Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 WP(C) No. 121of 2020 with
WP(C) No. 120 of 2019 with WP(C) No. 456 of 2019 with
WP(C) No. 1167 of 2018 with MC(WP(C) No. 143of 2021 with
MC(WP(C) No. 49 of 2020
1.
Shri Th. Ashnikumar Singh, aged about 27 years, s/o
Th.Nara Singh a resident of Charangpat Maning Leikai, PO & PS
and District Thoubal, Manipur.
2.
Smt L. Premi Devi, aged about 32 years, d/o L.Priyokumar
Singh a resident of SingjameiOkramLeikai, PO & PS Singjamei,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
3.
Mr. Ningtinglung Dangmei, aged about 39 years, s/o late
D.Zaolung a resident of Lubanglong Village, PO & PS Khoupum,
Noney District Manipiur.
4.
Mrs. Kimchonghoi Sithou, aged about 30 years, d/o
Lamkholen Sitlhou a resident of Motbung, PO Motbung, PS
Supermeina, Senapati District, Manipur.
... Petitioners
Versus
1.
The State of Manipur through the Addl. Chief Secretary
(For & Envt)., Government of Manipur, Secretariat Building, PO
& PS and District Imphal West, Manipur 795001.
2.
The Principal Chief Conservator of Forest and HoFF,
Government of Manipur, Sanjenthong, PO Imphal, PS District
Imphal East, Manipur 795001.
... Respondents
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 1
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE LANUSUNGKUM JAMIR
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. H.S. Paonam, Sr. Advocate &
Mr. M. Hemchandra, Sr.Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Lenin Hijam, Addl. Advocate
General, Manipur.
Dates of hearing
::
24.9.2021 & 28.9.2021
Date of judgment/order ::
06.06.2022
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(C A V)
All these writ petitions, having common cause of
action and relief sought being identical, are being disposed of by
this common judgment.
[2]
The Forest Department, Government of Manipur
issued an Advertisement dated 6.8.2016 inviting applications for
direct recruitment for the post of Forest Guards in Forest
Department, Government of Manipur under Forest Guards
Recruitment Rules, 2000 for 141 (one hundred and forty one)
posts. The number of posts was increased to 255 (two hundred
and fifty five) on the basis of a Cabinet decision. The petitioners
being eligible, applied for the post and on completion of the
recruitment process, the office of the Principal Chief Conservator
of Forest, Forest Department, Manipur issued a Notification
dated 23.12.2016 declaring the results of successful candidates
for recruitment of Forest Guards in the Forest Department,
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 2
Manipur. The names of the petitioners in WP(C) No.982 of 2019
appeared in the waiting list at Sl.No.1 (UR), Sl.No.2 (UR),
Sl.No.19- (ST) and Sl.No.20 (ST).
The names of the petitioners in WP(C) No.1167 of
2018 appeared in the waiting list at Sl.No.3 (UR) and Sl.No.4
(UR).
Thereafter, the Principal Chief Conservator of Forest
and HoFF, Government of Manipur wrote a letter dated
5.12.2017 addressed to the Addl.Chief Secretary (Forest and
Environment), Government of Manipur on the subject of
appointment to the post of Forest Guards in Manipur. The
contents of the letter are reproduced hereinbelow:
“Government of Manipur
Office of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests
Imphal: Manipur
No.2/44/2016/Forests(FG)
Imphal, the 5th December, 2017
To
The Additional Chief Secretary (Forest &Envt)
Government of Manipur.
Subject:-Appointment to the post of Forest Guard in Manipur.
Sir,
With reference to letter No.3/4/2015-For &Envt. (Pt-III)
dated 14.11.2017 on the above subject regarding the current
direct recruitment process of the Forest Guards in the Forest
Department, Manipur, I am to say that the Offer Forms of the
255 candidates recommended for appointment to Forest
Guards have been examined by a Committee consisting of
the Senior Forest Officers and it has been found that out of
the 255 candidates the Offer Forms and report on Medical
Examination, Police verification, Educational Certificate
verification of 248 candidates are proper and acceptable for
appointment to Forest Guards. The details list of the 248
candidates is at Enclosure-I A attached herewith. Further, 1
(one) candidate namely GulistanRahaman bearing Roll
No.1105 with Rank No.234 claims for ST status by virtue of
her marriage to one ST member (Enclosure1-B). Her case is
to be considered in the light of the O.M.No.A36011/1/2013Estt (Res) dated 23.01.2014. Chapter 10.11 which states that:
Claims through marriage “No Person who was not a member
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 3
of SC/ST/OBC by birth will be deemed to be a member of a
SC/ST/OBC merely because he/she has married a person
belonging to SC/ST/OBC. On the other hand a person who is
a member of a SC/ST/OBC would continue to be a member of
that SC, ST or OBC, as the case may be even after his or her
marriage with the person who does not belong to a SC, ST or
OBC. The verification of the Educational certificate of 1 (one)
candidate namely, Rejoicing Inbuon bearing Roll No.1337 with
rank No.214 is pending at Board of Secondary Education
Assam (Enclosure-IC). However, his case for appointment
may be considered subject to verification report of the
educational certificate by Board of Secondary Education,
Assam. Further 2 (two) candidates 1-UR and 1-ST bearing
Roll No.1919 and 1689 respectively joined other departments
and their Offer forms are also not available and hence their
case will not be considered for appointment (Enclosure-ID). 1
(one) Unreserved candidate bearing Roll No.1011 expired
(Enclosure-IE). The educational Qualificationcertificates
submitted by 2 (two) ST- candidates bearing Roll No.238 and
239 have been verified as “FAKE” by the Board of Secondary
Education, Manipur and as such that case may not be
considered for appointment (Enclosure-IF). Thus, out of 255
candidates, only 250 candidates including GulistanRahaman,
Roll No.1105 (subject to approval by the Govt. on ST
certificate) and Rejoicing Inbuon bearing Roll No.1337 are
qualified for appointment to Forest Guards. 5 (five) posts
consisting of 2-UR and 3-ST are found vacant due to rejection
of the candidature of the 5 candidates at Enclosure-I D,E,F.
Therefore, it is requested that the list of 248
candidates at Enclosure-IA and 1 candidate at Enclosure-1 C
may kindly be approved for appointment to Forest Guards.
The case of the 1 (one) candidate at Enclosure-1B regarding
ST Certificate may also be finalised.
Further, the 5 vacancies available due to rejection of
the candidature at Enclosure-I, D,E,F consisting of 2-UR and
3-ST may be allowed to fill from the wait-list candidates in
order of the rank as follows:
“
Sl.No.
1.
Roll
No.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Name
Category
Gender
UR
Category
allotted
UR
ThiyamAshinikumar
Singh
LaishramPremi Devi
NingtinglungDangmei
KimchonghoiSitlhou
N.LuntingmangBaite
UR
ST
ST
ST
UR
ST
ST
ST
Female
Male
Female
Male
Male
The 200 point Post Based Roster for 548 direct recruit
Forest guards consisting of the existing 207 Forest Guards
and 250 Forest Guards under recruitment is also enclosed
herewith as Enclosure-II. All the 250 new recruit Forest
Guards are accommodated in the Roster (457 out of 548).
There are still 91 posts of Forest Guards lying vacant.
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 4
Enclosed: Enclosure-I and Enclosure-II.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/(K.Angami)
Principal Chief Conservator of Forest &HoFF
Government of Manipur.”
[3]
The Deputy Secretary, (Forest & Environment),
Government of Manipur, wrote back by letter dated 14.12.2017
addressed to the Principal Chief Conservator of Forest, referring
to
the
letter
dated
5.12.2017
(reproduced
hereinabove)
conveying the approval of the Government for appointment of
248 (two hundred forty eight) candidates out of 255 (two hundred
fifty five) candidates to the post of Forest Guards in respect of
Forest Department, Manipur. Further, in the same letter, the
decision of the Government of Manipur was conveyed as under:
“1.
Acceptance of ST candidate bearing Roll No.1105
shall stand cancelled.
2.
Acceptance/appointment pertaining to Roll No.1337
may be considered subject to outcome of the verification from
Assam Board.
3.
Concurrence for filling up the vacant post from the
waiting list subject to fitting in the respective category and
roster points.
You are, therefore, requested kindly to take necessary
action under intimation to this Government.”
[4]
Consequently, by order dated 15.12.2017, issued by
the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, HoFF, Government of
Manipur 248 (two hundred forty eight) candidates who are
successful on the recommendation of the Recruitment Board and
on approval of the State Government, which was conveyed vide
letter dated 14.12.2017 were appointed as Forest Guards in the
Forest Department, Manipur on regular basis.
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 5
[5]
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019
The petitioners in the present writ petition, whose
names are in the waiting list for appointment due to
rejection/disqualification of 5 (five) selected candidates were
hopeful to get appointment. However, as there was no positive
action from the concerned authorities, the petitioners No.1 and 2
submitted a representation dated 27.12.2017 addressed to the
Principal
Chief
Conservator
of
Forests,
requesting
for
appointment to the post of Forest Guard from the waiting list.
However, as there was no positive response they approached
this Court by filing WP(C) No.737 of 2018 for considering their
case for appointment against the unfilled vacant post in terms of
the recommendation made by the competent DPC. In the said
writ petition, i.e. WP(C) No.737 of 2018 the State respondents
filed an affidavit in opposition annexing an Order dated
28.12.2017 contending that the concurrence conveyed by the
Government for filling up 5 (five) vacant posts from the waiting
list was withdrawn. Therefore, the petitioners again filed WP(C)
No.1025 of 2018 challenging the order dated 28.12.2017. WP(C)
No.1025 of 2018 was disposed of by order dated 10.03.2019
directing the respondents to reconsider the withdrawal of
approval order as per order dated 28.12.2017 to the post of
Forest Guards.
In the meantime, the State respondents issued
Advertisement No.1 of 2019 dated 25.01.2019 and 2 of 2019
dated 2.2.2019 along with Addendum dated 2.2.2019 for direct
recruitment of 90 (ninety) posts of Forest Guard including 10
(ten) posts of Sports Quota in the Forest Department. Pursuant
to the Advertisement, the State respondents constituted a
Departmental Recruitment Board for making selection of
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 6
candidates to fill up the notified vacancies as advertised by a
letter dated 7.11.2019 written by the Principal Chief Conservator
of Forests &HoFF, Government of Manipur and addressed to the
Under Secretary, Forest & Environment, Government of Manipur.
Being aggrieved, the petitioners have filed the the present writ
petition challenging the Advertisement Nos.1 of 2019 and 2 of
2019 with Addendum dated 2.2.2019 for direct recruitment of 90
(ninety) posts of Forest Guard and also for a direction to the
respondents to reconsider the withdrawal of the approval of the
case of the petitioners for appointment in terms of order dated
11.3.2019 passed in WP(C) No.1025 of 2019 against the vacant
post of Forest Guards.
This Court by an order dated 4.12.2019 passed an
interim order directing the respondents not to fill up 4 (four) posts
of Forest Guard, 2(two) unreserved and 2 (two) Scheduled
Tribes till the disposal of the writ petition.
[6]
WP(C) No.1167 of 2018
The names of the petitioners in the present writ
petition appears at Sl.Nos.3 and 4 of the waiting list in the
Notification dated 23.12.2016, and they have filed the present
writ petition praying for a direction to the respondents to consider
the case of the petitioners for appointment as Forest Guards in
pursuance to the Advertisement dated 6.8.2016 due to the fact
that 9 (nine) posts of Forest Guards still remain unfilled/vacant
due to non-appointment of 7 (seven) already selected candidates
and also that 2 (two) selected candidates have resigned after
joining service as Forest Guards.
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 7
[7]
WP(C) No.120 of 2019
The petitioners who are also petitioners in WP(C)
No.1167 of 2018 have filed the present writ petition challenging
the Advertisement Nos.1 of 2019 dated 25.01.2019 and 2 of
2019 dated 02.02.2019 and also the Addendum dated 2.2.2019
coupled with the prayer to reserve 2 (two) posts of Forest Guard,
or not to fill up 2 (two) posts of reserved vacancies which has
occurred due to non-joining, resignation of selected candidates in
consequence to the Advertisement dated 6.8.2016.
This Court by an order dated 20.02.2019 passed an
interim order directing that the respondents shall not fill up 2
(two) posts of Forest Guard out of 140 (one forty) posts which
have been advertised vide letter dated 10.08.2018 until further
orders.
[8]
WP(C) No.456 of 2019
The present writ petitioners who are also petitioners
in WP(C) No.1167 of 2018 and 120 of 2018 have filed the
present writ petition challenging the order dated 28.5.2019 and
also with a prayer to consider the case of the petitioners for
appointment to the post of Forest Guards.
This Court by an interim order dated 14.6.2019
directed the respondents not to fill up 2 (two) posts of Forest
Guards pursuant to the Advertisement Nos.1 of 2019 and
Addendum dated 2.2.2019 until further orders.
[9]
WP(C) No.121 of 2021
The petitioners in the present writ petition are also
the petitioners in WP(C) No.1167 of 23018, WP(C) No.120 of
2019 and WP(C) No.456 of 2019 and they filed the present writ
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 8
petition praying for quashing and setting aside the Recruitment
Notice dated 7.2.2020 in continuation of Advertisement No.1 of
1/2019 and No.2/2019 and any other consequential orders,
recruitment process, appointment orders pursuant to the
Recruitment Notice dated 7.2.2020 for appointment to the post of
Forest Guards in the Forest Department, Government of
Manipur.
This Court by an order dated 18.2.2020 passed an
interim order directing the respondents not to declare the results
of the DPC held on 6.2.2020 in respect of the Forest Guards till
the next returnable date, which was extended from time to time.
[10]
the
Heard Mr.H.S.Paonam, learned senior counsel for
petitioners
in
WP(C)
Nos.982
of
and
Mr.M.Hemchandra, learned senior counsel for the petitioners in
WP(C) Nos.1167 of 2018, 1WP(C) No.20 of 2019, WP(C) 456 of
2019 and WP(C) No.121 of 2021. Also heard Mr.LeninHijam,
learned Addl. A.G, Manipur for the State respondents.
[11]
Mr.H.S.Paonam, learned senior counsel submits
that the petitioners being eligible had applied for the post of
Forest Guards pursuant to the Advertisement dated 6.8.2016.
They participated in the recruitment process and the respondents
by Notification dated 23.12.2016 had declared the list of
successful candidates for the post of Forest Guards. Therein, the
names of the petitioners appeared in the waiting list at Sl.Nos.1,
2, 19 and 20. Thereafter, the Principal Chief Conservator of
Forests & HoFF, by letter dated 5.12.2017 addressed to the
Additional Secretary (Forest & Environment), Government of
Manipur indicated that 5 (five) vacancies are still available due to
rejection of candidates consisting of 2 (two) UR and 3 (three)
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 9
STs and, therefore, the said 5 (five) vacancies may be allowed to
be filled up from the wait list candidates. In the said letter the
names of the petitioners in WP(C) No.982 of 2019 were
indicated. The State Government had, thereafter, vide letter
dated 14.12.2017 convened its concurrence for filling up the
vacant post from the waiting list, subject to fitting in their
respective
category
and
roster
points.
The
respondents
thereafter issued an order dated 15.12.2017 by which 248 (two
hundred and forty eight) Forest Guards were appointed on
regular basis. The petitioners were hopeful of getting appointed
to the vacant posts due to rejection of some of the candidates.
However, as there was no positive response they filed a
representation dated 27.12.2017 requesting for appointment to
the post of Forest Guards from the waiting list. However, as there
was no response, they had filed WP(C) No.737 of 2018 before
this Court praying for a direction to consider their case for
appointment. In the said WP(C) No.737 of 2018 the State
respondents filed affidavit in opposition annexing an Order dated
28.12.2017 by which the approval conveyed for filling up the
vacant post from the waiting list was withdrawn. The petitioners
had therefore, filed WP(C) No.1025 of 2019 challenging the
order dated 28.12.2017 and this Court by an order dated
11.3.2019 had disposed of the WP(C) No.1025 of 2019 directing
the respondents to consider the withdrawal of the approval order
as per the order dated 28.12.2017 to the post of Forest Guards.
Learned senior counsel submits that in similar
circumstance with regard to the appointment to the post of
Deputy Ranger, the respondents have made an Advertisement
for direct recruitment of 28 (twenty eight) posts of Deputy
Rangers in the Forest Department. By Notification dated
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 10
16.12.2016 the respondents had declared the names of 28
(twenty eight) persons who are successful at the recruitment of
Deputy Rangers in the Forest Department. In the said
Notification, the names of three persons also appeared in the
waiting
list.
Before
giving
appointment
to
the
selected
candidates, one post became vacant as one of the merit
candidates surrendered her post and, accordingly, the State
respondents had proceeded to issue Offer Form to one person
from the waiting list by a letter dated 12.5.2017.
He also submits that the respondents issued an
Advertisement dated 19.11.2016 for direct recruitment of 20
(twenty) posts of Range Forest Officers. Thereafter, by a
Notification dated 20.5.2017 the number of 20 (twenty) Range
Forest Officers were increased to 28 (twenty eight) posts. The
Selection Committee recommended 28 (twenty eight) names of
candidates who are successful for the post of Range Forest
Officers along with 7 (seven) candidates in the waiting list.
Thereafter, 7 (seven) candidates in the waiting list were also
given appointment by an order dated 8.1.2019. He therefore,
submits that in the present case too, when there was clear
vacancy, enabling the respondents to appoint the petitioners to
the vacant post as indicated in the letter dated 15.12.2017, which
was also concurred by the State respondents by letter dated
14.12.2017,the action of the respondents in issuing the order
28.12.2017 by which the approval for filling up the vacant post
from the waiting list was withdrawn would clearly indicate that the
respondents are applying different yardsticks in respect of
similarly situated persons, which is against the principle of equity
and fairness. He also submits that the State respondents has
failed to file counter affidavit in the present writ petition, and
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 11
therefore, applying the settled position of law, averments made
by the petitioners in the present writ petition shall be deemed to
have been accepted by the respondents and, therefore, the
present writ petition should be allowed by directing the
respondents to appoint the petitioners to the vacant posts.
He
places
reliance
in
the
cases
of
(1)
A.K.Kraipak&Ors Vs Union of India &Ors reported in 1969 (2)
SCC 262, (2) East Coast Railway &Anr Vs MahadevAppa Rao
&Ors reported in (2010) 7 SCC 678, (3) R.S.Mittal Vs Union of
India reported in (1995) 2 SCC 230, (4) Asha Kaul (Mrs) &Anr
Vs State of Jammu & Kashmir &Ors reported in (1993) 2 SCC
573, (5) State of Jammu & Kashmir &Ors Vs Sat Pal reported
in (2013) 11 SCC 737, (6) State of Uttar Pradesh &Ors Vs
Mahesh Narain&Orsreported in (2013) 4 SCC 169 and (7)
Bachhittar Singh Vs State of Punjab &Anrreported in AIR
1963 SC 395.
[12]
Mr.M.Hemchandra, learned senior counsel for the
petitioners in WP(C) Nos.121 of 2020, 120 of 2019, 1167 of 2018
while adopting the submission made by Mr.H.S.Paonam, learned
senior counsel for the petitioners in WP(C) No.482 of 2019, also
submits that the names of the petitioners also appear at Sl.Nos.3
and 4 of the Notification dated 23.12.2016. He submits that there
were 5 (five) vacancies due to rejection of candidates as
indicated in the letter dated 5.12.2017. He submits that the Office
of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & HoFF, Forest
Department,
Manipur
had
issued
appointment
order
on
15.12.2017 appointing 248 (two hundred forty eight) Forest
Guards on regular basis on the recommendation of the
Recruitment Board and on the approval of the State Government
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 12
vide letter dated 14.12.2017, despite the declaration of 255 (two
hundred fifty five) successful candidates by Notification dated
23.12.2016. This would clearly indicate that there were 7 (seven)
clear posts of Forest Guards which remain unfilled. He further
submits that another two persons namely, Ningombam Sakhenbi
Devi and Khaidem Anandkumar Singh, who were appointed as
Forest Guards were terminated from service as they have
resigned.
Therefore, coupled with the resignation of 2 (two)
successful candidates, there were 9 (nine) clear vacancies of
Forest Guards which still remain unfilled. Therefore, the
petitioners were hopeful of being appointed to any of the 9 (nine)
vacant posts. However, the respondents had withdrawn the
approval for filling up the vacant post from the waiting list
candidates in public interest.
He also submits that no justification/reasons have
been cited in the order dated 28.12.2017 and in the absence of
such reasons, the order dated 28.12.2017 is also not sustainable
in the eye of law.
[13]
Mr.Lenin Hijam, learned Addl. A.G, Manipur referring
to the affidavit in opposition filed by the State respondents in
WP(C)No.120 of 2019 submits that the validity period of a
recommended/merit list is only for one year and the State may
extend the validity period for another 6 (six) months. However,
the State has never issued any order extending the validity
period of the recommended list by the Notification dated
23.12.2016 for recruitment of Forest Guards. He also submits
that the validity period of recommended list by the Notification
dated 23.12.2016 expired on 22.12.2017 after which the State
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 13
respondents has no authority to give appointment to any of the
wait listed candidates. It is also submitted that the approval for
filling up the vacant post from the wait listed candidates was
withdrawn by the Government by order dated 28.12.2017 in
public interest. Further, as the validity period of the Notification
dated 23.12.2016 had already expired, the Department has
started process for recruitment of fresh candidates from the open
market for the post of Forest Guards. He therefore, submits that
no right accrues to the petitioners after the validity of the
recommended list by Notification dated 23.12.2016 had expired
on 22.12.2017 and furthermore, when the Government has
withdrawn the approval given for filling up the vacant post from
the waiting list by order dated 28.12.2017.
[14]
I have considered the submissions forwarded by the
learned counsel for the parties.
[15]
As the State respondents have taken two grounds
for justifying the issuance of the Advertisement Nos.1 of 2019
and 2 of 2019 as well as the Addendum dated 2.2.2019 on the
ground that the validity period for appointment to the post of
Forest Guards by the Notification dated 23.12.2016 had expired
on 22.12.2017 and the State respondents have withdrawn the
approval given for filling up the vacant post from the waiting list
candidates in public interest by order dated 28.12.2017, this
Court propose to answer the said two contentions made by the
State respondents.
[16]
The undisputed facts in these batch of writ petitions
is that the Forest Department, Government of Manipur invited
applications for filling up 141 (one hundred and forty one) posts
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 14
of Forest Guards by Advertisement dated 6th August, 2016.
Notification dated 23rd September, 2016 was issued by the
Principal Chief Conservator of Forest, Government of Manipur
declaring the names of candidates who were successful for the
recruitment of Forest Guards, 2016 wherein, 255 (two hundred
and fifty five) candidates were in the merit list and 27 (twenty
seven) candidates were in the waiting list under Meritorious
Categories. Order dated 15th December, 2017 issued by the
Office of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forest and HOFF,
Forest Department, Government of Manipur appointed 243 (two
hundred and forty three) Forest Guards on regular basis on the
recommendation of the Recruitment Board and on approval of
the State Government. Issuance of letter dated 14th December,
2017 by the Deputy Secretary (Forest & Environment),
Government of Manipur to the Principal Chief Conservator of
Forest, Manipur concurring for filling up the vacant post from the
waiting list subject to fitting in the respective category besides
two other decisions and issuance of Order dated 28th December,
2017 by the Deputy Secretary (Forest & Environment),
Government of Manipur withdrawing the Government approval
under Sl. No. 3 of the letter dated 14-12-2017 for filling up the
vacant post from the waiting list candidates in public interest.
[17]
It is already settled position of law that the validity of
the recommended list would expire only when the State
Government
accepts
the
recommendation
and
makes
appointment on the basis of such recommendation. In the
present case in hand, the recommendation of 255 (two hundred
fifty five) candidates and 27 (twenty seven) wait list candidates
were made by the Notification dated 23.12.2016. Thereafter, the
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 15
State respondents issued order dated 15.12.2017 by which 248
(two hundred forty eight) candidates were given appointment
from amongst the 255 (two hundred fifty five) candidates. In the
considered opinion of this Court, the validity of the names of 27
(twenty seven) wait listed candidates would start w.e.f.
15.12.2017, i.e. the date on which the appointment orders of 248
(two hundred forty eight) candidates were made to the post of
Forest Guards on regular basis. Therefore, the recommended list
would expire on 14.12.2018.
[18]
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of
Jammu & Kashmir and Ors Vs Sat Pal (supra) had observed
as under:
“11. In view of the factual position noticed hereinabove,
the reason indicated by the appellants in declining the
claim of the respondent Sat Pal for appointment out of
the waiting list is clearly unjustified. A waiting list would
start to operate only after the posts for which the
recruitment is conducted, have been completed. A
waiting list would commence to operate, when offers of
appointment have been issued to those emerging on the
top of the merit list. The existence of a waiting list, allows
room to the appointing authority to fill up vacancies
which arise during the subsistence of the waiting list. A
waiting list commences to operate, after the vacancies
for which the recruitment process has been conducted
have been filled up. In the instant controversy the
aforesaid situation for operating the waiting list had not
arisen, because one of the posts of Junior Engineer
(Civil) Grade-II for which the recruitment process was
conducted was actually never filled up. For the reason
that Trilok Nath had not assumed charge, one of the
posts for which the process of recruitment was
conducted, had remained vacant. That apart, even if it is
assumed for arguments sake, that all the posts for which
the process of selection was conducted were duly filled
up, it cannot be disputed that Trilok Nath who had
participated in the same selection process as the
respondent herein, was offered appointment against the
post of Junior Engineer (Civil) Grade-II on 22.4.2008.
The aforesaid offer was made, consequent upon his
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 16
selection in the said process of recruitment. The validity
of the waiting list, in the facts of this case, has to be
determined with reference to 22.4.2008, because the
vacancy was offered to Trilok Nath on 22.4.2008. It is the
said vacancy, for which the respondent had approached
the High Court. As against the aforesaid, it is the
acknowledged position recorded by the appellants in the
impugned order dated 23.8.2011 (extracted above), that
the waiting list was valid till May, 2008. If Trilok Nath was
found eligible for appointment against the vacancy in
question out of the same waiting list, the respondent
herein would be equally eligible for appointment against
the said vacancy. This would be the unquestionable legal
position, in so far as the present controversy is
concerned.”
[19]
The petitioners No.1 and 2 in WP(C) No. 982 of
2019 made their representation dated 27.12.2017 to the Principal
Chief Conservator of Forest and HOFF, Government of Manipur
requesting for appointment to the post of Forest Guards from the
waiting list stating that 5 (five) of the successful candidates (UR2
and
ST-3)
have
either
expired/withdraw/joined
other
department.
The two writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 1167 of 2018
also made representation dated 10-12-2018 requesting for
appointment to the 9 (nine) vacant posts of Forest Guard from
the waiting list. Both the representations were made during the
validity of the waiting list. However, basing on the Order dated
28-12-2017, none of the petitioners in both the writ petitions were
appointed to the vacant post despite vacancy being available in
their respective categories of reservation.
[20]
The Order dated 28th December, 2017 by which the
approval for filling up the vacant post from the waiting list was
withdrawn in public interest has been considered by this Court.
No reasons have been given except for the statement that the
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 17
withdrawal for approval for filling up the vacant post from the
waiting list is in public interest.
In the considered opinion of this Court, when no
reasons are stated whatsoever for withdrawal of the approval
given for filling up the post from waiting list, clearly depicts none
application of mind and such decision lacks the pre-requisite for
making up a valid order. Therefore, Order dated 28th December,
2017 cannot be held to be valid in the eye of law particularly
when the validity of the waiting list was in operation. It is also
made clear that the wait listed candidates need not make any
representation for appointment against vacancies which arises
during the validity of the waiting list is subsisting. It is the
bounden duty of the respondents to offer appointment order to
the wait listed candidates to vacancies that arises when the
waiting list is in operation.
Therefore, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the petitioners have been denied justice for being appointed
to the post of Forest Guards against their respective categories
of reservation.
In that view of the matter, the writ petitions are
allowed and accordingly, the respondents are directed to appoint
the 4 (four) petitioners in WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 and the 2 (two)
writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 1167 of 2018 to the post of Forest
Guards in their respective category of reservation w.e.f., the date
when the vacancies arose in terms of the Order dated 15th
December, 2017 issued by the Principal Chief Conservator of
Forest and HOFF, Government of Manipur appointing 243 (two
hundred and forty three) Forest Guards on regular basis. This
exercise should be undertaken and completed within a period of
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 18
2 (two) months from the receipt of a copy of the judgment of this
Court.
All interim orders passed in the aforesaid Writ
Petitions stand merged with this order.
Writ petitions are accordingly allowed.
No Cost.
JUDGE
Priyojit
KH. JOSHUA JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2022.06.07
MARING
23:39:41 +05'30'
WP(C) No. 982 of 2019 & Ors
Page 19
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review