Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN TELEN
KOM
TELEN KOM
Date: 2023.08.16 10:54:32
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.736 of 2021
Lalnunthloung Hrangchal, aged about 31 years, S/o Lenmang Hranchal of
Manamjang Village, Kangpokpi District, Manipur-795132.
…Petitioner
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner (works),
Govt. of Manipur at Imphal, Manipur-795001.
2. The Chief Engineer (Building), PWD, Manipur-795001.
3. The Addl. Chief Secretary(Works)-cum-Estates Officer, Government
of Manipur-795001.
4. The Executive Engineer, Building Division-II, PWD, Lamphelpat,
Imphal West Manipur-795004.
5. The Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West, Lamphel, Imphal West,
Manipur-795004.
6. Shri Mayengbam Kenjit Singh aged about 51 years, resident of TypeD/26/PDA Quarters at NGV-III, Langol, Manipur-795004.
…. Respondents.
With
WP(C)No.192 of 2022
Shri Mayengbam Kenjit Singh aged about 51 years, resident of Quarter
No. T-B/194, N.G.V. Zone-II National Game Village, Imphal, Manipur.
…Petitioner
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner (works),
Govt. of Manipur at Imphal, Manipur-795001.
2. The Chief Engineer (Building), PWD, Manipur-795001.
3. The Addl. Chief Secretary(Works)-cum-Estates Officer, Government
of Manipur-795001.
4. The Executive Engineer, Building Division-II, PWD, Lamphelpat,
Imphal West Manipur-795004.
5. The Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West, Lamphel, Imphal West,
Manipur-795004.
6. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Imphal West, Lamphelpat, Manipur795004.
7. Lalnunthloung Hrangchal, aged about 31 years, S/o Lenmang
Hranchal of Manamjang Village, Kangpokpi District, Manipur.
…. Respondents.
With
WP(C)No.567 of 2021
Shri Mayengbam Kenjit Singh aged about 51 years, resident of Quarter
No. T-B/194, N.G.V. Zone-II National Game Village, Imphal, Manipur.
…Petitioner
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Additional Chief Secretary
(Works), Government of Manipur.
2. The Executive Engineer, Building Division-II, PWD, Manipur, and
3. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Lamphel, Imphal West, Manipur.
…. Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. O. Kiranjit, Adv. in WP(C)No.736 of
2021, Mr. KH. Chonjon, Sr. Adv. in
WP(C) No.192 of 2022 & WP(C)No.567
of 2021.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Shyam Sharma, GA for State
respondents in WP(C)No.736 of 2021;
Mr. S. Niranjan, GA for the State
respondents in WP(C)No.192 of 2022
& WP(C)No.567 of 2021; Mr. O.
Kiranjit, Adv. R7 in WP(C)No.192 of
2022 and Mr. KH. Chonjon, Sr. Adv. R6
in WP(C)No.736 of 2021
Date of reserved.
:
16.06.2023
Date of Judgment & Order :
03.07.2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
W.P.(C) No.736 of 2021 has been filed by the petitioner for
issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to hand over to the
petitioner the vacant possession of the Quarters No.Type-B/194 at National
Game Village, Langol allotted to him and to direct the respondents to make
such other arrangements in the similar Government quarters of the State for his
residence.
2. The sixth respondent in W.P.(C) No.736 of 2021 has filed W.P.(C)
No.192 of 2021 to quash the impugned cancellation order dated 18.1.2021. He
has also filed W.P.(C) No.567 of 2021 to quash the impugned eviction order
dated 24.8.2021.
3. Since the prayers made in all three writ petitions are interlinked with
each other, all the writ petitions were heard together and disposed of by this
common order.
4. The facts in W.P.(C) No.756 of 2021 is taken as lead case and,
accordingly,the parties are referred to as per their array in W.P.(C) No.756 of
2021.
5. The case of the petitioner is that he has been allotted Government
quarters bearing No.T/B-194 at National Game Village, Langol, however, the
same is being occupied by the previous occupant and yet to be vacated.
Hence, the petitioner has filed the writ petition directing the official respondents
to hand over the vacant possession of the quarters bearing No.T/B-194 allotted
to him or to make other arrangements in the Government quarters of the State
for his residence.
6. The respondent State filed affidavit-in-opposition stating that after
verification of all requirements, the House Allotment Committee cancelled the
quarters No.T/B-194 allotted to the sixth respondent Mayanglambam Kenjit
Singh, Assistant Inspector of Schools, SH-ADC, Kangpokpi and after
cancellation, the same was allotted to the petitioner vide order dated 18.1.2021.
Necessary intimation about possession of the Government quarters was issued
on 4.2.2021. It is stated that on receipt of the representation dated 6.3.2021 of
the petitioner, the office of the Executive Engineer, BD-II, PWD ascertained that
the said quarters was still occupied by an unauthorised occupant. On 6.3.2021,
notice was caused to the unauthorised occupant to vacate the quarters within
7 days from the date of receipt of the letter.
7. It is stated that on 20.3.2021, the Executive Engineer, BD-II/PWD
addressed a letter to the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West requesting to take
necessary eviction proceedings to vacate the unauthorised occupant out of the
quarters. On 24.8.2021, SDO, Lamphel passed an order in Eviction Case No.9
of 2021 directing the SDC, Imphal West Central to execute the eviction of
unauthorized occupant (6th respondent) from the Government quarters on
31.8.2021. By the interim order dated 1.9.2021 in W.P.(C) No.567 of 2021, the
eviction was stayed and the same is still continuing. Therefore, this Court may
allow the official respondents to evict the unauthorised occupant from the
quarters so as to enable to hand over the same to the petitioner.
8. The sixth respondent filed affidavit-in-opposition stating that
cancellation of the allotment order was never communicated to the sixth
respondent and the same was passed in collusion with the petitioner just to
accommodate him.
The said order was kept concealed from the sixth
respondent till the date of filing W.P.(C) No.736 of 2021 by the petitioner.
Instead, the sixth respondent was served with a show cause notice dated
28.4.2021 by the SDO, Lamphel, Imphal West and the sixth respondent has
also sent his reply. It is stated that all the actions and conduct were made
behind the back of the sixth respondent to dispossess him without due process
of law.
The sixth respondent is occupying the quarters No.T/B-194 in
accordance with law and has every right to continue to hold the said quarters.
The acts of the petitioner and the official respondents are arbitrary in nature
and quite unbecoming of a public servant and a responsible citizen.
9. Mr.O. Kiranjit, learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted that the
sixth respondent is in illegal possession of two Government quarters, namely,
No.T/B-194 at National Game Village and T/D-26/PDA at National Game
Village-III, Langol. Despite the petitioner deposited the requisite house rent for
the Quarters No.T/B-194 allotted to him, the official respondents have not given
the vacant possession of the same till date and that the said quarters is being
occupied by the illegal occupants without any lawful justification. Thus, a prayer
has been made to direct the official respondents to hand over to the petitioner
the vacant possession of the Quarters No.T/B-194.
10. Mr. Sh. Shyam Sharma, learned Government Advocate for the
official respondents, submitted that after cancellation of the allotment issued in
favour of the sixth respondent in respect of Quarters No.T/B-194, the same was
allotted to the petitioner, who was working as Section Officer, Grade-I, WRD,
Task Force Division, Khoyathong on 18.1.2021.
He would submit that after
ascertaining that the said quarters still being occupied by the unauthorized
occupants, legal action was initiated against them thereby giving show cause
notice and, in fact, eviction proceedings were also initiated against the sixth
respondent and the unauthorized occupants vide order dated 24.8.2021. Since
an interim order was granted by this Court in the writ petition being W.P.No.(C)
No.567 of 2021 filed by the sixth respondent thereby staying the operation of
the eviction order dated 24.8.2021, the order of eviction has not been carried
out. The official respondents are ready to hand over the Quarters No.T/B-194
to the petitioner after evicting the unauthorised occupants pursuant to the order
dated 18.1.2021 issued in favour of the petitioner.
11. Mr.Kh. Chonjon, learned senior counsel for the sixth respondent,
submitted that the cancellation of allotment order was not communicated to the
sixth respondent and the cancellation order was passed in collusion with the
petitioner to accommodate him in Quarters No.T/B-194. He would submit that
all actions were made behind the back of the sixth respondent to dispossess
him without due process of law. The concerned authority has never issued
show cause notice to the sixth respondent as to why the allotment in favour of
the sixth respondent should not be cancelled, instead passed an order behind
the back of the sixth respondent, which is arbitrary and malicious and also to
accommodate the petitioner in the said quarters.
12. The learned senior counsel for the sixth respondent further submitted
that the sixth respondent has been occupying Quarters No.T/B-194in
accordance with law and has every right to continue to hold the same. He
would submit that the Quarters No.T/B-194 is not being occupied by illegal
occupants. Since the acts of the petitioner and the official respondents are
arbitrary in nature, the sixth respondent filed W.P.(C) No.192 of 2021
challenging the order dated 18.1.2021 and W.P.(C) No.567 of 2021 challenging
the order dated 24.8.2021 and the interim order is operating in the said writ
petitions. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the writ petition filed by the
petitioner and allow the writ petitions filed by the sixth respondent.
13. This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the
materials available on record.
14. From the pleadings, the following facts emerge - On 27.9.2020 the
Assistant Engineer-IV, Building Division-II, PWD, Manipur, wrote a letter to the
Executive Engineer, Building Division-II, PWD that the Government Quarters
No.T/B-194 at NGV, Langol which was allotted to the sixth respondent vide
order dated 24.1.2015 was found to have been occupied by one Memcha Devi
and that the sixth respondent is presently occupying Type-D/26/PDA Quarters
at NGV-III.
Thereafter, on the recommendation of the House Allotment
Committee, the allotment in respect of the Quarters No.T/B-194 issued in favour
of the sixth respondent was cancelled vide order dated 18.1.2021 and the said
Quarters No.T/B-194 was allotted to the petitioner by way of the said order.
The petitioner has also deposited necessary house rent and certificate to that
effect was also issued to him. In this regard, the Under Secretary (Works)
addressed a letter to the Executive Engineer, Building Division-II, PWD to hand
over the Quarters No.T/B-194 to the petitioner.
Since the unauthorised
occupant is in possession of Quarters No.T/B-194and the petitioner was not
able to take possession of the same, he has submitted a representation on
6.3.2021 to the Executive Engineer and the Assistant Engineer-IV, in turn,
issued a notice to the occupant to vacate Quarters No.T/B-194within a period
of 7 days from the date of receipt of the said notice. Since the occupant has
not vacated the quarters, the Executive Engineer, Building Division-II wrote a
letter to the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West to take up an eviction
proceedings in respect of Quarters No.T/B-194 enabling to hand over the same
to the new allottee. Thereafter, necessary proceedings were initiated by the
Deputy Commissioner for eviction of the illegal occupants.
15. The case of the sixth respondent is that there is not a single word
being reflected as to the cancellation of the allotment order except in the
impugned order dated 18.1.2021 which was also kept concealed to the sixth
respondent, but rather the sixth respondent has been termed as an
unauthorised occupant only to justify the action of issuing the impugned orders
and at the same time to evict the sixth respondent from the allotted quarters
illegally just to accommodate the petitioner.
The further case of the sixth
respondent is that on 28.4.2021, he was served with a notice in connection with
Eviction Case No.9 of 2021 to show cause as to why the Government quarters
allotted to him shall not be vacated on or before 12.5.2021. On 12.5.2021 the
sixth respondent appeared before the Sub Divisional Officer and submitted his
written explanation and thereafter, the proceedings in the Eviction Case
remained dormant for some time.
However, to the utter surprise, an order
dated 24.8.2021 was served on the sixth respondent thereby ordering that the
sixth respondent shall be evicted from the quarters, where his family is residing.
Assailing the said notice, the sixth respondent has filed W.P.(C) No.567 of
2021.
16. During the course of hearing of the writ petitions, this Court directed
the official respondents to produce the original File pertaining to Quarters
No.T/B-194. Pursuant to the order of this Court, the official respondents have
produced the File.On a perusal of the File, this Court finds that on 10.11.2020
itself, the Assistant Engineer-IV, Building Division-II, PWD, Manipur, issued a
notice to the sixth respondent calling upon him to appear on 25.11.2020. The
said letter dated 10.11.2020 reads thus:
“I am informed you that the Govt. No.Type-B/194 NGV which was
allotted to you vide order No.1/38/2010-Est(W) dated 24/1/2015 was
not occupy the said qtr. Since a long time. You have subleted the qtr.
To an unauthorised person namely Smt. Mema Devi from Sekamai.
Therefore, you are requested kindly to attend this office personally on
or before 25/11/2020 positively, otherwise the matter will be brought to
the Estate Office for cancellation of the Qtr. As per Qtr. Allotment Rule.”
17. On 27.11.2020, the Assistant Engineer-IV wrote a letter to the
Executive Engineer, Building Division-II stating that during spot verification of
quarters, the sixth respondent did not appear and it is found that the Quarters
No.T/B-194 was occupied by one Memcha Devi from Sekmai and the sixth
respondent is currently occupying Type-D/26, PDA Quarters at NGV-III.
Thereafter, on the recommendation of the House Allotment Committee, the
Quarters No.T/B-194 was allotted to the petitioner after cancelling the allotment
made in favour the sixth respondent.
18. When the concerned official on physical/spot verification found that
the sixth respondent was not living in Quarters No.T/B-194 and he sublet the
said quarters to somebody, the Estate Officer was right in cancelling the
allotment issued in favour of the sixth respondent. The terms and conditions of
the allotment order stipulate that the allottee has to live in the allotted quarters
and at no point of time the allottee should not sublet the quarters. Since the
sixth respondentwas not in physical occupation of the Quarters No.T/B-194 and
one Memcha Devi is in occupation of the said quarters, the initiation of action
against the sixth respondent for cancelling the allotment is perfectly correct.
Therefore, this Court finds no infirmity in issuing the impugned order dated
18.1.2021 thereby allotting the Quarters No.T/B-194 in favour of the petitioner
by cancelling the allotment issued in favour of the sixth respondent. In view of
the above, the contention of the sixth respondent that the order dated 18.1.2021
was passed behind his back cannot be countenanced.
19. It appears that in the process of evicting the unauthorised occupant
from the Quarters No.T/B-194, on 26.4.2021, the Sub-Deputy Collector, Imphal
West (Central) addressed a communication to the Sub-Divisional Officer,
Lamphel stating that the Quarters No.T/B-194 is presently occupied by the
relatives of the previous allottee namely Mayengbam Kenjit (6 th respondent).
On 28.4.2021, the Sub-Divisional Officer, Lamphel issued a notice in Eviction
Case No.9 of 2021 to the Officer-in-Charge of Lamphel Police Station for
causing service to the person concerned by marking a copy to the sixth
respondent and other officials stating as under:
“Whereas, Executive Engineer, Building Division No.II P.W.D. Manipur
vide letter No.EE/BD-II/Eviction-Qtr./2020/340 dated 20/03/2021 has
written to the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West District for eviction
of the unauthorized occupant of Govt. Quarter No.T/B-194, Natinal
Game Village.
Whereas, Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West District has directed the
undersigned to cause inquiry and take up necessary action for eviction
of appropriate provision of law of Govt. Qtr. No.T/B-194, National
Game village vide letter No.DC(IW)/8/14/Eviction/2020/571 dated
08.04.2021.
Whereas, spot enquiry has been conducted by the SDC/IW (Central)
vide letter No.8/SDC/IW(C)/Evict/90/284 dated 26-04-2021 and it has
been reported that the Govt. Quarter No.T/B-194, National Game
Village is being occupied Unauthorizedly MayengbamKenjit.
Now, therefore, I.S. Surchandra Singh, MCS, Sub-Divisional Officer,
Lamphel, Imphal West in exercise of the powers conferred upon me
under Sub-Section (1) of Section 3 of the Manipur Public Premises
(Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1978, do hereby direct the
Opposite party to show cause as to why the Govt. Quarter No.T/B-194,
National Game Village shall not be vacated in writing by appearing in
person/by authorized pleader in this regard latest by 5.00 p.m. of
12/05/2021, failing which eviction will be carried out without further
notice.”
20. According to the sixth respondent, on 12.5.2021, he appeared before
the Sub-Divisional Officer and submitted an explanation stating that the
quarters is continuously occupied by the sixth respondent and his family
members and it is impossible for him to look for another shelter. Since way back
on 10.11.2020 itself the authorities found that the sixth respondent sublet
Quarters No.T/B-194, the statement of the sixth respondent made before the
Sub-Divisional Officer on 12.5.2021 that his family members are living in the
said quarters is unacceptable. After considering the explanation given by the
sixth respondent and other relevant materials, on 24.8.2021, the Sub-Divisional
Officer, Lamphel, has passed the impugned order stating as under:
“Whereas, the opposite party/unauthorized occupant Mayengbam
Kenjit was directed to vacate the Govt. Quarter No.T/B-194, National
Game Village vide this Court’s Notice dated 28th April, 2021 passed on
the Eviction Case No.9 of 2021;
Whereas, it has been reported by the Sub-Deputy Collector, Imphal
West (Central) vide letter No.8/SDC/IW(C)/Evict/2021 dated 23 rd
August 2021 that the unauthorized occupant has not complied with the
Notice of eviction dated 28.4.2021;
Now, therefore, I, Lanjoy Thoudam, MCS, Sub-Divisional Officer,
Lamphel, Imphal West in exercise of the powers conferred upon me
under Sub-Section (1) of Section 4 of the Manipur Public Premises
(Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1978 do hereby order that
the Opposite party/unauthorized occupant Shri Mayengbam Kenjit
Govt. Quarter No.T/B-194, National Game Village shall be evicted from
Govt. Quarter No.T/B-194, National Game on 31.08.2021 at 10.30 a.m.
for taking possession of the same;
SDC, Imphal West (Central) shall execute the above order with the
assistance of adequate number of police force to be provided by the
Superintendent of Police, Imphal West District, on the spot, date and
time as fixed above i.e. 31/08/2021 at 10.30 a.m;
The Executive Engineer, Building Division No.II P.W.D. Manipur shall
assist Rishikanta Loitongbam, SDC/Imphal West (Central) in the
execution of these orders.”
21. The aforesaid order has been assailed by the sixth respondent by
contending that he is not an unauthorized occupant by virtue of the fact that an
allotment order dated 24.1.2015 allotting Quarters No.T/B-194 to him is still
subsisting.
In the event the order dated 24.8.2021 is effectuated thereby
evicting the sixth respondent and his family from the said quarters, an
irreparable loss would be caused to him. The aforesaid contention of the sixth
respondent cannot be countenanced for the simple reason that only after
cancelling the allotment issued in favour of the sixth respondent, as he violated
the terms and conditions of the allotment, Quarters No.T/B-194 was allotted in
favour of the petitioner. As stated supra, the cancellation of the allotment is
primarily on the ground that he has not occupied the said quarters and he has
sublet the same to one Mema Devi and now the unauthorized occupant was in
possession of the same. As stated supra, the said fact was also reflected in
the show cause notice issued by the Assistant Engineer-IV to the sixth
respondent way back on 10.11.2020. Since the action initiated against the sixth
respondent in respect of Quarters No.T/B-194 is in accordance with law and
only after following the due process of law, the sixth respondent now cannot
assail the impugned order dated 24.8.2021. That apart, after cancellation,
neither the sixth respondent, nor the lease/tenant of the sixth respondenthas
no right to occupy the said quarters. The occupation of the sixth respondent
and one Mema Devi is to be termed as illegal occupants. Therefore, the SubDivisional Officer, Lamphel was right in issuing the impugned order dated
24.8.2021 and this Court cannot find any infirmity in it.
22. The argument of the learned Government Advocate that the sixth
respondent is currently occupying Type-D/26, PDA quarters at NGV-III and he
is not in occupation of Quarters No.T/B-194 and he is an unauthorised occupant
is appreciable and in support of the said argument, the official respondents
have also produced materials before this Court. From the perusal of the entire
records produced, this Court is of the view that the despite cancellation of the
allotment of Quarters No.T/B-194, he is still occupying the same by subletting,
which cannot be endorsed by this Court. Since the petitioner has been issued
with the allotment order in respect of the Quarters No.T/B-194 after following
the due process and he has also paid the necessary rent for the same, the
official respondents are duty bound to give possession of the said quarters to
the petitioner by evicting the unauthorized occupant.
23. During the course of arguments, the learned Government Advocate
submitted that since the interim order is in operation, the official respondents
are not in a position to carry out the eviction and the respondent authorities are
ready to evict the unauthorised occupants from Quarters No.T/B-194 at NGV
and hand over vacant possession of the same to the petitioner within the
stipulated time.
Since this Court finds that there are no infirmities in the
impugned orders dated 18.1.2021 and 24.8.2021 respectively and the same
were issued after following due process of law, there is no hurdle for the official
respondents in evicting the unauthorised occupants from Quarters No.T/B-194
and hand over the same to the petitioner pursuant to the allotment order dated
18.1.2021 issued to him. In the eviction process, if any police assistance is
required, the concerned official may seek police assistance from the
jurisdictional police and the jurisdictional police may render police assistance
to the respondent authorities.
24. In the result,
(i)
W.P.(C) No.736 of 2021 is allowed.
(ii)
The official respondents in W.P.(C) No.736 of
2021 are directed to hand over the vacant
possession of the Quarters No.T/B-194 at the
National Game Village, Langol to the petitioner
by evicting the unauthorised occupants.
(iii)
The said exercise is directed to be completed
within a period of two months from the date of
receipt of a copy of this order.
(iv)
W.P.(C) Nos.192 and 567 of 2021 are
dismissed.
(v)
No costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review