Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 12th August, 2026
Pronounced on: 12th October, 2026
Uploaded on: 12th October, 2026
#
CNR No: DLHC010880932024
+
RSA 203/2024, CM APPL. 70416-70417/2024 & 10075/2026
KULSUM BEGUM
W/O Late Islam Ahmad Qureshi
R/O House No.111-A, Basti Hazrat
Nizamuddin, New Delhi-110013
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Brahamjeet Tyagi and Mr. S. K.
Sharma, Advs.
versus
SYED YAYAH NIZAMI
S/O Mohd Zakaria
R/O 54, Basti Hazrat
Nizamuddin New Delhi-13
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Rajat Aneja, Senior Advocate
with Ms. Kaanchi Ahuja, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”) has been filed
against the Judgment and Decree dated 02.08.2024 passed in RCA No.
32/2024, whereby the learned First Appellate Court dismissed the Appeal
and affirmed the Order dated 05.12.2023 passed by the learned Trial Court
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
in CS SCJ No. 1935/2019, rejecting the plaint under Order VII Rule 11(d)
CPC.
2.
The Plaintiff, Kulsum Begum, filed Suit No. CS SCJ 1935/2019
seeking Declaration of title, by way of adverse possession, in respect of
property bearing No. 111-A, Basti Hazrat Nizamuddin, Delhi, along with a
decree of Permanent Injunction.
3.
The facts, in brief, as narrated in the plaint, are that the Plaintiff is the
widow of Islam Ahmed Qureshi, son of Mohd. Razi. The Plaintiff stated that
one Iliyas was in possession of property bearing No. 111-A, Basti Hazrat
Nizamuddin, Delhi-110013 (hereinafter referred to as the “suit property”),
which he left when he left for Pakistan. Thereafter, the Plaintiff’s father-inlaw, Mohd. Razi, entered into possession of the premises and remained
there.
4.
The Plaintiff asserted that the Defendant, Nayah Nizami, had never
interfered with the possession of the Plaintiff, her father-in-law or her
husband. She claimed that her possession had continued since Partition and
in any event, since her marriage to Islam Ahmed Qureshi, in 1957.
5.
The Plaintiff further stated that her children were born in the suit
property and were married from there. Her husband also passed away in the
premises, on 18.11.1996.
6.
In support of her possession, the Plaintiff relied upon her ration card,
election card, voting slips and other documents, which, according to her,
evidenced her peaceful enjoyment and possession of the suit property.
7.
The Plaintiff claimed that her possession was hostile to the Defendant
and that animus possidendi, existed as they continued in possession. She
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
further stated that her husband had constructed one room in 1992 and two
additional rooms in 1993–94, without objection from the Defendant.
8.
The Plaintiff also asserted that she had never recognised the
Defendant as the owner of the suit property and had always challenged his
title, claiming that the property belonged to Iliyas, who had left for Pakistan.
9.
According to the Plaintiff, the suit property had been declared
Evacuee Property under Section 7 of the Evacuee Property Act. The
Custodian General of India had issued a notice to Mohd. Zakaria, the
Defendant’s father, but he did not attend those proceedings or file any claim
to the suit property. The Plaintiff therefore, claimed that the property
remained with the Custodian General as evacuee property and that her
possession was continuous, adverse and hostile to the Defendant.
10.
The Plaintiff stated that the Defendant had filed Eviction Petition No.
6265/2016 against Dr. Arshad and others, without impleading her. She
filed objections before the Rent Controller, contending that the area in which
the suit property was situated, had not been urbanised and that the
provisions of the Delhi Rent Control Act did not apply to the premises, for
want of a Notification.
11.
The Plaintiff had earlier filed Civil Suit No. 893/2017, seeking a
Declaration of title to the suit property by prescription or adverse
possession. She stated that the Suit was withdrawn on 01.12.2017, with
permission to institute a fresh suit. The Plaintiff further pleaded that, at the
time, there was no law enabling her to seek such relief.
12.
The Plaintiff relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in
Ravinder Kaur Grewal v. Manjit Kaur, Civil Appeal No. 7764/2014, decided
on 07.08.2019, and the subsequent decision in Krishnamurthy S. Setlur v.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
O.V. Narasimha Setty, Civil Appeal No. 6111/2009, decided on 26.09.2019.
which recognised the right to seek a declaration of title, on the basis of
adverse possession under Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
13.
On that basis, she claimed that a fresh cause of action had arisen in
her favour and sought a Declaration of title by adverse possession, together
with Permanent Injunction for restraining the Defendant, his agents, heirs
and successors from interfering with her peaceful possession of the suit
property.
14.
The Defendant/Respondent filed an Application under Order VII
Rule 11 CPC, seeking rejection of the plaint, inter alia, on the ground that
no property bearing No. 111-A, existed. It was further contended that the
Suit was barred under Order XXIII Rule 1 and Order II Rule 2 CPC, since
the Plaintiff had withdrawn her earlier Suit bearing No. 893/2017 as well as
by the principle of res judicata, under Section 11 CPC.
15.
The Defendant further asserted that he had been declared the
owner/landlord of the entire property, whereas the Plaintiff claimed a right
only in respect of a portion of it. It was also contended that the Plaintiff was
claiming through persons, against whom an eviction Order dated 14.02.2017
had been passed, which was affirmed by the Supreme Court. The Defendant
also stated that the Plaintiff’s objections in Execution Petition No. 331/2017
had been dismissed by the learned ARC, after evidence had been led.
16.
The Defendant also objected that the Suit was not properly valued for
the purposes of court fee and jurisdiction. It was contended that the Plaintiff
claimed ownership without paying court fee on the market value of the
property, which was stated to be not less than ₹2.5 crores and beyond the
pecuniary jurisdiction of the Court.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
17.
The Defendant further contended that the Plaintiff was seeking,
through the present Suit, to overreach the jurisdiction of the Court and to
stay or stop the proceedings in Execution Petition No. 331/2017. It was also
asserted that the Suit was barred under Section 41(a) of the Specific Relief
Act, 1963. The Defendant accordingly, prayed that the plaint be rejected.
18.
The Plaintiff filed a Reply, opposing the Application.
19.
The learned Civil Judge noted that the Plaintiff had earlier filed Civil
Suit No. 893/2017, seeking, inter alia, a Declaration that the eviction Order
dated 14.02.2017 was not binding on her and that she was the owner of the
suit property by way of adverse possession. The Plaintiff had also sought a
Declaration that the suit premises were outside the jurisdiction of the Delhi
Rent Control Act and a Permanent Injunction for restraining the Defendant
from dispossessing her, except by due process of law.
20.
The learned Civil Judge further observed that, on 01.12.2017, the
Plaintiff withdrew the earlier Suit while stating that she had filed objections
in Execution Petition No. 331/2017. The Suit was disposed of as withdrawn,
without prejudice to the Plaintiff’s rights and contentions in accordance
with law. The learned Civil Judge held the withdrawal as having been
sought to pursue the objections in the Execution proceedings and held that
no permission to institute a fresh Suit had been granted.
21.
The learned Civil Judge further noted that the Plaintiff’s objections in
the Execution proceedings, had been decided by the learned ARC after
issues were framed and evidence was led. The learned Civil Judge referred
to the finding of the Ld. ARC that the objectors had failed to prove
independent title and that their claim to a separate property bearing No. 111-
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
A was unsupported. In view of the aforesaid, the Suit of the plaintiff was
rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
22.
Thereafter, the Plaintiff/Appellant challenged the Order dated
05.12.2023 by filing an Appeal bearing RCA DJ No. 32/2024.
23.
By Judgment dated 02.08.2024, the learned District Judge dismissed
the Appeal, holding that the Plaintiff had withdrawn her earlier Suit bearing
No. 893/2017, to pursue her objections in the Execution proceedings and
had not obtained permission to institute a fresh suit.
24.
It was also noted that, by Order dated 10.03.2022, the learned ARC
had dismissed the Plaintiff’s objections after finding that she had failed to
establish an independent title to the suit property under Section 25 of the
Delhi Rent Control Act. Concurring with the learned Civil Judge, the
learned District Judge held that the present Suit was barred under
Order XXIII Rule 1(4) CPC and the principle of res judicata under
Section 11, Explanation VII, CPC.
25.
Aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree dated 02.08.2024 in RCA DJ
No. 32/2024, the Plaintiff/Appellant has filed the present Regular
Second Appeal, under Section 100 CPC.
26.
The grounds of challenge are, that the learned Courts below erred in
applying Order XXIII Rule 1 CPC. The Appellant contended that the earlier
Suit bearing No. 893/2017 was withdrawn on 01.12.2017, before the
Supreme Court’s decision in Ravinder Kaur v. Manjeet Kaur, and that the
subsequent Suit was based on a fresh cause of action arising from the
recognition of a right to seek a declaration of title by adverse possession.
She further submits that, when the earlier Suit was withdrawn, there was no
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
legal basis for seeking such relief and no permission to institute a fresh Suit
was required.
27.
The Appellant also submitted that the learned ARC’s Order dated
10.03.2022 concerned her objections to Execution and her independent right
to resist dispossession under Section 25 of the Delhi Rent Control Act; it did
not determine her claim to title by adverse possession. According to the
Appellant, the Rent Controller had no jurisdiction to decide title, and the
issue of res judicata could not be determined, while considering an
Application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
28.
The Appellant contends that, while deciding the Application under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the learned Courts below relied on the Written
Statement and other matters, beyond the plaint. Only the plaint and the
documents relied upon by the Plaintiff could be considered, and that the Suit
should have proceeded to trial. Further, she stated that the subsequent Suit
raised a distinct cause of action and was not barred by Order II Rule 2 or
Section 11 CPC.
29.
The Appellant further submitted that the Order dated 01.12.2017,
disposing of the earlier Suit as withdrawn “without prejudice to the rights
and making contentions in accordance with law,” was misconstrued as
granting liberty only to pursue the Objections in the Execution. Further, she
asserted that her objection to valuation was not decided and an opportunity
was not given to her, to correct it.
30.
Moreover, the judgments relied upon by her were not properly
considered. Relying on Ravinder Kaur v. Manjeet Kaur; Keshav Sood v.
Kirti Pradeep Sood; Nagaraj & Anr. v. B.P. Mruthunjayanna & Ors.;
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
Darshan Kaur Bhatia v. Ramesh Gandhi & Anr., and Shri Hanumandas
Totala v. Hemant Vithal Kamat & Ors.,
31.
Further, the Appellant proposed the substantial questions of law as
under:
“(i) Can Order XXIII Rule 1(3) CPC is applicable to the existing facts of the
case on the grounds that the case withdrawn was instituted and there was no
authority of law?
(ii) Whether the court of Rent Controller can decide the issue of adverse
possession in any situation?”
32.
She sought setting aside of the judgment dated 02.08.2024 and
05.12.2023 and restoration of the Suit.
33.
The Respondent, in its written synopsis, opposed the Appeal, by
submitting that it raised no substantial question of law and that the Suit was
barred under Order XXIII Rule 1 CPC and Section 11, Explanation VII,
CPC. The Respondent contended that the Order dated 01.12.2017, did not
grant permission to institute a fresh Suit, and that the Appellant’s claim of
independent title, had already been adjudicated against her in the Execution
proceedings, after issues were framed and evidence was led.
34.
It was further submitted that Ravinder Kaur (supra) did not displace
the principles of res judicata or permit re-agitation of the claim. The
Respondent also alleged suppression of material facts, disentitled her from
any relief, for which he relied upon S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath,
(1994) 1 SCC 1.
35.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
The dismissal of the Appeal, was thus, sought.
RFA 203/2024
Submissions heard and record perused.
36.
The Plaintiff/Appellant filed Suit No. 1935/2019 seeking a
Declaration that she is the owner, by way of adverse possession, of property
bearing No. 111-A, Basti Hazrat Nizamuddin, Delhi-110013, and a decree
for Permanent Injunction.
37.
For an understanding of the factual background, reference may be
made to the Order dated 06.11.2024 passed in W.P. (C) No. 15470/2024.
The respondent had filed Eviction Petition No. 6265/2016 under Section
14(1)(e), read with Section 25B, Delhi Rent Control Act against Dr. Md.
Arshad and others. The tenants’ Application for leave to defend was
allowed by the learned ARC, vide Order dated 08.08.2016.
38.
This Order was challenged in Civil Miscellaneous Main No.
1007/2016 before this Court. The petition was allowed on 14.02.2017, and
the order granting leave to defend, was set aside. An Eviction Order was
consequently passed against the tenant and in favour of the Respondent.
39.
Dr. Md. Arshad preferred SLP No. 15776/2017, which was
dismissed on 04.07.2017. Thereafter, the owner/landlord initiated execution
of the Eviction Order by filing an Execution Petition No. 331/2017.
40.
The plaintiff/Appellant filed Objections under Order XXI Rule 97
CPC, and an issue was framed, as to whether she had an independent title
to the suit property, as envisaged under Section 25 of the Delhi Rent Control
Act. The learned ACJ on consideration of the evidence led by the parties,
held that the Objector/Plaintiff herein, had failed to establish an independent
title or the existence of a separate property bearing No. 111-A. The learned
ACJ also noted that, in her reply to the Notice, the objector had stated that
her family was residing with the family of Md. Iliyas, in the tenanted
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
premises. The issue was decided against the Objector and he was held to
have no independent title in the suit property and that her claim was
through the tenant, against whom the eviction petition had been decided,
vide Order dated 10.03.2022.
41.
The Order dated 10.03.2022, was not challenged by the Plaintiff and
has attained finality. The issue of the objector’s independent title, having
been finally decided against her, it could not have been re-agitated by way
of the present suit.
42.
It is contended on behalf of the appellant that the findings of the
learned Additional Rent Controller were confined to the Delhi Rent Control
Act and cannot operate as res judicata in civil proceedings.
43.
In Yadaiah & Anr. v. State of Telangana & Ors., (2023) 10 SCC 755,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court explained that an incidental, supplemental or
non-essential observation does not have that effect; only a determination
fundamental to the earlier decision and forming a vital part of its reasoning
on the merits, can operate as res judicata in subsequent proceedings.
44.
In the present case, the appellant’s claim to an independent title in the
suit premises was directly considered while considering her objections to an
Eviction Order against the tenant, and it is after framing of Issues and
consideration of evidence led by both the parties, that the Objections were
decided against her. That determination was essential for the decision on her
objections and was not merely incidental.
45.
Once the plaintiff’s title has been decided by a Court of competent
jurisdiction after recording evidence, the decision operates as res judicata.
The two courts, therefore, rightly held that the plaintiff’s suit was barred by
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
the principles of res judicata under Section 11 CPC as well as Issue
Estopple.
46.
Further, it is also an admitted fact that the plaintiff had earlier filed
Suit No. 893/2017, making the same claim for a Declaration of ownership,
by way of adverse possession. The plaintiff withdrew the said Suit, vide
Order dated 01.12.2017. In the Application for withdrawal, it was stated that
the suit suffered from a formal defect, as pointed out on the previous date of
hearing, and that the plaintiff wished to withdraw the Suit in accordance
with law.
47.
The statement of learned counsel for the plaintiff was recorded on
01.12.2017, who stated that, on the plaintiff’s instructions and authority, the
Suit was being withdrawn because the plaintiff had filed objections in
Execution Petition No. 331/2017, titled Syed Mohammad Yayah Nizami v.
Dr. Arshad, before the learned ACJ/CCJ/ARC. The Suit was thus sought to
be withdrawn “without prejudice to the rights and making contentions in
accordance with law”. On the basis of that statement, the learned ACJ
disposed of the Suit as withdrawn, noting that the objections had been filed
in the Execution Petition.
48.
The Orders passed in the earlier suit, CS No. 893/2017, show that the
Suit was withdrawn because the plaintiff had filed Objections concerning
her title in the execution proceedings and intended to pursue them. The Suit
was not withdrawn on account of a technical defect, nor was permission
sought to institute a fresh suit on the same cause of action. Order XXIII Rule
1(4) CPC provides that, where a plaintiff withdraws a Suit without
permission to file a fresh Suit on the same cause of action, the plaintiff is
precluded from instituting a fresh Suit in respect of the same subject matter.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
49.
In the present case, the plaintiff had not obtained permission to
institute a fresh Suit on the same cause of action. The present suit was
barred under Order XXIII Rule 1(4) CPC, as rightly held by the learned
Civil Judge in the Order dated 05.12.2023 and upheld by the learned District
Judge, in the Order dated 02.08.2024.
50.
The plaintiff has vehemently contended that the earlier suit was
withdrawn, because the law did not permit a declaration of title based on
adverse possession, and that this position was recognized only subsequently
by the Supreme Court, in the case of Ravinder Kaur. However, that was not
the reason for withdrawing the earlier Suit. The Appellant cannot, therefore,
raise it, as a new ground. Further, the judgment in Ravinder Kaur did not
declare the law of adverse possession, for the first time. The contention that
the judgment propounded a new law, is misconceived.
51.
The Appellant has also objected that, while deciding the Application
under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, reference was made to contentions raised in
the Written Statement. However, the Court considered only the Orders
passed by the courts, of which judicial notice can be taken under Section 57
of the Indian Evidence Act.
52.
No substantial question of law arises, in the present Second Appeal.
53.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is dismissed.
54.
The pending Applications, if any, are also disposed of, accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
OCTOBER 12, 2026/SK
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
17:27:24
RFA 203/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review