Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Revisional Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
----------------------------------------------------------------------
DATED : 04.06.2018
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
1.
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung
2.
Shri Krishna Bahadur Gurung
3.
Shri Iswar Gurung
4.
Shri Devendra Gurung
5.
Shri Mani Chandra Gurung
(All sons of late Ganja Bahadur Gurung
Residents of upper Sichey, P.O. & P.S.
Gangtok, East Sikkim).
6.
Smt. Ram Maya Gurung
W/o late Jiwan Gurung
R/o Upper Sichey
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
7.
Shri Nawa Ratna Gurung
S/o late Ganja Bahadur Gurung
R/o Upper Sichey
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
8.
Shri Lok Ratna Gurung
S/o late Ganja Bahadur Gurung
R/o Upper Sichey
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
9.
Smt. Ran Maya Gurung
W/o late Ganja Bahadur Gurung
R/o Upper Sichey
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
10.
Miss Sevika Gurung (Minor)
D/o late Jiwan Gurung,
R/o Upper Sichey
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
11.
Miss Dinisha Gurung (Minor)
D/o late Jiwan Gurung
R/o Upper Sichey
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
… Petitioner (s).
Versus
Shri Nirmal Gurung
Son of Late Bhaktay Gurung
R/o Upper Sichey,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…
Respondent (s).
---------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. B. Sharma, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Sajal Sharma,
Advocate for the Petitioners.
Mr. A. Moulik, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Kessang Diki
Bhutia, Mr. Ranjit Prasad and Ms. Kesang Choden
Tamang, Advocates for the Respondent.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
Seeking
review
of
the
Judgment
dated
26th
November 2015 rendered by this Court in RFA No. 10 of 2013,
whereby
the
first
appeal
was
dismissed
confirming
the
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
Judgment and Order dated 30th March 2013 rendered in Title
Suit No. 13 of 2012 by the Court of District Judge, Special
Division-II, East Sikkim at Gangtok, the instant review petition
is filed.
2.
The facts, in brief, relevant for consideration of the
instant review petition are that the respondent/plaintiff filed a
suit
for
recovery
of
possession,
eviction
and
other
consequential benefits claiming a decree for recovery of khas
possession of the suit property described in the Schedule „B‟ of
the plaint, after removing the defendants/ review petitioners
herein and also a decree for damages, wherein the following
issues were framed: “1.
Whether
the
suit
of
the
plaintiff
is
maintainable?
2.
Whether the suit barred by Law of Limitation?
3.
Whether the suit of the plaintiff is bad for nonjoinder of necessary parties?
4.
Whether
the
counter-claim
made
by
the
defendants is barred by the Principles of
Resjudicata and Estoppel?
5.
Whether the schedule „A‟ land as described in
the plaint is the ancestral property of the
parties? If so, whether the same is liable to be
partitioned?
6.
Whether the defendants have perfected their
rights over the schedule „B‟ land through
adverse possession?
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
7.
To what relief or reliefs, if any, are the parties
entitled?”
3.
Learned
District
Judge
holding
the
suit
as
maintainable, decided issue No. 2 in favour of the plaintiff/
respondent herein, that the suit was not time barred under law
of limitation. On the issue No. 3 as to whether the suit of the
plaintiff was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties, it was
held against the defendants. On issue No. 6, it was held that
the defendants have not perfected their rights over the suit
property.
On issue No. 5, it was held that the same issue
came up for consideration earlier in Civil Suit No. 65 of 1997
for partition of Schedule „A‟ property, wherein the Civil Judge
held that the suit property was self-acquired property of
Bhaktay Gurung, which he purchased in auction sale.
It was
stated that the said finding was upheld in Civil Appeal No. 05 of
2001 on 26th March 2002 in the first appeal. Accordingly, the
Schedule „A‟ property was held as self-acquired property. The
learned District Judge further observed that the issue has
attained finality, as Judgment dated 26th March 2002 rendered
by the First Appellate Court was taken in the second appeal,
which was dismissed on 02nd July 2002.
The Special Leave
Petition filed thereagainst in the Supreme Court of India was
also dismissed on 30th September 2002. Thus, the issue was
also hit by the rule of res judicata, holding that the Schedule
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
„A‟ property was not an ancestral property.
Issue No. 4 was
related to the counter claim which was, accordingly, considered
along with issue No.5. Resultantly, the suit was disposed of,
decreeing the suit denying the counter claim made by the
defendants.
4.
Feeling aggrieved, the defendants have preferred a
Regular First Appeal being RFA No. 10 of 2013. The High Court
by Judgment dated 26th November 2015 upheld the findings
and decree passed by the learned District Judge and dismissed
the appeal.
5.
Feeling dissatisfied, the instant review petition is
filed by the appellants/defendants solely on the ground that
issue No. 5 as framed in the trial Court was not considered and
decided in the same terms and the learned Single Judge of the
High
Court
also
committed
an
apparent
error
by
not
appreciating the issue No. 5 properly in its term framed by the
trial Court. It is also pleaded that the issue as to whether the
suit was barred by law of limitation was also not justly
considered by the trial Court as well as the High Court in the
first appeal. Mr. B. Sharma, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the review petitioners would contend that the learned trial
Court has completely overlooked the wording of the issue
which seeks finding on the issue as to whether the Schedule „A‟
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
land as described in the plaint was the ancestral property of
the parties, if so, whether the same was liable to be
partitioned. The learned trial Judge has wrongly relied on the
decision of the Civil Judge in Civil Suit No. 65 of 1997, wherein
it was held as self-acquired property of Bhaktay Gurung, but
there was no finding as to whether the said Schedule „A‟ land
as described in the plaint was ancestral property of the parties
or not. Thus, there is apparent error on the face of it, as the
issue was fully ignored by the learned trial Court as well as the
High Court in the first appeal.
6.
On the issue of limitation, Mr. B. Sharma, learned
Senior Counsel would contend that the trial Court has not
appreciated the scope of Section 3 and Section 9 of the
Limitation Act while holding that the suit preferred by the
plaintiff/respondent herein was not barred by limitation.
The
review petitioners seek appreciation of factual evidence in the
case.
7.
Mr. Sharma, referring to the observation of the
Supreme Court in paragraph 24 of the Judgment rendered in
Des Raj & Ors. v. Bhagat Ram (deceased by LRs) & Ors. 1 ,
submits that mere assertion of title by itself may not be
sufficient unless the plaintiff proves animus possidendi.
AIR 2007 SC (Supp) 512
The
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
plaintiff has to establish that his possession on the property in
a suit was exclusive, which was not done in the case on hand.
8.
Countering the submissions, Mr. A. Moulik, learned
Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent/plaintiff would
submit that the review petition seeks to challenge the
Judgment and Decree rendered by the trial Court. There is no
challenge to the observations made by this Court in Regular
First Appeal.
It is further contended that the issue as to
whether the Schedule „A‟ land as stated in the plaint was an
ancestral property has been settled way back in the earlier
suit.
Once it is held that the property was self-acquired
property, it was not necessary to reiterate that it was not an
ancestral property. Holding that the land in question was selfacquired property clearly negates the contention of the
petitioner that it was an ancestral property and the issue
attained finality.
Thus, the trial Judge has rightly dismissed
the claim of the defendants applying the principle of res
judicata also.
Mr. Moulik would further contend that the
limitation issue has clearly been considered and found that the
suit was not barred by limitation, which does not need further
appreciation in review jurisdiction.
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
9.
This Court in Mr. Nar Bahadur Khatiwada vs. State
of Sikkim & Anr. 2 decided on 01st December 2017, on
examination of various cases wherein the Supreme Court had
deliberated and examined the ambit and scope of review
jurisdiction, held as under: “22.
On studied examination of the aforestated
decisions laid down by the Supreme Court, the following
principles for maintainability of review are discernible:
(i)
Review proceedings are not by way of appeal
and have to be strictly confined to the scope and ambit of
Order 47 Rule 1 CPC.
(ii)
Review may be entertained when there is
some mistake or palpable error which is self-evident and is
not detectable by the long drawn process of reasoning.
(iii)
The error must strike at mere looking of the
record.
(iv)
Jurisdiction of review is not exercisable merely
on the ground that the decision is erroneous.
(v)
There should be apparent grave miscarriage of
justice.
(vi)
On mere ground that other view on the
subject is possible, the review cannot be maintained. In
other words, power of review can be invoked for correction
of mistake but not to substitute a view.
(vii) In a review petition, it is impermissible to
reappreciate the evidence to reach a different conclusion.
Review is not a rehearing of a original matter.
(viii) Review will be maintainable on discovery of
new and important fact or evidence which after the
exercise of due diligence was not within the knowledge of
the petitioner or could not be brought by him.
(ix)
Review may be exercised for application of
wrong authority or law that falls within the ambit of error
apparent on the face of the record.
(x)
Sufficient reasons, as specified in Order 47
Rule 1 CPC has to be read analogous to those specified in
the statutory provision.”
10.
Applying the well-settled principles of law on scope
of review jurisdiction to the facts of the instant case, it is
noticed that the issue as to “whether the said Schedule „A‟ land
as described in the plaint is the ancestral property of the
Review Pet. No. 06 of 2015
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
parties” came into consideration in the first appeal i.e. RFA No.
10 of 2013 in the High Court. The learned Single Judge in RFA
No. 10 of 2013 has examined the issue at length and held as
under: “33. In the earlier Civil Suit (CS No. 65/1997) the
Appellants-Defendants herein (except AppellantDefendant No. 6) had claimed a decree for
declaration that they had equal ½ right title and
interest in the properties of Schedule-A; a decree
directing the partition of the properties mentioned in
Schedule-A by metes and bounds; and issuance of
perpetual injunction restraining Defendant No. 1,
Respondent-Plaintiff herein, or any other person
claiming or acting under him, from disturbing the
possession of the Appellants and many other reliefs.
The main reliefs claimed by the Appellants in the
earlier Civil Suit were exactly the same which they
claimed vide their counter-claim in the instant suit.
The counter-claim made by them in the instant suit
has been quoted in paragraph 3.8 (supra). In earlier
Civil Suit, the claim of the Appellants was examined
by a competent court between the same parties and
a finding was recorded that Ganja Bahadur Gurung
had separated from his father during his life time
after realizing some amount in lieu of his share in his
father‟s property. This position remains undisturbed
in First Appeal and Second Appeal and the SLP filed
against the rejection of Second Appeal was
dismissed by the Supreme Court. Thus, the question
relating to the source of title allegedly derived by the
Appellants in their successory rights attained finality
between the parties in the previous Civil Suit filed for
the same reliefs, which they claimed in their counterclaim.
In such circumstances, the counter-claim
made by the Appellants-Defendants in the instant
suit on the same strength of their right and title,
thus, was not maintainable on the principles of res
judicata and the learned trial Court was fully justified
in holding so.”
11.
On examination, I do not find any mistake or
palpable error, which is self evident, even on long drawn
arguments advanced by the learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the review petitioners. Extended elaborate arguments put
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
forth by the Senior Counsel for the review petitioners does not
detect any error, as pleaded by the review petitioners,
warranting review of the Judgment dated 26th November 2015.
It is established that the Schedule „A‟ land was an issue in Civil
Suit No. 65 of 1997 which was held as self-acquired property
of Bhaktay Gurung, on his purchase on auction sale.
This
finding stood confirmed in the first appeal, second appeal and
ultimately in the Special Leave Petition preferred by the
defendants, except defendant No. 9, thus, the issue as to
whether the Schedule „A‟ land as described in the plaint was
the ancestral property of the parties is settled and no further
argument is necessary on the purported ground that there is
an error in appreciation of the facts, thus, the review is
rejected on this ground.
12.
On the issue of limitation, the High Court has
examined at length in the first appeal and held as under: “16. In the instant case, the Appellants-Defendants
throughout admitted that they were the co-sharers
of the suit – property along with the RespondentPlaintiff and they raised the plea of adverse
possession for the first time when they filed their
written statement on 18.08.2005. Thus, Article 65
will apply and the period for claiming adverse
possession shall begin to run from 18.08.2005 when
the Appellants-Defendants raised the above plea for
the first time. The above position has also been
highlighted by the Supreme Court in Des Raj
(supra), relied by learned Counsel for the AppellantsDefendants, in which it was laid down that if a hostile
title was asserted at any point of time, then the
period of limitation shall begin to run from the said
date and time and pendency of litigations between
the parties would never stop the running of
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
limitation. In the instant case, as I have already
said, upto the Supreme Court the AppellantsDefendants claimed themselves to be the co-sharers
and they raised the plea of adverse possession for
the first time in the instant suit on 18.08.2005.
Thus, the instant suit filed by the RespondentPlaintiff on 16.06.2005 was neither barred by
limitation nor the Appellants-Defendants had
perfected their title by way of adverse possession.”
13.
On appreciation of the facts as put forth by the
learned Senior Counsel in the review petition, I do not find any
error on application of legal provisions which falls within the
ambit of error apparent on the face of the record. Reliance of
the review petitioners in Moran Mar Basselios Catholicos and
another vs. Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius and others 3 ,
does not alter the well-settled legal principles on exercise of
review jurisdiction, wherein on examination of the facts
involved therein, the Supreme Court held that there was
certainly an error apparent on the face of the record. The facts
involved in the instant case are distinct and different.
14.
The petitioners have attempted to argue the case
on merit, afresh seeking re-appreciation of evidence on facts,
which is impermissible in review.
The petitioners have not
brought any facts into notice, which establishes that there was
an error apparent or some mistakes or palpable error which is
self evident in the Judgment sought to be reviewed in this
petition.
AIR 1954 SC 526
Review Pet (C) No. 01 of 2016
Shri Kharga Bahadur Gurung & Ors. vs. Nirmal Gurung
15.
On
studied
and
anxious
examination
of
the
pleadings and the submissions put forth by the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the parties, I do not find any merit in
the review petition, warranting interference.
16.
Consequently, the review petition is dismissed. No
order as to costs.
Chief Justice
04.06.2018
jk
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review