Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 590 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 31.01.2022 IN OS NO.231 OF 2019
OF MUNSIFF COURT, HOSDRUG ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT & DECREE DATED
20.12.2023 IN AS NO.19 OF 2022 OF SUB COURT, HOSDRUG
APPELLANT/APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
RANJINI KP,AGED 50 YEARS
W/O. SUNIL P, RESIDING AT ARDRA, KOVVAL, PUNCHAVI
KADAPPURAM, OZHINHAVALAPPU, KANHANGAD VILLAGE & PO,
KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671315
BY ADVS.
SURESH KUMAR KODOTH
SUKARNAN
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT:
SREE NARAYANA EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY,
AGED 54 YEARS,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
KG PRABHAKARAN, S/O. GOPALAKRISHNAN, MANNYOT, KOVVAPALLY,
KANHANGAD VILLAGE AND POST, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671315
BY ADVS.
PHILIP T.VARGHESE
THOMAS T.VARGHESE
ACHU SUBHA ABRAHAM
V.T.LITHA
K.R.MONISHA
JIJO PAULC.J.JINCY
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 25.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RSA.591/2024, 593/2024 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 591 OF 2024
AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT & DECREE DATED 20.12.2023 IN AS NO.18 OF 2022
OF SUB COURT, HOSDRUG ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT& DECREE DATED 31.01.2022
IN OS NO.230 OF 2019 OF MUNSIFF COURT, HOSDRUG
APPELLANT/APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
SHYLA P,
AGED 52 YEARS
W/O. GOPALAKRISHNAN K, RESIDING AT KOVVAL STORE, KANHANGAD
SOUTH, KANHANGAD VILLAGE & PO, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN 671531
BY ADVS.
SURESH KUMAR KODOTH
SUKARNAN
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT:
SREE NARAYANA EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, KG PRABHAKARAN, S/O.
GOPALAKRISHNAN, MANNYOT, KOVVAPALLY, KANHANGAD VILLAGE AND
POST, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671315
BY ADVS.
PHILIP T.VARGHESE
THOMAS T.VARGHESE
ACHU SUBHA ABRAHAM
V.T.LITHA
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
K.R.MONISHA
JIJO PAUL
C.J.JINCY
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 25.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RSA.590/2024 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 593 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 20.12.2023 IN AS NO.17 OF 2022 OF
SUB COURT, HOSDRUG ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 31.01.2022 IN
OS NO.229 OF 2019 OF MUNSIFF COURT, HOSDRUG
APPELLANT/APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
SAVITHRI PV,
AGED 62 YEARS
D/O. PV RAGHAVAN, RESIDING AT PATHAYAPPURA, KALLANCHIRA,
KANHANGAD VILLAGE & PO, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671531
BY ADVS.
SURESH KUMAR KODOTH
SUKARNAN
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT:
SREE NARAYANA EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, KG PRABHAKARAN, S/O.
GOPALAKRISHNAN, MANNYOT, KOVVAPALLY, KANHANGAD VILLAGE AND
POST, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671315
BY ADVS.
PHILIP T.VARGHESE
THOMAS T.VARGHESE
ACHU SUBHA ABRAHAM
V.T.LITHA
K.R.MONISHA
JIJO PAUL
C.J.JINCY
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 25.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RSA.590/2024 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 592 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 20.12.2023 IN AS NO.16 OF 2022 OF
SUB COURT, HOSDRUG ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 31.01.2022 IN
OS NO.228 OF 2019 OF MUNSIFF COURT, HOSDRUG
APPELLANT/APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
GOMATHI S,
AGED 60 YEARS
D/O. SADASHIVAN, RESIDING AT KARTHANDAN VEEDU, KALLANCHIRA,
KANHANGAD VILLAGE &PO, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671315
BY ADVS.
SURESH KUMAR KODOTH
SUKARNAN
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
SREE NARAYANA EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, KG PRABHAKARAN,S/O.
GOPALAKRISHNAN, MANNYOT, KOVVAPALLY, KANHANGAD VILLAGE AND
POST, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671315
BY ADVS.
PHILIP T.VARGHESE
THOMAS T.VARGHESE
ACHU SUBHA ABRAHAM
V.T.LITHA
K.R.MONISHA
JIJO PAUL
C.J.JINCY
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 25.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RSA.590/2024 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 595 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 20.12.2023 IN AS NO.14 OF 2022 OF
SUB COURT, HOSDRUG ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 31.01.2022 IN
OS NO.226 OF 2019 OF MUNSIFF COURT, HOSDRUG
APPELLANT/APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
LAKSHMI EV,
AGED 49 YEARS
W/O. CHANDRABOSE, RESIDING AT KAIPRAVAN VEEDU, KOVVAL,
KANHANGAD VILLAGE & PO, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671531
BY ADVS.
SURESH KUMAR KODOTH
SUKARNAN
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT:
SREE NARAYANA EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, KG PRABHAKARAN, S/O.
GOPALAKRISHNAN, MANNYOT, KOVVAPALLY, KANHANGAD VILLAGE AND
POST, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671315
BY ADVS.
PHILIP T.VARGHESE
THOMAS T.VARGHESE
ACHU SUBHA ABRAHAM
V.T.LITHA
K.R.MONISHA
JIJO PAUL
C.J.JINCY
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 25.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RSA.590/2024 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 594 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 20.12.2023 IN AS NO.15 OF 2022 OF
SUB COURT, HOSDRUG ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 31.01.2022 IN
OS NO.227 OF 2019 OF MUNSIFF COURT, HOSDRUG
APPELLANT/APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
LAKSHMI C,
AGED 63 YEARS
D/O. T LAKSHMANA RAO, RESIDING AT LAKSHMI NILAYAM, NEAR
MUTHAPPAN KAVU, KANHANGAD VILLAGE & PO, KASARGOD DISTRICT,,
PIN - 671531
BY ADVS.
SURESH KUMAR KODOTH
SUKARNAN
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT:
SREE NARAYANA EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY,
AGED 54 YEARS
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, KG PRABHAKARAN, S/O.
GOPALAKRISHNAN, MANNYOT, KOVVAPALLY, KANHANGAD VILLAGE AND
POST, KASARGOD DISTRICT,, PIN - 671315
BY ADVS.
PHILIP T.VARGHESE
THOMAS T.VARGHESE
ACHU SUBHA ABRAHAM
V.T.LITHA
K.R.MONISHA
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
JIJO PAUL
C.J.JINCY
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 25.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RSA.590/2024 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
JUDGMENT
[RSA Nos.590/2024, 591/2024, 593/2024, 592/2024, 595/2024, 594/2024]
1)
These Appeals arise from the judgments and decrees of six
identical suits against the same defendant, which are tried
separately by the Trial Court. The Appeals arising from the said
suits were disposed of by a common judgment by the First
Appellate Court. Since the claims made by the plaintiff in these
suits are the same against the defendants, these Appeals are
also disposed of by a common judgment.
2)
The plaintiff in the suit is the appellant in these Appeals. All the
plaintiffs except the plaintiff in O.S.No.229/2019 were teachers
of Sree Narayana Nursery School/Lower Primary School,
Koovappally,
run
by
the
defendant.
The
plaintiff
in
O.S.No.229/2019 was a peon in the same school. The first
defendant is an educational Society established under the
Societies Registration Act of 1860. It founded the aforesaid
school in the year 1991. The school was stopped for want of
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
recognition on 31.03.2018. On account of the same, the plaintiff
in all the suits lost their employment. Hence, the plaintiff in all
the suits claimed Rs.10 lakhs with future interest at the rate of
10% p.a. from the date of the suit till realisation as
compensation, including future salary, terminal benefits, and
damages for mental agony.
3)
The defendant admitted that the plaintiffs had been working with
the school till the date of closure on 31.03.2018. But the
defendant disputed the claim contending that the plaintiffs
worked in the school for the salary offered by the defendant
without any objection and they received salary up to the date of
closure that the defendants was compelled to close the school
for want of recognition. The plaintiffs were willing to work in the
school at the offered salary and their decision was voluntary and
not on the basis of any coercion. The defendant has not been
paying any benefit like Provident Fund, gratuity, family benefit,
bonus, incentives, or festival allowance to the plaintiffs or other
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
teaching staff. The plaintiffs have no right to claim any damages
due to loss of employment. They are not entitled to any
compensation as no mental agony was suffered by them
because of the defendant’s act or omission.
4)
The Trial Court dismissed all the suits without costs finding that
the suits are not maintainable and that the plaintiffs are not
entitled for any compensation or money as claimed in the plaint.
5)
Though the plaintiffs filed Appeals before the First Appellate
Court the same was dismissed confirming the judgments and
decrees passed by the Trial Court.
6)
The present Appeals are filed by the plaintiffs challenging the
judgments and decrees passed by the Trial Court which are
confirmed by the First Appellate Court and praying for decreeing
the suit as prayed for.
7)
I heard the learned counsel for the appellants Sri. Suresh Kumar
Kodoth and the learned counsel for the respondent/defendant
Smt. K.R. Monisha.
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
8)
The learned counsel for the appellant contended that the
plaintiffs are entitled to maintain the suit in view of the decision
of this Court in Toji Joseph v. State of Kerala [2009 (3) KLT
SN 2] in which it is held that teachers in unaided school can
seek compensation for wrongful termination in a competent civil
court. The five out of the six plaintiffs were teachers, and the
other plaintiff was a peon in the school. All of them had worked
more than 20 years in the school for a paltry sum offered as
salary. As on the date of closure, the salary was only Rs.3,580/and Rs.3,305/-. The defendant had been exploiting the plaintiffs
for its undue enrichment. The plaintiffs continued to work in the
school on the promise of the defendant that they would be
confirmed in the school as permanent staff when the school gets
recognition. The school did not get recognition on account of the
willful negligence and omission on the part of the defendant.
The Trial Court, as well as the First Appellate Court, failed to
appreciate the pleadings and evidence in the suits from the right
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
perspective, applying the correct law. The learned counsel cited
the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Punjab
and Ors. v. Jagjit Singh & Ors. [(2017) 1 SCC 148] which
highly deprecated the exploitative employment practices and
the decision of this Court in Joseph Didakose K.G. v. Cochin
Port Trust and Anr. [2017 3 KLJ 509] following the said
decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court. In the said decisions, it
is held that any act of paying less wages, as compared to others
similarly situate, constitute an act of exploitative enslavement
emerging out of a domineering position and that undoubtedly
the said action is oppressive, suppressive and coercive as it
compels involuntary subjugation.
9)
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent
contended that the judgments and decrees passed by the Trial
Court and the First Appellate Court are perfectly valid and
legally well founded. It answered all the contentions raised by
the appellants. The appellants could not prove any legal right
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
to claim compensation from the respondent. The defendant has
paid all the dues to the plaintiff till the date of closure of the
school. No substantial question of law is involved in the matter.
10) I have considered the rival contentions.
11) Admittedly, the defendant established the school in question in
the year 1991 and the defendant was compelled to close the
school on 31.03.2018 for want of recognition. Admittedly, the
plaintiffs had been working as staff of the school for a
considerably long length of time up to the date of closure on
31.03.2018. It is in evidence that they were paid only a meager
sum as monthly salary. Some of them were paid Rs.3,518/- and
others were paid Rs.3,305/-. The suit is filed relying on the
decision of this Court in Toji Joseph (supra). In the said
decision this Court held that teachers in an unaided school can
seek compensation for wrongful termination in a competent civil
court. Here, the plaintiffs are not terminated from service. They
lost their employment on account of the closure of the school.
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
They continued to work in the school for a long period without
raising any objection, fully knowing that the school did not have
any kind of recognition. In view of these facts, I am of the view
that the aforesaid decision in Toji Joseph (supra) is not
applicable to the facts and circumstances of the case. The Trial
Court correctly appreciated and understood the said decision.
The plaintiffs joined the service of the defendant in its school at
the salary offered by the defendant. They have no case that the
salary offered by the defendant is not paid. True, they were paid
only a paltry sum as salary and the defendant availed their
service by way of exploitation. But the fact remains that the
plaintiffs could have quit from service and opted for better
employment. That was not done by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs
do not have a case that the defendant compelled or coerced
them to continue their service in the school. The plaintiffs do not
have a case that the defendant in any way prevented the plaintiff
from joining better employment. In view of these facts, the
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
aforesaid decisions cited by the learned counsel for the
appellant are not applicable to the present case.
12) Even though, it is contended that the defendant promised to
confirm them in permanent posts after getting recognition, no
such promise is proved. As a matter of fact, the school did not
get recognition to claim permanent employment. The fact is that
the plaintiffs continued their service expecting permanent
employment after getting recognition for the school. In spite of
working of the school for a long period, the school could not
secure necessary recognition. The plaintiffs alleged that it is on
account of the clear willful negligence and omission on the part
of the defendant the school could not obtain necessary
recognition. The evidence in this regard is quite lacking in this
case. It is in evidence that the defendant submitted the
application before the authorities. It may be true that the school
could not obtain recognition on account of the inaction of the
defendant to take timely action for the same. Even the reason
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
for not getting recognition is not disclosed either in the pleadings
or in the evidence. The specific case of the defendant is that the
school could not get recognition as it could not comply with the
norms prescribed by the government. The plaintiffs could not
prove that it is on account of the willful negligence on the part of
the defendant the school could not comply with the norms
prescribed by the government. In the absence of these
evidences, the plaintiffs cannot claim compensation from the
defendant. The plaintiffs continued their employment in the
school without raising any objection fully knowing that the
school was not having any recognition. It is seen that the fees
from the students was the only source of income to the school.
There was no agreement between the plaintiffs and the
defendant with respect to the salary and other benefits. The
appellant could not point out any statutory provision on the basis
of it they are entitled to claim against the defendant. Any
violation of obligation on the part of the defendant is pleaded or
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
proved. The pleading and evidence would reveal that the
school, which was illegally conducted by the defendant, was
closed on 31.03.2018. The plaintiffs are not entitled to get salary
for the period subsequent to the closure of the school.
13) The plaint claim includes loss of salary for fifteen months from
31.03.2018. Another claim is loss of employment for a period of
ten years. Under this head, each plaintiff is claiming Rs.7 lakhs.
Admittedly, the plaintiffs did not work in the school after
31.03.2018. In fact, the school was not available for providing
work to the plaintiffs. Hence, the plaintiff is not entitled to get any
amount under these heads. The next claim is that of Provident
Fund and gratuity. Since the school had only 9 employees, the
Employees Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provision Act,
1952, and Payment of Gratuity Act,1972 are not applicable to
the school. Of course, an establishment can opt for registration.
Admittedly, the school had not opted for registration, and no
amount is collected from the plaintiffs towards the Provident
RSA Nos.590 of 2024 and con.cases
2025:KER:27340
Fund. The basis for claiming festival allowance is not disclosed.
The next claim is Rs.1 lakh compensation for mental agony
including medical expenses. As rightly held by the Trial Court
and the First Appellate Court that it is a special damage and
does not come within the scope of general damages. Special
damages have to be specifically pleaded and proved. There is
no pleading or proof with respect to the same.
14) In view of the aforesaid discussion, there is no error or illegality
in the judgments and decrees passed by the Trial Court and the
First Appellate Court. No substantial question of law is involved
in this matter. Accordingly, these Regular Second Appeals are
dismissed.
Sd/M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
jma
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review