Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 28TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA
CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION NO. 100006 OF 2021
(397(CR.PC)/438(BNSS))
BETWEEN:
KUBERAPPA S/O SOMAPPA @ SOMSHEKARAPPA
CHORAGASTI
AGE. 66 YEARS, OCC. RTD., PRINCIPAL
R/O. GADAG-582101.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. HANUMANTHAREDDY SAHUKAR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
Date: 2026.02.02
17:04:28 +0530
SMT. SUMANGALA W/O ARAVIND AKKI
AGE. 51 YEARS, OCC. HOME MAKER,
R/O KABADI ROAD, TEGGINPET,
BETGERI-GADAG-582102.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. LINGARAJ L. RATHOD, ADVOCATE FOR SRI. SUBHASH
J. BADDI, ADVOCATE)
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION IS FILED U/S 397
R/W 401 OF CR.P.C., SEEKING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT
DATED. 07/10/2020 IN CR.A.NO.97/2015 PASSED BY THE
LEARNED PRL. JUDGE FAMILY COURT AND DISTRICT AND
SESSIONS JUDGE, GADAG, AND SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND
ORDER OF SENTENCE DATED.03/11/2015 IN CC NO.502/2009
PASSED BY THE LEARNED 1ST ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC-I,
GADAG, AND ACQUIT THE PETITIONER FOR THE OFFENCE
PUNISHABLE UNDER SEC.138 OF NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENT
ACT, BY ALLOWING THE REVISION PETITION AS PRAYED FOR
WITH COST, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL ORDER
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA)
Heard Sri.Hanumanthareddy Sahukar, learned counsel
for the revision petitioner and Sri.Lingaraj L. Rathod,
learned counsel appearing on behalf of Sri.Subhash J.
Baddi, learned counsel for the respondent.
2.
Accused in CC No.502/2009 who has suffered an
order of conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable
Instruments Act which was confirmed by the First Appellate
Court
in
Crl.No.97/2015
is
the
revision
petitioner
challenging the validity of the conviction and sentence
passed by the learned Trial Magistrate.
3.
Facts of the case which are utmost necessary for
disposal of the revision petition are as under:
3.1.
A complaint came to be filed under Section 200
of Cr.P.C. alleging the commission of the offence under
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
Section
of
the
Negotiable
Instruments
Act
by
contending that complainant and accused were good friends
and in that connection, accused sought for grant of financial
assistance to the tune of Rs.1,80,000/- which was lent to
the accused by the complainant on 05.01.2009 at Gadag in
the house of the complainant wherein the accused had
agreed to repay the same within a period of two months.
3.2.
Towards repayment of the same, accused said to
have issued a cheque bearing No.639578 dated 05.03.2009
in a sum of Rs.1,80,000/-.
Said cheque on presentation
came to be dishonoured with an endorsement ‘funds
insufficient’ on 09.04.2009.
3.3.
Thereafter, a legal notice came to be issued by
the complainant demanding the payment of the amount
covered under the cheque which is duly served on the
accused but there was no compliance instead accused said
to have issued a paper publication stating that he has given
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
the cheque to Laxmanasa Meharwade and thereafter, he
died.
3.4.
Therefore, complainant filed a private complaint
against the accused and sought for action.
4.
Learned
Trial
Magistrate
after
completing
necessary formalities, secured the presence of the accused
and recorded the plea.
5.
Accused pleaded not guilty and therefore, trial
was held.
6.
In order to prove the case of the complainant,
complainant got examined herself as P.W.1 and two
witnesses namely Ravindra Ramachandra Purandwad and
Huligeppa Hadimani as P.W.2 and 3.
7.
Complainant
placed
on
record,
seven
documentary evidence which were exhibited and marked as
Exs.P.1 to 7 comprising of cheque, bank endorsement,
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
challan book, endorsement of bank, office copy of the legal
notice, postal acknowledgement and reply notice.
8.
As against the material evidence placed on
record by the complainant, two witnesses were examined
on behalf of the accused as D.W.1 and 2 namely accused
himself and Shekharappa Somappa Choragasti.
9.
On behalf of the accused, five documentary
evidence were placed on record comprising of Navodaya
daily newspaper, certified copy of the order of the Bagalkot
Court, death certificate of Laxmanasa Meharwade, office
copy of the reply notice and acknowledgement for having
sent the reply notice.
10.
recording
Learned Trial Magistrate after completing the
of
evidence,
cumulatively
appreciated
the
material evidence and convicted the accused.
11.
Being aggrieved by the same, accused filed an
appeal before the First Appellate Court in Crl.A.No.97/2015.
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
12.
Learned Judge in the First Appellate Court after
securing the records, heard the arguments of the parties in
detail and dismissed the appeal inter alia holding in
paragraph Nos.19 to 26 as under:
“19. In cases filed under Section 138 of Negotiable
Instruments
Act,
initial
burden
is
cast
upon
Complainant to prove issuance of the cheque,
bouncing of the cheque, issuance and service of
notice. As soon as Complainant discharges the
initial burden cast on him by leading cogent
evidence, there is mandatory presumption in his
favour as contemplated under the Act.
20. In present case, Complainant is examined as
PW
and
complaint.
she
reiterates
Nothing
examination
is
showing
her
elicited
that
pleadings
in
her
accused
in
cross-
had
not
borrowed money from her and that accused had
not issued cheque in her favour. I have carefully
perused
complaint.
Complainant
produced
documents at Ex.P1 to Ex.P7. Ex.P1 is cheque
which shows its number as 639578. Ex.P2 is bank
return memo dated 31/03/2009. Ex.P3 is Account
Pay in Slip. Ex.P4 is bank letter. Ex.P5 is legal
notice, Ex.P6 is postal acknowledgement. Ex.P7 is
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
reply notice. In view of evidence of PW 1 coupled
with Ex.P1
to
Ex.P7, it is to
be
held
that
Complainant has discharged initial burden cast
upon her. Now, the burden shifts on the accused to
rebut the same by leading rebuttal evidence which
should be probable and capable of being accepted
by the Court.
21. As can be seen from evidence on record, the
main contention of accused seems to be that he
had handed over 5 cheques to his brother as
security in respect of the loan to be taken and in
turn his brother had handed over the same to one
Laxmanasa
Meharwade.
Said
Meharwade
had
neither returned the cheques nor had given hand
loan to his brother. Thereafter his brother issued
public notice in news paper regarding handing over
of the cheques to Meharwade. Complainant has
filed present case misusing one of the cheques.
22. As soon as accused contends that he had
handed over blank signed cheques to his brother
who in turn handed over the same to one
Laxmanasa Meharwade, the burden shifts on him
to prove the same. significant to note that till this
date accused has not filed any criminal complaint
against Complainant on Meharwade alleging that
they had misused blank cheques issued by him as
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
security to take loan. It is significant to note that
accused is not ordinary layman and he is Principal
of Halsomeshwar School. Therefore it becomes
difficult to believe that accused had kept quiet
even
though
Complainant
had
misused
blank
cheques handed over to Meharwade.
23. It is pertinent to note that brother of the
accused had issued paper publication stating that
he
had
handed
over
blank
cheques
to
one
Meharwade. Instead he could have filed police
complaint against said Meharwade. No reason is
forthcoming from the accused as to why he did not
file complaint against said Meharwade. This is fatal
to the case of accused. It has become settled
principle of Law that if accused contends that he
had handed over blank cheques, presumption is
that he did so knowing its consequences and
therefore he cannot get any protection under Law.
Thus contention of the accused that he had handed
over blank cheques for securing loan does not hold
any water.
24. Accused has examined his brother as D.W.2. I
have carefully perused his evidence and have no
hesitation to say that there is nothing in his
evidence.Ex.D1 is paper publication. Ex. D2 is
Judgment passed by Civil Judge Court, Bagalkot.
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
Ex.D3
is
Meharwade.
death
certificate
Ex.D4
is
reply.
of
Laxmanasa
Ex.D5
is
postal
acknowledgement. Ex.D6 is Judgment passed in
some other court at Bagalkot. Ex. D7 is written
statement
filed
in
O.S.No.184/09,
Ex.D8
is
affidavit filed in said suit. Ex.D9 is order sheet in
said suit and Ex.D10 is certified copy of documents
in said suit. These documents do not come to aid
of accused in any way. Only because accused was
acquitted in those proceedings, that does not mean
that present accused also is to be acquitted in
present case. After going through materials on
record 1 am of the clear opinion that story of
accused of him handing over 5 blank signed
cheques to his brother and his brother handing
over the same to one Laxmanasa Meharwade for
taking
loan
and
complainant
misusing
those
cheques and filing false case against him has not
seen light of the day and that accused has not put
forth any material in support of his defence.
25. I have already held that Complainant has
successfully proved guilt of the accused in respect
of Ex.P1 cheque and that Complainant has filed
present
complaint
after
complying
all
the
requirement of Sec. 139 and 142 of Negotiable
Instruments Act. So, it is crystal clear that accused
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
has
committed
the
offence
punishable
under
Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
26. The Trial Court has examined materials before
it in right perspective and had properly appreciated
the oral and documentary evidence adduced before
it and has rightly come to the conclusion that the
accused has committed the offence punishable
under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments
Act and it has rightly convicted the accused for the
offence punishable under Section 138 of the
Negotiable
Instruments
Act
and
had
rightly
sentenced the accused to pay fine amount of
Rs.1,90,000/- and in default to undergo simple
imprisonment for a period of six months and had
further
ordered
that
out
of
fine
amount
Rs.10,000/- was to be forfeited to State and
remaining amount was to be paid to complainant
as compensation. I have no reason to interfere
with findings given by the Trial Court. I am of the
opinion that present appeal lacks merits.
Accordingly, I answer Points No.1 and 2 in the
Negative.”
13.
Being further aggrieved by the same, accused
filed the present revision petition on following grounds:
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
“That the judgment and order of sentence
passed by the courts below are illegal, arbitrary,
highly illegal, hence the same are liable to be set
aside.
That both the courts below have failed to see
that the respondent has not produced any
document to show that there is a transaction
between the petitioner and respondent. The
respondent has not produced any document to
show that he has paid the huge alleged amount
of
Rs.1,80,000/-
to
the
petitioner
without
obtaining any security of valuable property from
the petitioner. The courts below have failed to
see that the respondent has not proved that
there is a legally recoverable debt. In the
absence of any document to show that the
respondent has paid the alleged huge amount,
the courts below ought not to have convicted the
petitioner.
That the courts below have failed to see that the
respondent has not produced any document to
show that he is having source of income to lend
such a alleged huge amount to the respondent.
The courts below ought to have held that the
respondent has not produced any document to
show that the respondent has lent such huge
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
alleged
amount.
The
respondent
has
not
produced income tax returns to establish that
she has paid such a alleged huge amount to the
respondent and she is having so much of source
of income. In the absence of the same the
courts below are not justified in convicting the
petitioner, hence the order of the courts below
are liable to be set aside.
That
the
trial
court
wrongly
convicted
the
petitioner for the sum of Rs.1,90,000/- When
the transaction is not proved the question of
conviction does not arise, this aspect has not
been considered by the trial court and appellate
court, hence the order of conviction passed by
the trial court and confirmed by the appellate
court are liable to be set aside.
That the trial court and appellate court have not
properly considered the documents and evidence
of the petitioner to the effect that the cheque is
not given to the respondent. The brother of the
petitioner
Lakshmana
issued
R.
five
cheques
Merwade
to
for
one
Mr.
security.
Lakshmansa R Merwade died on 14.1.2009.
After his death brother of the petitioner asked
the family members regarding the said cheuqes
but they are not returned. Therefore the brother
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
of the petitioner issued legal notice to the family
members
through
paper
publication,
Hence
there is no legally recoverable debt. Hence the
order passed by the trial court and the appellate
court are liable to be set aside.
That the order passed by the trial court and
appellate
court
presumption
are
and
on
assumption
and
wrongly
convicted
the
petitioner. Hence the order passed by the courts
below are liable to be set aside.
That the trial court and appellate court failed to
see that the petitioner lead the evidence to rebut
the
presumption.
The
petitioner
examined
himself as DW 1 and one witness D.W 2 and
produced the documents at Ex. D 1 to Ex. D 5.
Hence the order passed by the trial court and
appellate court are liable to be set aside.”
14.
Learned
counsel
for
the
revision
petitioner
reiterating the grounds urged in the revision petition
vehemently contended that both the Courts have not
properly appreciated the defence taken by the accused and
wrongly
raised
the
presumption
in
favour
of
the
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
complainant resulting in miscarriage of justice and sought
for allowing the revision petition.
15.
He would further contend that the probative
value of paper publication issued by the accused and also
the probative value of certified copy of the order passed by
the Bagalkot Court is not properly appreciated while
considering the case of the accused resulting in miscarriage
of justice and sought for allowing the revision petition.
16.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent
supports the impugned judgments.
17.
He would further contend that the theory of
cheque being handed over to a person who is no more and
misuse thereof has not been established by the accused
atleast by placing plausible evidence on record.
18.
Therefore, the appreciation of material evidence
on record by both the Courts and conviction of the revision
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
petitioner is just and proper and sought for dismissal of the
revision petition.
19.
Having heard the arguments of both the parties,
this Court perused the material on record meticulously.
20.
On such perusal of the material on record, there
is no dispute that Ex.P.1 – cheque belongs to the accused
and signature found therein is that of the accused.
The
defence that has been put forth by the accused is that the
cheque was given to Laxmanasa Meharwade who is no more
and said cheque has been misused by the complainant for
wrongful gain.
21.
To establish the same, apart from self-serving
testimony of D.w.1, accused got examined another witness
as D.W.2.
22.
He has also placed on record Ex.D.1 which is a
paper publication issued in Navodaya newspaper.
As per
the same, cheque was issued by the accused to said
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
Laxmanasa Meharwade who is no more and it has been
misused.
23.
If it is so, when the accused has contacted his
Advocate for issue of reply, it was necessary for the accused
to file necessary police complaint or to take appropriate
action for misappropriation of the valuable security namely
cheque that has been done by the accused.
24.
Further, accused has also not taken any action
even after his conviction against the complainant.
25.
Another
complainant
who
according
to
the
accused having misused the cheque resulting in acquittal by
the Court at Bagalkot, will not have any bearing on the
merits of the matter in rebutting the statutory presumption
available on record in view of the admission of the fact that
cheque belongs to the accused and signature found therein
is that of the accused as is contemplated under Section 139
of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
26.
In this regard, the position of law is well settled
in the case of Rangappa v. Sri.Mohan reported in (2010)
11 SCC 441 and the similar principles has been reiterated
by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Rajesh Jain v.
Ajay Singh reported in (2023) 10 SCC 148.
27.
Taking
note
of
the
above
legal
principles
enunciated in the above decision, it is crystal clear that the
defence evidence though taken by the accused that it has
been issued to Laxmanasa Meharwade, is not probabilised.
28.
Further, if the complainant is a stranger, how she
would be in a position to come to know the address of the
accused and the cheque in fact belonged to the accused.
29.
These
aspects
of
the
matter
when
viewed
cumulatively, the theory put forward by the accused that
the complainant is a stranger cannot be countenanced in
law.
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
30.
Moreover, having regard to the scope of the
revision petition, this Court cannot revisit into the factual
aspects of the matter.
31.
When two Courts have recorded the factual
finding that the accused is guilty of the offences punishable
under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act more
so, in view of the presumption available to the complainant
under Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, this
Court does not find any legal infirmity or perversity in the
impugned judgments.
32.
This would take this Court to the next question
namely whether the sentence is excessive.
33.
Admittedly, the transaction is of the year 2008
and criminal case itself is of the year 2009, learned Trial
Magistrate has imposed fine of Rs.1,90,000/- and in the
absence of any revision petition by the complainant seeking
enhancement of the sentence, this Court does not find any
good grounds to alter the same sentence.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1014
CRL.RP No. 100006 of 2021
HC-KAR
34.
Accordingly, the following:
ORDER
Revision petition is meritless and hereby
dismissed.
Sd/(V.SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
KAV
CT-CMU
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review