The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. The register damaged by the applicant has although not been produced in evidence, but the facts established through prosecution evidence reveal that the applicant obstructed the official duties of complainant and caused her injuries in that episode. These injuries have been duly proved by Dr. Sushma Adhikari (PW9). The conviction of applicant under Section 332 of IPC is, therefore, 11:22:24 AM upheld.
13. Applicant was sentenced for the offence under Section 332 of IPC for 1 year rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs.1000/-. The custody report received from Sub Jail Bareli reveals that as on 13.12.2023 the applicant had suffered imprisonment for a period of 6 months and 14 days. He is still under custody. Having considered the period of custody, his sentence of imprisonment is modified to the period already undergone by him, while rest of the sentence is confirmed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE ANURADHA SHUKLA
ON THE 4 th OF JANUARY, 2024
CRIMINAL REVISION No. 3169 of 2023
BETWEEN:KHUMAN SINGH S/O SHRI PHOOL SINGH RAJPOOT,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NOT KNOWN
R/O GRAM VILLAGE MEHRA GAON P.S. AND TAHSIL
BARELI DISTRICT RAISEN (M.P.)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI MANISH MISHRA - ADVOCATE - ABSENT)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH POLICE
STATION BARELI DISTRICT RAISEN (M.P.)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SMT. VINEETA SHARMA - PANEL LAWYER)
.............................................................................................................................................
Reserved on
Pronounced on
:
:
21.12.2023
04.01.2024
This revision having been heard and reserved for order, coming on for
pronouncement this day, the court passed the following:
ORDER
The applicant is challenging the judgment dated 31.03.2021 passed by the
Additional Sessions Judge Bareli, District Raisen dismissing Criminal Appeal
No.9/2019 arising out of judgment dated 08.02.2019 passed by the Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Tahsil Bareli, District Raisen in RCT No.88/2007,
whereby he was convicted for the offence punishable under Section 332 of IPC
and sentenced to undergo one year’s rigorous imprisonment and fine amount of
Rs.1,000/- with additional rigorous imprisonment for the non-payment of fine.
Signed by: REENA
HIMANSHU SHARMA
Signing time: 1/5/2024
11:22:24 AM
2.
Being aggrieved by these judgments, the applicant had earlier preferred
Criminal Revision No.2217/2021, but for the reason that the applicant had not
surrendered after conviction, his criminal revision was not found maintainable
and the same was dismissed accordingly. Hence, this revision filed after
surrendering before the trial Court on 04.07.2023.
3.
Brief facts of the prosecution case are that complainant Mehar Prabha was
a Govt. Servant posted as Mahila Swasthkarta and on the date of incident, i.e.
05.04.2006 she was on official duty at 2:00 p.m. in Upswasth Kendra
Mehragaon Kala. Her duty was to vaccinate the pregnant women and children.
Applicant came there alongwith his pregnant sister-in-law and asked the
complainant to give effective medicine to his relative. Complainant told him to
wait for 5 minutes because she was issuing card to a pregnant woman.
Becoming furious on this reply, the applicant reacted violently, he abused the
complainant, torn the record which she was maintaining and physically
assaulted her. He gave her blows with hands and fists, pulled her hair and
crushed her feet with his leg. In the incident complainant suffered injuries. She
was also threatened by the applicant. On account of the act of applicant, the
official work of complainant was obstructed. She made a written complaint to
Thana Bareli, on the basis of which Crime No.197/2018 was registered after
writing down the FIR. The matter was investigated and the charge-sheet was
filed. After the trial, applicant was acquitted of the charges of Sections 294,
353 and 506-II of IPC and was convicted for the offence punishable under
Section 332 of IPC with the aforesaid sentence. The appeal preferred by him
was dismissed.
4.
The grounds raised in this criminal appeal are that the judgment
pronounced by the trial Court is bad in law and procedure because it is contrary
Signed by: REENA
HIMANSHU SHARMA
Signing time: 1/5/2024
11:22:24 AM
to material available on record. The prosecution had failed to prove its case
beyond reasonable doubt. Witnesses PW2, PW5 and PW10 were not reliable,
Dr. Sushma (PW9) had found three injuries in her MLC report marked as Ex.P10 and they all were simple in nature, the complainant was not on duty at the
time of incident and only interested witnesses had appeared before the trial
Court. It is, therefore, prayed that the applicant be acquitted or should be given
the benefit of Probation of Offenders Act.
5.
State has opposed this criminal revision by claiming that there is no
perversity or illegality in the finding of conviction and quantum of sentence,
therefore, it is prayed that the criminal revision be dismissed.
6.
The applicant did not appear before this Court to argue the matter finally.
The arguments on behalf of State have already been heard and the records of
the Courts below have been perused.
7.
In this case prosecution has relied upon the testimony of Anganwadi Karta
Usha Sharma (PW1), complainant Mehar Prabha (PW2), eyewitness Archana
(PW3), Dr. M. Parvesh (PW4) who was the Incharge of Samudayik Swasth
Kendra, Bareli, I.O. R.S. Thakur (PW5) and Chowkidar Dilip Singh (PW6) in
whose presence the damaged register was seized, Premlata (PW7), who was
posted in Health Department at the time of incident, Office Assistant Santosh
Singh (PW8), Medical Officer Dr. Sushma Adhikar (PW9) and another I.O. of
the case Maya Singh (PW10). It may be noted here that Usha Sharma (PW1),
Archana (PW3) Dilip Singh (PW6) and Premlata (PW7) were declared hostile
by the prosecution itself.
8.
To prove the fact that complainant was working as public servant and was
on her official duty at the time of incident, prosecution has relied upon the
Signed by: REENA
HIMANSHU SHARMA
Signing time: 1/5/2024
11:22:24 AM
statements of complainant Mehar Prabha (PW2) and Dr. M. Parvez (PW4).
Both of them have testified to the fact that complainant was on her official duty
at the time of incident. The duty-chart of Mehar Prabha proved by Dr. M.
Parvez (PW4) suggests that on every first Tuesday of the month complainant
Mehar Prabha had her duty at Mehragaon Kala. He has been cross-examined on
the point that this duty-chart marked as Ex.P-6 does not refer to the date and
time of the duty of complainant and a perusal of document (Ex.P6) confirms
this contention. Still the fact that complainant was executing her official duty is
proved in the case and for this reference can be made to the testimony of
Anganwadi Karyakarta Usha Sharma (PW1) and employee of Health
Department Premlala (PW7).
9.
Usha Sharma has admitted the fact that on the date of incident she was
working as Anganwadi Karyakarta in Mehragaon Kala and complainant was
distributing medicines to the pregnant ladies. She has also stated that on the
date of incident, there was a camp organized for health examination of pregnant
women and children. She has also stated that the complainant was working as a
nurse at that time. She has not been cross-examined on these facts by the
applicant. Similarly, Premlata has stated that complainant was ANM at the time
of incident, which occurred in Govt. Hospital of Village Mehragaon. She has
also stated that complainant had informed the BMO on phone about the
incident, upon which this witness left for Mehragaon alongwith BMO. These
unchallenged facts prove that complainant was working as Govt. Servant in the
Govt. Hospital of Mehragaon on the date of incident and she was discharging
her official duty of vaccinating and distributing medicines to pregnant women
and children.
10.
Signed by: REENA
HIMANSHU SHARMA
Signing time: 1/5/2024
11:22:24 AM
Complainant Mehar Prabha has reiterated the facts alleged in her written
complaints marked as Ex.P-2 and the FIR marked as Ex.P3. During her court
testimony not a single fact could be highlighted in her cross-examination which
would have casted doubt on her reliability.
Further, there is no enmity
established between the two parties. The presence of applicant on the spot is
proved by the fact suggested by defence that the condition of sister-in-law of
applicant was serious and despite the request of the applicant, complainant
ignored him.
It is further suggested on behalf of defence that it was the
complainant who reacted badly to the request made by applicant and started
scuffle with him. Thus, the facts stated in FIR and the testimony of complainant
have found due support from the suggestion given during the cross-examination
of complainant.
11.
Applicant has put up a defence that the quarel and scuffle was started by
the complainant herself, but this fact has not been supported by any of the
prosecution witnesses. Further, no suggestion to that effect was given to them
by the defence counsel. If there was any force used by complainant, as claimed
by the applicant, then this fact was to be proved through defence evidence, but
no witness was examined by applicant to support this story. The sister-in-law
of applicant, who was admittedly present at the scene of occurrence, has not
been produced as witness in the case, while she could have given strength to the
defence story.
12.
The register damaged by the applicant has although not been produced in
evidence, but the facts established through prosecution evidence reveal that the
applicant obstructed the official duties of complainant and caused her injuries in
that episode. These injuries have been duly proved by Dr. Sushma Adhikari
(PW9). The conviction of applicant under Section 332 of IPC is, therefore,
Signed by: REENA
HIMANSHU SHARMA
Signing time: 1/5/2024
11:22:24 AM
upheld.
13.
Applicant was sentenced for the offence under Section 332 of IPC for 1
year rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs.1000/-. The custody report received
from Sub Jail Bareli reveals that as on 13.12.2023 the applicant had suffered
imprisonment for a period of 6 months and 14 days. He is still under custody.
Having considered the period of custody, his sentence of imprisonment is
modified to the period already undergone by him, while rest of the sentence is
confirmed.
14.
The applicant be immediately released from custody in case the fine
amount is already paid by him.
15.
Let a copy of this order alongwith the record be sent to the trial Court for
information and necessary compliance.
(ANURADHA SHUKLA)
JUDGE
rv
Signed by: REENA
HIMANSHU SHARMA
Signing time: 1/5/2024
11:22:24 AM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review