The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. 11.2011. It is stated that the same is in violation of the settled proposition of law as held in the case of Rakhi Ray v. High Court of Delhi: (2010) 2 SCC 637 that vacancies cannot be filled up over and above the advertised and the candidate on panel cannot be appointed against the vacancy arising out of subsequent resignation of the person appointed. It is also stated that the petitioner did not apply for the post of Under Secretary as only one post was advertised. If more than one post were to advertised, he would have applied as he was eligible for the same post. [11] Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 & 2 has raised the preliminary objections that – (i) the delay of 5 years for filing the writ petition has not been WP(C) NO. 695 OF 2016 explained properly, (ii) the petitioner has no locus to file the present writ petition as he did not apply for the post of Under Secretary, and (iii) the issue will be academic only as the petitioner will not be eligible in subsequent recruitment process due to age bar. On merit, learned senior counsel submits that there is no illegality in appointing more candidates that the number of post advertised, as it was specifically mentioned in the advertised that the number of vacancy may be increased subject to availability of vacancy. In its proceedings dated 10.11.2011, the DPC for direct recruitment of Under …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.695 of 2016
L. Jayananda Singh, aged about 37 years,
s/o L.Ibobi Singh, resident of Singjamei
Mayengbam Leikai, Imphal West,
Imphal, Manipur
… Petitioner
-Versus1.
The Secretary, Manipur Legislative
Assembly, Government of Manipur, Imphal.
2.
The Manipur Legislative Assembly,
Represented by its Secretary, Government of
Manipur.
3.
Smt. Thokchom Nivedita Devi, Under Secretary,
Manipur Legislative Assembly Secretariat,
Imphal, Manipur.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner
::
Ms. B.Bidyalakshmi, Advocate
For the Respondents::
Mr.N.Ibotombi, Sr.Advocate,
Mr.Kh.Tarunkumar, Sr.Advocate &
H.Samarjit, Government Advocate
Date of Hearing
::
06.11.2023.
Date of Order
::
20.03.2024
WP(C) NO. 695 OF 2016
O R D E R (CAV)
[1]
Heard Ms. B. Bidyalakshmi, learned counsel for the
petitioner; Mr.Kh.Tarunkumar, Sr. Advocate assisted by Ms. Rebati,
learned counsel for respondent Nos.1&2; Mr. N. Ibotombi, Sr.
Advocate assisted by Mr. A. Rommel, learned counsel for respondent
No.3; and Mr. H. Samarjit, learned GA for respondent No.4.
[2]
The instant writ petition has been filed by the
petitioner herein
challenging the appointment order dated
22.11.2011, appointing the respondent No.3 as Under Secretary in
the Manipur Legislative Assembly. The said appointment was made
on
the
basis
of
Advertisement
dated
14.10.2011.
Before
advertisement of the said post of Under Secretary in the Manipur
Legislative Assembly, some employees who were working as Under
Secretary submitted resignation letters and in that view of such
submission of resignation letters, the authority anticipated that
some vacancies were likely to occur to the post of Under Secretary
and as such while issuing the above Advertisement dated
14.10.2011, the authority added a rider “the number of vacancy for
the above two posts may be increased subject to the availability of
vacancy”.
[3]
The petitioner neither applied for the post of Under
Secretary nor challenge the Advertisement dated 14.10.2021 but the
ground for challenging the appointment of the respondent No.3 is
that the official respondent had appointed the respondent No.3 in
excess of the advertised post.
[4]
The writ petition challenging the appointment order
dated 22.12.2011 was filed only on 14.09.2016, after a delay of
about five years, which is also not explained.
WP(C) NO. 695 OF 2016
[5]
The respondent No.3 who entered service as Under
Secretary on 22.12.2011 was given promotion to the post of Deputy
Secretary vide order dated 22.09.2014 and thereafter again
promoted to the post of Joint Secretary vide order dated
06.07.2021. The writ petitioner has not filed any rejoinder affidavit
denying the plea/explanation given/taken by the respondents in
their counter affidavit.
[6]
It is the case of the petitioner that although the
petitioner possessed all the essential and desirable qualifications for
the said post as per notification, he did not apply for the said post
as the number of vacancy was only one. However, if the number of
vacancy was more than one he would have definitely applied for the
said post and as the petitioner did not have sufficient resource for
engagement of lawyers for filing case in the Court for challenging
the said appointment order dated 22.12.2011, approached the High
Court Legal Services Committee, Imphal, and Mr.Ng.Kumar,
Advocate was appointed as Legal Aid Counsel for the petitioner.
[7]
Further, it is the case of the petitioner that the number
of vacancies/posts advertised is only one, however the official
respondents appointed respondent No.3 in excess of the advertised
posts and as such, the action of the State respondents in appointing
the respondent No.3 is wholly arbitrary and is in violation of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution and prays for a direction to the
respondents to hold fresh DPC for filling up the said resultant
vacancy/post of Under Secretary held by the respondent No.3 afresh
enabling the petitioner to apply and compete for the same.
[8]
The respondent Nos. 1 & 2 have filed affidavit in
opposition raising the preliminary point on maintainability of the
present writ petition being filed after a delay of about five years,
WP(C) NO. 695 OF 2016
which deserves to be dismissed and even if the prayer of the
petitioner is allowed and a fresh DPC/recruitment test for filling the
post of Under Secretary, present held by the answering respondent,
is to be held, the petitioner will not be eligible for the said post since
the petitioner is age barred.
[9]
In the additional affidavit it is further stated that on
the recommendation of the DPC, the Speaker, Manipur Legislative
Assembly, appointed the respondent No.3 as Deputy Secretary on
promotion vide order dated 22.09.2014 with immediate effect and
thereafter, the respondent No.3 has been appointed on promotion
to the post of Joint Secretary on the recommendation of the DPC
and the respondent No.3 is discharging duty as Joint Secretary.
Similar plea is taken by respondent No.3 in her counter affidavit.
[10]
Ms. B. Bidyalakshmi, learned counsel for the petitioner
has drawn the attention of this Court that only one post of Under
Secretary was advertised by respondent Nos.1 & 2. However, the
respondent No.3 was appointed as Under Secretary vide order
22.12.2011 in excess of the post advertised, after appointment of
one Km. Santasri Elangbam as Under Secretary vide order dated
18.11.2011. It is stated that the same is in violation of the settled
proposition of law as held in the case of Rakhi Ray v. High Court
of Delhi: (2010) 2 SCC 637 that vacancies cannot be filled up
over and above the advertised and the candidate on panel cannot
be appointed against the vacancy arising out of subsequent
resignation of the person appointed. It is also stated that the
petitioner did not apply for the post of Under Secretary as only one
post was advertised. If more than one post were to advertised, he
would have applied as he was eligible for the same post.
[11]
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel for the
respondent Nos. 1 & 2 has raised the preliminary objections that –
(i) the delay of 5 years for filing the writ petition has not been
WP(C) NO. 695 OF 2016
explained properly, (ii) the petitioner has no locus to file the present
writ petition as he did not apply for the post of Under Secretary, and
(iii) the issue will be academic only as the petitioner will not be
eligible in subsequent recruitment process due to age bar. On merit,
learned senior counsel submits that there is no illegality in
appointing more candidates that the number of post advertised, as
it was specifically mentioned in the advertised that the number of
vacancy may be increased subject to availability of vacancy. In its
proceedings dated 10.11.2011, the DPC for direct recruitment of
Under Secretary recommended the name of Santasri Elangbam for
appointment and that of the respondent No.3 as wait list panel to
meet anticipated exigency of vacancy. It is clarified that the
respondent No.3 was appointed against the resultant vacancy
available. It is submitted that the writ petition be dismissed being
devoid of any merit.
[13]
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel for the
respondent No.3 also adopts the submission of Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar,
learned counsel for respondent Nos. 1 & 2. He further submits that
the petitioner has no locus for filing the writ petition as he has not
applied for the post of Under Secretary in pursuance of the
Notification dated 14.10.2011. He refers to the decisions in the case
of RK Jain v. Union of India: (1993) 4 SCC 19 and B. Srinivasa
Reddy v. Karnataka Urban Water Supply & Drainage Board
Employees Association: (2006) 11 SCC 731 to the point that
third party has no locus in service matter. Learned senior counsel
also refers to the case of P S Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamil
Nadu: (1975) 1 SCC 152 to the point of unexplained delay in
approaching court and reluctance of the court to entertain such
petition to unsettle the already settled matter. It is pointed out that
the petitioner has miserably failed to explain the delay of 5 years
and during this time, respondent No.3 has been promoted to Deputy
WP(C) NO. 695 OF 2016
Secretary and Joint Secretary. It is also stated that the petitioner
has not rebutted the averments of the respondents by filing
rejoinder affidavit thereby admitting the same as held in (1993)
Suppl 4 SCC 46 and (2003) 8 SCC 673. It is prayed that the writ
petition be dismissed.
[14]
Mr. H. Samarjit, learned GA submits that the present
case relates to Manipur Legislative Assembly and State Government
has no role in the appointment made by it.
[15]
This Court has considered the materials on record, the
submissions made by the parties and relevant law in this regard.
[16]
From the pleading of the parties, it is seen that the
petitioner did not apply for the post of the Under Secretary in
pursuance to the Notification dated 14.10.2011 and hence, he is not
an aggrieved party. Accordingly, he has no locus to challenge the
appointment of the respondent No.3 as Under Secretary in the
Manipur Legislative Assembly. It is the settled proposition of law that
a third party has no locus to challenge appointment order of a
person by a writ of certiorari, except for a writ in the nature of quo
warranto on limited question of ineligible person occupying public
office. Besides, the petitioner has not able to explain the delay of 5
years in approaching this Court. By entertaining and allowing this
writ petition, it will amount to unsettle the established arrangement
and the respondent No.3 in now promoted to the post of Joint
Secretary. On merit also, the Notification specifically mentioned that
the vacancy may be increased subject to availability and the
respondent No.3 who was on panel, was adjusted against available
vacancy. The case law cited by the learned counsel for the petitioner
is not applicable in the present case.
WP(C) NO. 695 OF 2016
[17]
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed both on
maintainability as well as on merit. No cost.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Priyojit
signed
RAJKUMA Digitally
by RAJKUMAR
PRIYOJIT
SINGH
R PRIYOJIT
Date: 2024.04.10
SINGH
11:52:34 +05'30'
WP(C) NO. 695 OF 2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review