Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 19TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.100026 OF 2021
BETWEEN
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
LOKAYUKTA POLICE,
POLICE INSPECTOR,
KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA,
POLICE STATION, BALLARI DISTRICT
REPRESENTED BY SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD-580001
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. SANTOSH B. MALAGOUDAR, ADVOCATE)
AND
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
Date: 2026.02.20
12:33:18 +0530
K.R. GOVINDAPPA S/O. RAMAPPA
AGE. 60 YEARS, OCC. PSI, SPL. SQUAD,
EXERCISE AND LOTTERY WING,
HAVERI, R/O. HAVERI, TAL. AND DIST. HAVERI-581110.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. A.M. GUNDAWADE, ADVOCATE)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED U/S 378(1) AND (3) OF
CR.P.C., SEEKING TO GRANT LEAVE TO APPEAL AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF ACQUITTAL PASSED BY THE PRL.
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE AND SPECIAL JUDGE, AT HAVERI,
DATED 04/03/2020 SPL. VIGILANCE CASE NO.10/2016 AND SET
ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF ACQUITTAL PASSED BY THE
PRL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE AND SPECIAL JUDGE, HAVERI
DATED 04/03/2020 IN SPL. VIGILANCE CASE NO.10/2016 AND
CONVICT AND SENTENCE THE RESPONDENT / ACCUSED PERSON FOR
THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 7 OF THE PREVENTION
OF CORRUPTION ACT, 1988.
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR
JUDGMENT
ON
03.02.2026
AND
COMING
ON
FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN
AS UNDER:
-2CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA)
The Lokayukta, Haveri, is the appellant challenging the
order passed in Special Vigilance Case No.10/2016 dated
04.03.2020 passed by the Principal District and Sessions Judge,
Haveri, wherein respondent/accused has been acquitted for the
offence punishable
under Section 7 of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988.
2.
The facts in the nutshell which are utmost necessary for
disposal of the present appeal are as under:
A complaint came to be lodged by one Sri Kotresh Basappa
Kudarihal with Lokayuktha Police, Haveri, alleging that he is
possessing the license in the name of his wife Smt.Anasuya for
running a veg and non-veg dhaba by name ‘Sri Jagadamba
Dhaba’ at Heeladahalli Cross.
He used to frequently visit
Ranibennur for purchasing grocery and other required items to
run the said dhaba.
3.
As such, on 01.03.2013 he had been to Ranibennur for
purchase of the required groceries.
At about 03.00 p.m. he
receives a phone call from his wife stating that somebody from
-3CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
Haveri came in a police jeep.
They took away the licence and
beer bottles leaving their telephone number with her. She had
forwarded the said telephone number to the complainant.
Immediately complainant contacted the said telephone number.
He received a reply stating that how he has stored beer bottles
in the dhaba and he has not given ‘ªÀiÁªÀÄÆ°’.
They asked the
complainant to come near Hiregoudru complex at Ranibennur.
Complainant could not reach the said place on time and
therefore again there was a call from the said person asking the
complainant to come near the market where cattle are sold.
4.
At about 05.30 p.m. complainant visited the said place and
noted that Sri K.R.Govindappa, PSI and Chandrashekar K.
Sanganal, constable and others were there with whom he was
not acquainted with.
5.
Thereafter, the complainant was made to sit in the jeep
and was threatened that since liquor was stored illegally in his
dhaba, case would be filed against him. If case is registered, he
would be liable to pay fine upto Rs.50,000/-.
Instead, if he
wants to settle the matter then and there, he should pay
Rs.15,000/- and he can avoid further complications.
Further,
-4CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
complainant was asked to continue paying Rs.1,000/- every
month as usual towards ‘ªÀiÁªÀÄÆ°’.
6.
At that juncture, complainant said to have replied that he
would
enquire
and
revert.
Constable
Sanganal
told the
complainant that the Inspector is very strict and if he doesn't
settle the issue, he has to run around the Court for about 8 to 10
years.
7.
in
The complainant told that he would come and meet them
Haveri.
Again
on
Saturday,
accused
No.2-Sanganal
telephoned the complainant and enquired as to why he has not
come to Haveri to meet them. Complainant replied that as his
relative is not well he could not meet them.
8.
On 04.03.2013 complainant went to Haveri and met
accused No.2 wherein he demanded the illegal gratification.
Complainant replied that he would request the PSI Govindappa accused No.1, to which accused No.2 told that PSI has gone to
the Court.
9.
Again both accused Nos.1 and 2 demanded the legal
gratification from the complainant.
Since the complainant was
not interested to part away with the money, he informed the
-5CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
Lokayukta police, Haveri.
The Lokayukta police gave a voice
recorder to the complainant to record his conversation with the
accused.
10.
As such, on 04.03.2013 complainant went to meet the
accused persons. Sanganal-accused No.2 took him to the Court
on his motorcycle. At about 01.30 p.m. accused No.1 came out
of the Court and complainant kept the voice recorder on. At that
juncture,
accused
complainant.
But
No.1
demanded
complainant
told
Rs.10,000/-
from
the
that
got
only
he
has
Rs.5,000/-. Accused told that Rs.8,000/- should be handed over
to a beeda shop fellow and told accused No.2 to work out the
monthly ‘ªÀiÁªÀÄÆ°’.
11.
Thereafter, accused No.2 and complainant went near
Upahara Darshini hotel around 02.00 p.m. and complainant
proceeded to hand over a sum of Rs.2,500/- to accused No.2.
But he refused to take the said money. However, he told that
same should be handed over to beeda shop person by name
Manju.
Accused No.2 asked the complainant as to why he is
giving only Rs.2,500/-, for which complainant replied that he
-6CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
would give the remaining amount on the next day and take back
the dhaba licence.
12.
The
Lokayukta
police
after
hearing
the
conversation
recorded by the complainant, were sure of the demand made by
the accused persons and then registered a case in Crime
No.02/2013 for the offence punishable under Section 7 of the
Prevention of Corruption Act against accused Nos.1 and 2.
13.
Based on the complaint averments, Lokayukta police
secured two independent Government servants as panchas. Five
currency notes of Rs.1,000/- denomination and one currency
note of Rs.500/- denomination were secured and recorded the
serial numbers of the said currency notes on a separate paper.
Phenolphthalein powder was smeared on those currency notes
and demonstrated the chemical reaction of phenolphthalein
powder
with
sodium
carbonate
solution.
Thereafter,
experimental mahazar was drawn.
14.
On 06.03.2013 the Lokayukta police tried for the trap the
accused but it was not successful.
Again on 08.03.2013, the
tainted currency notes were kept in the shirt pocket of the
complainant.
The complainant and shadow witness by name
-7CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
Dattaraj (P.W-2) visited the place of the accused around 11.15
a.m. At about 12.45 p.m., complainant and shadow witness
came out of the police station of the accused without giving any
pre-designated signal. Head of the raid party asked them as to
what happened.
Complainant told that accused No.1 has not
visited the police station even on the said day. The trap failed
for want of presence of accused No.1.
15.
As such, third attempt was made on 11.03.2013 which also
failed. Yet another attempt was made on 12.03.2013 which also
ended in a failed trap.
16.
A final attempt was made on 05.04.2013 at about 12.00
noon which also failed. As such, it was decided that the accused
has entertained the doubt and therefore, he is not visiting the
police station and, dropped the attempt to trap the accused and,
based on demand alone, proceeded with investigation for the
offence under Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
17.
Therefore, Lokayukta police completed the investigation
and filed the charge sheet for the offence punishable under
Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
-8CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
18.
After receipt of the charge sheet, presence of the accused
was secured by issuing summons and charges were framed.
19.
Accused No.1 pleaded not guilty. Therefore trial was held
only against him, as accused No.2 viz., Chandrashekar K.
Sanganal said to have died during the pendency of the
investigation and therefore case stood abated as against him.
20.
In order to bring home the guilt of the accused No.1-
Govindappa, prosecution examined 14 witnesses as P.Ws.1 to 14
and placed on record 102 documents which were exhibited and
marked as Exs.P-1 to P-102 besides marking four material
objects as M.Os.1 to 4.
21.
In the case on hand, complainant did not support the case
of the prosecution. So also his wife who is examined as PW-7.
22.
Admittedly, case of the prosecution is that there was
demand of illegal gratification by accused Nos.1 and 2 in respect
of dhaba licence.
Five times the investigation agency tried to
trap the accused. On all those five occasions, the trap failed. To
prove that Rs.2,500/- was paid as bribe through one Manju, who
is running a beeda shop near Upahara Darshini Hotel, there is no
proper evidence placed on record.
-9CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
23.
Likewise, the prosecution has failed to place on record any
material to show that complainant was running a dhaba by name
‘Sri Jagadamba dhaba’ and he possessed the license and accused
persons had illegally seized the license of the dhaba and in that
regard, there was a demand of illegal gratification.
24.
Taking note of these aspects of the matter, learned Trial
Judge acquitted the accused No.1 for the offence under Section 7
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, as there is no material
evidence placed on record, to substantiate the ingredients of
Section 7 of the said Act.
25.
Said judgment of acquittal is called in question by the
State in this Appeal on the following grounds:
Sri. Kotresh S/o Basappa Kudarihal complainant who
turned hostile. But the Special Court has failed to
consider why the complainant turned hostile as the
accused No.1 is the PSI in Special Squad Excise and
Lottery Wing the complainant who is running a Dhaba
and as such the accused might have over powered the
complainant to save his skin and the complainant being
the private person who runs a business don't wanted to
depose against the accused. Hence, the accused has
won over the complainant. This fact is not considered
by Special Court.
- 10 CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
PW-2 to 4 are the Shadow witness and co-panchas of
the mahazars. The panchas of the mahazar have
supported to the prosecution case but the trap was not
succeeded. Now the question arise if the accused is not
demanded the bribe amount why the complainant came
to Lokayukta Police Station and why the complainant
recorded the conversations in between the accused and
himself. Why the trial court have not the considered
conversation of the accused. In the voice recordings the
voice of the accused is identified by PW-5 and PW-6
who are accustomed with his voice and they worked
together with him. The said conversation is marked as
M.0-2. This voice recorder is not considered by the
Special
Court.
The
panchanama
where
the
conversations are written are marked as Ex.P-2. But,
the Special Court has not considered their evidence,
hence requires interference by this Honble Court.
The Special Court has failed to consider why the
complainant has given complaint against the accused.
The complainant whose signature is appearing on the
complaint and on mahazars and what made him to sign
the mahazars and why he approached the Lokayukta
Police.
Why he recorded the conversation in between
accused and himself. When it is not the case of accused
that the complainant was having vengeance against
him the trial court ought to have given consideration for
these above mentioned material documents.
The Special Court has not considered why the FIR been
the accused. Why the reason the lodged against
investigation officer and panch witnesses are supported
- 11 CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
the prosecution. What is for the investigation officer to
draw
the
mahazars.
The
Special
Court
has
not
appreciated the evidence of the mahazar witness PW-5
and PW-6 who identified the voice of accused and the
evidence
of
investigation
officer.
Therefore
the
impugned judgment suffers from laxity and the same is
perverse.
The accused was public servant is not disputed by the
defence counsel. The accused has not adduced any
rebuttal evidence to disprove the presumption under
section 20 of the P.C Act. There are no inconsistencies
or material discrepancies in the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses. Thus viewed from any angle the
judgment requires to be set aside and the accused be
suitably convicted for the alleged offence leveled
against him. “
26.
Sri Santosh B. Malagoudar, learned counsel for the State
reiterating the grounds urged in the appeal memorandum would
contend that the conversation recorded in the voice recorder is
ignored by the learned Trial Judge while acquitting the accused
for the offence under Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption
Act and thus sought for allowing the appeal.
27.
He would further contend that even in the absence of a
proper trial, offence under Section 7 of the Prevention of
Corruption Act stands established by virtue of the material
placed on record and thus sought for allowing the appeal.
- 12 CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
28.
Per contra, Sri A.M.Gundawade, learned counsel for the
respondent/accused
supports
the
impugned
judgment
and
sought for dismissal of the appeal by contending that there is no
material evidence on record even to attract the ingredients of the
offence under Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
29.
I have heard the arguments of both sides and perused the
material on record meticulously.
30.
On such perusal of the material on record, following points
would arise for consideration:
(i)
Whether
the
Prosecution
has
successfully
established all the ingredients to attract the offence under
Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act?
(ii)
Whether the impugned judgment is suffering from
legal infirmity or perversity and thus calls for interference?
(iii)
If answer to point No.(i) is in the affirmative what
is the sentence?
(iv)
31.
What Order?
REGARDING POINT Nos.(i) AND (ii): In the case
on
hand, the prosecution alleged that when the complainant had
been to bring grocery from Ranibennur, accused persons visited
the dhaba run by the complainant in the name and style ‘Sri
- 13 CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
Jagadamba Dhaba’, serving both vegetarian and non vegetarian
food.
They seized the license and beer bottles from the said
dhaba. They had furnished their telephone number to the wife of
complainant(PW-7) who was present in the dhaba at that time.
32.
Accordingly complainant contacted the telephone number
furnished by PW-7 and at that juncture there was a demand for
illegal gratification.
Complainant met the accused near cattle
market in Ranibennur.
33.
The accused threatened the complainant that a case would
be filed under Excise Act for storing the beer bottles illegally for
which complainant would be fined upto Rs.50,000/-.
If the
complainant wanted to settled the matter then and there only,
he has to pay Rs.15,000/- as illegal gratification and Rs.1,000/of monthly ‘ªÀiÁªÀÄÆ°’.
34.
The complainant was not interested in parting away the
bribe money as demanded by the accused.
Therefore, he
approached the Lokayukta police who gave him the voice
recorder.
- 14 CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
35.
The
complainant
conversation
between
recorded
the
by
the
accused
complainant
is
and
part
of
the
the
experimental mahazar(Ex.P.2).
36.
Thereafter complainant met the accused and as per the
instructions of the accused, complainant said to have paid sum of
Rs.2,500/- to the beeda shop owner by name Manju in the
presence of accused No.2 who is no more and case stood abated
as against him.
37.
To establish these aspects of the matter, prosecution
examined the complainant and his wife as P.Ws.1 and 7. Both of
them have turned hostile to the case of the prosecution.
38.
In the case on hand, since there is a failure of the trap,
charge sheet is filed for the offence under Section 7 of the
Prevention of Corruption Act only.
39.
Based on the voice recording of the accused No. 2, that too
extracted in the experimental mahazar marked at Ex.P.2 in the
absence of any proper proof including the Certification under
Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, the learned Trial Judge
was constrained to acquit the accused for want of necessary
material evidence on record.
- 15 CRL.A No.100026 of 2021
40.
It is also observed by the learned Trial Judge that to
establish that the complainant and his wife were running a hotel
in the name ‘Sri Jagadamba Dhaba’ no material evidence is
collected by the Investigation Agency which would go to show
that the investigation has been done in a perfunctory manner.
41.
Therefore, viewed from any angle, this Court does not find
any good reasons to interfere with the Order of acquittal passed
by the learned Trial Judge.
42.
Accordingly, point Nos.(i) and (ii) are answered in the
negative.
43.
REGARDING POINT No.(iii):
Since the finding of this
Court on point No.(i) is in the negative, this point would not arise
for consideration.
44.
REGARDING POINT No.(iv):
In view of the finding of
this Court on point Nos.(i) to (iii) as above, the following:
(i)
ORDER
Appeal dismissed.
(ii)
Bail bond stands discharged.
Sd/(V.SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
kcm
CT-CMU
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review