Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
SWP No. 1234/2015
Reserved on: 02.02.2026
Pronounced on : 13.02.2026
Uploaded on : 13.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Kasturi Lal
….Petitioners
Through:-
Mr. D. S. Chauhan, Advocate.
V/s
State of J&K & Ors
Through:-
…..Respondents
Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA
\
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The petitioner has challenged the final seniority list
of the Secretaries issued by respondent No. 2 to the extent of
placement of respondents No. 3 to 5 with a prayer for re-fixing
of
seniority.
Challenge
has
also
been
thrown
to
promotion/confirmation of respondents No. 3 to 5 as Executive
Officers; with a further direction to the official respondents to
consider the petitioner for promotion/confirmation to the post
of Executive Officer with effect from the date respondents No. 3
to 5 were accorded promotion in terms of Government Order
SWP No. 1234/2015
No. 21-HUD of 2015 dated 23.01.2015 and to grant grade
attached to the post of Executive Officer to the petitioner w.e.f.,
14.01.2010.
02.
According to the petitioner, he came to be appointed
as an Electrician in Municipal Council, Rajouri on 21.11.1979
and he was promoted to the post of Store Keeper on
25.03.1986.
Thereafter, the petitioner was promoted to the
post of Senior Assistant on 15.01.1987 and to the post of
Secretary/Head Assistant on 15.01.1997. It is being claimed
that the petitioner was given the charge of Executive Officer
w.e.f., 14.01.2010.
It has been further stated that vide
Government Order No. 215-HUD of 2003 dated 28.08.2003,
pay scale of Rs. 6500-10500 was accorded to all the
Secretaries working in Local Bodies w.e.f., 28.08.2003 and the
petitioner was also granted the said benefit.
03.
According to the petitioner, a tentative seniority list
dated 09.12.2013 of the Secretaries was issued to which the
petitioner filed his objections but without considering his
objections, final impugned seniority list came to be issued
wherein the petitioner was placed at serial No. 6 but the
respondents No. 3 and 4, who rank junior to him, were placed
above him. It has been also submitted that vide Government
Order No. 21-HUD of 2015 dated 23.01.2015, respondents No.
3 to 5 have been granted promotion to the post of Executive
Officers but the claim of the petitioner has not been
considered.
SWP No. 1234/2015
04.
The petitioner has challenged the impugned action
of the respondents primarily on the ground that he ranks
senior to respondents No. 3 to 5, as such, he is entitled to be
promoted as Executive Officer with effect from the date
respondents No. 3 to 5 were accorded promotion to the said
post. It has been contended that impugned final seniority list
issued by respondent No. 2 wherein the petitioner has been
shown at serial No. 6, below respondents No. 3 and 4, is liable
to be quashed because the petitioner was appointed prior in
point of time to the aforesaid two respondents.
05.
Official
respondents
as
well
as
the
private
respondent Nos. 3 and 4 have contested the writ petition by
filing their separate replies.
06.
In their reply, official respondents have contended
that the petitioner was promoted as Head Assistant/Secretary
along with others by the DPC in the pay scale of Rs. 50008000 in terms of Order No. 352-DULBJ of 2004 dated
22.11.2004.
It has been submitted that vide Government
Order No. 215-HUD of 2003 dated 28.08.2003, the pay
anomaly of the Secretaries was removed and they were placed
in the pay scale of Rs. 6500-10500 and the said scale was
made applicable to all full-fledged Secretaries.
However,
President of Municipal Committee, Sunderbani placed the
petitioner in the grade of Rs. 6500-10500 retrospectively in
terms of his order dated 18.04.2006. The said order came to
be rescinded by respondent No. 2 by virtue of order No. 05
SWP No. 1234/2015
dated 10.01.2008 as the President, Municipal Committee,
Sunderbani was not vested with administrative power to place
the petitioner in higher pay scale. It has been submitted that
aforesaid order was challenged by the petitioner by filing writ
petition-SWP No. 226 of 2008 and the order was stayed by this
Court in terms of order dated 29.02.2008. It has been further
submitted that vide order dated 06.01.2012, the petitioner
along with others was designated as the Secretary notionally
w.e.f., 22.11.2004.
07.
Regarding respondent No. 3, it has been submitted
that he was directed to work as the Secretary in the pay scale
of Rs. 5000-8000 vide order dated 18.10.2002 and in terms of
Government Order dated 28.08.2003, which cleared the pay
anomaly of the Secretaries, respondent No. 3 was placed in the
pay scale of Rs. 6500-10500. Regarding respondent No. 4, it
has been submitted that he was promoted as Secretary in the
pay scale of Rs. 5000-8000 by the DPC vide order dated
06.04.2005 and later on vide order dated 06.01.2012, he was
designated as Secretary along with others w.e.f., 22.11.2004.
In respect of respondent No. 5, it has been submitted that he
was promoted to the post of Receptionist in the pay scale of Rs.
5000-8000 vide order dated 20.05.2009. It has been further
submitted that the post of Receptionist was re-designated as
Secretary vide order dated 26.04.2010.
It has also been
submitted that the post of Secretary was upgraded in the pay
SWP No. 1234/2015
scale of Rs. 6500-10500 vide order dated 15.12.2010 w.e.f.,
18.12.2008.
08.
The official respondents have claimed that tentative
seniority list of the Secretaries was issued on 09.12.2013 for
inviting objections whereafter the final seniority list was issued
wherein respondents No. 3, 4 and 5 figured at serial Nos. 4, 5
and 8 and the petitioner figured at serial No. 6. It has been
submitted that vide Government Order No. 21-HUD of 2015
dated 23.01.2015, respondents No. 3, 4 and 5 were promoted
as per their seniority and reservation rules.
It has been
submitted that respondent No. 5 has been confirmed as
Executive Officer on the basis of reservation roster applicable
to Scheduled Caste candidates under the reservation rules.
09.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case.
10.
The grievance of the petitioner in short is that he
was promoted to the post of Secretary on 15.01.1997 in terms
of order dated 18.04.2006 issued by President, Municipal
Committee, Sunderbani whereas, respondent No. 3 was
promoted to the said post on 28.08.2003, respondent No. 4
was promoted to the said post on 22.11.2004 and respondent
No. 5 was promoted to the said post on 18.12.2008. Therefore,
in the impugned seniority list of the Secretaries, the petitioner
could not have been placed below respondents No. 3 and 4,
who were promoted to the said post after the promotion of the
petitioner.
SWP No. 1234/2015
11.
dated
In the above context, it is to be noted that order
18.04.2006
issued
by
the
President
Municipal
Committee, Sunderbani, which accorded retrospective effect to
the promotion of the petitioner as Secretary w.e.f., 15.01.1997,
was rescinded by respondent No. 2 on the ground that
President of the Municipal Committee is not the competent
authority to accord approval to the retrospective effect to the
promotion of the petitioner. An order to this effect came to be
issued by respondent No. 2 on 10.01.2008.
12.
It seems that the aforesaid order was challenged by
the petitioner by way of writ petition bearing SWP No. 226 of
2008 before this Court.
Initially the said order dated
10.01.2008 was stayed by this Court but later on vide order
dated 11.11.2021, the writ petition came to be dismissed and
the interim order was vacated.
A copy of order dated
11.11.2021 has been produced by learned counsel for the
respondents during the course of hearing.
13.
Once order dated 18.04.2006 issued by President,
Municipal Committee, Sunderbani
whereby retrospective
effect to the promotion of the petitioner as Secretary was
granted stands rescinded, retrospective effect to his promotion
vanishes and it is to be treated that he has been promoted to
the post of Secretary w.e.f., 22.11.2004 in terms of order dated
06.01.2012. Thus, the very basis of the claim of the petitioner
that he ranks senior to respondents No. 3 and 4 vanishes.
SWP No. 1234/2015
14.
The stand of the official respondents is that
respondent No. 3 was promoted as Secretary on 18.10.2002
whereas petitioner and respondent No. 4 were promoted as
Secretaries w.e.f., 22.11.2004, therefore, respondent No. 3 has
to rank senior to both respondent No. 4 as well as to the
petitioner in the grade of Secretaries. Although, the petitioner
and respondent No. 4 were promoted as Secretaries on the
same date but initial date of appointment of the petitioner is
21.11.1979 whereas, respondent No. 4 was appointed on
01.06.1977. Therefore, the said respondent has to rank senior
to the petitioner.
15.
So far as respondent No. 5 is concerned, it is the
stand of the official respondents that he belongs to SC category
and he has been granted promotion on account of reservation
policy ahead of his seniors and has been placed in the grade of
Executive Officer in terms of Government Order dated
23.01.2015 along with respondents No. 3 and 4. The petitioner
as such, cannot have any grievance with regard to grant of
promotion to respondent No. 5 because he belongs to Open
Merit category. Respondent No. 5, being a reserved category
employee, is entitled to reservation in promotion as per the
roster point so the petitioner cannot claim parity with him.
16.
For what has been discussed hereinbefore, the
claim of the petitioner that he is entitled to seniority over and
above respondents No. 3 and 4 in the cadre of Secretaries is
without any basis once retrospective effect to his promotion as
SWP No. 1234/2015
Secretary stands rescinded.
His claim for promotion to the
post of Executive Officer on the ground that respondent No. 5
despite being junior to him has been promoted to the said post
is also without any merit because respondent No. 5 is a
reserved category candidate, hence entitled to promotion as
per the roster point applicable to him.
17.
For what has been discussed hereinbefore, there is
no merit in this petition. The same is, accordingly dismissed.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
13.02.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: No
Naresh Kumar
2026.01.29 03:50
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
SWP No. 1234/2015
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review