Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
signed by
SHOUGRAKPAM Digitally
SHOUGRAKPAM
DEVANANDA SINGH
DEVANANDA
Date: 2024.07.23 16:33:32
SINGH
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
1. Sri Lalbiakhluna, aged about 49 years, S/o T. Lalhnema, resident
of Kolasib, P.O. Kolasib, District Kolasib, Mizoram.
2. Sri Vanlalhruaia, aged about 62 years, S/o late L.K. Siama,
resident of Thingkangphai, Lamka, P.O. Churachandpur, District
Churachandpur, Manipur.
... Petitioners
-Versus1. The State of Manipur, represented by the Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur.
2. The State of Mizoram, represented by the Secretary (Home),
Government of Mizoram, Aizwal, Mizoram.
3. The Union of India, represented by the Secretary (Home) to the
Government of India, New Delhi.
… Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the petitioner
::
Mr. D. Julius Riamei, Advocate
For the respondents
::
Date of hearing
Date of judgment & order
::
::
Mr. Shyam Sharma, GA;
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, DSGI &
Mr. Serto T. Kom, Advocate
22-05-2024
23-07-2024
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[1]
Heard Mr. D. Julius Riamei, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners; Mr. Shyam Sharma, learned GA appearing for the respondent
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[2]
No. 1, Mr. Serto T. Kom, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.
2 and Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI appearing for the respondent No. 3.
[2]
The present writ petition has been filed with the prayer for issuing
a direction to close/ drop or for quashing the criminal proceeding being
Cril.(P) Case No. 9 of 1986 under FIR No. 103(6)1984 of Churachandpur
Police Station u/s 395/397/307/326/34 IPC and 27 I.A. Act pending in the
Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Churachandpur, in respect of the
petitioners only.
[3]
The facts of the case, in a nutshell, are that both the petitioners
were members of the Mizo National Army under the Mizo National Front
(MNF) when it was engaged in the armed struggle for several years against
the Government of India fighting for independence of the Mizo inhabited
areas in the North Eastern region of India. While the petitioners were in
the underground movement as members of the Mizo National Army, the
petitioners were arrested in the year 1984 along with some others in
Churachandpur District, Manipur, in connection with a case of armed
robbery of the State Bank of India, Churachandpur and the Churachandpur
Police registered a case being FIR No. 103/(6)/84 Churachandpur Police
Station u/s 305/397/121/221(A)/307/121(B)IPC 25 Arms Act and 13 UAP
Act. Subsequently, the petitioners were released on bail from their judicial
custody.
[4]
After several years of armed struggle under the banner of the
MNF and under the leadership of several prominent leaders including
Mr. Laldenga, the MNF entered into an agreement with the Government of
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[3]
India for a peaceful settlement of various outstanding issues by signing
a Memorandum of Settlement on 30-06-1986. The said memorandum was
signed by the authorities thereto after holding talks within the framework of
the Constitution of India and in course of talks, various issues were settled
which were incorporated in the said Memorandum of Settlement. With a
view to restoring peace and normalcy in Mizoram, it was incorporated at
para 3.1 of the Memorandum of Settlement that the MNF will, within the
agreed time frame, take necessary steps to end all underground activities,
to bring out all underground personnel of the MNF with their arms,
ammunition and equipment to ensure their return to civil life, to abjure
violence and generally to help in the process of restoration of normalcy
and that the modalities of bringing out all underground personnel and
deposit of arms, ammunition and equipment will be as worked out and the
implementation of the same will be under the supervision of the Central
Government.
[5]
In para 3.2, it was also incorporated that the MNF Party will take
immediate steps to amend its Articles of Association so as to make them
conform to the provisions of law and that in para 3.3 of the said
Memorandum of Settlement, it was incorporated that the Central
Government will take steps for the resettlement and rehabilitation of
underground MNF personnel coming overground after considering the
schemes proposed in this regard by the Government of Mizoram. In Para
4.2 of the said Memorandum of Settlement, it was also incorporated
that in order to give effect to the various commitments or agreements
made under the said Memorandum of Settlement, necessary legislative and
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[4]
administrative measures would be undertaken by the Central Government
including those for the enactment of Bills for the amendment of the
Constitution and other laws for the conferment of Statehood, etc. The
Memorandum of Settlement contemplates the following sequence of
events:(i) Coming overground of MNF personnel and depositing of arms,
ammunition and equipment by them in accordance with the time
bound programme as already agreed upon between the Ministry
of Home Affairs and the MNF delegation;
(ii) The MNF Party should take immediate steps to amend its Articles
of Association to make them conform to the provisions of law;
(iii) The Government will initiate steps for rehabilitation of MNF
personnel coming overground; and
(iv) After completion of action under Paras 1 and 2 above, the
Constitution Amendment Bill will be introduced in Parliament
for the grant of Statehood and other consequential legislative
measures to be taken up.
[6]
Consequent upon the signing of the aforesaid Memorandum of
Settlement, all the cadres of the MNF, including the petitioners, came
overground and gave up arms and ammunition with the hope and dream
of starting to lead a normal civil life. The Central Government also started
enacting and implementing laws and regulations in terms of the aforesaid
Memorandum of Settlement. Parliamentary enactments were passed and
various regulations/ instructions were issued for the smooth implementation
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[5]
of the said Memorandum of Settlement and the State of Mizoram came into
existence as a result of the aforesaid Memorandum of Settlement.
As the members/ cadres of the MNF were to gave up arms and
ammunition and entered civil life in terms of the Memorandum of
Settlement, the Government of India, in order to ensure smooth
implementation of the Memorandum of Settlement and as part of the
rehabilitation process of the MNF cadres, took the decision that no
member of the MNF coming overground shall be prosecuted for the
offences committed in connection with and during the period of
underground activities. The Government of India also decided that
investigation under progress at that time against the person coming
overground should be suspended immediately and dropped. The
Government of India also decided that on fulfilment of certain stipulation
as contained in para 3.1 and 3.2 of the Memorandum of Settlement, it
was proposed to withdraw prosecution in cases pending before the
courts for any offences committed by the members of the MNF Party
coming overground in connection with or during the period of overground
activities and persons convicted for any such offences would be granted
remission of sentence. The aforesaid decision of the Government of India
was communicated by the Home Secretary to the Government of India by
Wireless Message dated 30-06-1986 to the Lt. Governor of Mizoram.
[7]
While the petitioners were leading a normal civilian life with the
bona fide belief that the cases against them would have been dropped as
in case of other MNF cadres, who have come overground in terms of the
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[6]
aforesaid Memorandum of Settlement and the decision taken by the
Government of India, it is the case of the petitioner No. 1 that, to his shock
and surprise, he came to know that sometime in the year 2000, a warrant
of arrest had been issued against him in connection with the Cril. (P) Case
No. 9 of 1986 pending in the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Churachandpur, which was registered pursuant to the aforesaid FIR No.
103(6)1984 Churachandpur Police Station. As regards the petitioner No. 2,
he has been regularly attending the court in connection with the said
criminal case, while all the time expecting that the aforesaid criminal case
will be closed in view of the Memorandum of Settlement and the decision
of the Government of India. When no positive result was forthcoming, the
petitioners, feeling aggrieved, moved the authorities in Mizoram through
their former colleagues to do the needful for withdrawal of the said criminal
case pending against the petitioners in terms of the Memorandum of
Settlement and the decision taken by the Government of India.
[8]
Various high-ranking officials of the Government of Mizoram
including the Chief Secretary and the Chief Minister wrote various letters to
their counterparts of the Government of Manipur requesting to look into
the criminal case pending before the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Churachandpur and to take up necessary steps for closing the said criminal
case pending against the petitioners in terms of the Memorandum of
Settlement and the decision taken by the Government of India. On part of
the Government of Manipur, it has been responded to the various requests
made by the Government of Mizoram by stating that every measure is being
taken up for closing the said criminal case and the Government of Manipur
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[7]
have also sought instruction from the Government of India regarding the
matter and the instruction of the Government of India is being awaited.
[9]
In view of the series of efforts being made by the Government of
Mizoram for closing the said criminal case, the petitioners were under the
impression that necessary steps were being taken up by the Government
of Mizoram and Manipur for closing the aforesaid criminal case against the
petitioners in terms of the Memorandum of Settlement and the decision of
the Government of India and that eventually the said criminal case would
be closed. However, to the dismay of the petitioners, instead of closing the
aforesaid criminal case, a fresh warrant of arrest was again issued by the
Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Churachandpur, in connection with
the said Criminal Case No. 9 of 1986 against the petitioner No. 1 and
another MNF cadre. Having been aggrieved, the petitioners approached
this court by filing the present writ petition for redressing their grievances.
[10]
It has been submitted on behalf of the petitioners that the
said criminal case pending in the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Churachandpur, is in connection with a case of armed robbery which
occurred in the State Bank of India, Churachandpur, Manipur in the year,
1984 when the MNF movement were spread in all the Mizo inhabited areas
of the North East including the State of Manipur. It has also been submitted
that the MNA were also deployed in the Mizo inhabited areas of Manipur
including the Churachandpur District and the said incident of robbery were
carried out by the cadres of the MNF (MNA), including the petitioners, along
with other underground cadres of Manipur. The learned counsel for the
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[8]
petitioners strenuously submitted that since the Government of India have
taken a decision to drop/ withdraw all the criminal cases against the MNF
cadres/ MNA on their coming overground in terms of the Memorandum of
Settlement and since the petitioners have come overground and led a
normal civil life in terms of the Memorandum of Settlement, the aforesaid
criminal case pending against the petitioners in the Court of the Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Churachandpur, ought to have been dropped or
withdrawn. It has further been submitted that the continuation of the
aforesaid criminal case against the petitioners is clearly in violation of the
terms of the Memorandum of Settlement and the decision taken by
the Government of India as contained in the Wireless Message dated
30-06-1986.
[11]
It has also been submitted on behalf of the petitioners that the
cases against the other colleagues of the petitioners, who were ex-cadres
of the Mizo National Army, registered during the underground movement of
the MNF have been either closed or withdrawn. However, in case of the
petitioners, the same treatment has not been extended and the aforesaid
criminal case against the petitioners has been continued, thus causing
acute physical and mental harassment to the petitioners. It has further been
submitted that the petitioners have been subjected to hostile discrimination
and their Fundamental Right of Equality guaranteed under Article 14 of the
Constitution of India has been violated.
[12]
The counsel for the petitioners submitted that the Memorandum
of Settlement and the decision of the Government of India as contained
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[9]
in the Wireless Message dated 30-06-1986 are legally enforceable
documents which cannot be ignored or violated, moreso when the rights of
the persons who have given up arms and came overground are concerned.
It has further been submitted by the learned counsel that pursuant to the
aforesaid Memorandum of Settlement and the decision taken by the
Government of India, several steps have already been taken for the
effective implementation and rehabilitation of the ex-cadres of the MNF,
who have come overground in terms of the Memorandum of Settlement and
there is no reason why the decision of the Government of India to withdraw/
drop all the cases pending against the members of the MNF/ MNA should
not be implemented so far as the petitioners are concerned.
[13]
It has been submitted on behalf of the petitioners that it was the
solemn promise and the undertaking given by the Government of India that
it will take steps for the resettlement and rehabilitation of the underground
MNF personnel coming overground and for withdrawing/ closing all the
criminal cases against the cadres of the MNF/ MNA, who came overground,
for any offences committed by them in connection with or during the
period of underground activities. The learned counsel submitted that it was
because of this solemn undertaking/ promise given by the Government of
India that the petitioners gave up arms and came overground in the
expectation that the criminal cases against them would also be dropped/
closed. Accordingly, the State respondents are bound by the principle of
Promissory Estoppel and the petitioners have the legislative expectation
that the criminal cases pending against them will be withdrawn or closed.
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[10]
[14]
Mr. Serto T. Kom, learned counsel appearing for the State of
Mizoram submitted that in terms of the Memorandum of Settlement and the
aforesaid decision taken by the Government of India, no member of the
MNF Party, who have came overground, were prosecuted for offences
committed in connection with and during the period of underground
activities, investigation under progress at that point of time against the
members of the MNF Party, who have came overground, have been
suspended and dropped and prosecutions in cases pending before the
courts for any offences committed by the members of the MNF Party, who
have came overground, in connection with or during the period of
underground activities have been withdrawn or dropped.
[15]
The learned counsel further submitted that the Government of
Mizoram sincerely pursue the matter for withdrawal of the aforesaid criminal
case against the present petitioners. In this regard, the learned counsel
draw the attention of this court to various letters of the high ranking officials
of the Government of Mizoram, including the Chief Secretary and the Chief
Minister, addressed to their counterparts of the Government of Manipur
requesting for taking up necessary action for closing or withdrawing the
criminal cases pending against the petitioners. The learned counsel
submitted that despite the sincere and best efforts made by the
Government of Mizoram, the said criminal case pending against the
petitioners has not been withdrawn till date.
[16]
Mr. Shyam Sharma, learned GA and Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned
DSGI appearing for the State of Manipur and Union of India respectively
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[11]
submitted that the Cril. (P) Case No. 9 of 1986 arising out of the FIR No.
103(6)1984 of Churachandpur Police Station u/s 395/397/307/326/34 IPC
and 27 Arms Act, pending against the petitioners and others before the
Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Churachandpur, is in connection
with the offence of armed robbery of the State Bank of India in
Churachandpur District, Manipur. The learned counsel further submitted
that the Memorandum of Settlement dated 30-06-1986 between the
Government of India, Government of Mizoram and Mizo National Front as
well as the secret Message dated 30-06-1986 from the Government of India
to the Lt. Governor of Mizoram does not make any mention of dropping
of criminal cases for offences committed by the MNF cadres outside the
State of Mizoram and that there is nothing on record with the Government
of India to show that the offences committed by the cadres of the MNF
Party outside Mizoram were to be dropped or withdrawn. Thus, the State
Government as well as the Government of India have taken a view that
the aforesaid pending criminal case against the petitioners for committing
the offence in Churachandpur District, Manipur, in connection with the FIR
No. 103(6)1984 Churachandpur Police Station cannot be dropped or
withdrawn. The learned counsel also submitted that there is no merit in the
present writ petition and as such, the same is liable to be dismissed.
[17]
I have heard at length the learned counsel appearing for the
parties and also considered the rival submissions advanced by them. In
the present case, a Memorandum of Settlement was made on 30-06-1986
involving the Government of India, Government of Mizoram and the Mizo
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[12]
National Front. In para 3.1, 3.2 and 3.3 of the said Memorandum of
Settlement, it has been agreed upon among the parties as under:
“3.1. With a view to restoring peace and normalcy in Mizoram the
MNF Party, on their part, undertakes within the agreed timeframe, to take all necessary steps to end all underground
activities, to bring out all underground personnel of the MNF
with their arms, ammunition and equipment to ensure their
return to civil life, to abjure violence and generally to help in the
process of restoration of normalcy. The modalities of bringing
out all underground personnel and the deposit of arms,
ammunition and equipment will be as worked out. The
implementation of the foregoing will be under the supervision
of the Central Government.”
“3.2 The MNF Party will take immediate steps to amend is Articles
of Association so as to make them conform to the provisions
of law.”
“3.3 The Central Government will take steps for the resettlement and
rehabilitation of underground MNF personnel coming
overground after considering the schemes proposed in this
regard by the Government of Mizoram.”
[18]
It is also in record that the said Memorandum of Settlement
contemplates the following sequence of events:“1. Coming overground of MNF personnel and depositing of arms,
ammunition and equipment by them in accordance with the
time bound programme as already agreed upon between the
Ministry of Home Affairs and the MNF delegation.”
“2. The MNF Party should take immediate steps to amend its
Articles of Association to make them conform to the provisions
of law.”
“3. The Government will initiate steps for rehabilitation of MNF
personnel coming overground.”
[19]
It is also on record that on the date of making the said
Memorandum of Settlement, the Secretary (Home), Government of India,
sent a Wireless Message dated 30-06-1986 to the Lt. Governor of Mizoram
conveying the decision of the Government of India, which are as under:-
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[13]
“According to the Memorandum of Settlement in MIZORAM, the
MNF Party have undertaken to end all underground activities,
to bring out all underground personnel of the MNF with their
arms, ammunition and equipment to ensure they are, turn to
civillite, to abjure violence and generally to help in the
process of restoration of normalcy . in order to ensure smooth
implementation of above it has been decide that No member of
the MNF Party now coming overground shall be prosecuted for
offences committed in connection with and during the period
of underground activities (.) Consequently investigation under
progress currently against persons now coming overgrounds
should be suspended forthwith and dropped (.) PARA (.)
On fulfilment of certain stipulations by MNF contained in Para
3.1 and 3.2 of the Memorandum of Settlement, it is proposed
to withdraw prosecution in cases pending before Courts for
any offences committed by the members of MNF Party now
coming overground in connection with or during the period of
underground activities and persons convicted for any such
offences be granted remission of Sentence = 1”
[20]
There is no dispute with regard to the facts that the cadres of the
MNF/ MNA have fulfilled their undertakings given in para 3.1 and 3.2 of the
Memorandum of Settlement by bringing out all the underground personnel
of the MNF with their arms, ammunition and equipment and have abjure
violence and helped in the process of restoration of normalcy by returning
to their civilian life within the agreed time frame and also by amending its
Articles of Association. Consequent upon fulfilment of such undertaking
given by MNF Party, the Government also did not prosecute any member
of the MNF Party for the offences committed in connection with and during
the period of underground activities, dropped all the pending investigation
against such personnel of the MNF and have also withdrawn prosecution
in cases pending before courts against members of the MNF Party for the
offences committed by them in connection with or during the period of
underground activities in terms of the Memorandum of Settlement and
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[14]
decision taken by the Government of India as contained in the Wireless
Message dated 30-06-1986.
[21]
The only reason given by the State of Manipur and the Union
of India in their affidavit-in-opposition for refusing to withdraw or close
the aforesaid criminal case against the petitioners is that under the
Memorandum of Settlement and the decision of the Government of India,
nothing is mentioned about dropping of criminal cases for offences
committed by the MNF members outside the State of Mizoram and that
there is nothing on record to show that offences committed outside Mizoram
were to be dropped against the cadres of MNF. Thus, the Government have
taken a view that the aforesaid criminal case cannot be withdrawn or
dropped as the offence in connection with the said criminal case was
committed by the petitioners in Churachandpur District, outside the State of
Mizoram.
[22]
As per the Memorandum of Settlement, with a view to restoring
peace and normalcy in Mizoram, the MNF Party have undertaken to end all
underground activities to bring out all underground personnel of MNF with
their arms, ammunition and equipment to ensure their return to civil
life, to abjure violence and generally to help in the process of restoration
of normalcy within the agreed time frame. In order to ensure smooth
implementation of such undertaking, the Government of India on its part
have taken a conscious decision that no member of the MNF Party coming
overground shall be prosecuted for offences committed in connection with
and during the period of underground activities, to suspend forthwith and
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[15]
dropped investigation under progress against the personnel of MNF coming
overground and to withdraw prosecution in cases pending before courts
for any offences committed by the members of the MNF Party coming
overground in connection with or during the period of underground
activities.
There is no dispute among the parties in the present case that
such decision taken by the Government of India has been duly implemented
so far as the State of Mizoram is concerned. In my considered view, the
conscious decision taken by the Government of India is a sound one and
such conscious decision had been taken to ensure smooth implementation
and to facilitate in bringing out all the underground personnel of the MNF
with their arms, ammunition and equipment and to help in the process of
restoration of peace and normalcy in Mizoram. In my considered view, such
sound decision is one of the main reason which led to the end of all
underground activities of the MNF Party and in encouraging the personnel
of the MNF to come overground and agreeing to return to their civil life and
thereby resulting in bringing peace and normalcy in the State of Mizoram.
[23]
On careful examination of the Wireless Message dated
30-06-1986 containing the aforesaid Government of India's decision,
nothing is found on record to indicate that such decision will confine to
or in respect of offences committed by the personnel of MNF within the
State of Mizoram. The only fact that remains undisputed among the parties
is that the said decision of the Government of India is applicable to and only
for the benefit of personnel of MNF who have come overground in terms of
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[16]
the Memorandum of Settlement. When there is no material available on
record to indicate that the decision of the Government of India will be
applicable and confines to only those personnel of the MNF who have
committed offences only in the State of Mizoram and not in any other State,
this court is of the considered view that the reason given by the State of
Manipur and Union of India for refusing to withdraw or close the criminal
cases pending against the petitioners is misconceived, unfounded and
unsustainable before law as no specific territorial limit had been mentioned
in the said Government of India’s decision. As there is no dispute that the
said decision had been taken specially for the benefit of the personnel of
the MNF, who have come overground in terms of the Memorandum of
Settlement, I find no reason as to why the benefits given by the Government
of India’s decision should not be extended to the petitioners.
[24]
This court also find force and merit in the submission advanced
by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners that the petitioners
are also entitled to get the benefit of the decision taken by the Government
of India like the other personnel of the MNF similarly situated with them
irrespective of whether the petitioners have committed the offence
outside the State of Mizoram and that the petitioners have been treated
discriminatorily and that the State respondents have violated their
Fundamental Right of Equality as enshrined under Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
In view of the facts and circumstances of the present case and
for the findings and reasons given hereinabove, this court come to the
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
[17]
conclusion that the petitioners have been able to make out a strong case in
the present writ petition. Accordingly, the respondents are directed to take
necessary steps to withdraw prosecution of the petitioners in connection
with the Cril. (P) Case No. 9 of 1986 pending before the Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Churachandpur or to close the said criminal case so far as the
present petitioners are concerned. The whole process should be completed
within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a certified copy
of this order.
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is disposed
of. Parties are to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
FR / NFR
Devananda
WP(C) No. 390 of 2007
Contd…/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review