Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved On:
27.11.2025
Pronounced On:
28.01.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE V.LAKSHMINARAYANAN
W.P.No.42665 of 2025 and
W.M.P.Nos.47718 & 47722 of 2025
Koyambedu Periyar Kaaikari
Aangadi Maempaatu Sangam,
Rep. by its President,
No.E-114, Koyambedu Vegetable Complex,
Chennai – 600 107.
.. Petitioner
Vs.
1.State of Tamil Nadu,
Rep. Secretary to the Local Administration,
Ezhilagam Annex Building. 6th Floor,
Kamarajar Salai, Chepauk, Chennai – 600 005.
2.The Member Secretary,
Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority,
No.1, Gandhi Irwin Road,
Egmore, Chennai – 600 008.
3.Market Management Committee,
Rep. By its Chief Administrative Officer,
Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority,
No.1, Gandhi Irwin Road,
Egmore, Chennai – 600 008.
4.Superintendent Engineer, CMDA,
O/o of Superintendent Engineer,
Zone – 1, 1st floor, A block,
E salai, Koyambedu, Chennai – 600 107.
.. Respondents
Prayer: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India praying to issue a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus,
1/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
calling for the records of the 4
th
respondent vide impugned
computerized notification in E.tender Notice No.14/2025-26
dated 24.09.2025 and quash the same and further direct the
respondents 2 & 3 to consider the representation of the
Petitioner Sangam dated on 22.10.2025 for transferring or
leasing the Godowns No.V/N-124, V/G-88 to the members of the
Petitioner Sangam on rental basis.
For Petitioner
:
Mr.M.S.Krishnan
Senior Counsel
for Mr.M.Raja Sekhar
For R1
:
Mr.L.S.M.Hasan Fizal
Additional Government Pleader
For RR 2 & 4
:
Mr.V.Sudalai Selvan for CMDA
ORDER
The
petitioner
is
an
association
of
traders
in
the
Koyambedu market. The members of the petitioner association
indulge in vegetable business. Each of the members have been
allotted shops in the Koyambedu Wholesale Market. In the
market, seven godowns were constructed for the benefit of those
in retail trade.
2.The petitioner alleges that the seven godowns were
constructed in order to provide space for storing goods by the
traders, who have been allotted the shops. It is stated that of the
seven godowns bearing Nos.VN-124, VG-88, E-88, J-88, H-88,
A-124 & C-88, godown No.A-124 alone was the subject matter of
2/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
a sale in the year 2006. Other godowns were initially allotted on
rental basis to various associations and individuals, and godown
No.C-88 was sold to one, M/s.Indian Vegetables. They plead that
the sale of C-88, H-88 & A-124, is contrary to the policy decision
taken by the 1st respondent, since the godowns were meant only
for the vendors and they ought not to have been sold to third
parties.
3.The cause of action for the writ petition is that the 4 th
respondent – CMDA had issued a tender notification on
24.09.2025, for the sale of godown. It is pleaded that such a sale
is in violation of Section 5(2) of the Tamil Nadu Specified
Commodities Markets (Regulation of Location) Act,1996 (Tamil
Nadu Act 24 of 1996) (hereinafter referred to as 'Act 24 of 1996')
and hence, it requires to be interfered with.
4.I heard Mr.M.S.Krishnan, Senior Counsel for Mr.M.Raja
Sekhar for the petitioner, Mr.L.S.M.Hasan Fizal, Additional
Government Pleader for 1st respondent and Mr.V.Sudalai Selvan
for the respondents 2 & 4.
5.It is the plea of Mr.M.S.Krishnan that under Section 5 of
3/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
the Act 24 of 1996, it is only the 3
rd
respondent, Market
Management Committee, which has the jurisdiction to bring the
godown for sale and the CMDA does not have the jurisdiction to
do so. He invites my attention to Section 2(6), 2(7) and 2(8) of the
Act 24 of 1996, to urge that once a Market Committee is formed
under Section 5(1) of the Act 24 of 1996, then the property vests
with such a committee, and not that any of the other
respondents. He points out that the declaration under the Act
amounts to vesting of the property with the committee and
therefore, the impugned notification issued by the 4 th respondent
is null and void.
6.Mr.M.Raja Sekhar, after adopting these submissions,
points out that under Section 25 of the Act 24 of 1996, it is the
Market Management Committee which has to deal with the issue
and not respondents 2 & 4. He states the purpose for which
eight godowns were identified in the vegetable market, and four
godowns in the flower market, was to enable the wholesale
traders, who have been moved to the said area, to store their
goods, and alienation of the same amounts to a violation for the
very purpose for which the specified markets had been created.
He points out to the proceedings of the Market Management
4/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
Committee
dated
08.02.2018,
to
state
that
the
Market
Management Committee had decided to lease out these godowns
and today, it is moving away from the same and attempting to
alienate the same to the prejudice of the traders and merchants.
Hence, both the counsel plead that the impugned notification
deserves to be quashed on the ground of lack of jurisdiction.
7.I have carefully considered the submissions of both sides
and I have gone through the records in detail.
8.This is not the first time that the godowns are being
brought for auction. The CMDA had earlier floated a tender on
28.11.2019, for the allotment of VN-124 and VG-88. The tenders
were finalized in favour of one N.Karthik and A.Chinnadurai.
Challenging the said allotments, two writ petitions came to be
presented
in
this
Court
in
W.P.No.12286
of
&
W.P.No.14017 of 2020. By an order dated 05.03.2021, both
these writ petitions were dismissed, upholding the tender
process.
9.Aggrieved by the order dated 05.03.2021, the writ
petitioners had preferred two appeals in W.A.No.1104 of 2021
5/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
and W.A.No.1106 of 2021. A Division Bench of this Court
allowed the writ appeals, setting aside the allotment of the
aforesaid godowns in favour of N.Karthik and A.Chinnadurai.
The Division Bench had directed the CMDA to call for a fresh
tender based on the current market value, and complete the
process within a period of four (4) months.
10.Challenging these orders, two SLPs were preferred to
the
Supreme
Court
in
SLP(C).No.22482
of
and
SLP(C).No.22349 of 2024. Both the SLPs came to be dismissed
on 04.10.2024. The Supreme Court specifically held that it has
no reason to interfere with the direction given by the Division
Bench of this Court to go for a fresh tender process, as it would
secure the best market price, for the godowns.
11.The impugned tender notification was issued pursuant
to the directions of the Division Bench in the two appeals. The
Division Bench has specifically directed the CMDA to bring the
shops for a fresh tender auction.
12.The attempt of the petitioner to challenge the tender
notification by way of the present writ petition is an attempt to
6/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
indirectly set aside the directions given by the Division Bench.
Such an attempt cannot be entertained by this Court. It is
pertinent to point out that, nowhere in the affidavit has the
petitioner disclosed about the previous rounds of litigation. I am
holding against the petitioner on this ground alone.
13.Since the issue of jurisdiction has been raised, I have to
deal with the said issue independently from the aforesaid
paragraph. This is because no order of a Court can confer
jurisdiction of an authority which it does not possess statutorily.
Hence, I permitted both the counsel to argue on the issue of
jurisdiction.
14.The State of Tamil Nadu enacted the Tamil Nadu
Specified Commodities Markets (Regulation of Location) Act,1996
(Tamil Nadu Act 24 of 1996). The purpose of this legislation is to
regulate the location of market areas and wholesale markets in
respect of specified commodities falling within the jurisdiction of
Chennai Metropolitan Planning Area and in other local areas.
The legislation was brought about on account of issues of
congestion, traffic, accommodation, and other similar problems
faced in the Chennai Metropolitan Planning Area. In order to de7/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
congest certain parts of the city, it was decided to shift as many
commercial activities as possible, to places outside the areas
where they had been carried on. It was also proposed that by
such identification, it would lead to planned development and
better public health. Therefore, the State decided that it is
essential to declare market areas, in order to establish market
for specified commodities at suitable locations.
15.The area where the Koyambedu Wholesale Market is
situated was initially acquired by the Government of Tamil Nadu
to be used by the Tamil Nadu Housing Board. Subsequently, it
was decided that this area would be ideal for establishment of
the Koyambedu vegetable, flower and fruit market. After initial
resistance, the areas like Kothwal Chavadi, where wholesale
businesses were being carried on, were de-congested by shifting
the traders to Koyambedu. The management of the Koyambedu
Market was given to the Market Management Committee. As
stated by the writ petitioner, those indulging in wholesale, as
well as retail trade of flowers, fruits and vegetables were allotted
shops in the Koyambedu Wholesale Market Complex. Since the
goods are perishable by nature, godowns were also constructed
for the purpose of sharing the same.
8/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
16.In terms of Section 5(1) of Act 24 of 1996, the 1 st
respondent established the 3rd respondent. It is the 3rd
respondent, who has the duty to enforce the provisions of the Act
24 of 1996 and the Rules made thereunder in the Koyambedu
Market. In order to confer the market committee with certain
functions, powers and duties, with respect to Koyambedu
Market, such a provision should be specifically incorporated by
virtue of Section 5(2), the Market Committees were declared to
be body corporates. Section 5(2) also enables the 3 rd respondent
to acquire and to hold property, both movable and immovable,
with the right to lease or transfer the property vested in it or
acquired by it, in favour of others. The second proviso to Section
5(2) imposes a condition that the Market Committee cannot
alienate an immovable property vested in it, unless and until it
has the prior permission of the Government. For ready
understanding, Section 5 is extracted hereunder:-
“5.Establishment of market committee.(1) The Government shall establish a market
committee for every market area. It shall be the duty
of the market committee to enforce the provisions of
this Act and the rules and by-laws made under this
Act in such market area.
9/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
(2) Every market committee shall be a body
corporate by such name as the Government may
specify, shall have perpetual succession and a
common seal, may sue and be sued in its corporate
name, and shall, subject to such restrictions as are
imposed by or under this Act, be competent to
acquire and hold property, both movable and
immovable, shall, lease or otherwise transfer any
movable or immovable property which may have
become vested in or been acquired by it and to
contract and to do all other things necessary for the
purposes for which it is established:
Provided that any land required for the
purposes of this Act shall be acquired under the
provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (Central
Act I of 1894) as provided in Section 28 of this Act :
Provided further that no immovable property
shall be transferred by way of sale, lease or
otherwise by a market committee without the prior
permission of the Government.
(3) Where, after the establishment of a market
committee under sub-section (1), any declaration is
made in respect of any other specified commodity
under section 4 in relation to that market area, then,
the market committee shall be deemed to have been
established in respect of that specified commodity
also.”
10/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
17.It is the plea of Mr.M.S.Krishnan that by virtue of
Section 5(2), the Koyambedu Wholesale Market Complex vests
with the Market Management Committee and hence, any
alienation made by the CMDA would be erroneous.
18.I should point out here that, if I were to agree with this
argument, the petitioner would be shooting at its members in
their foot. This is because the shops purchased by them were
not alienated by the Market Committee, but it was done so by
the CMDA. Be that as it may, my reading of Section 5(2) does not
lead me to such a conclusion. The purpose of creating legal
persons / juridical person is rooted in commerce. By conferring
such status, the liability of individual members or shareholders
becomes limited, thereby protecting them from personal liability
of the entity’s debts and obligations. To give an example, if a
corporate entity like a company were to declare bankruptcy, then
the creditors can have a claim against the assets of the company
and
cannot
proceed
against
the
personal
assets
of
the
shareholders or directors. This broad proposition, which is
meant only to explain the purpose of clothing a body with legal
personality, should not be understood to mean that in all
circumstances, the directors and shareholders are not liable. At
11/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
the first instance, it is the property of the company which is
answerable to the claim.
19.The second reason for conferring an entity with the
juridical personality is to ensure perpetual succession. By
clothing an entity with legal personality, the death, retirement,
or change in the composition of its voting members does not
impinge upon the life of the institution. This ensures continuity
and stability.
20.Insofar as Government institutions are concerned, it is
statutorily declared as a corporate personality for the aforesaid
purpose. Once continuity is ensured, public resources and
services can be rendered efficiently, regardless of the musical
chair by which those governing it change. Conferment of a legal
personality is an instrument that provides a convenient and
effective
structure
for
allocating
the
rights,
duties
and
responsibilities clearly, thereby ensuring specialization and
accountability beyond what can be achieved by human beings.
Not stopping with the conferment of such status, it also explicitly
empowers the market committee to acquire, hold, lease, and
alienate movable and immovable properties.
12/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
21.By virtue of Section 5(2), the Koyambedu Market does
not vest with the Market Management Committee. As to what is
the meaning of 'vesting', has already been gone into by the
Supreme Court on more than one occasion. Vesting implies “to
settle, secure or put in fixed right of possession; to endow, to
descend,
devolve
or
to
take
effect,
as
a
right”,
see,
Vatticherukuru Village Panchayat Vs. Nori Venkatrama
Deekshithulu and others, [1991 Supp (2) SCC 228].
22.The word 'vest' means and implies conferment of
ownership of the property upon a person, and it gives an
immediate and fixed right of present and future enjoyment.
Vesting by itself does not have a fixed connotation. It may vest in
title or it may vest in possession or it may vest in a limited sense,
as indicated in the context in which it may be used in a
particular piece of legislation, (see, Fruit and Vegetable Market
Union, Subzi Mandi, Delhi Vs. Delhi Improvement Trust,
(1957) SCR 1).
23.The act of vesting requires a document recognized in
law by which title or possession is handed over to an entity.
13/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
Section 5(2) makes it clear that the market committee formed
under that Section is not only entitled to acquire property and
enter into a contract, but also deal with the properties vested in
it. The Koyambedu Market was not acquired by the 3 rd
respondent. It was acquired by the Government of Tamil Nadu
and thereafter, it was transferred to the 2 nd respondent. In order
to divest the 2nd respondent of its title and to vest the same in
the 3rd respondent, a document recognized by law should be
essential. The petitioners have failed to substantiate the same.
24.The interpretation that Mr.M.Raja Sekhar seeks to give
to Section 2(5) and Section 2(6) also does not improve his case.
They are mere definitions and they do not vest the property in
the 3rd respondent. Section 2(5) merely states that for the city of
Chennai, it shall be the 2nd respondent who shall be the local
authority, and Section 2(6) speaks about a market similar to the
Koyambedu Market.
25.By virtue of Section 5(2), a Market Committee can
acquire movable and immovable properties within in the country
or even in other parts of the world. This does not mean that
Koyambedu Market vests with the 3 rd respondent. Section 25
14/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
also does not make the Koyambedu Market, the property of the
3rd respondent.
26.Section 25 merely states that a Market Committee,
without the permission of the Government, cannot transfer by
sale, lease, exchange, mortgage or otherwise, any land or
building vested in it or acquired by it, and constitute a market
area. This provision shows that the Market Committee is also
entitled to purchase or acquire any land or building in a market
area. This is an enabling provision empowering the Market
Committee to acquire title to an immovable property in a market
area, and it does not mean that the present market area itself is
owned by the committee. If the market area itself was owned by
the committee, then there arises no necessity for it acquire it or
for the Government to vest the property in it.
27.Transfer of ownership implies transfer of the immovable
property from one person to another. One cannot acquire one's
own property. Section 25(2) also does not show that establishing
of a market committee nor does it declare such committee as
owner of the Koyambedu market. It only guides as to how the
market committee should dispose of the property vested in it.
15/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
When there is no transfer of the property from the Government
to the market committee or from the CMDA to the market
committee, this Court cannot hold that the market committee is
the owner of the property and therefore, it is that committee
alone which can bring the property for auction.
28.Insofar as the plea of Mr.M.Raja Sekhar that if the
godowns are sold, the wholesale and retail vendors will not have
the place to store their goods is concerned, I am of the view that,
unless and until a right is vested in the shop owners stating that
the area set apart from godowns must be reserved only for their
use, such a plea is untenable. It is a policy decision of the CMDA
whether it wants to alienate the property by way of sale or by
way of a lease. It is not for this Court to dictate how the owner of
the market is supposed to deal with it. The CMDA, is in its
wisdom, has decided to alienate its godown by way of a sale.
Unless and until, there is a specific bar to that the godowns
cannot be alienated, CMDA would be free to do so. A restriction
on the right of the ownership cannot be on the ground that if the
property is sold, it will affect another.
29.It is always open to the members of the petitioner
16/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
association to enter into a contract with the purchasers of the
godown and store their goods. The user of the godown would
obviously have to store materials, in order to generate an income
to justify the purchase. Merely because some inconvenience will
be caused to the petitioners, there cannot be a writ seeking a
direction that CMDA should not alienate the property.
30.In the light of the above discussion, I do not find any
reason to entertain the writ petition.
31.Accordingly,
this
Writ
Petition
stands
dismissed.
Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
No costs.
28.01.2026
krk
Index
: Yes / No
Internet
: Yes / No
17/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.42665 of 2025
V.LAKSHMINARAYANAN, J.
krk
To
1.State of Tamil Nadu,
Rep. Secretary to the Local Administration,
th
Ezhilagam Annex Building. 6 Floor,
Kamarajar Salai, Chepauk, Chennai – 600 005.
2.The Member Secretary,
Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority,
No.1, Gandhi Irwin Road,
Egmore, Chennai – 600 008.
3.Market Management Committee,
Rep. By its Chief Administrative Officer,
Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority,
No.1, Gandhi Irwin Road,
Egmore, Chennai – 600 008.
4.Superintendent Engineer, CMDA,
O/o of Superintendent Engineer,
Zone – 1, 1st floor, A block,
E salai, Koyambedu, Chennai – 600 107.
W.P.No.42665 of 2025 and
W.M.P.Nos.47718 & 47722 of 2025
28.01.2026
18/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review