The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. 02.2023 Order No.27 Received the case record from the Prosecution Section. In this case charge sheet has been filed against the accused person namely Kanishka Sinha U/s 448, 353, 506 of IPC. Perused the same. Cognizance of offence punishable U/s 448, 353, 506 of IPC is taken against the accused person namely Kanishka Sinha. Register the case as PRC(SP) case in my file. The instant case is withdrawn from my file and is transferred to the Court of Ld. Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Court No.2, Agartala, West Tripura, for disposal as per law. Send the case record to the Court of Ld. Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Court No.2, Agartala, West Tripura after observing all legal formalities….” [5] The petitioner approached this Court seeking the following reliefs: “i) Admit this petition; ii) Issue a Rule calling upon the respondents as to why the impugned East Agartala Police Station being no: EAG085 dated: 15-05-2018 under Section 448/353/506 of IPC against the petitioner and cognizance order no:27 dated: 20.02.2023 passed in PRC (SP) No.32 of 2023 (arising out of East Agartala Police Station being no: EAG085 dated: 15-05-2018) under Section 448/353/506 of by learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Agartala, West Tripura shall be quashed; iii) Ad interim order of stay of all further proceedings of PRC (SP) No:32 of 2023 arising out of East Agartala Police Station being no: EAG085 dated: 15…
15. 05.2018) on 20.02.2023. On the said technical reasons, this criminal case needs interference of this Court as required under law. [13] The contents of the complaint do not specifically indicate the time of the incidences when the petitioner had entered into the office of the complainant and it is also not specified in what way the petitioner has threatened the complainant. It is further necessary to point out that in the office of the respondent, obviously there should be CCTV footages and staffmembers and visitors and in such case, if any untoward incident had taken place, the complainant, at the first instance, himself could have initiated action against the petitioner. As per the complaint, it appears that on many occasions, the petitioner threatened the complainant but there is no such particulars indicated in the complaint. In the charge-sheet also, the Investigating Officer has not elaborated upon the issue with his investigation reports. This Court has no hesitation to say that the contents in the complaint bear no weightage. In view of the above, this Court is of the opinion that since, the period of limitation in terms of Section 468 of Cr.P.C. has been lapsed, no cognizance can be taken upon the petitioner. Only on this point, without going into the merits on technical reasons of the case, the criminal petition is allowed. Resultantly, the FIR dated 15.05.2018 is quas…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. Petn.27 of 2023
Kanishk Sinha,
son of late Bimal Bihari Sinha, resident of:122, Bidhanpally, P.O.
Garia, Kolkata 700084, District:- Kolkata, West Bengal presently
at District- West Tripura aged about 43 years, by profession
Advocate and Scientist having office at SKP Group Building,
132A Shyama Prasad Mukherjee Road, Police Station:
Bhowanipur, Kolkata- 700026
…………..Petitioner
VERSUS
1.
The State of Tripura service through the Public
Prosecutor, High Court of Tripura;
2.
East Agartala Police Station service through
the Officer In Charge, R7JP+XH2, Banamalipur,
Indranagar, Agartala, Tripura 799001; and
3.
Office of the Joint Transport Commissioner,
Paribahan Bhawan, Agartala.
………… Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Kanishk Sinha, Advocate (party in person).
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. Raju Datta, PP.
: 12.01.2024
: Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Kanishk Sinha, learned advocate party-in-person
through
video
conferencing.
Also
heard
Mr.
Raju
Datta,
learned
PP
representing the State.
[2]
The present criminal petition is filed under section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure praying for quashing of First Information Report dated
15.05.2018 under Section 448/353 of the Indian Penal Code registered at
East Agartala Police Station being No. EAG085 dated, 15.05.2018 against the
petitioner and impugned order no.27 dated, 20.02.2023 passed in PRC (SP)
32 of 2023 (arising out of East Agartala PS Case No. EAG085 dated,
15.05.2018) as time barred.
[3]
Brief facts of the case of the petitioner is that he is an inventor
and patent holder of technology applied for Eco Friendly Battery operated
vehicles having Patent No.254875 and several other inventions in the field of
renewable energy. He enrolled as an Advocate in the year 2021 with the Bar
Council of West Bengal. The petitioner filed two writ petitions before this High
Court being W.P.(C) No.177 of 2017 and W.P.(C) No.86 of 2017 against the
sale of E-Rickshaw illegally in the State of Tripura in violation of Motor
Vehicles Act 1988 as amended and in violation of various notifications issued
by the Central and State Government infringing the patent right of the
petitioner. On 28.03.2017, upon hearing the counsels for the parties, Hon’ble
Single Judge has passed the following order:
“……11. Having observed thus and directed accordingly, these
writ petitions are allowed to the extent as indicated above.
However, this decision will have nothing to do with the writ
petition filed by the petitioners in respect of their patent right
before various High Courts. It is made further clear that if any
violation is noticed even by the petitioners, they can file the
complaint to the Joint Transport Commissioner directly and who
in turn will take appropriate action on the said complaint. There
shall be no reluctance to take punitive action against the persons
who violate law……….”
[4]
In compliance with the said order, the District Transport Officer,
Kailashahar, Unakoti vide memo dated, 03.11.2017, suspended the dealership
of one M/s Ramthakur Enterprises for selling of E-Rickshaw in Tripura.
Thereafter, on 09.05.2018, the petitioner filed a complaint against the
respondent no.3, Joint Transport Commissioner, Agartala before the Officer In
Charge of East Agartala Police Station for sending threatening and defamatory
messages via SMS.
It is stated by the petitioner that it was most surprising to him when he
came to learn that Office of the Joint Transport Commissioner filed a
complaint on 15.05.2023 against the petitioner stating inter alia that on
24.04.2018, the petitioner entered in the office chamber of the Joint Transport
Commissioner, respondent no.3 with some unknown antisocial and threatened
him to act as per instruction of the petitioner else to be ready to face dare
consequences and again on 04.05.2018, the petitioner forcefully entered in
his office chamber with the unknown antisocial and threatened him in the
same way. On the basis of the said complaint lodged by the Joint Transport
Commissioner, an FIR was registered under Section 448 & 353 IPC against the
petitioner at the East Agartala Police Station on 15.05.2018 and the
Investigating Officer looked into the matter and subsequently, charge-sheet
was also prepared against the accused petitioner. The complaint of the
petitioner dated, 09.05.2018 was registered as counter First Information
Report being East Agartala Police Station Case No.EAG089 u/s 506 of Indian
Penal code against the respondent no.3, Joint Transport Commissioner.
Thereafter, on the basis of the FIR dated 15.05.2018, charge-sheet was filed
against the accused petitioner under Sections 448, 353, 506 of Indian Penal
Code and accordingly, learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Agartala, West
Tripura took cognizance vide order no.27 dated, 20.02.2023 passed in PRC
(SP) 32 of 2023, which is quoted as under:
“….Case No. PRC(SP) 32 of 2023
20.02.2023
Order No.27
Received the case record from the Prosecution
Section.
In this case charge sheet has been filed against the
accused person namely Kanishka Sinha U/s 448, 353, 506 of IPC.
Perused the same.
Cognizance of offence punishable U/s 448, 353,
506 of IPC is taken against the accused person namely Kanishka
Sinha.
Register the case as PRC(SP) case in my file.
The instant case is withdrawn from my file and is
transferred to the Court of Ld. Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Court
No.2, Agartala, West Tripura, for disposal as per law.
Send the case record to the Court of Ld. Judicial
Magistrate 1st Class, Court No.2, Agartala, West Tripura after
observing all legal formalities….”
[5]
The petitioner approached this Court seeking the following reliefs:
“i) Admit this petition;
ii) Issue a Rule calling upon the respondents as to why the
impugned East Agartala Police Station being no: EAG085 dated:
15-05-2018 under Section 448/353/506 of IPC against the
petitioner and cognizance order no:27 dated: 20.02.2023 passed
in PRC (SP) No.32 of 2023 (arising out of East Agartala Police
Station being no: EAG085 dated: 15-05-2018) under Section
448/353/506
of
IPC
by
learned
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate,
Agartala, West Tripura shall be quashed;
iii) Ad interim order of stay of all further proceedings of PRC (SP)
No:32 of 2023 arising out of East Agartala Police Station being
no: EAG085 dated: 15-05-2018 against the petitioner…”
[6]
Now, since the petitioner is a practicing lawyer and apprehending
arrest in the event if he is stepping in Tripura, accordingly, under the capacity
of party-in-person, he sought leave of this Court and represented his case
through virtual hybrid mode.
[7]
Mr. Raju Datta, learned Public Prosecutor has contended that the
present petition is not maintainable and the same is liable to be set aside. He
has also submitted that, the petitioner is not entitled for any relief as he along
with some antisocials entered into the office of the complainant and he
threatened him to be ready to face dare consequences on many occasions.
The investigation was also completed and charge-sheet was also filed and the
matter is pending before the Court below. Accordingly, learned PP has prayed
that the petitioner be directed to face the trial before the Court below.
[8]
The case runs around the complaint filed by the complainant, Joint
Transport Commissioner who is an Officer of the State and though he is not
shown as a respondent, this Court considers that the complainant being a
State Officer, the learned PP would suffice in representing the matter since the
complaint is not made under the individual capacity and the so-called cause of
action is in the Office of the complainant. For the better appreciation of the
facts, the contents of the complaint are extracted as under:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
OFFICE OF THE JOINT TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER,
PARIBAHAN BHAVAN: AGARTALA
No.F.21(17)/JTC/MISC/CON/2018
Dated, the 15th May, 18
To
The Officer-in-Charge
East Agartala P.S.
Sub:- Complaint against Sri Kanishk Sinha S/O Bimal Behari Sinha resident of
122, Bidhanpalli, PO- Garia, Kolkata- 700084, West Bengal.
Sir,
This is to report that I have been serving as Joint Transport
Commissioner in Transport Department, Government of Tripura having my
office near Vevekananda Ground, Agartala, Tripura. The aforesaid Kanishka
Sinha met me in my office about 3 years back and claimed that he is the
inventor of E-Rickshaw and he is having patent right for that.
And he also claimed that for each E-Rickshaw sold in Tripura he should
get Rs.10,000.00 as royalty money for his patent. But interestingly instead of
claiming his royalty to the manufacturers of E-Rickshaw who supposed to must
have taken his patent for manufacturing E-Rickshaw he wants me collect that
aforesaid money from the dealers and give it to him. Since there is no
provision in the Motor Vehicle Laws so I expressed my inability to collect
money from the person seeking registration of E-Rickshaw.
Subsequently, he asked me to give notice to all manufacturers directing
them to settle the patent issue with Sri Sinha. Here also I could not agree with
him. After that he asked me to issue advisory to all the manufacturer for the
same purpose. I expressed my inability on the same ground.
Now, he has adopted a policy to call me over telephone and threatened
me for dare consequences and sent huge number of SMS with slang languages
to make me tempted (copy enclosed).
(illegible), for the last 3 years, he has been actively refraining me and
the Government from taking any positive steps for formulating a
comprehensive policy for legalize plying of E-Rickshaws in the roads by serving
several legal notices with frivolous claims and thereby virtually threatening all
the Government corners for refraining from taking any positive steps in this
regard which as acted adversely to the public money at large and valuable
time of the Government.
On 24-04-2018, Sri Sinha entered in my office chamber with some
unknown antisocial and threatened me to act as per his instruction else to be
ready to face dare consequences. I had requested him not to behave like that.
He left my office chamber on that day. On 04-05-2018 he again forcefully
entered in my office chamber with the unknown antisocials and threatened me
in the same way.
In view of the above, I would request you to take appropriate action
against Sri Kanishk Sinha S/O. Bimal Behari Sinha resident of 122, Bidhanpalli,
PO-Garia, Kolkata-700084, West Bengal.
Yours Sincerely,
Enclo:- 06 sheets.
(Asim Saha)
Joint Transport Commissioner,
Tripura, Agartala.”
Upon the said complaint, the concerned Officer-in-Charge of the
East Agartala Police Station, registered the FIR under Sections 448/353 IPC.
As stated, investigation was completed and charge-sheet has been filed and
the matter is pending on the file of learned Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class,
Agartala, West Tripura.
[9]
On perusal of the record placed by the learned PP and going
through the charge-sheet, it appears that there is nothing more available on
record to substantiate the contents of the complaint.
[10]
For the purpose of examining the case under Section 482 of
Cr.P.C., this Court feels that it is necessary to consider the Sections brought
against the petitioner i.e. Sections 448, 353 and 506 IPC, which are extracted
as under:
Section 448 IPC“448. Punishment for house-trespass.— Whoever commits housetrespass shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a
term which may extend to one year or with fine which may extend to one
thousand rupees, or with both.”
Section 353 IPC“353. Assault or criminal force to deter public servant from
discharge of his duty.- Whoever assaults or uses criminal force to any
person being a public servant in the execution of his duty as such public
servant, or with intent to prevent or deter that person from discharging
his duty as such public servant, or in consequence of anything done or
attempted to be done by such person in the lawful discharge of his duty
as such public servant, shall be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or
with both.”
Section 506 IPC“506. Punishment for criminal intimidation.- Whoever commits the
offence of criminal intimidation shall be punished with imprisonment of
either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine,
or with both;
if threat be to cause death or grievous hurt, etc.- and if the
threat be to cause death or grievous hurt, or to cause the destruction of
any property by fire, or to cause an offence punishable with death or
[imprisonment for life], or with imprisonment for a term which may
extend to seven years, or to impute unchastity to a woman, shall be
punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may
extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both”.
In all the sections mentioned above, the punishment is up to three
years.
[11]
The petitioner drawn the attention of this Court on technical
reasons that the case of the prosecution is hit by limitation in terms of Section
468 of Cr.P.C. and no cognizance can be taken against the accused person.
Aaccordingly, for better appreciation of the fact, the provisions of Section 468
of Cr.PC are reproduced below:
“468. Bar to taking cognizance after lapse of the period of
limitation.(1) Except as otherwise provided elsewhere in this Code, no
Court, shall take cognizance of an offence of the category
specified in sub-section (2), after the expiry of the period of
limitation.
(2)
The period of limitation shall be—
(a) six months, if the offence is punishable with fine only;
(b) one year, if the offence is punishable
imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year;
with
(c) three years, if the offence is punishable with
imprisonment for a term exceeding one year but not exceeding
three years.
(3)
For the purposes of this section, the period of limitation,
in relation to offences which may be tried together, shall be
determined with reference to the offence which is punishable with
the more severe punishment or, as the case may be, the most
severe punishment.”
A fair reading of the above Section, clearly supports the argument of the
petitioner.
[12]
Admittedly, in Sections 448, 353, 506 IPC, the punishment is less
than three years. In such view of the matter, the period of limitation in terms
of Section 468 of Cr.P.C. shields the petitioner since the date of complaint is
on 15.05.2018 and the cognizance is taken in order No.27 passed in PRC (SP)
32 of 2023 (arising out of East Agartala PS Case No. EAG085 dated
15.05.2018) on 20.02.2023. On the said technical reasons, this criminal case
needs interference of this Court as required under law.
[13]
The contents of the complaint do not specifically indicate the time
of the incidences when the petitioner had entered into the office of the
complainant and it is also not specified in what way the petitioner has
threatened the complainant. It is further necessary to point out that in the
office of the respondent, obviously there should be CCTV footages and staffmembers and visitors and in such case, if any untoward incident had taken
place, the complainant, at the first instance, himself could have initiated
action against the petitioner. As per the complaint, it appears that on many
occasions, the petitioner threatened the complainant but there is no such
particulars indicated in the complaint. In the charge-sheet also, the
Investigating Officer has not elaborated upon the issue with his investigation
reports. This Court has no hesitation to say that the contents in the complaint
bear no weightage.
In view of the above, this Court is of the opinion that since, the
period of limitation in terms of Section 468 of Cr.P.C. has been lapsed, no
cognizance can be taken upon the petitioner. Only on this point, without going
into the merits on technical reasons of the case, the criminal petition is
allowed. Resultantly, the FIR dated 15.05.2018 is quashed and subsequent
cognizance order dated, 20.02.2023 passed in PRC (SP) 32 of 2023 is also set
aside.
Resultantly, the present petition is allowed and accordingly
disposed of. Miscellaneous application(s) pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi. G.
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
GHOSH
Date: 2024.01.18 17:32:14 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review