Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
CHONGNUNK Digitally
CHONGNUNKIM GANGTE
2023.03.14 13:46:28
IM GANGTE Date:
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 810 of 2022
Shri Laishram Radhakishore Singh, aged about 65 years,
S/o (Late) L. Nityai Singh, a resident of Keinou Thongkha
MakhaLeikai, P.ONambol P.S Bishnupur, Bishnupur
District, Manipur.
....Petitioner
-Versus1. The State of Manipur, represented by the Additional
Chief Secretary (Forest and Environment), Govt. of
Manipur, Old Secretariat (South Block) Babubapara, P.O
& P.S Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
2. The Manipur Pollution Control Board, represented by its
Member Secretary, MPCB, having its office at Lamphel,
DC Complex, P.O&P.S, Lamphel, Imphal West District,
Manipur – 795004.
………Official Respondents
3. Shri Usham Deben Singh, aged about 53 years old, S/o
Late Usham Pukchao Singh, a resident of Keirak
Kangjeibung
Mamang
P.O&P.S,
Kakching
District,
Manipur – 795103.
………..Private Respondent
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 1
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioner ::
Mr. N. Jotendro, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Murtaza Ahmed, Advocate
For the Respondents::
Mr. M. Devananda, Addl. AG
Ms. Jyotsana, Advocate
Mr. H. S Paonam, Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. Gunabanta, Advocate
Date of hearing
::
21-02-2023
Date of judgment ::
14.03.2023
JUDGMENT
(C A V)
Heard Mr. N. Jotendro, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. Murtaza Ahmed, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner, Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. AG assisted by
Ms. Jyotsana, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
No. 1 & 2 and Mr. H. S Paonam, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. S. Gunabanta, learned counsel appearing for
the respondent No. 3.
[2]
The present writ petition had been filed challenging
two orders both dated 20.09.2022, one order terminating the
service of the petitioner as Chairman of Manipur Pollution
Control Board and the other appointing the respondent No. 3 as
Chairman of the Manipur Pollution Control Board (MPCB).
[3]
The brief facts of the case is that by an order dated
24.03.2017 issued by the Chief Secretary (For. & Envt),
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 2
Government of Manipur, the petitioner was appointed as
Chairman of Manipur Pollution Control Board with immediate
effect and until further orders. The term of the office of the
Chairman of MPCB as provided under Section 5 (1) of the
Water (Prevention and Control
of Pollution) Act, 1974
(hereinafter referred to as “the said Act” for short) is of three
years from the date of nomination. During the term of his office
as the Chairman of MPCB, the petitioner issued various orders
dated 3.5.2018, 8.6.2018, 18.6.2018, 1.8.2018, 3.8.2018,
23.8.2018, 7.9.2018, 14.9.2018 and 29.10.2018 appointing as
many as 118 (one hundred and eighteen) persons on contract
basis in the following different capacities carrying the pay scale
noted against the post:-
Sl.
No.
Designation
1.
Assistant Environmental
Engineer
2.
Assistant Law Officer
Pay Scale
Rs.9300 + 4400
(GP)
Rs.9300 + 4400
(GP),
3.
Jr. Environmental Engineer,
Rs. 9300 + 4200
Assistant Programmer, Assistant
(GP),
I.T Officer, Assistant
Programmer and Junior Law
Officer
4.
Environmental Scientist, Field
Rs. 5200 + 2800
Inspector, Sr. Scientific
(GP),
Assistant, Computer Operator,
Data Collector and Smoke
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 3
Emission Tester
5.
6.
Sample Collector, Laboratory
Rs. 5200 + 2400
Assistant and Store Keeper
(GP),
Account Assistant, Assistant
Rs. 5200 + 1900
Field Inspector, LDC, Driver,
(GP),
Legal Assistant and
Photographer
7.
[4]
Grade – IV and Laboratory
Rs. 4440 + 1300
Attendant
(GP).
During the tenure of the service of the petitioner as
the Chairman of MPCB, the State Government issued a rule
called ‘Appointment of Chairman of Manipur Pollution Control
Board (MPCB), 2021’ (hereinafter referred to as “the said Rule”
for short). Subsequent to the framing of the said Rule, the State
Government issued an order dated 30-07-2021 re-constituting
the MPCB consisting of 11 (eleven) members including the
petitioner as the Chairman of the said reconstituted board. It is
the case of the petitioner that before completion of the tenure of
his service of three years as provided under Section 5 (1) of the
said Act and Rule 2 (iii) (b) of the said Rule, the State
Government issued an order dated 14-07-2022 appointing the
respondent No. 3 as the Chairman of MPCB with immediate
effect and until further orders.
[5]
Having being aggrieved, the petitioner assailed the
appointment of the respondent No. 3 by filing WP(C) No. 562 of
2022 before this Court. The said writ petition was disposed of by
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 4
a Judgment and Order dated 11-08-2022 passed by this Court
in WP(C) No. 562 of 2022 by quashing the impugned order
dated 14-07-2022 and by giving liberty to the State Government
to re-consider the case of the petitioner by following due
procedure of law. The operative portion of the said Judgment
and Order reads as under :“20. Principles of natural justice are those rules which
have been laid down by the Courts as being the minimum
protection of the rights of the individuals against the arbitrary
procedure that may be adopted by a judicial, quasi-judicial
and administrative authority while making an order affecting
those rights. These rules are intended to prevent such
authority from doing injustice. The purpose of following the
principles of natural justice is the prevention of miscarriage of
justice.
21. From the discussion aforesaid, it is apparent that
the order impugned of removal of the petitioner, irrespective
of the fact whether it is an order under Section 5 or under
Section 6 of the Act is not sustainable having been passed in
contravention of the mandatory requirement of Sub-section
(3) of Section 5 or Sub-section (2) of Section 6 of the Act.
The order impugned, thus is liable to be quashed.
22. In view of the detailed discussions,
(a) this writ petition is allowed and the
impugned order dated 14-07-2022 is hereby quashed, in the
light of the above observations.
(b) the State Government is at liberty
to
reconsider the case of the petitioner, if they are so advised,
by following the due procedure of law contemplated under
Section 5(3)or under Section 6 (2) of the Act.
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 5
(c) there will be no order as to costs.”
[6]
After the disposal of the aforesaid writ petition, the
authorities of the State Government issued a Memorandum
dated 09-09-2022 wherein, allegations have been made against
the petitioner that he made appointment against 107 posts in
the MPCB without obtaining prior approval of the Government
and without following due procedure for public employment and
directing the petitioner to submit a written explanation as to why
disciplinary action including civil and penal liabilities should not
be taken against him. In response to the said Memorandum, the
petitioner submitted a detailed written explanation dated 16-092022 to the Additional Chief Secretary (For. & Envt and CC),
Government of Manipur. In the said written explanation, the
petitioner did not deny the allegation that he appointed 107
incumbents in the MPCB without obtaining prior approval of the
Government and without following due procedure for public
employment. However, the petitioner took the stand, inter alia,
that the board has absolute and unfettered power to create
posts and make recruitment without seeking approval of the
Government if financial burdens are taken by the board.
[7]
After
examining
and
considering
the
written
explanation given by the petitioner, the authorities of the State
Government issued an order dated 20-09-2022 thereby
terminating the service of the petitioner as Chairman of MPCB
with immediate effect and declaring that the post of Chairman,
MPCB shall be deemed to be vacant with effect from the date of
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 6
issuance of the said order. On the same date, i.e., on 20-092022, the State Government issued another order appointing
the respondent No. 3 as the Chairman of MPCB with immediate
effect and until further orders. Having being aggrieved by the
issuance of the said two orders, the petitioner approached this
Court again by filing the present writ petition praying for
quashing and setting aside the two orders both dated 20-092022.
[8]
Mr. N. Jotendro, learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner submitted that the tenure of service of the
petitioner as Chairman of MPCB is of three years with effect
from the date of appointment, i.e., 30-07-2021 as provided
under Section 5 (1) of the said Act and Rule 2 (iii) (b) of the said
Rule and accordingly, the State Government cannot terminate
the service of the petitioner before completion of the tenure of
his service.It has also been submitted by Mr. N. Jotendro,
learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner that the
issue as to whether the service of the Chairman of MPCB can
be terminated or not before completion of the tenure of service
has already been decided by the Gauhati High Court in the case
of “Chandam Manihar Singh Vs. State of Manipur &Ors”
reported in 1999 Legal Eagle (GAU) 434. The relevant portion
of the judgment is reproduced herein below:“4.) The petitioner was appointed as Chairman of the Board
under Order No. 117 2/88-STE(Pt) dated 16.10.96 on honorary
capacity until further orders. Again under Order No. ll/2/88-STE(Pt)
dated 28th October, 1997, in suppression of the previews order,
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 7
another order was issued appointing him as Chairman of the Board
on contract basis for a period of 3 years with effect from the date of
his initial appointment which was made on honorary capacity.
Thereafter victie notification dated 18.1.98 the petitioner was
removed from the Chairmanship of the Board. This notification was
challenged by him by filing a writ petition being C.R. No. 91 of 1998
and under order dated 10.2.98 this Court suspended the order of
removal of the petitioner and ultimately the order of removal of the
petitioner/reconstitution of the Board was quashed by this court's
order dated 11.8.98. Again, under Memorandum dated 14.9.98 the
respondent issued a notice under Section 5(3), read with Section
6(2) of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974
(hereinafter referred to as 'the Act) to show cause why he should not
be removed from the Chairmanship of the Board, copy of this notice
is enclosed as Annexure-7 to the writ petition which was corrected
under Corrigendum dated 19.9.98 (Annexure-A/9).
18.) In our present case, as noted above, a composite notice
Under Section 5(3) and Section 6(2) of the Act was given under Office
Memorandum dated 14.9.98 (Annexure-A/7). Regarding the point as
to whether the posts to which so called appointments were made
were non-existent at the time of making the appointments or not, as
seen from the letter dated 28th October, 1998 from the MembarSecretary of the Board addressed to the Principal-Secretary, Forest
and Environment, Government of Manipur, it is found in Annexure-G/7
of the counter of the State- respondents that all the four posts i.e. the
posts of Environmental Engineer, Assistant Environmental Engineer,
Senior Scientific Officer and the Administrative Officer which are
mentioned in Annexures-A, B, C, D of the show cause notice
(Annexure-A/7) were created on 6.9.97,2.1.90,17.9.97 and 10.4.97
respectively with the approval/sanction of the Government and the incharge arrangement against these posts were made on 17.2.97 and
14.2.97. The copies of these orders are found at Annexures-A/7(1), A-
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 8
7(2), A-7(3) and A- 7(4) to rejoinder affidavit of the petitioner. Again
the aforesaid in-charge arrangement was even regularised on 16.9.97
and 14.2.97 on the recommendation of a regular D.P.C. The said
orders of regularisation/appointment are found at Annexures-A/17(1),
A-17(2), A-17)3) and A-17(4) to the rejoinder affidavit of the petitioner.
Thus, it is clear that these posts ware in existence as created with the
approval/ sanction of the Government before appointments were
made, whether by way of in-charge arrangement or by regular
appointment.
(19.) Regarding the point as to whether the Chairman
himself made the appointment orders thereby violating the provisions
of Rule 24(7) of the Rules, learned Advocate General submitted that
the employees being the employees of the Board, chey are to be
appointed by the Board in accordance with the provisions of the Rules
ie. Rule 24(7) of the Rules. Thus, according to learned Advocate
General the so called appointment orders are not in accordance with
the provisions of law. Rule 24(7) of the Rules prescribes that all
orders or instructions to be issued by the Board shall bear signature of
the Member-Secretary or of any other officer authorised in this behalf
by the Chairman. (20.) On this point Mr Y. Imo Singh and also Mr.
N.P.C. Singh submitted regarding the scheme of the Rule, more
particularly the provisions of Rule 22(3) of the Rules wherein it is
prescribed that subject to Rules as may be made under sub-section
(3) of Section 12 of the Act, the Chairman shall have full powers in
matter of promotion, confirmation, transfer and termination of service
of the officers and employees of the Board; and the Rule 22(6) of the
Rules wherein it is prescribed that the Chairman shall exercise all
such powers as are delegated to the Head of Administrative
Department of the State Government in case when powers are not
specifically delegated, the sanction of the Government shall be
required. And the learned counsel submitted that the Chairman who
himself has the powers to authorise others to sign all orders of the
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 9
Board may himself sign any order of the Board. Thus, the learned
counsel submitted that mere signing of the appointment orders by the
Chairman would not amount to violating the provisions of the Rules
and the learned counsel also submitted that this practice of signing all
such orders by the Chairman himself had been regularly followed.
Again the learned counsel also drawn my attention to Annexure- A/13
being/copies of appointment orders issued by the Meghalaya and
Kerala State Pollution Control Boards in which the Chairman of the
respective Boards signed the appointment orders. I find force in the
submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that mere signing
of the appointment orders by the Chairman himself, in the light of the
submission/discussion as made above,
appointment
may not
orders
render the
invalid.
(21.) On the point of prior sanction of the State Government for
appointment to the posts in the scale, Rule 23 of the Rules provides
that the Board may create such posts as it considers necessary.
Again, it is also provided that in respect of creation of and
appointments to posts in the scale the maximum of which is above
Rs.3,300/- per month, the Board shall obtain prior sanction of the
State Government. In this regard drawing the attention of the Court to
Annexure-G/7 as mentioned above, the learned Advocate General
submitted that the Member- Secretary of the Board wrote that prior
approval of the Government for issue of the appointment orders were
not obtained, learned Advocate General thus, submitted that it is a
gross violation of the provisions of Rule 23 of the Rules.
(22.) The learned counsel for the petitioner Mr.N.P.C. Singh in
this regard submitted firstly that in the present case the action of the
Government for removal of the Chairman is based upon the notice
contained in Annexure- A/7 to the writ petition and in the aforesaid
notice the appointments at Annexures-A, B, C and D to the notice are
in respect of those so called in-charge arrangement before the
regularisation of the appointments. The learned counsel submitted
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 10
that in such a case the authority concerned cannot go beyond the
contents of the notice and as such question of prior approval of the
Government is not called for in respect of in-charge arrangement
which were made for efficient performance and function of the Board.
Secondly, the learned counsel submitted that the so called
appointments at Annexures-A, B, C, D to the notice were regularised
subsequently by a regular D.RC. in which the third member was none
other than the Commissioner of the concerned department i.e. Forest
and Environment who represented the Government. Further the
learned counsel submitted that these appointment orders become
necessary for efficient performance of the function of the Board and
there has been a direction from the Central Pollution Control Board
and also the Central Government.
(29.) In this regard the statutory notice as noted above
mentions only two facts, namely. (1) the Chairman made
appointments against non-existent posts; (2) the Chairman signed
the appointment orders in violation of sub- rule(7) of Rule 24 of the
Rules. Nowhere it is mentioned in the notice that the Chairman
made any appointment without prior sanction of the Government.
When an action like the present one for removal from office of
Chairman of a State Board is taken up. the provisions contained in
the law has got to be strictly followed and complied with. If the point
regarding lack of prior sanction has not been included in the notice
then this fact cannot be used against the petitioner. It has already
been noted above that this action is a quasi judicial act in which the
principle of audialteramepartem which is an important limb of the
principles of natural justice has to be followed and if no allegation
has been mentioned in the notice/charge levelled against the
petitioner, no action can be taken on the basis of the material which
was not found in the notice.
(30) The posts were in existence as the same were created
with the approval/sanction of the Government before appointments
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 11
were made and on the point of signing by the Chairman by himself I
have already noted that the submission of the learned counsel for
the Petitioner that the Chairman may sign in such appointment
orders issued for appointment of employees of the Board is not
impermissible in view of the scheme of the Rules and Act as force.
(32) It appears that so far, the procedure prescribed for
nominating the Chairman of the Board has not been followed. The
Act even prescribes some qualifications for being the Chairman of
the Board and as such the appointment should be made to the
person and not by office. But in the State generally the practice is of
appointing the Minister in-charge as Chairman of the Board. This is
not contemplated by law. In fact, if the Chairman is to be changed
due to reshuffling of the Cabinet then it will be very difficult to
properly determine the remainder of the term in case of any
vacancy. Again, it appears that on every nomination of a new
Chairman or any other member of the entire Board is again
reconstituted.
This is also not
contemplated
by law. The
Government may look into the matter so that laws are complied with
properly. And considering the fact that it has become very difficult to
calculate the remainder of the term to be served by the newly
nominated member to fill a casual vacancy I am of the opinion that
the term of the Petitioner shall be counted from his initial
appointment i.e. 16.10.96. And he should be allowed to continue till
the completion of full term of 3 years. The decision cited by the
learned Advocate General is distinguishable from our present case
on point of the length of the remainder of the term of office.
(33) For the foregoing reasons and conclusion, the writ
petition is allowed. The order dated 19.10.98 removing the Petitioner
from being the Chairman of the Board is quashed. Consequently, it
is ordered that the Petitioner shall be reinstated as Chairman of the
Board forthwith with all the entitlements with effect from the date of
his removal and he should be allowed to continue to be the
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 12
Chairman of the Board till completion of full terms of 3 (three) years.
Under the facts and circumstances of the case there would be no
order as to costs.”
[9]
Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner
submitted that the earlier appointment of the respondent No. 3
as Chairman of the MPCB in place of the petitioner had already
been interfered with by this Court by quashing the impugned
order dated 14-07-2022 under the Judgment and Order dated
11-08-2022 passed in WP(C) No. 562 of 2022. Learned senior
counsel vehemently submitted that in view of the aforesaid
Judgment and Order dated 11-08-2022 passed by this Court,
the authorities cannot issue the impugned orders dated 20-092022.
[10]
It has also been submitted on behalf of the
petitioner that the petitioner appointed 107 (118) employees in
the MPCB as per the direction given by the National Green
Tribunal in its order dated 05-02-2021 passed in Original
Application No. 95 of 2018 and also in terms of the Convey
letter dated 26-02-2021 from the Secretariat, Forest and
Environment Department, Government of Manipur. Learned
senior counsel accordingly submitted that as the appointment of
the said 107 (118) employees had been made in terms of the
aforesaid order dated 05-02-2021 of the National Green
Tribunal and also in terms of the aforesaid Convey letter dated
26-02-2021, the petitioner did not commit any illegality in
carrying out the said appointments.
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 13
Mr. N. Jotendro, learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner also submitted that under the proviso to Rule
23 of the said Rule, no particular post is mentioned and that the
mandate of the proviso to Rule 23 is that for creation of and
appointment to the post in the pay scale, the maximum of which
is above Rs. 330 per month, the board is required to obtain prior
sanction of the State Government. The learned senior counsel
also submitted that the MPCB adopted all the Revision of Pay
Rules issued by the State Government from time to time and
that under ROP 1990 and ROP 1999, the scale of pay of Rs.
3300 had been increased to Rs. 9000 per month. Learned
senior counsel further submitted that since all the pay scales of
107 incumbents appointed by the petitioner are below Rs.
9000/- there is no requirement to obtain prior sanction of the
State Government before appointing the said 107 incumbents. It
has been accordingly submitted on behalf of the petitioner that
the ground on which the service of the petitioner had been
terminated is unsustainable and the impugned orders are liable
to be quashed and set aside.
[11]
Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. AG appearing for
the official respondents submitted that the earlier appointment of
the respondent No. 3 as Chairman of MPCB was made after
terminating the service of the petitioner and that the earlier
appointment of the respondent No. 3 was quashed by this Court
only on the ground that no notice was given to the petitioner
before issuance of the impugned order and the appointment of
the respondent No. 3 had been made in violation of the principle
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 14
of natural justice and the mandatory requirement of Section 5
(3) or Section 6 (2) of the said Rules. It has been submitted that
in para No. 22 of the Judgment and Order dated 11-08-2022
passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 562 of 2022, liberty was
given to the State Government to re-consider the case of the
petitioner by following due procedure of law contemplated under
Section 5 (3) or under Section 6 (2) of the aforesaid act.
Learned Addl. AG submitted that in view of the liberty given by
this Court, as mentioned herein above, the State Government
issued
a
Memorandum
dated
09-09-2022
directing
the
petitioner to submit a written explanation in his defense with
regard to the allegations of his appointing 107 incumbents in the
MPCB without obtaining prior approval of the Government and
without following the procedure for public employment. In
response to the said memorandum, the petitioner submitted his
written explanation and after due consideration, the State
Government issued the impugned orders dated 20-09-2022
terminating the service of the petitioner and thereafter,
appointing the respondent No. 3 as Chairman of MPCB.
Learned Addl. AG accordingly submitted that the arguments
advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
impugned orders have been issued in complete violation of the
judgment and order dated 18-08-2022 passed by this Court in
WP(C) No. 562 of 2022 is misconceived and baseless.
[12]
Mr.
M.
Devananda,
learned
Addl.
AG
also
submitted that the petitioner did not dispute the fact that he
appointed 107 (118) incumbents in the MPCB without following
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 15
due process of public employment and without obtaining prior
approval/sanction of the State Government as mandated under
Rule 23 of the said Rule and in complete violation of the order
dated 05-09-1998 issued by the Secretariat, Forest Department,
Government of Manipur, thereby rendering such appointment as
illegal appointments. Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. AG
further submitted that all the pay scale of the 107 (118) posts
against which 107 (118) incumbents have been appointed are
above Rs. 3300 per month and accordingly, obtaining prior
sanction of the State Government before making such
appointment was mandatory in view of the provisions under
Rule 23 of the said Rule.
[13]
Mr. M. Devananda strenuously submitted that by
abusing his position as the Chairman of MPCB, the petitioner
made illegal appointments and as such, the authorities
terminated the service of the petitioner in exercise of the power
conferred under Section 6 (1) (g) of the said Act as his
continuance as the Chairman of the MPCB was detrimental to
the interest of the general public.
[14]
It has also been submitted by Mr. M. Devananda
that there is a fallacy in the stand taken by the petitioner that he
appointed all the 107 (118) employees in the MPCB as per the
direction given by the National Green Tribunal and in terms of
the Convey Letter of the Government, inasmuch as, both the
orders of the National Green Tribunal and the Government
Convey Letter were passed/issued only in the year 2021
whereas, all the appointments were made in the year 2018. The
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 16
learned Addl. Advocate General accordingly submitted that such
stands taken by the petitioner deserves to be rejected outright
and the writ petition is liable to be dismissed as being devoid of
merit.
[15]
Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel appearing
for the respondent No. 3 adopted the arguments advanced by
the learned Addl. Advocate General. In addition, the learned
senior counsel submitted that as the petitioner had been
removed in terms of the provisions under Section 6 of the said
Act, he is no longer eligible for re-nomination as the member of
the Board and accordingly, he has no locus-standi to challenge
the appointment of the private respondent No. 3, unless and
until he succeeded in challenging his removal order. The
learned senior counsel further submitted that the respondent
No. 3 is more educated and qualified than the petitioner for
being appointed as the Chairman of the MPCB and as such, the
present writ petition is liable to be dismissed as being devoid of
merit.
[16]
I have heard the rival arguments advanced by the
learned counsel appearing for the parties at length and also
examined the material available on record. The petitioner
challenged his termination order on the following grounds:(1)
As the tenure of service of the petitioner as
Chairman of MPCB is of three years with effect from the
date of appointment, the State Government cannot
terminate his service before completion of the tenure of
his service;
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 17
(2)
The impugned orders have been issued in
complete violation of the Judgment and order dated
11.08.2022 passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 562 of
2022;
(3)
As the petitioner appointed all the 107 (118)
employees in the MPCB as per the direction given by the
National Green Tribunal and in terms of the Convey Letter
of the Government, he did not commit any illegality in
making such appointment and as such, he cannot be
penalised by terminating his service;
(4)
The scale of Rs. 3300/- as mentioned under
proviso to Rule 23 of the said Rule was increased from
time to time under the Revision of Pay Rules issued by
the Government from time to time. Since all the pay scale
of the said 107 (118) employees are below the revised
pay scale, there is no requirements to obtain prior
sanction of the Government before appointing them,
especially when the Board has absolute and unfettered
power to create posts and make recruitment without
seeking approval of the Government, if financial burdens
are taken by the Board.
[17]
Under Section 5 (3) of the said Act, it is provided
that the Central Government or the State Government may, if it
thinks fit, removed any member of a Board before the expiry of
his term of office after giving him a reasonable opportunity of
showing cause against the same. Under Section 6 of the said
Act, it is provided, inter-alia, that a member of a Board can be
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 18
removed by the Central Government or the State Government if
it is of the opinion that the member has so abused his position
as to render his continuance on the Board detrimental to the
interest of the general public and after giving him a reasonable
opportunity of showing cause against the same. Further, under
the proviso to Rule 23 of the said Rules, it is provided that for
the creation of and appointment to post in the scale, the
maximum of which is above Rs. 3300/- per month, the Board
shall obtain prior sanction of the Government.
[18]
In the present case, it is undisputedly on record that
the petitioner, while holding the office of the Chairman of MPCB,
appointed as many as 107 (118) persons in different capacities
in the Board without following the procedure for public
employment and without obtaining prior sanction of the
Government. It is also undisputedly on record that the pay scale
of the posts held by the said 107 (118) employees or the
monthly emoluments given to the said 107 (118) employees are
above Rs. 3300/-. Since the monthly emoluments given to the
said 107 (118) employees are above Rs. 3300/-, the petitioner
was required to obtain prior sanction of the State Government
before making such appointment in terms of the mandatory
provisions under the proviso to Rule 23 of the said rules. As the
petitioner failed to obtain prior sanction of the State Government
before making such appointments and as the petitioner did not
follow any of the procedure for public employment, the
authorities issued a memorandum dated 09.09.2022 raising
such allegations against the petitioner and directing him to
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 19
submit a written explanation as to why disciplinary action should
not be taken up against him. In response to the said
memorandum, the petitioner submitted a detailed written
explanation in his defense. After taking into consideration the
written statement submitted by the petitioner, the authorities
issued
the
impugned
order
dated
20.09.2022
thereby
terminating the service of the petitioner as Chairman of MPCB,
in exercise of the power conferred under Section 6 (1) (g) of the
said Act. In view of the above undisputed factual position and
provisions of law, this Court is not inclined to accept or entertain
the first ground raised by the learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner. In my considered view, the judgment of the
Hon’ble Gauhati High Court in the case of Chandam Manihar
Singh (Supra) cited by the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner is of no help to the petitioner as the said judgment is
not applicable in the facts and circumstances of the present
case.
[19]
With regard to the second ground raised on behalf
of the petitioner, it is to be noted that the earlier writ petition
being WP(C) No. 562 of 2022 filed by the present petitioner was
allowed by this Court under its judgment and order dated
11.08.2022 by quashing the impugned order dated 14.07.2022
and by giving liberty to the State Government to reconsider the
case of the petitioner by following due procedure of law
contemplated under Section 5 (3) or under Section 6 (2) of the
said Act. In the present case, the authorities have acted in
pursuance of the liberty given by this Court in the aforesaid
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 20
judgment and order and by strictly following due procedure of
law provided under Section 5 (3) or under Section 6 (2) of the
said Act. Moreover, the petitioner have failed to point out any
instance of violating the aforesaid judgment and order of this
Court by the authorities while issuing the impugned orders. In
view of the above, this Court did not find any substance in the
second ground raised on behalf of the petitioner.
[20]
With regard to the third ground raised on behalf of
the petitioner, it is to be pointed out that all the appointment
order of the aforesaid 107 (118) employees were issued in the
year 2018 whereas the judgment and order of the National
Green Tribunal and the Convey Letter of the State Government
were given only on 05.02.2021 and 26.02.2021 respectively. In
view of such factual position, this Court is of the considered
view that there is a fallacy in the third ground raised on behalf of
the petitioner that the petitioner issued all the appointment
orders as per direction given by the National Green Tribunal and
in terms of the Convey Letter of the State Government.
[21]
During the course of hearing of the present writ
petition and despite giving ample opportunities, the learned
senior counsel appearing for the petitioner failed to point out
any relevant provisions under the various Revision of Pay Rules
issued by the State Government, revising the Pay Scale of the
posts against which the aforesaid 107 (118) employees have
been appointed. Moreover, as none of the posts held by the
said 107 (118) employees of the Board are included or
mentioned in any of the Revision of Pay Rules produced by the
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 21
petitioner, this Court is not inclined to accept the bald statement
made on behalf of the petitioner that the Scale of Pay of Rs.
3300/- mentioned in the proviso to Rules 23 of the said Rules
had been revised from time to time under various ROPs issued
by the Government.
In the result, the writ petition fails as the petitioner
has failed to make out any reasonable ground for interfering
with the impugned orders. Accordingly, the present writ petition
is dismissed as being devoid of merit, however, without any
order as to costs. Earlier interim order stands vacated.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Kim/Lhaineichong
WP(C) 810 of 2022
Page 22
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review