The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. WPA 8182 of 2020 is dismissed.
16. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 15
18.02.2026
Court. No. 25
Suvayan
WPA 8182 of 2020
Keshab Mukherjee
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Anr.
Mr. Sourav Prasanna Mukherjee
Mr. Arka Mondal
…for the Petitioner.
Mr. Joydip Banerjee
…for the State.
1.
The petitioner has filed the present writ application
praying for a direction upon the respondent no. 2 to
release the arrear payment of Rs. 13,50,000/- against
work done by the petitioner as per the work order issued
by the respondent no. 2. The petitioner has relied upon
the work order dated June 25, 2014 with respect of
plinth protection, repairing roof and making water
proofing treatment on roofs of “C” type and “D” type
quarters (six numbers) in BCW compound at Nutanchati,
Bankura.
2. The petitioner further relied upon another work order
dated July 9, 2015 issued by the Project Officer-cumDistrict Welfare Officer, Backward Classes Welfare,
Bankura for supplying Orient ceiling fan, emergency
light and stand fan for EMRS, Mukutmonipur, Bankura.
It is the further case of the petitioner that apart from the
said work order, the District Project Officer has also
issued verbal work orders to the petitioner and the
petitioner has completed all the work orders and raised
the bills accordingly.
3. The petitioner has relied upon the completion certificate
issued by the Project Officer-cum-District Welfare
Officer, Backward Classes Welfare, Bankura dated June
26, 2018 wherein it is certified that the agency has
completed the work in all respect and full satisfaction of
the department.
4. The grievance of the petitioner is that as per the written
work orders and verbal work orders, the petitioner has
completed the work and has submitted bills. The
authorities have also issued the completion certificate
but have not released the payment accordingly, the
petitioner has filed the present writ application.
5. By an order dated January 8, 2025 this Court directed
the respondent no. 2 to hold a meeting with the
petitioner within a period of two weeks from the date of
the order and the petitioner is directed to produce all
relevant documents justifying his claim. The respondent
authorities were directed to file the report with regard to
the outcome of the meeting. In compliance of the order
dated January 8, 2025 the respondent authorities have
filed the report. The petitioner has participated in the
said meeting and the petitioner has placed his grievances
before the authorities. After hearing of the grievance of
the petitioner the authorities have observed as follows:
“1. From the office records it is found that a work
order
vide
memo
no.944/BNK/BCW
dtd.
25.06.2014 was issued from this office in
connection with the said work.
2. As per terms & conditions mentioned in the
work order earnest money deposition by Agency
in the present petitioner and the copy of the
formal agreement between the parties i.e. the
BCW Deptt Bankura and Petitioner are not
available in office records, The agency also failed
to submit those documents. These documents
were most important documents as these may be
cause of cancellation of the work (as per direction
of the work order itself).
3. The completion certificate has not been found
in office records. There are so many mismatched
information/figures in the document in terms of
the Tender Documents, work order etc. there
exists typing errors too. The then Sub Asstt.
Engineer gave a deposition (Annexure A) that the
genuineness of the completion certificate is in
question and he was in dark about the completion
of the work during his tenure in office 2014-1018.
During his tenure no such claim on the part of the
petitioner was brought under his notice.
4. The Agency claimed that he had completed the
work in 2014 but submitted his claim in 2016
February.
But
from
the
office
records
it
transpires that such bill submission documents of
the petitioner are not recorded in Office Receipt
Register. So officially no such claim of Agency
was received in connection with this work.
5. The Then PO cum DWO submitted that he had
been released from the office on 18.02.2016 Till
then no such bill, even any claim of non-payment
of completed works from the petitioner was
brought under notice from the Engineering
Section of the office or from the Agency himself.
The relevant files in this regard were kept and
maintained at concerned sections. From time to
time various issues were put up before him and
decision was taken accordingly.
6. The Agency failed to submit any photographs
or videos or list of witnesses in support of his
work done which are mandatory for office
records. Audit etc.
***It may be mentioned that as per Govt orders
any construction related works after completion
of works bills are usually prepared from the
Engineering Section along with measurement
book and after that it is put up before the head of
office who finally approved the bill.
Therefore, due to above observation this office is
not in a position to arrange for the payment for
the work.”
6. After the said observation, the petitioner has made
further submission and after hearing the submission of
the petitioner the authorities have further come to the
conclusion which reads as follows:
“(1) The Then PO cum DWO submitted that
Petitioner's plea regarding his verbal instruction
is completely false, He submitted that during his
tenure no such claim have ever received by him.
(2) The then Teacher-in-Charge Ekalavya Model
Residential School submitted that the Petitioner's
claim in respect of works at the school is not true.
No such work has ever been done or materials as
claimed have been received.
(3) The then Superintendent of Nibedita Central
Hostel submitted that the Petitioner's claim in
respect of works at the school is not true. No such
work has ever been done or materials as claimed
have been received.
(4) As per the deposition submitted by the then
SAE (Annexure-A) that the genuineness of the
submission of the petitioner is in question and he
was in dark about those works during his tenure
in office 2014-1018. During his tenure no such
claim on the part of the petitioner was brought
under his notice.
(5) From the office records it transpires that such
bill submission documents of the petitioner are
not recorded in Office Receipt Register. So
officially no such claim of Agency was received in
connection with this work.
(6) No work order/Supply order for such items
were produced during hearing by Sri Keshab
Mukherjee as well as no official record were
found to corroborate those.
(7) The Agency failed to submit any photographs
or videos or list of witnesses in support of his
work done which are mandatory for office
records. Audit etc.”
7.
Considering the report submitted by the authority, this
Court finds that there is a dispute with regard to issuance
of work order and completion of work by the petitioner
and as such the learned counsel for the State submits
that it is not possible for the respondents to release any
amount as the petitioner failed to prove his case that any
work order was issued to the petitioner and the
petitioner has completed the work. He further submits
that this is a disputed question of fact which cannot be
decided in the present application.
8. Per contra, learned advocate appearing for the petitioner
has relied upon the judgment in the case of ABL
International Ltd. & Anr. vs. Export Credit
Guarantee Corporation reported in AIR Online
2003 SC 700 and submits that the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has categorically held that in an appropriate case, a
writ petition as against the State or an instrumentality of
the State arising out of the contractual obligation is
maintainable. He further submits that in the present
case the authorities have issued the work order, the
petitioner has completed the work order subsequently,
the authorities have issued the completion certificate and
as such the writ petition is maintainable.
9. The petitioner is also relied upon the unreported
judgment in the case of Raiganj Municipality and
Ors. vs. Nandalal Saha and Ors. passed in MAT
896 of 2025 dated July 14, 2025 and submits that in
the said case also the Division Bench of this Court has
came to a conclusion that the Raiganj Municipality is
liable to pay the amount to the petitioner and appellate
the order passed by the learned Single Bench.
10. Considered the submission made by the learned counsel
for the respective perused the materials on record, report
submitted by the authority and the judgment relied by
the petitioner.
11. This Court finds that the petitioner has relied upon the
written work orders, completion certificate and the bill
submitted by the petitioner. In terms of the order passed
by this Court dated January 8, 2025, the respondents
held meeting along with the petitioner.
During the
meeting the documents which the petitioner has relied
upon are not available in the office of the respondents. It
was also found that the document which the petitioner
has relied upon has not been issued from the office of the
respondent authorities.
In the report, it is also
mentioned
are
that
there
so
many
mismatched
information and figures. The Sub-Assistant Engineer
who was posted during the period of 2014-2018 stated
that no such claim was filed by the petitioner.
12. In the present case, this Court finds that the work orders
and the completion certificate which the petitioner has
relied upon are of 2015 and 2016. In the year 2018 itself
it was informed to the petitioner to produce supporting
documents/work orders of the work done by the
petitioner but thereafter no steps was taken by the
petitioner.
13. Now only in the year, 2020 the petitioner has filed the
writ petition claiming the demand of 2014-2018. Thus
the claim made in the writ petition itself barred by
limitation.
14. Considering the above, this Court finds that there is a
disputed question of fact as the documents which the
petitioner has relied upon that has been denied by the
authorities. In a writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India this Court cannot decide the
disputed question of fact. The judgment relied by the
petitioner
is
distinguishable
from
the
facts
and
circumstances of the present case.
15. WPA 8182 of 2020 is dismissed.
16. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
17. Urgent Xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of all necessary
formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review