Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Non-reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.689 of 2022
1.
Mr.Khangembam Jayanta Singh,
aged about 60 years, s/o (L) Kh.Thambou
Singh of Wangkhei Ningthem Pukhri
Mapal, Imphal East District,
Manipur.
2.
Mr.Mutum Milankumar Singh, aged about
53 years, s/o (L) M.Dhananjoy Singh of
Kongba Bazar, PO Imphal, PS Porompat,
Imphal East District, Manipur and;
3.
Mr.Brahmacharimayum Manoranjan
Sharma, aged about 55 years, s/o
(L) B.Dinamani Sharma of Palace
Compound PO Imphal, P.S Porompat,
Imphal East District, Manipur.
… Petitioners
-Versus-
1.
The State of Manipur represented by the
Principal Secretary/Commissioner/
Secretary (Revenue), Government of
Manipur, New Secretariat Buidinng,
Imphal 795001 and
2.
The Principal Secretary/Commissioner/
Secretary (DP), Government of Manipur,
Old Secretariat Building, Imphal 795001
… Respondents
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioners
::
Mr.Ng. Jotindra, Advocate
For the respondents
::
Date of hearing
Date of order
::
::
Mr. S. Niranjan, Government
Advocate
27.05.2025
28.11.2025
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
[1]
The petitioners in the present writ petition are
challenging the impugned order dated 20.09.2021 passed by
the Commissioner (Revenue), Govt. of Manipur, by which the
claim of the petitioners for payment of pay/salary and
remuneration as entitled to Government servants for the
period from 1.9.2010 to 30.12.2013, has been denied on the
ground that their unauthorised engagements by individual
officers for this period, does not create any responsibility on
the State Government.
[2]
Heard Mr. Ng. Jotindra, learned counsel for the
petitioners and Mr. S. Niranjan, learned Government Advocate
for the State respondents.
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
[3]
The ad-hoc services of the petitioners were utilized
since the date of initial appointment by issuing post facto
extension orders from time to time. During such valid
extension period, the petitioner Nos.1 and 2 approached the
High Court for regularisation and protection of their respective
ad-hoc services. WP(C) No.138 of 1999 filed by the petitioners
was disposed on 13.12.2000 directing the concerned authority
to consider the case of the petitioners for regularisation with
other similarly situated persons. Petitioner No.3 along with
twenty others also jointly filed WP(C) No.1028 of 2001 and the
Court was pleased to pass interim order on 15.6.2001 not to
disturb their services until further order if they are really
serving under the respondent department with further
direction to afford their salary regularly.
By an order dated 11.7.2001 issued by the
Principal Secretary (Finance) Government of Manipur, the post
occupied by the ad-hoc/in-charge arrangements shall stand as
abolished with immediate effect with the exceptions to the
cases involving court direction. Thereafter, a corrigendum
dated 1.8.2001 was issued by the Deputy Secretary
(Finance/PIC), Government of Manipur deleting the term “with
the exceptions to the cases involving Court’s direction”
appearing in the last line of para 5 of the aforesaid order dated
11.7.2001. The said Corrigendum was challenged by the
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
petitioners vide WP(C) No.6011 of 2001 (GAU)/1422 of 2001
(Imphal) and by an interim order of the Court dated 24.8.2001
suspended the operation of the aforesaid order dated
11.7.2001 and corrigendum dated 1.8.2001 issued by the
Finance Department, Manipur and further the respondents
were directed not to oust the petitioners from their services if
they are working as on that day. Thereafter, by order dated
4.12.2001 issued by the Principal Secretary (Finance) the
corrigendum dated 1.8.2001 was withdrawn. Thereafter, the
ad-hoc service of the petitioners were extended up to
31.8.2010 by various orders of the competent authority from
time to time.
[4]
While the petitioners were serving in different
capacities in the Revenue, Census and Election a letter dated
18.10.2013 was issued by the Under Secretary (Revenue),
Government of Manipur to all DCs, all ADCs, all SDOs and all
Sub Registrars, Manipur, regarding the Government policy on
ad-hoc regularisation in respect of 288 direct recruit ad-hoc
employees of various Government Departments/offices.
Thereafter, the ad-hoc services of the petitioner Nos.1 and 2
were regularized as Zilladar vide order dated 31.12.2013
issued by the Under Secretary (Revenue), Govt of Manipur and
ad-hoc service of the petitioner No.3 was also regularized as
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
Mandol vide order dated 31.12.2013 issued by the Under
Secretary (Revenue), Government of Manipur and as such, the
petitioners are still in service. However, the respondents have
not paid their pay and allowances for the period from 1.9.2010
to 30.12.2013 without proper reasons.
[5]
The present petitioners along with four others
approached the Court by filing WP(C) No.769 of 2014 for
payment of their pay and allowances for the period from
1.9.2010 to 30.12.2013 and the same was disposed of on
30.01.2015 by directing the respondents to verify the service
records of the petitioners and to pay their salary and
allowances if they are found to have served for the period they
claimed. It was also directed to be completed within a period
of six months from the date of receipt of the order.
Further, the present petitioners along with another
jointly filed WP(C) No.324 of 2019 before the Court for a
direction to the respondents to comply with the directions
passed in WP(C) No.769 of 2014, which was disposed of on
17.7.2019 directing the respondents to comply with the
direction passed in WP(C) No.769 of 2014 within a period of
three months without fail from the date of receipt of copy of
the order. As the order of Court dated 17.7.2019 was not
complied, a contempt petition being Cont. Case (C) No.221 of
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
2019 was filed. While contempt was initiated, a letter dated
13.9.2021 was issued by the Deputy Secretary (Revenue),
Government of Manipur to the petitioners separately thereby
directing the petitioners to furnish their service verification for
the period from 1.9.2010 to 30.12.2013 duly counter signed
by the concerned senior officers (SDO and DC). In response to
the letter dated 13.9.2021 an application in the form of
detailed explanation was submitted by the petitioners
separately on 15.9.2021 to the Deputy Secretary (Revenue),
through proper channel.
[6]
In the counter affidavit of Respondent No.1 it is
stated that the last extension of the petitioners’ ad-hoc service
was done w.e.f. 1.9.2008 to 31.8.2010 vide Government Order
No.2/17/2005-Com (Rev) Pt dated 26.10.2010 and thereafter
there was no extension of ad-hoc service of the petitioners in
the Revenue Department, now Land Resources Department.
Hence, the petitioners were not in Government service for the
period w.e.f. 1.9.2010 to 30.12.2013. It is also stated that the
Office Memorandum dated 03.10.2013 for one-time scheme of
regularisation of direct recruit ad-hoc employees in various
departments of the government does not include provisions for
payment of back wages and the regularisation is prospective
from the date of such regularisation. It is pointed out that as
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
per the OM, (i) the person must be serving on ad-hoc basis
continuously since 23.03.2006,
(ii) duty certificate of
continuously working countered signed by the Administrative
Secretaries
concerned,
and
(iii)
regularisation will
be
prospective. Since there is no extension order between the
period 01.09.2010 to 30.12.2013, the claim of back wages for
the period of ad-hoc service not extended by the competent
authority, has rightly been rejected.
[7]
Mr. Ng. Jotindra Luwang, learned counsel for the
petitioner submits that it is admitted fact that the petitioners
were initially appointed on ad-hoc basis and their service has
been extended from time to time and in most cases, by issuing
orders for retrospective extension of ad-hoc service for a bulk
period. Learned counsel refers to such an order dated
26.10.2010 [Annexure-A/8] issued by the Commissioner
(Revenue), Govt. of Manipur for extension of ad-hoc services
of 124 employees of different designations in the Revenue
Department for a period of 24 months wef 01.09.2008 to
31.08.2010. This order includes the names of the three writ
petitioners. It is submitted that the ad-hoc employees are
allowed to continue to work and usually post facto extension
orders have been issued. In the circumstances, the petitioners
and other ad-hoc employees of the department continued to
work even after expiry of the ad-hoc period in anticipation of
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
post facto extension. Learned counsel for the petitioners draws
the attention of this Court to the various orders [Annexure-A/9
series] issued by the higher officials of the Revenue
Department directing the petitioners and other ad-hoc
employees to work in particular villages for smooth functioning
of the official works in the circles and also assigning them for
other works such as election duty, revision of electoral rolls. In
some of such orders in Annexure-A/9 series, it has specifically
mentioned that the ad-hoc employees including the petitioners
are rendering their service continuously. These utilisation
orders have not been denied by the respondent in their
counter affidavit and in para 7 it simply says no comment. It
is reiterated the plea of non-extension of ad-hoc service wef
01.09.2010 to 30.12.2013 cannot be a ground to deny
remuneration for the period of their services that have been
extracted by the department from them. It is vehemently
urged that the regularisation order dated 31.12.2013 of the
petitioners under the OM dated 03.10.2013 has impliedly
extended the ad-hoc service, as continuous working on ad-hoc
basis wef 23.03.2006 is a pre-condition for regularisation of
ad-hoc service. Hence, the State authority is estopped from
taking the plea that the ad-hoc service wef 01.09.2010 to
30.12.2013 has not been extended.
It is prayed that the
impugned order dated 20.09.2021 issued by the Commissioner
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
(Revenue), Govt. of Manipur denying the remuneration for the
period wef 01.09.2010 to 30.12.2013 be set aside and the
respondents be directed to release the due remuneration.
[8]
Per contra, Mr. S. Niranjan, learned Government
Advocate submits that the petitioners have themselves
admitted that their ad-hoc service has not been extended for
the period wef 01.09.2010 to 30.12.2013. It is also admitted
fact that the ad-hoc services of the petitioners and others were
regularised wef 31.12.2013 with immediate effect, thereby
meaning that the regularisation will be prospective and OM
dated 03.10.2013 does not include payment of back wages. In
the circumstances, it is submitted that the claim of back wages
for the period wef 01.09.2010 to 30.12.2013 was rightly
rejected by the impugned order dated 20.09.2021. It is prayed
that the writ petition be dismissed being devoid of any merit.
[9]
This Court has perused the materials on record,
the submissions made at the bar and law in this regard. The
short question arose in the present petition is
“Whether the employees whose ad-hoc service has not
been extended, are entitled to remuneration for the
period which their services have been utilised by the
employer?”
[10]
From the pleadings of the parties, the following
facts are admitted:
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
(i)
The petitioners were appointed on ad-hoc basis vide
orders dated 29.08.1997 and 23.12.1997.
(ii)
Their ad-hoc services were extended from time to time.
(iii)
As seen from order dated 26.10.2010 [Annexure-A/8]
issued by the Commissioner (Revenue), Govt. of Manipur,
services of 124 ad-hoc employees of the departments were
extended post facto for the period wef 01.09.2008 to
31.08.2010 for a period of 24 months. This shows that there
has been practice of post facto extension of ad-hoc service for
a bulk period.
(iv)
There has not been any official extension of ad-hoc
service for the period wef 01.09.2010 to 30.12.2013 till the
date
of
prospective
regularisation
vide
order
dated
31.12.2013. However, there are various orders issued by
SDCs/SDOs for utilisation of the services of the petitioners and
other similarly employees during the period wef 01.09.2010 to
30.12.2013 in various assignments as seen from orders
annexed as Annexure-A/9 series. Such orders are not denied
by the respondents, except for the plea that the officers issuing
such orders are not competent to extend the ad-hoc services.
(v)
The ad-hoc services of the petitioners and others were
regularised vide orders dated 31.12.2013 with immediate
effect.
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
(vi)
By
the
impugned
order
dated
20.09.2021,
the
remuneration for the period wef 01.09.2010 to 30.12.2013 has
been denied to the petitioners on ground of non-extension of
ad-hoc service for this period.
(vii) OM dated 03.10.2013 issued by the Government of
Manipur for one time regularisation of 288 direct recruit adhoc employees in various departments pre-supposes ‘serving
on ad-hoc basis continuously from 23.03.2006 onwards’.
(viii) The ad-hoc services of the petitioners and similarly
situated persons, were regularised wef 31.12.2013 under the
OM dated 03.12.2013 on the basis of recommendation of a
duly constituted special DPC.
[11]
This Court is of the view that the petitioners are
entitled to remuneration for the period wef 01.09.2010 to
30.12.2013 during which period their services were utilised
and/or extracted by the respondents on the basis of specific
orders, notwithstanding issuance of any formal order of
extension of ad-hoc services. It is further held that
regularisation of the ad-hoc service prospectively vide order
dated 31.12.2013 will amount to implied extension of ad-hoc
services of the petitioners for the period wef 01.09.2010 to
30.12.2013 in view of the clear mandate of the OM dated
03.10.2013 which presupposes continuing service on ad-hoc
basis since 23.03.2006 [as observed in Para 10(vii) above].
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
Respondents are directed to release the due remunerations of
the petitioners for the period wef 01.09.2010 to 30.12.2013
within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order.
[12]
Writ petition is allowed and is disposed of in terms
of directions and observations in para 11 above. No cost.
[13]
Send a copy of this order to the Administrative
Secretary (Revenue, now Land Resource), Govt. of Manipur for
information and necessary compliance.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Priyojit
signed by
RAJKUMAR Digitally
RAJKUMAR
PRIYOJIT PRIYOJIT SINGH
Date: 2025.11.28
SINGH
16:37:12 +05'30'
WP(C) NO. 689 OF 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review