Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.M.MANOJ
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 2681 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED 19.10.2024 IN IA NO.14/2024 IN IA
NO.15 OF 2024 OF ASSISTANT SESSIONS COURT/PRINCIPAL SUB COURT/COMMERCIAL COURT,
KOTTAYAM ARISING OUT OF THE ORDER/JUDGMENT IN CS NO.432 OF 2021 OF ASSISTANT
SESSIONS COURT/PRINCIPAL SUB COURT/COMMERCIAL COURT, KOTTAYAM
PETITIONERS/DEFENDANTS:
LAL C GEORGE
AGED 70 YEARS
S/O GEORGE, CHOTHIRAKUNNEL HOUSE, THOTTAKKADU P.O.
AMBALAKKAVALA, KOTTAYAM, PIN – 686 539
GRACE LAL
AGED 60 YEARS
W/O LAL C GEORGE, CHOTHIRAKUNNEL HOUSE, THOTTAKKADU P.O.
AMBALAKKAVALA, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686539
BY ADVS. C.S.MANILAL
S.NIDHEESH
RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF:
M/S NCR FINANCERS
KARAPPARA BUILDINGS, VAKATHANAM VILLAGE, CHANGANACHERRY,
REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER IPEKUTTY THOMAS,
KARAPPARA VETTIYIL HOUSE, VAKATHANAM VILLAGE, VAKATHANAM P.O,
CHANGANACHERRY, PIN - 686538
BY ADV G.S.REGHUNATH
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 02.04.2025, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
P.M. MANOJ, J
-----------------OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
---------------------Dated this the 2nd day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
The Original Petition is preferred by the Plaintiffs in three
commercial suits on the files of Commercial Court, Kottayam.
The
plaints are for the realisation of money amounting to Rs.26 lakhs,
stated to have been borrowed on three different occasions, i.e.,
21.04.2015, 24.04.2015 and 02.05.2015. The amounts borrowed on
the respective dates were Rs.6 lakhs, Rs.10 lakhs and Rs.10 lakhs. The
demand is raised on the basis of a promissory note issued by the
defendants. On failure, Suits were filed as CS No.432/2021 for an
amount of Rs.18,71,000/-, CS No.309/2021 for an amount of
Rs.37,40,300/- and CS No.22/2020 for an amount of Rs.11,21,800/-.
Exts.P1 to P3 are the plaints filed before the Commercial Court,
Kottayam.
2.
The
transactions.
defendants
filed
written
statement
denying
the
It is denied that the defendants had approached the
plaintiff for availing loan of Rs.36 lakhs in total. It is their case that on
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
account of dire necessity, taking advantage of the precarious and
vulnerable position of the defendants, the plaintiff compelled them to
put their signatures in various printed forms and plain papers more
than 10 in numbers. One Ipekutty Thomas, who is the person in charge
of the financial institution, was instructed to get the blank papers
signed and the signatures of the 2nd defendant on the documents
produced are false, fabricated and forged.
The plaintiff is conducting
an illegal establishment doing money lending business without
following the statutory requirements.
3. The orders impugned in this Original Petition are Exts.P8, P11
and P14. Ext.P8 is the order of the trial court whereby it refused to
examine witnesses Nos.1 and 4 in the witness schedule produced in IA
No.14/2024. Ext.P11 is an order of the trial court refusing to summon
documents from the office of the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner
that are related to statutory licenses, forms, returns etc. Ext.P14 is
the order declining the direction to produce the statutory documents
that are sought to be produced by the plaintiff.
4. According to the petitioners herein, the examination of PW1 is
over and the cases were jointly tried.
On 27.07.2024, prior to the
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
defendants’ evidence, Ext.P7 witness list was submitted requiring the
presence of four witnesses. The 1st defendant was examined as DW1
on 31.07.2024. It is stated that much prior to that, the defence list was
submitted.
The first witness is the registering authority under the
Money Lenders Act, i.e. the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner AIT &
ST Department, Kottayam. The 2nd and 3rd witnesses are the Manager
and Secretary of the bank and Co-operative Society respectively. The
fourth witness is none other than the wife of the power of attorney
holder of the plaintiff, who is also directly involved in the affairs of the
plaintiff firm. The witness list was filed along with IA No.14/2024. I.A.
No.15/2024 was preferred, i.e. Ext.P9 along with IA No.14/2024 for a
direction to the first witness, the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner,
to produce statutory documents listed as serial Nos.1 to 6 in Ext.P9.
The other witnesses were also directed to produce specific documents
which are necessary to prove certain transactions.
The petitioners
herein stated that they have assigned specific reason for summoning
document Nos.1 to 6 by the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner and
have also preferred I.A. No.16 of 2024 under Order XI Rule 14 CPC to
produce three documents numbered a, b and c, as evident from
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
Ext.P12 which are the statutory documents to be compulsorily
maintained by an establishment conducting money lending business
under the Kerala Money Lenders Act, 1958 (for short ‘the Act’).
5. However, I.A. No.14/2024 has been partly allowed, whereby
PW2 and PW3 were recalled, and the prayer to summon witness Nos.1
and 4 was rejected.
rejection.
But no specific reason was assigned for such
Whereas I.A. Nos.15/24 and 16/24 were rejected on a
common ground, as seen in Exts.P11 and P14, that the documents
sought to be called under the Act are the returns filed and forms
produced which are totally irrelevant to the subject of issue.
6. The case projected by the petitioners/defendants is that it is
an admitted case of the plaintiff that the firm is doing financial business
as recognized under the extant law.
In that facet, the defendants
contend that the plaintiff is an illegal establishment doing business in
the field of money lending. In order to deny the transaction which is
stated to be illegal in the Plaint, the defendants/petitioners herein
brought the attention of this Court to the relevant provisions of the Act.
As per Section 3(1) of the Act read with Rule 3(3) of the Kerala Money
Lenders Rules, 1964 a licence is compulsory for money lending
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
business. Section 4 prescribes the provisions for rejecting the licence.
Section 2 (4A) of the Act defines the licensing authority as officers
notified under the Act. Going by the Notification it can be seen that
the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner AIT & ST of Kottayam is the
officer defined under Section 2 (4A) of the Act for Kottayam District.
In order to prove the illegality of the money lending business and nonfollowal of the procedure by the plaintiff firm, the petitioners sought to
bring the said authority as first witness on the defendants’ side since
being the licensing authority, the transactions of the money lending
business are controlled and monitored by him.
Therefore, the trial
court cannot deny the evidence sought from the said witness and the
documents in his possession under no circumstances can be treated as
not relevant. It is in such circumstances that the plaintiff claims that
the firm is doing money lending business strictly under the Act and
Rules.
7. Similarly, as per Section 9(1) of the Act, the firms involved in
money
lending
business
have
to
maintain
compulsorily
mandatorily certain documents which are as follows :
and
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
Under Sub-Clause (a) it is mandated to regularly record and
maintain or cause to be recorded and maintained an account showing
for each debt, i.e. the particulars of such debt
(i) Date of the loan, the principal amount of the loan and the rate
of interest charged on the loan.
(ii) The amount of every payment received by the money lender
in respect of the loan and the date of such payment.
8. From the aforementioned provision, it is discernible that the
date of the loan and the principal amount shall be recorded in the
register to be maintained. Likewise, the amount received by the money
lender in respect of the loan and the date of such payment are to be
reflected in the books of account. Such books of accounts are to be
maintained mandatorily to file returns by virtue of Section 9(1)(d) of
the Act.
9. On the strength of these contentions, the petitioners herein are
trying to establish that if a particular payment is effected by way of loan
on a particular date with a particular amount, the same should be
reflected in the books of account and the books of account shall be subject
to verification of the officer defined under Section 2 (4A) by filing
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
periodical returns. Such arguments are raised only to show the casual
connection and relevancy of the statutory document as well as the
books of account kept by the money lender which are highly essential
to prove the transaction between the plaintiff and the defendants.
10. Similarly, Rule 15(3)(a) contemplates, the quarterly returns
relating to loans advanced by the money lender and deposits or loans
received by the money lender in that quarter.
Rule 15(3)(b)
contemplates the yearly returns to be filed in respect of loans
advanced, amount received including deposits should be reflected in
such returns. This being the statutory position, in order to prove the
transaction between the plaintiff and the defendants, that should be
reflected in the books of account of the money lender and in the
statutory return to be filed by the money lender before the authority
sought to bring in as first witness in I.A. No.14 of 2024. Thereby, it is
discernible that the impugned transactions are to be reflected in the
books of account of the plaintiff as well as in the returns filed before
the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner. Thereby the view taken by the
trial court that the same has no relevance is beyond jurisdiction of the
trial court and is perversive.
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
11. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondents submitted
that the defendants in CS No.432 of 2021 took a loan of Rs.30 lakhs
from the respondents for the purpose of their Estate on 24.04.2015.
They borrowed Rs.10 lakhs on the strength of a Promissory Note dated
02.05.2015. The Suit is related to the said transaction.
12. When they failed to repay and the notice sent was not replied
to,
the
defendants
were
requested
to
execute
a
letter
of
acknowledgement on 08.02.2018 requesting them to repay. It was in
their handwriting. They did not honour their undertaking to repay the
amount. Thereafter a lawyer notice was issued on 30.01.2020. That
was also declined to receive. Therefore, CS No.432/2021 is filed before
the Commercial Court, Kottayam. Ext.R1(b) is the copy of the plaint,
and Ext.R1(c) is the copy of the written statement.
13. It is further asserted that evidence was completed, and the
suit was posted for final hearing. On the knowledge that the suit will
be decreed, they preferred a petition under Order XI Rule 14 CPC for a
direction to the defendants to produce certain documents, other than
the documents already produced and marked which are absolutely
irrelevant, in the written statement. The execution of a promissory
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
note is denied in a vague manner and it is contended that only signed
papers were given.
No.432/2021
It is also contended with respect to CS
that, in urgent
need of money, the defendants
approached the plaintiff and requested a loan of Rs.6 lakhs. It is
contended by the defendants that a demand was raised by the plaintiff
firm to put signature in blank paper and printed forms as a condition
for sanction of the amounts. These facts are denied. For realisation of
the amount, three suits were filed demanding the loan amount with
18% interest, if no interest is provided by the Negotiable Instrument.
Therefore, the order rejecting the request to call for records is legally
sustainable.
14. It is further argued that the contention of the petitioners that
the claim for 18% interest is unlawful is not sustainable. Section 80 of
the NI Act provides for 18% interest, if no interest is provided in the
Negotiable instrument.
It is also argued that the contention with
respect to signed blank papers cannot be sustained since, when a
promissory note is executed, it will be affixed with the required revenue
stamp as a prerequisite and the promissory note is executed in white
papers with revenue stamps of necessary value. These are the matters
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
to be ascertained by the Sub Court on the basis of the evidence to be
adduced. This is not a matter to be agitated in an Original Petition
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
15. Here the challenge is with respect to the
I.A. filed under
Order XI Rule 14 CPC. The trial has started. Plaintiff and two witnesses
are already examined as PWs 1 to 3 and the 1st defendant is examined
as DW1. It is also contended that these are the matters to be examined
by the trial court. Finding that the contentions raised by the defendants
are not sustainable, he filed I.A. No.16/2024 under Order XI Rule 14
CPC to protract the case. Therefore, the question to be decided in this
Original Petition is the entertainability of the petition filed under Order
XI Rule 14 CPC.
The defendant has produced plaints in CS No.432
and 309 of 2021 and CS No.22/2020 as Exts.P1 to P3, respectively.
Written statements in the above three Original Suits are also produced
as Exts.P4 to P6 respectively. Ext.P7 is I.A. No.14/2024. All these
documents are produced only to protract the litigation.
16. The defendants have admitted the receipt of Rs.6 lakhs and
execution of the promissory note. That position is clear from the
contention that signed papers are issued. The nature of such signed
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
papers with revenue stamps of necessary value is a matter to be
ascertained by the trial court. So, the question to be decided is the
maintainability of the Original Petition filed under Article 227 for
challenging Ext.P14 order.
There are no valid or relevant grounds
raised for such a challenge.
17. The suit is primarily based on a promissory note. Therefore,
the findings of the Sub Court that it is an attempt of the defendants to
protract the litigation for dismissing the plea for witness schedule as
irrelevant witnesses and irrelevant documents are sustainable. On an
attempt to protract the matter, I.A. No.16/2024 was filed in CS
No.432/2021.
A copy of the counter affidavit filed in the said suit
produced as Ext.P13 will prove that the contentions of the petitioners
will not sustain. Large numbers of irrelevant documents are sought to
be produced with the objective of complicating a simple suit for
recovery of money on the strength of a promissory note, which is not
denied specifically.
18. Section 118 of the NI Act stands for the presumption as to
the negotiable instruments which says, until the contrary is proved,
the presumption of consideration, the date, the time of acceptance, the
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
time of transfer, order of indorsement, stamp, holder is a holder in due
course, shall be made. This position is clear from the reported decision
in Oriental Bank of Commerce v. Prabodh Kumar Tewari, [2022
(5) KHC 560] wherein it is held that the presumption which arises on
the signing of a cheque cannot be rebutted merely by a report of a
handwriting expert. Even if the details in the cheque have not been
filled up by the drawer but by another person, this is not relevant to
the defense whether the cheque was issued towards a payment of debt
or discharge of a liability. The petitioner has also brought the attention
of this Court to a reported decision Shalini Syam Shetty and another
v. Rajendra Shankar Patil [2010 (3) KLT SN 90/2010 KHC 4492]
wherein it is held that the power of High Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution is that of superintendence/revision which is not greater
than the power under Article 226. It is only to ensure that Tribunals
function within the limits of their authority. The power under Article
227 is discretionary and has to be exercised on equitable principles.
The power can be exercised in order to ensure that law is followed by
such Tribunals and Courts by exercising jurisdiction which is vested on
them and not by declining to exercise jurisdiction which is vested on
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
them. In such cases, the High Court can interfere in exercising powers
under Article 227 in cases where patent perversity in the order of the
Tribunal and courts subordinate to it or where there has been a gross
and manifest failure of justice or the basic principle of natural justice
have been floated.
Such power should be sparingly exercised.
19. In this case, the Original Petition filed under Article 227
cannot be entertained because the trial court, exercising its power
under Order XI Rule 14 CPC, held that the petitioners/defendants are
not entitled to cause the trial court to conduct an enquiry because the
scope of the suit is limited.
20. In reply, the counsel for the petitioners submitted that the
Supreme Court decision relied on by the plaintiff relates to prosecution
under Section 138, which has nothing to do with the promissory note
which is the subject matter of the suit in the present case. Therefore,
the said decision, Ravi Prasad Supra has no relevance. The
presumption under Section 118 relied on by the plaintiff to canvas the
position that the burden is on the defendants to show that there is no
consideration, etc, are liable to be rejected in as much as the case of
the plaintiff cannot be proved by presumption.
In order to attract
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
presumption, two fundamental things have to be fulfilled. The first one
is the basic fact from which the presumption can be drawn. The basic
facts relating to the transaction are the alleged documents which had
already been disputed and forgery and fabrication had been alleged.
In the absence of the basic facts being proved no inferential fact can
be deducted.
Therefore, the presumption cannot be applied at this
stage of proceedings.
Moreover, Section 118 of the NI Act casts a
burden on the defendant and it is therefore highly essential as a matter
of right for the defendants to adduce evidence, that had been denied
by the court below, which is illegal, perversive and beyond jurisdiction.
21. Shalini Shetty supra laid down the general principle of
exercising jurisdiction under Article 227, which categorises the
situations in which the power of superintendence and revision is
exercised, in the case of patent illegality by ignoring the statutory law.
In the case on hand, foreclosing the chance of defendants to adduce
evidence, being a gross injustice, the exercise of jurisdiction under
Article 227 is attracted. Hence, the said decision stands in the favour
of the petitioners herein.
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
22. I have heard Sri.C.S. Manilal, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioners and Sri. G.S. Regunath, learned counsel appearing for
the respondent.
23. Having considered the rival contentions, it appears that the
petitioners herein availed a loan of Rs.6 lakhs from the respondent for
which, as a prerequisite, they signed blank papers which were later
alleged to be converted as a promissory note. Moreover, the unavailed
amounts were claimed using the alleged promissory note and three
suits i.e. CS No.432/2021, CS No.309/2021 and CS No.22/2020 were
filed before the Commercial Court, Kottayam. According to the plaintiff,
the petitioners herein borrowed money on three different occasions,
namely on 24.04.2015 an amount of Rs.10,00,000/-, on 02.05.2015
another amount of Rs.10,00,000/- and on 21.04.2015 an amount of
Rs.6 lakhs.
The amounts were availed allegedly executing promissory
notes. On failure to repay, the aforementioned suits were filed claiming
Rs.18,71,000/-, Rs.37,40,300/- and Rs.11,21,800/- respectively.
24. The suits were instituted before the Commercial Court,
Kottayam by the respondent herein on the basis of alleged promissory
notes. It is the case of the respondent company that they indulged in
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
money lending business after complying with all the necessary
formalities under the Act. The petitioners had executed promissory
notes to avail the loans.
They failed to repay, and the initial notices
were not responded to by them. Later, lawyer notice was issued which
was also not accepted. This was the circumstance in which the suits
were initiated. Though the petitioners admit availing of Rs.6 lakhs,
they deny the execution of promissory notes.
Instead, it is alleged
that signatures were obtained in blank papers as a condition for giving
the money required by the petitioners. When the suit came to the trial
stage, PWs 1 to 3 were examined, and 1st petitioner was examined as
DW1 with an intention to protract the proceedings on realising that
suits were going to be decreed, petitioners approached the trial court
with a fresh witness list by preferring I.A. No.14/2024 under Section
31 and 151 CPC for accepting the witnesses scheduled which was
allowed in part as per Ext.P8. Later, he again filed I.A. No.15/2024 to
summon the witness Nos.1 to 3 and to direct them to produce
documents sought in the application.
But that was rejected as per
Ext.P11. Then another application as I.A.No.16/2024 under Order XI
Rule 14 CPC was filed to call for certain records from the plaintiff
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
himself. That was also rejected as per Ext.P14. Exts.P11 and P14 are
rejected on the ground that it is only a delaying tactics.
25. Against that, the contention of the petitioners herein is that
the respondent is stated to be involved in money lending business. As
per Section 3(1) read with Rule 3(3) of the Act and Rules, a licence is
compulsory for money lending activity.
Section 4 provides the
discretionary power to grant or refuse such licence. Section 2(4A) of the
Act defines the licensing authority. In the case on hand such authority is
in the first witness schedule attached in Ext.P7. As per Section 9(1) of
the Act, those who were indulged in money lending business have to
maintain compulsorily and mandatorily certain documents and under Subclause (a) regularly record and maintain or cause to be recorded and
maintained an account showing for each debt separately.
The nature of
such recording is explained under Sub-Clause (a) (i) and (ii). That is why
the petitioners sought to bring the authorised officer under Sections 3 and
4, which are defined under Section 2(4A) by preferring I.A. No.14/2024.
26. In order to prove the transactions as per the documents
contemplated under Section 9(1) the petitioners have preferred I.A.
No. 15/2024.
Since both these requests were declined by the trial
court, I.A. No. 16/2024 was preferred to obtain the documents to prove
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
the transaction from the records which are to be maintained by the
money lender under Section 9. All these requests were denied by the
trial court on the reason that the requests were irrelevant and were an
attempt to protract the proceedings.
27. However, on evaluating the circumstances, it appears that it
is an admitted fact that the petitioners availed a loan from the
respondent. What is in dispute is the number of loans and the amount
of loans. It is an admitted case of the respondent that petitioners had
availed loans by executing promissory note to repay the same, and the
firm is involved in money lending business. It is also argued on the
strength of Rule 118 of the NI Act that the presumption is on the part
of the defendants, which is the general presumption.
To meet the
contentions with respect to the general presumption, it requires some
material evidence. To adduce such material evidence the only source
available to the defendants is to bring the necessary documents before
the trial court.
28. To ascertain such official documents, an officer needs to be
examined. That is the first witness who is the authorised officer under
Section 2(4A) of the Act and the nature of the documents to be
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
maintained are explained under Section 9(a).
Those are the
documents sought to be called by the petitioners by preferring I.A.
Nos.14 and 15 of 2024. Those applications were rejected, especially
the witness list, without assigning proper reasons and calling for the
records were declined on accepting the objection raised by the
respondent on the reason that it is an attempt to protract the
proceedings.
That appears to be a denial of justice on a perverse
finding without proper application of mind since the provisions of the
Money Lenders Act are crystal clear with respect to the maintenance of
documents and the need for registration of the firm involved in the
money lending business.
29. Those factors were not properly considered and evaluated by
the trial court. The documents and the witness under the provisions
of the Money Lenders Act are crucial documents and witnesses to rebut
the presumptions as mandated under Section 118 of the NI Act.
Therefore, the findings of the trial court in Ext.P8 and P11 are perverse.
The only available source for the petitioners to obtain certain
documents that the respondent would have maintained under the
provisions of Section 9 being a licensed money lender as per Section 3
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
is to file an application.
That was also denied on an improper
application of mind and on a prejudicial attitude as an attempt of the
petitioners to protract the matter.
That cannot be countenanced,
especially in the background of presumption under Section 118 of the
NI Act as contended by the counsel for the respondent. Therefore, the
findings in Ext.P14 are also perverse.
30. In the aforementioned circumstances, the bar to exercise
jurisdiction under Article 227, as the petitioners contended on the
strength of Shalini Syam supra, cannot be sustained.
On the aforementioned findings, the petitioners have made out
a good case that warrants interference under Article 227 to set the trial
court correct as there is a manifest failure of justice on the part of the
trial court. Accordingly, the Original Petition is allowed. The impugned
orders are set aside, directing the Trial Court to reconsider I.A. Nos.14,
15 and 16 of 2024 filed by the petitioners herein.
Sd/-
P.M.MANOJ
JUDGE
ttb
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 2681/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
A COPY OF THE PLAINT IN C.S 432/2021 OF THE
SUBORDINATE COURT KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P2
A COPY OF THE PLAINT IN C.S 309/2021 OF THE
SUBORDINATE COURT KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P3
A COPY OF THE PLAINT IN C.S 22/2020 OF THE
MUNSIFF’S COURT CHANGANASSERY
Exhibit P4
A TRUE OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT IN C.S 432/2021
DATED 3.7.2022 OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P5
A TRUE OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT IN C.S 309/2021
DATED 30.5.2022 OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT
KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P6
A TRUE OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT IN C.S 22/2020
DATED 2.2.2021 OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P7
A COPY OF THE I.A NO.14/2024 IN CS 432/2021
DATED 27/07/2024 OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT
KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P8
A COPY OF THE ORDER IN I.A NO.14/2024 IN CS
432/2021 DATED 19/10/2024 OF THE COMMERCIAL
COURT KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P9
A COPY OF THE I.A. NO.15/2024 IN CS 432/2021
DATED 31/07/2024 OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT
KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P10
A COPY OF THE OBJECTION IN CS 432/2021 DATED
07/08/2024 OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P11
A COPY OF THE ORDER IN I.A NO. 15/2024 IN CS
432/2021 DATED 19/10/2024 OF THE COMMERCIAL
COURT KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P12
A COPY OF THE I.A NO.16/2024 IN CS 432/2021
DATED 06/08/2024 OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT
2025:KER:27565
OP(C) No. 2681 of 2024
KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P13
A COPY OF THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT IN CS 432/2021
DATED NIL OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT KOTTAYAM
Exhibit P14
A COPY OF THE ORDER IN I.A NO.16/2024 IN CS
432/2021 DATED 16/10/2024 OF THE COMMERCIAL
COURT KOTTAYAM
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1(a)
Copy of the Power of Attorney dated 18/02/2020
Exhibit R1(b)
Copy of the plaint in C.S No. 432/2021 before
the Commercial Court, Kottayam
Exhibit R1(c)
Copy of the Written Statement in C.S No.
432/2021 before the Commercial Court, Kottayam
Exhibit R1(d)
Copy of the petition in C.S No. 432/2021 before
the Commercial Court, Kottayam
Exhibit R1(e)
Copy of that Order dated 19/10/2024 in I.A No.
16/2024 in C.S No.432/2021
//TRUE COPY//
Sd/P.S. TO JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review