Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 10
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
MA No. 449/2012
„
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Kamlesh Devi and others
Through: Mr. Harshwardhan Gupta, Advocate.
vs
The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and others
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. D. S. Chauhan, Advocate
Ms. Damini Singh Chauhan, Advocate.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
ORDER(ORAL)
06.08.2026
1.
This appeal is directed against the award dated 31.07.2012 passed by
the learned Presiding Officer, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Jammu (for short the „Tribunal‟) in claim petition titled “Smt.
Kamlesh Devi and others vs. The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and
others”, whereby the claim of the appellants for grant of compensation
on account of death of husband of appellant No. 1 and father of
appellant Nos. 2 and 3, has been rejected.
2.
The appellants have assailed the award dated 31.07.2012 primarily on
the ground that the appellants had successfully proved the issue No. 1
by leading cogent evidence, whereas on the contrary, the respondentInsurance Company, except examining the Investigating Officer, did
not lead any evidence to rebut the evidence led by the appellants, as
such, the claim petition of the appellants could not have been
dismissed by the learned Tribunal. It is further submitted that the
appellants had neither relied upon the first investigation report nor the
MA No. 449/2012
final report and rather they had filed the protest petition against the
final report. In fact, the FIR was appended with the claim petition in
compliance with the J&K Motor Vehicle Rules.
3.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
4.
Brief facts necessary for disposal of the present appeal are that the
appellants filed a claim petition for grant of compensation on account
of demise of Romesh Singh, by pleading that the deceased was coming
to his house at Lehar, Tehsil Akhnoor on scooter bearing Registration
No. JK02K1089 and when he reached near Doomi Malpur, a truck
bearing registration No. JK02W1835 standing on the Doomi Malpur
Link Road was suddenly reversed by its driver in a rash and negligent
manner with high speed, as a result of which the said truck collided
with the scooter and Romesh Singh suffered serious injuries, who died
on the way while he was being taken to GMCH, Jammu for treatment.
It was pleaded that the deceased was working as Daily Wager in the
PHE Division, Akhnoor, and was due for regularization. Besides, he
was also working as electrician in his shop and as such, it was claimed
that the deceased was earning around Rs. 1 Lakh per annum.
5.
The respondents were put to notice. Respondent No. 1 filed its
response thereby objecting to the claim of the appellants on the ground
that at the time of accident, truck bearing No. JK02W1835 was
stationary and parked on the roadside. The deceased Romesh Singh,
due to his negligence struck the scooter with the truck on rear side and
lost his life, which is clear from the Police Report. Precisely, the
contention of the respondent-Insurance Company was that the
MA No. 449/2012
deceased died on account of his own rash and negligent driving,
therefore, the appellants are not entitled to any compensation.
6.
Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 did not cause appearance before the learned
Tribunal and accordingly were set ex-parte.
7.
On the basis of pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed
by the learned Tribunal:
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
8.
Whether an accident occurred on 06.09.2007 at
Rajouri Poonch NHW near Doomi Malpur, Dist.
Jammu by rash and negligent driving of offending
vehicle bearing registration No. JK02W1835
being driven rashly and negligently in the hands
of erring driver in which decease Romesh Singh
sustained fatal injuries? OPP
If issue No. 1 is proved in affirmative, whether
petitioner is entitled to the compensation, if so to
what amount and from whom? OPP.
Whether the driver of the offending vehicle at the
time of accident was not holding a valid and
effective driving license plied the vehicle in
violation of insurance policy? OPR-1
Relief? OP Parties.
In support of their claims, the appellants, besides examining appellant
Nos. 1 and 3, also examined Rajinder Bali, Subash Singh, Basant
Ram, Suresh Kumar and Ramesh Singh, whereas the respondentInsurance Company examined only Head Constable Mohan Lal.
9.
Learned Tribunal, after examining the statements of eyewitnesses i.e.
Basant Ram, Suresh Kumar and Ramesh Singh and Respondent
witness, namely, Mohan Lal, who had investigated the FIR No.
65/2007 under Sections 279/304 RPC registered with Police Station
Kana Chak, decided the issue No. 1 against the appellants and in
favour of the respondent-Insurance Company. As issue No. 1 was
MA No. 449/2012
decided against the appellants, therefore, learned Tribunal did not
determine the other issues.
10.
It is contended by the appellants that the learned Tribunal has ignored
the evidence of the eye-witnesses examined by the appellants before
the learned Tribunal and by placing reliance upon the statement of
RW-Mohan Lal, dismissed the claim petition and also observed that
the appellants were relying upon the contents of the FIR but at the
same time they are disputing the same, which was not the course
available to the appellants. Further, the learned Tribunal relied upon
the judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in cases titled as
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Premlata Shukla and others
reported in 2007 (5) Supreme 370 and National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Rattani and others reported in 2009 ACJ 925, while rejecting the
claim of the appellants.
11.
Perusal of the statements of the PWs Basant Ram, Suresh Kumar and
Ramesh Singh reveals that they had seen the occurrence on
09.06.2007. They have stated in unequivocal terms that in the evening
they saw a truck bearing No. JK02W1835 parked on Doomi Malpur
Road and all of a sudden, the driver of the vehicle reversed the truck,
as a result of which, accident took place. Though abovementioned
witnesses
were
cross-examined
by
the
respondent-Insurance
Company, but this Court finds that during the cross-examination, the
respondent-Insurance Company could not elicit any material thereby
either negating their presence on spot or discrediting their statements
regarding the accident.
12.
MA No. 449/2012
The respondent-Insurance Company examined Head Constable Mohan
Lal, who had investigated the FIR No. 65/2007 for offences under
Section 279/304 RPC of Police Station Kana Chak and in his
examination-in-chief, he had stated that from the statements of the
eye-witnesses to the occurrence, it was found that the driver of the
truck, after parking his truck, had gone to take water from the handpump and in the meantime scooter in question collided against the
truck and it was on the basis of the statements recorded by him, he
stated that the accident took place due to negligence of the deceased.
He further stated that closure report was also submitted before the
court, which was marked as Mark A.
13.
Learned Tribunal has placed reliance upon the judgments passed by
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in cases titled as Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Premlata Shukla and others reported in
2007 (5) Supreme 370 and National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Rattani
and others reported in 2009 ACJ 925.
14.
In the Prem Lata Shukla‟s case, it was held that once a part of the
contents of the documents is admitted in evidence, the party bringing
the same on record cannot be permitted to turn round and contend
that the other contents contained in the rest part thereof have not been
proved. Further in the Rattani‟s case, it was held that ordinarily an
allegation made in the First Information Report would not be
admissible in evidence per se but once the allegations made in the
First Information Report have been made a part of claim petition, then
the Tribunal as well as the appellate court has to look into the same.
15.
MA No. 449/2012
It is the positive case of the appellants that the FIR was appended in
compliance to the Motor Vehicle Rules, whereas the appellants had
led independent evidence to prove the negligence of the driver of the
offending vehicle. In, National Insurance Company Ltd. vs.
Chamundeswari and others reported in 2021 ACJ 2558, Hon‟ble
Supreme Court of India after taking note of the judgment in Premlata
Shukla‟s case (Supra) has observed as under:
“It is clear from the evidence on record of PW-1 as
well as PW-3 that the Eicher van which was going in
front of the car, has taken a sudden right turn without
giving any signal or indicator. The evidence of PW-1
and PW-3 is categorical and in absence of any rebuttal
evidence by examining the driver of Eicher van, the
High Court has rightly held that the accident occurred
only due to the negligence of the driver of Eicher van.
It is to be noted that PW-1 herself travelled in the very
car and PW-3, who has given statement before the
police, was examined as eye-witness. In view of such
evidence on record, there is no reason to give
weightage to the contents of the First Information
Report. If any evidence before the Tribunal runs
contrary to the contents in the First Information
Report, the evidence which is recorded before the
Tribunal has to be given weightage over the contents
of the First Information Report. In the judgment,
relied on by the appellant’s counsel in the case of
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. v. Premlata Shukla
and others, 2007 (13) SCC 476, this Court has held
that proof of rashness and negligence on part of the
driver of the vehicle, is therefore, sine qua non for
maintaining an application under Section 166 of the
Act. In the said judgment, it is held that the factum of
an accident could also be proved from the First
Information Report. In the Judgment in the case of
Nishan Singh and others v. Oriental Insurance
Company Limited, 2018 (6) SCC 765, this Court has
held, on facts, that the car of the appellant therein,
MA No. 449/2012
which crashed into truck which was proceeding in
front of the same, was driven negligently by not
maintaining sufficient distance as contemplated under
Road Regulations, framed under Motor Vehicles Act,
1988. Whether driver of the vehicle was negligent or
not, there cannot be any straitjacket formula. Each
case is judged having regard to facts of the case and
evidence on record. Having regard to evidence in the
present case on hand, we are of the view that both the
judgments relied on by the learned counsel for the
appellant, would not render any assistance in support
of his case.”
16.
Further in case titled as Mathew Alexander v. Mohammed Shafi
and another reported in (2023) 13 SCC 510, Hon‟ble the Supreme
Court of India has held as under:
“In that view of the matter, it is for the Appellant
herein to establish negligence on the part of the
driver of the tanker lorry in the petition filed by him
seeking compensation on account of death of his son
in the said accident. Thus, the opinion in the final
report would not have a bearing on the claim petition
for the aforesaid reason. This is because the appellant
herein is seeking compensation for the death of his son
in the accident which occurred on account of the
negligence on the part of the driver of the tanker lorry,
causing the accident on the said date. It is further
observed that in the claim petitions filed by the
dependents, in respect of the other passengers in the
car who died in the accident, they have to similarly
establish the negligence in accordance with law.”
(emphasis added)
17.
The respondent-Insurance Company has not examined any eyewitness
to rebut the evidence led by the appellants. The evidence of RW
Mohan Lal could not have been relied upon by the learned Tribunal
for discarding the evidence of eyewitnesses examined by the
appellants.
18.
MA No. 449/2012
In view of what has been said and discussed hereinabove, this Court is
of the considered view that the award dated 31.07.2012 passed by the
learned Presiding Officer, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jammu in
claim petition titled “Smt. Kamlesh Devi and others vs. The Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd. and others” is not sustainable in the eyes of law.
19.
Accordingly, the award dated 31.07.2012 is set-aside and the matter is
remitted to the learned Tribunal for deciding the remaining issues in
accordance with law.
20.
Parties are directed to appear before the learned Tribunal on
19.08.2026.
21.
Disposed of along with the connected application, if any.
22.
Registry to return the record to the learned Tribunal forthwith along
with a copy of this order.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
Jammu
06.08.2026
Sahil Padha
Whether the order is speaking: Yes/No.
Whether the order is reportable: Yes/No.
Sahil Padha
2026.08.06 07:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review