Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
HCP No. 137/2025
Reserved on: 03.03.2026
Pronounced on : 12.03.2026
Uploaded on : 12.03.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Kamal @ Kaka
Through:-
….Petitioners
Mr. Jagpaul Singh, Advocate.
V/s
UT of J&K & Ors
Through:-
…..Respondents
Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA.
\
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The petitioner, through the medium of the present
petition, has challenged order No. PSA/165 dated 16.06.2025
(hereinafter to be referred to as “impugned
order
of
detention”) issued by respondent No. 2-District Magistrate,
Kathua whereby he has been placed under preventive
detention with a view to prevent him from continuing his
criminal activities and to maintain public peace and order.
02.
The petitioner has challenged the impugned order of
detention on the ground that whole of the material, forming
the basis of grounds of detention, has not been furnished to
him, which has deprived him from making an effective
HCP No. 137/2025
representation against the impugned order of detention. It has
also been contended that the grounds of detention are replica
of the dossier of SSP, Kathua. It has also been contended the
grounds of detention have not been explained to the petitioner
in a language which he understands.
It has also been
contended that activities alleged to have been committed by
the petitioner cannot form a basis for passing of impugned
order of detention on the ground that the same are prejudicial
to the public order.
03.
It has further been contended that that there has
been unexplained delay in passing of the impugned detention
order
by
the
detaining
authority
inasmuch
as
dossier
recommending detention of the petitioner was submitted by
Senior Superintendent of Police, Kathua on 16.05.2025 before
the District Magistrate, Kathua but the impugned order of
detention came to be passed after lapse of more than one
month i.e., 16.06.2025.
04.
The petition has been contested by the respondents
by filing counter affidavit of the detaining authority viz
respondent No. 2.
In the counter affidavit, it has been
submitted that whole of the material, on the basis of which
grounds of detention have been formulated, has been provided
to the petitioner and contents of the same have been explained
to
the
detenue
understands.
in
Hindi/Urdu
language,
which
he
It has been further submitted that all the
statutory and legal requirements were followed by the
HCP No. 137/2025
respondents while executing the detention order against the
petitioner.
The respondents have also produced detention
record to lend support to their contentions.
05.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case including the detention record,
which has been produced by the respondents.
06.
Although
the
petitioner
has
challenged
the
impugned order of detention on several grounds but main
thrust of learned counsel for the petitioner for challenging the
impugned order of detention was on following two grounds:
(i)
that there has been unexplained delay in passing of the
impugned detention order by the detaining authority
inasmuch as dossier recommending detention of the
petitioner was submitted by Senior Superintendent of
Police, Kathua on 16.05.2025 before the District
Magistrate, Kathua but the impugned order of detention
came to be passed after lapse of one month i.e., on
16.06.2025;
(ii)
that activities alleged to have been committed by the
petitioner cannot be termed as the activities prejudicial
to the public order.
07.
In the context of the first ground urged by the
petitioner, it is to be noted that dossier, recommending
detention
of
the
petitioner,
was
forwarded
by
Senior
Superintendent of Police, Kathua vide his communication
dated 16.05.2025 whereas, the impugned order of detention
has been passed by the District Magistrate, Kathua on
HCP No. 137/2025
16.06.2025. No explanation much less satisfactory explanation
has been furnished by the detaining authority in his counter
affidavit for the delay of one month in passing the impugned
order of detention. The detention record also does not furnish
any
explanation
in
this
regard.
There
has
been
no
correspondence between the detaining authority and the
sponsoring agency during this period of one month either to
seek clarification or to seek further information with regard to
the present case.
08.
The issue as to what would be the effect of
unexplained delay in passing the impugned order of detention
by the detaining authority in such circumstances came to be
considered by this Court in the case of Javed Iqbal Itoo Vs.
UT of J&K & ors [WP(Crl) No. 153/2022, decided on
06.12.2022].
While considering this issue, this Court has
observed as under:
“7. The detention of a person under the special
legislation, such as Public Safety Act, necessarily
presumes the immediacy and urgency of curtailing the
liberty of a particular person to preclude him from acting
in any manner prejudicial to the security of the State or
public order, as the case may be. The fact that the
respondents did not feel it necessary to detain the
petitioner even after the lapse of more than three
months of submission of the dossier, shows that the
situation was not of such an emergent nature as would
have warranted taking resort to preventive detention of
the petitioner. On this ground alone, the impugned order
of detention gets vitiated.”
HCP No. 137/2025
09.
From the foregoing analysis of legal position on the
subject, it is clear that unexplained delay in passing the
impugned order of detention gives rise to an inference that
situation was not of such an emergent nature as would have
warranted preventive detention of the detenue. In the present
case, as already stated, the detaining authority did not act
upon the dossier submitted by the sponsoring agency for good
one month, which clearly shows that there was no urgent need
to put the petitioner behind the bars. The impugned order of
detention, therefore, gets vitiated.
10.
So far as second ground urged by the petitioner is
concerned, in this regard, it is to be noted that in the grounds
of detention, reference is made to as many as eight FIRs viz.,
FIR No. 117/2022 of Police Station Rajbagh, FIR No. 129/2022
of Police Station Kathua, FIR No. 222/2022 of Police Station
Rajbagh, FIR No. 21/2023 of Police Station Hiranagar, FIR No.
257/2023 of Police Station Kathua, FIR No. 353/2023 of Police
Station Kathua, FIR No. 16/2024 of Police Station Ghagwal
and FIR No. 07/2025 of Police Station, Lakhanpur.
In all
these FIRs, the allegation against the petitioner is that he was
indulging in transportation of bovine animals thereby violating
the prohibitory orders issued by the concerned District
Magistrate.
11.
It has been contended by learned counsel for the
respondents that the fact that the petitioner has indulged in as
HCP No. 137/2025
many as eight cases of bovine smuggling shows that he has no
respect for the law and because bovine animals include cows,
which are held in reverence by a particular community, the
activities of the petitioner have the potential of creating
communal tension, hence a threat to public order.
12.
At first blush, the contention raised by learned
counsel for the respondents appears to be attractive but when
examined closely, in the light of what has been recorded by the
District Magistrate in the grounds of detention, it becomes
clear that while drawing subjective satisfaction for need to
pass the impugned order of detention against the petitioner, he
has nowhere stated that the activities of the petitioner have the
potential of causing hurt to feelings of any particular
community.
While recording the grounds of detention, the
District Magistrate has recorded that activities of the petitioner
create widespread fear, insecurity and terror among public and
disrupt public peace, order and tranquility as also communal
harmony. It is not indicated in the grounds of detention as to
whether there was an apprehension of causing hurt to the
religious feelings of any particular community in the face of
alleged activities of the detenue. In the absence of any such
satisfaction having been recorded by the detaining authority
while formulating the grounds of detention, it cannot be stated
that the alleged activities of the petitioner had the potential of
disturbing the communal harmony or causing hurt to the
religious feelings of any particular community.
HCP No. 137/2025
13.
In somewhat similar circumstances, a Coordinate
Bench of this Court in the case of Bhupinder Kumar alias
Pappu Krishan Lal Vs. UT of J&K & ors, AIR Online 2025
J&K 499 has, while dealing with the effect of allegations
relating to transportation of bovine animals and cruelty
against animals and considering the issue as to whether such
allegations would have the potential of disturbing the public
order, made the following observations:
16. It appears that the detenue was charged for having
contravened the order issued by the District Magistrate
to
have
transported
the
bovine
animals
without
permission, therefore, simply registering a case under
section 188 IPC does not “ipso facto‟ constitute an
offence of “bovine smuggling‟. Transportation without
permission can be a disobedience of an order issued by
public authority which does not necessarily mean that it
amounts to bovine smuggling of which the detenue has
been alleged. For example a person who transports his
own animals or purchased animals from one district to
another without permission cannot be stated to have
smuggled such bovine animals and such an offence if
committed by a person can be dealt with under the
penal law for which invoking the preventive detention of
a person for a period of one year, without affording him
an opportunity of being heard or without being tried
would be a travesty of justice. The detaining authority
in this case has, thus, exceeded its jurisdiction to state
that the detention order was required to be passed so
as to prevent the detenue from carrying on the activities
prejudicial to the public order. Public order is a form of
development, which erupts due to public anger and is
something beyond the failure of the law and order,
therefore, without any such development, it cannot be
HCP No. 137/2025
stated that the detenue was a threat to the maintenance
of public order, so as to attract his detention.
17. Instead of being contended with, investigation into,
prosecution therefor, with regard to penal offences, the
State should not take recourse to preventive detention of
an accused of such offences, without there being any
right to bail, as during trial. Preventive detention is a
strong arm tactic of the State to divest a citizen, from his
most
cherishable
fundamental
right
of
“personal
liberty‟. The State should not resort to take recourse to
preventive detention, on drop of a hat, but reserve this
option for exceptionally grave cases, which may call for
the same, having regard to the prejudicial activities to
public order or national security. Public order is a grave
situation, much beyond the law and order situation. In
the detenue‟s case, no such instance or activity on his
part has been shown that there was any problem of law
and order even, the State had to tackle with, not to talk
of public order.
14.
From the foregoing analysis of legal position, it is
clear that merely because the petitioner is alleged to be
involved in the offences relating to transportation of bovine
animals without permission is not a sufficient ground to
invoke the remedy of preventive detention, particularly, in a
case where the detaining authority has not recorded any
subjective satisfaction that such activities of the detenue have
either resulted or have the potential to lead to public outrage.
The impugned order of detention is, therefore, unsustainable
in law on this ground as well.
HCP No. 137/2025
15. For what has been discussed hereinbefore, the petition is
allowed and the impugned order of detention is quashed.
The
respondents are directed to release the petitioner from the
preventive custody forthwith, provided he is not required in
connection with any other case.
17.
The record be returned to learned counsel for the
respondents.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
12.03.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes
Naresh Kumar
2026.02.25 03:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
HCP No. 137/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review