Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 3rd OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 1643 of 2019
BETWEEN:KRISHNAVALLABH DECEASED THROUGH LR SMT KETKI VYAS W/O
LATE SHRI KRISHNAVALLABH VAYS, AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
1.
OCCUPATION: HOUSEHOLD, R/O 60, YANTRA MAHAL MARG,
JAYSINGHPURA, UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
KRISHNAVALLABH DECEASED THROUGH LR MITHILESH S/O LATE
SHI KRISHNAVALLABH VYAS, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, R/O 60,
2.
YANTRA MAHAL MARG, JAYSINGHPURA UJJAIN (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT S
(NO.1 BY SHRI MURARI LAL PATHAK, ADVOCATE.)
AND
MAHENDRA S/O RAJARAM JAT, AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
1. OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE GRAM HARSODAN, TEHSIL AND DISTT
UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
GRAM PANCHAYAT HARSODAN THROUGH SARPANCH GRAM
2. PANCHAYAT HARSODAN GRAM PANCHAYAT HARSODAN TEHSIL
UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
COLLECTOR THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH KOTHI PALACE
UJJIAN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(NONE PRESENT FOR THE RESPONDENTS.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This appeal coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
-2-
ORDER
The appellants / defendants have filed this appeal under
Section 100 of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 against the (i) judgment and
decree dated 22.12.2016 passed in Civil Suit No.18A/2016 whereby the
suit filed by the respondents / plaintiffs has been decreed and, (ii)
judgment dated 25.02.2019 passed in Civil Appeal No.3A/2018 passed
by Third Additional District Judge, Ujjain whereby the first appeal filed
by the defendants has been dismissed.
Facts of the case in short are as under:
02.
Plaintiff-Mahendra filed a civil suit for declaration and
permanent injunction in respect of the suit land bearing survey No.384/3
area 0.060 hectare at Gram Harsodan, Tehsil and District Ujjain.
According to the plaintiff, said land is an ancestral land and he got this
land from his father. According to him, the defendant has constructed a
house on 30 x 30 sq.ft. of suit land on survey No.384/3 (hereinafter
referred to as “disputed land”). The plaintiff objected to the construction
but the defendant created the dispute which gave him a cause of action
for filing the suit. Before filing the suit, the plaintiff applied for
demarcation before the Tehsildar Ujjain. The Tehsildar directed Patwari
and Revenue Inspector to conduct a demarcation and as per the report
submitted by the Revenue Inspector, the construction of a home by the
defendant No.1 was found on a suit land and accordingly the Tehsildar
passed an order dated 14.12.2010 hence, the plaintiff claimed possession
of the disputed land of 30 x 30 sq.ft. and the means profit @ Rs.500/per month. The plaintiff also sought an injunction that the respondent be
restrained to interfere into possession of the plaintiff.
-3-
03.
According to the plaintiff, his name has been mutated in the
revenue record and revenue authorities have issued the Rin Pustika in
his name and he is regularly paying the lease rent.
04.
The defendant filed the written statement contending that he
did not receive the notice from the Tehsildar, therefore, the order dated
14.12.2010 is not binding on him. The demarcation was carried out in
his absence. It is further submitted that he purchased the land 30 x 30
sq.ft. by way of registered sale-deed from Laxminarayan Patidar.
Initially, a land area 30 x 60 sq.ft. was allotted by Gram Panchayat
Harsaudan to one Bashir Sheikh thereafter, it was transferred in the
name of Rafique Sheikh S/o Bashir Sheikh and certificate to that effect
dated 10.09.1986 was issued by the Panchayat. Thereafter, Rafique
Sheikh sold 30 x 30 sq.ft. plot in Rs.17,500/- to Laxminarayan Patidar.
The Gram Panchayat granted permission to Laxminarayan for
construction of the house on 13.11.1998 thereafter, the defendant No.1
purchased the said plot from Laxminarayan by registered sale-deed
hence, the suit be dismissed.
05.
The learned Civil Judge framed 7 issues for adjudication,
plaintiff examined himself as PW/1 and exhibited 6 documents as
exhibit P/1 and P/6. The defendant examined himself as DW/1 and
exhibited 18 documents as Exhibit D/1 to D/18.
06.
The learned Court appointed a Commissioner to conduct a
demarcation under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC. A panchnama dated
08.09.2016 (Exhibit C/1) was prepared and the Revenue Inspector
submitted a report dated 08.09.2016 (Exhibit C/4) before the Court
according to which the 30 x 30 sq.ft. house constructed by the defendant
-4-
is found on a land bearing survey No.384/3 belonging to the petitioner.
07.
After appreciating the evidence came on record, the learned
Civil Judge vide judgment dated 22.12.2016 decreed the suit in favour
of the plaintiff by directing defendant to handover the vacant possession
of the disputed land within two months and also pay means profit @
Rs.200/- per month from January 2011 to the plaintiff. Learned Civil
Judge has also held that the defendant illegally constructed a house on
30 x 30 sq.ft. i.e. 900 sq.ft. on survey No.384/3 area 0.060 hectare
owned by the plaintiff. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment, the
defendant preferred an appeal and vide judgment dated 25.02.2019 first
appeal has been dismissed. Hence, this second appeal before this Court.
08.
I have heard the learned counsel for the appellant and
perused the record.
09.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the plaintiff
has not produced any document to establish that the land bearing survey
No.384/3 was an ancestral and he got the same by way of succession or
partition from his father. He has not filed any document of ownership
except the Kharsa panchshala and Rin Pustika which cannot be treated
as title document as held by this Court in case of Lakhanlal V/s
Narsingh [2019 (4) M.P.L.J. 517]. It is further submitted that in case of
Jitendra Singh V/s The State of M.P. and others [2021 SAR (Civ) 992]
the Apex Court has held that entry in the revenue register or jamabandhi
are only for the purpose of payment of land revenue, no ownership is
conferred.
10.
Learned counsel has also placed reliance on a judgment
passed in case of Chairman, Board of Trustee, Sri Ram Mandir Jagtial
-5-
Karimnagar District, A.P V/s S. Rajyalaxmi (Dead) & Ors. [2019 SAR
(Civil) 188] in which the Apex Court has held that the suit for
declaration of title, the burden to prove ownership over the suit property
is on the plaintiff which cannot be shifted on defendant. It is further
submitted that the demarcation proceeding has wrongly been relief on
which were drawn behind the back of the defendant.
11.
Therefore, the judgment and decree are perverse and liable
to be set aside. He has proposed the following substantial question of
law:
1. Whether the suit filed by Plaintiff is without complying
with the provisions of S. 108 of M.P. Panchayat Raj and
Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam against Defendant Number 2.
2. Whether both the Lower Courts have erred in holding that
the revenue entries are the documents of title.
3. Whether the Coruts below have erred in facts & law that
the demarcation report is not as per the provisions of S. 129
of M.P. Land Revenue Code.
4. Whether the findings of both the Lower Courts are
perverse to the documents, records and as well as evidence.
12.
The plaintiff in support of his claim filed the khasra
panchshala of the year 2009-10 in which the land bearing survey
No.384/3 area 0.060 hectare is recorded in his name. There is an entry of
the house and the plaintiff mortgaged the aforesaid land and took loan of
Rs.3,60,000/- from the State Bank of India. Therefore, the bank
recognized the said khasra entries and the ownership of the plaintiff to
grant the loan. On the basis of the said entries, the Rin Pustika was also
prepared in favour of the plaintiff and he has been regularly paying the
rent. During pendency of the plaint, the defendant Krishnavallabh
expired and his legal heirs were brought on record and Mithlesh Vyas
-6-
S/o Krishnavallabh examined himself as DW/1.
13.
The defendant claimed the ownership by virtue of the sale-
deed dated 09.11.2009. The defendant has not filed any title document
to establish the title of Laxminarayan. He has also not filed any
document to establish the title of predecessor Bashir Sheikh (afterwards
it was transferred in the name of Rafique Sheikh S/o Bashir Sheikh)
who said to have been allotted the land by the Gram Panchayat. In
paragraph No.25 & 26 of the cross-examination the DW/1 admits that it
is correct that in Exhibit D/1 i.e. sale-deed the survey number of the land
is not mentioned, therefore, the defendant has failed to establish that the
land which he purchased i.e. 30 x 30 sq.ft. is part of survey No.384/3.
The Commissioner’s report Exhibit C/4 has duly established that the
defendant constructed the house on the land belonging to the plaintiff
i.e. survey No.384/3.
14.
The defendant came up with the plea that he is the owner of
the land 30 x 30 sq.ft. by virtue of sale-deed hence, the burden was on
him to prove his title. The plaintiff has filed a revenue record in which
his name is recorded as Bhoomi Swami as well as the Rin Pustika both
the documents are statutory documents issued under the provisions of
Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959 therefore, as compared to
the title document filed by the defendant, the plaintiff is having a better
title documents. The defendant has only produced the sale-deed by
which he said to have purchased the plot No.402/1 Ward No.5 without
there being survey number of land. No one has been examined from the
Gram Panchayat to establish that the plot No.402/1 is situated on survey
No.384/3 which belongs to the Gram Panchayat. The defendant did not
-7-
apply for mutation in revenue record after execution of sale-deed DW/1.
15.
In view of the above, when the defendant came up with the
specific plea that he is the owner of the land area 30 x 30 sq.ft. by virtue
of sale-deed dated 09.11.2009, then burden is on him to establish title of
vendor and predecessor hence, I do not find any question of law
involved in this case. There are concurrent findings recorded by both the
Courts which are not liable to be interfered in second appeal as held by
Apex Court in following cases:
16.
Kondiba Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai Sopan Gujar : (1999)
3 SCC 722, has held as under:
5. It is not within the domain of the High Court to investigate the
grounds on which the findings were arrived at, by the last court
of fact, being the first appellate court. It is true that the lower
appellate court should not ordinarily reject witnesses accepted by
the trial court in respect of credibility but even where it has
rejected the witnesses accepted by the trial court, the same is no
ground for interference in second appeal when it is found that the
appellate court has given satisfactory reasons for doing so. In a
case where from a given set of circumstances two inferences are
possible, one drawn by the lower appellate court is binding on the
High Court in second appeal. Adopting any other approach is not
permissible. The High Court cannot substitute its opinion for the
opinion of the first appellate court unless it is found that the
conclusions drawn by the lower appellate court were erroneous
being contrary to the mandatory provisions of law applicable or
its settled position on the basis of pronouncements made by the
Apex Court, or was based upon inadmissible evidence or arrived
at without evidence.
6. If the question of law termed as a substantial ques-tion stands
already decided by a larger Bench of the High Court concerned
or by the Privy Council or by the Federal Court or by the
Supreme Court, its merely wrong application on the facts of the
case would not be termed to be a substantial question of law.
Where a point of law has not been pleaded or is found to be
arising between the parties in the absence of any factual format, a
litigant should not be allowed to raise that question as a
substantial question of law in second appeal. The mere
appreciation of the facts, the documentary evidence or the
-8meaning of entries and the contents of the document cannot be
held to be raising a substantial question of law. But where it is
found that the first appellate court has assumed jurisdiction
which did not vest in it, the same can be adjudicated in the
second appeal, treating it as a substantial question of law. Where
the first appellate court is shown to have exercised its discretion
in a judicial manner, it cannot be termed to be an error either of
law or of procedure requiring interference in second appeal. This
Court in Reserve Bank of India v. Ramkrishna Govind Morey
[AIR 1976 SC 830]held that whether the trial court should not
have exercised its jurisdiction differently is not a question of law
justifying interference.
17.
In case of Laxmidevamma v. Ranganath : (2015) 4 SCC
264, again the Apex court has held as under:
16. Based on oral and documentary evidence, both the courts
below have recorded concurrent findings of fact that the plaintiffs have established their right in A schedule property. In the
light of the concurrent findings of fact, no substantial questions
of law arose in the High Court and there was no substantial
ground for reappreciation of evidence. While so, the High Court
proceeded to observe that the first plaintiff has earmarked the A
schedule property for road and that she could not have fullfledged right and on that premise proceeded to hold that
declaration to the plaintiffs’ right cannot be granted. In exercise
of jurisdiction under Section 100 CPC, concurrent findings of
fact cannot be upset by the High Court unless the findings so
recorded are shown to be perverse. In our considered view, the
High Court did not keep in view that the concurrent findings
recorded by the courts below, are based on oral and documentary
evidence and the judgment of the High Court cannot be
sustained.
18.
Recently, the Apex Court in case of Adiveppa & Others Vs.
Bhimappa & Others : (2017) 9 SCC 586 has held as under:
"17. Here is a case where two Courts below, on appreciating
the entire evidence, have come to a conclusion that the Plaintiffs
failed to prove their case in relation to both the suit properties.
The concurrent findings of facts recorded by the two Courts,
which do not involve any question of law much less substantial
question of law, are binding on this Court.
18. It is more so when these findings are neither against the
pleadings nor against the evidence and nor contrary to any
provision of law. They are also not perverse to the extent that no
-9such findings could ever be recorded by any judicial person. In
other words, unless the findings of facts, though concurrent, are
found to be extremely perverse so as to affect the judicial
conscious of a judge, they would be binding on the Appellate
Court."
19.
With the aforesaid, Second Appeal is dismissed.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Divyansh
SHUKLA
Date: 2024.01.05 17:46:49 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review