Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P.(C) No. 594 of 2022
Chabungbam Thoibisana Devi, aged about 54 years old, D/o Late
Chabungbam Ibotombi of Keishampat Leimajam Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795 001.
…. Petitioner
- Versus 1.
The State of Manipur represented by its Commissioner (Law), Law
& Legislative Affairs Department, Government of Manipur,
Secretariat, P.O. & P.S. Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
2.
The
Deputy
Secretary
(Law),
Law
&
Legislative
Affairs
Department, Government of Manipur, Secretariat, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
3.
The
Director
of
Prosecution,
Directorate
of
Prosecution,
Lamphelpat, P.O. & P.S. Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
…. Official Respondents
4.
R.K. Bhubaneshwari Devi, aged about 52 years old, W/o Thigom
Mangi Singh, a permanent resident of Sagolband Tera Sapam
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur –
795001.
5.
Akoijam Bobby Singh, aged about 48 years old, S/o A.K.
Shaymkishore Singh, a permanent resident of Wangkhei Koijam
Leikai, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795001.
6.
Hagzamoi Tonsing, aged about 48 years old, S/o T. Thongzathang,
a permanent resident of Dorcas Road, Dorcas Veng, New Lamka,
P.O. & P.S. Churachandpur, Churachandpur District, Manipur –
795128.
P a g e 1 | 21
7.
Shri Khangembam Mohen Singh, aged about 48 years old, S/o
(Late) Kh. Gouri, a permanent resident of Chingmeirong Mamang
Leikai, P.O. Porompat & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal East District,
Manipur.
8.
Leimapokpam Bimol Singh, aged about 45 years old, S/o L. Mangi
Singh, a permanent resident of Athokpam Mayai Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur – 795138.
9.
Khodram Anupama Devi, aged about 44 years old, D/o (Late) Kh.
Suresh Singh, a permanent resident of Kwakeithel Bazar, Opposite
Kwakiethel Girls High School, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur – 795001.
10.
Thounaojam Bandana Devi, aged about 43 years old, W/o M.
Okendro Singh, a permanent resident of Heirangoithong Makha
Mutum Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur
– 795008.
…. Private Respondents
W.P.(C) No. 600 of 2022
Lamneichong Haokip, aged about 51 years old, W/o Sheikhohao Kipgen
of Tuipaijang Village, P.O. & P.S. G. Sapormeina, Kangpokpi District,
Manipur – 795129 present residing at National Game Village, Mary Kom
Complex, Zone – 3, P.O & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur.
…Petitioner
- Versus 1.
The State of Manipur represented by its Commissioner (Law), Law
& Legislative Affairs Department, Government of Manipur,
Secretariat, P.O. & P.S. Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
…. Official Respondent
2.
R.K. Bhubaneshwari Devi, aged about 52 years old, W/o Thigom
Mangi Singh, a permanent resident of Sagolband Tera Sapam
P a g e 2 | 21
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur –
795001.
3.
Akoijam Bobby Singh, aged about 48 years old, S/o A.K.
Shaymkishore Singh, a permanent resident of Wangkhei Koijam
Leikai, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795001.
4.
Hagzamoi Tonsing, aged about 48 years old, S/o T. Thongzathang,
a permanent resident of Dorcas Road, Dorcas Veng, New Lamka,
P.O. & P.S. Churachandpur, Churachandpur District, Manipur –
795128.
5.
Shri Khangembam Mohen Singh, aged about 48 years old, S/o
(Late) Kh. Gouri, a permanent resident of Chingmeirong Mamang
Leikai, P.O. Porompat & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal East District,
Manipur.
6.
Leimapokpam Bimol Singh, aged about 45 years old, S/o L. Mangi
Singh, a permanent resident of Athokpam Mayai Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur – 795138.
7.
Khodram Anupama Devi, aged about 44 years old, D/o (Late) Kh.
Suresh Singh, a permanent resident of Kwakeithel Bazar, Opposite
Kwakiethel Girls High School, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur – 795001.
8.
Thounaojam Bandana Devi, aged about 43 years old, W/o M.
Okendro Singh, a permanent resident of Heirangoithong Makha
Mutum Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur
– 795008.
…. Private Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioners :
Mr. S. Biswajit, Senior Advocate &
W. Sanatomba, Advocate
Mr. Serto T. Kom, Advocate
P a g e 3 | 21
For the respondents :
Mr. Niranjan Sanasam, Govt. Advocate
Ms. Ayangleima, Advocate
Date of hearing
03.10.2025
:
Date of Judgment &
Order
:
23.12.2025
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. S. Biswajit, learned senior counsel and Mr. Serto T. Kom,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioners; Mr. Niranjan Sanasam, learned
Government Advocate appearing for the State and Ms. Ayangleima, learned counsel
appearing for private respondents.
[2]
The annexures mentioned in this judgment are from the writ petition
WP(C) No. 594 of 2022 for easy reference. Since both these writ petitions pertain to
the same impugned order, they are being disposed of by this common judgment.
Factual matrix of the case in a nutshell is that the present petitioners were initially
appointed as Assistant Public Prosecutor -cum- Assistant Government Advocate on
contract basis for a period of 1 (one) year vide order dated 20.12.2005 issued by
Secretary (Law), Government of Manipur (Annexure – A/1) wherein the petitioners
appeared at Sl. No. 2 & Sl. No. 3 and services of the petitioners were extended from
time to time by the competent authority till December, 2016 (Annexure – A/2).
Regarding appointment of the said post, the Secretary (Law), Government
substantiated through Local Newspaper (Naharolgi Thoudang) vide publication dated
03.01.2006 (Annexure – A/3) whereby reporting that the afore-referred appointment
P a g e 4 | 21
did not suffer from any irregularity as the recruitment was conducted through an
advertisement inviting applications from eligible advocates either through All Manipur
Bar Association or Law Department, Government of Manipur.
[3]
Vide order dated 02.12.2016 issued by the Secretary (Law), Government
of Manipur (Annexure – A/4), the petitioners were appointed on regular basis along
with 13 (thirteen) others by regularizing their past contract services and on the very
same day, 6 (six) other APP-cum-AGA were also made regular appointment by
regularizing their past contract services. In the said appointment order, the petitioners
in W.P.(C) No. 594 of 2022 and W.P.(C) No. 600 of 2022 were placed at Sl. No. 1 &
Sl. No. 2 respectively and as per the decisions made by the State Cabinet dated
04.08.2016 and 07.11.2016. The order was also made as one time measure which
was issued by the Department of Personal & Administrative Reforms (Personal
Division), Government of Manipur dated 22.11.2026.
[4]
The Deputy Secretary (Law), Government of Manipur, vide notification
dated 13.09.2021 (Annexure – A/5) wherein the petitioners appeared at Sl. No. 4 &
Sl. No. 6 in W.P.(C) No. 594 of 2022 and W.P.(C) No. 600 of 2022 respectively, issued
a tentative seniority list of APP(District)-cum-AGA (District) whereby calling any claims
and objections to the said list. Thereafter, a final seniority list was published vide
notification dated 23.11.2021 whereby the petitioner was placed at Sl. No. 10 & Sl.
No. 11 in W.P.(C) No. 594 of 2022 and W.P.(C) No. 600 of 2022 respectively (Annexure
– A/6).
[5]
In this regard, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that
the petitioners were initially appointed on contract basis on 20.12.2005 and made
regularization on 02.12.2016. However, without any reason, the petitioners in W.P.(C)
P a g e 5 | 21
No. 594 of 2022 and W.P.(C) No. 600 of 2022, were placed at Sl. No. 10 & Sl. No. 11
respectively which are below the batches of APPs appointed in the years 2007, 2009
and 2010.
[6]
Being aggrieved by the said seniority list, the petitioners challenged the
same by filing a writ petition i.e. W.P.(C) 895 of 2021 before the High Court and the
said writ petition was allowed vide order dated 01.06.2022 (Annexure – A/7) upholding
the regularization of the petitioners made by the Secretary (Law), Government of
Manipur dated 02.12.2016. Operative portion of the order passed in the afore-referred
writ petition is reproduced herein below:
“In terms of the proposal made by the learned A.G., Manipur, the
respondents are directed to finalize the Final Seniority List of Assistant Public
Prosecutor (District) -cum- Assistant Government Advocate (District), Manipur
in the Office of the Public Prosecutor (District), Manipur within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a copy of the order of this Court. Thereafter,
promotion to the post of Addl. Public Prosecutor (District)-cum-Additional
Government Advocate (District) in the Office of Public Prosecutor (District),
Manipur shall be made within a period of 3 (three) months in accordance with
the prevailing Recruitment Rules when the vacancies arose.
It is also made clear that the promotional post to the post of Addl. Public
Prosecutor (District)-cum-Additional Government Advocate (District) in the
Office of Public Prosecutor (District) shall not be filled up by way of any other
method except in terms of the directions passed by this Court.”
In pursuance of the order passed in the afore-referred writ petition, vide
notification dated 08.06.2022(Annexure – A/8), the Deputy Secretary (Law),
Government of Manipur set aside and quashed the seniority list dated 23.11.2021. As
per the said notification whereby calling claims and objections, if any, from the
concerned on or before 22.06.2022, the petitioners filed their objection against the
tentative seniority list wherein the petitioners in W.P.(C) No. 594 of 2022 and W.P.(C)
No. 600 of 2022 appeared at Sl. No. 9 & Sl. No. 10 respectively.
P a g e 6 | 21
[7]
The learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners further submits
that without considering the judgment & order dated 01.06.2022 passed in W.P.(C)
No. 895 of 2022 and also the objection filed by the petitioners, vide notification dated
22.07.2022 (Annexure – A/10), the Deputy Secretary (Law), Government of Manipur
published a final seniority list wherein the petitioners appeared at Sl. No. 10 & Sl. No.
11 well below her colleagues who are junior to both of them, which is impugned in
the present writ petition. The impugned notification reads as follows:
“GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
SECRETARIAT : LAW & LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT
NOTIFICATION
Imphal, the 22 July, 2022
Subject:
Final Seniority List of Asst. Public Prosecutor (District)-cumAsst. Government Advocate (District), Manipur in the office of Public Prosecutor
(District), Manipur.
No.GAP-3/5/2021-SEC-LAW Whereas, the Hon'ble High Court of Manipur has
directed to State Government to finalize the finial seniority list of Asst. Public
Prosecutor (District)-cum-Asst. Government Advocate (District), Manipur in
office of the Public Prosecutor (District), Manipur within a period of two months
from the date of receipt of copy of the order of Hon'ble High Court in the order
dated 01-06-2022 passed in WP(C) No. 2 of 2019 with WP(C) No. 896 of 2018
with MC(WP(C)) No. 137 of 2022 with MC(WP(C)) No. 138 of 2022 with
MC(WP(C)) No. 139 of 2022 with MC(WP(C)) No. 89 of 2019 with WP(C) No. 5
of 2020 with MC(WP(C)) No. 132 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 895 of 2021 (Ch.
Thoibisana Devi & Anr-vs-State of Manipur);
2 Whereas, the tentative seniority list of Asst. Public Prosecutor (District)-cumAsst Government Advocate (District), Manipur has been published under this
Department's Notification of even number dated 13.09.2021 inviting therein
claims or objections from all concerned,
3 Whereas, all the claims and objections in respect of st. no. 01 to 13 received
in this regard were examined and considered including obtaining of
comment/view along with additional submission by holding person to person
meeting with the Whit Petitioners which were held at different timings from
14.07.2022 (09:30 am) to 15.07.2022 (09:30 am);
4 Whereas, the Asst. Public Prosecutor (District)-cum-Asst. Government
Advocate (District), Manipur from sl. no. 14 to 18 in the list had not submitted
P a g e 7 | 21
any claims and objections and that their appointment was on the
recommendation of MPSC in the recruitment year of 2018 on merit.
5. And after detailed examination and consideration, it is hereby notified for
information of all concerned, the final seniority list of Asst. Public Prosecutor
(District)-cum-Asst. Government Advocate (District), Manipur in the Office of
Public Prosecutor (District), Manipur as in ANNEXURE appended herewith.
Sd/(Henry Alemo Francis)
Deputy Secretary (Law),
Government of Manipur
ANNEXURE
Notification No. GAP-3/5/2021-SEC-LAW
Imphal, 22nd July, 2022
FIAL SENIRITY LIST OF ASST. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (DISTRICT)-CUM-ASST.
GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE (DISTRICT), MANIPUR IN THE OFFICE OF PUBLIC
PROSECUTOR (DISTRICT), MANIPUR
Sl.
No.
Name
1.
Smt.
RK
Bhubaneshwari Devi
2.
Shri Akijam Bobby
Singh
Shri
Hangamoi
Tonsing
Shri Khangembam
Mohen
Shri Leimapokpam
Bimol Singh
Miss
Khomdram
Anupama Devi
Smt. Thounaojam
Bandana Devi
Shri
Khuman
Cheirakpam
Basanta Singh
Shri
Mutum
Ajitkumar Singh
Smt.Chabungbam
Thoibisana Devi
Smt. Lamneichong
Haokip
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Date
of
appointment
on regular
basis
02.12.2016
Date of birth
Remarks
01.02.1969
Initially engaged
on contract basis
by
selection
through
open
recruitment
process
-do-
05.03.1973
-do-
-do-
01.05.1973
-do-
-do-
10.02.1974
-do-
-do-
01.02.1976
-do-
-do-
24.12.1977
-do-
-do-
01.03.1978
-do-
-do-
01.01.1963
-do-
-do-
01.02.1963
-do-
-do-
01.03.1967
-do-
-do-
01.03.1971
-do-
P a g e 8 | 21
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
Smt.
Meitankeishangbam
Jamuna Devi
Smt. Rakhi Golmei
Smt. Phuritsabam
Chaoba Devi
Smt.
Kangjam
Malemnganbi
Chanu
Shri
Hrangao
Rozhemai
Smt.
Mayanglambam
Vidhyalaxmi Devi
Shri K.S. Pamreiso
-do-
01.03.1971
-do-
-do21.12.2018
01.03.1977
01.03.1983
-do-
01.04.1991
-doAppointed vide
Order No.
7/52/2018-GA/L
dated
21.12.2018 on
recommendation
by MPSC vide
their letter No.
7/6/2018-MPSC
(DR) dated
15.10.2018
-do-
-do-
01.03.1985
-do-
-do-
30.03.1986
-do-
-do-
15.10.1988
-do-
Sd/(Henry Alemo Francis)
Deputy Secretary (Law),
Government of Manipur“
Being aggrieved by the afore-referred notification, the petitioners filed
the present writ petition challenging the same. It is evident from the earlier final
seniority list dated 23.11.2022, those persons appearing at Sl. No. 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 and 7
were initially appointed on 26.11.2009. Furthermore, the one appearing at Sl. No. 4
was initially appointed on 17.02.2010. By any standard, the present petitioners ought
to be above those persons at Sl. No. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 & 7. Even if age is the standard
to be used, then the petitioners (whose date of birth is 01.03.1967) must be placed
well above those persons appearing at Sl. No. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7.
[8]
Furthermore, it has been submitted by the learned counsel for the
petitioners that the respondent authority made the impugned notification in violation
of principle of equality guaranteed under Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
P a g e 9 | 21
The mandate of Article 14 and 16 demands that determination of seniority to be based
on some principles, which are justice and fair. The said seniority list prepared by the
respondent authority placed the petitioners below the batches of APPs junior to both
of them are in and of itself discriminatory and arbitrary.
[9]
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners also submits that since
the appointment has been made by following the constitutional scheme of public
employment, it is entitled to due consideration while conferring benefits of service
condition including seniority. Hence, in the impugned final seniority list dated
22.07.2022, the indication “Initially engaged on contract basis by execution of
agreement” against the petitioners is grossly wrong and it should be “Initially engaged
on contract basis by selection through open recruitment process” and therefore, the
petitioners would be placed at Sl. No. 1 & Sl. No. 3. Therefore, the present writ
petition has been filed with a prayer for giving direction to the respondent authority
to maintain the order/sequence as shown in the regularization order No. 7/13/2015GA/L(B) dated 02.12.2016 and set aside the impugned notification dated 22.07.2022.
[10]
In respect of W.P.(C) No. 594 of 2022, learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner has made written submission on behalf of the petitioner.
A. SCOPE AND GROUNDS OF CHALLENGE
The impugned seniority list published vide notification dated 22-07-2022 (AT
ANNEXURE A/7) is being challenged inter alia on the following grounds:
1. Arbitrary placement of the petitioner below her juniors and
consequent violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India.
The impugned final seniority list has inexplicably placed the present
petitioner—who was appointed as APP-cum-AGA on a contractual basis as
far back as 2005—below her peers who entered service only in 2009 on an
P a g e 10 | 21
identical contractual footing. This inversion of seniority is not merely
illogical; it is manifestly arbitrary and fundamentally inconsistent with
established principles of fairness in public service. It is crucial to underscore
that the services of both the petitioner and her peers were subsequently
regularized by the Government vide order dated 02-12-2016 (AT
ANNEXURE A/4). The regularization order itself speaks unequivocally: the
petitioner’s name appears at the very top of the list, a placement that
unmistakably demonstrates that the Government had consciously
recognized the petitioner’s longer and uninterrupted tenure of contractual
service while determining the relative standing of the APPs-cum-AGAs at the
time of regularization. The order and the sequence reflected therein are
neither accidental nor cosmetic; they constitute a deliberate administrative
determination acknowledging the petitioner’s seniority. The respondent
authority cannot now attempt to rewrite history by ignoring the
regularization order and substituting it with an entirely new and inconsistent
basis for seniority. Such an act not only disturbs a settled position but also
undermines the binding effect of a government order that has neither been
appealed against nor modified by any competent court of law, and has
therefore attained finality.
Furthermore, even if one were to assume for the sake of argument that
past contractual service is to be disregarded altogether and seniority is to
be determined strictly by reference to the regularization order dated 02-122016, the petitioner’s name still appears at the top of that list. By any lawful
metric—whether by reckoning past contractual service or by using the
regularization order as the baseline—the petitioner’s rightful place is at the
top of the seniority list. Significantly, even if age were to be adopted as an
additional criterion to resolve any supposed tie in seniority, the petitioner is
demonstrably the oldest among her peers and, on that ground as well, is
entitled to precedence over the others. The impugned seniority list’s
departure from all these settled and objective standards—past service, the
sequence in the regularization order, and even the criterion of age—renders
it patently arbitrary, irrational, and violative of Article 14. It reflects a blatant
arbitrary exercise of power and a failure to adhere to the most basic tenets
of fairness and equality, and is thus unsustainable in law.
2. Arbitrary, irrational and whimsical distinction of categories and
consequent violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India.
The impugned final seniority list impermissibly carves out two artificial
categories of employees within the very same cadre and grade on the
ostensible ground that their initial appointments were contractual in
different forms. Such a distinction is plainly irrational, manifestly arbitrary,
and unsustainable in law. Once the Government, by its regularization
orders, ratified the entirety of their past contractual service and accorded
them the same substantive status, there remained no lawful basis to
resurrect the nature of their initial engagement as a ground for differential
treatment. The respondent authority cannot now rewrite history or employ
shifting yardsticks to deny parity in seniority to officers who stand on an
P a g e 11 | 21
equal footing in every material respect. Any such attempt amounts to a
blatant violation of Articles 14 and 16 and an affront to the rule of law.
3. The complete disregard and non-consideration of the judgment
and order dated 01-06-2022 passed by this Hon’ble High Court in
WP(C) No. 895 of 2022.
It may be poignant to note that this is second round of litigation with
regard to the issue of seniority amongst the APPs-cum-AGAs. In the earlier
round of litigation raised in WP(C) No. 895 of 2022, a coordinate bench of
this Hon’ble High Court was pleased to set aside and quash the earlier final
seniority list. Moreover, the Ld. AG at the relevant time submitted that the
Department was willing to undertake another exercise for reconsideration
of the final seniority list. Consequently, the said writ petition was allowed
by the Hon’ble High Court vide judgment and order dated 01-06-2022
thereby allowing the prayer of the petitioner to maintain the order/sequence
reflected in the regularization order dated 02-12-2016 (AT ANNEXURE
A/4). This judgment and order nor regularization order has been appealed
or challenged before any court of law and has attained finality and therefore,
deserves to be followed in letter and spirit by the respondent authority.
Hence, any departure therefrom amounts to a clear disregard of judicial
mandate and strikes at the root of administrative fairness and the rule of
law.
B. POSITION OF LAW IN FAVOUR OF THE PETITIONER
Determination of seniority
The settled principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court on the
determination of seniority are as follows:
1. In the cases of A.K. Subrman and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.1,
it has been held by the Supreme Court that in the absence of statutory
seniority rules, seniority is to the determined on the basis of length of
service in the grade as well as in an equivalent grade.
2. In the case of Rudra Kumar Sain and Ors. Vs. Union of India and
Ors.2, the Supreme Court observed “20. In the service Jurisprudence, a
person who possesses the requisite qualification for being appointed to a
particular post and then he is appointed with approval and consultation of
the appropriate authority and continues in the post for a fairly long period,
then such appointment cannot be held to be ‘stop gap or fortuitous or purely
ad hoc’. In this view of the matter, the reasoning and basis on which, the
appointment of the promotes in the Delhi Higher Judicial Service in the case
at hand was held by the High Court to be ‘fortuitous/ ad hoc/ stop gap’ are
wholly erroneous and, therefore, exclusion of those appointees to have their
continuous length of service for seniority is erroneous”.
(1975) 1 SCC 319
AIR 2000 SC 2808
P a g e 12 | 21
3. In the case of G.S. Lamba and Ors. VS. Union of India and Ors.3, the
Supreme Court observed that in the absence of any valid principle of
seniority, continuous officiation in the cadre, grade service will provide valid
principle for seniority.
4. In the case of Narender Chadha and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.4,
the Supreme Court referred to the case of D.R. Nim Vs. Union of India (AIR
1967 SC 1301), wherein it has been observed that when an officer has
worked for a long period for nearly 15 to 20 years in a post and had never
been rebutted, his continuation in the office cannot be held to be a
temporary or stop gap arrangement even though the order of appointment
may state so and in such circumstances, entire period of officiation has to
be counted for seniority.
5. In the case of Desoola Rama Rao and Anr. Vs. State of Andhra
Pradesh and Ors.5, the Supreme Court observed that in the absence of
any seniority rules, length of service is the basis of fixing inter-se-seniority.
6. In the case of S.N. Dhingra and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.6, the
Supreme Court, referring to the Constitution Bench’s Judgment in Rudra
Kumar Sain and others (supra), observed that continuous length of service
should be the basis for inter-se-seniority.
7. In the case of D.P. Das Vs, Union of India and Ors.7, the Supreme Court,
referred to the case of M.B Joshi and others Vs. Satish Kumar Pandey and
others, reported in AIR 1993 SC 267, wherein it has been laid down that in
the absence of any specific rules, seniority amongst persons holding similar
post in the same cadre has to be determined on the basis of length of service
and not on any other fortuitous circumstances. In the case of D.P. Das
(supra), the Supreme Court observed that, if no rule is prescribed for
determination of seniority, the guide line following from the executive
instruction may be accepted in order to evolve a just policy, for
determination of seniority.
In view of the above principles laid down by the Apex Court, it is clear that
in the absence of any service rule, uninterrupted length of service rendered by
an appointee in a grade is required to be taken as the criteria for fixing his
seniority. The service of the appointees made dehors the service rules cannot
be taken into consideration to fix the seniority over the appointees, who are
appointed as per the service rules. It is also settled law that the seniority of an
incumbent, appointed as per the service rules, is to be counted from the date
of his appointment and not according to the date of his confirmation. However,
if the initial appointment is not made following the service procedure, but the
incumbent is allowed to continue in the post interruptedly till regularization of
his service in accordance with the rules, the period of officiating service is
required to be counted.
(1985) 2 SCC 604
(1986) 2 SCC 157
AIR 1988 SC 857
AIR 2001 SC 1535
AIR 2011 SC 2947
P a g e 13 | 21
C. REBUTTAL
The so-called distinction sought to be drawn between officers in the very
same cadre merely on the pretext that the petitioner’s initial contractual
appointment was irregular is not only arbitrary but patently unsustainable in
law. This contrived ground collapses under the weight of the contemporaneous
press statement issued by the then Law Department itself, published in the
newspaper, which categorically affirmed that the appointments to the post of
APP were publicly advertised and that no irregularity whatsoever tainted the
selection process. When the appointing authority’s own public declaration
disproves the allegation of irregularity, the respondents cannot now be
permitted to invent a justification to deny the petitioner parity in seniority. (AT
ANNEXURE A/3).
[11]
WRITTEN ARGUMENT WITH CITATION ON BEHALF OF THE
PETITIONER WP(C) No. 600 of 2022:
1. Prayer in the Writ petition :
The petitioner is praying for quashing the Notification/Final Seniority List of
Assistant Public Prosecutor (District)-Cum-Asst. Govt. Advocate(District), Manipur dt.
22-7-2022 at Annexure-A/10 of the Writ petition. (at page 41 of the writ petition).
2. Grounds :
A. Petitioner was appointed earlier than all the private Respondents in the
post of APP(District)-Cum- Asst. Govt. Advocate(Dist.) Manipur:
(i) Initial appointment of the petitioner by an order dt. 20-12-2005 at
Annexure-A/1 of the petition (at page 19 of the petition).
The Clarification of Law Secretary in the Local Paper Naharolgi Thaodang at
Annexure-A/3 (at page 21 & 22 of the writ petition) that recruitment of 3 APPS
including the petitioner, were made after advertisements made and published in
the various Local papers.
(ii) Initial appointment of the Respondents reflected by the Annexure of the
Notification 23-11-2021 at Annexure-A/6 (at page 28-30 of the writ petition).
Sl.No.
1.
2.
3.
Respondent
No.
2, 3, 4, 6, 8
Date of Initial
Appointment
26-11-2009
17-2-2010
05-1-2010
B. In the Regularisation order dt. 2-12-2016 at Annexure-A/4 (at page 23 of the
writ petition) in respect of the petitioner and all the Private Respondents, the
P a g e 14 | 21
petitioner is rightly placed at Sl.No. 2 above all the Private Respondents (at Sl.No.
5,6,7,8,9, 10 & 11).
C. The act of the Respondent No.1 is arbitrary and illegal in view of the following facts
and grounds :(i)
No Reason and Reconsideration of Seniority Position :
The impugned order is being issued without any reason and
reconsideration against the undertaking made by the Ld. A.G. Manipur reflected in
the order dt. 01-06-2022 passed by this Hon'ble Court in W.P.(C)No.2 of 2019,
W.P.(C)No.896 of 2018, W.P.(C) No.5 of 2020 and W.P.(C)No.895 of 2021 (at page
32, of the petition), wherein the similar previous Final Seniority 23-11-2021 (at page
28 of the petition) was set aside (at page 34 and 35 of the writ petition).
No reason is being assigned by the Govt. for issuing the Final Seniority
list of APP(District)-Cum- Asst. Govt. Advocate(Dist.) Manipur, without any change
from the previous Final Seniority list dt. 23-11-2021 (already quashed).
(ii)
Petitioner treated differently:
Though the petitioner and the Private Respondents were similarly
engaged on contract basis and regularized by the same order dt. 2-12-2016 (at page
23 of the petition) the Private Respondents were differently treated to march over the
petitioner in the Final Seniority list.
(iii)
Non consideration of the length of service:
That the Respondent No.1 has failed to consider the length of service of
the petitioner which qualifies her to be above all the private Respondents in the
seniority list of the APP(District)-Cum- Asst. Govt. Advocate(Dist.) Manipur, in view of
the law laid down by the Apex Court in a Catena of cases, that in the absence of
binding rule of seniority, the length of continuous service is valid principle
of seniority. In the present case also, there is no Rule for consideration seniority of
contract employees.
CITATIONS:
1. G.P. Doval - Vs- Chief Secretary, Govt. of U.P. reported in (1984) 4 SCC
329 Para 15 is reproduced hereunder :
" 15 Now if there was no binding rule of seniority it is well-settled that
length of continuous officiation prescribes a valid principle of seniority. The
question is from what date the service is to be reckoned ? It was urged that any
appointment of a stop-gap nature or pending the selection by Public Service
Commission cannot be taken into account for reckoning seniority. In other words, it
was urged that to be in the cadre and to enjoy place in the seniority list, the service
rendered in a substantive capacity can alone be taken into consideration. We find it
difficult to accept this bald and wide submission. Each case will depend
P a g e 15 | 21
upon its facts and circumstances. If a stop-gap appointment is made and the
appointee appears before the Public Service Commission when the latter proceeds to
select the candidates and is selected, we see no justification for ignoring his past
service. At any rate, there is no justification for two persons selected in the
same manner being differently treated. That becomes crystal clear from the
place assigned in the seniority list to petitioner No. 1 in relation to respondent No. 7.
In fact if once a person appointed in a stop-gap arrangement is confirmed in his post
by proper selection, his past service has to be given credit and he has to be assigned
seniority accordingly unless a rule to the contrary is made. That has not been done in
the case of all the petitioners. The error is apparent in the case of petitioner 1 and
respondent No. 7. These errors can be multiplied but we consider it unnecessary to
do so. In fact a fair rule of seniority should ordinarily take into account the
past service in the stop-gap arrangement is followed by confirmation. This
view which we are taking is borne out by the decision of this Court in Baleshwar Dass
and Ors. etc. v. State of U.P. and Ors. etc., wherein this Court observed that the
principle which has received the sanction of this Court's pronouncement is that
'officiating service in a post for all practical purposes of seniority is as good as service
on a regular basis. It may be permissible, within limits for government to ignore
officiating service and count only regular service when claims of seniority come before
it, provided the rules in that regard are clear and categorical and do not admit of any
ambiguity and cruelly arbitrary cut-off of long years of service does not take place or
there is functionally and qualitatively, substantial difference in the service rendered in
the two types of posts.' It was said that service rules will have to be reasonable, fair
and not grossly unjust if they are to survive the test of Articles 14 and 16. It is thus
well-settled that where officiating appointment is followed by confirmation unless a
contrary rule is shown, the service rendered as officiating appointment cannot be
ignored for reckoning length of continuous officiation for determining the place in the
seniority list. Admittedly, that has not been done and the seniority list is drawn up
from the date on which the approval/selection was made by the Public Service
Commission in respect of each member of the service, which is clearly violative of Art.
16, and any seniority list drawn up on this invalid basis must be quashed.
2. Nirmal Kumar Choudhary & Ors.—Vs- State of Bihar & Ors
1988(Supp) SCC 107 para 4 is reproduced hereunder:
"4. It is a well-settled position in law that seniority would ordinarily depend
upon length of service subject, of course, to rules holding the field. That view
has been taken by this Court in several cases and it is unnecessary to refer to all of
them. In A. Janardhana v. Union of India & Ors., [1983] 2 SCR 936 the situation was
somewhat the same as here. The Court found that the method adopted for fixing
seniority overlooked the character of appointments and pushed down persons validly
appointed below others who had no justification to be given higher place. At page 960
of the Reports, the Court observed:
"It is an equally well recognised canon of service jurisprudence that in the absence of
any other valid rule for determining inter se seniority of members belonging to the
same service, the rule of continuous officiation or the length of service or the date of
P a g e 16 | 21
entering in service and continuous uninterrupted service thereafter would be valid and
would satisfy the tests of Article 16."
We may also refer to a very recent decision of this Court in K.S. Vora & ors. v. State
of Gujarat & Ors., [1987] 4 Judgment Today 179. The High Court recorded a finding
that there is no applicable rule in the matter of fixing inter se seniority in a situation
of this type. In the absence of rules, the more equitable way of preparing the
combined gradation list would be to take the total length of service in the common
grade as the basis for determining inter se seniority. We would like to add that in
regard to the Supervisors (now called Junior Engineers) serving in the three wings
there is no dispute of the grade being the same. While we do not agree with the High
Court that confirmation should be the basis and would substitute it by the length of
service test, we would uphold the direction that in fixing the combined gradation list
the inter se seniority of the incumbents in their respective departments would not be
disturbed. Even if this be the test, the gradation list as published by Government has
to be modified. We would accordingly confirm the conclusion of the High Court that
Annexures 1 1, 11/1, 12, 13, 13/1, 15 and 16 should be quashed and a fresh combined
gradation list has to be published. We have altered the test for fixing the seniority
inter se generally but we have approved the direction of inter se seniority in their own
departments to be respected. The respondent-State and its officers are directed to
prepare and publish the fresh combined gradation list keeping the aforesaid directions
in view."
3. Sudhir Kumar Atrey –Vs- Union of India & Ors
(2022)1 SCC 352 Para 17 is reproduced hereunder:“17. We are also of the view that in the matter of adjudging seniority of the candidates
selected in one and the same selection, placement in the order of merit can be adopted
as a principle for determination of seniority but where the selections are held
separately by different recruiting authorities, the principle of initial date of
appointment/continuous officiation may be the valid principle to be
considered for adjudging inter se seniority of the officers in the absence of
any rule or guidelines in determining seniority to the contrary.”
4. Maneka Gandhi – Vs – Union of India
(1978) 1 SCC 248 Para 7 is reproduced hereunder:
“7 Now, the question immediately arises as to what is the requirement of Article 14 :
what is the content and reach of the great equalising principle enunciated in this article
? There can be no doubt that it is a founding faith of the Constitution. It is indeed the
pillar on which rests securely the foundation of our democratic republic. And,
therefore, it must not be subjected to a narrow, pedantic or lexicographic approach.
No attempt should be made to truncate its all embracing scope and meaning for, to
do so would be to violate its activist magnitude. Equality is a dynamic concept with
many aspects and dimensions and it cannot be imprisoned Within traditional and
doctrinaire limits. We must reiterate here what was pointed out by the majority in E.
P a g e 17 | 21
P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu & Another (1) namely, that "from a positivistic point
of view, equality is antithetic to arbitrariness. In fact equality and arbitrariness
are sworn enemies; one belongs to the rule of law in a republic, while the
other, to the whim and caprice of an absolute monarch. Where an act is
arbitrary, it is implicit in it that it is unequal both according to political logic and
constitutional law and is therefore violative of Article 14". Article 14 strikes, at
arbitrariness in State action and ensures fairness and equality of treatment.
The principle of reasonableness, which legally as well as philosophically, is an essential
element of equality or non-arbitrariness pervades Article 14 like a brooding
omnipresence and the procedure contemplated by Article 21 must answer the best of
reasonableness in order to be in conformity with Article 14. It must be "right and just
and
fair" and not arbitrary, fanciful or oppressive; otherwise, it would be no procedure at
all and the requirement of Article 21 would not be satisfied."
5. Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi & Ors – Vs- State of U.P. & Ors.
(1991)1 SCC 212 para 35 & 36 is reproduced hereunder :
“35 It is now too well-settled that every State action, in order to survive, must
not be susceptible to the vice of arbitrariness which is the crux of Article 14 of the
Constitution and basic to the rule of law, the system which governs us. Arbitrariness
is the very negation of the rule of law. Satisfaction of this basic test in every State
action is sine qua non to its validity and in this respect, the State cannot claim
comparison with a private individual even in the field of contract. This distinction
between the State and a private individual in the field of contract has to be borne in
the mind.
36.The meaning and true import of arbitrariness is more easily visualized than
precisely stated or defined. The question, whether an impugned act is arbitrary or not,
is ultimately to be answered on the facts and in the circumstances of a given case. An
obvious test to apply is to see whether there is any discernible principle emerging from
the impugned act and if so, does it satisfy the test of reasonableness. Where a mode
is prescribed for doing an act and there is no impediment in following that procedure,
performance of the act otherwise and in a manner which does not disclose any
discernible principle which is reasonable, may itself attract the vice of arbitrariness.
Every State action must be informed by reason and it follows that an act
uninformed by reason, is arbitrary. Rule of law contemplates governance by laws
and not by humour, whims or caprices of the men to whom the governance is
entrusted for the time being. It is trite that be you ever so high, the laws are above
you'. This is what men in power must remember, always.”
[12]
Mr. Niranjan Sanasam, GA for the State respondents has submitted that
the petitioners were engaged as APP-cum-AGA on contract basis on payment of Rs.
150/- per day subject to the execution of Contract Agreement vide order no.
P a g e 18 | 21
7/45/2003-GA/L dated 20.12.2005 and there is no advertisement and Selection
Test/DPC for the engagement of the said APP -cum-AGA. It is pointed out that private
respondents were appointed as APP-cum-AGA after issuing proper notification and
hence they have been placed above the petitioners in the final seniority list.
[13]
Ld. counsel of the State respondent further submitted that the govt. has
regularized the contract service of 20 (twenty) APP-cum-AGA vide order No.
7/13/2015-GA/L(B) and No. 7/13/2015-GA/L(C) dated 02.12.2016 by a cabinet
decision as a policy decision and not a matter of right. Further, the list in the
regularization order was randomly set and not on the basis of merit and there is no
such mention of merit in the regularization order.
[14]
The Ld. counsel of the respondent also submitted that in WPC No. 895
of 2021 the Hon’ble Court directed to finalize the final seniority list within 2 (two)
months and in pursuance of the said order, the govt. had notified the final tentative
seniority list on 22.07.2022 vide notification No. GAP-3/5/2021-SEC-LAW. And such
was notified after detailed examination and consideration of all the claims and
objections received with regard to the tentative seniority list issued vide notification
No. GAP-3/5/2021-SEC-LAW dated 08.06.2022.
[15]
The Ld. GA has further submitted that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Civil Appeal No. 7002 of 2004 ( D.P. Das vs Union of India) has laid down that
for the determination of seniority of the officers who were recommended on the same
date, age is the only valid and fair basis where the merit wise position of the persons
who were directly recruited could not be ascertained. This department had prepared
the seniority list accordingly and keeping in view the claims and objections received.
P a g e 19 | 21
[16]
Ms. Ayangleima, ld. counsel of the private respondents has adopted the
submission of the State respondents and submits that there is no illegality in the final
seniority list prepared by the State Government.
[17]
This Court has considered the materials on record, the submissions
made at bar and the case laws cited by the parties.
[18]
The short issue involved in the present case is the determination of
seniority of contract employees appointed in different years, but regularized on the
same day when the rule is silent in this regard.
[19]
It is the settled principle of law that the seniority of direct recruits in a
common examination is based on the merit list of the recruitment examination, unless
differently specified by the relevant rules. If contract employees appointed in different
years are regularized on the same day, the contract employees appointed in the earlier
years will be senior to those appointed later on. This principle shall be followed in
absence of any contrary provided under the rules. It may be noted that the recruitment
to the post of APPs-cum-AGAs is through direct recruitment and as a corollary, the
regularization of contract employees in the cadre of APP-cum-AGA will also be direct
recruitment.
[20]
It will be relevant to refer to the following case law with regard to
seniority in case of direct recruits.
(i)
Sudhir Kumar Atrey v. Union of India, (2022) 1 SCC 352
17. We are also of the view that in the matter of adjudging seniority of the
candidates selected in one and the same selection, placement in the order of
merit can be adopted as a principle for determination of seniority but where
the selections are held separately by different recruiting authorities, the
principle of initial date of appointment/continuous officiation may be the valid
principle to be considered for adjudging inter se seniority of the officers in the
absence of any rule or guidelines in determining seniority to the contrary.
P a g e 20 | 21
(ii)
Bimlesh Tanwar v. State of Haryana, (2003) 5 SCC 604
47. It is also well settled that in the absence of rules governing seniority an
executive order may be issued to fill up the gap. Only in absence of the rule or
executive instruction, the court may have to evolve a fair and just principle
which could be applied in the facts and circumstances of the case.
[21]
From the above decisions, it is clear that in case of appointments in
different years, the initial date of appointment will be a good consideration for
determining seniority. In absence of any rules and/or execution instructions, it will
appropriate for the courts to evolve a fair mechanism to decide the seniority of persons
appointed on different dates, but regularized on the same day. In the case in hand,
there is no specific rule for determining seniority of persons appointed on contract on
different dates, but regularized on the same day. Besides, there is no executive
instructions in this aspect. The action of the State respondents giving preference to
contract employees appointed on later dates is arbitrary, unreasonable and not
supported by any rules or instructions from the competent authority. The same is in
contravention of the direction of this Court in order dated 01.06.2022 passed in WP(C)
No. 2 of 2019 and connected matters where similar seniority list of APP-cum-AGA was
set aside with a direction to decide afresh.
[22]
In the circumstances, the impugned seniority list of APP-cum-AGA dated
22.07.2022 issued by Deputy Secretary (Law), Government of Manipur is set aside.
Writ petitions are allowed and Misc cases are closed. Interim order, if any, merges
with the final order. Seniority as reflected in the order dated 02.12.2016 of
regularization shall be the final seniority list of APP-cum-AGA as the same has been in
order of years of initial appointment. In other words, the petitioners herein shall be
placed at serial number 1 & 2 of the new seniority list. Other incumbents will be placed
in order of merit as per the years of recruitment. No cost.
JUDGE
OINAM
THOIBA
MEITEI
OINAM THOIBA
MEITEI
Date: 2025.12.23
16:00:06 +05'30'
P a g e 21 | 21
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review