Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
"
#
#
$
!!
%
(
!
SUMITRA
SHERIGAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
#
$
"
!%
"
&
' ((
)&
*
&
'
-2-
"
((
!
!
&
+
$
#
$
+
"
&
#
'
)&
(
*
,
((
%-
.!
%
(
"
,
,
,
(
((
(
/
! !
&
,
! ! !$
&
(
(
((
"
,
,,
"
,
-3-
0&
0&
#
)(
0&
*
12 3242536578 95
259/;
9<9: =3>2 653
/
,
! !
/5 712 49:2 /4 712
2<63=;>6 ?4/; 81/;7 @ ;96:
/=;7AB 16<2 49:23 7198 6CC26: D16::25>95> 712 E=3>F257
653 32D;22 36723
!
! ! !$ C68823 712;295
12 C6;7928 816:: 125D24/;71 G2 ;242;;23 7/ 68
712H I2;2 6;;6H23 G24/;2 712
;96:
/=;7
12 6CC2::6578
12;295 I2;2 712 3242536578 I19:2 712 ;28C/532578 I2;2
712 C:69579448
$
)9*
12 8=97 95
32D:6;679/5 7167 C:6957944
/8
/
! !
I68 49:23 4/;
7/
/ $ 6;2 712 6G8/:=72
/I52;8 95 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 653
4/; C2;C27=6: 95E=5D79/5 7/ ;287;695 712 3242536578 4;/F
9572;42;95> I971 7129; C/882889/5 653 4/; 6 32D:6;679/5 7167
712 86:2 32238 G26;95> 3/D=F257
/
%
! !
!
-4-
%! ! !
!
2>987;6;
2<63=;>6 36723
324253657
;2>9872;23
/
/449D2
! !
653 324253657
/ $ 6;2 9::2>6:
/4
=G
653 2J2D=723 GH
/ ! 95 46</=; /4 324253657
5=:: 653 </93 653 5/7 G95395> /5 712
C:69579448 653 7/ 87;9K2 /44 712 56F28 /4 712 3242536578
4;/F 712 ;2D/;3 /4 ;9>178 95 ;28C2D7 /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2
C;/C2;7928 653 9582;7 712 56F28 /4 712 C:69579448 95
/8 % 653
)99*
C:6957944
/:=F5
! /4 712 ;2D/;3 /4 ;9>178
12 C:69579448 D:69F23 7167 712 1=8G653 /4
/
D19:3;25 /4
712 C:6957944
/ ! 653 C:6957944
16;636FF6 653
F6;2>6=36
/ $ 6;2 712
12H D:69F23
7167 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 87//3 95 712 56F2 /4
F7
16;636FF6 653 I68 12:3 GH 712 E/957 46F9:H
D/FC;9823 /4 712 C:69579448
12 8693
957287672
324253657
G;/712; /4
472; 12; 32671
F7
16;36FF6 3923
/
G295> 712
16;636FF6 >/7 198 56F2 2572;23 95 712
;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 653 712;26472; D/5<2H23 712 8=97 C;/C2;7H
95 46</=; /4 324253657
/$
86:2 F632 GH 324253657
12 C:69579448 D:69F 7167 712
/
653 324253657
/ ! 95
-5-
46</=; /4 324253657
/ $ 98 9::2>6: 653 5/7 G95395> =C/5
7129; 9572;287 653 D/582L=257:H 8/=>17 4/; 712 ;2:9248
F2579/523 6G/<2
)999*
12 324253657
D/5725395>
/
49:23 6 I;97725 87672F257
7167 12 653
16;36FF6 6:/5> I971
82<25 /712;8 I2;2 712 D19:3;25 /4
65=F657;6H6
D:69F23 7167 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 I2;2 C=;D16823 GH
65=F6571;6H6 95 712 56F2 /4
712;26472;
F7
F7
16;636FF6 653
16;636FF6 D/5825723 /5 712 86H /4 12;
46712; 7/ 7;65842; 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 95 712 56F2 /4 12;
2:32; G;/712;8
DD/;395>:H 68 C2; 65 /;6: C6;7979/5 712
8=97 C;/C2;7928 42:: 7/ 712 816;2 /4 324253657
/
D:69F23 7167 198 56F2 I68 2572;23 95 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38
4;/F 712 H26;
%%- %
3=;95> 712 :94279F2 /4
F7
16;636FF6
2 6:8/ D/5725323 7167 712 C:69579448
71/=>1 I2;2 6I6;2 /4 712 6G/<2 46D78 16<2 D/F2 =C I971
6 46:82 C:26 7167 712 :6538 I2;2 7;65842;;23 7/ 712 56F2 /4
324253657
529712;
/
F7
G21953 7129; G6DK
2 6:8/ D:69F23 7167
16;636FF6 5/; 712 C:69579448 I2;2 95
-6-
C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 653 7167 97 98 712
3242536578
/
/ ! I1/ 6;2 95 :6I4=: C/882889/5
653 D=:79<679/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928
87672F257 /4 324253657
/!
24253657
)9<*
/
12 I;97725
I68 63/C723 GH 324253657
/ $ 393 5/7 49:2 65H 87672F257
&6823 /5 712 6G/<2 D/572579/58 712
;96:
/=;7
4;6F23 712 4/::/I95> 988=28
! " # #$
! " # #$
#% #
#
&
'
%
()(
-7-
*
!!*$!
+
)<*
,
12 C:6957944
812 F6;K23
("!
J8 (
7/ (!!
24253657
F6;K23
J8
/
/
I975288 I68 2J6F9523 68
I68 2J6F9523 68
7/
3/D=F2576;H 2<9325D2
I68 2J6F9523 68 ("
"
653 12
&6823
/5
/;6:
;96:
/=;7 12:3 7167 712
C:69579448 163 C;/<23 7167 712H 6;2 712 /I52;8 /4 712 8=97
C;/C2;7928
/I2<2;
97 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448 393 5/7
C;/3=D2 65H 3/D=F2578 7/ 81/I 7167 712H I2;2 95
C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 68 /5 712 3672 /4 712 8=97
653 D/582L=257:H 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448 469:23 7/ C;/<2
7167 712H 6;2 95 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928
712;24/;2 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448 163 469:23 7/ C;/<2 712
6::2>23 9572;42;25D2 GH 712 3242536578
8 ;2>6;38 712
-8-
L=2879/5
I12712;
3242536578
324253657
/
86:2 32238
2J2D=723
324253657
/!
GH
46</=;
/4
/ $ I68 G95395> /5 712 C:69579448 97 12:3 7167
712 86:2 32238 G295> 9::2>6: 393 5/7 G953 712 C:69579448
-
68 712 988=2 I12712; 712 C:69579448 6;2 25797:23 4/;
;2D7949D679/5 /4 712 ;2D/;3 /4 ;9>178
97 12:3 7167 68 712
C:69579448 469:23 7/ C;/<2 7167 712H 6;2 95 C/882889/5 /4 712
8=97 C;/C2;7928 712H I2;2 5/7 25797:23 4/; 7;65842; /4 7129;
56F28 95 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38
/
7 6:8/ 12:3 7167 324253657
469:23 7/ C;/<2 7167 12 653 324253657 ! I2;2 95
:6I4=: C/882889/5 653 D=:79<679/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928
32D;223 712 8=97 95 C6;7 653 32D:6;23 712 86:2 32238
2J2D=723 GH 3242536578
/
653 324253657
/ ! 95
46</=; /4 324253657
/ $ 68 5=:: 653 </93 653 5/7 G95395>
=C/5 712 C:69579448
&295> 6>>;92<23 GH 712 8693 E=3>F257
653 32D;22 712 3242536578 6;2 G24/;2 7198
/=;7
/=;7 988=23 5/79D2 7/ 712 ;28C/532578 653
6:8/ 82D=;23 712 ;2D/;38 /4 712 ;96:
/=;7
-9-
:26;523
D/=582:
4/;
3242536578
D/5725323 7167 712 C:69579448 16<2 5/7 D16::25>23 712
;2<25=2 257;928 GH I19D1 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 I2;2
7;65842;;23 4;/F 712 56F2 /4
56F2 /4 324253657
/
F7
16;636FF6 7/ 712
2 D/572538 7167 712 ;2<25=2
257;928 I2;2 6::/I23 7/ 87653 4;/F 712 H26;
%%-
%%
653 /5I6;38 653 712;24/;2 712 C:69579448 6;2 G/=53 7/ 16<2
K5/I:23>2 /4 712 D:69F /4 324253657
/
2 D/572538
7167 712 8=97 98 49:23 95 712 H26; ! ! 653 712;24/;2 712 8=97
98 G6;;23 GH :6I /4 :9F97679/5
2 6:8/ D/572538 7167 712
8=97 C;/C2;7928 I2;2 5/F956::H C=;D16823 95 712 56F2 /4
F7
16;636FF6 653 67 6 C6;7979/5 G27I225 324253657
/
653 198 G;/712;8 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 42:: 7/ 712 816;2
/4 324253657
F7
/
F7
16;636FF6
12;24/;2
16;636FF6 D/5825723 7/ 7;65842; 712 ;2<25=2
;2D/;38 7/ 712 56F2 /4 324253657
324253657
/
/
2 D/572538 7167
G295> 712 :6I4=: /I52; /4 712 8=97
C;/C2;7928 163 D/5<2H23 712F 7/ 324253657
712;24/;2
/ $ 653
712 86F2 98 G95395> =C/5 712 C:69579448
- 10 -
4=;712; D/5725323 7167 712
;96:
/=;7 168 398F98823 712
8=97
68 97 ;2:6728 7/ 712 ;2:924 /4 C2;C27=6:
95E=5D79/5
2 712;24/;2 D/572538 7167 712
;96:
/=;7
D/=:3 5/7 16<2 >;65723 6 G6;2 32D:6;679/5 7167 712 86:2
32238 2J2D=723 95 46</=; /4 324253657
=C/5 712 C:69579448
$
/4 712
C2D949D
/ $ 98 5/7 G95395>
2 D/572538 7167 GH <9;7=2 /4
2:924
D7
2D79/5
%-$ 97 I68 95D=FG257 =C/5
712 C:69579448 7/ C;/<2 7167 712H I2;2 95 :6I4=: C/882889/5
/4 712 C;/C2;7928 653 895D2 712H 16<2 5/7 D16::25>23 712
E=3>F257 653 32D;22 /4 712 ;96:
/GE2D79/58
/=;7 /; 16<2 49:23 D;/88
97 98 322F23 7167 712 C:69579448 6;2 5/7 95
C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 653 712;24/;2
5/
32D:6;67/;H ;2:9248 D/=:3 G2 >;65723 7/ 712 C:69579448
&289328 7198 12 D/572538 7167 712 C:69579448 16<2 63F97723
7167 712 3242536578 6;2 95 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928
653 712;24/;2
712 C:69579448 D655/7 F6957695 6 8=97 4/;
32D:6;679/5 I971/=7 822K95> 712 ;2:924 /4 ;2D/<2;H /4
C/882889/5
- 11 -
-
12 :26;523 D/=582: 4/; 712 C:69579448 8=GF97723
7167 712 46D7 7167 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 87//3 95 712 56F2 /4
F7
16;36FF6 98 5/7 398C=723 GH 712 3242536578
D/572538 7167 324253657
/
98 D:69F95> 797:2 7/ 712 8=97
C;/C2;7928 GH <9;7=2 /4 ;2<25=2 257;928
6772579/5 /4 712
2<25=2
/=;7 7/
D7
%-
2D79/5
!
2 95<9723 712
/4 712
6;5676K6
653 D/5725323 7167 ;2<25=2
;2D/;38 D65 G2 7;65842;;23 /5:H I125 712;2 98 65 6:925679/5
9572; <9</8 653 712;24/;2
;2<25=2 257;928 D:69F23 GH
324253657
/
3/28 5/7 D/542; 65H 797:2 /5 19F 653
125D2 712
;96:
/=;7 I68 E=8794923 95 32D;2295> 712 8=97 95
C6;7
2 D/572538 7167 95 ;28C2D7 /4 <6D657 6>;9D=:7=;6:
:6538 712 49;87 C;95D9C:2 /4 :6I 98 7167 C/882889/5 4/::/I8
797:2
2 D/572538 I125 712 797:2 /4
F7
16;36FF6 98
5/7 95 398C=72 7125 97 81/=:3 /;3956;9:H G2 D/587;=23 7167
F7
16;36FF6 I68 95 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928
712;24/;2
C/I2; =532;
C;6H23 7167 7198
;32;
/=;7 F6H 2J2;D982 978
=:2 $$ /4 712
/32 /4
9<9:
- 12 -
(;/D23=;2 7/ ;2<2;82 712 495395>8 /4 712
68 88=2
/8 ! 653
;96:
/=;7 958/46;
6;2 D/5D2;523
"2 16<2 D/58932;23 712 8=GF9889/58 /4 712
:26;523 D/=582: 4/; 712 3242536578 653 712 :26;523
D/=582: 4/; 712 C:69579448
;2D/;38 /4 712
32D;22
;96:
"2 16<2 6:8/ C2;=823 712
/=;7 68 I2:: 68 978 E=3>F257 653
12 /5:H C/957 7167 6;9828 4/; D/58932;679/5 98
M"12712; 324253657
/
I68 E=8794923 95 D:69F95> 7167 12
163 G2D/F2 712 /I52; /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928
G6823 /5 F=7679/5 257;928 G;/=>17 6G/=7 3=;95> 712
:94279F2 /4
F7
16;36FF6 653 I12712; 12 D/=:3 ;28987
712 8=97 49:23 GH 712 C:69579448 4/; 6 32D:6;679/5 7167 712H
6;2 712 /I52;8 /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 653 7/
32D:6;2 7167 712 86:2 32238 2J2D=723 GH 324253657
653 ! 95 46</=; /4 324253657
/8
/ $ 3/28 5/7 G953 712
C:69579448NO
12 ;2D/;38 F6;K23 G24/;2 712
C:69579448
2876G:981
G2H/53
3/=G7
;96:
/=;7 GH
8=97
- 13 -
8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 I2;2 /I523 653 C/8828823 GH
16;36FF6 653 712 86F2 98 2<93257 4;/F
712 F=7679/5 2J7;6D7 95
/
$
3/28 5/7 398C=72 712 8693 46D7
J(
24253657
F7
I19D1 98
/
6:8/
G=7 168 D672>/;9D6::H
63F97723 712 86F2 95 712 I;97725 87672F257
12 ;2<25=2
;2D/;38 /4 712 :6538 G26;95>
! 653 ! %
87//3 95 712 56F2 /4
2<93257 4;/F
/
J(
F7
7/
=;<2H
/8
16;36FF6 653 712 86F2 98
J(
12 56F2 /4 324253657
I68 2572;23 95 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 /4
4;/F 712 H26;
%%
/! %
%%- 653 /5I6;38 653 95 ;28C2D7 /4
=;<2H
/
! 4;/F 712 H26;
J8 (
7/
J (!
%%% !
653 /5I6;38
6;2 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 /4 712 :6538 /4
712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 79:: 712 H26; ! !
%
=;<2H
24253657
/
! !
393 5/7 C;/3=D2 65H 3/D=F2578
7/ 81/I 712 G6898 /5 I19D1 198 56F2 I68 2572;23 95 712
;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 653 I12712;
F7
16;36FF6 163 ;26::H
D/5825723 7/ 8=D1 7;65842; /4 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 7/ 198
56F2
2 6:8/ 393 5/7 C;/3=D2 65H 3/D=F2576;H 2<9325D2
- 14 -
7/ E=8794H 198 D:69F 7167 67 6 C6;7979/5 G27I225 19F 198
G;/712;8 653
F7
198 816;2 653 7167
16;36FF6 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 42:: 7/
F7
16;36FF6 163 D/5825723 7/ 712
7;65842; /4 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 95 198 56F2
/
7;923 7/ ;2:H =C/5 D2;7695 C;/D22395>8 95
98D2::652/=8
/4
24253657
/$
!
6F3=;>6 <9::6>2 653
95 ;28C2D7 /4
=;<2H
=;<2H
!
6DL=9;23 4/; 712 C=;C/82 /4 712
/I2<2;
/
9<9:
/
I19D1 I68
6;6H656C=;6
9>17
656:
712 46D7 ;2F6958 7167 712 :6538 95
L=2879/5 I2;2 /I523 653 C/8828823 GH
F7
16;36FF6
653 95 712 6G825D2 /4 65H F672;96: 7/ 81/I 7167 324253657
/
6DL=9;23 797:2 7/ 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928
G295> 712 129;8 /4
F7
712 C:69579448
16;36FF6 6;2 25797:23 7/ G2
32D:6;23 68 712 /I52;8 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 68 712H 16<2
8=DD22323 7/ 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 =C/5 12; 32671
5 7167 <92I /4 712 F6772;
2J2D=723 GH 324253657
/8
712 86:2 3223
653 ! 95 46</=; /4 324253657
/ $ 393 D2;7695:H 5/7 G953 712 C:69579448
;96:
/=;7
- 15 -
I68 E=8794923 95 32D;2295> 712 8=97 653 32D:6;95> 7167 712
86:2 3223 2J2D=723 GH 324253657
324253657
/8
653 ! 95 46</=; /4
/ $ 393 5/7 G953 712 ;9>178 797:2 653 9572;287 /4
712 C:69579448 95 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928
!
8 ;2>6;38 712 D/572579/5 /4 712 C:69579448 7167
;96:
/=;7 D/FF97723 65 2;;/; 95 658I2;95>
/8 ! 653
88=2
6>69587 712 C:69579448 653 7129; C;6H2; 7/
F/394H 712 E=3>F257 653 32D;22 GH 2J2;D9895> C/I2;
=532;
;32;
7167 712
;96:
=:2 $$ /4 712
(
I2 6;2 /4 712 /C959/5
/=;7 16<95> 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448 163
C;/<23 7129; 797:2 7/ 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 81/=:3 5/7 16<2
I97112:3 9782:4 95 1/:395> 7167 712 C:69579448 393 5/7 C;/<2
7129;
C/882889/5
8=97
C;/C2;7928
;9>17:H
D/5725323 GH 712 :26;523 D/=582: 4/; 712 C:69579448
;28C2D7 /4 <6D657 6>;9D=:7=;6: :653 712 49;87 C;95D9C:2 /4 :6I
98 7167 C/882889/5 4/::/I8 797:2 "125 712 C:69579448 16<2
C;/<23 :6I4=: 797:2 7/ 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 712H I2;2 5/7
- 16 -
2JC2D723 7/ C;/3=D2 65H /712; F672;96: 7/ 2876G:981 7167
7129; C;232D288/;
$
F7
;32; P
16;36FF6 I68 95 C/882889/5
=:2 $$ /4
C/I2;8 /4 65 6CC2::672
(
98 712 ;2C/897/;H /4
/=;7 7/ 3/ E=879D2 G27I225 712
C6;7928 GH C68895> 6 E=3>F257 7167 98 6C7 G6823 /5 712
46D78 653 D9;D=F8765D28 /4 712 D682 653 712 2<9325D2 :23
95 GH 712 C6;7928
E=3>F257 I19D1 98 2;;/52/=8 /5 46D78
653 :6I D655/7 G2 6::/I23 7/ ;2F695 /5:H /5 712 >;/=53
7167 712 C6;7H 6442D723 GH 8=D1 E=3>F257 168 5/7
6CC26:23
7 5/I 52238 5/ ;2972;679/5 7167 65 6CC26: 98 6
D/5795=679/5 /4 712 8=97 653 712 6CC2::672
/=;7 168 6:: 712
C/I2;8 /4 6 ;96:
/=;7 95 4;6F95> 65 988=2 63395> C6;7928
76K95> 2<9325D2
988=95> D/FF9889/58 27D
6CC26: 98 63F97723 712 D682 32D9323 GH 712
5D2 712
;96:
/=;7 98
/C25 4/; 8D;=795H 8/ 68 7/ C688 6 E=87 E=3>F257 95 712 46D78
653 D9;D=F8765D28 /4 712 D682
12;24/;2 712
;96:
/=;7
16<95> /5D2 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448 163 C;/<23 7129; 797:2
D/=:3 5/7 16<2 658I2;23 988=2
/ ! 6>69587 712 C:69579448
- 17 -
8 6 F6772; /4 46D7 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 95 712
4/;F /4
7/
J(
J(
68 I2:: 68 712 ;2<25=2 257;928 68 C2;
2876G:981 7167
F7
J(
16;36FF6 I68 712 /I52;
95 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 79:: 712 H26;8
%%
%%- 653
=;<2H
%%
/8 ! % 653
F7
%%% /5I6;38 95 ;28C2D7 /4
!
5 712 6G825D2 /4 65H F672;96: 7/ 81/I
16;36FF6 163 D/5<2H23 /; 7;65842;;23 712
8=97 C;/C2;7928 7/ 324253657
/
95 6 F6552; K5/I5 7/
:6I 6 F2;2 D165>2 95 712 ;2<25=2 257;928 D655/7 32C;9<2
12; /4 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928
393 5/7 D/542; 797:2 /5 712 324253657
7 6:8/
/
5 7167 <92I /4 712 F6772; 712 E=3>F257 653
32D;22 /4 712
;96:
/=;7 ;24=895> 712 ;2:924 /4 C2;C27=6:
95E=5D79/5 I6;;6578 9572;42;25D2
49:23 GH 712 3242536578 98
E=3>F257 653 32D;22 /4 712
DD/;395>:H 712 6CC26:
/I2<2;
;96:
/=;7 98 F/394923 653 95
633979/5 7/ 712 32D:6;679/5 /4 797:2 /4 C:69579448 7/ 712 8=97
C;/C2;7H 6 32D;22 /4 C2;C27=6: 95E=5D79/5 98 >;65723 653
3242536578
6;2
;287;69523
4;/F
9572;42;95>
I971
- 18 -
C26D24=: C/882889/5 653 25E/HF257 /4 712 C:69579448 95 712
8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928
7 98 /C25 4/; 712 C:69579448 7/
I/;K /=7 712 ;2F23H 7/ >27 7129; 56F28 ;287/;23 95 712
;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 G6823 /5 712 32D;22 C68823 GH 712
/=;7 653 7198
-
/=;7
449D2 98 39;2D723 7/ 3;6I 6 32D;22 95 72;F8 /4
7198 E=3>F257
)&
%
'
)&
%
&
/
;96:
:
/
!
$
'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review