Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WPA 28281 of 2025
04.05.
IA No. CAN 1 of 2026
IA No. 3 of 2026
Ct. No.
Kumar Suraj and others
Vs.
Indian Maritime University and others.
---------------
Ab
Mr. Anant Shaw,
Mr. Yogesh Kumar Sharma,
Mr. Ranvijay Singh,
Mr. Vikash Agarwal.
… for the petitioners.
Mr. Bhaskar Mukherjee,
Ms. Deblina Banerjee.
… for the respondent nos. 1 to 3..
Mr. Suman Ghosh,
Mr. Pradipta Siddhanta.
… for the State.
Mr. Anil Kumar Gupta.
… for the UGC.
1. The
present
dispute
stems
from
an
act
of
commission and/or omission of the respondent
nos. 1 and 2, the Indian Maritime University, a
Central University.
2. The petitioners are 3rd Year students pursuing a
course of B.Tech (Maritime) since 2023. The
petitioners will complete the 4th Year course in
2027.
3. The petitioners have been suspended on December
5, 2025 by the Anti Ragging Committee of the
University, which has been impleaded as the
respondent no. 3 herein.
4. This entire incident of suspension on the ground of
the petitioners having been the perpetrators of a
ragging incident is what has been challenged by
way of the present writ petition.
5. The conspectus of facts is very short.
6. The 3rd Year students had indulged in an act of
ragging against some 2nd Year students, who had
lodged a complaint with the local Police Authorities
as well as the University, pursuant whereto the
University had taken steps.
7. The steps taken by the University were in terms of
the
University
Grants
Commission
Act,
(hereinafter the Act) and the regulations framed
there under in 2009 (hereinafter Regulations of
2009). In terms of the Investigation Report, which
was filed by the Anti Ragging Committee, the
petitioners were suspended for a period of six
months, which expires on June 4, 2026.
8. Mr. Shaw, learned Advocate appearing for the
petitioners, has raised the following issues:
(a) There was no incident of ragging at all. What
happened on November 22, 2025 between
two groups of students was merely a scuffle
or at best, a brawl.
(b) No complaint had been made by any of the
2nd Year students alleging ragging. What
had been alleged by the students was an
incident of disagreement, which aggravated
into an act of physical brawl between two
groups of students.
(c) There has been a gross violation of the
principles of natural justice, inasmuch as
the investigation report of the Anti Ragging
Committee, which forms the basis of an
order of suspension, was never served on
the petitioners. The petitioners were never
given an opportunity to present their case
and were merely interviewed by the Anti
Ragging Committee. The petitioners were
denied an opportunity of cross-examining
the complainants, the 2nd Year students. No
hearing was given to the petitioners prior to
meting out a severe punishment in the
nature of suspension.
(d) The
constitution
of
the
Anti
Ragging
Committee by the University is in complete
violation of the regulations framed under the
University Grants Commission Act, 1956.
The Regulation 6.3(a) specifies and indeed
stipulates the persons, who are to be
engaged
as
part
of
the
Anti
Ragging
Committee.
The
present
Anti
Ragging
Committee is in complete violation of the
particulars as specified and cannot therefore
be
construed
as
a
Committee
validly
constituted under the Regulation of 2009.
(e) He has relied on a decision of the Hon’ble
High
Court
at
Patna
in
Civil
Writ
Jurisdiction Case No. 1378 of 2022 (Vivek
Kumar and others vs. The State of Bihar
and others).
9. Mr. Mukherjee, learned Advocate appearing for the
respondent nos. 1 to 3, makes the following
submissions:
(a) The incident reported by the 2nd Year
students was reported as a ragging incident.
(b) There is no violation of principle of natural
justice as the perpetrators, the petitioners
herein, do not have any right to obtain the
investigation report or cross-examine any of
the complainants as there was no hearing,
which was required to be held nor was it
ever held.
(c) The investigation report by the Anti Ragging
Committee
was
filed
after
giving
opportunities of hearing to all the petitioners
as well as the complainants and taking into
account persons, who had in any manner
witnessed the incident or even part thereof.
Thus, there was no question of violation of
any of the principles of natural justice.
(d) In any event, in a matter of this magnitude,
not giving a mere hearing ought to be
overlooked the principles of natural justice
have to be construed in a constricted and
strict manner as held in 2018 SCC Online
Gujrat 2766, which has been relied upon by
him.
(e) The
formation
of
the
Anti
Ragging
Committee was done in a manner, which
would facilitate the entire process.
(f) Clause 6.3(a) of the Regulations of 2009 are
merely directory in nature and do not have
any mandatory force. The University Grants
Commission, the Nodal Body, has also never
objected to such Anti Ragging Committee, as
constituted by the University. The same was
put up in the Anti Ragging Website, which
was
known
to
the
UGC,
which
never
objected to the same.
(g) He has placed reliance on (2009) 7 SCC 726,
(2009) 16 SCC 712, (2013) 3 SCC 594, AIR
1993 Delhi 354 and 2018 SCC Online
(Gujrat) 2766.
10. Mr. Gupta, learned Advocate appearing for the
University Grants Commission, has made the
following submissions:
(i) The said Act provides for regulations to be
framed
thereunder,
pursuant
whereof
the
Regulations of 2009 have been framed. Thus, it
is mandatory on the respondents to proceed in
consonance with such Act and the Regulations
framed therein.
(ii) The State of West Bengal has duly adopted
the UGC Regulations, 2009. The Regulations of
2009 are mandatory in nature and are also
pervasive and are not in any manner to be
construed
as
directory
and
any
violation
thereof, will render the entire act of commission
and/or omission of the concerned Authority, in
this case the University, completely otiose.
(iii) He has relied upon two decisions reported
in (2009) 4 SCC 590 and 2025 SCC Online
1420. Both decisions are on the issue that
these Regulations framed under the said Act
are binding and mandatory in nature.
11. I have heard the learned Advocates appearing for
the parties and peruse the documents and the
judgments relied upon by them.
12. The main matter has been taken up for hearing
with the consent of all the parties, even though the
same is appearing under the heading “To Be
Mentioned”.
13. The principal issues, which require attention, may
be summarized as under:
(a) Whether the investigation has been held
following due process of law?
(b) Whether the procedure adopted conforms
to the validated procedures of propriety?
14. While exercising jurisdiction of judicial review, as
in the present case, a Court has to be extremely
cautious in its approach.
15. The accepted parameters for exercise of judicial
review are illegality, irrationality and procedural
impropriety adopted by an authority. It is not for
the Court to see whether the decision taken is right
or wrong or even whether it is correct or not. This
would mean that the Courts would unnecessarily
travel into the domain of the executive and adjudge
the
merits
of
the
decision,
which
has
been
repeatedly held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and
by various Courts of this country to be beyond the
purview of judicial review.
16. The powers of judicial review of a Court exercising
the
jurisdiction
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India stem from Article 13 of the
Constitution. The significance of judicial review is
to prevent misuse of power by an executive and
more importantly to safeguard the rights of the
citizen against any arbitrary or whimsical exercise
of such power by the executive.
17. In the process of preventing any misuse of power
and to safeguard the rights of the citizen, the
Courts are well equipped to travel into the domain
of natural justice or its violation or whether such
an act of commission or omission complained of is
ultra vires and also whether the punishment meted
out pursuant to such an act is disproportionate to
the nature of the complaint made against the errant
individuals.
18. In the present case, it would not be proper to go
into the question as to whether the incident could
be termed as an incident of scuffle or brawl or
whether it would tantamount to an act of ragging
committed by the petitioners.
19. The issue would be whether the investigation
conducted by the respondent no. 3 was done
following the due process of law and whether the
punishment meted out, that of suspension for six
months is proportionate to the action complained
of. The brief reference to the incident made in the
investigation report seems to suggest that a group
of senior students (3rd Year), had engaged in an
untoward incident resulting from a disagreement as
entailed in the investigation report itself. Whether
or not this can be construed as an incident of
ragging is best left for the experts. However,
undeniably, this was an incident of complete
misconduct whether attributable to the petitioners
or the complainants (2nd Year students) is again
beyond the domain of the writ petition. The
petitioners were hauled up for this incident and
were meted out a punishment of suspension for six
months on the basis of an investigation conducted
by the respondent no. 3.
20. It is this investigation report and far more
importantly the body, the respondent no. 3 herein,
which conducted such investigation that has to be
scrutinized.
21. Admittedly, there was no hearing held for the
purpose of coming to a finding that there was an
incident of ragging. If there was no such hearing,
the investigation report becomes the sole document
on which reliance has been placed to mete out the
punishment of suspension. The investigation report
dated November 27, 2025, inter alia, holds on a
reasonable conclusion that there was a verbal
disagreement, which led to a physical assault of
Cadet Aswar Choudhury and that the complainant
Cadets were subject to a few slaps and one of them
sustained scratch marks on his neck. Bereft of the
finding of the number of slaps and nature of
scratches,
this
much
is
clear
that
a
verbal
disagreement resulted into an assault or even a
brawl.
22. The petitioners were all interviewed as were the
complainants
and
several
others
who
had
witnessed the sequence subsequent to the incident.
It is not in dispute that an incident did occur on
the night of November 22, 2025. It is also not
dispute that these petitioners were part of such
incident whether as perpetrators or as victims is
not clear.
23. The question of violation of principles of natural
justice may not have been germane, particularly
since no hearing was held to come to the finding in
the
investigation
report
or
in
the
order
of
suspension. However, it will not be out of place to
mention that the investigation report came to the
conclusion that there had been a disagreement
between
the
parties
and
such
disagreement
resulted in certain acts of assault. Two issues arise
out of this finding. First, that it was not simplicitor
an issue of ragging. Second, that the parties were
all
part
of
an
incident,
subsequently
termed
as
subsequently,
deliberately,
which
has
been
I
say
neither
the
ragging.
since
investigation report nor the order of suspension
refers to any of the provisions under the said Act or
the Regulations of 2009 relating to ragging. It was
on the basis of the finding alone as contained in the
investigation report, that the authorities proceeded
to mete out the punishment of suspension to the
petitioners. Thus, the petitioners ought to have
been
given
an
opportunity
to
challenge
this
investigation report or at least the findings in the
investigation report. In any event, the findings of
the report are contrary to the suspension order. By
not giving a copy of the report to the petitioners,
who were affected by the findings, there is a gross
violation of the principles of natural justie. The
severity of punishment is not for the nature of the
punishment but the fact that such a punishment
would render the petitioners handicapped by one
academic year.
24. Thus, it cannot be said that there was no violation
of the principles of natural justice. It cannot,
however, be said that the punishment meted out be
said to be disproportionate to the act.
25. Thus, as the petitioners are reading to become
Marine Engineers, which requires the highest form
of discipline, the investigation and the report filed
pursuant thereof are clearly indicative of the fact
that the petitioners have acted in a manner not
befitting the Marine Engineers. There has been no
misuse
of
power
nor
any
illegality
nor
any
forseeable irrationality in the process undertaken
by the authorities to suspend the petitioners.
26. There
is
just
one
issue,
which
requires
consideration. This issue evolves from the fact that
the Regulations of 2009 specifies in 6.3(a) which is
set out herein :
“That
particularly
persons
would
be
nominated to this Committee, which it wold be
known as the Anti-Ragging Committee to be
headed by the Head of the Institution.
The
representation in this Committee has been
spelt out in no uncertain terms in the
aforestated clause of Regulations of 2009.
Clearly the respondent no. 3 herein, which
professes to be the Anti-Ragging Committee of
the University does not have these persons as
stipulated in Clause 6.3(a) of the Regulations
of 2009. The representatives of the civil and
police
administration,
local
media
non-
Government organizations involved in youth
activities and representatives of the students
belonging to freshers category do not form
part of the Committee.”
27. Mr. Mukherjee has fairly submitted that even
though a student’s representative is part of the
Anti-Ragging Committee, she was not present at
the time the investigation was made or the report
submitted.
28. It will not be out of place to mention here that the
State of West Bengal has duly adopted this
Regulation and is binding upon all the Universities.
29. In fact, the decisions relied upon by Mr. Gupta
reported in (2009) 4 SCC 590 (Para 42) and (2025)
SCC
Online
(Para
46)
are
clear
and
unequivocal that the UGC Act and the Regulations
herein are binding on all Universities whether
conventional or open.
30. Even though Mr.Mukherjee made a submission
that this particular regulation (6.3(a)) is merely
directory in nature and not mandatory, it does not
stand to reason that the entirety of the regulations
are mandatory barring this particular clause as
argued by him. The entire regulations in the form
of a subordinate legislation, permitted by the Act of
1956 itself, cannot be construed to be violative of
any of the grounds of subordinate legislation or
ultra vires thereof.
31. These regulations are construed to be part and
parcel of the process of implementation and
facilitating the object of the Act of 1956. Hence, it
would be an improper interpretation to hold that
only Clause 6.3(a) is directory in nature while all
other parts and portion of the Regulations are
mandatory.
32. In view of the afore-stated decisions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court as relied upon by Mr. Gupta, I have
no
hesitation
to
hold
that
Clause
6.3(a)
is
mandatory in nature.
33. If Clause 6.3(a) is mandatory, which it is, then
there has been a complete procedural impropriety
in the University forming the Committee as in the
respondent no. 3 and relying on a report of the
respondent no. 3 to suspend the petitioners to the
extent that they loose an academic year of their
career.
34. Mr. Mukherjee’s submission that the investigation
and the suspension have been in strict consonance
with the Regulation and particularly in terms of the
definition contained in Regulation 3(b), 3(c), 3(g)
and 3(i) do not find any support either from the
report filed by the respondent no. 3 or the order of
suspension dated December 5, 2025, issued by the
respondent no. 1.
35. In
view
of
the
afore-stated
discussions
and
observations, I hold the following :
(a) Though the acts of commission and/or
omission of the respondent nos. 1,2 and 3
cannot be termed as illegal or rational, they
suffer
from
serious
procedural
improprieties;
(b) these procedural improprieties stems from
the fact that an Anti-Ragging Committee
was constituted in violation of Clause
6.3(a) of the University Grants Commission
Regulations 2009 and thus required to be
set aside;
(c) There is other than the procedural
improprieties, the violation of the principles
of
natural
justice,
inasmuch
as
the
investigation report of November 27, 2025
ought
to
petitioners,
have
been
before
disclosed
giving
to
the
them
the
punishment on December 5, 2025. The
petitioners being the affected parties ought
to have been known and if advised would
have challenged the same, the findings of
the investigation report.
36. In view of the afore-stated, the order of suspension
dated December 5, 2025 is set aside.
37. The petitioners will be permitted to sit for their
exams, provided they have the requisite percentage
of attendance, which if they do not have on account
of the suspension, they will be permitted to obtain
such attendance after having taken the exams.
38. This order, however, will not be construed in any
manner as validating any act of indiscipline or
misconduct that the petitioners may have indulged
in.
39. With the afore-stated directions, the writ petition
is allowed and to the afore-stated extent the
connected applications, namely, CAN 1 of 2026 and
CAN 3 of 2026 are accordingly disposed of.
40. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.
41. Mr. Mukhrejee has made a prayer for stay of the
instant order. Such prayer is considered and
declined.
42. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied for, be given to the parties on priority basis.
(Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review