment. He prays for dismissal of
the writ petition.
[9]
Mr. Boboy Potsangbam, learned CGSC, stated that there is
no obligation on the part of the Central Government to consider and decide
the representation not addressed to it and prayed that the writ petition may
be dismissed.
[10]
The PIT-ND&PS Act has been enacted in the year 1988 in
order to provide for preventive detention of person indulging in illicit
trafficking in ND & PS in a considerable magnitude and such activities
could not be dealt with by the normal criminal procedure. So, in short, it
Page 7
confers a power on the Central Government or State Government to detain
a person with a view to prevent him from engaging in illicit trafficking in ND
& PS. The detenu is in apprehension of a committing clandestine business
in Narcotic Substances. There is a departure from the normal criminal
proceeding and involving such stringent
provisions affects the right of
person and liberty enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution. Such
detention has to satisfy the mandate of Article 22 of the Constitution.
Therefore, the State Authorities have to deal with very carefully while
considering with the preventive detention and the same should satisfy the
requirements as prescribed under Articles 21 and 22 of the Constitution.
[11]
In the present case, it is the stand of the respondent No. 3
(Central Government) that since the representation was addressed to the
State Advisory Board and not to it and there is no obligation on the part of
the Central Government to consider and dispose of the representation
submitted by the detenu but this plea is in contrast with the law laid down
by Bombay High Court in the case of Sohinidevi Mohanlal Jain –vs –
Union of India and others.
[12]
We are of the view that non-examination of the representation
dated 29.09.2022 submitted by the detenu by Central Government on the
plea that the same was not addressed to it cannot hold ground and it
affects the life and liberty of a person as enshrined under Article 21.
Accordingly, the detention order dated 16.09.2022 is set aside and the
detenu be released from detention unless he is required in any other case.
[13]
Writ petition is allowed and disposed of. No cost.
JUDGE
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
joshua
signed by KH.
KH. JOSHUA Digitally
JOSHUA MARING
Date: 2023.02.21
MARING
16:15:09 +05'30'
Page 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review