Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with
MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
Laishram Nobin Singh aged about 37 years old, S/o (L) L. Angou Singh of
Khangabok Awang Leikai, Part-I, P.O. & P.S. Thoubal, Thoubal District,
Manipur.
… Petitioner
- Versus 1. The State of Manipur through the Commissioner (Health), Government
of Manipur.
2. The Director of Health Services, Lamphelpat, Imphal West, Manipur.
3. The Manipur Public Service Commission through its Secretary.
4. M. Bimolata Devi, Medical Record Technician, Health & Family Welfare
Department, Govt. of Manipur.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner
:
Mr. H.S. Paonam, Sr. Adv. & Mr. A. Arunkumar,
& Ms. Malemleima, Advocates.
For the respondents :
Mr. Th. Sukumar, GA; Mr. A. Mohendro &
Mr. David Boon, Advocates.
Date of reserved
:
Date of Judgement :
10.07.2025
28.10.2025
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
JUDGEMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. H.S. Paonam, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. A. Arunkumar, learned counsel and Ms. Malemleima, learned counsel
for the petitioner; Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned Government Advocate for the
State respondents and Mr. A. Mohendro, learned counsel assisted by Mr.
David Boon, learned counsel for the respondent no. 4.
[2]
The present writ petition has been preferred by the
petitioner herein challenging the impugned order dated 30.07.2012 issued
by Under Secretary (Health), Govt. of Manipur inter-alia appointing on
promotion of the private respondent no. 4 as Medical Record Technician
(in short MRT) along with a prayer to issue a direction to hold review DPC
of the DPC proceedings held on 26.06.2012 strictly in terms of the
recruitment rules and also for stay of the impugned order dated
30.07.2012. The prayer of the petitioner is reproduced below:
i) issue rule nisi and call for the records;
ii) issue a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate writ or
direction for quashing and setting aside the impugned
order dated 30.07.2012 appointing the private respondent
No. 4 including the DPC proceedings held on 26.06.2012
which recommended the private respondent who is not
qualified for the post as per the recruitment rules;
iii) consequently, further direct to hold review of the DPC held
on 26.06.2012 strictly in term of the recruitment rules;
iv) in the interim, stay/suspend the impugned order dated
30.07.2012 pending disposal of the present case and
v) pass any further order (s) direction(s) which this Hon'ble
court may seem fit and proper to secure the ends of
justice.
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
[3]
It is the case of the petitioner that he was initially appointed
as CSSD Technician on regular basis on the recommendation of a duly
constituted DPC vide order dated 16.12.2006 and the petitioner attended
the course of MRT held at Safdarjung Hospital, Medical Record Department
& Training Centre, New Delhi w.e.f. 01.01.2011 to 30.06.2011 and hence,
he is eligible for promotion to the post of MRT.
[4]
It is stated that the post of CSSD Tech. is a feeder post for
promotion to the post of MRT (Medical Record Technician). The
appointment to the post of MRT is regulated by the recruitment rules called
the “Department of Health, Manipur [Medical Record Technician (MRT)]
Recruitment Rules, 2011” and the relevant portions is reproduced below:
“No. 1/30/88-RR/DP
Imphal, the 3rd September, 2011
RECRUITMENT RULES FOR THE POST OF MEDICAL
RECORD TECHNICIAN (MRT) IN HEALTH DEPARTMENT,
MANIPUR.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Designation of post(s)
Medical Record Technician
(MRT)
No. of post(s)
11 (Eleven)
Classification
GCS Class II/Gr. B (Gazetted)
Scale of pay
Rs. 5,000-150-8,000/- p.m.
(pre-revised)
[Corresponding Pay Band of Rs.
9,300-34,800/- plus grade pay
of Rs. 4,200/- p.m. as per MS
(RP) Rules, 2010]
Whether selection post Selection
or non- selection post
Age for direct recruits
35 (thirtyfive) years & below
(upper age limit is relaxable for
Govt. servants appointed under
the Govt. of Manipur to the
extent of the period of
continuous services put in the
post/service and by 5 years for
SC/ST candidates and by 3
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
years for OBC candidates and a
Govt. servant who belongs to
SC/ST/OBC will get the facility
admissible to a Govt. servant in
addition to the relaxation
admissible
to
SC/ST/OBC
candidates.)
7. Educational and other ESSENTIAL:
qualifications required Graduate of a recognized
for direct recruits
University.
DESIRABLE:
Knowledge of Manipuri and
Hindi
8. Whether
age
and N.A.
educational qualification
prescribed for the direct
recruits will apply in the
case of promotees.
9. Period of probation, if 2 (two) years
any
10. Method of recruitment
50% by promotion and 50% by
whether by direct
direct recruitment
recruitment or by
promotion or by
deputation/transfer and
percentage of the
vacancies to be filled by
various methods.
11. In case of recruitment
Promotion:
by promotion/
1. Grade-III employees
deputation/ transfer,
with Graduation having 2
grades from which
(two) years regular service
promotion/deputation/
in the grade and trained in
transfer to be made
Medical Record Technician
course of at least 6 (six)
months duration from a
recognized
Institution.
If
not
available,
2. Non-graduate Grade-III
employees having 5 (five)
years regular service in the
grade and trained in
Medical Record Technician
course of at least 6 (six)
months duration from a
recognized Institution.
12. If a DPC exists what is its Class-II D.P.C.
compositions
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
13. Circumstances in which As required under MPSC
MPSC is to be consulted (Exemption from consultation)
in making recruitment
Regulations, 1972
MZ. CHAMTHIU,
Under Secretary (DP), Government of
Manipur.”
[5]
A proposal was made by the Director of Health Services for
filling up the post of MRT by promotion to the Govt. of Manipur. Since MRT
is a Class-II/Group- B post, DPC is to be conducted by the MPSC, the
Director of Health Services submitted a proposal in MPSC Form-6 for
requisition to the MPSC for holding DPC vide letter dated 17.01.2012. The
Under Secretary (Health), Govt. of Manipur by its letter dated 17.01.2012
requested the Director, Health Services for filling up the vacant post of
MRT. Accordingly, Director Health Services issued a memorandum dated
02.02.2012 informing all Grade-III employees to furnish all relevant
certificates of MRT courses and the same is reproduced herein below:
“GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
MEDICAL DIRECTORATE
MEMORANDUM
Imphal, the 2nd February, 2012
No. G/RA/89-DHS(Pt.II)/4390:
In pursuance of
Secretariat: Health Department, Manipur letter No./
31/17/08-M(Misc) dated 17/01/2012, all the concerned Head
of Offices/ DDOs are requested to inform the following
Grade-III employees working under their administrative
control, to furnish the original certificates of MRT course and
other relevant documents etc., so as to reach the
undersigned on or before 18/02/2012 for onward
submission.
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
Sl.
No
.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Name of Grade-III Head of
employee
& Offices/ DDOs
Designation
Sh. Tabopi Devi, LDC
Under CMO
Imphal West
K. Shyamkumar Singh, Under CMO
LDC
Imphal East
Sh.
Sumati
Devi, Under Medical
Record Assistant
Supdt., DH
Thoubal
L. Shyamo Singh, MHW Under CMO
Ukhrul
L. Nobin Sirgh, CSSD Under Medical
Technician
Supdt., DH
Thoubal
Lamjahao
Lhouvum, Under CMO
LDC
Imphal West.
M.
Bimolata
Devi, Under Medical
Medical
Record Supdt., JN
Assistant
Hospital, Imphal.
Petitioner
herein
Respondent
No. 4 herein
The HOOs/ DDOs concerned.
Sd/(S. Ibomcha Singh)
Director of Health Services,
Manipur.
[6]
DPC for promotion to the post of MRT in the Health & Family
Welfare Department, Manipur on regular basis was held on 26.06.2012 in
association with the MPSC. On the recommendation of the said DPC, 6(six)
employees (from the sub-cadres of LDC/RA/MRA/MHW) were given
promotion to the post of MRT in the scale of pay of Rs. 9300-34,800 with
grade pay of Rs. 4,200/- under the ROP, 2010 with usual allowances as
admissible under the rules vide order dated 30.07.2012. It is stated that
in the recommendation of the DPC, the petitioner, the senior most CSSD
Tech. in the Department of Medical & Health Services, was not included in
spite of possessing all the requisite qualification including passing of MRT
course. Respondent no. 4, who did not possess the certificate of passing
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
MRT course, was included at serial no. 5 of the impugned promotion order
dated 30.07.2012. The promotion of respondent no. 4 is challenged on the
ground that respondent no. 4 did not possess the qualification of MRT
Training as required under the recruitment rules and she has attended
Medical Record Officer training (in short, MRO) which is not prescribed by
the RR. Accordingly, it is prayed that the appointment of the respondent
no. 4 on promotion to the post of MRT be set aside, as she did not possess
the requisite qualification of training in MRT.
[7]
It is also stated that MRO Training is not equivalent to the
MRT training as stipulated by the recruitment rules. Respondent no. 3,
MPSC filed a short-written submission stating that the respondent no. 4
has already passed MRO Training of 1(one) year duration which was
inclusive of 6(six) months syllabus of MRT course. In the circumstances,
she was recommended for promotion to the post of MRT by the DPC held
on 26.06.2012 and as such there is no irregularity in recommending the
name of the respondent no. 4 for promotion to the post of MRT.
[8]
State respondent nos. 1 & 2 have filed counter affidavit
stating that (i) the duration of MRO course is 12(twelve) months and for
MRT is 6(six) months and the person who has already been trained in MRO
training course is not considered for MRT training, since MRO training
curriculum course is more elaborate and (ii) MRO training course
curriculum includes all the curriculum covered in MRT course. Accordingly,
it is stated that respondent no. 4 who had successfully completed 1year
training course in MRO at Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi was found
eligible for consideration for promotion to the post of MRT and her case
was duly considered by the DPC along with other eligible officers.
[9]
Respondent no. 4 has filed counter affidavit stating that she
was initially appointed as Medical Record Assistant, in the Health
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
Department, Govt. of Manipur, vide order dated 08.08.1996 issued by
Director of Health Services, Manipur and the petitioner was appointed as
CSSD Tech. vide order dated 16.12.2006 and as such the respondent no.
4 is 10(ten) years senior to the petitioner. The petitioner attended 6(six)
months training course of MRT from 01.01.2011 to 30.06.2011 at
Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi and the respondent no. 4 attended the
MRO training course at Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi for the period of
1(one) year from 01.07.2009 to 30.06.2010.
[10]
It is also stated that a query dated 19.01.2012 was
submitted by the respondent no. 4 to the Director, Central Bureau of
Health Intelligence, (DGHS), New Delhi for clarification about nonrequirement of MRT course for those who has already completed MRO
course. The Deputy Director, CBHI, New Delhi clarified by an email letter
dated 08.02.2012 stating that the duration of MRO course is for 12(twelve)
months and the MRT course is for 6(six) months. The person who has
already been trained in MRO training course is not considered for MRT
training, since the MRO training curriculum course is more elaborate and
further clarified that once a person has already been trained as an MRO,
further application from the same person for MRT training will not be
considered.
[11]
It is also further stated that to the query of the
Administrative Officer of Medical Directorate, J.N. Hospital, Porompat vide
letter dated 10.02.2012 about the MRO course and MRT course in respect
of the respondent no. 4, the Deputy Director, Ministry of Health & Family
Welfare, Govt. of India clarified vide its letter dated 28.02.2012 that MRO
course is conducted by CBHI at Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi for 1(one)
year duration and is more elaborated than the 6(six) months MRT training
course conducted at the same hospital by CBHI. Further, it was clarified
that MRO training course curriculum includes all the curriculum covered in
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
MRT course. In the circumstances, the DPC rightly considered the case of
the respondent no. 4 as eligible, as she has already successfully completed
the MRO training course of 1(one) year inclusive of the syllabus of 6(six)
months MRT training course. In other words, it is reiterated that MRO is a
higher qualification than MRT.
[12]
The petitioner filed an additional affidavit dated 11.09.2014
bringing on record the graduation certificate of the petitioner for passing
3(three) years degree course in Chemistry in the year 1998 from Manipur
University (in short, MU) and also the fact that in the DPC proceeding, the
respondent no. 4 was treated as undergraduate. It is pointed out that as
per
the
recruitment
rules,
graduates
are
given
preference
to
undergraduate and when graduates are not available, undergraduates can
be considered for promotion. Since the petitioner is a graduate and the
respondent no. 4 is only undergraduate, she cannot be promoted without
considering the case of the petitioner.
[13]
The respondent no. 4 filed an additional affidavit dated
09.10.2014 stating that she passed 3(three) years degree course in
Statistics from Manipur University in the year 2000 and she also had taken
leave for appearing in the examination and she appeared in the Three
Years Degree Course (TDC) Examination as a private candidate from the
MU. Documents have been annexed for applying leave and grant of leave
for appearing in the examinations.
[14]
The respondent no. 3, MPSC has also filed an additional
affidavit dated 28.01.2015 stating that in the DPC proceedings, the remark
against the respondent no. 4 to be treated as ‘undergraduate’ is a printing
mistake and it should be read as ‘graduate’ and also the same is placed on
record. Vide letter dated 01.06.2012, the Under Secretary (Health), Govt.
of Manipur, wrote to the Secretary, MPSC, Imphal for filling up the vacant
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
posts of MRT along with relevant documents including the Note for DPC.
In the Note of DPC, it is stated that there are 6(six) posts of MRT under
promotion quota. As per the existing guidelines, the allocation of quota for
5 UR posts of MRT (excluding 1 post of ST) under promotion quota
amongst the different Grades/Feeder posts is reproduced below:
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Name of Feeder Post of
different
categories/
Grades
Record Assistant
CSSD Technician
MHW
LDC
MRA
% of Quota of 5 UR Posts to
be allocated to the different
Grades/Feeder post(s)
20% of 5 posts = 1 post
20% of 5 posts = 1 post
20% of 5 posts = 1 post
20% of 5 posts = 1 post
20% of 5 posts = 1 post
Total 100%
= 5 posts
Remarks – For the 5 UR posts for 5 different feeder posts,
the % comes to 20% for each feeder post.
[15]
The names of the officials/incumbents in the five different
sub-cadres indicating their date of appointment to their parent
service/grade and date of their eligible for promotion to MRT are indicated
hereunder as separate lists:
1. Record Assistant
Sl. Name of
Post held
No. Employee &
Qualification
Date of
Appointment
1.
31.05.1994
Sh. Sumati
Devi,
Graduate
Record
Assistant
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
Date of
eligible for
promotion
to MRT
31.05.1996
She
completed
MRT course
on
30.06.1993
2. CSSD Technician
Sl. Name of
Post held
No. Employee &
Qualification
Date of
Appointment
1.
16.12.2006
L. Nobin
Singh,
Graduate
CSSD
Technician
(Petitioner)
Date of
eligible for
promotion
to MRT
01.07.2011
He
completed
MRT course
on
30.06.2011
3. Male Health Worker
Sl. Name of
Post held
No. Employee &
Qualification
Date of
Appointment
1.
MHW
14.09.1997
Sl. Name of
No. Employee &
Qualification
Post held
Date of
Appointment
1.
LDC
03.03.1987
L. Shyamo
Singh,
Graduate
Date of
eligible for
promotion
to MRT
01.01.2007
He
completed
MRT course
on
31.12.2006
4. LDC
S. Tabopi
Devi,
Graduate
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
Date of
eligible for
promotion
to MRT
01.01.1995
She
completed
MRT course
on
31.12.1994
2.
K.
Shyamkumar
Singh,
Graduate
LDC
08.01.1998
3.
Lamjahao
Lhouvam
(ST),
Graduate
LDC
18.11.1989
01.01.1995
He
completed
MRT course
on
31.12.1994
01.01.2004
He
completed
MRT on
31.12.2003
5. Medical Record Assistant
Sl. Name of
Post held
No. Employee &
Qualification
Date of
Appointment
1.
08.08.1096
M. Bimolata
Devi,
Graduate
MRA
(Res. No.4)
[16]
Date of
eligible for
promotion
to MRT
01.07.2010
She
completed
Medical
Record
Officer
course of 1
year
(inclusive of
6 months
syllabus of
MRT course)
on
30.06.2010.
Administrative Department requested the DPC to select
employee(s) from each of the feeder grades, i.e., 1(one) each from (i)
Record Assistant, (ii) CSSD Technician, (iii) Male Health Worker, (iv)
Medical Record Assistant respectively, and (v) 2(two) inclusive of 1(one)
ST employee from group of LDCs and recommend/interpolate in a
combined merit list based on their ACRs and requisite length of service in
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
the feeder grade and date from which they became eligible for
appointment by promotion to MRT.
[17]
On the recommendation of DPC and vide order dated
30.07.2012, the following 6(six) persons are appointed as Medical Record
Technician from the feeder cadres of Record Asstt./MHW/LDC/Medical
Record Asstt. and is reproduced below:
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
[18]
Name & Designation
S. Tabopi Devi, LDC
K. Shyamkumar Singh, LDC
Lamjahao Lhouvum (ST), LDC
Sh. Sumati Devi, RA
M. Bimolata, MRA - respondent no. 4 herein
L. Shyamo, MHW
Since the name of the petitioner was not recommended and
accordingly not promoted by the impugned order, he challenged the
appointment of respondent no. 4 on the ground that she was not eligible
as she did not pass the MRT 6(six) months course and 1(one) year training
course of MRO could not be considered as equivalent to MRT course as
stipulated in the rules. It is urged that the respondent no.4 is only an
undergraduate and petitioner, who is a graduate, should be given
preference in terms of the recruitment rules.
[19]
Vide judgement and order dated 01.08.2016 in W.P. (C) No.
834 of 2013, this Court dismissed the writ petition by observing that the
respondent no. 4 is a graduate and passing of 1(one) year MRO higher
training course can be treated in compliance of the requirement of MRT
course of 6(six) months. Thereafter, the petitioner filed an RTI application
dated 08.08.2016 to the CPIO, Manipur University, Canchipur requesting
to furnish the following information with respect to respondent no. 4.
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
1. Whether M. Bimolata Devi passed the B.A. (Statistics) Exam,
1999 conducted by the Manipur University under Roll No.
716591.
2. If yes, whether she is a private candidate or regular
candidate.
3. Whether B.A.(Statistics) can be pursued by a private
candidate.
[20]
The Deputy Registrar (Aca), MU furnish the following
information vide letter dated 23.08.2016 stating that –
1. Ms. M. Bimolata Devi passed the BA (STAT) in 1999 in
Second Class under Roll no. 716591.
2. She is a regular candidate as per Tabulation Sheet.
3. In no case, subjects involving Practicals can be allowed as a
Private Candidate. Statistics is a subject involving Practical
Papers in TDC 3rd Year Exam, 1999.
[21]
Upon coming to know that the respondent no. 4 passed TDC
3rd Year Exam, 1999 in Statistics as a regular candidate, the petitioner
preferred a review petition being Review Petition No. 16 of 2016 against
the order dated 01.08.2016 passed by this Court in W.P. (C) No. 834 of
2023 amongst on the ground that:
1. The respondent no. 4 made fraudulent plea that she herself
appeared as a private candidate for studying graduation,
while the University stated that she appeared as a regular
course. The order obtained by fraud is void ab initio. For
undergoing graduation course as a regular candidate, at
least 75% attendance is required. The BA (Statistics) being
a subject involving practical, it could not be possible to
complete without regular attendances. The respondent
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
no.4 never took study leave to attend regular class. Her
graduate certificate as a regular candidate cannot be
considered for the purpose of promotion by the DPC and
she should be treated as undergraduate.
2. Vide order dated 01.03.2024 in Review petition No. 16 of
2016, the matter was directed for consideration afresh
keeping in view of the contention of the respondent no. 4
as a private candidate in graduation vis-a-vis the
University’s confirmation that she was a regular candidate.
In the circumstances, the matter is heard afresh by this
Court on merit on all points.
[22]
The respondent no. 4 also filed an application being MC[W.P.
(C)] No. 277 of 2024 for dismissal of the writ petition, as the same is not
maintainable against the respondent no. 4. It is stated that as per the Note
of DPC filed by the official respondent, it is evident that there are 5(five)
different grade feeder posts, i.e., (i) Record Asstt., (ii) CSSD Tech., (iii)
MHW, (iv) LDC & (v) MRA for promotion to the post MRT (Medical Record
Technician) and for the 5(five) posts for UR available before the DPC, 1
post each was distributed for each of the 5 feeder cadres and as such only
1 person each can be recommended from the 5 feeder cadres. The
Administrative Department has also requested the DPC to select 1 each for
UR from the five feeder cadres, i.e., 1 each from Record Asstt., CSSD
Tech., MHW, LDC (+ 1 for ST) & MHW. It is stated that the DPC
recommended 6(six) candidates i.e. 3 for LDC (2 UR & 1 ST) and 1 each
from Record Asstt., MRA & MHW. Since 2 UR seats from LDC sub-quota
were recommended by the DPC for promotion, taking 1 seat from the
quota of CSSD Tech., the petitioner was not considered and not
recommended by the DPC. It is stated in the application that the petitioner
should have challenged the recommendation and subsequent promotion
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
of the excess LDC seats taken from the quota of CSSD Tech. to which the
petitioner belongs. It is highlighted that the present writ petition is not
maintainable in the present form, as the petition cannot be considered
from the sub-quota of MRA to which the respondent no. 4 belongs.
[23]
Mr. H.S. Paonam, learned sr. counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that as per the recruitment rules, the post of MRT is a Class-II
Group-B Gazetted and there are 11(eleven) posts. 50% of recruitment is
by promotion and 50% by direct recruitment and for direct recruitment,
the eligibility criteria is graduate. In case of promotion, Class-III Graduate
employee with 2(two) years regular service and trained in MRT course at
least 6(six) months duration from a recognized institution is to be
considered first, and if graduates are not available, the non-graduate
Grade-III having 5(five) years regular services in the grade and trained in
MRT training course of at least 6(six) months course from a recognized
institute can be considered. It is also pointed out that there are 5(five)
feeder posts for promotion, i.e., Record Asstt., CSSD Tech, MHW, LDC &
MRA. The learned sr. counsel for the petitioner has further pointed out
that the petitioner has attended 6(six) months MRT course from
Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi, whereas the respondent no. 4 attended
1(one) year MRO course from Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi. In absence
of any clarification or exception, the MRO training course cannot be treated
as a substitute course for MRT as stipulated in the recruitment rules and
as such the respondent no. 4 does not have the requisite qualification of
having trained in MRT for 6 months. The respondent no. 4 is
undergraduate as per the DPC proceeding, but the same is clarified by the
MPSC as graduate in the additional affidavit before this Court. It is
submitted that the proceeding of the DPC cannot be clarified or upgraded
in an affidavit filed before the Court, when the correctness of the same is
in question. It is also pointed out that in the additional affidavit filed by
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
the respondent no. 4, she stated that she passed the 3(three) years degree
course in Statistics as a private candidate from Manipur University in the
examination conducted in the year 2000. However, in the reply to RTI
application, the MU has clarified that the respondent no. 4 passed TDC 3rd
year degree course in Statistics as a regular candidate and Statistics
subject has practical papers. Since the Statistics has practical papers, the
private candidates are not allowed to appear for such examination. The
respondent no. 4 has misrepresented and played fraud on this Court by
wrongly stating that she passed 3 (three) years degree course in Statistics
as a private candidate. The graduation certificate of the respondent no.4
cannot be considered for the purpose of promotion and she should be
considered as undergraduate. As per the recruitment rules, the graduates
are to be preferred to undergraduates and only in case of non-availability
of any graduate, the undergraduate can be considered. It is submitted that
the impugned order dated 30.07.2012 promoting the respondent no. 4 for
promotion to MRT be set aside with a direction to the State Authority to
hold review DPC strictly in terms of the recruitment rules.
[24]
Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned Government Advocate for the
State respondents, has pointed out that the recruitment rules stipulate
passing of the MRT courses for 6(six) months by an employee in the feeder
cadre of Class-III. He draws attention of this Court to the clarification
submitted by the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Govt. of India that
MRO course of 1(one) year is more elaborate than MRT course of 6(six)
months and it includes all the syllabus of MRT. Ministry further adds that
a person, having attended 1(one) years training course under MRO, is not
required to undergo the 6(six) months MRT course. In the circumstances,
learned GA has submitted that the DPC rightly considered the case of the
respondent no. 4, who had successfully attended 1 year MRO course, as
eligible for consideration for promotion to the post of MRT. Since Manipur
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
University has not withdrawn the graduate certificate issued to the
respondent no. 4, the State authority cannot treat the graduation
certificate of the respondent no. 4 as void or invalid. The respondent no.
4 is a graduate with 1(one) year MRO and she is eligible as per the
recruitment rules. Learned GA also draws the attention of this Court to the
Note of DPC where for the 5(five) UR posts for promotion to MRT amongst
the 5(five) feeder cadres of Record Asstt., CSSD Tech., MHW, LDC & MRA.
In order to avoid heartburn to the employees belonging to the different
feeder cadres, 1 post each is assigned to the 5(five) feeder posts, i.e.,
20% of the 5 posts (1 post each). In other word, 1(one) UR post each is
earmarked for Record Asstt., CSSD Tech., MHW, LDC and MRA, for
promotion from the feeder cadres to the post of Medical Record Technician
for 5(five) UR vacancies and the Administrative Department requested the
DPC to select 1(one) employee each from the above 5 categories. In the
circumstances, the respondent no. 4, being the sole candidate under MRA
sub-cadre, she was recommended by the DPC and was appointed by the
State Govt. vide impugned order dated 30.07.2012. Learned GA has
further clarified that even if the respondent no. 4 is treated as
undergraduate, she has to be considered due to non-availability of any
eligible graduate candidate under MRA quota and as per the recruitment
rules, in case of non-availability of graduate employee, non-graduate
grade-III employee with 5 (five) years regular service with 6(six) months
training course of MRT is eligible. In such a peculiar situation, the
appointment of the respondent no.4 can be justified on this ground also.
The respondent no.4 has attended higher training course of MRO and has
more than 16(sixteen) years of regular service in the feeder cadre. It is
submitted that writ petition may be dismissed with cost.
[25]
On the other hand, Mr. A. Mohendro, learned counsel
for the respondent no. 4 has pointed out that it is the admitted fact that
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
the respondent no. 4 completed 1(one) year training course in MRO which
is superior and more elaborate course inclusive of the syllabus of MRT
training course of 6 (six) months. To her query, the Ministry by the email
dated 08.02.2012 clarified that MRO course is more elaborate than the
MRT and the candidate having attended the MRO training course is not
required to undergo the MRT training course for 6(six) months and as such
the respondent no. 4 has rightly been considered by the DPC as eligible in
terms of the clarification given by the Ministry. It is also pointed out that
the respondent no. 4 applied for appearing in the 3(three) years degree
course in Statistics from the Manipur University as private candidate and
she took leave for appearing in the examination and she also attended
some classes. However, she cannot be faulted for issuing a graduation
certificate as regular candidate by the MU. The issue of private or regular
candidate does not make any difference in the certificate issued by MU,
unless the university withdraws the graduation certificate issued to her.
Even if assumed as an undergraduate, the respondent no.4 is still eligible
in the RR, as she is the lone eligible employee under the MRA sub-cadre.
[26]
Mr. A. Mohendro, learned counsel for the respondent no. 4,
has clarified that on a plain reading of the certificate issued by MU, it does
not reflect whether the candidate is a private or regular. Hence, this fact
has no relevancy in considering whether the respondent no. 4 is a graduate
or not. The DPC has made some mistake in recording the respondent no.
4 as undergraduate. However, the error has been clarified and explained
by the MPSC in the additional affidavit that the respondent no. 4 should
be treated as ‘graduate’.
[27]
The learned counsel for the respondent no. 4 submits that
assuming for the sake of argument (but not admitting that respondent no.
4 is an undergraduate), she is the only eligible candidate under the subquota of MRA. She being the only available candidate under the MRA subWP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
quota of 1 seat, her appointment can be treated as valid in view of the
consideration of the non-graduate Grade-III employee due to nonavailability of the graduate MRA employee as stipulated in the RR. It is
stated that the order dated 01.08.2016 passed earlier by this Court does
not require any re-consideration, as the question of regular/private
candidate of the respondent no.4 in her graduation certificate, is not at all
relevant. It is urged that the petitioner cannot be considered for promotion
in the sub-quota of MRA and he should have challenged the excess
recommendation and promotion from the sub-quota of LDC by taking over
1 seat from the sub-quota of CSSD Tech. It is prayed that the writ petition
is not maintainable and be dismissed.
[28]
The respondent no. 4 also submitted a written submission
dated 18.07.2025 and brings on record the new fact that during the
pendency of the writ petition, the petitioner has been promoted to the post
of MRT vide order dated 08.02.2024 and the petitioner has accepted the
same without any protest and as such the cause of the writ petition does
not survive anymore.
[29]
This Court has considered the materials on record, the
submissions made at the bar, the relevant rules and case laws in this
regard.
[30]
As per the recruitment rules of 2011 for the posts of MRT
[Medical Record Technician], MRT is a Gazetted Grade-II post (50% post
is by promotion & 50% by direct recruitment) and as per record, there are
5(five) feeder cadres of Grade-III post for promotion to the post of MRT,
i.e., (i) Record Asstt., (ii) CSSD Tech., (iii) MHW, (iv)LDC, & (v) MRA. The
vacancy position before the DPC for promotion to the post of MRT for the
year 2011-2012, is 5 seats are available for UR and 1 for ST. The 5 UR
seats are divided amongst the 5 feeder cadres equally, i.e., 1 each from
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
the Record Asstt., CSSD Tech., MHW, LDC, MRA was earmarked. The
Administrative Dept. requested the DPC to select 1(one) employee from
each of the feeder grades of Record Asstt., CSSD Tech., MHW, MRA and 2
inclusive of 1 ST employee from LDC. In short, 1 UR each from the 5 feeder
cadres, 1 ST for LDC have to be recommended. 2 employees from LDC
cadre can be recommended, i.e., 1 UR and 1 ST and 1 each for the
remaining 4 cadres for the total vacancy of 6 seats. As per the recruitment
rules, the first preference is Grade-III Graduate employee with 6 months
training course in MRT from a recognized institution. In case of nonavailability of the graduate employee, non-graduate Grade-III employee
with 6 months training course in MRT can be considered for promotion.
The Ministry has clarified that MRO training course of 1 year is superior,
more elaborate and inclusive of the syllabus of 6 months MRT training
course and a person having attended the 1 years MRO course is not
required to undergo 6 months MRT course and hence, a person having
undergone the MRO course will be considered as having higher
qualification. In the circumstances, the DPC, on the basis of the
clarification by the Ministry, has considered the case of the respondent no.
4 having attended 1 years MRO course as eligible for promotion from the
feeder cadre of MRA to Medical Record Technician. On perusal of the DPC
Note submitted by the department, it is seen that object of the distribution
of 1 UR seat to all 5 feeder cadres is to have a uniformity and to remove
heartburn to the employees belonging to the various cadres. Accordingly,
the quota available from UR is 1 seat each from Record Asstt., CSSD Tech.,
MHW, LDC & MRA. Since 1 seat out of the 6 vacant seats is earmarked for
ST, 5 UR seats are distributed to the 5(five) feeder cadres and the
Administrative Department requested the DPC to recommend 1 seat each
for the 5 UR seats from the 5(five) feeder cadres and 1 LDC from ST. In
the circumstances, the DPC is required to recommend 1 seat each from
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
Record Asstt., CSSD Tech., MHW, MRA and 2 seats from LDC (1 UR & 1
ST) for the 6 (six) vacancies for the year 2011-2012.
[31]
The respondent no. 4 claims that she appeared in the 3 years
degree course in Statistics from Manipur University in the year 2000
examination as private candidate and this Court, vide order dated
01.08.2016, considered her as a graduate and held that the respondent
no. 4, being a graduate with 1 year MRO training course in terms of the
explanation by the Ministry, was held eligible for promotion to the post of
MRT under the MRA sub-quota. This aspect is directed to be examined in
the review order.
[32]
It is the case of the petitioner that the respondent no. 4 has
played fraud on this Court by misrepresenting the fact that she appeared
as private candidate in the graduation examination. In the RTI reply given
by the Manipur University, it has been clarified that the petitioner was a
regular candidate in the examination and for the subjects with practical
papers, no private candidate could appear in the examination. The
respondent no.4 did not take study leave and according to her pleading,
she was a private candidate. In terms of the explanation from the
university, her graduation certificate in Statistics cannot be considered,
having been appeared as a private candidate in Statistics subject. Hence,
the substantive qualification of the respondent no.4 is only an undergraduate and the petitioner, being a graduate, should have been preferred
to the respondent no. 4 and she cannot be considered for promotion in
terms of the recruitment rules. In the review order, the matter was
directed to be re-heard on the point of private and regular graduation
certificate of the respondent no.4.
[33]
This Court has considered the rival submissions in this
regard. In the additional affidavit of the respondent no. 4, she stated that
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
she passed 3 years degree course in Statistics in the year 2000 as a private
candidate from Manipur University. However, in the RTI reply given to the
petitioner, the MU clarified that the respondent no. 4 was a regular
candidate in the examination. It is also an admitted fact that the
graduation certificate of the respondent no. 4 has not been withdrawn till
date by MU. In the circumstances, it will not be proper for the DPC or any
other authority to treat the graduation certificate of the petitioner as
invalid, unless the same is declared as void by a competent authority/
court. It is also an admitted fact that the university or any other authority
has not declared the graduation certificate of the respondent no. 4 is
invalid or void. In view of the admitted factual matrix of the case, this
Court cannot accept the submissions of the petitioner that the respondent
no. 4 is not a graduate. Moreover, the certificate issued by Manipur
University does not indicate anything about the status of the candidature
of the respondent no.4 as private or regular. It is a graduation certificate
simpliciter.
[34]
In the alternative, if this Court presumes the respondent no.
4 is an undergraduate, she can still be adjusted against the 1(one) UR seat
from MRA sub-quota. Admittedly, the petitioner belongs a CSSD Tech. and
1 post is earmarked for the UR candidate under CSSD Tech. feeder quota
in the Note of DPC submitted by the Administrative Department. Since only
1 person is available in the MRA sub-quota of 1 UR seat and in case of
non-availability of graduate Grade-III MRA employee, the respondent no.
4 (if considered as an undergraduate) is also eligible under the second
limb of Column 11 of the of the recruitment rules. On careful examination
of the DPC proceedings, it is seen that the DPC has recommended 3
persons from LDC sub-quota, i.e., 2 UR & 1 ST thereby, 1 UR seat
earmarked for CSSD Tech. has been taken over by LDC quota. The
recommendation is done in excess of 1 UR seat under the LDC sub-cadre,
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
and the same is contrary to the proposal submitted by the Administrative
Department to the Manipur Public Service Commission. In the situation,
the petitioner who belonged to CSSD Tech. sub-cadre was omitted by the
DPC and accordingly not recommended for promotion. The petitioner
should have challenged the excess recommendation of 1 UR seat under
LDC quota, as the same has engrossed upon 1 UR quota for CSSD Tech.
sub-cadre to which the petitioner belongs. However, the petitioner chose
a wrong person, i.e., the respondent no. 4 by challenging her promotion,
whereas he should have challenged one excess recommendation and
appointment on promotion from the 1 UR LDC quota. This Court finds
substance in the application, i.e., MC[WP(C)] No. 277 of 2024 filed by the
respondent no. 4 for the dismissal of the writ petition, as the petitioner
cannot challenge the appointment of the respondent no. 4 on promotion
to MRT under MRA sub-quota. It may be noted that there is no excess
recommendation and subsequent promotion from the MRA quota.
Ironically, the petitioner has not challenged the excess appointment from
LDC quota which has taken over the 1 UR seat from the sub-quota of CSSD
Tech. This Court is not inclined to interfere with the excess
recommendations and promotion from the LDC quota, as the same has
not been challenged in the present writ petition and the interested parties
are not impleaded as respondents. In the circumstances, the writ petition
is dismissed and MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024 is allowed.
[35]
From the written submission made by the respondent no.4,
it is seen that the petitioner has been promoted to the post of MRT vide
order dated 02.08.2024 issued by Joint Secretary, Health & Family
Welfare, Govt. of Manipur. While not interfering with the excess
recommendations from the LDC quota by the DPC held on 26.02.2012 and
impugned order of appointment dated 30.07.2012, this Court is of the view
that the DPC has committed an error in recommending 1 UR seat extra in
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
the LDC sub-quota by taking over the 1 UR seat from CSSD Tech. subquota, thereby depriving the petitioner, who is the lone eligible candidate
under the CSSD Tech. quota, the opportunity for promotion. If the DPC
has taken due care in recommending the correct and accurate candidates
from the sub-feeder quota as per the guidelines and as proposed by the
Administrative Committee, the petitioner could also have been included in
the recommendation list of the DPC held on 26.02.2012 and in the
impugned appointment order dated 30.07.2012. Due to this serious lapse
on the part of DPC, the petitioner has lost the precious time of more than
12 years in waiting for promotion to the post of MRT in the year 2024,
whereas he was eligible and ought to have been recommended by the DPC
held on 26.06.2012 and subsequently would have been appointed by the
impugned order dated 30.07.2012. The petitioner has suffered for a
considerable period of time, but he chooses a wrong person to ventilate
his grievances.
DOCTRINE OF MOULDING OF RELIEF
[36]
In a recent judgment of J. Ganapatha and Ors. vs. N.
Selvarajalou Chetty Trust and Ors.: MANU/SC/0387/2025: 2025
INSC 395, Hon’ble Supreme Court discussed the concept of moulding of
relief in a proceeding based on the facts and circumstances of the case,
even if the relief granted was not actually prayed for. Relevant para is
reproduced below:
“20. The concept of moulding of relief refers to the ability of a court
to modify or shape a relief sought by a party in a legal proceeding
based on the circumstances of the case and the facts established
after a full-fledged trial. The principle enables the court to grant
appropriate remedies even if the relief requested in the pleading is
not exact or could not be considered by the court or changed
circumstances have rendered the relief obsolete. The court aims
that justice is served while taking into account the evolving nature
of a case. The above road map is pursued by a court based on the
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
notion of flexibility in relief, equitable jurisdiction, and is tempered
by judicial discretion. When moulding the relief, the court considers
the issues and circumstances established during the full-fledged
trial, looks at shortening the litigation, and then in its perspective,
renders complete justice to the issue at hand. The converse of the
above is that the moulded relief should not take the aggrieved
party by surprise or cause prejudice. The relief is moulded as an
exception and not as a matter of course.”
[37]
In the case of Shivanna and Ors. vs. B.S. Puttamadaiah
(Dead) through L.Rs.: MANU/SC/1462/2023, Hon’ble Supreme
Court reiterated the principles of moulding of relief as an exception to do
complete justice to the parties. Relevant para are quoted below for easy
understanding:
“11. The submission made by Mr. Sharanagowda Patil, learned
Counsel appearing for the Appellants and Mr. Ashwin v. Kotemath,
learned Counsel appearing for the Respondents are considered.
What is important to note here is that the First Appellate Court
declared title in favour of the Defendant although the Defendant
never put forth any such claim in the Civil Suit. The suit was filed
by the Plaintiff seeking declaration and injunction and the Appellate
Court after dismissing the suit could not have then issued the
declaration of title and possession, in favour of the Defendant,
particularly when the Defendant never claimed any such relief from
the Civil Court. It is well-settled in law that the principle of moulding
of reliefs could at best be applied as an exception. This Court in
Om
Prakash
Gupta
v.
Ranbir
B.
Goyal, MANU/SC/0035/2002 : 2002 INSC 35 : (2002) 2
SCC 256 laid down the following conditions where the relief could
be moulded:
11. The ordinary Rule of civil law is that the rights of the
parties stand crystallised on the date of the institution of the
suit and, therefore, the decree in a suit should accord with the
rights of the parties as they stood at the commencement of
the lis. However, the Court has power to take note of
subsequent events and mould the relief accordingly subject to
the following conditions being satisfied:
(i) that the relief, as claimed originally has, by reason of
subsequent events, become inappropriate or cannot be
granted;
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
(ii) that taking note of such subsequent event or changed
circumstances would shorten litigation and enable complete
justice being done to the parties; and
(iii) that such subsequent event is brought to the notice of the
court promptly and in accordance with the Rules of procedural
law so that the opposite party is not taken by surprise.”
[38]
In the circumstances, by resorting to the doctrine of
moulding of relief as an exception and in order to do complete justice to
all parties and specially to the petitioner who has become a victim of the
lapses on the part of the DPC, this Court is of the opinion that it will be in
the interest of justice, equity and legitimate expectation to direct the
Administrative Department to give notional promotion without arrears to
the petitioner for the purpose of further promotion, pensionary and other
service benefits wef 30.07.2012. The petitioner shall be placed after the
last candidate as mentioned in the impugned order 30.07.2012. The
aforementioned direction shall be complied within a period of two months
from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
[39]
FINDINGS & CONCLUSION: This Court holds and issues
the following directions:
(i)
The writ petition, being WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 is dismissed
and the application, i.e., MC[WP(C)] No. 277 of 2024 filed by the
respondent no.4 for dismissal of the writ petition, is allowed.
(ii)
The respondent no.4 has rightly been recommended for
promotion to the post of Medical Record Technician (MRT) from
the sub-cadre of Medical Record Assistant, as she is the lone
eligible candidate under this sub-cadre. 1 year MRO training course
is higher course than 6 months MRT training course as stipulated
under the recruitment rules. MRO includes all the syllabus of MRT
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
in a more comprehensive and elaborate manner and is a higher
qualification.
(iii)
The status of private or regular graduation certificate of the
respondent no.4 is not relevant in the present case, as she is the
lone available candidate under the sub-feeder cadre of Medical
Record Assistant regarding 1 UR vacancy earmarked for the same.
She has to be considered (even if assumed to be an under-
graduate) when graduate employees are not available in terms of
the service rules. Admittedly, the graduation certificate of the
respondent no.4 has not been withdrawn by the Manipur University
nor has the same been invalidated by any authority/court.
(iv)
The petitioner is the lone eligible candidate for the 1 UR seat
earmarked for CSSD Tech. sub-quota, but he was wrongly
overlooked by the DPC by recommending excess seat from LDC
sub-quota by taking over 1 UR seat from CSSD Tech. sub-quota.
(v)
In absence of any challenge to the excess recommendation
and promotion from the LDC sub-quota and non-impleading of
necessary parties, this Court is not interfering with the
recommendation of the DPC held on 26.06.2012 and the impugned
promotion order dated 30.07.2012.
(vi)
Resorting to the “doctrine of moulding of relief” and in order
to do complete justice to the petitioner who has been denied his
due promotion in the year 2012 due to the lapses on the part of
the DPC, the Administrative Department is directed to confer
notional promotion to the petitioner wef 30.07.2012 without
arrears for the purpose of further promotion, pensionary and other
service benefits, as he has been promoted to the post of MRT only
on 03.08.2024 after wait of a long tortuous 12 years. He should be
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
placed after the last person in the impugned promotion order dated
30.07.2012. This direction is to be complied within 2 months from
the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
[40]
With these directions and observations, the present WP(C)
No. 834 of 2013 is disposed of. The MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024 is also
disposed of accordingly. No cost.
[41]
Send a copy of this judgment to the Administrative Secretary
(Health), Government of Manipur for information and necessary
compliance. A compliance report be submitted to this Court.
OINAM
THOIBA
MEITEI
OINAM THOIBA
MEITEI
Date: 2025.10.28
14:22:20 +05'30'
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Thoiba
WP(C) No. 834 of 2013 with MC(WP(C)) No. 277 of 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review