Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT:
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE B.KEMAL PASHA
TUESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF AUGUST 2014/28TH SRAVANA, 1936
FAO (RO).No. 364 of 2013 ()
---------------------------AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN AS 255/2010 of III ADDL.SUB COURT,
ERNAKULAM DATED 18-06-2013
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN OS 1226/2007 of I ADDL.MUNSIFF'S COURT,
ERNAKULAM DATED 20-11-2010
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS 1 & 2/DEFENDANTS 1 & 2:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------1. KAPIL NAGPAL
CHAIRMAN, NAGPAL BUILDERS, 33/2155-B5
N.H. BYE-PASS, NEAR MEDICAL CENTRE, VENNALA PO
KANAYANNUR TALUK, ERNAKULAM 682 028.
2. NAGPAL BUILDERS
33/2155-B5, N.H. BYE-PASS, NEAR MEDICAL CENTRE
VENNALA PO
KANAYANNUR TALUK ERNAKULAM 682 028 REPRESENTED
BY ITS OFFICER N.VIJAYAKUMAR.
BY ADV. SRI.TOM K.THOMAS
RESPONDENTS/APPELLANT/RESPONDENTS 3 TO 5/PLAINTIFF & ADDL. PLAINTIFFS:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1. T.M.KALAM, AGED 40 YEARS
S/O.MUSSA, SELMA MANZIL, MARADU
KANAYANNUR TALUK PIN.682 304.
*
2. SHAMEER SULAIMAN, AGED 22 YEARS
(DELETED)
S/O.LATE T.M.SULAIMAN, SELMA MANZIL, MARADU
KANAYANNUR TALUK
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN.682 304.
*
3. LAILA SULAIMAN, AGED 42 YEARS
W/O.LATE T.M.SULAIMAN, SELMA MANZIL, MARADU
KANAYANNUR TALUK
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN.682 304
(DELETED)
*
4. SHAMEENA SULAIMAN, AGED 19 YEARS
D/O.LATE T.M.SULAIMAN, SELMA MANZIL, MARADU
KANAYANNUR TALUK
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN.682 304
(DELETED)
(RESPONDENTS 2 TO 4 ARE DELETED FROM THE PARTY ARRAY AT THE RISK
OF THE APPELLANTS VIDE ORDER DTD 7.4.2014 IN IA.475/14)
R1 BY ADV. SRI.M.P.RAMNATH
R1 BY ADV. SRI.P.RAJESH (KOTTAKKAL)
R1 BY ADV. SMT.UMA R.KAMATH
R1 BY ADV. SMT.S.SANDHYA
THIS FIRST APPEAL FROM ORDER - REMAND ORDER HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 19-08-2014, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
B. KEMAL PASHA, J.
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
F.A.O. (RO) No.364 of 2013
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
Dated this the 19th day of August, 2014
JUDGMENT
~~~~~~~~~
Challenging
judgment
and
decree
dated
18.06.2013 passed by the Subordinate Judge's Court,
Ernakulam in A.S. No.255/2010, respondents 1 and 2 before
the court
below, who are
the
defendants
in O.S.
No.1226/2007 of the I Additional Munsiff's Court, Ernakulam,
have come up in appeal.
2.
O.S. No.1226/2007 was filed by respondents 1
and 2 herein as plaintiffs for recovery of possession,
mandatory injunction, and perpetual injunction. The case of
the plaintiffs is that an extent of 14 cents of landed property,
which is the western portion of a property having a total
extent of 27 cents covered by Ext.B6 sale deed, was
purchased by them through Exts.A1 and A2 sale deeds
dated 19.11.1990. The plaintiffs have been paying basic tax
FAO(RO).364/2013
:2:
in respect of the property and mutation was also effected in
their favour. The vendor of the plaintiffs is one P.P.Cherian
Tharakan, who had purchased the said 27 cents covered by
Ext.B6 sale deed. While the plaintiffs were away at Madras
in connection with their business, the defendants purchased
the property on the eastern side of the properties purchased
by the plaintiffs. According to the plaintiffs, the defendants
wanted to snatch away their property also and they were
threatened
by
the
defendants
that
they
would
be
dispossessed of the property in case the said properties
also were not sold to them.
As the plaintiffs wanted to
preserve their property, by expressing their apprehension,
the suit was initially filed as one for perpetual injunction
against trespass. It is alleged that after the institution of the
suit, the defendants had trespassed into the portion of the
plaint schedule property at its eastern side and constructed
a compound wall by encroaching into a portion of the plaint
schedule property having an extent of 1.575 cents.
By
FAO(RO).364/2013
:3:
describing the said encroached portion as 'plaint A' schedule
property, the plaintiffs amended the plaint thereby seeking
recovery of possession of 'plaint A' schedule property with
its mesne profits and also for mandatory injunction for the
removal
of
the
compound
wall
constructed
by
the
defendants.
3.
The defendants filed a joint written statement
contending, inter alia, as follows:“The description as well as the boundaries in respect
of plaint schedule properties are incorrect and misleading.
The defendants have purchased the properties having an
extent of 33.213 cents which is lying as 13 cents in
re-survey No.377/9 and 20.213 cents in re-survey No.377/1
in Block No.13 of Maradu village, through Ext.B5 sale deed.
At the time of purchase of the property by the defendants,
there was a boundary wall on the western side of the said
13 cents which was more than 20 years old. The said
boundary wall was the eastern boundary wall of the 14 cents
FAO(RO).364/2013
:4:
of the plaintiff. After the purchase of the property by the
defendants, the first plaintiff approached the first defendant
on several occasions requesting for the sale of that portion
of the property so that the plaintiff could take bigger vehicles
to his residence through the eastern side of their property.
As the road frontage of the property of the defendants is
only 11.7 metres, the first defendant was not inclined to
accept the proposal forwarded by the plaintiffs. During
October 2007, the plaintiffs demolished a portion of the
eastern compound wall of their property with a view to
encroaching into the portions of the property of the
defendants. As a compound wall at western side of the
property of the defendants was required, the defendants
had no other go than to construct a compound wall to their
property at the western boundary of their property.
According to the defendants, the plaintiffs had removed the
compound wall at the eastern boundary of their property
with a view to showing that both the properties were lying
FAO(RO).364/2013
:5:
contiguously.
4.
After the amendment of the plaint, an additional
written statement was also filed denying all the claims of the
plaintiffs. On the side of the plaintiffs, PWs 1 to 3 were
examined and Exts.A1 to A13 were marked. On the side of
the defendants, the first defendant was examined as DW1
and another witness was examined as DW2, and Exts.B1 to
B17 were marked. Exts.X1, X2 and X3 were also marked.
The Commissioner and the surveyor, who accompanied the
Commissioner, were examined as CW1 and CW2 and
Exts.C1 and C2 series were also marked. The second
plaintiff died during the pendency of the suit and his Legal
representatives were impleaded. The trial court, after
hearing both sides, found that the first plaintiff is not entitled
to the decree prayed for. Consequently, the suit was
dismissed with costs. Aggrieved by the said judgment and
decree, the first plaintiff filed A.S. No.255/10 before the
Subordinate Judge’s Court, Ernakulam.
FAO(RO).364/2013
:6:
5.
The learned Subordinate Judge, after hearing
both sides, has allowed the appeal by setting aside the
judgment and decree in O.S. No.1226/2007 and remitted
the matter to the trial court for giving an opportunity to the
plaintiffs to file a fresh commission application in order to
locate the plaint schedule property as per the title deed and
old survey sketch in respect of the property. Aggrieved by
the said remand order, respondents 1 and 2 in the appeal
before the lower appellate court have come up in appeal.
6.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellant
Sri.Tom K. Thomas and the learned counsel for the first
respondent Sri. M.P. Ramnath. The other respondents were
deleted from the party array as the first respondent has
purchased
the
portions
of
properties
of
the
other
respondents also.
7.
The learned counsel for the appellants has
argued that the remand order passed by the court below is
not at all warranted and that the court below ought to have
FAO(RO).364/2013
:7:
considered and dismissed the appeal on merits. It is also
argued that there is no question relating to the identity of the
properties arise for consideration in the matter as the
plaintiffs had willingly purchased the property having an
extent of 14 cents, after ascertaining its western boundary
and they purchased a property having an extent of 14 cents
which is lying just east to the then existing western boundary
of that property. It is also argued that the present attempt
on the part of the plaintiffs is to grab portions of the property
of these appellants by making it to appear that there is
'purampoke' land at the western portion of the said 14 cents
being possessed by the plaintiffs.
8.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the first
respondent herein has argued that being the first purchaser
of 14 cents of property out of the 27 cents of property owned
and possessed by the vendor, the first respondent is entitled
to get 14 cents covered by EXts.A1 and A2 and the same
cannot include any portions of 'thodu purampoke' situated
FAO(RO).364/2013
:8:
at the western most portion of the said property. The learned
counsel for the first respondent has taken a stand that there
was no compound wall at the eastern boundary of the
property of the first respondent and what was demolished
was the wall of a building which was in existence in the
property. It is also argued that the first respondent has lost
possession over an extent of 1.575 cents of property
through revenue records as such a portion lying at the
western extremity of the said 14 cents being possessed by
the first respondent at present is styled as 'thodu
purampoke' by the revenue authorities and, therefore, the
first respondent is entitled to get such a portion recovered
from the property being presently possessed by the
appellants.
9.
Admittedly, the first respondent is the first
purchaser from the vendor of the first respondent as well as
the appellants.
It is also true that he had purchased an
extent of 14 cents of property. The said 14 cents is situated
FAO(RO).364/2013
:9:
in survey Nos. 573/1 and 574/2. As per Exts.A1 and A2, the
plaintiff had purchased the entire extent of 12 cents coming
in survey No.574/2 and 2 cents from survey No.573/1. The
total extent of property which the vendor was having in
survey No.573/1 was 15 cents. After excluding the 2 cents
purchased by the first respondent from that property, the
appellants purchased the remaining 13 cents from survey
No.573/1.
According to the lower appellate court, it has
come out through Ext.C2(a) plan that there was no such
actual extent of 27 cents available with the vendor and that
two plots marked as 'K' and 'L' shown at the western portion
of the property in the possession of the first respondent are
'purampoke' land on which the first respondent cannot claim
title. It is based on the said contents of Ext.C2(a), the lower
appellate court has taken the view that the properties
purchased for the first respondent as well as the appellants
as per their title deeds are to be located with reference to
the survey numbers, for which the lower appellate court has
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 10 :
set aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial court
and remitted the matter to the trial court. According to the
learned counsel for the appellants, the remand is quite
unnecessary and the remand has been made just for the
sake of a remand.
10. The learned counsel for the appellants has taken
this Court to the evidence adduced by the parties. The
specific case of the appellants is that it was the first
respondent who demolished the then existing compound
wall at the eastern boundary of the property of the first
respondent, in order to make it appear that there was no
compound wall at all and these two properties were lying
contiguously. According to the appellant, it was with a view
to getting sufficient width for getting bigger vehicles to the
residence of the first respondent, such a mischief was done
by the first respondent by demolishing his own compound
wall. On going through the records and on going through
Exts.B1 to B4 photographs, it seems that the said argument
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 11 :
forwarded by the appellants is correct. It cannot be said that
the said compound wall was demolished by the appellants.
Over and above it, even the first respondent has no case
that compound wall at the eastern boundary of the property
of the first respondent was demolished by the appellants.
The specific stand of the appellants is that there was no
compound wall separating these two properties, and by
force the appellants trespassed into the portions of the
property of the first respondent at the eastern portion of that
property and reduced a portion of that property into the
possession of the appellants by constructing a compound
wall.
11.
PW1 is the first plaintiff. In his cross examination
on 11.06.2010, he has admitted that the western compound
wall to his property was constructed by him. When he was
asked as to when that compound wall was constructed, he
answered that he constructed that compound wall at the
western boundary of his property just after two years from
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 12 :
the date of its purchase. Further, he has admitted that the
said compound wall was constructed after ascertaining the
western boundary of his property through a properly
conducted survey and measurement. He has further
specifically admitted that the said compound wall at the
western side was the said western boundary of his property
even at the time when he purchased it.
The two plots
allegedly styled as 'thodu purampoke' marked as 'K' and 'L'
are coming at the eastern side of the western compound
wall. Admittedly, PW1 purchased his property having an
extent of 14 cents by identifying and agreeing the present
western boundary, as the western boundary of the said 14
cents. Therefore, the first respondent cannot claim that he
had purchased such 14 cents of property excluding any
'thodu purampoke'. He had no case that at the time when
he purchased the property, 'thodu purampoke' was also
purchased by him and the same was included in that plot of
property purchased by him. The first respondent has no
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 13 :
case that the plot of property purchased by him was 14
cents with any excess land of 'thodu purampoke'. When
admittedly he had purchased the property having an extent
of 14 cents lying at the eastern side of his western
compound wall, he cannot claim mere extent than what he
had purchased. It seems that the lower appellate court has
lost sight of the said clear admissions by PW1 in his cross
examination.
12. When PW1 was asked in cross examination
whether the plot marked as 'K' and 'L' in Ext.C2(a) are lying
at the eastern side of his western compound wall in his
possession, he had no answer at all. His further specific
case in cross examination is that he does not know whether
any 'thodu purampoke' is there in his possession. He had
admitted that he has never received any notice from the
revenue authorities that he had encroached into any
portions of the 'thodu purampoke'. It has clearly come out
that there is an eastern retaining wall to the 'thodu' lying at
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 14 :
the western side of the property of the first respondent. He
has admitted that his western compound wall is constructed
on the eastern retaining wall of the said canal.
13. When there is any discrepancy with regard to
measurements,
survey
number
and
boundaries,
the
boundaries will prevail. When the first respondent had
purchased his 14 cents by identifying the present western
compound wall as the western boundary of that 14 cents of
property, he can claim only an extent of 14 cents of property
lying at the eastern side of that western compound wall and
nothing more.
If at all, any 'thodu purampoke' is there,
within that plot of property, it is for him to suffer as he ought
to have got it identified at the time of purchase of the
property. Admittedly, he had purchased the property and he
had constructed the said compound wall after ascertaining
that portion as his western boundary through a properly
conducted survey and measurement. The learned counsel
for the appellants has argued that Ext.C2(a) plan is
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 15 :
manipulated in such a way to show that some 'purampoke'
land is also coming within the property in the possession of
the first respondent with a view to enabling him to grab
portions of the properties of the appellants.
On going
through the specific admissions of PW1, the said argument
forwarded by the learned counsel for the appellants seems
to be correct.
14. The learned counsel for the first respondent has
pointed out that if recovery of possession is not granted
from the portions of the properties in the possession of the
appellants, the first respondent will be a loser and he will
have to lose 1.575 cents of property. The learned counsel
for the first respondent has invited the attention of this Court
to Ext.A14 letter No.B9-63082/07 dated 15.01.2008 issued
by the District Collector, Ernakulam. It seems that the first
respondent had filed an application before the District
Collector stating that he had been remitting tax for his 14
cents of property in re-survey No.377/9 of the Maradu
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 16 :
village for the period up to 1999-'00 and presently as per
village records, the extent of the property to which he is
entitled is reduced to 12 cents and, therefore, he wanted to
get back the remaining 2 cents also included in his property
to which he has to pay tax. The District Collector has stated
that even though the extent of the property in the name of
the first 'thandaperu' holder was shown as 27 cents, actually
as per re-survey records, the extent was only 25 cents in
survey No.377/9 and that was why the said deficiency in
extent had occurred. It is not the look out of the appellants
to make good the deficiency, if any, in the properties of the
first respondent. As per Ext.A14, it is admitted that the first
respondent was paying tax for an extent of 14 cents till
1999-'00. It is only after resurvey, the extent was reduced to
12 cents. Therefore, if at all he wants to have a remedy, it is
for him to take necessary steps as per the Survey and
Boundaries Act. He cannot point fingers to the appellants,
who are having only 13 cents of property purchased by
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 17 :
them.
It seems that the records have been manipulated
unnecessarily in the resurvey by noting down that the total
extent of the property in the possession of the first
respondent is 14 cents which is inclusive of 1.575 cents of
'thodu purampoke' also. So far the revenue authorities are
not proceeded against the first respondent under the Land
Conservancy Act. He had been paying tax for 14 cents till
the resurvey in 1999-'00. There was no reason for denying
his opportunity to continue to pay tax for 14 cents even after
resurvey. The resurvey authorities ought to have considered
the said fact and acted accordingly. Still, the first respondent
is in possession of 14 cents of property and he is entitled to
pay tax for the said 14 cents of property. It cannot be
considered that any 'thodu purampoke' is there within the
said 14 cents of property. When he was permitted to pay
tax for 14 cents till 1999-'00, his continued right to pay tax
for such an extent of property cannot be curtailed. He shall
be continued to pay tax for 14 cents of property, as the
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 18 :
mischief has occurred in the resurvey alone. At the same
time, by pointing out such a misfortune fell on him after
1999-'00, he cannot proceed against the appellants to grab
the portions of the properties of the appellants.
15. As this Court has considered the appeal field by
the first respondent before the lower appellate court as A.S.
No.255/2010, there is no scope for any further remand of
the matter for the consideration of the first appellate court.
The first appellate court ought not to have remitted the
matter to the trial court. It seems that the remand order
passed by the lower appellate court is unnecessary and it
cannot be a remand within the meaning of Order XLI Rules
23, 23A and 25 CPC. The impugned judgment and decree
in A.S. No.255/2010 are devoid of merits, and is only to be
dismissed, and I do so.
In the result, this appeal is allowed and the
impugned judgment and decree are set side. A.S.
No.255/2010 stands dismissed. In the nature of this appeal,
FAO(RO).364/2013
: 19 :
there is no order as to costs.
The Registry is directed to forward a copy of this
judgment to the District Collector, Ernakulam to act in
accordance with the directions contained in paragraph 14 of
this judgment.
Sd/(B.KEMAL PASHA, JUDGE)
aks/22/08
// True Copy //
PA to Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review