Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:23404
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.NAGARESH
THURSDAY, THE 20TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 29TH PHALGUNA, 1946
SA NO. 742 OF 1999
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 22.09.1998 IN AS NO.152 OF 1991 OF
I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, PALAKKAD ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT
DATED 30.03.1991 IN OS NO.300 OF 1986 OF ADDITIONAL SUB COURT,
PALAKKAD.
APPELLANTS (APPELLANTS / DEFENDANTS 1 TO 4):
KRISHNAMANI
S/O.PAZHANIYAPPA MUDALI,
RESIDING AT THENARI AMSOM AND DESOM,
PALAKKAD TALUK, PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
SHANMUGHAN,
S/O..DO., RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
RADHAKRISHNAN,
S/O.THANKAMANI, RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
PARVATHY,
W/O.THANKAMANI,RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
BY ADVS.
SMT.PRABHA R.MENON
SRI.PUSHPARAJAN KODOTH
SRI. A.P. CHANDRASEKHARAN (SR.)
SRI. M. KRISHNA KUMAR
RESPONDENTS (RESPONDENTS / PLAINTIFFS &
DEFENDANTS 5 TO 7 & 10 TO 16):
* 1
CHAMIYAR,
(DIED)
S/O.KUNCHAN, RESIDING AT KUTTIYAMPAK,
THENARI AMSOM, PALAKKAD TALUK,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
:2:
* 2
PARIJATHAM,
(DIED)
S/O.CHAMIYAR, RESIDING AT PARAMBAKKAD,
PERUVEMBA AMSOM, PALAKKAD TALUK, P
ALAKKAD DISTRICT.
* 3
RAMAKRISHNAN,
(DIED)
S/O.KUNCHAN, RESIDING AT KUTTIYAMPAK,
THENARI AMSOM, PALAKKAD TALUK,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
* 4
RAMAKRISHNAN,
(DIED)
S/O.KANDAN, RESIDING AT VAKKALA KALAM,
THENARI AMSOM, PALAKKAD TALUK.
CHILDREN KANNADASAN,
KANNADASAN, RESIDING AT VAKKALAKALAM,
THENARI AMSOM, PALAKKAD TALUK.
JAGADEESH KUMAR,
RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
KRISHNA MOORTHY,
RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
(RESPONDENTS 5 TO 7 ARE RECORDED AS LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES OF DECEASED 4TH RESPONDENT AS
PER ORDER DATED 16.01.2019 IN IA. NO.5/2019 IN
SA. NO.742/1999)
* 8
GOPALAN NAIR, (DELETED)
S/O.OORANDATH KALLYANI AMMA, RESIDING AT
VAKKALA KALAM, THENARI, ELAPULLY (PO),
PALAKKAD TALUK.
* 9
THILLA,
(DELETED)
S/O.KATTIYAMPAKKIL VELAYUDHAN, RESIDING AT
VATHANKULUMBA, THENARI (PO), PALAKKAD.
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
:3:
* 10
THATHA,
(DELETED)
W/O.VAKALAKALAM RAJAN, RESIDING AT VAKKALA
KALAM, THENARI, ELAPULLY P.O., PALAKKAD.
(RESPONDENTS 8, 9 & 10 ARE DELETED FROM THE
PARTY ARRAY AT THE RISK OF THE APPELLANT AS PER
ORDER DATED 03.03.2010 IN IA.577/2010)
RAMAN,
S/O.MARUKANDI, RESIDING AT KATTIYAMPAK,
THENARI AMSOM, PALAKKAD.
SAROJINI'S CHILDREN :
RAJESWARI,
KUTTIYAMPAK,THENARI AMSOM,
PALAKKAD TALUK.
RAJESH,
RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
RADHIKA,
RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
RENUKA,
RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
RAMESH (MINOR)
16 YEARS, RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
RATHISH (MINOR)
14 YEARS, RESIDING AT .DO. .DO.
(MINOR RESPONDENTS 16 AND 17 ARE REPRESENTED BY
GUARDIAN FATHER RAMAN, 11TH RESPONDENT.
* 18
KUNCHAPPAN,
AGED 54 YEARS
SON OF CHAMIYAR, RESIDING AT KUTTIYAMPAK,
THENARI (P.O.), PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
:4:
* 19
ANANTHAKRISHNAN,
AGED 43 YEARS
SON OF CHAMIYAR
RESIDING AT KIZHAKKEPURA KUTTAMPAK,
THENARI (P.O.), PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
(ADDITIONAL RESPONDENTS 18 & 19 ARE IMPLEADED
AND 2ND RESPONDENT IS RECORDED AS LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVE OF DECEASED 1ST RESPONDENT AS
PER ORDER DATED 02.04.2024 IN IA.NO.2386/2011
(RENUMBERED
AS
IA.NO.5/2011)
AND
IA.NO.2388/2011 (RENUMBERED AS IA.NO.4/2011)
RESPECTIVELY IN SA.NO.742/1999)
* 20
VIJAYAM,
AGED 65 YEARS
W/O.RAMAKRISHNAN,
RESIDING AT KIZHAKKEPPURA,
KUTTIYAMPAK,THENARI P.O.,
ELAPPULLY,PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
* 21
RAJESH,
AGED 40 YEARS
S/O.RAMAKRISHNAN,
RESIDING AT KIZHAKKEPPURA,
KUTTIYAMPAK,
THENARI P.O.,ELAPPULLY,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
* 22
RAJEEV,
AGED 35 YEARS
S/O.RAMAKRISHNAN,
RESIDING AT KIZHAKKEPPURA,
KUTTIYAMPAK,THENARI P.O.,
ELAPPULLY,PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
* 23
RAMESH,
AGED 33 YEARS
S/O.RAMAKRISHNAN,
RESIDING AT KIZHAKKEPPURA,
KUTTIYAMPAK,THENARI P.O.,
ELAPPULLY,PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
:5:
* 24
RATHEESH,
AGED 31 YEARS
S/O.RAMAKRISHNAN,
RESIDING AT KIZHAKKEPPURA,
KUTTIYAMPAK,THENARI P.O.,
ELAPPULLY,PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
* 25
RAJANEESH,
AGED 29 YEARS
S/O.RAMAKRISHNAN,
RESIDING AT KIZHAKKEPPURA,
KUTTIYAMPAK,THENARI P.O.,
ELAPPULLY,PALAKKAD DISTRICT.
(LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES
OF
DECEASED
3RD
RESPONDENT
ARE
IMPLEADED
AS
ADDITIONAL
RESPONDENTS 20 TO 25 AS PER ORDER DATED
18.06.2024 IN IA.NO.2385/2011 (IA.3/2011) IN
SA.NO.742/1999.
* 26
JAYARAJAN P.K.,
RESIDING AT KALYANI NIVAS,
PARAMBAKKAD,PERUVAMBA P.O.,PALAKKAD-678531.
* 27
SREEKRISHNA P.J.,
RESIDING AT KALYANI NIVAS,PARAMBAKKAD,
PERUVAMBA P.O.,PALAKKAD-678531.
* 28
KAVITHA P.J.,
W/O.SIVANANDAN K.,PALANCHERIKALAM,
NENMENI P.O.,KOLLENGODE,PALAKKAD-768506.
* 29
RADHIKA J.,
W/O.RAJEEV V.G.,ILLATHUKULAM,
PIRAYIRI P.O.,PALAKKAD-678004.
(LEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED 2ND RESPONDENT ARE
IMPLEADED AS ADDITIONAL RESPONDENTS 26 TO 29 AS
PER ORDER DATED 03.07.2024 IN IA.NO.4/2019 IN
SA. NO.742/1999)
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
:6:
* 30
DAKSHAYANI,
RESIDING AT VAKKALAKALAM,NOMBIKODE,
ELAPULLY P.O.,PALAKKAD-678622.
(ADDITIONAL 30TH RESPONDENT IS IMPLEADED AS
LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES
OF
DECEASED
4TH
RESPONDENT AS PER ORDER DATED 02.04.2024 IN
IA.NO.3/2019 IN SA.NO.742/1999)
BY ADVS.
RAJESH SIVARAMANKUTTY, FOR R30
MAYA C.P., FOR R30
K.V.ANTONY, FOR R30
VIJINA K., FOR R30
ARUL MURALIDHARAN, FOR R30
J.MARY HELP JOHN DAVID, FOR R1 & R4
S.RAMACHANDRAN, FOR R1 & R4
THIS SECOND APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
07.08.2024, THE COURT ON 20.03.2025 DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
:7:
N. NAGARESH, J.
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
S.A. No.742 of 1999
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
Dated this the 20th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
~~~~~~~~~
Defendants 1 to 4 in OS No.300/1986 on the files
of the Sub Court, Palakkad and the appellants in AS
No.152/1991 on the files of the District Court, Palakkad, are
the appellants in this Second Appeal.
The appellants
challenge the judgment and decree dated 22.09.1998 in AS
No.152/1991 and the judgment and decree dated 30.03.1991
in OS No.300/1986. In this judgment, parties are referred to
as they are described in the OS, for clarity.
2.
Plaintiffs (respondents 1 to 7) filed the suit for
declaration that they are entitled to half of the water in the
plaint schedule tanks and to restrain the defendants from
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
:8:
objecting to take half of the water from the tanks and further
from obstructing the Ramesam Pottakulam filling with water
from Kunnamkattupathy through pipe 206 and to restrain the
defendants from diverting the water to the Vathankulambu
Nilam from pipe 206.
The plaintiffs further sought for a
decree to allow them to walk through the varamba of the
defendants' field to draw half the water and catch fish.
3.
three
In the plaint, the plaintiffs stated that there are
tanks
which
originally
belonged
to
Ekkanathu
Tharavadu and the water from the said tanks was utilised for
irrigating the paddy fields in Kuttiyambak belonging to the
aforesaid family. The fields at Kuttiyambak were taken on
lease by Kunjan, father of plaintiffs 1 to 3. Water from the
aforesaid tanks was utilised for irrigation.
Ramesam
Pottakulam used to be filled up with water from Cochin Sarkar
through pipe 206.
4.
The Jenmi wanted to terminate the lease and the
1st plaintiff, son of Kunjan, released the entire properties to
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
:9:
the Jenmi on 30.03.1953. On the very same day, as per a
registered lease deed, the 1st plaintiff took half of the
properties on lease. Half of the properties were entrusted to
the 4th plaintiff.
The remaining half was retained by the
Jenmi. The tanks scheduled in the plaint were also released
in favour of the Jenmi. However, the right to collect half of the
water from the tanks for irrigation of paddy fields in the
possession of the tenants, was retained.
5.
The plaintiffs stated that on the southern side of
Kuttiyambak Nilam, the Jenmi had certain other paddy fields
named Vathankulambu Nilam.
Those paddy fields were
cultivated using the water from Kunnamkattupathy channel.
Water from the plaint schedule tanks was never used for
irrigation of Vathankulambu paddy fields.
The Jenmi sold
their rights over the property retained by them to defendants 1
to 4 (appellants herein).
Defendants 1 to 4 started
obstructing the right of plaintiffs to take water from the tanks.
They have started to pump out the water from Ramesam
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 10 :
Pottakulam for irrigation of Vathankulambu paddy fields.
They also tried to channelise the water from pipe 206 to
Vathankulambu paddy fields. They have no right to do so.
6.
The plaintiffs urged that though the defendants
have purchased the plaint schedule tanks, they will not get
right for the entire water in the tank. The plaintiffs claimed
that they are entitled to half the water in the plaint schedule
tanks.
7.
The defendants contended that Kunjan was not in
possession as a lessee of the entire Kuttiyambak Nilam. The
defendants are not aware of lease deed executed on
30.03.1953. The tanks were in the possession of Jenmi at all
times. The Jenmi has not given right to the plaintiffs to use
half of the water from the tanks. They are entitled only to
collect the let out by the Jenmi from the tanks. The water
which comes through the pipe of Kunnamkattupathy channel
is used not only for Ramesam Pottakulam.
certain other paddy fields also.
It is used for
The plaintiffs have never
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 11 :
taken water from the tanks. The defendants are not bound by
the lease deed.
8.
Based on the pleadings, the Sub Court framed the
following issues:
(1)
Whether the plaintiffs' father Kunjan was a
lessee of Kuttiyambakkam paddy field and
whether he was in exclusive enjoyment of the
tanks mentioned in the plaint?
(2)
Whether the surrender mentioned in the plaint
is true?
(3)
Whether the plaintiffs surrendered a portion of
the land included in the pattom chit and took
on lease the other lands and whether the
plaintiffs were using the water of the tank as
of right?
(4)
Whether the tenants were in possession of
the tanks and were using the water?
(5)
Is there any cause of action for the suit?
(6)
Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get the
declaration and injunction prayed for?
(7)
Reliefs and costs?
The plaintiffs marked Exts.A1 to A51 documents and
examined PW1.
documents.
defendants.
The defendants produced Exts.B1 to B4
No witness was examined on behalf of the
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 12 :
9.
After analysing the evidence, the Sub Court found
that Kunjan was a lessee of Kuttiyambakkam paddy field and
he was in exclusive possession of the tank mentioned in the
plaint. The Jenmi had leased out the property to Kunjan as
per Ext.P1. The Sub Court held that Ext.A5 clearly provides
that the 1st plaintiff is entitled to half the water in Ramesam
Pottakulam, Karupambully Kulam and Kongakulam. The Sub
Court therefore held that the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree
of injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with
their right to take half of the water from the plaint schedule
tanks.
Accordingly, a decree was passed restraining
defendants 1 to 5 from interfering with the right of the plaintiffs
to take water due to them.
10. Aggrieved by the judgment dated 30.03.1991 in
OS No.300/1986, defendants 1 to 4 filed AS No.152/1991.
The plaintiffs also filed AS No.186/1991. The appeals were
heard together. The District Court, Palakkad held that as per
Ext.A5, the plaintiffs have obtained right to take water from
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 13 :
the plaint schedule tanks.
The objections raised by the
defendants would show that they are obstructing the plaintiffs.
The defendants being the assignees of properties, cannot
obstruct the plaintiffs from taking water through the chals
situated in the property.
The trial court is fully justified in
granting an injunction.
11. The District Court noted that there may be practical
difficulties in gauging the quantity of water available in the
plaint schedule tanks. But, that cannot be taken as a ground
to disallow the declaration and injunction sought for.
12. As regards the appeal filed by the plaintiffs, the
District Court found that Ext.A5 does not give the plaintiffs
any right to walk along the varambas of the paddy field in
connection with catching of fish from the plaint schedule
tanks. They have only the right to take one half of the water
from the tanks. On these conclusions, both the appeals were
dismissed by the District Court.
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 14 :
13. Aggrieved
by
the
judgments
and
decrees,
defendants 1 to 4 have filed this Second Appeal claiming that
the
following
substantial
questions
of
law
arise
consideration.
(1)
Whether the permission granted by landlord
to the user of water from the water tanks owned and
possessed by him would not terminate once the
landlord assigns the property and the tanks without
reserving any right to the plaintiffs to draw water
from the tanks?
(2)
Whether the recitals in the assignment deed
in favour of the plaintiffs permitting them to draw
water from the suit tanks would give them an
absolute right to draw water from the tanks which
have been assigned to the defendants?
(3)
Whether the recitals regarding the user of the
water by the plaintiffs mentioned in their assignment
deed is only a licence and whether it would not
terminate when the landlord assigns the tanks to the
defendants?
(4)
When the quantity of water in the water tanks
could not be gauged, a decree to take half the water
could be lawfully granted without laying down the
mode of drawing half the quantity of water from the
tanks?
(5)
Whether the decree granted by the lower
courts is not executable and results in unnecessary
litigation by the parties, more so since the right of
the defendants to use the water in the tanks owned
and in their possession are found to be entitled to
the water for irrigating any of their properties?
for
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 15 :
14. The counsel for the appellants argued that the
courts below failed to note that when the quantity of water in
the three tanks could not be gauged, the courts below should
not have given a declaration that the plaintiffs can draw half
the quantity of water.
15. The courts below having negatived the contention
of the plaintiffs that the water from the tanks could not be
used by the defendants to irrigate their other lands, erred in
holding that the plaintiffs could draw half the amount of water
from the tanks.
16. The courts below ought to have noted that the
landlord assigner has only permitted the plaintiffs to use the
excess water let out from the tanks. In fact, the plaintiffs had
only a licence to draw water from the tanks and the said
licence stood terminated when the entire property with the
tanks were assigned to the defendants. The judgments of the
courts below are therefore liable to be set aside.
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 16 :
17. I have heard the learned counsel for the appellants
and the learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
18. The specific case of the plaintiffs (respondents 1 to
7) was that the paddy fields at Kuttiyambakkam were taken
on lease by Kunjan, the father of plaintiffs 1 and 3. Since the
Jenmi wanted to terminate the lease, the 1st plaintiff, son of
Kunjan,
released
the
entire
properties
to
Jenmi
on
30.03.1953. On that day itself, Ext.A5 registered lease deed
was executed between the parties and the 1st plaintiff took
half of the properties on lease.
19. Much later, the Jenmi sold right over the property
retained by them to defendants 1 to 4 (appellants herein), on
07.02.1986. After purchasing the property, the defendants
obstructed the plaintiffs from drawing water from the tanks in
their possession.
As the defendants are purchasers of
property from the Jenmi, they purchased the property with all
rights and liabilities as existed on the date of sale. Ext.A5
registered deed in unequivocal terms made it clear that the
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 17 :
plaintiffs had right to draw half the quantity of water from the
water tanks. The right of the plaintiffs over half of the water in
the three tanks is made amply clear in Ext.A5 lease deed.
20. As the Jenmi was bound by the terms of Ext.A5,
the defendants being assignees of the Jenmi cannot have a
better right than the Jenmi. The defendants cannot deny the
right of the plaintiffs.
The courts below came to the right
conclusion in this regard.
The evidence adduced amply
showed that the plaintiffs' father Kunjan was in possession
and enjoyment of the tanks.
The deposition of PW1 and
Ext.A1 certified copy of the lease deed established the same.
21. Ext.A5 document would show that the Jenmi had
leased out the property to Kunjan as per Ext.A1. The Jenmi
can handover possession of the property to Chamiyar (1 st
plaintiff) only if the earlier lease was surrendered. Therefore,
the recital in Ext.A5 as regards surrender of land has to be
accepted.
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 18 :
22. The plaintiffs, who had filed AS No.186/1991, had
sought for an injunction to restrain the defendants from
interfering with the plaintiffs in walking along the varambas of
the paddy fields in connection with catching of fish from the
plaint schedule tanks.
Ext.A5 document did not contain
recitals in respect of grant of such a right to walk or to catch
fish. The grant was only for drawing water from the plaint
schedule tanks for irrigation purpose.
The District Court
therefore rightly refused the contentions of the plaintiffs to that
effect. The District Court, however, held that the defendants
cannot restrain the plaintiffs from walking along the varambas
for the purpose of taking one half of the water from the plaint
schedule tanks.
23. The recitals in Ext.A5 clearly gave a right to the
plaintiffs to the user of water from the water tanks scheduled
in the plaint.
Such right would not get terminated if the
landlord assigns the property and the tanks to the defendants.
The recitals in Ext.A1 assignment deed in favour of the
2025:KER:23404
S.A. No.742/1999
: 19 :
plaintiffs give an absolute right to the plaintiffs to draw water.
It cannot be treated as a mere licence revokable at the hands
of assignees. The mere fact that the quantity of the water in
the water tanks cannot be measured, will not disentitle the
plaintiffs from getting a decree of the court.
The decree
passed by the courts below cannot be described as
unexecutable.
For all the above reasons, I find that the Second
Appeal preferred by the appellants / defendants 1 to 4 is
without any merit. The Second Appeal fails and it is hence
dismissed.
Sd/N. NAGARESH, JUDGE
aks/17.03.2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review