Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
,
W.A. No.3354 of 2024
In the matter of appeals under Clause 10 of the Letters
Patent of Patna High Court read with Article 4 of the Orissa
High Court Order, 1948 from judgment dated 04.11.2024
passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No.12265 of
2021.
-----------
Laxman Kumar Pradhan
….
Appellant
….
Respondents
-versusState of Odisha & Others
Advocates Appeared in this case
For Appellant -
Mr. S. Mallik, Advocate
For Respondents -
Mr. U.C. Behura,
Addl. Government Advocate
------------
CORAM :
MR. JUSTICE KRISHNA S. DIXIT
MR. JUSTICE CHITTARANJAN DASH
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing & Judgment: 05.05.2026
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------PER KRISHNA S. DIXIT, J.
Appellant, a compulsorily retired forest official has
preferred this Intra-Court Appeal for assailing a learned Single
Judge’s order dated 04.11.2024 whereby his W.P.(C) No.12265 of
2021 has been negatived. In the said Petition, he had called in
question the Compulsory Retirement Order dated 20.01.2021.
2.
Learned counsel for the Appellant urged the following
grounds in support of the Appeal.
i.
The impugned order is punitive in nature and therefore,
could not have been entered without complying with the principles
of natural justice.
ii.
The impugned order could not have been made, regard being
had to the service credentials of the Appellant, such as two
promotions, State awards and the like.
iii.
The committee constituted for adjudging the credentials of
service did not advert to the relevant factors and thus there is a
non-consideration of the material on record to the disadvantage of
the Appellant.
iv.
Learned counsel for the Appellant in support of his
submissions pressed into service a Co-ordinate Bench decision of
this Court in Sanjaya Kumar Sahoo vs. State of Odisha1. He drew
our attention to the provisions of Rule 71 of Orissa Service Code,
which reads as under:
“Provided that a Government servant may be retired from service
any time after completing 30 years' qualifying service or on
attaining the age of fifty years, by giving a notice in writing to the
appropriate authority atleast three months before the date of which
he wishes to retire or by giving the said notice to the said authority
before such shorter period as Government may allow in any case.
It shall be open to the appropriate authority to withhold permission
. 2025 Live Law (Ori) 90.
to a Government servant who seek to retire under this rule, if he is
under suspension or if enquiries against him are in progress. The
appropriate authority may also require any officer to retire in
public interest any time after he has completed thirty years'
qualifying service or attained the age of fiffy years, by giving a
notice in writing to the Government servant atleast three months
before the date on which he is required to retire or by giving three
months pay and allowances in lien of such notice:”
3.
After service of notice, the official Respondents having
entered appearance through the learned AGA resist the Appeal
making submission in justification of the impugned order of the
learned Single Judge and also the Compulsory Retirement Order,
pointing out the circumstances into which they culminated. He
contends that the credentials of the Appellant are not that rosy as
sought to be made out; Appellant did not declare the acquisition
and holding of assets by his spouse contrary to Rules; he is also
facing VGR Case No.47 of 2019, which eventually is registered as
Balasore Vigilance P.S. Case No.13 of 2020, in which after
investigation, charge-sheet having been filed, charges also have
been framed by the Special Court; the Committee comprising of
high functionaries of the Government after having considered all
relevant factors has recommended the compulsory retirement and
the Government after examining all aspects of the matter, has
issued the order of compulsory retirement and therefore, a deeper
examination cannot be undertaken by this Court because of
conventional constraints.
4.
Having heard learned counsel for the Parties and having
perused the Appeal papers, we are inclined to grant indulgence in
the matter as under and for the following reasons:
4.1. The Appellant came to be appointed as Forester vide order
dated 08.12.1986 & he secured his first promotion as Range
Officer on 05.08.1996. Further, he got second promotion to the
post of Assistant Conservator of Forests with effect form
26.09.2018. He has also secured twice the State Award as the best
Range Officer for consecutive years 2015 & 2016. All these
glories have not been reflected in the deliberations made by the
Committee and that would constitute the first lacuna apparent on
the face of the record. In Sanjaya Kumar Sahoo supra, the Coordinate Bench observed that if the Officer concerned was given a
promotion despite adverse entries in ACRs, that is a fact weighing
in his favour. It hardly needs to be stated, when relevant factors do
not enter the fray of decision making, that makes the decision
vulnerable for challenge.
4.2. Learned counsel for the Appellant is right in telling us that a
Compulsory Retirement cannot be levied casually as a substitute
for holding the Disciplinary Enquiry, when allegations of
misconduct are serious. True it is that there were wild allegations
against the Appellant, for which the DE was proposed. However,
after securing his reply, the idea of holding the same has been
abandoned. Instead, the Committee referred to these abandoned
proceedings while recommending for Compulsory Retirement.
This amounts to error apparent on the face of the record. We
hastily add that the contention of learned AGA that no formal
order of dropping of enquiry proceedings against the Appellant
herein has been passed, pales into insignificance once he is
compulsorily retired.
4.3. Compulsory retirement is not a punishment, writes
Samaraditya Pal in Law Relating to Public Service, Third Edition,
LexisNexis, at Pages 905 & 906, which read as under:
“In service law 'punishment' has a special meaning. In short, it is
penal action taken against an employee by way of dismissal,
removal, reduction in rank, with- holding of promotion etc. for
misconduct after holding an enquiry. Punishment normally entails
forfeiture of some accrued benefits and invariably casts a stigma
on the employee concerned...
In 1954, the Supreme Court in Shyamlal v. State of U.P.2 explained
why premature retirement is not punishment. The Court gave the
following reasons:
...(c) "Compulsory" retirement has no stigma or implication of
misbehaviour or incapacity.
(d) Service rules ... indicate that dismissal or removal is a
punishment as it involves loss of benefit already earned and
deprives the employee of pension which he has earned-whereas in
compulsory retirement there is no such deprivation or loss.
But this is not an absolute proposition. In a given case, ... if the
Court is persuaded to hold that in substance, the order of
compulsory retirement was made by way of punishment, then it
would be void as, in such a case it would amount to dismissal or
removal made in violation of Art. 311 of the Constitution (in the
case of Government servants) and of the disciplinary rules (in
cases of other public employment).”
The reasoning of the Committee in recommending Compulsory
Retirement runs counter to the above opinio juris and that would
constitute second infirmity apparent on face of the record.
. AIR 1954 SC 369.
4.4. Above view also gains support from the Co-ordinate Bench
decision in Sanjaya Kumar Sahoo supra, which has secured
imprimatur at the hands of Apex Court in SLP No.22484 of 2025
decided on 07.04.2026, wherein paragraphs 9 & 10 run as under:
“9. Having considered the matter ... we find ourselves unable to
sustain that portion of the impugned order which, while setting
aside the compulsory retirement, simultaneously withholds
reinstatement and monetary benefits pending the outcome of the
fresh decision.
10. In our considered view, once an order of compulsory retirement
is set aside, the legal consequence that flows therefrom is the
restoration of the officer to his position in service, as though the
order had never been passed. Once an order of compulsory
retirement is set aside, the employer- employee relationship stands
restored. Without such reinstatement, the officer would stand
outside the service, and the Review Committee or the Full Court
would be placed in the anomalous position of deliberating upon the
continuance or retirement of a person who is not, in law, in service
at all. Any fresh decision taken in such circumstances would be
without a legally coherent foundation. The approach adopted by
the High Court, of setting aside the order while simultaneously
deferring its operative consequences, is therefore contradictory
and cannot be sustained.”
4.5. The service of Forest Officials such as the Appellant are
essential for protecting the Forests and environment, a
constitutional duty lying on the State vide Articles 48A & 51A (g)
in the light of T.N. Godavarman Tirumulpad3 Jurisprudence.
Admittedly, the Appellant-Forest Official has put in a continuous
service of about more than three decades. In his reply to the
Charge Memo issued in a contemplated Disciplinary Enquiry, he
had mentioned about the physical attack he suffered at the hands of
Forest Poachers eventually resulting into his hospitalization twice.
He has also mentioned about State accolade such as Chief
T.N. Godavarman Tirumulpad v. UOI, AIR 2012 SC 1254.
Minister’s Medals for protecting the Forest fauna & flora. That
being the position, it does not stand to reason that an Official of
this commitment should be thrown out from Public Service.
4.6. We also noticed from the record that the vigilance case is
pending against the Appellant as mentioned above, wherein the
Court has taken cognizance of the charge-sheet and framed
charges. However, as on the date the Committee recommended
and the Compulsory Retirement order came to be issued, the
matter was still at the investigation stage. It hardly needs to be
stated that what happened subsequently cannot infuse strength to
an otherwise unsustainable order, ex post facto. Under the extant
provisions of the Odisha Service Code, the criminal proceedings
are deemed to have been instituted when the charge-sheet has been
filed and not at any stage anterior thereto. Added, the
Disproportionate Assets Case, we are told at the Bar, involves 23%
excess income qua that from the known sources. Much is not
necessary to deliberate on this when the said case is pending at the
stage of trial.
4.7. Learned counsel for the Appellant is right in arguing that in
the teeth of text of the Proviso to Rule 71, an order of Compulsory
Retirement cannot be passed by the Government without
examining the recommendation of the Committee, howsoever high
its members be. The Government ought to have examined the
credentials of the Appellant such as long service of three decades,
procurement of two promotions on the basis of merit-cumPage 7 of 9
seniority, the trauma he underwent in protecting the Forests from
poachers, his hospitalization and the State Awards conferred on
him twice. Merely because a DA Case is pending, one cannot
hastily jumped to the conclusion as to what would happen to the
said case, especially when not even the charge-sheet was filed in
the Special Court, when decision was made. Further, no action is
taken against the Appellant allegedly for not reporting the
acquisition of assets by his spouse. Non-reporting is a ground for
denying promotion. However, in this case, two promotions granted
to him is a matter of record. Such a grant renders the arguable
misconduct into insignificance vide Sanjaya Kumar Sahoo
supra.
4.8. All the above being said, there is force in the submission of
learned AGA that even if the order of compulsory retirement is
quashed, no reinstatement can be granted to the Appellant, who
has already attained the age of superannuation i.e. 60 years
pendente lite. He is also right in submitting that Appellant may not
be awarded back wages till he comes out unscathed by securing an
order of honourable acquittal in the vigilance case in terms of Ram
Lal vs. State of Rajasthan4 and P.V. Rudrappa vs. State of
Karnataka5, because of that the ratio in Sanjaya Kumar Sahoo
supra to that extent does not come to the aid of Appellant. The
decision in this regard has to be taken by the State depending upon
the kind of disposal of the said case. We are also told at the Bar
. (2024) 1 SCC 175.
. 2024 KHC 4013-DB.
that because of the pendency of the said Vigilance Case, the
terminal benefits of have not yet been settled. What applies to the
payment of terminal benefits should equally apply to the claim for
back wages for the period between compulsory retirement and the
date on which Appellant would have normally retired after
attaining the age of superannuation.
In the above circumstances, this Appeal succeeds; a writ of
certiorari issues quashing the impugned order of compulsory
retirement in view of the observations herein above made.
Web copy of this order to be acted upon by all concerned.
(Krishna S. Dixit)
Judge
(Chittaranjan Dash)
Judge
Bijay/Sarbani
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SARBANI DASH
Designation: Junior Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 09-May-2026 10:45:34
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review