Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 2nd OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 836 of 2021
BETWEEN:LAKSHMANSINGH S/O DULESINGH RAJPUT, AGED ABOUT 61
1. YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE AND AGRICULTURIST VILLGADHKHAJURIA, TEH. SONKACHH (MADHYA PRADESH)
DIPENDRASINGH S/O LAKSHMANSINGH RAJPUT, AGED ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURE
VILLAGE
2.
DADHKHAJURIA, TEH.
SONKACHH AND
DIST.DEWAS
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI AKASH RATHI, ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THR.
COLLECTOR OFFICE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SUB
DIVISIONAL
OFFICER
REVENUE
DEPARTMENT
SONKACHH. DIST. DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
TEHSILDAR
PRADESH)
4.
PATWARI. VILLAGE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
TEH.
SONKACHH.
DIST.
GADHKHAJURIA,
COLLECTOR
DEWAS
TEH.
(MADHYA
SONKACHH.
NARBETSINGH S/O BAJESINGH GAARI, AGED ABOUT 36
5. YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURE
VILLAGE
GADHKHAJURIA, TEH. SONKACHH. (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(RESPONDENTS NO.1 TO 4 / STATE BY SHRI PRADYUMNA KIBE,
PANEL LAWYER)
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
-2(RESPONDENT NO.5 BY SHRI SUNIL JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE
ASSISTED BY SHRI KUNJAN MITTAL, ADVOCATE)
This appeal coming on for admission this day, the court
passed the following:
ORDER
The appellants/plaintiffs have filed this Second Appeal
under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 against
the judgment and decree dated 19.12.2015 passed by the Civil
Judge, Class – II, Sonkachh, District – Dewas in Civil Suit No.31A/2010 dismissing the suit for declaration of title and permanent
injunction and also against the judgment dated 19.03.2021 passed
by the II Additional District Judge, Sonkachh, District – Dewas,
whereby the Regular Civil Appeal No.10005/2016 has been
dismissed.
02.
Facts of the case in short are as under:-
2.1.
The plaintiffs filed a suit for declaration of title and
permanent injunction in respect of (i) the land bearing Surveys
No.654 area of 0.857 hectares, 685/1 (new number 702) area of
1.09 hectares and 703 area of 0.30 hectares purchased by the
plaintiff No.1 vide registered sale deed dated 01.03.2002 from
Kalu S/o Amraji and (ii) the land bearing Surveys No.655 & 685
after settlement of Survey No.704 area 1.370 hectare purchased by
plaintiff No.2 vide registered sale deed dated 02.01.1986 from
Ganga Bai Widow of Kesha. According to the plaintiffs, these two
lands were initially recorded in the name of Amraji S/o Gulab and
Deva S/o Kishan (minor) as Mauruusii Krishak and after the
abolition of Zamindari System, they being a Mauruusii Krishak
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
-3-
became Bhumiswami of the land. After the death of Amraji, the
name of his son was mutated as Bhumiswami in the year 1977 –
78 and after the death of Deva, the name of Ganga Bai Widow of
Kesha was mutated as owner from 1977 – 78. In between, the
word minor was removed. This land continued in the name of
Kalu and Ganga Bai from Sanvata – 2028 to 2031 and thereafter,
they were in need of money, therefore, sold the land to the
plaintiffs vide registered sale deed as stated above.
2.2.
According to the plaintiffs, respondent No.5 wrongly
submitted an application on 26.03.2007 before defendant No.1
that vide order dated 14.04.2006, he has been appointed as Pujari
by Gram Panchayat – Gadhkhajuria but the plaintiffs got mutated
their names on the basis of sale deed which is liable to be
cancelled. The said application was sent to Tehsildar, Sonkachh
and thereafter, the Collector vide order dated 08.09.2008 directed
the parties to file a civil suit for cancellation of the sale deed.
However, in compliance of the order of the Sub Divisional
Officer, the land has been recorded in the name of Dev Dharmraj
Mandir through the Collector. Against the said order, the plaintiffs
preferred an appeal before the Collector and the same is pending.
2.3.
After notice in the suit, the defendants filed a written
statement by submitting that in the year 1918, the suit land was
recorded in the name of Dev Dharmraj Mandir through Pujari and
by way of the collusion with the Pujari and revenue authorities,
the records were changed.
2.4.
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
On the basis of pleadings, the trial Court framed four
-4-
issues for adjudication which are as under:Øa-
Okkn fo"k;
D;k oknh Øekad&1 us xzke x<+[ktqfj;k dh Hkwfe losZ uacj vkaf'kd izekf.kr
654 ,oa 685 @1 ftudk cUnkscLr losZ uacj 702 jdck
10-09 gSDVs;j rFkk 703 jdck 0-30 gSDVs;j dh Hkwfe dks
jftLVMZ foØ; i= ds ek/;e ls Ø; dj ml ij dkfct
gS\
D;k oknh Øekad&2 xzke x<+[ktqfj;k dh Hkwfe losZ uacj vkaf'kd izekf.kr
655 o 685 cUnkscLr ds ckn losZ uacj 704 jdck 1-370
gSDVs;j dks foØl; i= ds ek/;e ls d`f"k djds ml ij
dkfct gS\
D;k oknhx.k mDr fookfnr Hkwfe ds laca/k esa izfroknhx.k ls iSjk Øekad 21 ds vuqlkj
bl vk'k; dh LFkk;h fu"ks/kkKk ikus ds vf/kdkjh gS fd os
oknhx.k ds 'kkafriw.kZ vkf/kiR; esa u rks Lo;a gLr{ksi djs
vksj u gh fdlh vU; ls gLr{ksi djok;s\
lgk;rk ,oa O;; \
2.5.
fu"d"kZ
iSjk Øekad 22 ds vuqlkj
Both the plaintiffs were examined as P.Ws-1 & 2. The
plaintiffs examined three more witnesses namely Chandar Singh
(P.W-3), Narendra Kumar (P.W-4) and Kamal Kishore (P.W-5).
Defendants No.1 to 4 examined Dinesh Ojha, Assistant, Grade – II
Record Keeper as D.W-4 and Pankaj Pal, SDO. Defendant No.5
examined himself as D.W-1, Atmaram (D.W-2) and Bheem Singh
(D.W-3).
2.6.
After appreciating the evidence that came on record, the
learned Civil Judge found issues No.1 & 2 partially proved in
favoyr of plaintiffs . In respect of issue No.1, it has been found
that the plaintiffs are in possession hence
not liable to be
dispossessed without following due process of law and
accordingly, passed the judgment and decree dated 19.12.2015.
2.7.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree,
the plaintiffs preferred a first appeal before the District Judge
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
-5-
which came to be dismissed vide judgment dated 19.03.2021.
Both the Courts below have held that the plaintiffs have failed to
prove the title of their predecessor by oral as well as documentary
evidence, therefore, the title of the plaintiffs cannot be recognized.
Hence, this second appeal is before this Court.
03.
Shri Rathi, learned counsel for the appellants / plaintiffs
submits that only on the basis of singular revenue entry of the year
1918 in the name of Bhumidev Dharmraj Mandir, learned Civil
Court as well as appellate Court both have dismissed the suit,
whereas the plaintiffs are having registered sale deed duly
executed by Kalu and Ganga Bai. Kalu & Ganga Bai succeeded
the land from Amra and Deva who were the Mauruusii Krishak
and their names were recorded in the Khasra Panchshala of 1951
which is liable to be believed by virtue of Section 117 of Madhya
Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959. Names of Kalu and Ganga
Bai were also recorded as Bhumiswami in records from Sanvata
2028 to 2031 which is not liable to be disbelieved. It is further
submitted that in the list of temples published by the State
Government (Ex-P/20), there are only two temples in Village –
Gadhkhajuria i.e. Shri Ram Mandir, Bazar Chowk and Shri Ram
Mandir, Sonar Mohalla. There is no such entry in the name of
Dev Dharamraj Mandir which has been admitted by the
defendants' witnesses. Even if the temple was there in the year
1918 but by the passage of time it fell into disrepair and the suit
land was again allotted to the Mauruusii Krishak for cultivation.
Therefore, the appeal is liable to be admitted on the following
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
-6-
substantial question of law:(a) Whether learned Courts below erred in holding that the
suit property is Temple Land as per revenue record of single
year 1912 – 13 while ignoring the consistence record from
1950 in favour of the Plaintiff and applying this legal
principle discriminately against the Plaintiffs and in
favour of the Defendants ?
(b) Whether learned Courts below have grossly erred in
drawing adverse inference against the Appellants while
ignoring the legal provision of Section 117 of the MP Land
Revenue Code which says that all the entries made in the
land records shall be presumed to be correct until proven
otherwise ?
(c) Whether the action of the Respondent in directly
removing name of Plaintiffs from revenue records and
declaring the Suit property as Government Land is legal
valid in light if the finding that lower Appellate Court in
Para No.68 of its judgment ?
(d) Whether title of the Plaintiffs is good in the face of
undisputed registered sale deeds and past revenue
records ?
(e) Whether the State is bound by the law of estoppel as
representation by the State in the form of revenue record
was acted upon by the Plaintiffs while purchasing the suit
property ?
(f) Whether legal principle that title cannot be inferred
from revenue records can be made applicable in the present
case ?
(g) Whether the judgments and decrees passed by the
learned Courts below are against the evidence on record
and hence perverse.
(h) Other substantial question of Law arising in the case
which this Hon'ble Court deems fit to frame ?
Appreciations & Conclusion
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
-7-
04.
On the basis of the deposition of the witnesses of the
Revenue Department and as admitted by the plaintiffs, the land
was initially recorded in the name of Dev Dharamraj Mandir (ExD/2). According to the plaintiffs, initially, this land was recorded
in the name of Amraji and Devaji (minor) in the year 1950 – 51,
B-1, Kishtbandi Khatauni and Khasra and after the abolition of
the Gwalior State, they became the owner of the land as they were
Mauruusii Krishak and after the death of Amra and Deva,
successor of Kalu and Ganga Bai became the owner. However, the
plaintiffs have not filed any document or evidence to show that
Kala and Ganga Bai were the only successors of Amra and Deva.
The plaintiffs have not produced any oral or documentary
evidence to show that on what basis names of Kalu and Ganga
Bai were recorded in the revenue records. Unless titles of Kala
and Ganga and thereafter title of Kala and Ganga Bai are duly
established, the Civil Court as well as learned appellate Court
have rightly held that they had no right to sell the suit land. Even
no document has been filed to show that Amra and Deva and
thereafter, Kalu and Ganga Bai paid the land revenues after
becoming the Bhumiswami. Being a Mouroshi Krushak they were
liable to deposit the land revenue .
05.
It is a settled law that revenue entry does not confer any
right, therefore, in order to establish the title, the plaintiffs were
required to establish the title of Amra, Deva, Kalu and Ganga Bai.
So far as the title of Government is concerned, by virtue of
Section 54 of the M.P. Land Revenue Code, 1959, the
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
-8-
Government is the owner of all the land in the State of Madhya
Pradesh.
06.
So far as the list of temples is concerned, D.W-5 in his
evidence has admitted that there are other temples in the village
whereof names are not mentioned in the list, therefore, this list
which is published by the Government, is not an exhaustive list
that all the temples on the Government land, for which Collector
is the Manager are recorded therein. Before filing a suit, the
revenue authorities examined the revenue record and did not find
any valid entry to establish the title of Amra, Deva, thereafter
Kalu and Ganga Bai. As per the original revenue record produced
by the defendants' witness, in the year 1912 – 13, this suit land
was recorded in the name of Dev Dharamraj Mandir, Wakedehaja
Ehtamam Pujari Bawal Pujari Vald Dayaram as Kastkar.
Therefore, how this land in the years 1950 – 51 came in the name
of Amra and Deva has not been established by the plaintiffs. No
order has been produced by which the name of the temple was
removed and the names of Amra and Deva were recorded.
07.
The plaintiffs claimed that there is no temple on the suit
land. Defendant No.5 tried to confront him with the photograph of
the temple but
P.W-1 refused to see the photograph and the
objection taken by his counsel was upheld by the learned Civil
Court. P.W.- 1 admits that an idol of Bheruji is there in the temple.
Learned Civil Judge as well as First Appellate Court after
examination concurrently decreed the suit as well as first appeal,
therefore, I do not find any question of law involved in this
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
-9-
appeal.
08.
Even otherwise, the Apex Court in the case of Kondiba
Dagadu Kadam v/s Savitribai Sopan Gujar reported in (1999) 3
SCC 722 has held as under:
“5. It is not within the domain of the High Court to
investigate the grounds on which the findings were
arrived at, by the last court of fact, being the first
appellate court. It is true that the lower appellate court
should not ordinarily reject witnesses accepted by the
trial court in respect of credibility but even where it has
rejected the witnesses accepted by the trial court, the
same is no ground for interference in second appeal when
it is found that the appellate court has given satisfactory
reasons for doing so. In a case where from a given set of
circumstances two inferences are possible, one drawn by
the lower appellate court is binding on the High Court in
second appeal. Adopting any other approach is not
permissible. The High Court cannot substitute its opinion
for the opinion of the first appellate court unless it is
found that the conclusions drawn by the lower appellate
court were erroneous being contrary to the mandatory
provisions of law applicable or its settled position on the
basis of pronouncements made by the Apex Court, or was
based upon inadmissible evidence or arrived at without
evidence.
7. If the question of law termed as a substantial question stands already decided by a larger Bench of the High
Court concerned or by the Privy Council or by the
Federal Court or by the Supreme Court, its merely wrong
application on the facts of the case would not be termed
to be a substantial question of law. Where a point of law
has not been pleaded or is found to be arising between
the parties in the absence of any factual format, a litigant
should not be allowed to raise that question as a
substantial question of law in second appeal. The mere
appreciation of the facts, the documentary evidence or
the meaning of entries and the contents of the document
cannot be held to be raising a substantial question of law.
But where it is found that the first appellate court has
assumed jurisdiction which did not vest in it, the same
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
-10-
can be adjudicated in the second appeal, treating it as a
substantial question of law. Where the first appellate
court is shown to have exercised its discretion in a
judicial manner, it cannot be termed to be an error either
of law or of procedure requiring interference in second
appeal. This Court in Reserve Bank of India v.
Ramkrishna Govind Morey [AIR 1976 SC 830]held that
whether the trial court should not have exercised its
jurisdiction differently is not a question of law justifying
interference.
09.
In case of Laxmidevamma v/s Ranganath reported in
(2015) 4 SCC 264 again the Apex court has held as under:“16. Based on oral and documentary evidence, both the
courts below have recorded concurrent findings of fact
that the plaintiffs have established their right in A
schedule property. In the light of the concurrent findings
of fact, no substantial questions of law arose in the High
Court and there was no substantial ground for
reappreciation of evidence. While so, the High Court
proceeded to observe that the first plaintiff has earmarked
the A schedule property for road and that she could not
have fullfledged right and on that premise proceeded to
hold that declaration to the plaintiffs’ right cannot be
granted. In exercise of jurisdiction under Section 100
CPC, concurrent findings of fact cannot be upset by the
High Court unless the findings so recorded are shown to
be perverse. In our considered view, the High Court did
not keep in view that the concurrent findings recorded by
the courts below, are based on oral and documentary
evidence and the judgment of the High Court cannot be
sustained.”
10.
Recently, the Apex Court in case of Adiveppa & Others
v/s Bhimappa & Others reported in (2017) 9 SCC 586 has held as
under:
"17. Here is a case where two Courts below, on
appreciating the entire evidence, have come to a
conclusion that the Plaintiffs failed to prove their case in
relation to both the suit properties. The concurrent
findings of facts recorded by the two Courts, which do
not involve any question of law much less substantial
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
-11-
question of law, are binding on this Court.
18. It is more so when these findings are neither against
the pleadings nor against the evidence and nor contrary to
any provision of law. They are also not perverse to the
extent that no such findings could ever be recorded by
any judicial person. In other words, unless the findings of
facts, though concurrent, are found to be extremely
perverse so as to affect the judicial conscious of a judge,
they would be binding on the Appellate Court."
11.
In view of the above, the Second Appeal stands dismissed.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Ravi
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/9/2024
5:27:24 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review