Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
30th September 2019
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia,
S/o Shri Tseten Bhutia,
R/o Arithang,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
.… Appellant/Defendant
versus
Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B. B. Rai,
S/o Shri Buddha Lal Rai,
R/o Linding Busty,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…. Respondent/ Plaintiff
-------------------------------------------------------------------------Appeal under Order XLI, Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908.
Appearance:
Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Mr. Sonam
Rinchen Lepcha, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Mr. Sunil Baraily,
Advocate for the Respondent.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT
(30.09.2019)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
This Appeal under Order XL1, Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 is against the judgment and decree both
dated 29.08.2017 passed by the Learned District Judge, East
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
Sikkim at Gangtok in Money Suit No.11 of 2015 decreeing the
suit in favour of Bir Bahadur Rai (The Plaintiff).
The Plaint
2.
Bir Bahadur Rai’s case was that he and Karma Loday
Bhutia (Defendant) were both contractors known to each other.
Karma Loday Bhutia was entrusted with the contract to
construct the Panchayat Ghar at Rakdong-Tintek. As Karma
Loday Bhutia was unable to pursue the contract he executed an
irrevocable power of attorney (exhibit-2) in favour of Bir
Bahadur Rai. Thereafter, Bir Bahadur Rai commenced the
construction of the Panchayat Ghar investing his own money
and completed it. When he came to learn that Karma Loday
Bhutia had received payments from the running bills he issued
legal notice dated 30.03.2012 (exhibit-3) to Zilla Panchayat to
stop payment. On 27.02.2013 the Department sanctioned the
final bill slip of Rs. 7,89,000/- (exhibit-4) and handed over a
cheque for the said amount to Karma Loday Bhutia in the
presence of Bir Bahadur Rai. Thereafter, Karma Loday Bhutia
issued two cheques i.e. State Bank of Sikkim’s cheque dated
06.03.2013 for Rs.7,89,000/- (exhibit-5) and HDFC Bank’s
cheque dated 12.03.2013 for Rs.7,90,000/- (exhibit-6) to Bir
Bahadur Rai. Both the cheques were dishonoured vide return
memos dated 19.03.2013 (exhibit-7) and 15.03.2013 (exhibit-8).
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
Although, Bir Bahadur Rai informed Karma Loday Bhutia about
it he did not pay the amount due. He could not therefore make
the labour payments for which the labourers complained to the
Panchayat (exhibit-9). The President of the Panchayat issued
letter dated 17.04.2013 (exhibit-10) to Bir Bahadur Rai
informing him about it. Bir Bahadur Rai waited till March 2015
for payment and issued legal notice dated 23.03.2015 (exhibit11) to Karma Loday Bhutia.
Thereafter, he filed the suit for
recovery of Rs.15,79,000/-.
The Written Statement
3.
Karma Loday Bhutia disputed the execution of the
irrevocable power of attorney. He denied he was not capable to
pursue the contract work. He asserted that he had executed the
contract work and completed it on 30.06.2011. Karma Loday
Bhutia explained that the irrevocable power of attorney was
executed by him as Bir Bahadur Rai had assured him that he
had an enlistment of a Grade-B contractor but when he failed to
produce it he refused to get it registered and cancelled it. Karma
Loday Bhutia specifically denied that Bir Bahadur Rai had
executed the work. He asserted that it was him who had
executed the work after taking loans from friends, relatives and
financial institutions. He denied issuing the two cheques in
favour of Bir Bahadur Rai and asserted that he had procured
the cheques deceitfully. He also stated that in fact the
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
Panchayat had called him due to the complaint by the labourers
after which he settled the dispute with them and drew a
„milapatra‟.
The Issues Framed
4.
The
learned
District
Judge
framed
four
issues
on
12.05.2016. They were:
“1.
Whether the Plaintiff was appointed by the Defendant
as his Attorney to execute the contract work for
construction of Panchayat Ghar at Rakdong Tintek?
2.
Whether the Defendant had executed the contract
work and had issued to the Plaintiff two cheques
bearing No.066152 dated 06.03.2013 of Rs.7,89,000/(SBS)
and
No.421328
dated
12.03.2013
of
Rs.7,90,000/-?
3.
Whether the present suit is barred by limitation?
4.
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the relief claimed?”
The Trial
5.
During the trial Bir Bahadur Rai examined himself, Tulsi
Pradhan (P.W.2) and Binod Rai (P.W.3) both his co-villagers.
Karma Loday Bhutia examined himself, Om Prakash GurungJunior Engineer (D.W.2) and B. B. Gurung-Panchayat Member
(D.W.3).
The Impugned Judgment and Decree
6.
Based on the oral and documentary evidence led by the
parties during the trial the learned District Judge passed the
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
impugned judgment dated 29.08.2017 decreeing the suit in
favour of Bir Bahadur Rai for a sum of Rs.15,79,000/- along
with interest @ 8% per annum from the date of filing of the suit
till the realization of the decreed amount. Bir Bahadur Rai was
further granted a decree for a sum of Rs.31,580/- payable by
Karma Loday Bhutia being the court fees deposited by Bir
Bahadur Rai.
7.
The learned District Judge came to the conclusion that the
power of attorney was validly executed by Karma Loday Bhutia
in favour of Bir Bahadur Rai and he had not cancelled it; after
completion of the contract work Karma Loday Bhutia had
issued the two cheques to Bir Bahadur Rai of Rs.7,89,000/and Rs.7,90,000/- which bears his signatures; suit was not
barred by limitation and that Bir Bahadur Rai was entitled to
the reliefs claimed.
The Rival Contentions
8.
Aggrieved thereby Karma Loday Bhutia has preferred the
present appeal. Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, learned Senior Advocate
for Karma Loday Bhutia submitted that the Plaintiff has to
prove its own case and cannot take advantage of the weakness
of the Defendant. He relied upon the judgment of the Supreme
Court in re: State of M.P. v. Nomi Singh1 for the said proposition.
The Supreme Court had held that it is settled principle of law
(2015) 14 SCC 450
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
that in respect of relief claimed by a Plaintiff, he has to stand on
his own legs by proving his case. It was submitted that
therefore, Bir Bahadur Rai was required to prove that the
irrevocable power of attorney was valid and enforceable in law
and that he had himself executed the contract work and
completed the same using his own resources. Bir Bahadur Rai
however, failed to do so. On the contrary Karma Loday Bhutia
has been able to cogently prove that it was he who executed the
work. It was submitted that Bir Bahadur Rai had admitted that
the cheques were not directly handed over to him by Karma
Loday Bhutia and he could not identify the handwritings
appearing thereon. Karma Loday Bhutia on the other hand had
deposed that he had not issued the cheques in favour of Bir
Bahadur Rai for executing the work as his attorney.
9.
Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior Advocate for Karma Loday
Bhutia on the other hand supported the judgment of the
learned District Judge. It was submitted that unlike a criminal
case the Civil Court may come to the conclusion on the basis of
preponderance of probabilities.
The fact that Karma Loday
Bhutia had in fact executed the irrevocable power of attorney
and issued the two cheques under his signature in favour of Bir
Bahadur Rai coupled with the oral and documentary evidence
led
by
him
leads
to
the
conclusion
on
the
basis
of
preponderance of probabilities that the two cheques totaling to
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
Rs.15,79,000/- were issued by Karma Loday Bhutia as the
work was in fact executed by Bir Bahadur Rai.
The Consideration
10. Before examining the issues it would be relevant to
consider the concept of proving a civil case on the basis of
preponderance of probability. Section 3 of the Indian Evidence
Act, 1872 provides that a fact is said to be “proved” when, if
considering the matters before it, the Court either believes it to
exist, or considers the existence so probable that a prudent
man might, under the circumstances of a particular case, to act
upon the supposition that it exist. The conformational effect of
evidence in civil and criminal cases is not always the same.
Preponderance of probability is sufficient for a decision in a civil
case. Due regard must be given to the “burden of proof”. The
standard of proof in a civil case is lesser than a criminal
prosecution. Therefore, a higher degree of probability providing
assurance to the Plaintiff’s case set up would shift the “onus of
proof” upon the Defendant. It is equally exigent to discern the
essential difference between “burden of proof” and “onus of
proof”. The “burden of proof” lies upon the person who has to
prove the fact. This “burden of proof” never shifts. “Onus of
proof” on the other hand shifts. In the present suit for recovery
of money Bir Bahadur Rai was required to create a high degree
of probability to discharge his “burden of proof” so as to shift
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
the “onus of proof” upon Karma Loday Bhutia. If Bir Bahadur
Rai succeeded to do so Karma Loday Bhutia would be required
to discharge his “onus of proof” and in the absence thereof the
“burden of proof” lying on Bir Bahadur Rai would be held to be
discharged.
Issue No.3
11. Issue No.3 is taken up first. Issue No.3 was whether the
suit was barred by limitation? The learned District Judge has
held that since the suit was for realization of money the period
of limitation was three years and as the two cheques are dated
06.03.2013 and 12.03.2013 the suit filed was within the period
of limitation. The said cheques were dishonored on 19.03.2013
and 15.03.2013 and thus the suit filed on 16.07.2015 was
within the period of limitation.
Issue No.1
12. Issue No.1 is taken up next. Bir Bahadur Rai produced
and exhibited the original irrevocable power of attorney (exhibit2) which had been signed by the executant i.e. Karma Loday
Bhutia and the recipient i.e. Bir Bahadur Rai. It was signed in
the presence of two witnesses i.e. Tulsi Pradhan (P.W.2) and
Binod Rai (P.W.3). Both the witnesses deposed that they had
signed it in favour of Bir Bahadur Rai. It has been executed
under the seal and signature of an Oath Commissioner who
was however, not examined. The irrevocable power of attorney
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
recited
that
Karma
Loday
Bhutia
was
entrusted
with
contractual work for the construction of the Panchayat Ghar at
Rakdong-Tintek for the sum of Rs.29 lakhs but being unable to
fully fulfill the work and effectively deal with it he has decided
to appoint Bir Bahadur Rai as his attorney “to take over the said
construction work and to do all acts and deeds in relation
thereto”. It also acknowledged that Bir Bahadur Rai had
immensely contributed in respect of obtaining the contract work
and had interest therein. Bir Bahadur Rai was cross-examined.
Karma Loday Bhutia put to him that the irrevocable power of
attorney was invalid which was denied. To the suggestion that a
contract awarded to the contractor cannot be sublet Bir
Bahadur Rai said he was not aware. Karma Loday Bhutia did
not put any further question on the irrevocable power of
attorney although in the written statement he had denied the
execution thereof. Instead, Karma Loday Bhutia during crossexamination admitted his signatures on the irrevocable power of
attorney. He also admitted that it was with regard to
construction of the Panchayat Ghar and that he had appointed
Bir Bahadur Rai as his lawful attorney through the irrevocable
power of attorney to take charge of the construction of the
Panchayat Ghar at Rakdong-Tintek. He admitted that he had
not filed any document to show that he had cancelled the
irrevocable power of attorney. Karma Loday Bhutia admitted
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
that as per the irrevocable power of attorney he had sublet the
contract work to Bir Bahadur Rai and that it was not submitted
to the concerned Department for approval. He admitted that the
concerned department was not aware of the irrevocable power
of attorney having been executed by him in favour of Bir
Bahadur Rai.
13. Consequently, the learned District Judge’s finding on
issue No.1 is affirmed and it is held that Karma Loday Bhutia
had in fact executed the irrevocable power of attorney.
Whether after being appointed as attorney by Karma Loday
Bhutia did Bir Bahadur Rai commence the construction of the
Panchayat Ghar at Rakdong-Tintek investing his own money and
completed the same?
14. Bir Bahadur Rai had pleaded that after being appointed as
an attorney of Karma Loday Bhutia he had commenced the
construction work, invested his own money and completed it.
Karma Loday Bhutia on the other hand denied the assertion.
The learned District Judge however, did not frame the
necessary issue which ought to have been framed on the rival
pleadings. The issue was: Whether after being appointed as
attorney by Karma Loday Bhutia did Bir Bahadur Rai
commence the construction of the Panchayat Ghar at RakdongTintek investing his own money and completed the same? This
issue was an issue of fact to be established by cogent evidence.
Instead the learned District Judge framed issue No.2 as quoted
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
above. As both the parties were fully aware about their
pleadings and led necessary evidence this Court shall examine
first if Bir Bahadur Rai has been able to establish that he had
invested his money and completed the contract work as
claimed.
15. Beside stating that he had done so, during crossexamination Bir Bahadur Rai admitted that he did not make
any claim for payments for executing the work; the Department
had not issue any letter of authority to him to execute the work;
He did not make the final payment to the laborers as claimed
in exhibit-9 and exhibit-10; apart from the power of attorney he
did not have any other document pertaining to the agreement
between him and Karma Loday Bhutia concerning the contract
work; he did not file any document or bill showing that he had
made payment or the accounts of expenditure pertaining to the
said work; he did not hand over any such document or bill to
the concerned department as well and he had not deposited any
bills, voucher etc. showing the payment made by him in the
said contract work.
16. Bir Bahadur Rai’s other two witnesses did not throw much
light on his involvement in the contract work after the execution
of the irrevocable power of attorney. A feeble attempt was made
by Binod Rai though. He stated that after a few weeks of signing
of the agreement Bir Bahadur Rai asked him to assist him in
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
the construction work and he was his employee on a salary
basis. Binod Rai however, stated that he had stayed there for 34 days only. He also stated that thereafter also he was sent by
Bir Bahadur Rai 2-3 times to the construction site with cash for
labour payment which he handed over to B.B. Gurung. During
cross-examination however, he admitted that he was a close
friend of Bir Bahadur Rai; he did not have any document to
establish that he was engaged by Bir Bahadur Rai; Bir Bahadur
Rai did not pay him any amount for looking after his work, not
even his expenses. Bir Bahadur Rai did not get a confirmation
from B. B. Gurung about Bimal Rai handing over money to him
for labour payment. Bimal Rai’s evidence cannot be construed
as satisfactory evidence to prove that after his appointment as
Karma Loday Bhutia’s attorney, Bir Bahadur Rai had invested
his own money, commenced and completed the contract work.
17. Along with the irrevocable power of attorney and the two
cheques,
Bir
Bahadur
Rai
also
produced
three
other
documents. First was a complaint dated 13.04.2013 (Exhibit-9)
by labourers about non-payment of their dues by him as the
sub-contractor.
The second was a communication dated
17.04.2013 (Exhibit-10) by B. B. Gurung, President, RakdongTintek GPU to Bir Bahadur Rai about it bringing to his notice
the receipt of the complaint against him for non-payment and
requiring him to be present on 21.04.2013 to discuss the
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
matter. Exhibit-9 and exhibit-10 were exhibited by Bir Bahadur
Rai. Both were attested copies. It was Bir Bahadur Rai’s own
case that due to the failure of Karma Loday Bhutia to honor the
cheques issued in his favour totaling to Rs.15,79,000/- he
could not make the labour payments. Bir Bahadur Rai also
produced final bill slip (exhibit-4) dated 27.02.2013 with his
signature which does reflect that he had signed it when Karma
Loday Bhutia had received the final payment. From the said
documents all that could be inferred is that Bir Bahadur Rai
was probably involved in the contract work as a sub-contractor
but to what extent is not clear.
18. Bir Bahadur Rai did not examine any of the labourers he
claimed to have hired for the construction of the Panchayat
Ghar. There is not a single independent person who even
claimed to have seen him at the contract site leave alone the
site engineers. Bir Bahadur Rai has neither produced oral nor
documentary evidence to prove that he had in fact invested his
own money for the contract work. An investment of 15,79,000/is a huge amount and it is unbelievable that Bir Bahadur Rai
did not have a single piece of evidence to show the investment
although even in the legal notice dated 30.03.2012 (exhibit-3)
issued by him to the Department and legal notice dated
23.03.2015 (exhibit-11) issued to Karma Loday Bhutia he had
asserted that he had in fact constructed the Panchayat Ghar
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
from his investments and expenses. It was incumbent upon Bir
Bahadur Rai to prove the facts he asserted. Bir Bahadur Rai
has failed to prove that after being appointed as attorney he
commenced the contract work investing his own money and has
completed the same.
19. Framing of issue is crucial to arrive at a correct
conclusion. An erroneous issue may misdirect the Court.
Similary, failure to fix the burden of proof upon the party who
asserts the fact may also lead the Court to determine and
appreciate facts incorrectly.
20. The Learned District Judge did not examine whether Bir
Bahadur Rai had been able to prove that after being appointed
as an attorney by Karma Loday Bhutia he had in fact invested
his own money, commenced and completed the contract work
as no such issue was framed.
Issue No.2
21. This Court shall now examine issue no.2 framed by the
learned District Judge. Issue No.2 actually incorporates two
issues.
22. The first part related to the assertion made by Karma
Loday Bhutia that he had executed the contract work. The
Learned District Judge was examining a suit filed by Bir
Bahadur Rai against Karma Loday Bhutia. Whereas Bir
Bahadur Rai had asserted that it was he who had done the
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
contract work, Karma Loday Bhutia had denied this assertion
and asserted that it was in fact he who had done so. The
examination of the evidence led by Karma Loday Bhutia must
be appreciated keeping this fact in mind.
23. The second part relates to the assertion of Bir Bahadur
Rai that the two cheques were issued by Karma Loday Bhutia.
Therefore, the burden of proof was on Bir Bahadur Rai to prove
the fact he asserted.
24. It would be apposite to refer to Section 101 and 102 of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 at this juncture. Section 101
provides that whoever desires any Court to give judgment as to
any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts
which he asserts, must prove that those facts exists. When a
person is bound to prove the existence of any fact, it is said that
the burden of proof lies on that person. Section 102 provides
that the burden of proof in a suit or proceeding lies on that
person who would fail if no evidence at all were given on either
side.
25. The learned District Judge examined the evidence and in
view of the communication dated 13.04.2013 (exhibit-9) issued
by six labourers to the President of the Rakdong-Tintek Unit
complaining about the failure of the sub-contractor to make
payments to them came to the conclusion that Bir Bahadur Rai
was involved in the construction work. The learned District
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
Judge also held that the two cheques had in fact been issued by
Karma Loday Bhutia in favour of Bir Bahadur Rai and that it
had not been deceitfully obtained. Consequently, the learned
District Judge held that Karma Loday Bhutia was liable to
make the payment to Bir Bahadur Rai without considering what
the consideration was and if he had been able to prove it.
Did Karma Loday Bhutia execute the contract work?
26. Although it was Karma Loday Bhutia’s case that he had
executed the work after having taken loan from financial
institutions, friends and relatives for completion of the work he
did not produce any document to substantiate that he had
taken loan from relatives. He admitted so in his crossexamination. He produced only a legal notice dated 16.03.2011
(exhibit-H) issued by a lawyer for the State Bank of Sikkim to
prove the fact that he had taken loan and advances from
financial institutions. The letter reflects that Karma Loday
Bhutia had an overdraft account showing debit balance of
Rs.4,61,082/- as on 28.02.2011. Karma Loday Bhutia admitted
in his cross-examination that exhibit-H does not disclose that
he had taken loan from State Bank of Sikkim for completion of
the contract work. He also produced a photo copy of an
undertaking dated 14.07.2013 (document-Y) executed by him
stating that he would repay the amount of loan taken from B.B.
Gurung. B.B. Gurung stated that the undertaking was in fact
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
executed by Karma Loday Bhutia to repay the loan taken from
him for the purpose of the construction. During crossexamination he admitted that document-Y was only a photo
copy and denied the suggestion that it was not executed by
Karma Loday Bhutia. The said document was not exhibited
being photocopies. Karma Loday Bhutia had not been able to
sufficiently prove that he had in fact taken loans and advances
to complete the contract work.
27. Karma Loday Bhutia produced attested copy of the work
order (exhibit-A) issued in his favour. Om Prakash Gurung
(D.W.-2), the Junior Engineer for Karma Loday Bhutia proved
the work order.
28. The work order (exhibit-A) issued in favour of Karma
Loday Bhutia is dated 11.02.2009. It provided the following
details:“Completion Time:
9 (Nine) months
Total Sanctioned Amount:
Rs.29,00,000/-
Electrification:
Rs. 1,76,025/-
Contingency:
Rs. 1,01,630/-
Amount Civil Work put to Tender: Rs.26,22,345/Tender Rate ATPAR:
Rs.26,22,345/-
Work Order Value:
Rs.26,22,345/-”
29. To prove his assertion Karma Loday Bhutia produced
attested copies of Government approvals for procurement of 128
and 300 bags of cement dated 16.03.2009 (exhibit-A) and
11.08.2009 (exhibit-B colly); attested copy of cash memo dated
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
12.08.2009 (exhibit-B colly) for purchase of 127 bags of cement;
attested copy of cash memo dated 16.10.2009 for Rs.32,400/for
purchase
of
timber
(exhibit-C);
original
receipt
of
Rs.34,750/- for purchase of timber (exhibit-D); original receipt
of Rs.1,50,000/- (exhibit-L) for construction of trust and GCI
sheet roof of the Panchayat Ghar and original receipt of
Rs.1,05,040/- for the RCC work for the Panchayat Ghar
(exhibit-M).
30. None of the aforesaid documents were proved by their
makers. Karma Loday Bhutia however, exhibited all of them as
recipient of the said receipts without any protest from Bir
Bahadur Rai. All these documents relate to the construction of
the Panchayat Ghar and apparently involve Karma Loday
Bhutia as the contractor executing the work.
31. Karma Loday Bhutia produced exhibit-K i.e. original
notebook with handwritten title “Construction of Panchayat
Ghar at Rakdong Tintek, E/Sikkim”. The said notebook contains
attendance of seven labourers for the month of January 2011
till May 2011. None of the labourers were examined. Karma
Loday Bhutia exhibited the notebook as labour payment
register maintained by him. He deposed that labourers were
hired by him for the construction of Panchayat Ghar and a
labour payment register was maintained by him which was
submitted to the labour department from time to time and
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
returned after verification. He did not identify the handwriting
and signature appearing in exhibit-K. Bir Bahadur Rai did not
make an issue of it. During cross-examination Karma Loday
Bhutia admitted that the contract work commenced from
February 2009 and was completed in June 2011. He also
admitted that he had filed labour payment register of January
2011 to May 2011 and not for the year 2009 and 2010. He
denied the suggestion that he had not done so as the payment
was made by Bir Bahadur Rai.
32. Karma Loday Bhutia produced original show cause notice
dated 18.02.2010 (exhibit-E) issued by the Zilla Panchayat
requiring him to show cause for the delay in construction;
attested copies of recommendations for extension of time till
31.07.2010 (exhibit-F) and 30.06.2011 (exhibit-G); attested
copy of completion report dated 14.11.2011 issued by the
Audit-cum-Vigilance Committee (exhibit-I colly), completion
certificate from the Zilla Panchayat reflecting completion date as
30.06.2011 (exhibit-I colly); handing over certificate issued by
the Zilla Panchayat reflecting handing over the Panchayat Ghar
on 30.06.2011 (exhibit-J) and attested copy of labour clearance
certificate dated 14.02.2012 issued by the Department of
Labour giving its no objection for release of final bill in favour of
Karma Loday Bhutia (exhibit-N).
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
33. None of the aforesaid documents were proved by their
makers. They were however exhibited by Karma Loday Bhutia
as the recipient of the documents without any protest. All these
documents also relate to the construction of the Panchayat
Ghar and involve Karma Loday Bhutia as the contractor.
34. Om Prakash Gurung (D.W.2) Junior Engineer deposed
that in the year 2009 Karma Loday Bhutia was awarded the
contract through the work order dated 11.02.2009. After the
award of work he being the Junior Engineer under the Zilla
Panchayat had shown the construction site and explained the
details of the work to Karma Loday Bhutia. He was the
immediate site engineer of the construction work. Karma Loday
Bhutia started executing the work. Om Prakash Gurung (D.W.2)
used to visit the work site from time to time and verify the
progress of the work. After 50% of the progress of the work Om
Prakash Gurung (D.W.2) processed the first running bill of the
construction work of Karma Loday Bhutia. After processing the
first running bill Om Prakash Gurung (D.W.2) was transferred
to the Department of Animal Husbandry. Om Prakash Gurung
(D.W.2) asserted that Bir Bahadur Rai was not connected to the
work in question which was awarded to Karma Loday Bhutia
and who completed the work to the satisfaction of the
Department and the bills were paid to him. In his crossexamination Om Prakash Gurung (D.W.2) admitted that he did
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
not know that Bir Bahadur Rai had been appointed attorney by
Karma Loday Bhutia to execute the construction of the
Panchayat Ghar. He admitted that all Government contract
works were governed by Sikkim Public Works Manual and
subletting of Government contract work is not allowed under it.
He admitted that if someone is found subletting the contract
work awarded to him the Department/Government has power
to cancel the contract work and to award it to another
contractor. He admitted that the Zilla Panchayat office was also
not aware that Karma Loday Bhutia had in fact sublet the
contract work to Bir Bahadur Rai. He admitted that since he
was transferred to the Department of Animal Husbandry he
could not say who completed the contract work.
35. B. B. Gurung (D.W.3) came to the witness box as witness
for Karma Loday Bhutia. He deposed that he was earlier the
Panchayat and later the President of the same Panchayat Unit
at the relevant time. According to him in the year 2009 Karma
Loday Bhutia was awarded a contract for construction of
Panchayat Ghar. Karma Loday Bhutia started executing the
work and he used to supervise the work as well. Om Prakash
Gurung, Junior Engineer used to visit and inspect the
construction site. Karma Loday Bhutia hired number of
labourers for the construction of the Panchayat Ghar and all
the payments were made by him. He had issued letter dated
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
03.07.2013 (exhibit-O) to Karma Loday Bhutia to be present on
14.07.2013 before him for decision against the complaint
lodged by the labourers against him. Karma Loday Bhutia
appeared before him and the matter was amicably settled as
Karma Loday Bhutia made the necessary payments to the
labourers and a “milapatra” dated 14.07.2013 (exhibit-P) was
executed acknowledging the receipt of the payments from him.
During his cross-examination B.B. Gurung admitted that
exhibit-9 is a complaint made by the labourers against the subcontractor Bir Bahadur Rai regarding the default in making
payment even after 18 months of completion of work. He also
admitted that exhibit-10 was a letter sent to him by Bir
Bahadur Rai. However, he denied that the labourers mentioned
in exhibit-9 were engaged by Bir Bahadur Rai. In fact he
volunteered to say that the labourers were engaged by Karma
Loday Bhutia. B. B. Gurung admitted that the labourers
reported the matter before him against Bir Bahadur Rai for
non-payment of their money and that he appeared on
21.04.2013 and asked for two more days to make the labour
payment.
36. The evidence led by Karma Loday Bhutia proves that he
was awarded the contract. It also proves that he started the
execution of the contract work. It probablises that he hired
labourers and paid them; purchased some materials and paid
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
for them. It proves that when he could not complete the work
on time extension was sought for and granted to him. It also
proves that the completion certificates were issued to him once
the work was completed. Bir Bahadur Rai had to stand on his
own feet to establish the case he sought to make out. Karma
Loday has been able to make it probable that it was him who
had executed the work.
The issuance of the two cheques
37. Bir Bahadur Rai had stated in his plaint that after
receiving the final bill of the contract work Karma Loday Bhutia
had issued the two cheques in his favour which were
dishonoured.
38. Bir Bahadur Rai produced the two original cheques i.e.
exhibit-5 and exhibit-6). Exhibit-5 was signed by Karma Loday
Bhutia as the drawer of the cheque in the front and two
signatures at the back. Bir Bahadur Rai had also signed at the
back at two places. Bir Bahadur Rai was the drawee of the said
cheque. Exhibit-6 was also signed by Karma Loday Bhutia as
the drawer of the cheque in the front and one signature at the
back. Bir Bahadur Rai had signed at two places at the back. Bir
Bahadur Rai was the drawee of this cheque too.
39. Karma
Loday
Bhutia
admitted
during
his
cross-
examination that signatures on the two cheques were in fact
his. He also admitted that he had neither lodged any First
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
Information Report before any Police Station alleging that Bir
Bahadur Rai had deceitfully obtained the said two cheques nor
directed the banks to stop payment.
40. Bir Bahadur Rai produced and exhibited the original
cheque return memos of the State Bank of Sikkim (exhibit-7)
and HDFC bank (exhibit-8) returning both the cheques one on
account of account being closed and the other for insufficient
funds.
41. Bir Bahadur Rai was cross-examined on this aspect. He
admitted that the two cheques were not directly handed over to
him by Karma Loday Bhutia. Bir Bahadur Rai could not identify
the handwriting appearing on the said two cheques. He denied
the suggestion that the cheques were procured from a third
person and they were meant for the said person and not for
him. He also denied he had obtained it deceitfully for illegal
gain. He admitted that he had not filed any private complaint
under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 for the dishonour
of the cheques. He admitted that he had not lodged any
complaint before the Sadar Police Station for the same. It is
therefore, quite certain that the two cheques had in fact been
issued by Karma Loday Bhutia in favour of Bir Bahadur Rai. It
is also evident that the two cheques were presented for payment
by Bir Bahadur Rai but were dishonoured.
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
Presumption as to negotiable instruments under Section 118(a)
and the relevance of the debt being “legally enforceable debt or
other liability” under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments
Act, 1881
42. Bir Bahadur Rai did not lead any evidence at all to prove
the fact that he had commenced the construction work,
investing his own money and completed it. He sought to rely
upon the irrevocable power to attorney and the issuance of the
cheques by Karma Loday Bhutia to prove the fact that it was
him who had executed the work. The learned District Judge has
held that Karma Loday Bhutia after completion of the contract
work issued the two cheques. The learned District Judge also
held that the two cheques had been issued by Karma Loday
Bhutia by affixing his signature thereon in favour of Bir
Bahadur Rai and therefore he was liable to make the payment
to him. The fact that Karma Loday Bhutia had in fact issued the
two cheques which were dishonored is sufficiently proved. The
fact that Bir Bahadur Rai had commenced the construction
work and completed it investing his own money has not been
proved. However, it must be examined whether the mere fact
that Bir Bahadur Rai has been able to prove the execution of
the irrevocable power of attorney and the issuance of the two
cheques which were dishonored would lead to a presumption
that Bir Bahadur Rai executed the said work. For this purpose
it is important to examine Section 118 (a) and Section 138 of
the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (the said Act).
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
43. Section 118 of the said Act provides for presumptions as
to negotiable instruments. Section 118 (a) of the said Act
provides:“118. Presumptions as to negotiable instruments.-Until the
contrary is proved, the following presumptions shall be made:(a) of consideration-that every negotiable instrument was made
or drawn for consideration, and that every such instrument,
when it has been accepted, indorsed, negotiated or transferred,
was
accepted,
indorsed,
negotiated
or
transferred
for
consideration;
xxxxx
Provided that, where the instrument has been obtained from its
lawful owner, or from any person in lawful custody thereof, by means
of an offence or fraud, or has been obtained from the maker or
acceptor thereof by means of an offence or fraud or for unlawful
consideration, the burden of proving that the holder is a holder in due
course lies upon him.”
44. Section 138 of the said Act reads as under:“138. Dishonour of cheque for insufficiency, etc., of funds
in the account. Where any cheque drawn by a person on an account
maintained by him with a banker for payment of any amount of
money to another person from out of that account for the discharge, in
whole or in part, of any debt or other liability, is returned by the bank
unpaid, either because of the amount of money standing to the credit
of that account is insufficient to honour the cheque or that it exceeds
the amount arranged to be paid from that account by an agreement
made with that bank, such person shall be deemed to have committed
an offence and shall, without prejudice to any other provision of this
Act, be punished with imprisonment for a term which may be
extended to two years, or with fine which may extend to twice the
amount of the cheque, or with both:
Provided that nothing contained in this section shall apply
unless—
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
(a) the cheque has been presented to the bank within a period of six
months from the date on which it is drawn or within the period of
its validity, whichever is earlier;
(b) the payee or the holder in due course of the cheque, as the case
may be, makes a demand for the payment of the said amount of
money by giving a notice in writing, to the drawer of the
cheque, within thirty days of the receipt of information by him from
the bank regarding the return of the cheque as unpaid; and
(c) the drawer of such cheque fails to make the payment of the said
amount of money to the payee or, as the case may be, to the holder
in due course of the cheque, within fifteen days of the receipt of the
said notice.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, “debt or other
liability” means a legally enforceable debt or other liability.”
45. The cheques having been issued by Karma Loday Bhutia
in favour of Bir Bahadur Rai a presumption is raised under
Section 118 (a) of the said Act that the same were for
consideration. In a case of a negotiable instrument the
presumption under Section 118 of the said Act has to be made
until the contrary is proved. Karma Loday Bhutia could show
either by direct evidence or circumstantial evidence that the
negotiable instrument was not supported by consideration.
46. In re: Bharat Barrel & Drum Manufacturing Company v. Amin
Chand Payrelal2 the Supreme Court while hearing a civil appeal
arising out of a suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 filed by a holder of a promissory note, the
2 (1999) 3 SCC 35
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
defendant agreeing to pay the amount specified therein to the
Plaintiff, held as under:
“12. Upon consideration of
various
judgments
as
noted
hereinabove, the position of law which emerges is that once
execution of the promissory note is admitted, the presumption
under Section 118(a) would arise that it is supported by a
consideration. Such a presumption is rebuttable. The defendant
can prove the non-existence of a consideration by raising a
probable defence. If the defendant is proved to have discharged
the initial onus of proof showing that the existence of
consideration was improbable or doubtful or the same was
illegal, the onus would shift to the plaintiff who will be obliged
to prove it as a matter of fact and upon its failure to prove
would disentitle him to the grant of relief on the basis of the
negotiable instrument. The burden upon the defendant of
proving the non-existence of the consideration can be either
direct
or
by
bringing
on
record
the
preponderance
of
probabilities by reference to the circumstances upon which he
relies. In such an event, the plaintiff is entitled under law to rely
upon all the evidence led in the case including that of the
plaintiff as well. In case, where the defendant fails to discharge
the initial onus of proof by showing the non-existence of the
consideration, the plaintiff would invariably be held entitled to
the benefit of presumption arising under Section 118(a) in his
favour. The court may not insist upon the defendant to disprove
the existence of consideration by leading direct evidence as the
existence
of
negative
evidence
is
neither
possible
nor
contemplated and even if led, is to be seen with a doubt. The
bare denial of the passing of the consideration apparently does
not appear to be any defence. Something which is probable has
to be brought on record for getting the benefit of shifting the
onus of proving to the plaintiff. To disprove the presumption, the
defendant has to bring on record such facts and circumstances
upon consideration of which the court may either believe that
the consideration did not exist or its non-existence was so
probable that a prudent man would, under the circumstances of
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
the case, shall act upon the plea that it did not exist. We find
ourselves in the close proximity of the view expressed by the
Full Benches of the Rajasthan High Court and the Andhra
Pradesh High Court in this regard.”
47. Has
Karma
Loday Bhutia been able
to
rebut the
presumption under Section 118 (a) of the said Act by showing a
preponderance of probabilities in his favour and against Bir
Bahadur Rai is the vexed question which this Court must
answer.
48. The only conclusion one could arrive at on a meaningful
and purposeful reading of the plaint is that it was Bir Bahadur
Rai’s case that the consideration for the issuance of the cheque
was his investment in the contract work. As held by the
Supreme Court in re: Bharat Barrel & Drum MFG.Co. (Supra) it
was open to Karma Loday Bhutia to prove that the case set up
by Bir Bahadur Rai was not true and rebut the presumption
under Section 118 (a) of the Act by showing a preponderance of
probabilities in his favour and against Bir Bahadur Rai. The
words “until the contrary is proved” in the said section does not
mean that Karma Loday Bhutia must necessarily show that the
cheques were not supported by any form of consideration but
he could ask the Court to consider the non-existence of
consideration so probable that a prudent man ought, under the
circumstances of the case to act upon the supposition that the
consideration did not exist.
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
49. Although Bir Bahadur Rai claimed to have invested his
own money not an iota of evidence was led by him to show that
he had invested even a penny. Karma Loday Bhutia on the
other hand led substantial evidence not only to show that he
had executed the work himself but he had also invested his
money. Appreciating the evidence led by Karma Loday Bhutia to
this limited extent Karma Loday Bhutia has been able to rebut
the presumption against him under Section 118(a) of the said
Act on preponderance of probabilities.
50. The question which still remains unanswered is why did
Karma Loday Bhutia issue the cheques in favour of Bir
Bahadur Rai for such a huge amount of Rs.15,79,000/-. The
evidence led by the parties does not permit this Court to come
to a definite conclusion.
51. The irrevocable power of attorney acknowledged that Bir
Bahadur Rai has immensely contributed in respect of obtaining
the said work and had interest therein. Bir Bahadur Rai during
the cross-examination of Karma Loday Bhutia suggested to him
that as per irrevocable power of attorney he had sublet the
contract work to him. It was Bir Bahadur Rai’s version that
after the execution of the irrevocable power of attorney he had
invested his own money, commenced and completed the
contract work. Om Prakash Gurung (D.W.2) the only site
Engineer and a Government Servant examined by Karma Loday
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
Bhutia during the trial admitted that as per the Sikkim Public
Works Manual subletting is not permissible and if someone is
found subletting the contract work awarded to him the
Department has power to cancel the said contract work on the
suggestion made by Bir Bahadur Rai himself. It is therefore,
probable that the cheques were issued by Karma Loday Bhutia
for subletting as suggested.
Section 138 of the Negotiable
Instruments Act, 1881 provides that it would be an offence if
any cheque drawn for any “legally enforceable debt or other
liability” is dishonored. Subletting being impermissible and
illegal as per Bir Bahadur Rai’s own assertion,
the cheques
issued by Karma Loday Bhutia in favour of Bir Bahadur Rai
could not have been considered as cheques drawn for any
“legally enforceable debt or other liability”. An agreement of subcontract contrary to law cannot also be enforced. Bir Bahadur
Rai having failed to establish any “legally enforceable debt or
other liability” against Karma Loday Bhutia, the suit filed by
him must necessary fail.
Issue No.4
52. In view of the findings above, issue No.4 is held against Bir
Bahadur Rai. It is held that Bir Bahadur Rai is not entitled to
relief claimed.
53. Consequently, the judgment and decree both dated
29.08.2017 are set aside. The Appeal succeeds.
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2017
Shri Karma Loday Bhutia v. Shri Bir Bahadur Rai @ B.B. Rai
54. No order as to costs. Karma Loday Bhutia had deposited
an amount of Rs.3 lakhs as security for the present appeal. The
amount shall be returned to Karma Loday Bhutia along with
interest earned thereon.
55. Copy of this judgment be sent to the Court of the learned
District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
30.09.2019
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
to/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review