The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. To put it otherwise, it is the material irregularity or fraud which affects the method and manner of publishing the proclamation and the actual conduct of the sale clothes the Court with a jurisdiction to set aside the sale under Order 21 Rule 90 C.P.C. Where Order 21 Rule 90 applies, Section 47 is not available. However, where there is inherent illegality in the execution application, the same is a matter arising in execution, outside the purview of Order 21 Rule 90 and thus, within the scope of Section 47 of the Code. This very same proposition of law was laid down by this Court in Subrahmanya Bhat Y. v. P. Santhosh Kumar and Another, (2010 KHC 318) and in Jayarajan v. Sambasivan, [2022 (2) KLT 624].
27. In fact, the period of limitation to set aside a sale OPC 1306/24 2025:KER:26673 under Order 21 Rule 90 C.P.C. is governed by Article 127 of the Limitation Act where the period provided is 60 days from the date of sale. On the other hand, while filing an application under Section 47 C.P.C, it is three years from the date of sale under Article 137 of the Limitation Act.
28. The Apex Court in S.A. Sundararajan v. A.P.V. Rajendran, 1981 KHC 74, affirming the Full Bench decision of Madras High Court in A.P.V. Rajendran v. S.A. Sundararajan and others, (AIR 1980 Madras 123), has held that settling the proclamation of sale is part of the integral process of publishing the sale and irregularities committed in that process fall within the amplitude of Order 21 Rule 90 and thus, the Judgment Debtor cannot escape the period of limitation by framing his application as one under section 47 CPC. Thus, it can be safely concluded that the present application filed by the respondent under Section 47 is not at all maintainable OPC 1306/24 2025:KER:26673 as those aspects fall directly under the question to be adjudicated under Order 21 Rule 90 CPC. On that score also, Ext.P9 is perverse and illegal within its exercise of jurisdiction. Accordingly, I am of the view that Ext.P9 is to be set aside, and I do so. In the result, this O.P.(C.) is allowed. Sd/BASANT BALAJI dl/ OPC 1306/24 2025:KER:26673 Exhibit P1 A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION DATED 30/9/2016 IN I A NO. 4585/2016 IN OS 166/2023 FILED BY THE RESPONDENT BEFORE THE SUB COURT, ERNAKULAM Exhibit P2 A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DTD. 30/8/2017 IN O S NO. 166/2013 OF THE SUB COURT, ERNAKULAM TOGETHER WITH AGREEMENT OF THE ERNAKULAM MEDIATION CENTRE Exhibit P3 A TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DTD. 19/11/2018 IN E A 774/2…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 1306 OF 2024
OS NO.166 OF 2013 OF ASSISTANT SESSIONS COURT/PRINCIPAL SUB COURT
/COMMERCIAL COURT,NORTH PARAVUR ARISING OUT OF THE ORDER IN EP NO.6 OF
2020 OF ASSISTANT SESSIONS COURT/PRINCIPAL SUB COURT / COMMERCIAL
COURT,NORTH PARAVUR
PETITIONER/S:
KULATHU IYYER, S.S, AGED 89 YEARS
S/O. LATE S.S.M. SUBBIAH IYYER, SUDHARMA, 14/252, NEAR VARMA
CLINIC, TRIPUNITHURA, PIN - 680306
BY ADVS.
SINDHU SANTHALINGAM
A.D.SHAJAN
JESSY S.SALIM
RESPONDENT/S:
E.A. JAYAKUMAR @ JAYAN PUTHENPURACKAL
S/O. AYYAPPAN PILLAI, VISHNU VIHAR, PLOT NO. 209, THEEN
MOORTHY NAGAR, PONEKARA, EDAPPALLY., PIN - 682041
BY ADVS.ABRAHAM P.GEORGE
M.SANTHY(K/001410/1999)
RISHABH DILRAJ(K/000501/2024)
OTHER PRESENT:
ADV. SANTHALINGAM SR.
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 3.3.2025, THE COURT
ON 26.03.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 26th day of March 2025)
The petitioner herein is the decree holder/auction
purchaser and the respondent is the judgment debtor in E.P.
6/2020 in O.S 166/2013, on the files of the Sub Court, Paravur.
This petition is filed assailing the order in E.A. No 183/2023,
dated 28.2.2024, in the abovesaid E.P.
2.
The petitioner is an octogenarian, who lent an
amount of Rs. 7 lakhs to the respondent, on 02.09.2008. The
respondent provided cheques that were subsequently dishonoured
due to insufficient funds. The petitioner filed O.S. No. 166/2013
in the Sub Court, Ernakulam, on 18.02.2013, to which the
respondent has filed a written statement dated 30.01.2014, stating
that he has no means to pay and asserted the absence of property
within the court's jurisdiction. Due to the respondent's repeated
absences, he was declared ex-parte and an ex-parte decree was
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
passed against him on 05.01.2016. Thereafter, the respondent
filed a petition to set aside this decree as I.A. No. 4585/2016,
which was allowed and the case was included in the list on
01.09.2016. The respondent again failed to appear, leading to a
second ex-parte decree on 05.09.2016, following the setting aside
of the second ex-parte decree again.
3. The respondent agreed to settle the dispute through
mediation and on the basis of the mediation agreement, a
judgment was passed in terms of the mediation.
4. The petitioner filed E.P 93/2018 in the Sub Court,
Ernakulam. The respondent appeared on 05.10.2018, and filed an
objection on 26.10.2018. The Execution Court recorded "no cross
for Judgment Debtor ", since he did not appear before the court
on 7.11.2018. Subsequently, the respondent filed another
objection as Ext P3 in E.A. 774/2018 in E.P. 93/2018, again
claiming inability to pay and stated that no property is situated
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
within the jurisdiction of the Execution Court. Since the
respondent's property was at Paravur, E.P No. 93/2018 was
transferred to the Sub Court, Paravur, and renumbered as E.P No.
6/2020 and the Sub Court was directed by Ext.P4 to dispose of
the E.P. within six months.
5. Thereafter, on 27.1.2021, both parties appeared,
but on 29.1.2021, the respondent requested more time to file
objections, and was posted to 11.2.2021. On that day, neither the
respondent nor his counsel appeared, and the matter was posted
for further steps on 18.2.2021. Subsequently, an attachment
schedule (Ext P5) was filed by the petitioner on 17.2.2021. On
18.2.2021, as there was no representation from the respondent,
the petitioner submitted the Fair Value Statement (Ext P6) and
Encumbrance Certificate (Ext P7).
6. The court ordered attachment and issued a warrant,
scheduling the sale proclamation on 20.3.2021. The sale was
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
conducted on 17.1.2022, with an upset price of Rs. 15,75,000/-,
and was confirmed on 23.3.2022.
7.
The respondent failed to appear before the
Execution Court on 4.1.2021, despite serving of notice and the
court below noted appearance of the decree holder and the
endorsement of Rule 67 shows that the process was served and
the same returned unserved in view of Covid -19 restrictions. The
respondent did not object to the attachment schedule filed by the
petitioner and the draft sale proclamation was produced on
24.3.2021.
8. On 8.9.2021, as per order in E.A. No. 53/2021, the
petitioner was permitted to participate in the auction, and the
property was sold for Rs. 15,78,900/-. In fact, the decree amount
as on 8.9.2021 was more than that of the purchase price, but the
Court has miscalculated the same and has ordered for payment of
balance. On 9.11.2021, the execution court noted that the balance
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
consideration is not deposited, and the sale was not confirmed and
resale was ordered.
9.
On 30.11.2021, the court ordered notices to be
affixed to the property and directly served at the respondent's
residence. The upset price was fixed at Rs. 15,75,000/-, and the
sale was scheduled for 17.01.2022. On 18.1.2022, the court
recorded that the property was auctioned for Rs. 15,76,000/- and
scheduled the sale confirmation for 19.3.2022. The sale was
confirmed on 23.01.2022, and the E.P was closed. A Commission
Application as E.A. No.76/2022 was filed, and notice was served
on the respondent and a report was filed on 12.12.2022 (Ext P9),
and the E.A was closed. The petitioner, therefore, obtained the
encumbrance in respect of the property from the Village office.
10. Meanwhile, the petitioner filed E.A. No. 296/2022,
dated 24.3.2022 (Ext.P11), to remit stamp duty of Rs. 1,26,000/-.
E.A. No. 230/2022, Ext P12, dated 8.6.2022, was filed to obtain
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
a certified copy of the schedule of the respondent's adjacent
property in E.P. No. 146/2017, along with the obtained schedule.
Ext.P13, E.A. No. 209/2022 dated 27.9.2022 was filed to appoint
a surveyor to prepare a sketch and boundary of the scheduled
property. An application was filed on 15.11.2022 to issue a Sale
Certificate based on the Commission report and sketch as E.A.
No. 292/2022. Ext.P14 and Ext.P15 are the sale certificates
issued by the Sub Court, Paravur and that in E.A No 292/2022
respectively. Thereafter, the petitioner filed E.A. No. 113/2023
(Ext P17), requesting the court to depute an Amin for delivery of
the property.
11.
After deliberately protracting the proceedings,
the respondent filed an objection Ext.P18, to the said E.A. on
25.9.2023. Subsequently, the respondent filed an E.A.No. 183 of
2023 (Ext P19), dated 28.9.2023, under Section 47 read with
Section 151 CPC, seeking to set aside the sale conducted on
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
17.01.2022, the confirmation of sale on 23.2.2022, and the
cancellation of the sale certificate dated 13.6.2023.
12.
On 28.2.2024, the court passed an order (Ext P21)
allowing the said E.A filed under sec 47 thereby setting aside the
sale confirmation and the issuance of the sale certificate. Hence,
aggrieved by Ext P21, present O.P.(C) is filed.
13. The counsel for the petitioner contents that Under
Order 21 rule 72(2) CPC, the amount of decree may be taken as
payment of purchase money by decree holder who purchases the
property with the permission of the court. The execution court on
08.09.2021, has ordered that the property was auctioned for
Rs.15,78,900/- and for payment of balance, case was adjourned
to 09.11.2021. The decree amount available with the court was
Rs.16,29,833/- as on 08.09.2021, which is more than the purchase
price. The execution court miscalculated the decree amount to be
lesser than the purchase price and consequently ordered for resale.
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
It ought not to have ordered for resale of the property.
14. He further contended that there is no irregularity in the
publication or conduct of the sale as alleged and the irregularities
alleged were only to attract section 47 CPC and to escape from
the limitation period.
The judgment debtor neither filed
objection to the commission report nor examined the
commissioner. He had not substantiated any of his contentions by
adducing evidence. He has not objected to the auction sale at the
appropriate stage. Thus, he has no authority to question the
validity of any of the earlier proceedings at a subsequent stage.
The execution court failed to consider the merits of the case and
acted merely on the basis of groundless allegations from the side
of the respondent/Judgment debtor. The finding of the court that
no notice was served under Order 21 R 66 CPC is not correct as
the Amin has obtained the signature of Judgment Debtor on both
occasions. Affidavit verifying sale proclamation was also served
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
on him. In the present case, substance of the application shows
that it falls under Order 21 Rule 90 CPC because the sale alleged
to be vitiated was due to the irregularities which comes under
Order 21 Rule 90 and not under Section 47. The
respondent/Judgment Debtor has filed Section 47 petition so as to
escape from the period of limitation.
Thus, the execution court
ought to have held that order in E.A. 183/2023 filed under sec 47
read with section 151 CPC, is illegal and hence not maintainable.
15.
Per contra, the counsel for the respondent submitted
that after the first sale was set aside for non-payment of the
balance sale consideration, the execution court on 9.11.2021, did
not confirm the sale and re-sale was ordered. On 30.11.2021, the
execution court posted the case for settlement of proclamation
and issued notice to the judgment debtor to be served directly or
by affixture and posted it to 2.12.2021. On that day, the execution
court, without verifying as to the service of Rule 66 notice, fixed
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
the upset price at Rs.15,75,000/- and ordered sale on 17.01.2022
and for report on 18.01.2022. The Rule 66 notice was served on
the respondents only on 14.12.2022 and thus an opportunity to
object to the fixing of upset price and objection to the sale was
denied. Thus, the sale conducted on 17.01.2022 is vitiated by
material irregularities. The execution court had allowed the
petition filed by the respondent under section 47 of the CPC as
there is material irregularities. Thus, no interference is warranted
to Ext.P21.
16.
The question that arise for consideration is whether
any interference is warranted to Ext.P21 order passed under
Section 47 CPC. The execution court had raised 9 points while
considering the application under Section 47 CPC. The first two
points related to service of notice under Order 21 Rule 66 CPC.
The execution court held that no notice was served on the
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
respondent before the sale of the property on 08.09.2021. Ext.P2
is a notice issued by the execution court to the respondent under
Order 21 Rule 66 CPC intimating regarding the sale of the
property on 08.09.2021.
The endorsement of the amin on
03.08.2021 shows that the notice was affixed on the schedule
property village office, Panchayath office as well as in the notice
board of the court. Therefore, the finding of the execution court
on point Nos.1 and 2 is factually wrong.
17. Point Nos.3 and 4 are regarding the service of fresh
proclamation ordered under Order 21 Rule 87 which was served
on the judgment debtor. The execution court came to a definite
conclusion that decree holder has not taken steps for the resale of
the schedule property mandated under Order 21 Rule 87. Ext.P28
is the notice of re-sale on 17.1.2022. The notice shows that the
judgment debtor/respondent accepted the notice on 14.12.2021 in
person and it was affixed on the schedule property, village office,
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
panchayat office as well as on the notice board of the court. Thus,
the finding of the court is against facts as notice was served on
14.12.2021.
18. Point Nos.5 and 6 relate to the fixing of upset price on
the basis of the encumbrance certificate issued for a period of 12
years. The execution court had clearly stated that the decree
holder had produced a copy of the notification dated 03.04.2022
fixing the fair value of the land in Kerala Gazette and the upset
price was fixed on the basis of the fair value. Moreover Ext.P7
shows that encumbrance certificate is for a period of 12 years.
Thus, the finding in point Nos.5 and 6 are also wrong.
19. As far as the 7th point is concerned, the question is
regarding the identification of the scheduled property. It is to be
noted that the execution court has ordered attachment of the
property scheduled as Ext.P5 after identification of a part of the
property. Moreover, after receipt of the notice in the execution
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
proceedings and being represented in the court through an
Advocate on 27.11.2021, no objection is filed by the respondent.
Therefore, at the second stage, the respondent cannot raise such a
contention. There was no objection to the same extent of property
when the first sale was conducted on 8.9.2021.
From the
discussions made above, it can be safely concluded that the
execution court had, on a wrong appreciation of the facts and
documents, entered into a wrong and perverse finding to set aside
the sale under Section 47 CPC.
20. The next question to be considered is whether an
application under Section 47 is maintainable to set aside a sale on
the ground of material irregularities or fraud in publishing or
conducting it.
21.
The apex court in M/S. Brakewel Automotive
Components (India) Pvt. Ltd v. P.R Selvam Alagappan,
reported in 2017 (5) SCC 371, has held that section 47 of the
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
Code mandates determination by an executing court, questions
arising between the parties or their representatives relating to the
execution, discharge or satisfaction of the decree and does not
contemplate any adjudication beyond the same. A decree of court
of law being sacrosanct in nature, the execution thereof ought not
to be thwarted on mere asking and on untenable and purported
grounds having no bearing on the validity or the executability
thereof.
22. Judicial precedents are to the effect that the purview
of scrutiny under Section 47 of the Code qua a decree is limited
to objections to its executability on the ground of jurisdictional
infirmity or voidness are plethoric. This Court, amongst others in
Vasudev Dhanjibhai Modi v. Rajabhai Abdul Rehman and
others [1971 (1) SCR 66], in essence enunciated that only a
decree which is a nullity can be the subject matter of objection
under Section 47 of the Code and not one which is erroneous
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
either in law or on facts.
23.
Dhurandhar Prasad Singh v. Jai Prakash
University & Ors [2001 (6) SCC 534] also reiterates that the
exercise of powers under section 47 is very narrow and
microscopic and the execution court can allow objection under
sec 47 to the executability of the decree if it is found that the same
is void ab initio and a nullity, apart from the ground that the decree
is not capable of execution under the law.
24.
As per the dictum laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Jagan Singh and Company v. Ludhiana
Improvement Trust And Others, reported in [(2024) 3 SCC
308], Order 21 Rule 90(3) of the said Code clearly states that no
application to set aside a sale on grounds of irregularity or fraud
under the Rule can be entertained on any ground which the
applicant would have taken on or before the date on which the
proclamation of sale was drawn up. The Explanation to the Rule
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
further says that mere absence of or defect in attachment of the
property sold, should not by itself be a ground for setting aside
the sale under this rule.
25.
In Rajarethna Naikkan v. Parameswara Kurup
in (1997 (1) KLT 777), this court had occasion to consider the
difference between section 47 and Order 21 Rule 90 CPC,
wherein it was held that when a judgment debtor makes an
application under Order 21 Rule 90, he accepts the factum of the
sale and seeks to challenge it on the ground that the sale is vitiated
by material irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting the
sale. When an application under Section 47 CPC is made by a
judgment debtor challenging the sale, he claims the sale to be void
for illegality or in any event voidable on grounds other than those
referred to in Order 21 Rule 90. The errors committed in settling
the sale proclamation are mere irregularities and cannot be
described as errors which render a sale void and hence, Order 21
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
Rule 90 application alone can be filed. Therefore, in a case where
the judgment debtor invokes Section 47, Order 21 Rule 90 of the
Code could not be applied.
26.
To put it otherwise, it is the material irregularity or
fraud which affects the method and manner of publishing the
proclamation and the actual conduct of the sale clothes the Court
with a jurisdiction to set aside the sale under Order 21 Rule 90
C.P.C. Where Order 21 Rule 90 applies, Section 47 is not
available. However, where there is inherent illegality in the
execution application, the same is a matter arising in execution,
outside the purview of Order 21 Rule 90 and thus, within the
scope of Section 47 of the Code. This very same proposition of
law was laid down by this Court in Subrahmanya Bhat Y. v. P.
Santhosh Kumar and Another, (2010 KHC 318) and in
Jayarajan v. Sambasivan, [2022 (2) KLT 624].
27. In fact, the period of limitation to set aside a sale
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
under Order 21 Rule 90 C.P.C. is governed by Article 127 of the
Limitation Act where the period provided is 60 days from the date
of sale. On the other hand, while filing an application under
Section 47 C.P.C, it is three years from the date of sale under
Article 137 of the Limitation Act.
28.
The Apex Court in S.A. Sundararajan v. A.P.V.
Rajendran, 1981 KHC 74, affirming the Full Bench decision of
Madras High Court in A.P.V. Rajendran v. S.A. Sundararajan
and others, (AIR 1980 Madras 123), has held that settling the
proclamation of sale is part of the integral process of publishing
the sale and irregularities committed in that process fall within the
amplitude of Order 21 Rule 90 and thus, the Judgment Debtor
cannot escape the period of limitation by framing his application
as one under section 47 CPC.
Thus, it can be safely concluded that the present application
filed by the respondent under Section 47 is not at all maintainable
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
as those aspects fall directly under the question to be adjudicated
under Order 21 Rule 90 CPC. On that score also, Ext.P9 is
perverse and illegal within its exercise of jurisdiction.
Accordingly, I am of the view that Ext.P9 is to be set aside, and
I do so.
In the result, this O.P.(C.) is allowed.
Sd/BASANT BALAJI
JUDGE
dl/
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1306/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION DATED 30/9/2016 IN I
A NO. 4585/2016 IN OS 166/2023 FILED BY THE
RESPONDENT BEFORE THE SUB COURT, ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DTD. 30/8/2017 IN O S
NO. 166/2013 OF THE SUB COURT, ERNAKULAM TOGETHER
WITH AGREEMENT OF THE ERNAKULAM MEDIATION CENTRE
Exhibit P3
A TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DTD. 19/11/2018 IN E
A 774/2018 IN EP 93/2018 IN OS 166/2023 FILED BY
THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE SUB COURT, ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P4
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DTD. 24/11/2020 IN O
P ( C) NO. 1706/2020 OF THE HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF
KERALA
Exhibit P5
A TRUE COPY OF THE ATTACHMENT SCHEDULE OF THE
PROPERTY DTD. 17/2/2021 IN E P NO. 6/2020 IN O S
NO. 166/2013 BEFORE THE SUB COURT, PARAVUR FILED
BY THE PETITIONER
Exhibit P6
A TRUE COPY OF THE FAIR VALUE STATEMENT PUBLISHED
IN GAZETTE NOTIFICATION DTD. 3/4/2020
Exhibit P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE ENCUMBRANCE CERTIFICATE DTD.
25/5/2024 OF THE SUB REGISTRAR OFFICE, ALANGAD
Exhibit P8
A TRUE COPY OF THE PAPER REPORT PUBLISHED IN
MALAYALA MANORAMA DAILY DTD. 17/8/2016
Exhibit P8(a)
A TRUE COPY OF THE PAPER REPORT PUBLISHED IN
JANMABHUMI DAILY DTD. 17/8/2016
Exhibit P9
. A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMISSION REPORT DTD.
12/12/2022 IN E A NO. 76/2022 IN E P 6/2022 FILED
BY THE ADVOCATE COMMISSIONER BEFORE THE PRINCIPAL
SUB COURT, NORTH PARAVUR
Exhibit P10
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DTD. 22/9/2017 SENT BY
THE VILLAGE OFFICER, ELOOR TO THE PETITIONER
Exhibit P11
A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION DTD. 24/3/2022 IN E A
NO. 296/2022 IN E P NO. 6/2020 FILED BY THE
PETITIONER BEFORE THE SUB COURT PARAVUR
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
Exhibit P12
A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION DATED 8/6/2022 IN E A
NO. 230/2022 IN E A 76/2022 IN EP NO. 6/2020 IN O
S NO. 166/2013 TOGETHER WITH THE SCHEDULE
OBTAINED
Exhibit P13
A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION DTD. 27/9/2022 IN E A
NO. 209/2022 IN E A 76/2022 IN EP NO. 6/2020 IN O
S NO. 166/2013 FILED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE
SUB COURT, PARAVOOR
Exhibit P14
TRUE COPY OF THE SALE CERTIFICATE DTD. 13/6/2023
OF THE HON’BLE SUB COURT, PARAVOOR
Exhibit P15
A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION DATED 15/11/2022 IN E
A NO. 292/2022 IN EP NO. 6/2020 IN O S NO.
166/2013 FILED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE SUB
COURT, PARAVOOR
Exhibit P16
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS OBTAINED FROM THE
WEB SITE
Exhibit P17
A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION DTD. 21/6/2023 IN E A
NO. 113/2023 IN EP 6/2020 FILED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE SUB COURT, PARAVUR
Exhibit P18
A TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DTD. 25/9/2023 IN E
A NO. 113/2023 FILED BY THE RESPONDENT BEFORE THE
SUB COURT, N. PARAVUR
Exhibit P19
A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION DTD. 28/9/2023 IN E A
NO. 183/2023 IN E P NO. 6/2022 IN O S NO.
166/2013 FILED BY THE RESPONDENT BEFORE THE SUB
COURT, NORTH PARAVOOR
Exhibit P20
A TRUE COPY OF THE LIST OF DOCUMENTS DTD.
28/10/2023 IN E A NO. 183/2023 IN E P NO. 6/2022
IN O S NO. 166/2013 FILED BY THE RESPONDENT
BEFORE THE SUB COURT, NORTH PARAVOOR
Exhibit P21
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DTD. 28/2/2024 IN E A
NO. 183/2023 IN E P NO. 6/2022 IN O S NO.
166/2013 OF THE SUB COURT, NORTH PARAVUR
Exhibit P22
A TRUE COPY OF THE E A NO. 201/2024 IN E A NO.
76/2022 IN E P 6/2020 FILED BEFORE THE EXECUTION
COURT FOR FURNISHING THE PETITIONER ALL THE
NOTICES ISSUED TO THE JUDGMENT DEBTOR
OPC 1306/24
2025:KER:26673
Exhibit P23
A TRUE COPY OF NOTICE DTD. 9/3/2020 ISSUED BY THE
SUB COURT, NORTH PARAVUR TO THE JUDGMENT DEBTOR
FOR APPEARING BEFORE THE EXECUTION COURT FOR
HEARING ON 3/4/2020
Exhibit P24
A TRUE COPY OF THE DEPARTMENT NOTICE DTD.
22/1/2021 ISSUED BY THE PRL. SUB COURT, N.
PARAVUR TO THE RESPONDENT/JD TO ATTEND THE
HEARING ON 27/1/2021
Exhibit P25
A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DTD. 30/8/2023 ISSUED
TO THE PETITIONER TO ATTEND THE COURT TO SUBMIT
HIS OBJECTION IN E A 113/2023. THOUGH JUDGMENT
DEBTOR HAS CLEVERLY EVADED ACCEPTANCE OF NOTICE,
JUDGMENT DEBTOR’S WIFE MAYA DEVI WAS SERVED
NOTICE AND HER SIGNATURE WAS ALSO OBTAINED ON
23/8/2023 AND THE AFORESAID NOTICE TOGETHER WITH
THE ENDORSEMENT ON THE BACK SIDE
Exhibit P26
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCLAMATION NOTICE DTD.
27/7/2021 ACCEPTED BY THE AUTHORISED OFFICER AT
COLLECTORATE, ERNAKULAM ON 3/9/2021
Exhibit P27
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCLAMATION NOTICE DTD.
27/7/2021 AFFIXED ON THE PROPERTY OF THE JUDGMENT
DEBTOR
Exhibit P28
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCLAMATION NOTICE DTD.
6/12/2021 AFFIXED ON THE PROPERTY OF THE JUDGMENT
DEBTOR
Exhibit P29
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCLAMATION NOTICE DTD.
6/12/2021 AFFIXED ON THE NOTICE BOARD IN THE
OFFICE OF THE JUDGMENT DEBTOR
Exhibit P30
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS FROM 6/7/2023 TO
28/2/2024 IN E A NO.113/2023 IN E P 6/2020 IN O S
NO. 166/2013 BEFORE THE PRINCIPAL SUB COURT,
NORTH PARAVUR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review