The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. 01.2021. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the present petition has been filed. Learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that the present respondent/defendant had purchased a plot bearing survey no.1274 through sale-deed and to the south side of the said survey number there is a Government land bearing survey no.1272 which is an abadi land over which the house of the present petitioner/plaintiff has been standing for ages and adjacent 12:02:28 PM to his house there is a public path and the grievance of the petitioner arose when defendant while raising construction of his house on survey no.1274 not only encroached the public path, but had also encroached the plot of the petitioner. It was further submitted that since it was the matter of encroachment by the present respondent/defendant, he had moved an application under Order 26 Rule 9 for elucidating the factual boundaries of the plots and the encroachment made by the respondent/defendant and since the aspect of encroachment could only be ascertained by issuance of Commission by making local investigation, it was incumbent upon the learned Trial Court to have allowed the said application and direct the Commissioner so appointed to conduct the spot inspection and submit its report, but instead thereof the application itself has been rejected which is per se illegal. It was further submitted that learned Trial has misdirect…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
ON THE 9th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. PETITION No. 1978 of 2021
BETWEEN:LAXMINARAYAN S/O SHRI DHANIRAM, AGED-62
YEAR S, OCCUPATION: RETIRED B.S.F. R/O VILLAGE
AKODA PS UMARI DISTT BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI T.C. NARWARIYA- ADVOCATE)
AND
BADAN SINGH S/O SHRI CHHOTE SINGH YADAV, AGED68 YEARS, R/O VILLAGE AKODA PS UMARI PARAGNA
DIST BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI DHARMENDRA RISHISHWAR- ADVOCATE)
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
The present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has
been directed against the order dated 15.01.2021 passed by First Civil Judge
Class-2 Bhind in Civil Suit No.19-A/2016, whereby application filed under
Order 26 Rule 9 CPC for getting the land bearing survey no.1274 which
belongs to the present respondent was sought to be locally investigated by
issuance of a Commission alleging that the present respondent had encroached
upon a part of the land of the petitioner/plaintiff and Government land bearing
survey no.1272.
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
Brief facts of the case are that the present petitioner who is a plaintiff had
preferred a suit bearing no.19-A/2016 for permanent injunction against present
respondent/defendant for restraining him from raising any construction over the
land situated in between the plot of the petitioner/plaintiff and survey no.1274 as
the rights of the present petitioner/plaintiff were getting affected.
A written statement has been filed in the matter on behalf of the present
respondent/defendant, wherein the averments made by the petitioner/plaintiff
had been denied in toto. In the written statement it has been averred that the land
which has been made the center point of dispute is a Government land, as well
as
the
land
bearing
survey
no.1274,
admittedly,
belongs
to
respondent/defendant, thus, the prayer for permanent injunction in the suit is
baseless and prayer for dismissal of the suit was made.
The present status of suit is that issues are yet to be framed and evidence
is yet to start and prior to this the present petitioner/plaintiff had moved an
application under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC for conducting physical inspection of
the spot and a request was made to call for the report with regard to
encroachment made by the respondent over the plot of the petitioner as well as
public path. A reply was filed to the said application and the learned Trial Court
after considering the rival contentions had rejected the said application dated
15.01.2021. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the present petition has been
filed.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that the present
respondent/defendant had purchased a plot bearing survey no.1274 through
sale-deed and to the south side of the said survey number there is a
Government land bearing survey no.1272 which is an abadi land over which the
house of the present petitioner/plaintiff has been standing for ages and adjacent
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
to his house there is a public path and the grievance of the petitioner arose when
defendant while raising construction of his house on survey no.1274 not only
encroached the public path, but had also encroached the plot of the petitioner.
It was further submitted that since it was the matter of encroachment by the
present respondent/defendant, he had moved an application under Order 26
Rule 9 for elucidating the factual boundaries of the plots and the encroachment
made by the respondent/defendant and since the aspect of encroachment could
only be ascertained by issuance of Commission by making local investigation, it
was incumbent upon the learned Trial Court to have allowed the said application
and direct the Commissioner so appointed to conduct the spot inspection and
submit its report, but instead thereof the application itself has been rejected
which is per se illegal.
It was further submitted that learned Trial has misdirected itself in holding
that under the garb of the aforesaid application the petitioner/plaintiff wants to
collect evidence which is converse to the very pleadings of the
petitioner/plaintiff and, thus, the order being perverse deserves to be set aside
and suitable directions are required to be issued to the learned Trial Court to
appoint a Commissioner and conduct a local investigation to ascertain the
factum of encroachment made by the present respondent/defendant.
Per contra, Shri Dharmendra Rishishwar appearing for the respondent
while supporting the order passed by the learned Trial Court submitted that no
illegality has been committed by learned Trial Court in rejecting the application,
as the petitioner/plaintiff wants to get the boundaries of survey no.1274, which
admittedly, belongs to respondent/defendant ascertained by issuance of a
Commission which is not permissible and further the petitioner/plaintiff without
disclosing the boundaries of plot of his ownership or the factual map wants to
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
collect evidence regarding survey nos.1272 and 1274, thus, it was contended
that learned Trial Court has rightly rejected the application.
To bolster his submissions reliance was placed in the matter of Smt.
Dwarakibai vs. Raghunath passed in S.A. No.95/2001 dated 17.12.2003, in
the matter of Hussain Khan vs. Sudama Prasad reported in 2002 (2) MPJR
446 and in the matter of Suryabhan Singh vs. State of M.P. passed in W.P.
No.3584/2004 on 06.02.2006 and lastly in the matter of Smt. Indira
Chaurasia (Deceased) through Lrs. vs. Director, Krishi Upaj Mandi
Board and Ors. passed in M.P. No.3220/2020 on 15.01.2021.
Heard the counsels for the parties and perused the record.
Rule 9 of Order 26 of CPC empowers the Court to issue Commission to
make local investigation, which may be required for the purpose of elucidating
any matter in dispute. Though the object of local investigation is not to collect
evidence, which can be taken in the Court, but the purpose is to obtain such
evidence, which from its inferior nature can only be headed on the spot with a
view to elucidate, which is left doubtful on the evidence produced before the
Court.
The Court can issue local investigation even suo-motu, if in the facts and
circumstances of the case it is deemed necessary that the local investigation is
required and is proper for the purpose of elucidating the matter in dispute.
Though exercise of these powers is discretionary to the Court, but in case the
local investigation is requisite or proper in facts and circumstances of the case,
it should be exercised so as to elucidate the matter and just to render his
remedies. Thus, it is a discretionary power which is required to be exercised by
the learned Trial Court in case the needs so arises.
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
The law with regard to issuance of a Commission under Order 26 Rule 9
CPC has been discussed by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the matter of Haryana
Waqf Board vs. Shanti Sarup and Ors. reported in 2008 (8) SCC 671 and
in the judgment passed by this Court in the matter Jaswant vs. Deen Dayal
reported in 2011 (2) MPLJ 576.
Further in the matters of Durgaprasad vs. P. Faujdar reported in 1975
MPLJ 810 and in the matter of Anusuiya Bai and Ors. vs. Rajendra Parsai
and Ors. passed in W.P. No.1915/2014 decided on 03.04.2018, the scope of
order 26 Rule 9 CPC has been considered and in the cases like demarcation,
encroachment, boundary disputed etc it has been held that these questions can
only be ascertained by issuance of a Commission and, therefore, a
Commissioner should be appointed in such matters so that the controversy
would be resolved.
But the facts in the present matter are altogether different. The petitioner
himself is not sure as to the boundaries of his plots. From the plaint it is seen
that no boundaries have been mentioned therein except for the fact that adjacent
to the land bearing survey no.1272 which admittedly is a Government land and
on which the plot of the petitioner/plaintiff is situated, is the land of
respondent/defendant bearing survey no.1274 and it stated that under garb of
raising construction over survey no.1274 the present respondent/defendant had
encroached upon the Government land as well as the plot of the present
petitioner/plaintiff, which in the absence of placing the exact boundaries cannot
entail that the present respondent/defendant had encroached their plot. Even
otherwise stage for filing such an application has not arisen yet as there is no
evidence available before the learned Trial Court which could require it to
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
elucidate the actual dispute. It is required for the petitioner/plaintiff to furnish
certain evidence first then only it could ask for appointment of a Commissioner
and, thus, this Court finds that the learned Trial Court has not committed any
error in holding that the said application has been preferred just to collect the
evidence.
Even otherwise the scope of interference in exercise of jurisdiction under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India is limited. The Supreme Court in the
matter of Shalini Shyam Shetty and Another vs. Rajendra Shankar Patil
reported in (2010) 8 SCC 329 has held that High Court in exercise of its
power cannot interfere to correct mere errors of law or fact or just because
another view than the one taken by the tribunals or courts subordinate to it, is a
possible view. The High Court can exercise this power when there has been a
patent perversity in the orders of the tribunals and courts subordinate to it or
where there is manifest failure of justice or the basic principles of natural justice
have been flouted.
Thus, this Court finds that no illegality or perversity committed by the
Trial Court in passing the impugned order. Thus, the petition being devoid of
any substance is hereby dismissed.
(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
Chandni
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review