Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:22299
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P. (L) No. 1544 of 2018
Employer in relation to the Management of the Central Bank of India,
body Corporate constituted under the Banking Companies (Acquisition
and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1970 represented through its Chief
Manager, Regional office, Motihari, namely, Mr. Sujit Kumar, S/o. Sri
Raghubir Prasad, aged about 45 years, resident of: Shivpur Visa, Dumra,
P.O., P.S. & District-Sitamarhi, State- Bihar; presently residing at: Central
Bank of India, Regional Office, Baluatal, P.O., P.S. & District- Motihari,
State-Bihar.
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
Their workman, namely, Sri Kanhaiya yadav, son of Late Ram Balak
Yadav, resident of: Village: Navada, P.O. & P.S: Siswan (Chainpur), Dist:
Siwan, State: Bihar represented through General Secretary, Bihar State
Central Bank Employees' Association, having its office at: Shail
Maheshwari Apartment, Flat No.102, 1st Floor, 11-Kidwaipuri, P.O. S. K.
Puri, P.S. Shastrinagar, Town & District Patna, Near Thakur Prasad
Community Hall, Patna-800001
…
… Respondent
With
Cont. Case (Civil) No. 870 of 2025
Kanhaiya Yadav, aged about 64 years, Son of Late Ram Balak Yadav
Resident of Village- Nawada, PO + PS- Siswan, District- Siwan (Bihar)
now retired
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Sujit Kumar, Employer in relation to the Management of the Central
Bank of India, body Corporate constituted under the Banking Companies
(Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1970 represented through
its Chief Manager, Regional Office, Motihari, namely Mr. Sujit Kumar,
S/o Sri Raghubir Prasad, resident of Shivpur Visa, Dumra, PO, PS &
District- Sitamarhi, State -Bihar presently residing at Central Bank of
India, Regional Office, Baluatal, PO & PS & District- Motihari, State of
Bihar
…
… Opp. Parties
--CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Petitioner
: Ms. Amrita Sinha, Advocate
Ms. Shweta Suman, Advocate
Ms. Pragunee Kashyap, Advocate
2026:JHHC:22299
[W.P. (L) No. 1544 of 2018]
: Ms. Amrita Sinha, Advocate
Ms. Shweta Suman, Advocate
Ms. Pragunee Kashyap, Advocate
[Cont. (Civil) No. 870/2025]
: Mr. Ajit Kumar, Sr. Advocate
Ms. Khushboo Kumari, Advocate
Mr. Shailesh Kumar, Advocate
For the Resp. No. 2
For the Resp.-Workman
--th
25/28 July 2026
W.P. (L) No. 1544 of 2018
1.
This writ petition has been filed challenging the award dated
22.06.2017 passed by the learned Presiding Officer, Central Government
Industrial Tribunal No. 1, Dhanbad in Reference Case No. 77/2014,
whereby the learned Tribunal has directed for reinstatement of the
workman in his post immediately within one month from the date of
publication of the award in the official gazette, failing which the
Management was directed to pay back wages to the workman from 31 st
day of the publication of the award in the gazette.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner representing the employer has
submitted that the domestic enquiry was held to be fair and proper vide
order dated 22.09.2015 and that order has attained finality. Once the
domestic enquiry is held to be fair and proper, the learned Tribunal was
under legal obligation to examine the case in the light of the provision of
Section 11-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to
as the Act).
3.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to the findings of
the learned Tribunal and submitted that the learned Tribunal has referred
to the order with respect to the enquiry proceedings of another person and
the said person had challenged the enquiry proceedings and certain order
was passed by the Hon’ble High Court. The learned counsel submits that
the learned Tribunal has not done the needful in terms of Section 11-A of
the aforesaid Act, so far as the concerned workman involved in this case is
2026:JHHC:22299
concerned. The learned counsel submits that in that view of the matter, the
impugned award is perverse and cannot be sustained in the eyes of law.
4.
Learned senior counsel for the respondent, though has opposed the
prayer, but does not dispute the fact that the learned Tribunal has not
considered the case of the concerned workman in the light of the provision
of Section 11-A of the aforesaid Act.
5.
The learned counsels for the parties have jointly referred to the
judgment passed in the case of Workmen of M/s Firestone Tyre &
Rubber Co. of India (P) Ltd. vs. Management and others reported in
(1973) 1 SCC 813 and submitted that even if the domestic enquiry is held
to be fair and proper, the needful is required to be done by the learned
Tribunal in terms of Section 11-A of the aforesaid Act. Paragraph 39 to 41
and 41A of the aforesaid judgment are quoted as under: “40. Therefore, it will be seen that both in respect of cases where
a domestic enquiry has been held as also in cases where the
Tribunal considers the matter on the evidence adduced before it
for the first time, the satisfaction under Section 11-A, about the
guilt or otherwise of the workman concerned, is that of the
Tribunal. It has to consider the evidence and come to a conclusion
one way or other. Even in cases where an enquiry has been held
by an employer and a finding of misconduct arrived at, the
Tribunal can now differ from that finding in a proper case and
hold that no misconduct is proved.
41. We are not inclined to accept the contentions advanced on
behalf of the employers that the stage for interference under
Section 11-A by the Tribunal is reached only when it has to
consider the punishment after having accepted the finding of guilt
recorded by an employer. It has to be remembered that a Tribunal
may hold that the punishment is not justified because the
misconduct alleged and found proved is such that it does not
warrant dismissal or discharge The Tribunal may also hold that
the order of discharge or dismissal is not justified because the
alleged misconduct itself is not established by the evidence. To
come to a conclusion either way, the Tribunal will have to reappraise the evidence for itself. Ultimately it may hold that the
misconduct itself is not proved or that the misconduct proved does
not warrant the punishment of dismissal or discharge. That is
2026:JHHC:22299
why, according to us, Section 11-A now gives full power to the
Tribunal to go into the evidence and satisfy itself on both these
points. Now the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to reappraise the
evidence and come to its conclusion enures to it when it has to
adjudicate upon the dispute referred to it in which an employer
relies on the findings recorded by him in a domestic enquiry. Such
a power to appreciate the evidence and come to its own
conclusion about the guilt or otherwise was always recognised in
a Tribunal when it was deciding a dispute on the basis of evidence
adduced before it for the first time. Both categories are now put
on a par by Section 11-A.
41-A. Another change that has been effected by Section 11-A is
the power conferred on a Tribunal to alter the punishment
imposed by an employer. If the Tribunal comes to the conclusion
that the misconduct is established, either by the domestic enquiry
accepted by it or by the evidence adduced before it for the first
time, the Tribunal originally had no power to interfere with the
punishment imposed by the management. Once the misconduct is
proved, the Tribunal had to sustain the order of punishment
unless it was harsh indicating victimisation. Under Section 11-A,
though the Tribunal may hold that the misconduct is proved,
nevertheless it may be of the opinion that the order of discharge
or dismissal for the said misconduct is not justified. In other
words, the Tribunal may hold that the proved misconduct does not
merit punishment by way of discharge or dismissal. It can, under
such circumstances, award to the workman only lesser
punishment instead. The power to interfere with the punishment
and alter the same has been now conferred on the Tribunal by
Section 11-A.”
6.
After hearing the learned counsel for the parties and considering the
undisputed fact that the domestic enquiry was held to be fair and proper,
which finding remained unchallenged, this Court finds that the impugned
award does not reflect any consideration of the materials on record in the
light of Section 11-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. What has been
taken into consideration is the case of another employee who was also
subjected to departmental proceedings.
7.
This Court is of the considered view that the learned Tribunal has
failed to exercise its power in terms of Section 11-A of the aforesaid Act
2026:JHHC:22299
and therefore the impugned award cannot be sustained in the eyes of law,
which is hereby set-aside.
8.
Consequently, the matter is remanded to the learned Tribunal for
fresh consideration in terms of Section 11-A of the aforesaid Act.
9.
The parties shall appear before the learned Tribunal on 19th of
August, 2026 at 11.00 am and cooperate with the proceedings.
10.
Since the reference itself is of the year 2014, the learned Tribunal is
directed to decide the matter within a period of three months from the date
of appearance.
11.
This writ petition is hereby disposed of.
12.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, is dismissed as not
pressed.
Cont. Case (Civil) No. 870 of 2025
13.
This contempt petition has been filed for non-compliance of the
order dated 09.07.2024 passed in W.P. (L) No. 1544 of 2018.
14.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the concerned
workman has no surviving grievance in view of the order of remand
passed in the writ petition.
15.
Considering the submission, the contempt proceedings are hereby
dropped.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Dated: 28.07.2026
Uploaded On: 29.07.2026
Mukul/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review