Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
11.09.2026
Ct. No.655
Sl. No. 69
CO 4411 of 2025
Subadip
Lal Mohan Parui
Vs.
XXXXX
Mr. Souradipta Banerjee,
Ms. Fatima Hassan,
Mr. Ranjoy Mullick.
…for the petitioner
(In Court:-)
1.
The instant civil revisional application has been
preferred under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,
calling
in
question
the
legality,
propriety
and
correctness of the impugned order dated 03.09.2025,
being Order No. 37, passed by the learned Trial Court
in connection with Probate Case No. 19 of 2022,
whereby the application filed by the petitioner seeking
correction/rectification of certain particulars in the
affidavit of assets and inclusion of an omitted property
forming part of the estate of the deceased was
rejected.
2.
The genesis of the proceeding lies in the
application preferred by the petitioner seeking grant of
probate in respect of the last Will and Testament dated
23.03.2021, executed by one Sunil Kumar Parui, since
deceased. The said testamentary proceeding was
registered as Probate Case No. 19 of 2022. In the said
proceeding,
the
petitioner,
being
the
applicant/executor, furnished the particulars of the
landed properties belonging to the deceased and
incorporated the relevant details in the schedule of
immovable properties appended to the application for
probate and in the affidavit of assets filed in connection
therewith.
3.
The said Will dated 23.03.2021 was ultimately
probated by the learned Trial Court by an order dated
19.06.2024. Significantly, during the pendency of the
probate proceeding, no objection or caveat was raised
by any of the near relations or legal heirs of the
deceased. The grant of probate, therefore, came to be
made without any contest as regards the genuineness
or validity of the testamentary instrument.
4.
It is the specific case of the petitioner that,
subsequent to the grant of probate, upon making
necessary enquiries and verifying the relevant land
records from the office of the Block Land and Land
Reforms Officer, Chanditala-I, District Hooghly, certain
discrepancies and omissions in the description of the
properties came to his notice. It was discovered that,
in respect of Plot Nos. 1478 and 1651, the share of the
deceased
in
the
concerned
properties
had
been
incorrectly stated. It was further found that the
relevant R.S. Plot number, of the said two parts,
had not been mentioned. In addition thereto, the
particulars relating to Plot No. 1739, corresponding to
R.S. Plot No. 1628, including the quantity/area of the
land, had also been inadvertently omitted from the
affidavit of assets filed in the probate proceeding.
5.
According
to
the
petitioner,
the
aforesaid
discrepancies were neither deliberate nor intended to
alter or enlarge the testamentary disposition made by
the
deceased. They came
to
light
only
after a
subsequent verification of the records maintained by
the
competent
land
authority.
The
petitioner,
therefore, approached the learned Trial Court by filing
an application dated 02.07.2025, praying for necessary
correction/rectification of the erroneous particulars
already incorporated in the affidavit of assets and also
for bringing on record, by way of supplementary or
additional
inventory,
the
property
which
had
subsequently been discovered to stand in the name of
the deceased.
6.
The said application, however, came to be
rejected by the learned Trial Court by the impugned
order
dated
application,
03.09.2025.
the
learned
While
Trial
rejecting
Court,
the
principally,
proceeded on the premise that a probate Court, after
granting
probate,
does
not
adjudicate
upon
or
determine the title of the deceased in respect of any
particular property or share mentioned in the Will. The
learned Trial Court further observed that the prayer
made by the petitioner related to certain changes in
respect of the plot numbers in the affidavit of assets
filed with the Will itself and, upon such consideration,
declined to entertain the prayer for amendment,
correction or rectification.
7.
The principal issue which, therefore, falls for
consideration in the present revisional application is
whether, after grant of probate, the executor can seek
correction
or
rectification
of
an
inadvertent
or
erroneous description of an immovable property in the
affidavit of assets and, further, whether an asset
belonging to the deceased, which was inadvertently
omitted from the original inventory and subsequently
discovered, can be brought within the administration of
the estate by filing a supplementary or additional
inventory/affidavit of assets.
8.
In my considered view, the question has to be
examined by keeping in perspective the distinction
between the testamentary adjudication embodied in
the grant of probate and the subsequent administration
and identification of the estate of the deceased. The
grant of probate establishes the Will as the operative
testamentary instrument and clothes the executor with
the authority to administer the estate in accordance
with
the
testamentary
disposition.
Such
grant,
however, cannot reasonably be understood to mean
that every description of every asset furnished in the
inventory is thereafter incapable of correction, nor does
it
necessarily
signify
that
the
estate
has
been
exhaustively identified in every factual or descriptive
detail.
9.
The identification and disclosure of the assets of
the deceased constitute a distinct aspect of the
administration of the estate. An inadvertent mistake in
describing an asset which was already intended to be
included in the testamentary proceeding stands on an
entirely different footing from an attempt to introduce,
after the grant, a new property which was never
covered by the Will or to alter the substantive
testamentary disposition of the testator.
10. Where an immovable property has already been
disclosed but its particulars are subsequently found to
contain an inadvertent error, for example, an incorrect
plot number, incorrect area or share, omission of an
R.S. number, incorrect municipal description, boundary
or other identifying particulars, the correction of such
error would ordinarily be rectificatory in character. Its
purpose is merely to bring the record maintained in the
testamentary proceeding in conformity with the actual
description and identity of the property forming part of
the estate. Such a correction, by itself, does not
amount to an alteration of the Will or a review of the
order by which probate was granted.
11. The Court, however, must necessarily exercise
due caution while considering such an application. The
petitioner cannot,
under the guise of seeking a
correction, introduce a property which is fundamentally
different
from
testamentary
the
property
instrument
or
covered
seek
to
by
the
enlarge
the
substantive scope of the probate. The Court is,
therefore, required to ascertain whether the proposed
amendment is genuinely corrective and whether the
identity of the property remains substantially the
same. The source of title, the relevant land records,
the recitals contained in the Will, the original inventory
and the nature and extent of the correction sought
would
all
be
relevant
considerations
for
such
determination.
12. In this context, Section 317 of the Indian
Succession
Act,
assumes
considerable
significance. The said provision casts a statutory
obligation upon an executor or administrator, after the
grant of probate or letters of administration, to exhibit
before the Court an inventory containing a full and true
estimate of all the property in possession of the
executor or administrator and belonging to the estate
of
the
deceased.
requirement
is
to
The
object
secure
of
proper
such
statutory
identification,
disclosure and administration of the estate and to
ensure that the assets belonging to the deceased are
duly brought within the testamentary administration.
13. The statutory obligation to furnish a full and true
inventory cannot, in my view, be construed in such a
manner as to make an honest omission or inadvertent
mistake incapable of rectification once it is discovered.
Such an interpretation would run contrary to the very
object of Section 317. If, upon subsequent verification
of the records, it comes to light that an asset belonging
to the deceased was inadvertently omitted or that the
particulars
of
an
already
disclosed
asset
were
incorrectly recorded, the executor ought, rather than
being prevented from correcting the record, to bring
the
true
and
complete
particulars
before
the
testamentary Court.
14. The
statutory
scheme,
therefore,
places
emphasis upon the proper and complete administration
of the estate, rather than upon perpetuating an
accidental error merely because probate has already
been granted.
15. At
the
time
of
hearing,
learned
Advocate
appearing for the petitioner has also drawn our
attention to Section 261 of the Indian Succession Act,
1925, which is of particular relevance in the present
context.
Section
expressly
contemplates
rectification of errors in names and descriptions and
also provides for alteration and amendment of the
grant
of
probate
or
letters
of
administration
in
appropriate cases. The provision thus recognises, in
statutory terms, that an error in the grant or in the
description accompanying the grant is not, in every
circumstance, beyond the corrective jurisdiction of the
testamentary Court.
16. The significance of Section 261 lies in the
distinction between a rectification of an error and a
substantive
alteration
of
the
testamentary
grant.
Where the property was already the subject matter of
the Will and the probate proceeding, but its description
contains an accidental, clerical or inadvertent error,
such as an incorrect plot number, area, share, R.S.
number or other identifying description, the Court,
upon being satisfied about the bona fides of the
application and the identity of the property, may
consider appropriate rectification. Such exercise does
not amount to rewriting the Will or changing the
testamentary intention of the deceased.
17. The same principle must logically extend to a
property which, according to the petitioner, belonged
to the deceased and was inadvertently omitted from
the original affidavit of assets but was subsequently
discovered during verification of the land records. The
omission of such an asset from the original inventory
does not, by itself, divest the estate of its character as
property belonging to the deceased, nor does it confer
any independent right upon a third party merely
because the asset was not initially included in the
affidavit of assets. The executor remains under a
continuing obligation to ensure that the estate is
properly identified and administered.
18. It
is
also
relevant
that,
according
to
the
petitioner, the Will itself contains an express stipulation
to the effect that, if any property of the testator is left
out or omitted from the schedule, such property may
subsequently be brought within the estate/inventory
and administered in accordance with the terms of the
Will.
If
that
contention
is
borne
out
from
the
testamentary instrument, the same would constitute
an additional circumstance requiring consideration by
the learned Trial Court while deciding the application.
19. In such circumstances, if a property genuinely
belonging
to
the
deceased
and
covered
by
the
testamentary disposition was inadvertently left out
from the original affidavit of assets and its existence
was subsequently discovered, the appropriate course
would ordinarily be for the executor to place the
particulars of such property before the testamentary
Court by way of a supplementary/additional inventory
or supplementary affidavit of assets. Such a course
would advance, rather than defeat, the object of the
testamentary
jurisdiction,
namely,
the
proper
administration of the estate in accordance with the
Will.
20. This Court, therefore, unable to accept the broad
proposition that merely because probate has already
been
granted,
the
testamentary
Court
becomes
completely functus officio in respect of every question
relating to correction or rectification of the inventory or
affidavit of assets. The fact that the probate has
already been granted undoubtedly places limitations
upon the jurisdiction of the Court; the Court cannot,
under the guise of correction, reopen the validity of the
Will,
adjudicate
a
disputed
question
of
title
or
materially alter the testamentary disposition. At the
same time, however, the Court is not powerless to
correct an accidental or inadvertent error in the
description of an asset or to consider the inclusion of
an
asset
subsequently
discovered,
where
such
correction or inclusion is permissible in law and is
necessary for proper administration of the estate.
21. The learned Trial Court, therefore, ought to have
examined the nature and extent of the correction
sought rather than rejecting the application principally
on the ground that probate had already been granted.
The Court was required to ascertain whether the
proposed changes in respect of Plot Nos. 1478 and
1651, the omission of the relevant R.S. number and
the particulars relating to Plot No. 1739 were merely
accidental or inadvertent errors in description, or
whether the petitioner was, in substance, seeking to
introduce a different property or alter the testamentary
disposition.
Similarly,
in
respect
of
the
allegedly
omitted property, the learned Trial Court ought to have
considered the relevant land records, the recitals of the
Will, the original schedule and affidavit of assets and
the materials relied upon by the petitioner before
determining whether the property formed part of the
estate of the deceased and could appropriately be
brought
on
inventory.
record
by
way
of
a
supplementary
22. The
jurisdiction
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India is supervisory in nature and is not
ordinarily exercised merely because another view on
the facts is possible. However, where the subordinate
Court proceeds upon an erroneous understanding of
the scope of its jurisdiction and, on that basis, declines
to examine a prayer which it was competent to
consider in accordance with the statutory scheme,
interference becomes warranted. In the present case,
the learned Trial Court, in my view, proceeded on an
unduly restrictive understanding of its jurisdiction after
the grant of probate and consequently failed to
examine the application on its true legal and factual
parameters.
23. I make it clear that I have not expressed any
final opinion as to whether the corrections or the
inclusion of the subsequently discovered property
sought by the petitioner are, in fact, liable to be
allowed. That determination necessarily rests with the
learned Trial Court upon consideration of the relevant
materials. The petitioner shall be required to establish
that the proposed correction is bona fide, accidental or
inadvertent, that the property sought to be included
genuinely belonged to the deceased, and that such
inclusion
or
correction
does
not
amount
to
a
substantive alteration of the Will or an enlargement of
the probate granted by the Court.
24. The
learned
Trial
Court
shall
also
remain
conscious of the distinction between an application for
rectification of the description of an estate and an
application seeking adjudication of title. If any serious
or contentious dispute as to title arises, the same shall
have to be dealt with in accordance with law and within
the limits of the jurisdiction of the testamentary Court.
The present order, therefore, shall not be construed as
conferring upon the probate Court any jurisdiction to
finally adjudicate a disputed title which falls outside the
scope of probate proceedings.
25. For the reasons stated hereinabove, I find that
the impugned order dated 03.09.2025, passed by the
learned Trial Court in Probate Case No. 19 of 2022,
suffers from an error of jurisdiction and cannot be
sustained in its present form. The learned Trial Court
ought to have considered the petitioner's application on
its merits in the light of Sections 261 and 317 of the
Indian Succession Act, 1925, after examining whether
the proposed correction and inclusion are genuinely
required for proper administration of the estate and
whether they are consistent with the testamentary
disposition.
26. Accordingly, the present revisional application is
allowed.
27. The impugned order dated 03.09.2025, being
Order No. 37, passed by the learned Trial Court in
connection with Probate Case No. 19 of 2022, is hereby
set aside.
28. The learned Trial Court is directed to reconsider
and dispose of the application dated 02.07.2025, filed
by the petitioner, afresh, in accordance with law and in
the light of the observations made hereinabove. The
learned Trial Court shall examine, inter alia, whether
the corrections sought in respect of the properties
already disclosed are merely inadvertent or accidental
errors
in
description
and
whether
the
property
subsequently stated to have been discovered forms
part
of
the
estate
of
the
deceased
and
can
appropriately be brought on record by way of a
supplementary/additional
inventory
or
affidavit
of
assets.
29. The learned Trial Court is requested to dispose
of the said application, preferably within three weeks
from the date of communication of this order, without
being influenced by any observation made herein which
may be construed as an expression of opinion on the
ultimate merits of the petitioner's claim.
30. It is, however, made clear that the petitioner
shall be at liberty to produce before the learned Trial
Court all relevant documents and such other materials
as
may
ownership
question.
be
necessary
and
to
description
establish
the
of
properties
the
identity,
in
31. Accordingly, C.O. No. 4410 of 2025 stands
allowed.
32. There shall be no order as to costs.
33. Let a copy of this order be sent to the learned
Trial Court forthwith for information and necessary
action.
34. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied for, be given to the parties on payment of
requisite fees.
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review