Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SYAM KUMAR V.M.
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
FAO NO. 75 OF 2019
ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 21.07.2018 IN AS
NO.156 OF 2016 OF I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, ERNAKULAM
ARISING OUT OF THE ORDER DATED 08.04.2015 IN
I.A.NO.5626/2007 IN OS NO.65/1999 OF I ADDITIONAL SUB
COURT, ERNAKULAM
APPELLANT/1ST REPONDENT/PLAINTIFF:
LAILA
AGED 53 YEARS
W/O.THOMAS, PADINJAREKUTTU,
THITHIYOOR, KAKKANAD, ERNAKULAM, PIN-682 037
BY ADVS.
NAVEEN THOMAS
SRI.ANSU VARGHESE
RESPONDENTS/APPELLANT (3RD PARTY) &
RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS:
GEORGE BENSON
AGED 50 YEARS
S/O. M.V.GEORGE,MOOLAMKUZHY HOUSE,
JN-6, KOCHAPPAN LANE, KONTHURUTHY,
THEVARA P.O., ERNAKULAM,PIN-682 015
SANTHOSH
AGED 51 YEARS
S/O. LUKA KOYIKKARA, KALATHIL VEETTIL, PERUMANUR,
KONTHURUTHY,THEVARA, ERNAKULAM,PIN-682 015
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
LEELAMMA
: DIED, LRS IMPLEADED
AGED 58 YEARS
W/O.CHALACKAL AMBI, CHALACKAL HOUSE,
NJARACKAL, KOCHI-682 505.
LISSY,
AGED 55 YEARS
W/O,PATHROSE,PULICKAL HOUSE,
THURUTHY,PERUMBAVOOR, KOCHI-683 542
ANNA VINCENT,
AGED 78 YEARS
W/O. VINCENT, KEETTUPARAMBU VEEDU, PANANGADU
DESOM, KUMBALAM VILLAGE, KOCHI-682 506
MINI,
AGED 46 YEARS
W/O.SANTHOSH, KALTHIL VEETTIL, PERUMANOOR,
KONTHURUTHY, THEVARA,KOCHI-682 015.
ADDL.R7:
LIBY POPPY ,
AGED 41 YEARS, W/O POPPY, MENACHERY HOUSE,
NAYARAMBALAM P O, VYPIN, ERNAKULAM, PIN-682509.
ADDL.R8:
LIJOY A CHALACKAL
AGED 39 YEARS,S/O AMBI, CHALACKAL HOUSE,
LIJOY NIVAS, NARAKKAL P O, VYPIN,
ERNAKULAM 682505.
THE LEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED 3RD RESPONDENT ARE
IMPLEADED AS ADDL.R7 & ADDL. R8 VIDE ORDER DATED
13/12/2024 IN I.A.3/2024.
BY ADVS.
SRI.M.P.RAMNATH, R1
SRI.P.RAJESH (KOTTAKKAL)
SEI.M.VARGHESE VARGHESE
SRI.SEBASTIAN K.JOSE
SMT.S.SANDHYA
SRI.BEPIN PAUL
SRI.SHALU VARGHESE
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
SRI.S.DEEPAK
SRI.ANTONY THARIAN
A.BALAGOPALAN, ADDL. R7 & R8
A.RAJAGOPALAN, ADDL. R7 & R8
M.N.MANMADAN
M.S.IMTHIYAZ AHAMMED
P.SEENA
THIS
FIRST APPEAL
FROM ORDERS
HAVING BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD ON 02.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 02nd day of April, 2025
This F.A.O. is filed challenging the judgment and decree in
A.S.No.156 of 2016 dated 21.07.2018 of the I Additiona
l District Court, Ernakulam and seeking to confirm the final
decree and order dated 08.04.2015 of the I Additional Sub Court,
Ernakulam, in I.A.No.5626 of 2007 in O.S.No.65 of 1999. Appellant
herein was the 1st respondent in the A.S. and plaintiff in the O.S.
The 1st respondent was the appellant (3 rd party) in the A.S.
(hereinafter referred to as the 3rd party purchaser). The other
respondents were the respondents in the A.S. and defendants in
the O.S. (hereafter referred to as per their status in the O.S.).
2. The question to be considered in this appeal is whether
the I Additional District Judge erred in setting side the final decree
passed by the learned Sub Judge in a partition suit permitting a third
party purchaser to get impleaded in the final decree proceedings, so
as to seek allotment of property to the share of his assignors.
3.
O.S.No.65 of 1999 was filed by Laila Thomas, a
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
daughter of Koikkara Luka and his wife Kochuthressia (who had five
children - a son and four daughters) seeking partition of the property
owned by her parents having an extent of 1.21 acres situated in
Kanayannur Taluk. The suit was decreed and a preliminary decree
of partition was passed. In A.S.No.212 of 2003 filed challenging the
preliminary decree, the District Court made some alterations in
shares to accommodate a testamentary disposition by the mother
Kochuthressia in favour of her son Santhosh and his wife.
Subsequently based on the Commissioner's report, a final decree
was rendered by the Sub Court. It is at that stage, the 3 rd party
purchaser, who claimed title from Kochuthressia (mother), Santhosh
(son) and Leelamma (daughter) filed an appeal after seeking special
leave contending that the Advocate Commissioner, who had
knowledge about the assignment in his favour, had chosen to ignore
the same though he had accepted and acted upon similar
dispositions in favour of third parties. He thus sought setting aside of
the final decree and remanding the matter back for affording him an
opportunity to implead in the final decree proceedings and seek
allotment of property based on the relevant sale deed as regards the
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
shares of his assigned. The said prayer was allowed by the District
Judge and the said order is impugned before me in this F.A.O.
4. Heard Sri.Naveen Thomas, Advocate for the appellant
(Plaintiff), Sri.M.P.Ramanth, Advocate for the 1 st respondent (3rd
party purchaser) and Sri.A.Balagopalan Advocate for R7 and R8.
5. The learned counsel for the appellant assails the
judgment placing reliance on the dictum laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Ravi T. and another v. B.Chinna Narasimha
and others [2017 KHC 6209] wherein, in the context of doctrine of
lis pendens, it was held that transferee of a property pendente lite
would be bound by the decree as much as if he were a party to the
suit and that where a co sharer of property had sold the property to
a third party, the purchaser pendente lite is bound by the preliminary
decree with respect to the shares so determined and that the same
cannot be reopened. The purchaser would be entitled to the specific
share of his vendor only and cannot claim the entire property.
6. Per Contra, Sri.M.P.Ramnath, Advocate for the 1st
respondent, contended that the judgment of the District Court was
valid and proper and that the learned Judge was only following the
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
trite and settled law. He contends that transferees are entitled to
protection of Section 43 of the Transfer of Property Act which
substantially amounts to satisfying the equitable principle of feeding
the grant by estoppel. He placed reliance on the dictum laid down in
Brahmvart Sanathan Dharam Mahamandal, Kanpur and others
v. Prem Kumar and others [1985 KHC 659] and seeks to augment
the said proposition further by pointing to the judgments rendered by
this Court in Michael v. Victor and others [1995 KHC 31] and
Madhukumar and others v. Gopala Menon and others [2009
KHC 940].
7. I have heard both sides and perused the records. The
specific case of the third party purchaser before the District Court
was that Kochuthressia (mother), Santhosh (son) and Leelamma
(daughter) were having an extent of 26.337 cents corresponding to
their shares and the transfer effected to him was of an extent of 18
cents. Thus, according to him, at the time of execution of the
relevant sale deed (No.1748 of 2003) more extent than even sold to
the 3rd party purchaser ie., himself, was available within the share
extent of his vendors viz., Kochuthressia, Santhosh and Leelamma.
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
Though the extent to work out equities to set apart the share of the
vendors to the third party purchaser was available and the
knowledge of purchase by him was evident especially since his
document had been mentioned in the final decree commission
report, the said property was not set apart/ adjusted nor was himself
as the third party purchaser, made a party in the proceedings. The
said course, however, was followed with respect to other similar
transactions. The learned District Judge had validly taken note of
the said relevant facts as well as the law and precedents on the
point which led him to conclude that the third party purchaser, the
assignment in whose favour by the sharers had been noted by the
Advocate Commissioner, cannot be simply ignored during the final
decree proceedings. The reliance placed by the learned District
Judge on the dictum laid down in K.A.Khader v. Rajamma John
Madathil and others (AIR 1994 Ker. 122) and Madhukumar and
others v. Gopala Menon and others (2009 KHC 940) and the
conclusion arrived at that till the joint status is severed, every co
owner is entitled to each and every inch of the co-ownership
property and that one co-owner cannot assume to himself right over
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
any particular portion of the property and hence the assignment of a
particular portion of the common property can be accepted only to
the limited extent of the right of the co-owners to transfer their
undivided shares with no choice of location, is valid and apposite.
The contention put forth by the learned counsel based on the dictum
in Ravi T. (supra) does not apply to the facts and circumstances of
the case at hand. On the contrary, the reliance placed on
Brahmvart Sanathan Dharam Mahamandal (supra) and Michael
(supra) buttresses the reliance placed by the learned District Judge
on the dictum in K.A.Khader (supra) and Madhukumar (supra).
8. The finding arrived at by the District Judge that applying the
doctrine of feeding the grant by estoppel, such assignees can be
given the limited power of participating in the final decree
proceedings and getting their shares from the properties allotted to
their assignees in equity is trite and settled. Indeed the equities
ought to have been worked out with the third party purchaser in the
party array. The learned District Judge was only ensuring the same.
I see no reason to interfere with the judgment and decree in
A.S.No.156 of 2016 dated 21.07.2018 of the I Additional District
FAO NO.75/2019
2025:KER:28588
Court, Ernakulam.
F.A.O. is dismissed. No costs. All interlocutory applications are
closed.
Sd/SYAM KUMAR V.M.
JUDGE
csl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review