Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHOUGRAKPAM
DEVANANDA
SINGH
SHOUGRAKPAM DEVANANDA
SINGH
Date: 2026.02.06 15:35:45
+05'30'
IN. 8
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Keisham (O) Chandrajini Devi
… Petitioner
Vs.
State of Manipur & ors.
… Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Oral)
05-02-2026
[1]
Heard Mr. Ch. Robinchandra, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner; Mr. Th. Vashum, learned GA appearing for the
respondents No. 1 to 5 and Mr. L. Gunindro, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent No. 6.
[2]
The petitioner is the wife of Late Shri K. Kameshor Singh,
who was working as a regular Work-Charged Assistant Electrician in the
Electricity Department during his lifetime.
[3]
The present writ petition has been filed assailing the order
dated 22-01-2020 issued by the Secretariat: Power Department by
which the claim made by the petitioner for grant of family pension under
the Terminal Benefits for Work-Charged Staffs of PWD/ IFCD/ PHED/
MI and Electricity Rules, 1978 (hereinafter referred to as “Terminal
Benefits Rules, for short”) had been rejected. The petitioner has also
prayed for issuing appropriate directions to the respondents to pay family
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-2-
pension in respect of her deceased husband under the said Terminal
Benefits Rules.
[4]
The case of the petitioner is that her husband initially
entered as Casual/ Muster Roll employee in the Electricity Department,
Government of Manipur, in the year 1979-1980 along with other
incumbents. After her husband had completed more than 10 (ten) years
of service as a Casual/ Muster Roll employee, he along with
other Casual/ Muster Roll employees of the Electricity Department,
Government of Manipur, jointly filed a writ petition before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India, which was registered as WP(C) No. 56 of 1990
“Smt. K. Leima Devi & 194 ors. Vs. State of Manipur & 2 ors.” praying
for regularising their Casual / Muster Roll service. The said writ petition
was allowed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India by an order dated
06-08-1990 by issuing the following directions:“The respondents are directed to absorb the petitioners in regular
service in their respective posts according to rules by granting
them exemption of age limit, if required, whenever vacancies
arise provided the petitioners satisfy the requisite qualifications.
Further we direct the respondents to pay the salaries and
allowances etc. equal to that of regular employees doing similar
work from the date of their absorption in their regular service.”
[5]
Pursuant to the directions given by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in its order dated 06-08-1990 in WP(C) No. 56 of 1990, the Chief
Engineer (Power), Government of Manipur, issued an Office Order No.
561 dated 19-10-1991 ordering the conversion of 195 Muster Roll
workers, including the husband of the present petitioner, into WorkWP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-3-
Charge establishment w.e.f. 19-10-1991. In the said order, it was also
mentioned that the name of post and scale of pay into the Work-Charged
Establishment to which the Muster Roll employees converted shall be
issued separately. In the Annexure – I of the said order, the name of the
husband of the petitioner appeared at Sl. No. 128.
[6]
Later on, the Chief Engineer (Power), Govt. of Manipur,
issued another Office Order No. 620 dated 07-11-1991 converting the
service of 189 Muster Roll workers of the Electricity Department,
Manipur, into Work-Charged establishment w.e.f. 23-10-1991 to the post
and scale of pay mentioned against their names in the Annexure – A
enclosed to the said order. In the said Annexure – A, the name of the
husband of the present petitioner is at Sl. No. 2 (Assistant Electrician).
Subsequently, on 26-08-1997, the Chief Engineer (Power), Government
of Manipur, issued a Corrigendum dated 26-08-1997 to the effect that
the words “converted into workcharged” appearing in the 5th line of
the earlier Office Order No. 620 dated 07-11-1991 should be read as
“absorbed into regular workcharged”. It is also mentioned in the said
Corrigendum that the said Corrigendum was issued in compliance of the
Supreme Court’s order dated 06-08-1990 passed in WP(C) No. 56 of
1990. For easy reference, the scanned copy of the said Corrigendum is
reproduced hereunder:-
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-4-
[7]
It is the case of the petitioner that the husband of the
petitioner served as a regular Work-Charged employee in the Electricity
Department, Manipur, w.e.f. 23-10-1991 till 23-11-1999 on which date,
the husband of the petitioner expired while he was still in service. After
expiry of the petitioner’s husband, the petitioner earlier approached this
court by filing a writ petition registered as WP(C) No. 651 of 2009 praying
for directing the respondents to grant to her the family pension due
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-5-
payable to her upon the demise of her husband as provided under the
said Terminal Benefits Rules. The said writ petition was disposed of
by this court by an order dated 29-10-2018 by directing the State
Government to consider the claim of the petitioner and to pass a
speaking order within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of
a copy of the said order. In purported compliance with the directions
earlier given by this court, the Secretariat: Power Department issued an
order dated 22-01-2020 thereby rejecting the claim of the petitioner
only on the ground that the Work-Charged service rendered by the
petitioner’s husband was not confirmed and as such, the petitioner is not
entitled to avail family pension as provided under the Terminal Benefits
Rules. Hence, the present writ petition.
[8]
The respondent No. 1 and 3 i.e., the Administrative Secretary
(Power), Government of Manipur and the Administrative Officer,
Electricity Department, Government of Manipur, the respondent No. 4,
i.e., the Administrative Secretary (Finance), Government of Manipur
and the respondent No. 6, i.e., the Principal Accountant General,
Manipur, have filed their respective counter affidavits. The stand taken
by the said respondents are common. It is their stand that as the
petitioner’s husband never rendered service as confirmed/ permanent
Work-Charged employee in the Electricity Department, neither the
petitioner nor her husband was entitled to avail pension/ family pension
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-6-
as provided under the Terminal Benefits Rules. It has also been averred
that the authorities have duly considered the claim made by the
petitioner and as her husband never rendered service as permanent/
confirmed Work-Charged employee, the petitioner is not entitled to get
family pension as provided under the Terminal Benefits Rules.
[9]
I have heard the rival submissions advanced by the learned
counsel appearing for the parties at length and also carefully examined
all the materials available on record. On close scrutiny of the order
dated 22-01-2020 impugned in the present writ petition as well as
the averments made by the respondents in their respective counter
affidavits, it is crystal clear that the only ground taken by the respondents
in rejecting the claim of the petitioner for availing family pension is only
on the ground that her husband never rendered service as a confirmed/
permanent Work-Charged employee and as such, neither the petitioner
nor her husband is entitled to avail family pension/ pension as provided
under the Terminal Benefits Rules. It is also the stand of the respondents
that as the petitioner’s husband rendered service for a period of only
8 (eight) years and 16 days, which is short of the period required as
provided under Rule 6(A)(i) of the Terminal Benefits Rules, the petitioner
is not at all entitled to receive family pension.
[10]
At paras. 2 to 5 of the writ petition, the petitioner has made
specific averments that her husband initially entered service as a
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-7-
Casual/
Muster
Roll
employee
in
the
Electricity
Department,
Government of Manipur, in the year 1979-1980 and that after rendering
for more than 10 years of service as a Muster Roll/ Casual employee,
the husband of the petitioner along with other Muster Roll/ Casual
workers approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court by filing a writ petition
and the said writ petition was allowed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court by
issuing certain directions to the respondents to absorb those petitioners
in regular service in their respective posts. It has also been clearly
averred by the petitioner that pursuant to the order passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, the Chief Engineer (Power), Manipur, after
obtaining approval from the Government of Manipur, issued orders
absorbing the services of 195 Muster Roll workers, including the
husband of the petitioner into Work-Charged establishment w.e.f.
19-10-1991. Subsequently, another order dated 07-11-1991 was issued
by the Chief Engineer (Power), Manipur, after obtaining approval of
the Government, thereby converting the service of 189 Muster Roll
workers of Electricity Department, Manipur, including the husband of the
petitioner into Work-Charged establishment w.e.f. 23-10-1991 against
the post and scale of pay mentioned against their names as indicated
in the said order. Subsequent thereto, the Chief Engineer (Power),
Manipur, issued a Corrigendum dated 26-08-1997 clarifying that the
words “converted into Work-Charged” should be read as “absorbed
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-8-
into regular Work-Charged” as mentioned in the earlier order, meaning
thereby that the Casual/ Muster Roll service of the petitioner’s husband
and other Casual/ Muster Roll employees of the Electricity Department
had been absorbed in the regular Work-Charged establishment w.e.f.
23-10-1991. It is also clearly mentioned in the said Corrigendum as well
as in the earlier order that the said order as well as the Corrigendum
had been issued in compliance with the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order
dated 06-08-1990 passed in WP(C) No. 56 of 1990.
[11]
In the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondents No. 1
and 3, 4 and 6, the specific and clear averments made by the petitioner
about the factum of the appointment of her husband as regular WorkCharged have not been denied by the respondents. In my considered
view, the authorities have rejected the claim of the petitioner by issuing
the impugned order dated 22-01-2020 without application of mind and
without considering the Corrigendum dated 26-08-1997 by which it was
made clear that the service of the husband of the petitioner and other
Casual/ Muster Roll employees have been absorbed into regular
Work-Charged establishment and that the said impugned order had
been issued arbitrarily and without application of mind. Accordingly, this
court has no hesitation to interfere with the order impugned in the
present writ petition.
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-9-
[12]
On a plain reading of the Corrigendum dated 26-08-1997
along with Office Order No. 620 dated 07-11-1991 issued by the Chief
Engineer (Power), Manipur, which have been issued in compliance with
the order dated 06-08-1990 passed by the Supreme Court of India in
WP(C) No. 56 of 1990, this court is satisfied that the husband of the
petitioner had been absorbed into regular Work-Charged establishment
in the Electricity Department w.e.f. 23-10-1991 and he had rendered
service as regular Work-Charged for more than 8 years and as such, this
court is of the considered view that the husband of the petitioner
was entitled to receive pension and upon his demise the petitioner is
also entitled to receive family pension as provided under the Terminal
Benefits Rules. The relevant rules of the Terminal Benefits Rules are
reproduced hereunder for ready reference:“GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
(Pay Implementation Cell)
NOTIFICATION
Imphal, the 8th September, 1994
No. 17/3/86/PIC: The Governor of Manipur is pleased to accord approval
to make the following rules further to amend the Terminal Benefit for
Work-Charged Staff of P.W.D., IFCD, PHED, MI and Electricity Rules, 1978
(i)
These rules may be called the Terminal Benefit for work charge staff
P.W.D., IFCD, PHED, M.I. and Electricity (Amendment) Rules 1994.
(ii) They shall come into force from the date of publication in the Official
Gazette.
In rule 6(A) of the Terminal Benefit for work Charged Staff of P.W.D.,
IFCD, PHED, M.I., and Electricity, Rules 1978, the following rules shall
be substituted namely:-
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-10-
Rule 6(A) - Family pension as calculated under MCS (Pension) Rules
1979 as amended from time to time subject to the following
conditions:(i)
The benefit shall be available to the family of any permanent work charged employee who died on or after 21-6-1990 after rendering not
less than 1 (one) year of service after confirmation.
(ii) The payment of family pension shall be effective from 21-5-93 and no
arrears in cash or otherwise for the period from 21-6-90 to
21-5-93 shall be paid.
Sd/(R.R. Rashmi)
Secretary (Finance),
Government of Manipur”
[13]
In view of the facts and circumstances narrated hereinabove,
the present writ petition is allowed by issuing the following directions:(i) The impugned order dated 22-01-2020 issued by the
Secretariat: Power Department is hereby quashed and set
aside;
(ii) The respondents are hereby directed to pay to the petitioner
family pension due payable to her upon the demise of her
husband w.e.f. 23-11-1999 on which date the petitioner’s
husband expired as provided under the Terminal Benefits
Rules as early as possible but not later than three months
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
(iii) The petitioner is also directed to co-operate with the
authorities as and when the authorities require her to submit
any documents in connection with the payment of family
pension; and
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
-11-
(iv) It is made clear that in the event the respondents failed to
release the family pension due payable to the petitioner
within the stipulated period given hereinabove, the whole
amount of family pension due payable to the petitioner will
carry an interest of 9 percent per annum w.e.f. 23-11-1999
till the actual payment of the said family pension.
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is
disposed of. There will be no order as to cost.
JUDGE
Devananda
WP(C) No. 342 of 2020
Contd…/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review