Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
Reserved on: 05.08.2026
Pronounced on : 20.08.2026
Uploaded on : 20.08.2026
Operative part or full judgment: Full
Karnail Singh
S/O Nanak Chand
R/O H. No. 141, Lane No. 8,
Shanti Nagar, Kunjwani,
Jammu.
Through:-
….Petitioners
Mr. Sachin Gupta, Advocate
Ms. Arsha Sharma, Advocate.
V/S
Rahul Singh Sambyal
S/O Sh. Shiv Karan Singh
R/O Mandi Pachwallian
Tehsil and District Samba.
Through:-
…..Respondents
Mr. Jagpaul Singh, Advocate
Mr. Nikhil Sharma, Advocate.
\
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
Petitioner, through the medium of this petition,
moved under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 seeks quashment of order dated 26.03.2021 passed by
the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Samba (hereinafter to be
referred to as “trial court”) in case titled ‘Rahul Singh
Sambyal Vs. Karnail Singh’ under section 504/506 IPC.
02.
It is pleaded in the petition that the respondent has
filed a complaint before the trial court on the allegations that a
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
dispute with regard to land was reported at Police Post Supwal
where the petitioner was posted as Inharge Police Post at that
relevant time and the petitioner had made some remarks
against the respondent, who is practicing lawyer in District
Court, Samba; that at about 9.00 PM, respondent called the
petitioner on his telephone number to verify about the case
and during the telephonic conversation, the petitioner started
shouting at the respondent. It is further pleaded in the petition
that the respondent has misrepresented the trial court by
making false and frivolous allegation that the petitioner
shouted at him but in fact the respondent threatened the
petitioner of dire consequences for not lodging an FIR on the
application of respondent’s client; that the respondent in order
to wreak vengeance and to terrorize and demoralize the police
agency has filed the false and frivolous complaint against the
petitioner.
03.
It is next alleged that the respondent has been
involved in FIR No. 0189/2019 dated 29.08.2019 in the Police
Station, Samba as he along with some fellow colleagues
attacked the police personnel; that the respondent has also
been involved in filing the false cases against other person also
and lodged FIR No. 256/2013 dated 30.12.2013, falsely
implicating Panku Sharma, Vinod Sambyal and Shivdarshan
Singh.
04.
Petitioner has assailed the impugned order, inter
alia, on the grounds that the complaint filed by the respondent
is a way to wreck vengeance and to terrorize and demoralize
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
the police agency; that there was no provocation on the side of
the petitioner, in fact, it was the respondent who called the
petitioner and asked him to be ready for the consequences for
not lodging an FIR on the application filed by the respondent’s
client, moreover, it was the respondent only who called the
petitioner and started threatening him, in order to wreak
vengeance on the previous issues; that for the offence of
criminal intimidation, there should be threat with any injury to
the person, reputation or property or to the person or
reputation in whom the person is interested; that the
complaint which is pending disposal before the trial court is a
concocted story portrayed by the respondent; and that the
present complaint is filed only to force the presence of the
petitioner in the court complex, Samba. Finally, it has been
prayed that the order impugned be quashed.
05.
Pursuant to notice, objections have been filed by the
respondent
asserting
therein
that
bare
perusal
of
the
complaint transpires that ‘prima facie’ a case under section
504/506 IPC has been made out against the petitioner as the
basic ingredients of both the offences are admittedly fulfilled in
the complaint; that the averments made in the petition
regarding registration of FIR No. 0189/2019 has no connection
with the order impugned, in fact, the respondent was wrongly
implicated in the said FIR along with all the members of the
Bar; that the registration of the said FIR is a glaring example of
the abuse of the process of law; that the FIR No. 256/2013, as
mentioned by the petitioner in the petition, has no connection
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
with the order impugned as how the petitioner can say that the
respondent has narrated false and frivolous allegations in the
said FIR.
Finally, it has been prayed that the petition be
dismissed.
06.
Learned counsel for the petitioner while reiterating
the grounds of challenge has argued that the petitioner is a
police officer, who was investigating the case wherein one
client
of
respondent-Advocate
was
involved;
that
the
respondent-Advocate had filed the complaint against the
petitioner alleging that he had made some scandalous remarks
about the petitioner regarding which the complaint has been
filed against him before the court below.
He further argued
that there was a civil dispute between two brothers and the
respondent, who is a practising advocate at Samba court, had
called the petitioner, telephonically, to help his client in the
case and that during conversation, he was threatened by the
respondent with dire consequences and on being told that he
would investigate the case as per law, the respondent-Advocate
having offended filed a complaint against him for the
commission of offences under sections 504, 506 IPC. Even
without seeking requisite sanction, as required under section
197 CrPC, the petitioner has, thus, been prosecuted.
The
learned Magistrate not only entertained a false complaint
lodged against the petitioner by the respondent but also took
cognizance and issued the process of which he is aggrieved,
hence he has filed this petition seeking quashment.
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
07.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has further
argued that the petitioner was called by the respondent while
performing an official act of investigation of a case regarding
which the respondent had tried to interfere, as such, whatever
the respondent has alleged against the petitioner was made
during the performance of his official duty during investigation
of the case, as such, before launching any prosecution against
the petitioner, sanction under section 197 CrPC read with
Section 8 of the Police Act was a pre-requisite and imperative,
however, the complaint was lodged without seeking any
sanction from the competent authority and, as such, the
complaint is not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed.
08.
Learned counsel for the respondent, ex adverso,
argued that Section 197 CrPC with regard to sanction to
prosecute public servants was not applicable to the petitioner
as he can be removed from his service under the orders of the
Deputy Inspector General of Police, in terms of Rule 335 of the
J&K Police Rules. He further argued that the trial court has
rightly taken cognizance of the complaint and drawn the
attention of this Court to paragraphs 6 and 8 of the complaint
which, inter alia, discloses that at about 9 P.M., a colleague of
the respondent-complainant, namely, Mandeep Singh Sambyal
visited him and in order to verify the remarks reported to him
by his client made by the petitioner-accused and to know that
why the accused person had made those remarks, the
complainant called him on his mobile phone and asked him
about the same but to the utter surprise of the complainant,
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
the accused started shouting at him, abusing and using most
vulgar and shameful language, threatening, that he will call
him to teach him a lesson, will make an adverse entry in the
roznamcha, ruin his entire career and that he shall be
implicated in a false case of NDPS; that when the complainant
told the accused person that he will prosecute against him
under law, then he told him that, whatever you may do, he is
not afraid of anything, thereby provoking the complainant to
commit an offence against him, however, his colleagues
pacified the complainant.
09.
rightly
He finally argued that the complaint has been
entertained
by
the
learned
Magistrate
and
the
prosecution of the petitioner is required to reach to the just
conclusion of the case.
10.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the
record and considered the matter.
11.
Besides pleading that he has been falsely implicated
in the case by the respondent, who has filed a complaint
against him before the court of learned Magistrate, the
petitioner has mainly relied upon absence of sanction to
prosecute him with the assertion that alleged offence was
reasonably connected with the performance of his official duty
as a police officer and that he cannot be prosecuted without
obtaining a sanction under section 197 CrPC.
12.
It would be appropriate to extract Section 197 CrPC
for better understanding of the case:
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
“197. Prosecution of Judges and public servants.
(1)
When any person who is or was a Judge or Magistrate
or a public servant not removable from his officer save
by or with the sanction of the Government, is accused of
any offence alleged to have been committed by him
while acting or purporting to act in the discharge of his
official duty, no Court shall take cognizance of such
offence except with the previous sanction-
(a)
in the case of a person who is employed or, as the case
may be, was at the time of commission of the alleged
offence employed, in connection with the affairs of the
Union, of the Central Government;
(b)
in the case of a person who is employed or, as the case
may be, was at the time of commission of the alleged
offence employed, in connection with the affairs of a
State of the State Government.”
13.
The Patna High Court in a case of Abhay Narayan
Singh Vs. State of Bihar & Ors, 2025 SCC Online Pat 2224
had held that the requirement of prior sanction under section
197 of CrPC protects public servant from vexatious and
retaliatory legal proceedings for acts reasonably connected to
the discharge of their official duties. The Apex Court in a case
titled D.T. Virupakshappa Vs. C. Subash reported as 2015
CriLJ 2589 had held that whole allegation is on police excess
in connection with the prosecution of the criminal case and
that offensive conduct was reasonably connected with the
official duty of the appellant.
14.
The Apex Court in a case of Om Parkash & Ors Vs.
State of Jharkhand & Anr, (2012) 12 SCC 72 after referring to
various decisions, particularly pertaining to the police excess,
summed up the guidelines in pargraph 32, which are extracted
as under:
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
“32. The true test as to whether a public servant was acting or
purporting to act in discharge of his duties would be whether
the act complained of was directly connected with his official
duties or it was done in the discharge of his official duties or it
was so integrally connected with or attached to his office as to
be inseparable from it. (K. Satwant Singh). The protection given
under Section 197 of the Code has certain limits and is
available only when the alleged act done by the public servant
is reasonably connected with the discharge of his official duty
and is not merely a cloak for doing the objectionable act. If in
doing his official duty, he acted in excess of his duty, but there
is
a reasonable
connection
between
the
act and
the
performance of the official duty, the excess will not be a
sufficient ground to deprive the public servant of the protection.
(Ganesh Chandra Jew). If the above tests are applied to the
facts of the present case, the police must get protection given
under Section 197 of the Code because the acts complained of
are so integrally connected with or attached to their office as to
be inseparable from it. It is not possible for us to come to a
conclusion that the protection granted under Section 197 of the
Code is used by the police personnel in this case as a cloak for
killing the deceased in cold blood.”
15.
The Apex Court in a case titled G.C. Manjunath &
Ors Vs. Seetaram reported as 2025 (5) SCC 390, held that
prior sanction under section 197 of the CrPC and Section 170
of the Karnataka Police Act is mandatory for prosecuting police
officer for acts purportedly done in discharge of official duties,
even if, such acts exceed, authority provided there is a
reasonable nexus between the act and official duty.
16.
In the case on hand, the respondent has filed the
complaint against the conduct and remarks made about him
by the police officer in connection with the investigation of the
case.
The respondent, a legal practitioner at Samba courts,
claimed to have called the petitioner, who was investigating a
case and on not entertaining him by the petitioner, some
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
altercations seem to have ensued between them, which, as per
the respondent-complainant, was offensive, as such, he filed a
complaint, which was entertained and cognizance was taken
by the learned Magistrate vide impugned order, therefore, the
offence, if any, had taken between the parties, it was regarding
the investigation of the case being carried out by the petitioner
as a police officer wherein the respondent, as a practising
lawyer, wanted to interfere in the interests of his client
resulting into unfortunate conversation between the two
leading to the filing of a criminal case against the police officer.
The development that had taken place was, thus, intrinsically
related to the official duties of the petitioner as a police officer
and to prosecute him for the commission of any offence in
such a case, there is a requirement of prior sanction from the
competent authority to launch prosecution against petitioner,
which, in the instant case, was filed by the respondent against
the petitioner before the court below without any prior
sanction. The learned Magistrate also seems to be oblivious of
his legal position, having not only entertained the complaint
but issued process against the petitioner, of which he is rightly
aggrieved of.
17.
Having regard to the aforesaid discussion and the
applicability of the law laid down by the Apex Court to the
factual background of the case, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the petitioner cannot be prosecuted without
obtaining prior sanction. The entertainment of the complaint
and issuing process thereon by the learned Magistrate is, thus,
CRM(M) No. 486/2021
an illegality committed by the learned Magistrate. The
impugned order is, thus, liable to be quashed.
18.
Viewed thus, the petition is allowed. The impugned
order dated 26.03.2021 is quashed. Proceedings in complaint
are ordered to be stopped, awaiting sanction to prosecute to be
produced by the complainant.
19.
The petition is, accordingly, disposed of along with
connected application(s).
(M A CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
JAMMU
20.08.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes
Raj Kumar
2026.08.20 16:44
I attest to the accuracy
and No. 486/2021
CRM(M)
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review