Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S.A.No.767 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on: 19.02.2026
Pronounced on: 27.04.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.DHANABAL
S.A.No.767 of 2018
Kosalai @ Renuka
… Appellant
vs
1.D.Srinivasan
2.Vasantha Devi
Karthikeyan (Deceased)
4.B.Kamalathai
5.T.P.Pameswaran
Periyanayaki (died)
7.Vijayalakshmi
8.A.Chitra Karthikeyan
9.V.K.Kaviya
(R8 and R9 brought on record as Lrs of the deceased R3 vide order of the Court dated 20.11.2018
made in C.M.P.No.5118 of 2018)
10.V.Bhoopathy
11.Surya
1/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
.... Respondents
S.A.No.767 of 2018
(R10 and R11 are brought on record as Lrs of the deceased R6 vide order dated 22.08.2025 made
in C.M.P.No.10232 of 2025)
Prayer: Second Appeal filed under Section 100 CPC, 1908 to set aside the
judgment and decree made in A.S.No.36 of 2014 on the file of the
Subordinate Judge, Dharapuram, dated 23.02.2017, confirming the judgment
and decree made in O.S.No.127 of 2008, dated 03.10.2012, on the file of the
Subordinate Judge, Kengeyam.
For Appellants
: Mr.N.Manoharan
For Respondents
: M/s.Chitra Sampath
Senior Counsel
for Mr.P.Navaneetha Krishnan (for R4)
Mr.Sriram
for Mr.K.N.Selvabharathi (for R5)
R3 and R6 died
R1, R7 to R11-Served-No appearance
R2-Party-in-person
JUDGMENT
This Second Appeal has been preferred as against the judgment and
decree made in A.S.No.36 of 2014 on the file of the learned Subordinate
Judge, Dharapuram, dated 23.02.2017, confirming the judgment and decree
made in O.S.No.127 of 2008, dated 03.10.2012, on the file of the learned
Subordinate Judge, Kengeyam.
2/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
th
2.The appellant is the 7 defendant in O.S.No.127 of 2008 filed by the
plaintiff, who is the 1st respondent in this appeal for the relief of partition.
The trial Court dismissed the suit and the plaintiff filed an appeal in
A.S.No.36 of 2014 on the file of the learned Subordinate Judge,
Dharapuram, and the appellate Court also dismissed the appeal by
confirming the decree and judgment passed by the trial Court. Aggrieved by
the said decree and judgment, the 7 th defendant in O.S.No.127 of 2008 has
preferred this second appeal.
3. The brief facts of the averments made in the plaint before the
trial Court are as follows:
The suit properties originally belonged to one V.G.Periyasamy
Goundar by ancestrally. The 1st defendant is the 2nd wife of said Periyasamy
Goundar. The 2nd defendant is the son of 1st defendant and the said
Periyasamy Goundar. The defendants 5 and 6 (Deceased Balagurunathan
and Karpagavalli) are the Children born to the said Periyasamy Goundar
through his 1st wife, namely Valliyammal. The said Periyasamy Goundar
died intestate in the year 1968. The son of deceased Periyasamy Goundar,
namely, Balagurunathan, died intestate leaving behind the plaintiff and the
5th defendant as his legal heirs in the year 1974. The daughter of the
3/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
deceased Periyasamy Goundar, namely Karpagavalli also died intestate
leaving behind the defendants 3 and 4 as her legal heirs. The 1 st item of the
suit properties ancestrally belonged to the deceased Periyasamy Goundar.
The 2nd item of the suit properties and others originally belonged to the
father of the deceased Periyasamy Goundar separately. The sons of
Gurusamy Goundar, namely Periyasamy Goundar, Chinnasamy Goundar,
Archuna Goundar, partitioned their properties through partition deed dated
04.04.1949 and the 2nd item of the suit properties and other properties were
allotted to the said Periyasamy Goundar as 'B' schedule properties through
the said partition. In respect of the properties allotted to the Periyasamy
Goundar through the said partition, the said Periyasamy Goundar and his
sons Balagurunathan and the 2nd defendant namely, Parameshwaran
partitioned their properties through partition deed dated 29.11.1959. The 2 nd
item of the suit properties, which was allotted as 'A' schedule in the said
partition to the said Periyasamy Goundar and after his demise, his 2 nd
wife/1st defendant and his sons and daughters/Defendants 2, 6 and 7 along
with Karpagavalli and Balagurunathan jointly enjoyed the properties. The
suit properties are jointly enjoyed by the plaintiffs and the defendants and
are under common enjoyment. The defendants 1 and 2 jointly entitled to
1/6th share, the defendants 5 to 7 are separately entitled to 1/6 th share, the
4/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
th
defendants 3 and 4 jointly entitled to 1/6 share and the plaintiff and the 5 th
defendant jointly entitled to 1/6th share of the suit properties. The 5th
defendant executed a release deed dated 21.11.1990 in favor of the plaintiff
and thereby, the plaintiff is entitled to 1/6 th share of the suit properties. The
defendants are evading partition and thereby, the plaintiff filed the suit.
4.The gist of the written statement filed by the 2 nd defendant is as
follows;
The suit is not maintainable and same is liable to be dismissed. The
plaintiff is not entitled to get the relief of partition. Neither the plaintiff nor
the defendants 3 to 7 have right or interest over the suit properties. All the
properties belonging to Periyasamy Goundar through partition deed dated
29.11.1959 and thereby, those properties are his separate properties. The first
wife of Periyasamy Goundar, namely Valliathal, predeceased him.
Thereafter, he married the 1st defendant and the 2nd defendant was born to the
1st defendant through the said Periyasamy Goundar and the partition was
effected on 29.11.1959 itself. Therefore, there are no joint family properties
as alleged by the plaintiff. The said Periyasamy Goundar, while he was in a
sound state of mind, executed a Will dated 15.07.1968 in favour of the first
defendant. After the demise of the said Periyasamy Goundar, the Will came
5/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
st
into effect and the 1 defendant had been in possession enjoyment of the
properties. The other legal heirs of the Periyasamy Goundar have also not
raised any objection over the enjoyment of the properties of the 1 st
defendant. The father of the plaintiff Balagurunathan not died in the year in
1974. In fact, he died on 27.08. 1976. The wife of Balagurunathan, who is
the mother of the plaintiff died intestate in the year 1968. The daughter of
the Periyasamy Goundar namely Karpagavalli died in between 1971 and
1972. After the demise of the Periyasamy Goundar, the 1 st defendant alone
enjoyed the properties as her absolute properties and the allegation that after
the demise of the Periyasamy Goundar, the defendants 1, 2, 5, 6 and 7 are in
common possession are false. The said Balagurunathan and his legal heirs
admitted the above said Will in the land ceiling proceedings and therefore,
they are estopped from denying the Will. The property in S.F.No.549, to an
extent of 6.65 acres was already sold in the year 1969 to one
V.M.Chinnasamy and the property in S.No.533 measuring to an extent of
1.30 acre was sold through sale deed dated 1.3.1995 and the land in
S.No.534 to an extent of 0.10 acre was sold to the 7 th defendant through sale
deed dated 12.11.1990. Thereafter, the plaintiff purchased the same property
from one Renuka through sale deed dated 30.5.1994. Therefore, they have
already admitted the Will executed by the Periyasamy Goundar. Therefore,
6/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
the plaintiff is estopped from denying the Will and after accepting the will,
he purchased the property. The plaintiff also witnessed the sale deed dated
12.11.1990. Further, the property was also mortgaged to the primary
agricultural co-operative bank and the properties were alienated in favour of
several individuals. The said transactions have not been disputed for more
than 12 years by the plaintiff. Further, the purchasers of the properties have
not been included in the suit. Therefore, the suit is not maintainable and
liable to be dismissed.
5.The gist of the written statement filed by the 5 th defendant is as
follows:
The 5th defendant is the daughter of Periyasamy Goundar through his
first wife Valliathal. She also has a share in the property. Since this
defendant is also in constructive possession, she has not claimed any mesne
profits. She is entitled to a 1/6th share of the suit property .
6.The gist of the written statements filed by the defendants 3, 4, 6
and 7 are as follows;
The averments made in the plaint are admitted. The defendants 3, 4, 6
and 7 are jointly entitled to 1/6th share. Therefore, there is no objection to
7/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
pass preliminary decree and they are also ready to pay Court fee for their
shares.
7. The other defendants have not filed any separate written statements
before the trial Court.
8. Based on the above said pleading and after hearing both sides, the
trial Court framed the following issues:
a) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the preliminary
decree as prayed for in this suit?
b) Whether the suit properties belong to the first
defendant through the unregistered Will dated 15.7.1968?
c) Whether the suit is barred for non-joinder of necessary
parties?
d) What other reliefs is the plaintiff entitled to?
9. Before the trial court on the side of the plaintiff P.W.1 was
examined and Exhibits A1 to A5 were marked. On the side of the
defendants, D.W.1 to D.W.7 were examined and Ex.B.1 to Ex.B.38 were
marked. Apart from those documents, Ex.X1 was also marked.
8/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
10. After evaluating the oral and documentary evidence adduced on
both sides the trial Court dismissed the suit . Aggrieved by the said decree
and judgment, the defendants 3 and 4 have preferred appeal before the
Subordinate Judge, Dharapuram, in A.S.No.36 of 2014 on various grounds.
11. The first appellate Court has framed the following points for
determination:
a)Whether the decision of the trial Court that the
defendants 3 and 4/appellants 1 and 2 are not entitled to share
over the property is correct?
b)Whether the decree and judgment passed by the trial
Court is correct?
c)Whether this appeal is to be allowed or not?
12. After analyzing the evidence on both sides, the first appellate
Court also dismissed the appeal by confirming the decree and judgment
passed by the trial court. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment, the 7 th
defendant, who is the 6th respondent in the first appeal has preferred this
second appeal.
9/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
13.
This Court at the time of admitting the second appeal had
formulated the following substantial questions of law:
(1)Whether the Courts below are correct in law in
accepting a copy of the Will Ex.B.5 especially when the loss of
the original Will has not been mentioned anywhere in the
pleadings?
(2)Whether the Courts below are correct in law in
dismissing the suit for partition especially after finding that the
suit properties are joint family properties and when the Will is
not proved in the manner known to law?
14. For the sake of convenience and brevity, the parties in this appeal
hereinafter will be referred to as per their status/ ranking in the trial Court.
15. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant would submit that
originally the suit properties belonged to one V.G.Periyasamy Goundar and
the said Periyasamy Goundar had two wives, namely, Valliathal, the first
wife and Kamalathal/first defendant, the second wife. The said Periyasamy
Goundar had one son, Balagurunathan and one daughter, Karpagavalli,
10/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
through his first wife. The said Balagurunadhan is the father of the plaintiff
and the fifth defendant. The said Karpagavalli died intestate leaving behind
with the defendants 3 and 4 as her legal heirs and the defendants 2, 6 and 7
were born to the said Periyasamy Goundar through his second wife/first
defendant. Thereafter, the said Periyasamy Goundar died in the year 1968
and the son of the said Periyasamy Goundar who born through the first wife
namely, Balagurnadahan died in the year 1974. Therefore, the plaintiff and
fifth defendant are jointly entitled to 1/6 th share. The defendants 3 and 4 are
jointly entitled to 1/6th share. The defendants 2, 6 and 7 are each entitled to
1/6th share. The plaintiff has filed a suit for the relief of partition claiming
share of the properties and the defendants admitted the relationship of the
parties and also admitted that the properties belonged to said Periyasamy
Goundar. However, the first defendant had taken a plea that the said
Periyasamy Goundar entitled the properties through partition deed dated
29.11.1959 and those properties are his separate properties and thereafter, he
executed a
unregistered Will dated 15.07.1968 in favour of the first
defendant and
after the demise of said Periyasamy Goundar, the first
defendant has been in possession and enjoyment over the property as her
absolute properties. Therefore, neither the plaintiff nor the defendants 3, 4
and 5 have any right over the property. In fact the alleged will dated
11/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
15.07.1968 has not been produced before the ourt. Per contra, according to
the defendants, the said Will was produced before the land ceiling
proceedings before the Authorised officer under the Tamilnadu Land
Reforms (Fixation of Ceiling on Land) Act, 1961, (for brevity hereinafter
called as “The Act, 1961”) and the copy from the land ceiling proceedings
alone has been produced. The said Will has not been proved by examining
the attested witnesses in the said Will. Therefore, the Will has not been
proved by the defendants. The said Will has been marked as Ex.B5. Even as
per the recitals of the Will, the testator had signed in Tamil. However, in
earlier proceedings, the partition deeds Ex.A1, A2, B9 and B10 signed in
English. The evidence given by the attestors to the so-called Will, which was
produced before the authorized officer has not been marked before the trial
Court. The evidence of
D.W.7 completely falsifies the version of the
defendants that Ex.B.5 was very same Will allegedly produced before the
authorized officer in the land ceiling proceedings. The Ex.B5 has not been
proved in accordance with law. The D.W.7 has reported that Ex.B5 was
prepared without even producing the original Will and according to his
evidence, the original Will is not available in their office. Therefore the
original Will has not been proved by the defendants. Moreover, as per
recitals of the Ex.B11, sale deed dated 25.05.1969 executed by
12/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
Balagurunathan, who is the father of the plaintiff and the first defendant,
who is said to be the beneficiary under the Will and Parameswaran/second
defendant in favour of one Chinnasamy Goundar had not returned the said
Will. Similarly, Ex.B.21 sale deed dated 30.08.1973 executed by the first
defendant,
Kamalathal,
Balagurunathan,
Karthikeyan/plaintiff,
Peiyanayagi/D5, Vasanthadevi/D4 in favour of one M.s.Palanichamy
Goundar, there was no reference at all to any Will. Therefore, had the
Ex.B.5/Will been executed in favor of the first defendant on 15.07.1968,
there would be no necessity to sell the properties on 25.05.1969 and
30.08.1973 by the legal heirs of the said Periyasamy Goundar. Therefore, the
conduct of the first defendant in executing sale deeds along with the other
legal heirs of the said Periyasami Goundar would show that there was no
Will Ex.B5 was in existence on the date of those sale deeds. Therefore, it is
clear that Ex.B.5/Will was created after thought, to protect the family
properties from the clutches of land ceiling proceedings launched on
19.07.1974.
15.1.Moreover, the assessing authority has no power to decide the
genuineness of the Will and as per Section 9 of the Act, 1961, only confers
the Assessing Authority with powers to decide such questions summarily.
Section 77 of the Act, 1961, stipulates jurisdiction and powers of land
13/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
Tribunals and specifically states that every land Tribunal shall have the same
powers as are vested in a civil Court under the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908. Therefore, the powers given to the Tribunal are not available with the
Authorized officer under the Act, 1961. Moreover, the evidence adduced
before the land ceiling proceedings is not relevant to this case as they are not
fulfilled the conditions under Section 33 of the Indian Evidence Act. The
appellant was not a party to the proceedings before the authorized officer.
Moreover, neither Balagurunathan nor Kamalathal can said to be
“representatives in interest” of the seventh defendant. the entire proceedings
took place behind her back. Therefore, the appellant being an adverse party
had no right to cross-examine the witnesses, who deposed before the
Authorized officer. Therefore, the evidence given before the Authorized
officer is not relevant to the present case due to the non-compliance of
essential requirements of the proviso to Section 33 of Evidence Act.
Therefore, the will has now been proved by the defendants. However, the
Courts below have failed to consider the same and have dismissed the suit
by holding that the Will was admitted by the parties and that the suit is bad
for non-joinder of necessary parties due to non-inclusion of some purchasers
of the properties. Without producing the Will, the Courts below have
accepted the Ex.B5, which is neither the original and nor a copy of the Will
14/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
and the parties admitted the relationship between the parties and the
properties are the joint family properties and without proving the Will, the
Courts below accepted the Will. Therefore, the decree and judgement passed
by the Courts below are liable to be set aside and the second appeal has to be
allowed.
16.The learned counsel appearing for the respondents would submit
that the plaintiff filed a suit for partition alleging that the properties are joint
family properties of the plaintiff and the defendants. In fact, the properties
belonged to the said Periyasamy Goundar through partition deed dated
29.11.1959 and therefore, the said properties are separate properties of the
said Periyasamy Goundar. During his life time, he executed a Will on
15.07.1968 and the said Periyasamy died in the year 1969 and after his
demise, the Will came into effect and thereby, the first defendant alone is
entitled to the properties and the said Will was accepted by the defendants in
the land ceiling proceedings initiated by the authorities under the Act, 1961
and the appellant has also accepted the Will. In land ceiling proceedings, the
defendants are also parties and thereafter, the properties were sold to the
third parties and the said sale deeds have not been disputed by the appellant
and all other respondents. However, by suppressing the said facts, the
15/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
plaintiff filed a suit for partition and the trial court, after analyzing all the
evidence on both sides, correctly dismissed the suit on the grounds that the
said Periyasamy Goundar executed the Will in favour of the first defendant
and the said Will was accepted by the plaintiff and other defendants in the
land ceiling proceedings and all the purchasers of the properties are not
parties to the suit and thereby, the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary
parties. The suit has been filed without including all the necessary parties
and thereby, the Courts below have correctly dismissed the suit. Therefore,
there is no any illegality or perversity in the judgment and decree passed by
the Courts below. Therefore, the second appeal is liable to be dismissed.
17. Heard both sides and perused the materials available on record.
18. In this case, there is no dispute in respect of the relationship
between the parties and the properties originally belonged to one Periyasamy
Goundar and the said Periyasamy Goundar had two wives. The father of the
plaintiff and the fifth defendant, namely Balagurunathan and one
Karpagavalli were born to the said Periyasamy Goundar through his first
wife, namely Valliyathal. After the demise of Valliyathal, the said
Periyasamy Goundar married the first defendant and the defendants 2, 6 and
16/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
7 were born to the said Periyasamy Goundar through the first defendant.
These are all the admitted facts. According to the plaintiff, since he is one of
the legal heirs of the said Periyasamy Goundar, he is also entitled to the
share over the suit properties. According to the plaintiff, he along with the
fifth defendant are jointly entitled to 1/6 th share. The defendants 3 and 4 are
jointly entitled to 1/6th share. The defendants 2, 6 and 7 are each entitled to
1/6th share over the properties of the said Periyasamy Goundar. According to
the first defendant, the suit properties were acquired by the said Periyasamy
Goundar through partition deed dated 04.04.1949 and thereby the properties
are self acquired properties of the said Periyasamy Goundar, during his life
time, he executed a Will dated 15.07.1968 in favour of the first defendant
and he died in the year 1968 and thereby after the demise of the said
Periyasamy Goundar, the first defendant alone is entitled to get properties
through Will. The plaintiff and the other defendants 3 to 5 have denied the
Will. Therefore, it is the duty of the first defendant to prove the Will.
19. The said Will has not been produced before the trial Court.
According to the first defendant, the said Will was produced before the land
ceiling authorities under the Act, 1961 and the said Will was not available
and thereby the copy extracted from the office of the authorised officer of
17/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
land ceiling proceedings under the Act, 1961 has been produced before the
trial Court and the said documents has been marked as Ex.B5. To that effect,
the D.W.7 was also examined and the same was produced by him. Even
according to the first defendant, the said Will was an unregistered Will and it
was produced before the land ceiling proceedings. Since the Will was not
available in the records, a copy extracted from the said Will has been marked
as Ex.B5. There is no evidence that the Ex.B5 is original extract of the
original Will produced in the land ceiling proceedings. Moreover, attested
witnesses of the said Will have not been examined in this proceedings and
thereby the Will has not been proved in accordance with law. The appellant,
who is the 7th defendant herein is not a party to the proceedings under the
Act, 1961. Even assuming that the Will was produced before the authorities,
since the appellant is not a party to the proceedings, the evidence of the
P.W.7 and the Ex.B.5 are not relevant and the same Will not come under
Section 33 of the Indian Evidence Act.
20. In this context, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant
would submit that Rule 11 of the Act, 1961, reiterates that the proceedings of
the Authoised Officer shall be summary and shall, subject to the provisions
of the Act and these rules, as far as possible, be governed by the provisions
18/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
of the code of Civil Procedure, 1908 with regard to the issue of service of
summons, examination of parties and witnesses, production of documents,
amendment of pleadings, addition of parties, passing of ex-parte orders and
setting them aside for good cause. Since the proceedings are summary in
nature, the Will cannot be proved through the summary proceedings and the
Will has to be proved in the manner known to law under Section 63 of
Indian Succession Act, 1925 and Section 68 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
Even though the Will was produced before the Land Ceiling proceedings,
that by itself is not sufficient to prove the Will in civil proceedings for
deciding title to the properties. The summary proceedings were conducted
only to determine surplus lands, and therefore, the Will produced before the
Tribunal cannot be taken as having been proved in the manner known to law.
More over, after execution of the alleged Will and after demise of
V.G.Periyasamy Goundar, his properties were sold by his legal heirs
including the first defendant. The first defendant has not returned the Will in
the sale deeds, however, the reasonable doubt would arise about the alleged
Will as to whether it was executed as alleged by the first defendant. There is
no explanation on the side of the first defendant as to why the 1 st defendant
executed sale deed along with other legal heirs of the said Periyasamy
Goundar, when the Will was executed by the said Periyasamy Goundar and
19/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
the said Will was first time produced before the land ceiling proceedings,
after execution of the sale deeds by the legal heirs of the said Periyasamy
Goundar. The said evidence would show that the will was executed at the
time of sale of the said properties by the legal heirs of the said Periyasamy
Goundar.
21.In this context, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant
relied upon the judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court in the case of
V.Kalyanswamy and another Vs. L.kakthavatsalam and others reported in
(2021) 16 SCC 543, wherein, the Honourable Supreme Court held as
follows:
The evidence regarding the Will would be relevant
in a subsequent judicial proceedings only if the
proceeding was between the same parties or their
representatives in interest, the adverse party in the
first proceeding had the right and opportunity to
cross examine.
In the present case, the appellant was not a party to the proceedings
before the authorized officer. Neither the Balagurunathan, father of the
plaintiff, nor the Kamalathal/D1 can be said to represent the interest of the
appellant /D7. Therefore, the proceedings before the authorized officer in the
20/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
land ceiling proceedings are not relevant, in so far as the appellant is
concerned.
22.The learned counsel appearing for the appellant further relied
upon the judgment of this Court in the case of Selvaraj Vs. Loganayagi and
others in S.A.No.32 of 2017 and Cross.Obj.No.98 of 2022, dated
05.04.2024, wherein this Court held that since the plaintiff was not made as
a party to the earlier civil suit, wherein the Will was proved behind back the
plaintiff, such proceedings would not bind a non-party to the proceedings
and the appellant is entitled to a fresh opportunity to prove the Will in the
presence of the plaintiff.
23.Further, he relied upon the judgment of the High Court of Madhya
Pradesh, in the case of Anand Choudhary Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh
and others, reported in 2025 SCC online MP 977, wherein the High Court
of Madhya Pradesh held that the scope and ambit of the powers to be
exercised by the Tahsildar are limited and the Tahsildar has no authority to
decide the validity of a Will. The Civil Courts alone have jurisdiction to
decide the validity of a Will, and revenue courts have no jurisdiction to
adjudicate upon its validity. Therefore, as per the aforesaid judgments, it is
21/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
clear that the Will produced before the authorities under the Act, 1961, will
not bind the plaintiff, as she was not a party to the proceedings.
24.Further, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant submitted
that the Tribunal under the Act, 1961, is only a person designated and not a
Court. The authorised officer has not been invested with all the powers of a
Civil Court, and only certain enumerated powers have been conferred upon
him. However, the Land Tribunal has not been vested with all the powers of
a Civil Court. Therefore, the authorised officer has no authority to decide
upon the validity of a Will.
25.To support this contention, he relied upon the judgment of this
Court in the case of S.Sundararajan Vs. The Authorised Officer, reported in
(1980) 1 Mad LJ 36.
26.On careful perusal of those judgments, it is clear that the land
Tribunal under the Act 1961 is only a person designated and not a Court and
the authorized officer has not been invested with all the powers of the civil
Court and only certain enumerated powers have been conferred on the
authorized officer. The nature of enquiry conducted by the authorized officer
22/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
shall only by summary and any substantial questions of law or fact shall be
referred to the land Tribunal. In this case, the appellate Tribunal remanded
back the matter to the authorized officer to decide the Will and thereby, the
authorized officer decided the Will and the authorised officer held that Will
has been proved. Though the Will has been proved before the authorized
officer, that is only for the purpose of deciding the land ceiling proceedings
and the title of the parties cannot be decided in those proceedings, Since
those proceedings are summary proceedings. Moreover, the appellant is not
a party to the land ceiling proceedings and thereby, the said will has not been
proved in accordance with law.
27.The learned counsel appearing for the respondents also relied upon
the judgments of this Court in the case of Thayarammal @ Sundarlakshmi
Vs. The Tamilnadu Land Reforms Special Appellate Tribunal, Chennai
reported in 2011 SCC Online Mad 700. In this case, this Court has not dealt
with the Will but decided that the Tribunal has power to take evidence. No
doubt the Tribunal has power to take evidence but the dispute is whether the
authorised officer has power to decide the validity of the Will or not.
Therefore, the aforesaid judgment is no way helpful to decide the case. In
the case on hand,the Will has not been produced and no attesting witness of
23/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
the Will have been examined, thereby, the Will has not been proved in
accordance with law. As far as the Will is concerned, it has to be proved in
the manner known to law that is under section 63 of the Indian Succession
Act and Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act. There are no pleadings in the
plaint about the availability of the original Will. In the land ceiling
proceedings, the appellant is not a party to the proceedings and thereby, the
said Will has to be proved in the presence of the plaintiff and the other
defendants or in the presence of the appellant. The said Will has not been
produced before the trial Court and the first defendant has not even
examined any witnesses to prove the above said Will and mere conduct of
enquiry under the land ceiling proceedings to decide the surplus land will
not amount to proving the Will for the purpose of deciding the title of the
property. However, the Courts below have erroneously held that Will has
been proved and the Will has been admitted by the parties in the land ceiling
proceedings.
28.Even the Will has been admitted by the parties, it has to be proved
in the manner known to Law. In this regard, V.Prabhakara Vs. Basavaraj
K.(Dead) by L.R. and another reported in 2022 1 SCC 115, wherein the
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that in a case where a party admits the
24/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
execution of the document in the nature of a Will, which is otherwise proved
in accordance with Section 63 and Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act
respectively, it becomes a relevant fact duly proved, in the absence of any
discretion by the Court. In this case, there are no witnesses to the Will and
neither the original Will nor the copy of the Will has been produced before
the Courts below, thereby, the first defendant failed to prove the Will in the
manner known to law. Therefore, the findings of the Courts below in that
aspect is not in accordance with law.
29.As far as the first substantial questions of law: Whether the Courts
below are correct in law in accepting a copy of the Will Ex.B.5 especially
when the loss of the original Will has not been mentioned anywhere in the
pleadings is concerned, the first defendant relying upon the Will allegedly
executed by the said Periyasamy Goundar dated 15.07.1968, but the said
original Will has not been produced before the Courts below and the first
defendant has produced the copy of Ex.B5, which is copy received from the
Land ceiling proceedings authority under the Act, 1961.
D.W.7 was
examined as a witness, and he deposed that he does not know whether Ex.B5
is an extracted copy of the Will or not. The first defendant has not taken any
steps to retrieve the original Will after the land ceiling proceedings, nor has
25/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
she produced the extracted copy of the Will/Ex.B5. Further, Ex.B5 is not an
authenticated document, and there are no pleadings regarding the alleged
loss of the Will. Therefore, the Courts below are not correct in law in relying
upon the copy of the Will, especially when the loss of the original Will has
not been mentioned anywhere in the pleadings. Thus, the first substantial
question of law is answered.
30.As far as the second substantial question of law, whether the
Courts below are correct in law in dismissing the suit for partition especially
after finding that the suit properties are joint family properties and when the
Will is not proved in the manner known to law is concerned, there is no
dispute in respect of the relationship between the parties and according to
the first defendant, the said Periyasamy Goundar executed a Will dated
15.07.1968. The copy of the Will has not been produced before the trial
Court and the Will has not been proved in the manner known to law. The
production of Will before the authorised officer under the Act, 1961, has not
been proved. The findings rendered by the authority in respect of the Will
are not sufficient to prove its authenticity, particularly when the same is
disputed by the other side. Therefore, the mere production of the Will and
the conclusion of the land ceiling proceedings based on it are not sufficient
26/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
to prove the Will and the same has to be produced in the manner known to
law. Moreover, the appellant was not a party to the said land ceiling
proceedings under the Act, 1961, and therefore, the production of the Will
from the previous proceedings is not in consonance with the provisions of
Section 33 of the Indian Evidence Act. Therefore, the Will has not been
proved in the manner known to law and therefore, in view of the same, the
Courts below are not correct in law in dismissing the suit for partition
especially after finding that the suit properties are joint family properties and
Will has not been proved in the manner known to law. Thus, the second
substantial question of law is answered.
31.However, the defendants have taken plea that the suit is bad for
non-joinder of necessary parties, since the properties have been sold and the
purchasers of the properties have not been implicated in this case. The trial
Court also framed proper issues in respect of the non-joinder of necessary
parties, despite that no steps have been taken to implead all the purchasers in
this suit and the Courts below have correctly concluded that the suit is bad
for non-joinder of necessary parties. Therefore, without presence of the
purchasers of the properties, the suit being the partition suit cannot be
decided effectively. Therefore, the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary
27/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
parties.
32.In view of the aforesaid discussions and the answers to the
substantive questions of law, the Court is of the opinion that the suit filed by
the plaintiff is bad for non-union of necessary parties and thereby, without
the presence of the purchasers of the properties, the suit cannot be decided
and thereby, the suit is liable to be dismissed. The Courts below also have
rendered concurrent finding in respect of that point and thereby the second
appeal has no merits.
33.Accordingly, this Second Appeal stands dismissed. However, the
parties are at liberty to file a fresh suit by including all the shareholders as
parties to the suit in the manner known to law. No costs.
27.04.2026
Index: Yes/No
Internet: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-Speaking order
vsg/MJS
28/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
To
1. The Subordinate Judge, Kengeyam.
2.The Subordinate Judge, Dharapuram.
3. The Section Officer, VR Section, High Court, Madras.
29/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.767 of 2018
P.DHANABAL, J.
vsg/MJS
S.A.No.767 of 2018
27.04.2026
30/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review