Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
SHAMURAILATP
AM SUSHIL
SHARMA
SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2022.07.21 10:45:01
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 77 of 2022
Prabin Mongjam, aged about 39 years, S/o Mongjam
Gouro Singh of Chalou, PO Lamlong & PS Lamlai,
Imphal East District, Manipur – 795126.
… Petitioner
-Versus1.
The
State
of
Manipur
Commissioner/Secretary
represented
(DP),
by
the
Government
of
Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District- Imphal West,
Manipur-795001.
2.
The Director General, State Academy of Training,
P.O & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur795004.
3.
The Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department,
Government of Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur-795001.
4.
Dingamlung Panmei, LDC/OACCO c/o EE/IMD-11,
Water Resources Department, Government of
Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
5.
N. Areena Devi, LDC/OACCO c/o EE/IMD, Water
Resources Department, Government of Manipur,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur795001.
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
Page |2
6.
Arambam Naobi Devi, LDC/OACCO c/o EE/IMD,
Water Resources Department, Government of
Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
7.
Thangjangam
EE/TCD-IV,
Thouthang,
Water
LDC/OACCO
Resources
c/o
Department,
Government of Manipur, P.O .& P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur-795001.
…. Respondents.
WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
1. Laishram Nongpoknganba Singh, aged about 38
years, S/o (L) L. Birendrakumar Singh of Wangkhei
Tokpam Leikai, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur-795001.
2. Chingkheinganba Laishangbam, aged about 38
years, S/o L. Rupa Roshni of Keishamthong Hodam
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur, Pin-795001.
3. Thounaojam Satyendra Meetei, aged about 35 years,
S/o (L) Th. Indramani Singh of Sagolband Ingudam
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur, Pin-795001.
4. Moirangthem Winner Singh, aged about 32 years, S/o
M. Sarat Singh of Uripok Khaidem Leikai, P.O.
Imphal, P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur,
Pin-795001.
… Petitioners
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
Page |3
-Versus1.
The
State
of
Manipur
Commissioner/Secretary
represented
(DP),
by
the
Government
of
Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Pin-795001.
2.
The Director General, State Academy of Training,
P.O & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur,
Pin-795004.
3.
The Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department,
Government of Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur, Pin-795001.
4.
Arambam Naobi Devi, LDC/OACCO c/o EE/EMD,
Water Resources Department, Government of
Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Pin-795001.
5.
Yourthing Awungshi LDC/OACCO c/o EC/IC-I,
Water Resources Department, Government of
Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Pin-795001.
6.
Naorem Areena Devi, LDC/OACCO c/o EE/IID,
Water Resources Department, Government of
Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal-795001.
7.
Thangjangam
EE/TCD-IV,
Touthang,
Water
LDC/OACCO
Resources
c/o
Department,
Government of Manipur, P.O .& P.S. Imphal 795001.
…. Respondents.
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
Page |4
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mrs. H. Bisheshwari, Advocate
in both the writ petitions.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Y. Ashang, GA for the State
respondents in both the writ
petitions;
Mr. N. Jotendro, Sr. Advocate
for the respondents No. 4,5,6 &
7 in WP(C) No. 992 of 2021.
Date of Hearing and
Reserving Judgment & Order ::
15.06.2022
Date of Judgment & Order
20.07.2022
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
These writ petitions have been filed to quash the
notification dated 24.11.2021 qua the private respondents, as
they are juniors to the petitioners and to direct the second
respondent to include the petitioners in the 84th Batch of State
Accounts Training as their right for promotion to the ensuing DPC
for promotion of UDC is deprived of.
2.
The case of the petitioners is that on the
recommendation of Class III DPC, they have been appointed to
the post of LDC/OACC on 7.11.2016 and in the list of
appointment order, the names of the petitioners appear at Serial
Nos.11, 8, 9, 24, 7 respectively, while the names of the private
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
Page |5
respondents appear at Serial Nos.15,28,34, 35, 13, 58
respectively. According to the petitioners, the seniority list of
LDC/OACCO has been published by the Department of Water
Resources on 21.3.2020 and, as such, the names of the
petitioners found place at Serial Nos.54,43,52,68,51 respectively
and that the private respondents names appear at Serial
Nos.137, 138, 139, 140, 57, 59, 72, 79 respectively.
3.
Further case of the petitioners is that passing of
State Accounts Training is a pre-condition for promotion to the
post of UDC from LDC and the same can be seen from the
Recruitment Rules of UDC published in Gazette on 24.5.2016.
As the petitioners are quite eligible and qualified for consideration
for promotion to the post of UDC, the Department has already
forwarded their names for State Accounts Training, 84th Batch on
12.10.2021, 2.11.2021 and 12.11.2021 respectively. The
consideration was pursuant to the notification of the second
respondent dated 8.10.2021. Further, the parent Department of
the petitioners have also furnished the names of the petitioners
along with others to the authority on 27.10.2021 for consideration
of ensuing DPC for promotion to the post of UDCs. However, the
office of the second respondent omitted the names of the
petitioners in the selection list for State Accounts Training, 84 th
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
Page |6
Batch, which is very much necessary for the petitioners,
however, selected the private respondents who are juniors to
them. Hence, the writ petition.
4.
The second respondent filed affidavit-in-opposition
stating that all the eligible applicants could not be selected for
84th Batch as the State Academy of Training does not have the
capacity to conduct training for 468 trainees. The Scheme of
Accounts Training notified by the Department of Personnel and
Administrative Reforms (Administrative Reforms Division) dated
17.3.2005 deals with selection of trainees does not list seniority
as the sole criteria. The accounts training is required by GroupC employees in all Departments and posted in various districts.
If seniority becomes the sole criteria, a situation may arise
whereby a majority of trainees are from one Department or one
District.
5.
It is stated that the State Academy of Training is not
privy to information regarding consideration of the petitioners for
promotion to UDC and the Scheme of Accounts Training does
not provide for special consideration for those applicants due to
promotion. The classes for 84th Batch Accounts Training had
commenced on 2.12.2021 and the first unit test for the said
training had also been conducted on 29.12.2021. Hence, re-
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
Page |7
considering the nomination at this stage will defeat the purpose
of the training as many important syllabus had already been
covered.
6.
It is further stated that the 85th Batch Accounts
Training is likely to commence from June/July, 2022 and the
petitioners may apply for inclusion as trainees when nominations
are called for. For selection of 160 trainees from amongst 468
nominations, a Board of officials was duly constituted and the
Board selected the trainees considering seniority as an important
factor while also giving due weightage to allocation of seats
amongst Departments and Districts. Out of 468 applicants, only
160 could be selected for 84th Batch State Accounts Training and
if 308 applicants who could not be selected due to limitations of
capacity claim violation of rights, Accounts Training cannot be
conducted since the State Academy of Training does not have
the capacity to train 468 trainees. Hence, prayed for dismissal of
the writ petition.
7.
Assailing the impugned notification, Mrs. H.
Bisheshwari, the learned counsel for the petitioners submitted
that though the parent departments of the petitioners have
recommended the names of the petitioners for State Accounts
Training in 84th Batch, their juniors have been selected for the
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
Page |8
84th Batch training. According to the learned counsel, the private
respondent are juniors to them and in fact in the appointment
order as well as in the seniority list, the names of the private
respondents appear below the petitioners.
8.
The learned counsel urged that the petitioners are
eligible and qualified for consideration for promotion to the post
of UDC and for that only the department has forwarded their
names for training. It is submitted that in similar situation, this
Court in W.P.(C) No.34 of 2021 directed the State Academy of
Training to allow the incumbents vide order dated 22.1.2021 in
the last 83rd Batch and the petitioners case is covered by such
order.
9.
The learned counsel next submitted that the
authority concerned has not selected the petitioners though their
names have been recommended by their department to the best
knowledge known to them. The aforesaid would constitute an
arbitrary exercise done by the respondent authorities, which
causes a great prejudice to the petitioners. Since the private
respondents are juniors to the petitioners, the impugned
notification in respect of them is liable to be quashed and at the
same time, the second respondent be directed to include the
petitioners in the 84th Batch of State Accounts Training as their
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
Page |9
right for promotion to the ensuing DPC for promotion of UDC is
deprived.
10.
Per contra, Mr. Y. Ashang, learned Government
Advocate submitted that though 468 staff members have been
recommended for the 84th Batch Accounts Training, all the
eligible applicants could not be selected for 84th Batch, as the
State Academy of Training does not have the capacity to conduct
the training for 468 trainees. He would submit that the State
Academy of Training is not the authority for consideration of the
petitioners for promotion to the cadre of UDC and it does not
provide for special consideration for those applicants due to
promotion.
11.
The
learned
Government
Advocate
further
submitted that the classes for 84th Batch was commenced on
2.12.2021 and also the first unit test had been held. Thus, the
question of re-considering the nomination of the petitioners at this
stage will defeat the purpose of the training. However, the 85 th
Batch is likely to commence from July, 2022 and the petitioners
can very well apply for inclusion as trainees when nominations
are called for. Thus, prayed for dismissal of the writ.
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 10
12.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
13.
The grievance of the petitioners is that though they
are seniors to the private respondents by appointment as well as
in seniority as LDCs, the names of the petitioners have been
omitted in the select list for State Academy of Training in the 84th
Batch and that the State Academy of Training is very much
essential for promotion to the post of UDCs and including the
names of the private respondents in the select list for 84th Batch
by omitting the petitioners is an arbitrary exercise and, hence, the
impugned notification in respect of the private respondents is to
be quashed.
14.
As could be seen from the materials produced, on
8.10.2021, the Director General of State Academy of Training,
Manipur, issued a notification informing all the Heads of
Department that 6 months State Accounts Training (84 th Batch)
was scheduled to commence from 1st week of December, 2021
at the State Academy of Training, Takyelpat and any Group C
employee who fulfills the eligibility criteria wishing to participate
in the said training get himself/herself nominated by the
concerned Head of Department/Head of Office in the prescribed
form and the said nomination form should reach on or before
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 11
17.11.2021 to the Academy. Pursuant to the notification dated
8.10.2021, the Head of Offices nominated the petitioners and,
accordingly, sent nomination forms to the Director General, State
Academy of Training within the time stipulated in the notification.
15.
The challenge to the impugned notification has
been made mainly on the ground that the names found place in
the impugned select list for training, particularly the private
respondents herein, are juniors to the petitioners and same
would be evident from the appointment order as well as the
seniority list and that the non-selecting the petitioners in the 84th
Batch Accounts Training has seriously affected their promotion
to the post of UDCs.
16.
It appears that the second respondent had issued
the impugned notification dated 24.11.2021 selecting 160
candidates for undergoing the State Accounts Training (84 th
Batch) and announced that the training will commence from
December, 2021. Accordingly, the training was commenced on
2.12.2021. In the impugned notification, the second respondent
issued certain conditions which should be observed during the
training period.
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 12
17.
The learned Government Advocate contended that
totally 468 candidates have been nominated, of which, 160 have
been selected for training in the 84th Batch Accounts Training,
leaving others, as the Academy does not have the capacity to
conduct training for 468 trainees. This Court finds some force in
the submission made by the learned Government Advocate.
Nothing has been produced by the petitioners to show that
training could be given more than 160 trainees.
18.
The Scheme of Accounts Training issued by the
State Academy of Training, Government of Manipur provides
“selection” clause, wherein it has been stated as under:
“Preliminary selection of trainees will be done by the
State Academy of Training by inviting applications
from the Asst./Clerks/Stenographers through the
respective Heads of Offices well in advance after
which final approval of the selection will be obtained
from the Government of Manipur, A.R. Department.
The selected trainees after their release should
report to the Joint Director, State Academy of
Training
one
day
ahead
of
the
date
of
commencement. The Head of Departments/Offices
should release the selected trainees immediately in
time to join training on receipt of the selection order.
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 13
Selected trainee who reports after 7 days of the
starting of the training will not be allowed to join the
training.
On joining the training, the trainee is required to
submit one Bio-data in Form-II along with two latest
passport size photographs. The trainees will be
released from the afternoon of the following day of
completion of the examination after submission of
Assessment Report.”
19.
Thus, the Scheme does not provide that those who
have been nominated have to be selected for Accounts Training.
On the other hand, a preliminary selection has been done by the
Academy
with
final
approval
of
the
selection
by
the
Administration Reforms Department, Government of Manipur.
Admittedly, both the petitioners and the private respondents are
working in the same Department of Water Resources.
20.
On a perusal of the impugned notification, it is seen
that the staff members of other Departments working in the
capacity of JA, LDC, Data Assistant, Auditor, Accountant, UDC,
JAA, Computer Operator have also been nominated for 84th
Accounts Training. Except the petitioners, who are working in
the WRD, the staff members working in the other departments
have no grievance over the non-selection of 84th Accounts
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 14
Training though their departments have nominated them.
Nothing has been produced by the petitioners to show that all the
nominated staff members have to be selected for Accounts
Training as such.
21.
When W.P.(C) No.992 of 2021 came up for
admission, this Court passed the following order:
“Heard Ms. H. Bisheswari, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners.
Issue notice, returnable within 3 (three) weeks.
Mr.Y.Ashang, learned GA accepts notice on
behalf of the respondents No.1, 2 & 3, hence, no
formal notice is called for in respect of the said
respondents.
Petitioner is to take steps for service of notice upon
the respondents No.4 to 7 by speed post within 1
(one) week.
It has been submitted by the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners that the petitioners
are all eligible and qualified for undergoing 6 (six)
months State Accounts Training and in fact their
names has also been recommended by the
concerned
authorities
for
undergoing
such
training. However, the respondent No.2 did not
included the petitioners in the list of Trainees
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 15
without assigning any reason and on the other
hand the respondents No.4 to 7, who are junior to
the petitioners, have been included in a very
arbitrary and discriminatory manner. The learned
counsel also submitted that if the petitioners are
not allowed to join the said State Accounts
Training, the purpose of filing the present writ
petition will be defeated.
Mr.Y. Ashang, learned GA submitted that he
needs to get instructions from the authorities as to
the reason for not including the names of the
petitioners for undergoing the said training.
As prayed for, list this case again on 10.02.2022,
on which date the learned Government Advocate
is directed to place the necessary instructions for
not allowing the petitioners to undergo the said
training.
measures,
In the meantime and as an interim
it
is
hereby
directed
that
the
respondent No.2 should allow the petitioners to
join the said State Accounts Training, 84 Batch
2021 as soon as possible. It is, however, made
clear that the training of the present petitioners will
be subject to the outcome of the present writ
petition.
A copy of this order be furnished to both the
learned counsel appearing for the parties through
their Whatsapp/e-mail.”
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 16
22.
At this juncture, the learned Government Advocate
submitted that the classes for 84th Batch had commenced on
2.12.2021 and the first unit test for the said training has also been
conducted on 29.12.2021. Hence, re-considering the nomination
at this stage will defeat the purpose of the training as many
important syllabus had already been covered. This Court finds
some force in the submission of the learned Government
Advocate.
23.
The factum of commencement of classes for 84th
Batch has not been disputed by the petitioners. Though this
Court by the interim order dated 10.1.2022 directed the second
respondent to allow the petitioners to join the said State Accounts
Training, 84th Batch, in view of the commencement of classes
and also the Academy does not have the capacity to conduct
training for more than 160, the petitioners in W.P.(C) No.992 of
2021 have not joined the 84th State Accounts Training. Further,
the duration for the 84th State Accounts Training came to be
ended in June, 2022 and the 85th Batch Accounts Training will be
commenced from July, 2022. In view of the aforesaid factual
scenario, the petitioners can very well participate in the 85 th
Accounts Training and the official respondents ought to have
nominated petitioners.
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 17
24.
The selection of 160 trainees from amongst 468
nominations was done by the duly constituted Board by giving
due weightage to allocation of seats amongst the Departments
and Districts.
The argument of the learned counsel for the
petitioners that the right for consideration for promotion to the
post of UDC is infringed by virtue of the exclusion of the names
of the petitioners from the select list of Accounts Training, 84 th
Batch, cannot be countenanced. Further, the duly constituted
Board of officials have selected the staff members of different
Departments for the 84th Accounts Training taking into
consideration of their eligibility and other things as per the
Scheme. Since the private respondents are juniors to the
petitioners in the appointment cannot be a ground to interfere
with the impugned notification. On the other hand, the impugned
notification has been issued pursuant to the selection made by
the duly constituted Board and upon taking note of the eligibility
criteria as per the Scheme. Further, this Court while exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot
interfere with the impugned notification as the same has been
issued taking note of the Scheme for Accounts Training and also
the eligibility.
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 18
25.
Thus, this Court is of the view that the second
respondent has not purposefully omitted to include the names of
the petitioners in the select list for 84th Accounts Training.
Further, the plea of the petitioners that despite their names have
been forwarded, the authority concerned has not selected them
to the best reason known to them while integrity certificates have
already been furnished to the authority for ensuing DPC
promotion to the post of UDC does not merit acceptance, as the
State Academy Training is not the sole for consideration of the
petitioners for promotion to UDC. That apart, the Scheme of
Accounts Training also does not provide for special consideration
for the applicants due to promotion. Further, the benefit of the
order passed in W.P.(C) No.34 of 2021 can be extended to the
petitioners as they are similarly situated persons in the next
commencement of programme.
26.
For the foregoing discussions, this Court is of the
view that no valid ground has been made to interfere with the
impugned notification in respect of the private respondent.
Accordingly, the writ petitions fail and are liable to be dismissed.
27.
In the result,
a)
Both the writ petitions are dismissed.
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
P a g e | 19
b)
The official Respondents are directed to
allow the petitioners to join in the 85th Batch
of State Accounts Training.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
W.P.(C) No. 77 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 992 of 2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review