Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
CR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 131 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 31.10.2023 IN AS NO.24 OF 2022 OF
SUB COURT, PERUMBAVOOR ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 25.01.2022
IN OS NO.222 OF 2016 OF MUNSIFF COURT, PERUMBAVOOR
APPELLANT/APPELLANTS/DEFENDANTS 2 AND 3:
KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY. VAIDHUTHY BHAVAN,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004
ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD, PERUMBAVOOR DIVISION,
PERUMBAVOOR, ERNAKULAM., PIN - 683542
BY ADVS.
ARUNKUMAR A., SC, KSEB
Nirmal S
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFF & DEFENDANTS 1 AND 4:
GOPALAKRISHNAN
AGED 76 YEARS
S/O SUBRAHMANIA AYYAR, SHANMUGHAVILASAM HOUSE, PERUMBAVOOR
KARA, PERUMBAVOOR VILLAGE, KUNNATHUNAD TALUK, PIN - 683542
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
R.VARADARAJAN
AGED 66 YEARS
S/O. RAMANADHAN, KRISHNAVILAS MADED, PERUMBAVOOR KARA,
PERUMBAVOOR VILLAGE, KUNNATHUNAD TALUK, ERNAKULAM, PIN 683542
N.V.HARIS
S/O.MAKKI, BUSTHAN HOUSE, PERUMBAVOOR KARA, PERUMBAVOOR
VILLAGE, KUNNATHUNADU TALUK, ERNAKULAM., PIN - 683542
BY ADVS.
R1 BY ADVS.P.JAYABAL MENON
REKHA AGARWAL
R2 BY ADVS.P. THOMAS GEEVERGHESE
TONY THOMAS (INCHIPARAMBIL)
AMRUTHA K.P
SRADHA MOHAN
SAGAR ROSHAN
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 04.04.2025,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
CR
JUDGMENT
1.
Kerala State Electricity Board and its Assistant Executive
Engineer who were the defendants 2 and 3 in the suit are the
appellants. The 1st respondent is the plaintiff and 2nd and 3rd
respondents are defendants 1 and 4.
2.
The plaintiff filed the suit originally against three defendants.
The 1st defendant is having property on the western side of the
plaint schedule property belonging to the plaintiff and his
siblings. The plaint schedule property is 13.12 Ares, belonging
to the plaintiff, which is situated on the immediate northern side
of G.K.Pilla lane. The property of the 1st defendant is also
situated on the immediate northern side of G.K.Pilla lane.
Originally, there was an electric post on the immediate southern
side of the plaint schedule property on the side of G.K.Pilla lane.
Defendants 2 and 3 drew an electric line from the said post to
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
the new house of the 1st defendant, installing two posts inside
the eastern boundary of the property of the 1st defendant along
with the western boundary of the plaintiff. Defendants 2 and 3
have drawn an electric line crossing the plaint schedule property
at the southern portion to the new house of the 1st defendant
without the consent of the plaintiff.
3.
The case of the plaintiff is that due to the drawing of the electric
line, the plaintiff’s property became useless. Shifting of electric
line from the property of the plaintiff is absolutely necessary.
There is sufficient property for the 1st defendant to draw the
electric line. Defendants 2 and 3 are preparing to draw a line in
continuation of the existing line drawn through the plaint
schedule property of the plaintiff. The defendants are to be
restrained from doing so. On these allegations, the plaintiff
sought a decree for mandatory injunction directing the
defendants to remove the electric line which is drawn through
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
the plaint schedule property and also along the side of the plaint
schedule property to the 1st defendant’s property and to draw
the same without causing any disturbance to the plaintiff.
4.
The 1st defendant filed a Written Statement opposing the suit
prayers, contending, inter alia, that the electric line is not drawn
across the property of the plaintiff. The jurisdiction to decide the
dispute regarding drawing of electric line is vested with the
Additional District Magistrate. Hence the plaintiff is not entitled
to get the mandatory and prohibitory injunctions sought for. The
plaintiff has no cause of action to file the suit. The 1st defendant
sold 25 cents from the northern part of his property to one Haris,
and the plaintiff filed the present suit with false allegations about
when the electric line was to be drawn to the property given to
Haris.
5.
Defendants 2 and 3 filed a Written Statement contending, inter
alia, that the suit is not maintainable as the prayer is for the
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
removal of the electric line near and in the plaint schedule
property. As per Section 42 of the Electricity Act, 2003, it is
mandatory for a distribution licensee to develop and maintain an
efficient, coordinated, and economical distribution system in the
area, the failure of which will invite penal provisions. Section 67
of the Electricity Act is an enabling provision to take action to
fulfill the said objective. As per S.67(4), the authority is specified
to consider the dispute involved in this case. Section 145
specifically bars the jurisdiction of the civil court. Since other coowners are not parties, the suit is bad for non-joinder of
necessary parties. The allegation that the defendants have
drawn an electric line across the property of the plaintiff is false.
The electric line is drawn along the private road owned by the
1st defendant, and no damage is caused to any object or tree of
the plaintiff. The plaintiff made a request to shift the electric line
to the other side of the private road, and the 1st defendant
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
considered the request and inquired about the willingness of the
1st defendant, and as the 1st defendant was not willing for such
shifting, reply was given to the plaintiff in that regard.
6.
The person who purchased property forming the northern part
of the 1st defendant’s property was impleaded as an additional
4th defendant. He filed a Written Statement contending, inter
alia, that the suit is not maintainable. Due to the status quo order
passed by the court, the 4th defendant could not draw an electric
line to his 25 cents of land purchased from the 1st defendant.
The 2nd defendant gave a Reply stating that on account of the
status quo order of the Court, he is unable to give an electric
connection to the 4th defendant. The jurisdiction to decide the
dispute is with the Additional District Magistrate.
7.
From the side of the plaintiff, PW1 and PW2 were examined and
Exts.A1 to A7 were marked. PW1 is the plaintiff. PW2 Advocate
Commissioner who prepared Exts.C1 and C1(a). From the side
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
of the defendants, the 1st defendant was examined as DW1, the
4th defendant was examined as DW2 and Exts.D1 to D3
documents were marked. The Commission Report and Rough
Sketch submitted by PW2 are marked as Exts.C1 and C1(a).
8.
The Trial Court decreed the suit with costs directing the
defendants 2 and 3 to shift the electric line across the plaint
schedule property from G.K.Pilla lane to the property of the 1st
defendant within thirty days from the date of decree and
allowing the plaintiff to get the line shifted through the process
of the court, in case of default. The defendants are further
restrained from drawing or extending electric line along the side
of the plaint schedule property against the provisions of Works
of Licensees Rule 2006. The Trial Court found that the suit is
perfectly maintainable, and Section 145 of the Electricity Act
bars the jurisdiction of the Civil Court with respect to the matters
regarding the assessment done by the Officer referred to in
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
Section 126 or the decision of the appellate authority referred to
in Section127 or the determination of the work done by the
adjudicating officer appointed under the Act and that since the
plaintiff approached the Court against the illegal drawing of
electric line in and along the side of the plaint schedule property
the said dispute will not come under S. 126 and 127 of the
Electricity Act, 2003. The Trial Court found that Ext.C1
Commission Report would show that an electric line is drawn
across the plaint schedule property by erecting two concrete
posts in the 1st defendant's property; that the electric line drawn
is approximately 2 ft. in the plaint schedule property; that plaintiff
had obstructed drawing of the line at the time of drawing; that
the 2nd defendant did not obtain written permission from the
authorities provided under Rule 3(1) of Works of Licensees
Rules 2006; that no consent from the plaintiff also obtained for
drawing line through his property; that the defendants 2 and 3
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
are trying to extend the electric line along the western side of
the plaint schedule property against the protest of the plaintiff
and hence plaintiff succeeded in establishing his apprehension
to get a decree for permanent prohibitory injunction.
9.
Defendants 2 and 3 filed an Appeal before the First Appellate
Court, and the same was dismissed, confirming the judgment
and decree of the Trial Court.
10.
The First Appellate Court also found that defendants 2 and
3 had drawn an electric line through the plaint schedule property
without prior permission from the plaintiff and his siblings and
without getting an order from the Additional District Magistrate
or the other authorities concerned and hence the drawing of the
electric line by the defendants through the plaint schedule
property is illegal, and they are not entitled to maintain the said
electric line through the plaint schedule property. It was also
found that the permanent prohibitory injunction granted by the
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
Trial Court was fully justified.
11.
This Court admitted the Regular Second Appeal on the
following substantial question of law.
“Whether the court went wrong in holding the suit to be
maintainable in the light of S.145 of the Electricity Act?”
12. I heard the learned counsel for the appellant Sri.Nirmal S, the
learned counsel for the 1st respondent Sri. P.Jayabal Menon and
the learned Counsel for the respondents 2 and 3 Sri.Thomas
Geevarghese.
13. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that the suit is
clearly barred under Section 145 of the Electricity Act. The last
limb of Section 145 makes it abundantly clear that no injunction
shall be granted by any court or other authority in respect of any
action taken or to be taken in pursuance of any power conferred
by or under this Act. The plaintiff did not have any objection for
drawing of electric line from G.K.Pilla lane to the first post
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
situated in the 1st defendant's property. The said line is only a
service line slightly passing through the southern corner of the
plaint schedule property. It is not causing any difficulty to the
plaintiff. The 2nd defendant is statutorily bound to give electric
connection to the consumers who apply for electric connection
without delay. On account of the order passed by the Trial Court,
the 2nd defendant could not give electric connection to the 1st
and 4th defendants since the year 2016. It is clear from Ext.A4
Petition submitted by the plaintiff to the 3rd defendant that the
complaint is only regarding the extension of the electric line from
the 2nd post fixed in the 1st defendant's property to the 3rd post
fixed in the 1st defendant's property. As per Second Proviso to
Rule 3 (1) of the Works of Licensees Rules, 2006, the plaintiff
can file an application before the authorities mentioned therein
to remove or alter the works which have been carried out, and
hence, the suit is not maintainable in this regard. The learned
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
counsel cited the decision of this court in Hamsa. A.P v.
Secretary, Kerala State Electricity Board Ltd [2023 KHC
757] to substantiate the point that the jurisdiction of the civil
court is barred with respect to the matters coming within the
jurisdiction of the District Magistrate. The Learned Counsel
further submitted that the suit is barred under Section 41(h) of
the Specific Relief Act, as the plaintiff is having effective
alternate remedy before the District Magistrate.
14. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the 1
st
respondent
argued that the suit is perfectly maintainable and the bar under
Section 145 of the Electricity Act is only with respect to the
matters covered under Sections 126 and 127 of the said Act.
Both the limbs of Section 145 of the Electricity Act are to be read
conjunctively and not disjunctively to understand the true
meaning of the said provision. The last limb of the Section could
not be read in isolation. The plaintiff is not liable to file an
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
application before the District Magistrate under the Second
Proviso to Rule 3(1) of the Works of Licensees Rules, 2006. It
is well settled by the decision of this Court in Moan M Joseph
v. Kerala State Electricity Board [2014(2) KLT 13] that the
land owner is entitled to seek shifting of electric line within his
property and not outside the property. Here, the plaintiff is
seeking shifting of the electric line from his property to outside
his property, and hence, he can not seek shifting the subject
electric line. It is clear from Ext.A4 that he objected to the
drawing of the line through his property, and it is not limited to
the drawing of the electric line through the 1st defendant's
property along the western boundary of the plaintiff. Admittedly,
the electric line was drawn across the plaint schedule property
by defendants 2 and 3 without obtaining prior consent from the
plaintiff as provided in Rule 3(1) of the Works of Licensees
Rules, 2006, and without obtaining permission as mandated
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
under First proviso to the said Rule. The Trial Court granted the
decree, and the First Appellate Court confirmed the same
finding of illegality in the drawing of the electric line. There is
nothing to interfere with the impugned judgments and decrees.
15. The counsel for respondents 2 and 3 contended that on account
of the pendency of this dispute, they are not getting an electric
connection to their houses. They have been waiting for electric
connections since the year 2016. The jurisdiction of the civil
court is clearly barred. The dispute is to be adjudicated by the
District Magistrate and not by the Civil Court.
16. On conclusion of the arguments, in order to have clarity of the
dispute, this Court enquired with the counsel for the 1st
respondent/plaintiff whether the plaintiff is aggrieved by the
drawing of the electric line through the posts erected inside the
eastern boundary of the property of the 1st defendant along with
his western boundary. The learned counsel for the 1st
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
respondent submitted that the grievance of the plaintiff is only
with regard to the drawing of the electric line through the
southern portion of his property from the existing post in the
G.K.Pilla lane to the first post installed in the property of the 1st
defendant. As a matter of fact, the plaintiff cannot object to
drawing an electric line through the posts erected in the property
of the 1st defendant along with the western boundary of the
plaint schedule property, as the line will not pass through the
plaint schedule property.
17.
The first question to be answered is whether the suit is
barred under Section 145 of the Electricity Act, 2003. It is
apposite to extract Section 145 hereunder.
“S.145.Civil court not to have jurisdiction.--No civil court shall
have jurisdiction to entertain any suit or proceeding in respect of
any matter which an assessing officer referred to in section 126 or
an appellate authority referred to in section 127 or the adjudicating
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
officer appointed under this Act is empowered by or under this Act
to determine, and no injunction shall be granted by any court or
other authority in respect of any action taken or to be taken in
pursuance of any power conferred by or under this Act.”
18. The decision of this Court in Hamsa. A.P (supra) cited by the
learned counsel for the appellant is a decision rendered in a
Regular Second Appeal. It arose from a suit for injunction to
restrain the Electricity Board from charging the transformer
erected/placed on the plaint schedule property and also for a
mandatory injunction directing the defendants to remove the
transformer from the plaint schedule property. Though the Trial
Court decreed the suit, the First Appellate Court dismissed the
suit, finding bar under Section 41(h) of the Specific Relief Act in
view of the alternate remedy under Section 164 of the Electricity
Act. This Court specifically considered the question of whether
Section 145 completely ousts the jurisdiction of the civil court. It
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
is apposite to extract the relevant portion of Paragraph No.15 of
the said decision answering the said question hereunder.
“15. Reading the above provision, civil court jurisdiction is barred
(1) to entertain any suit or proceeding in respect of any matter
which an assessing officer referred to in S.126, (2) an appellate
authority referred to in S.127 or the adjudicating officer appointed
under this Act is empowered by or under this Act to determine and
(3) no injunction shall be granted by any Court or other authority
in respect of any action taken or to be taken in pursuance of any
power conferred by or under this Act. Thus, it is discernible that
excluding the above three contingencies dealt in S.145 of the
Electricity Act, civil court jurisdiction is not totally barred and in
view of S.9 of CPC, civil court can deal with suits and other
proceedings in relation to matters not covered by S.145 of the
Electricity Act.…….”
19.
This Court dismissed the Regular Second Appeal after
entering the following findings in Paragraphs Nos.29 & 30.
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
“29.It is in this context, the mandate of S.41(h) of the Specific
Relief Act, 1963 assumes significance. It has been provided that
when equally efficacious relief can certainly be obtained by any
other usual mode of proceeding except in case of breach of trust.
30. In the case at hand, indubitably, the plaintiffs, who are
aggrieved in the matter of installation of transformer in their
property and there is refusal of the demand, at the instance of the
plaintiffs, by the Authority, they could very well make a requisition
before the District Magistrate for the removal of the same and the
said relief, couched in the form of mandatory injunction in the
instant suit, civil court jurisdiction is barred as provided under
S.145 of the Electricity Act.”
20.
In the aforesaid decision also, this Court considered the
maintainability of a suit similar to the suit filed by the plaintiff in
the present case. The only difference is that the subject matter
in the said suit is a transformer, and in the present suit, it is an
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
electric line. The applicable legal provisions are almost the
same in the case of both these items. This Court found that the
jurisdiction of the civil court is barred under Section 145 of the
Electricity Act and Section 41(h) of the Specific Relief Act. This
Court took such a stand on account of the availability of
alternate remedy before the District Magistrate under Section
16(1) of the Indian Telegraph Act,1885, which is made
applicable exercising the power under Section 165 of the
Electricity Act,2003.
21. Section 10 of the Telegraph Act permits the Telegraph Authority
to place and maintain a telegraph line under, over, along, or
across and posts in or upon any immovable property. Section
16(1) provides that if the exercise of the powers mentioned in
Section 10 in respect of property referred to in clause (d) of that
section is resisted or obstructed, the District Magistrate may, in
his discretion, order that the telegraph authority shall be
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
permitted to exercise them. Section 17 provides for removal or
alteration of telegraph line or post.
22. As
rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the 1st
respondent, this Court held in the decision in Moan M.Joseph
(supra) that removal or alteration of the telephone line or post
that is permissible under Section 17 is to shift the line to another
part of the property through which the line is passing or the post
is laid or to alter the line or the post to a higher or lower level or
alter in form; and that shifting of a line or post that is permissible
under this provision can only be from one part of the property
through which the line is passing to another part and not outside
the property.
23. Here, admittedly, the line is drawn through the property of the
plaintiff. Hence, he could not initiate proceedings under Section
17 of the Telegraph Act to shift the same outside his property.
24. The Works of Licensees Rules, 2006 is made by the Central
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
Government in the exercise of its powers conferred under
Section 176 read with Section 67(2) of the Electricity Act 2003.
The Trial Court, as well as the First Appellate Court, relied on
the said Rules. The relevant part of Rule 3 is extracted
hereunder.
3. Licensees to carry out works.-(1) A licensee may-(a) carry out works, lay down or place any electric supply line or
other works in, through, or against, any building, or on, over or
under any land whereon, wherever or whereunder any electric
supply-line or works has not already been lawfully laid
down or placed by such licensees, with the prior consent of the
owner or occupier of any building or land;
(b) ……………..
Provided that in case where the owner or occupier of the building
or land raises objections in respect of works to be carried out under
this rule, the licensee shall obtain permission in writing from the
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
District Magistrate or the Commissioner of Police or any other
officer authorised by the State Government in this behalf, for
carrying out the works:
Provided further that if at any time, the owner or occupier of any
building or land on which any works have been carried out or any
support of an overhead line, stay or strut has been fixed shows
sufficient cause, the District Magistrate or the Commissioner of
Police, or the officer authorised may by order in writing direct for
any such works, support, stay or strut to be removed or altered.
(2) ……………
(3) ……………
(4) Nothing contained in this rule shall effect the powers conferred
upon any licensee under Section 164 of the Act.
25.
Sub Rule (4) of Rule 3 makes it clear that the Rule shall
not affect the power under Section 164 of the Act, which means
Rule 3 is addition to Section 16(1) of the Telegraph Act.
26. Rule 3(1) (a) mandates to obtain prior consent of the land owner
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
before drawing line through his property. Admittedly, the 2nd and
3rd defendants have not obtained prior consent from the 1st
defendant before drawing an electric line through the plaint
schedule property.
27. Even though the learned counsel for the appellant contended
that the objection of the plaintiff was against the drawing of the
electric line along the western boundary of his property and not
with respect to the drawing of the electric line through the
southern portion of the plaint schedule property, I find from
Ext.A4 submitted by him to the 3rd defendant that the objection
of the plaintiff is with respect to the extension of power line from
the G.K.Pilla Lane. It would indicate that the plaintiff’s objection
was against the drawing of the electric line from the post
situated on the southern side of his property on the side of G.K.
Pilla lane, which was drawn through the southern portion of his
property. In such case, defendants 2 and 3 should have
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
obtained permission from the District Magistrate before drawing
an electric line through the property of the plaintiff in view of the
objection raised by the plaintiff either under Section 16(1) of the
Telegraph Act or under First Proviso to Rule 3(1) of the Works
of Licensees Rules, 2006.
28. The drawing of the electric line through private property without
obtaining prior consent of the land owner or without obtaining
permission from the District Magistrate, when it is objected by
the land owner is not an action taken or to be taken in pursuance
of any power conferred by or under this Act referred in Section
145 of the Electricity Act. Neither the Electricity Act nor Rules
made thereunder does authorize such an action of the 2nd and
3rd defendants. The Civil Court’s jurisdiction is not barred under
Section 145 with respect to an action which is taken beyond the
powers conferred by or under the Electricity Act.
29. Of course, Second Proviso Rule 3(1) of the Works of Licensees
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
Rules, 2006 permits removal or alteration of the electric line
outside the property of the land owner, unlike Section 17 of the
Telegraph Act, which permits only shifting within the property of
the land owner. The decision of this Court in Moan.M (supra)
rendered with respect to Section 17 of the Telegraph Act is not
applicable to the matters covered in Second Proviso to Rule
3(1) of the Works of Licensees Rules, 2006. But, when the 2nd
and 3rd defendants have acted beyond the powers conferred on
them by the Electricity Act and the Rules made thereunder, their
action is an illegal action, and they shall not be permitted to
contend that it is for the land owner to approach the District
Magistrate for removal or alteration under Second Proviso to
Rule 3(1) of the Works of Licensees Rules, 2006. Hence, I find
that the suit filed by the plaintiff is perfectly maintainable. I
answer the substantial question of law in the negative and
against the appellant.
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
30. Though the Regular Second Appeal is liable to be dismissed
confirming the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court,
which is confirmed by the First Appellate Court, it does not in
any way fetter the right of the 2nd and 3rd defendants to approach
the authority concerned either under Section 16(1) of the Indian
Telegraph Act, 1885 or under Second Proviso to Rule 3(1) of the
Works of Licensees Rules, 2006 to remove the objection raised
by the plaintiff or to obtain permission and thereafter draw the
electric line. The plaintiff will get the opportunity to present his
case in such proceedings, and it is for such other authority to
find out the least inconvenient feasible route to draw an electric
line to give electricity connections to the 1st and 4th defendants.
Even if the existing line drawn through the southern part of the
plaint schedule property is removed, it is well within the powers
of the 2nd and 3rd defendants to draw an electric line after getting
permission from the District Magistrate. Plaintiff is not having
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
absolute right to prevent drawing of electric line through his
property in view of Section 10 of the Telegraph Act which
permits the 2nd defendant to place and maintain an electric line
under, over, along or across, and posts in or upon, any
immovable property. The only thing is that such right of the 2nd
defendant under Section 10 is subject to the provision Section
16(1) of the Telegraph Act and Rule 3 of the Works of Licensees
Rules, 2006, which mandate obtaining permission from the
Authority concerned. I once again make it clear that the
objection of the plaintiff is only with respect to the drawing of the
electric line inside the southern portion of the plaint schedule
property, and the plaintiff cannot raise any objection with respect
to the line passing through the property of the 1st defendant
along with his western boundary. Even without obtaining
permission either under Section 16(1) of the Telegraph Act or
under First Proviso to Rule 3(1) of the Works of Licensees
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
Rules, 2006, the defendants 2 and 3 are free to charge the
above said electric line passing through the property of the 1st
defendant for giving electric connections to the 1st and 4th
defendants if it is possible to charge the same avoiding the line
drawn through the plaint schedule property. The 2nd and 3rd
defendants are statutorily duty-bound to supply electricity to the
owner or occupier of any premises within one month from the
date of receipt of the application requiring supply under Section
43 of the Electricity Act, 2003. It is quite unfortunate that
defendants 1 and 4 have been waiting for the supply of
electricity since the last 9 years. They are the ultimate sufferers
of this litigation. Fortunately, this Court could dispose of this
admitted Regular Second Appeal of the year 2024 without much
delay. Otherwise, the defendants 1 and 4 will have to wait
another 5 to 10 years to get electricity connections. The right of
the plaintiff was only to show an alternate, feasible, convenient
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
route for giving electric connection to defendants 1 and 4. If the
authority concerned finds that the route through the property of
the plaintiff is the most feasible route, the plaintiff has no right to
object to the same. On the mere lapse of defendants 2 and 3 to
obtain the required permission from the authority concerned, the
litigation started, and it continued for nine years. Even after
starting the litigation, defendants 2 and 3 could have taken steps
to obtain the necessary permission, accepting their lapses, and
thus could have avoided the huge delay in the matter.
Unfortunately, it was not done. It is not fair and proper for this
Court sitting in the jurisdiction of the Second Appeal to issue
directions to the appellants/defendants 2 and 3 in the Appeal
filed by them to take emergent steps to supply electricity to the
1st and 4th defendants. This Court hopes and trusts that the
appellants will take emergent steps to provide electricity
connections honouring the duties bestowed upon them under
RSA NO.131 OF 2024
2025:KER:28696
Section 43 of the Electricity Act. Defendants 1 and 4 are free to
obtain necessary orders from the appropriate forum in case of
any further delay on the part of the appellants/defendants 2 and
3 in supplying electricity to them.
31. The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed without costs subject
to the observations in the preceding Paragraph No.30 of this
judgment.
SD/-
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
Jma/shg
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review