The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. It is noticed that, on above oral testimony and dying declarations, learned Trial Court has convicted accused persons for only offence under Section 498-A read with Section 34 of the IPC. The learned Trial Court, in paragraph No. 47, has clearly recorded a finding that the deceased herself gave two versions and, therefore, the prosecution case cannot be said to have been proved beyond reasonable doubt. However, merely by observing in paragraph No. 48 -10- CriAppeal-483-2017 that accused Nos. 1 and 3 were present at the spot and were dutybound to explain the cause of the deceased’s death, the learned Trial Court held that they were required to be convicted for offence under Section 498-A read with Section 34 of the IPC. Apparently, learned Trial Court has erred while drawing above conclusion. It is fairly settled position that each of the charge to be distinctly proved. Here, in one dying declaration, role is attributed to all the three accused, but in other dying declaration, role is attributed solely to mother-inlaw. There is no distinct evidence in the form of independent witness to show that all three accused were also present in the morning hours on the day of occurrence. There is no evidence to show that the accused persons maltreated deceased in the backdrop of demand for a gas connection. What is stated in the dying declarations is that there was a quarrel. In both dying…
13. 09.2017, for the offence under Section 498-A read with Section 34 of the IPC, stands quashed and set aside. IV. The appellants viz. (1) Latif Khan Maheboob Khan Pathan and (3) Ifranabi w/o Jawed Khan Pathan stand acquitted of the offence punishable under Section 498-A read with Section 34 of the IPC. The bail bonds of the appellants stand cancelled. VI. Fine amount deposited, if any, be refunded to the appellants after the statutory period. VI. It is clarified that there is no change as regards the order regarding disposal of muddemal. [ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.] scm
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:48484
CriAppeal-483-2017
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.483 OF 2017
1.
Latif Khan Maheboob Khan Pathan
Age: 60 years, Occu.: Labour,
2.
Mannabi w/o Latif Khan Pathan
Age: 55 years, Ocu.: Household,
3.
Iftanabi w/o Jawed Khan Pathan,
Age: 30 years, Occu.: Household,
All R/o. Ajijpura, Kaij,
Taluka Kaij, District Beed.
.. Appellants
Versus
.
The State of Maharashtra
Through Police Station Officer,
Police Station Kaij, Taluka Kaij,
District Beed.
.. Respondent
…
Mr. Manish P. Tripath, Advocate for the appellants.
Mr. S. M. Ganachari, APP for the respondent/State.
...
CORAM :
ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.
Reserved on : 12.10.2026
Pronounced on : 13.10.2026
JUDGMENT :1.
In this appeal, there is challenge to the judgment and order of
conviction dated 13.09.2017 rendered by the learned Additional
-2-
CriAppeal-483-2017
Sessions Judge, Ambejogai in Sessions Case No.97 of 2012 thereby
convicting the appellants for offence under Section 498-A read with
Section 34 of Indian Penal Code [IPC].
BRIEF FACTS OF THE PROSECUTION CASE
2.
Crime No.38 of 2012 was registered by Kaij Police Station,
District Beed for offence under Section 307 of the IPC on dying
declaration of deceased Naseem Pathan, who reported that on
13.03.2012, her in-laws abused her, beat her for failing to arrange for
gas and it is alleged that, she was incinerated. While being admitted
and undergoing treatment at Civil Hospital, Ambejogai, her above
dying declaration was recorded and on the strength of it, above crime
was registered. As deceased died due to burns, offence was converted
to Section 302 of the IPC and after investigation, parents-in-law,
husband and in-laws were duly charge-sheeted with above Sessions
Case. By judgment and order dated 13.09.2017, the accused Nos.1 to
3 came to be acquitted from offence under Sections 302, 504 read
with Section 34 of IPC. Accused No.4 came to be acquitted from all
the charges, whereas accused No.1 i.e. father-in-law, accused No.2
wife of accused No.1 and accused No.3 came to be convicted for
offence under Section 498-A read with Section 34 of IPC. Hence,
instant appeal at their instance.
-3-
CriAppeal-483-2017
SUBMISSIONS
On behalf of appellants :3.
At the outset, learned Counsel for the appellants submits that
appellant No. 2, Mannabi Latif Khan Pathan, died on 19.10.2021. He
has tendered a pursis along with death certificate of appellant No.2.
The same is taken on record. In view of the said pursis, the appeal
stands disposed of as abated against appellant No.2.
4.
As regards to appellant Nos.1 and 3 are concerned, learned
Counsel for the appellants pointed out that the prosecution has
miserably failed to bring home the charges. He would submit that
offence is registered on the basis of dying declaration, but the dying
declaration is not voluntary and moreover, is a product of tutoring.
That, second dying declaration is contrary to the first dying
declaration and is at variance. That, there was no demand or
harassment as alleged. He would point out that there is already
acquittal from Sections 302, 504 of the IPC. According to him,
allegations on the point of demand are general, omnibus and non
specific. There is no independent witness account. That learned Trial
Court ought not to have convicted accused on the same evidence, on
the basis of which they are acquitted. Hence, he prays to allow the
appeal.
-4-
CriAppeal-483-2017
On behalf of respondent/State :5.
Per contra, learned APP would support the judgment and order
of conviction. According to him, the incident of burning has taken
place in the house of accused. That, in the dying declaration deceased
had specified the role of each of the accused. There being correct
appreciation of evidence, he prays to dismiss the appeal for want of
merits.
EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIAL COURT AND ANALYSIS
Oral/ocular evidence :6.
Visited and studied the evidence on record. PW1 seems to be
the panch to spot, but he did not support. Likewise, PW2 is the
another panch, who did not support on the point of memorandum of
disclosure and recovery of kerosene can as well as matchbox from the
accused. PW3 is the second panch to recovery, who also has not
supported the prosecution. PW4, who is panch to seizure of plastic
bottle and burned cloth, also did not support prosecution.
7.
PW5 mother of the deceased, in her evidence at Exhibit-49,
deposed that, her deceased daughter married to accused Sattarkhan
and after marriage, she went to reside with accused in-laws. That,
after first delivery, accused did not take her daughter back and on
indulgence of relatives, she was taken back. In paragraph No.2 of her
examination-in-chief, she deposed that accused persons were
-5-
CriAppeal-483-2017
demanding Rs.50,000/- for purchasing tempo and gas connection and
accused Nos.1 to 4 beat her on that count. A meeting was held to give
understanding to the accused, following which her daughter was sent
back to cohabit with the accused. However, on the eve of RamzanEid, the accused-husband again dropped her at her parental home,
where she stayed for eight months. The husband did not take her
back to the matrimonial home. He used to visit her fortnight and
there was beating 20 to 22 days prior to the incident, during which
matter was settled. On 13.03.2012, phone call was received from
accused No.1 that deceased had set herself on fire. They all went to
the hospital, but according to her, she died on 14.03.2012. She claims
that, while offering juice to her daughter in the burn ward, she
inquired with her daughter, who told her that there had been a
quarrel at home over gas, as they were asking her to bring it from her
parental home. She further stated that her mother-in-law had poured
kerosene on her, whereas her father-in-law and sister-in-law had
abused her, and thereafter, her father-in-law had set her on fire with
a matchstick.
.
While under cross-examination, in paragraph No.13, she
answered that her statement was recorded by police on 15.03.2012,
wherein omission is brought to the extent of accused No.3 to be
-6-
CriAppeal-483-2017
divorcee, about daughter informing about quarrel at her house on
account of gas and about her daughter telling her mother-in law
poured kerosene, father-in-law and sister-in-law abusing her and
father-in-law igniting her. Therefore, these are material omissions and
her examination-in-chief is apparently improvised.
8.
Except above evidence of mother, there is no other evidence of
any other relative or even immediate neighbour.
9.
Apart from above total account, prosecution is also based on
two Dying Declarations, one is at Exhibit-54 and another is at
Exhibit-76.
10.
PW6 seems to have recorded dying declaration Exhibit-54 and
this police official, in his evidence at Exhibit-53, deposed about
requisition for recording dying declaration and accordingly visiting
hospital, approaching doctor to check the patient and to verify the
fitness and he accordingly named the doctor. He claims that after
obtaining endorsement, he asked all relatives to leave and then
recorded the statement, regarding which, in paragraph No.3 of his
examination-in-chief, he narrated about deceased informing him that
on 13.03.2012 at about 10.00 to 10.30 a.m., father-in-law, mother-inlaw and sister-in-law quarreling with her for not bringing gas from
-7-
CriAppeal-483-2017
her parental house. She reported that mother-in-law Manna poured
kerosene on her person and father-in-law ignited her. That time
husband came from outside and brought her to the hospital.
According to him, after the recording, he obtained her thumb
impression, again took certificate of doctor about fitness and read
over the statement to her. This witness identified the dying
declaration at Exhibit-54, the requisition letter at Exhibit-55, his
signature on the inquest panchanama at Exhibit-45, and the
postmortem report.
.
While under cross-examination, he stated that he did not record
dying declaration in question answer form. He admitted that thumb
impression of deceased is not attested.
11.
PW7 is the doctor, who issued certification of fitness Exhibit-
72A and Exhibit-72-B. In paragraph No.5 of his cross-examination, he
admitted that as per case papers, history was of suicidal burns.
12.
Contents of Dying declaration Exhibit-54 :“On 13.03.2012, around 10.00 to 10.30 a.m., in laws quarreled
and abused her for not bringing gas from parental house and
according to her, mother-in-law poured kerosene, sister-in-law
and father-in-law abused her and then father-in-law ignited
her.”
-8-
13.
CriAppeal-483-2017
Thus, what is emerging from above contents of dying
declaration Exhibit-54 is that role of sister-in-law is of hurling abuses,
whereas father-in-law ignited after mother-in-law poured kerosene.
14.
Second dying declaration is at Exhibit-76, which is recorded by
PW8 and he, in his evidence at Exhibit-75, deposed about receiving
requisition, visiting hospital, meeting doctor, obtaining endorsement
of fitness and then recording her statement. According to him,
deceased reported that she resides with her husband and in-laws and
the kid. That, her mother-in-law happens to be her maternal aunt in
relation. She reported that mother-in-law and sister-in-law always
raise quarrels with her. In the morning on the day of incident, there
was quarrel with mother-in-law and mother-in-law poured kerosene
and she only set her fire, due to which she sustained burns. This
witness has identified dying declaration Exhibit-76.
.
While under cross-examination, he stated that deceased told
that at the time of incident husband and father-in-law were not
present in the house.
15.
Contents of Dying Declaration Exhibit-76 are that :“After marriage she resides with husband and in-laws. She
reported that mother-in-law, father-in-law and sister-in-law
-9-
CriAppeal-483-2017
always quarrel with her by picking the quarrels on small
counts. That, in the morning on the day of incident, mother-inlaw picked up quarrel and even father-in-law and sister-in-law
joined her. That time, mother-in-law poured kerosene and
ignited her and thereby, she gave full names of father-in-law,
mother-in-law and sister-in-law.”
16.
Thus, on placing Exhibit-54 in juxtaposition with Exhibit-76, as
submitted, both are found to be at complete variance with each other.
In Exhibit-54, the deceased had named her mother-in-law as the
person who poured kerosene on her and her father-in-law as the
person who ignited her. However, contrary to this, in Exhibit-76, she
attributed both the acts of pouring kerosene and igniting her to her
mother-in-law alone. Resultantly, though both dying declarations,
Exhibits-54 and 76, were recorded in quick succession, they are
contrary to each other for the reasons stated above.
17.
It is noticed that, on above oral testimony and dying
declarations, learned Trial Court has convicted accused persons for
only offence under Section 498-A read with Section 34 of the IPC.
The learned Trial Court, in paragraph No. 47, has clearly recorded a
finding that the deceased herself gave two versions and, therefore, the
prosecution case cannot be said to have been proved beyond
reasonable doubt. However, merely by observing in paragraph No. 48
-10-
CriAppeal-483-2017
that accused Nos. 1 and 3 were present at the spot and were dutybound to explain the cause of the deceased’s death, the learned Trial
Court held that they were required to be convicted for offence under
Section 498-A read with Section 34 of the IPC. Apparently, learned
Trial Court has erred while drawing above conclusion. It is fairly
settled position that each of the charge to be distinctly proved. Here,
in one dying declaration, role is attributed to all the three accused,
but in other dying declaration, role is attributed solely to mother-inlaw. There is no distinct evidence in the form of independent witness
to show that all three accused were also present in the morning hours
on the day of occurrence. There is no evidence to show that the
accused persons maltreated deceased in the backdrop of demand for a
gas connection. What is stated in the dying declarations is that there
was a quarrel. In both dying declarations, except stating that there
was quarrel and that abuses were hurled, there is no further
clarification. Even otherwise, it is a solitary incident and not a case of
continuous harassment so as to attract the provisions of Section 498-A
of the IPC. Resultantly, evidence on the point of Section 498-A of the
IPC is also patently missing. Hence, the judgment and order of
learned Trial Court to that extent is also required to be quashed and
set aside. Hence, the following order is passed :-
CriAppeal-483-2017
-11-
ORDER
I.
The Criminal Appeal stands allowed.
II.
The Criminal Appeal stands disposed of as abated as against
appellant No.2.
III. The conviction awarded to the appellants viz. (1) Latif Khan
Maheboob Khan Pathan and (3) Ifranabi w/o Jawed Khan
Pathan by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Ambajogai in
Sessions Case No.97 of 2012 vide judgment and order dated
13.09.2017, for the offence under Section 498-A read with
Section 34 of the IPC, stands quashed and set aside.
IV. The appellants viz. (1) Latif Khan Maheboob Khan Pathan and
(3) Ifranabi w/o Jawed Khan Pathan stand acquitted of the
offence punishable under Section 498-A read with Section 34 of
the IPC.
V.
The bail bonds of the appellants stand cancelled.
VI. Fine amount deposited, if any, be refunded to the appellants
after the statutory period.
VI. It is clarified that there is no change as regards the order
regarding disposal of muddemal.
[ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.]
scm
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review