Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.08.03 14:22:36 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.729 of 2019
Leishangthem Chandrakeshore Singh, aged about
62 years, S/o (Late) L. Chaoba Singh, R/o Tera
Sapam Leirak, P.O. & P.S. : Lamphel, District: Imphal
West 795001, Manipur.
...Petitioner
-Versus-
1. The State of Manipur, represented by the
Principal
Secretary/Commissioner,
Minor
Irrigation Department, Government of Manipur,
Secretariat, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District : Imphal
West, Pin No. 795001.
2. The Chief Engineer, Minor Irrigation Department,
Government of Manipur.
3. The
Principal
Accountant
General
(A&E),
Manipur, Imphal-795001.
...Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. L. Anand, Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. S. Suresh, Adv. for R-3
Mrs. L. Monomala, GA for
R-1 & R-2
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
04.07.2023
Date of Judgment & Order ::
02.08.2023
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
Heard Mr. L. Anand, learned counsel for the
petitioner; Mrs. L. Monomala, learned GA for the respondents 1
and 2; and Mr. S. Suresh, learned counsel for the third
respondent.
2.
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to
quash a portion of the impugned statement dated 13.10.2017
issued by the office of the Accountant General, Manipur, on the
basis of which, a sum of Rs.5,82,002/- was recovered as excess
payment/over payment from the gratuity amount and dearness
relief after his retirement and to direct the official respondents
to refund the said amount with admissible interest.
3.
Mr. L. Anand, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner was retired from service on
28.2.2017 on attaining the age of superannuation as RoadMohorrir in Minor Irrigation Department, Government of
Manipur.
After his retirement, the pension papers was
submitted to the authorities for processing his entitled retiral
benefits. In due course of time, the office of the third respondent
issued pension payment order along with the impugned
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
Page |3
statement showing the details of calculation of his retirement
benefits and deduction of overpayment from his gratuity and
dearness relief.
4.
The learned counsel for the petitioner further
submitted that the impugned portion of the statement dated
13.10.2017 shows the calculated amount of total dearness relief
as
Rs.1,37,033/-;
gratuity
payment
order
amount
to
Rs.5,46,000/- and commutation payment order amount to
Rs.2,97,148/-.
While so, to the utter shock, an amount of
Rs.5,82,002/- was deducted from the total amount of gratuity
payment order of Rs.5,46,000/- and the remaining balance
amount of Rs.36,000/- from the amount of dearness relief of
Rs.1,37,033/-.
5.
According to the learned counsel for the petitioner,
there is an illegal deduction/recovery for overpayment of a huge
amount of Rs.5,82,002/- and the same has been completely
curtailed and arbitrarily forfeited by the respondent authorities
form the retirement benefit of the petitioner which would be
impressible in law. In fact, the aforesaid deduction made the
petitioner to suffer from untold miseries and hardships.
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
Page |4
6.
According to the learned counsel, aggrieved by
the action of the respondents, the petitioner submitted a
representation on 19.8.2019 requesting refund of the said
amount. Though the said representation was duly received by
the office of the respondents, no action has been taken till date.
7.
The learned counsel for the petitioner urged that
the alleged overpayment made by the official respondents was
not on account of any misrepresentation or fraud on the part of
the petitioner. Therefore, the petitioner cannot be held liable
and made to suffer for the wrong committed by the officials. The
petitioner is presently facing lot of hardship for survival with the
meagre
retirement
benefits
he
is
receiving
after
the
deduction/recovery made by the respondent authorities. Thus,
a prayer has been made to set aside the portion of the
impugned statement on the basis of which the amount of
Rs.5,82,002/- was recovered as excess payment from the
gratuity amount and dearness relief. To fortify his submissions,
the learned counsel relied upon the following decisions:
(i) Shyam Babu Verma and others v.
Union of India and others, (1994) 2
SCC 521.
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
Page |5
(ii) State of Punjab and others v. Rafiq
Masih (White Washer) and others,
(2015) 4 SCC 334.
8.
Per contra, Mr. S. Suresh, the learned counsel for
the third respondent submitted that on scrutiny of pension
papers and service records of the petitioner, it was found that
the petitioner was appointed as Road Mohorrir in the scale of
pay of Rs.215-340/- with effect from 14.5.1980. Under ROP
1999, the pay of the petitioner was fixed in the scale of pay of
Rs.3050-4590 with effect from 1.1.1996. He was granted ACPI in the scale of pay of Rs.4000-100-6000/- and his pay was
fixed at Rs.4500/- on 1.7.2005 and he was granted ACP-II in
the scale of pay of Rs.5000-100-8000 and his pay was fixed at
Rs.5000/- on 1.7.2005. However, as per condition No.8 of the
conditions for grant of benefits under the ACP Scheme as
contained in Annexure 1 to the office memorandum dated
20.7.2005 issued by the Finance Department, the financial
upgradation under the scheme shall be given to the next higher
grade in accordance with the existing hierarchy in a
grade/category of posts without creating new posts for the
purpose.
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
Page |6
9.
Mr. S. Suresh, the learned counsel for the third
respondent drawing this Court’s attention to the office
memorandum dated 20.7.2005 further submitted that when the
petitioner was entitled to financial upgradation under ACP-I and
ACP-II with effect form 1.7.2015, his pay should have been fixed
at Rs.4475/- in the scale of pay at Rs.3200-4900/- i.e. the next
higher pay scale from his existing scale of Rs.3050-4590/-, but
it was wrongly fixed at Rs.4000-6000/- by jumping one
additional stage under ROP, 1999 and in ACP-II his pay should
have been fixed at Rs.4600/- in the scale of pay of Rs.40006000/- i.e. next higher pay scale of Rs.3200-4900/-, but it was
wrongly fixed at Rs.5000/- in the scale of pay of Rs.5000-8000/-.
10.
The learned counsel for the third respondent
added that consequent on revision of pay under ROP 1020, the
pay of the petitioner was fixed at Rs.9300/- in the pay band of
Rs.9300-34800/- with grade pay of Rs.4200/- with effect from
1.6.2006 which should have been fixed at Rs.8560/- in the pay
band of Rs.5200-20200/- with grade pay of Rs.2400/- with effect
from 1.6.2006. Due to non-fixation of pay to the corresponding
higher scale of pay while granting financial upgradation under
ACP-I and ACP-II respectively and the non-fixation of pay in the
corresponding pay band of Rs.5200-20200/- with grade pay of
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
Page |7
Rs.2400/- with effect from 1.1.2006 under ROP 2010, there was
overpayment
of
pay
and
allowances
amounting
to
Rs.5,82,002/-.
11.
The learned counsel next submitted that the said
irregularity was intimated to the Chief Engineer on 28.6.2017.
Pursuant to the said letter, the Chief Engineer submitted the
service book of the individual and the order dated 28.8.2017 of
excess
payment
of
pay
and
allowances
amount
to
Rs.5,82,002/- vide letter dated 30.8.2017.
12.
The learned counsel urged that on the basis of the
consent certificate given by the petitioner consenting that he
has no objection to the recovery of the Government
dues/outstanding dues, if any found/detected from the
receivable retirement gratuity coupled with the order/decision
from the Executive Engineer, MID. The third respondent settled
the retiral benefits of the petitioner after adjusting the amount of
Rs.5,82,002/- being overpayment of pay and allowances from
the retirement gratuity of the petitioner.
13.
Mr. S. Suresh, the learned counsel for the third
respondent submitted that it will be a violation of existing
provision of MSC (Pension) Rules, 1977, if the deduction of
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
Page |8
overpayment of pay and allowances was not carried out by the
third respondent.
The action of the third respondent is in
accordance with the condition under Rule 70(A), 71(2) and
73(3) of the MCS (Pension) Rules, 1977. Thus, a prayer has
been made to dismiss the writ petition.
14.
Mrs. L. Monomala, the learned Government
Advocate appearing for the respondents 1 and 2 has adopted
the arguments made by the learned counsel for the third
respondent.
15.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
16.
The grievance of the petitioner is that deduction of
a huge amount of Rs.5,82,002/- from the retiral benefits of the
petitioner after his retirement by the authorities on account of
overpayment during his service period has made the petitioner
to suffer much hardship. The malafide act of the officials of the
respondent is against the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
17.
According to the third respondent, the Principal
Accountant Genera/Accountant General is not responsible for
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
Page |9
the administrative function/decision of the State authority
except for compliance of the State authority in relation to GPF,
pension and gazette entitlement. It is the say of the third
respondent that in accordance with Rule 70(A), 71(2) and 73(3)
of the MCS (Pension) Rules, 1977 read with the GI decision
No.6 below Rule 73 of the MCS (Pension) Rules, 1977, the third
respondent settled the pension by deducting overpaid pay and
allowances amounting to Rs.5,82,002/-.
18.
It is an admitted fact that the petitioner after
serving a gross qualifying service of about 37 years retired on
attaining the age of superannuation on 28.2.2017 as Road
Mohorrir, which is a Class-III/IV service under Minor Irrigation
Division-I M.I Department, Manipur.
19.
The learned counsel for the third respondent
submitted that it was wrongly fixed at Rs.4000-6000/- by
jumping one additional stage under ROP 1999 and in ACP-II,
the petitioner’s pay should have been fixed at Rs.4600/- but it
was wrongly fixed at Rs.5000/-. Consequent on revision of pay
under ROP 2010, the pay of the petitioner was fixed at
Rs.9300/- in the pay band of Rs.9300-34800/- with grade pay
of Rs.4200/- with effect from 1.1.2006 which should have been
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
P a g e | 10
fixed at Rs.8560/-.
Due to non-fixation of pay to the
corresponding higher scale of pay while granting financial
upgradation under ACP-I and ACP-II respectively and the nonfixation of pay in the corresponding pay band of Rs.520020200/- with grade pay Rs.2400/- with effect from 1.1.2006
under ROP 2010, there was overpayment of pay and
allowances amounting to Rs.5,82,002/-.
20.
Nothing has been produced by the respondents to
show that the nature of fixation of pay and granting financial
upgradation to the petitioner since 2005 was due to any
misrepresentation or fraud played by the petitioner. The fixation
of pay was done by the officials of the Department.
In Shyam Babu Verma, supra, the Hon’ble
21.
Supreme Court held that higher pay scale given erroneously to
incumbents without their fault, shall not be recovered.
paragraph 11, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“11. Although we have held that the petitioners
were entitled only to the pay scale of Rs 300480 in terms of the recommendations of the
Third Pay Commission w.e.f. January 1, 1973
and only after the period of 10 years, they
became entitled to the pay scale of Rs 330-
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
In
P a g e | 11
560 but as they have received the scale of Rs
330-560 since 1973 due to no fault of theirs
and that scale is being reduced in the year
1984 with effect from January 1, 1973, it shall
only be just and proper not to recover any
excess amount which has already been paid
to them. Accordingly, we direct that no steps
should be taken to recover or to adjust any
excess amount paid to the petitioners due to
the fault of the respondents, the petitioners
being in no way responsible for the same.”
22.
The learned counsel for the third respondent
argued that the petitioner himself voluntarily and on his own
agreed that he has no objection to the recovery of the
Government dues/Outstanding dues, if any found from his
receivable retirement gratuity which he reduced in writing in the
form of consent. Therefore, based on the consent letter, the
third respondent deducted the overpayment and, thus, the third
respondent was right in their action. The learned counsel for
the third respondent has relied upon few orders of the Single
Bench of this Court in support of his argument.
23.
On a perusal of the orders of this Court relied upon
by the learned counsel for the third respondent, namely (i)
W.P.(C) No.258 of 2018, decided on 27.7.2018; (ii) W.P.(C)
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
P a g e | 12
No.259 of 2018, decided on 27.7.2018 and (iii) W.P.(C) No.690
of 2010, decided on 25.7.2019, it is clear that the facts set out
in the aforesaid cases are entirely different compared to that of
the present case. In the aforesaid orders, the Single Bench held
that the petitioners therein by their own conduct are disentitled
to the relief sought for in the writ petitions. Whereas, in the case
of hand, if we see the alleged consent letter relied upon by the
third respondent, it is clear that the consent letter said to have
been given by the petitioner does not show even the date.
24.
In the consent letter said to have been submitted
by the petitioner, it has been stated “… I have no any objection
to the recovery of the Government dues/Outstanding dues if any
found/detected from my receivable Retirement Gratuity”.
25.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted
that if there is existence of any kind of undertaking or consent
towards recovery obtained from the petitioner by the
respondent authorities under duress at the time of finalization of
his pension papers, which the petitioner cannot correctly recall
nor has any record of such, the same is illegal and cannot be
lawfully used against the petitioner.
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
This Court finds some
P a g e | 13
force in the said submission made by the learned counsel for
the petitioner.
26.
It is well settled that any consideration or object of
an agreement which is forbidden by law or which may cause
injury to person or property of another or opposed to public
policy is unlawful.
27.
Normally, if the retiring staff refused to sign in the
consent letter, the pension proposal could not be processed.
Therefore, faced with that situation only, the employee is
signing. In this case also, as rightly argued by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, the petitioner at that stage is bound
to sign the said letter against his will for speedy sanction of his
pension proposal. Thus, the case of the third respondent that
based on the consent letter deduction was made cannot be
countenanced.
In Rafiq Masih (White Washer), supra, the Hon’ble
28.
Supreme Court held that recovery should not be made from the
retired employees.
In paragraph 18, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held:
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations
of hardship which would govern employees on
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
P a g e | 14
the issue of recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in
excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based
on
the
decisions
referred
to
hereinabove, we may, as a ready reference
summarise
the
following
few
situations,
wherein recoveries by the employers, would
be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to
Class III and Class IV service (or Group C and
Group D service)
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or
the employees who are due to retire within one
year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the
excess payment has been made for a period
in excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties
of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have
rightfully be required to work against an
inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives
at the conclusion, that recovery if made from
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
P a g e | 15
the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far
outweigh
the
equitable
balance
of
the
employer’s right to recover.”
29.
The situations summarized by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih (White Washer), supra, are
squarely applicable to the case on hand.
Therefore, the
petitioner being a Class III/Class IV employee and the wrong
fixation is not on the fault or misrepresentation of the petitioner,
the deduction of the overpayment from the retiral benefit after
the retirement of the petitioner is illegal and the same is not
permissible under law. This Court is of the view that if any such
excess payment is allowed to be recovered from the employees
of lower rung, it would cause them far more hardship, than the
reciprocal gains to the employer.
In this regard, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, time and again, held that excess recovery from
employees belonging to the lower rungs i.e. Class III and Class
IV/Group C and Group D of service should not be subjected to
the ordeal of any recovery, even though they were beneficiaries
of receiving higher emoluments, than were due to them. Such
recovery would be iniquitous and arbitrary and, therefore, would
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
P a g e | 16
also breach the mandate contained in Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
30.
As stated supra, in the case on hand, the petitioner
after serving a gross qualifying pensionable service of about 37
years had retired on reaching superannuation on 28.2.2017. It
is trite that any excess recovery would be iniquitous and
arbitrary, if it is sought to be made after the date of retirement.
Any excess amount paid to the employee who had already
retired from service, more particularly Class C and Class D
employees, cannot be recovered.
31.
It is pertinent to note that in the impugned
statement dated 13.10.2017, the third respondent has failed to
show the detailed amount of overpayment made at regular
intervals or increments made to the petitioner by indicating the
year. Besides, no notice was issued to the petitioner to explain
as to how the excess payment should not be deducted from the
retiral benefits of the petitioner. In the absence of notice to the
employee before the recovery of the excess payment, the action
of the authorities is in violation of the principles of natural justice.
In any event, the excess amount which had been already made
to the petitioner by the employer and which had not been
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
P a g e | 17
occasioned due to any fraud or misrepresentation on the part of
the petitioner shall not be permissible for any recovery to be
made after his retirement.
Therefore, this is a fit case to
interfere with the action of the respondent authorities in
deducting Rs.5,46,000/- from the total amount of gratuity
payment order and Rs.36,000/- from the amount of dearness
relief, totaling Rs.5,82,002/-.
32.
During the course of arguments, the learned
counsel for the third respondent has relied upon the following
decisions:
(i)
K.D.Sharma v. State Authority of India
Ltd., (2008) 12 SCC 481.
(ii) High Court of Punjab & Haryana v. Jagdev
Singh, (2016) 14 SCC 267.
(iii) Vikramjit Singh v. State of Madhya
Pradesh, (1992) Supp 3 SCC 62.
(iv) Jai Singh and others v. MCD, (2010) 9
SCC 385.
(v) Amarjeet Singh and others v. Devi Ratan
and others, (2010) 1 SCC 417.
(vi) P.Singaravelan v. Collector, Tituppur,
(2020) 3 SCC 133.
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
P a g e | 18
(vii) State of U.P. and another v. Synthetics
and Chemicals Ltd. and another, (1991) 4
SCC 139.
(viii) Haryana Financial Corporation and others
v. Jagdamba Oil Mills and another, (2002)
3 SCC 496
(ix) Central
Board
of
Dawoodi
Bohra
Community and another v. State of
Maharashtra and another, (2005) 2 SCC
673.
(x) Dr. Shah Faesal and others v. Union of
India and another, (2020) 4 SCC 1.
(xi) Chandra Prakash and others v. State of
UP and another, (2002) 4 SCC 234.
(xii) National Insurance Company Limited v.
Pranay Sethi and others, (2017) 16 SCC
680.
33.
In view of the factual finding arrived at by this
Court, the decisions aforesaid relied upon by the learned
counsel for the third respondent are not elaborated further in
this order. Moreover, the same are not squarely applicable to
the case of the third respondent.
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
P a g e | 19
34.
For the reasons stated supra, this Court is of the
view that the prayer made in the writ petition is acceptable and,
accordingly, this Court is inclined to pass the following order:
(i)
The writ petition is allowed.
(ii)
The portion of the impugned statement
dated 13.10.2017 issued by the office of the
Accountant General, Manipur, whereby
deduction of a sum of Rs.5,82,002/- is made
from the gratuity amount and dearness relief
of the petitioner is set aside.
(iii)
The official respondents are directed to
refund the amount of Rs.5,82,002/- to the
petitioner within a period of three months
from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
(iv)
There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 729 of 2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review