Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J(2)
In the High Court at Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’be Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
And
The Hon’ble Justice Supratim Bhattacharya
W.P.L.R.T. 209 of 2025
Sri Sri Dodhimohan Jew
represented by its present Seva Puja Committee
Vs.
The State of West Bengal and others
With
W.P.L.R.T. 220 of 2025
Kalyan Das @ Kalyan Kumar Das
Vs.
The State of West Bengal and others
For the petitioner
In both the matters
:
Mr. Sounak Bhattacharyya
Ms. Sangeeta Roy
Mr. Chandra Prakash
Ms. Monalisa Maity
For the State
In WPLRT 209 of 2025
:
Mr. Sk. Md. Galib
Mr. Abu Siddik Mallick
For the State
In WPLRT 220 of 2025
:
Mr. Sk. Md. Galib
Mr. Kapil Guha
For the respondent no.4
In WPLRT 209 of 2025 &
For the respondent no.9
In WPLRT 220 of 2025
:
Mr. Ayan Banerjee
Ms. Debasree Dhamali
Ms. Riya Ghosh
Ms. Debolina Ghosh
Heard on
:
14.01.2026 & 22.01.2026
Judgment on
:
22.01.2026
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.:-
1.
The present two writ petitions assail the self-same judgment of
the West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal, both filed
by one Kalyan Das, alias Kalyan Kumar Das, one in the name of
the deity Sri Sri Dodhimohan Jew, claiming himself to be the
president of a committee which is allegedly looking after the
deity in the capacity of sebait, and the other in his individual
capacity.
2.
The matter arises out of two independent original applications,
one filed by the present writ petitioner and the other by the
private respondents.
3.
The present writ petitioner, in its original application, sought for
a direction on the Block Land and Land Reforms Officer to
consider the representation of the petitioner to the effect that
the petitioner’s name ought to be recorded as Raiyat in respect
of the disputed plots.
4.
On the other hand, the other original application was filed by
the private respondents, seeking for a declaration that the
subject plots had not vested in the State, for declaration that the
recording of their names as Raiyats in respect of the subject
plots was correct, and for relief in the nature of injunction to
protect their possession.
5.
The learned Tribunal, by the impugned judgment, dismissed the
original application filed by the writ petitioner on the ground
that the writ petitioner does not have any locus standi to
maintain the same, having no truck with the deity.
6.
On the other hand, limited relief was granted in the original
application of the private respondents, by holding on the basis of
the materials before the Tribunal that the subject property had
not vested in the State.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends, by placing reliance
on Sri Iswar Radha Kanta Jew Thakur and others vs. Gopinath
Das and others reported at AIR 1960 Cal 741, a judgment
rendered by a learned Single Judge of this Court, that according
to Hindu law, a sebait represents the deity and he alone is
competent to institute a suit in the name of the deity; in
exceptional circumstances, however, where the sebait does not,
or by his own act deprives himself of the power of representing
the deity, a third party is competent to institute a suit in the
name of the deity to protect the debottar property.
8.
It is contended that in the present case, the private respondents
have claimed to purchase the subject property, which was
dedicated to the deity, from the heirs of one of the original
sebaits, by altering the character of the property to a secular
property.
9.
Such transfer, ex facie, was barred by law in the absence of any
leave being taken from a competent court before such transfer
was effected, particularly in the absence of any proof that the
transfer was for the benefit of the deity.
10. It is secondly argued that the Arpannama-in-question, by which
the property was purportedly dedicated to the deity, was
embossed on a stamp paper of Bangladesh, which nation had
not come into existence on the date of execution of the
Arpannama in the year 1946.
11. That
apart,
the
transfer
deed
in
favour
of
the
private
respondents was executed by the heirs of one Nitya Krishna
Bhattacharya, whose name does not feature among the heirs of
the settlor as appearing from the Arpannama itself.
12. In the Arpannama, it was provided that the settlor Ram Narayan
Bhattacharya and his sons, who are named therein, were
appointed as the sebaits. However, the name of Nitya Krishna
does not feature in the said document.
13. Thus, it is argued that the very premise of the alleged title of the
private respondents is in considerable doubt.
14. Learned counsel for the writ petitioner next argues that the
Tribunal acted beyond its jurisdiction in deciding conclusively
that the petitioners do not have any locus standi to maintain the
representation before the appropriate authority, that is, the BL
& LRO, thereby depriving the writ petitioners of two forums.
15. In the event an adjudication was made on the representation by
the BL & LRO, there is provision in law for an appeal against the
same, against which an original application lies before the
Tribunal.
16. Even thereafter, the writ petitioner would have the benefit of the
remedy of a further writ petition before a Division Bench of this
Court against the order of the Tribunal.
17. Thus, the excess exercise of jurisdiction by the Tribunal is also
disputed by the writ petitioner.
18. Learned counsel for the writ petitioner next places reliance on
the extracts of records of rights, from where it transpires that
although the name of the deity and its settlor are recorded as
Raiyats, simultaneously, in respect of the water body belonging
to the deity, it has been recorded in Bengali vernacular that the
same is for the domestic and bathing activities of the public in
general.
19. Such recording, it is submitted, clearly indicates that the public
had access to the properties of the deity and, by necessary
implication, rights in the usufructs of the said properties.
20. Thus, it is contended that the Tribunal’s finding to the extent
that the writ petitioner does not have any locus standi was
erroneous.
21. Learned counsel places reliance on an unreported coordinate
Bench judgment of this court in SAT 195 of 2016 (Sri Bijoy
Krishna Mishra and another vs. Chittaranjan Das Bera and
others), where it was observed that the deity is a perpetual minor
and sale of any debottar property without obtaining permission
from the District Judge concerned is void.
22. It is submitted that the private respondents have failed to
establish that any such permission was obtained from the
concerned District Judge.
23. Thus, the private respondents did not have locus standi to claim
any rights in respect of the subject property, which also vitiates
the recording of the names of the private respondents in respect
of the said property.
24. Learned Senior Government Advocate, appearing for the State,
contends
that
the
learned
Tribunal
was
well
within
its
jurisdiction in deciding the question of locus standi, since the
writ petitioner had to cross such threshold hurdle before an
adjudication on merits on its representation by the appropriate
authority.
25. With regard to the declaration in the impugned judgment of the
Tribunal regarding the subject property not being vested, it is
submitted that the same was based on evidence.
26. The other reliefs which the private respondents were not entitled
to get, were not granted by the Tribunal.
27. Learned counsel appearing for the private respondents supports
the
impugned
respondents
judgment
had
initially
and
contends
approached
the
that
Civil
the
private
Court
for
declaration in similar lines as the reliefs sought before the
Tribunal, which suit culminated in a second appeal where
liberty was granted to the private respondents to approach the
appropriate authority.
28. Consequentially, the Tribunal was approached.
29. It is submitted that the private respondents have no quarrel with
the impugned judgment and have not challenged the same
before this court.
30. Before entering into the merits of the contentions regarding the
alleged rights of the private respondents to the subject property,
this court is to deal with two questions:
i)
Whether the learned Tribunal was justified in deciding the
question of locus standi, apparently prematurely, instead
of just directing the representation of the writ petitioner to
be considered by the appropriate authority, including the
question of locus standi, and
ii)
Whether the writ petitioner had locus standi to maintain
the application before the Tribunal and/or to make the
representation before the appropriate authority.
31. Taking up such threshold issues at the outset, we find that the
sole straw on which the petitioner Kalyan Das premises his
arguments is that he is apparently the president of a registered
society, a committee, which is a self-proclaimed sebait of the
deity-in-question.
32. Another plinth of his submission is a recording in the records of
rights to the extent that the pond adjacent to the property of the
deity, which also belongs purportedly to the deity, was opened
for being used for domestic purposes by the public in general.
33. However, from the recording of the records of rights itself, it is
amply clear that the deity, represented by the settlor and one of
the sebaits Ram Narayan, was recorded as the Raiyat of the
subject property.
34. The user by the general public was restricted not to the
usufructs of the property but only to specific user of the water
body, which is a part of the deity’s property, for the limited
purpose of day-to-day use for domestic purposes.
35. Such right, as is clear from the extract of the records of right
produced before us, is in the nature of an easement right and
does not create any title or greater right than that of user in
favour of the general public insofar as the debottar property is
concerned.
36. In any event, the general public has never been recorded in the
records-of-rights in the capacity of owner or Raiyat in respect of
the said property.
37. That apart, even in terms of the judgment of the learned Single
Judge in Sri Iswar Radha Kanta Jew Thakur (supra), cited by the
petitioner, anybody can act as next friend of a deity but the law
requires that anybody other than a sebait instituting a suit in
the name of the deity must be appointed as such by the order of
the court.
38. In the present case, there is nothing on record to indicate that
any such appointment was made by any competent court in
favour of the petitioner Kalyan Das or the committee presided
over by the said writ petitioner, permitting either the said Kalyan
Das or the committee to represent the deity as next friend, in the
capacity of its sebait or otherwise.
39. In paragraph no.17 of Sri Iswar Radha Kanta (supra), it has been
further observed that according to Hindu law, it is the sebait
who represents the deity and he alone is competent to institute a
suit in the name of the deity.
40. Only in exceptional circumstances, where the sebait does not or
by his own act, deprives himself of the power of representing the
deity, a third party is competent to institute a suit in the name
of the deity to protect the debottar property.
41. In the present case, there is nothing on record to indicate that
the sebaits deprived themselves of the power of representing the
deity, to entitle any third party to act as next friend of the deity,
a perpetual minor in the eye of law.
42. Even otherwise, by its very nature, as evidenced from the
materials-on-record, it is clear that the property was in the
nature of a private debottar property and not a public debottar
property, which could confer any right on the general public at
large, let alone a particular committee formed by certain specific
set of persons who have utterly failed to prove their locus standi,
to represent the deity in the present case.
43. In view of the above, since the writ petitioner fails to cross the
threshold hurdle of establishing his locus standi, this court is
unable to permit the petitioner’s challenge on the merits of the
transfer in favour of the private respondents.
44. Unless the initial window of locus standi is crossed by the writ
petitioner, it is beyond the scope of the writ court or of the
Tribunal to adjudicate on the merits of the other questions
raised by the petitioner.
45. Insofar as the other question is concerned, regarding the
veracity or authenticity of the Arpananma and/or the title of the
private respondents, even in that regard, we fail to understand
as to how the petitioner Kalyan Das, or the committee presided
over by him, acquired any right to represent the deity or has
established any interest in respect of the deity.
46. In any event, we do not want to dwell much on the said issue,
within the limited constraints of a writ court in a matter arising
out of an adjudication by the Land Reforms Tribunal within the
limited ambit of the specified acts as enumerated in the West
Bengal Land and Land Reforms Tenancy Tribunal Act.
47. It would be entirely within the domain of a competent civil court
to decide such issues and as such, we observe that our findings,
even if any, on the merits of the title of the private respondents
are only of a tentative and prima facie nature.
48. The last question which remains to be decided is whether the
Tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction in deciding the question of
locus standi of the writ petitioner by itself, without giving the
writ petitioner an opportunity to present its representation
before the appropriate authority, that is, the concerned BL &
LRO.
49. However, we concur with the conclusion of the Tribunal on such
count as well.
50. It is well within the domain of a Tribunal to assess whether a
representation, regarding which direction for adjudication is
sought, is maintainable in the first place.
51. The said exercise ought to be done at least at a prima facie level
by the Tribunal to ascertain as to whether any direction on the
concerned authority to consider a representation would be a
futile exercise.
52. Viewed from such perspective, the learned Tribunal was justified
in deciding the lack of locus standi of the petitioner Kalyan Das
to represent the deity and consequentially to seek correction of
the records of right on the strength of such representation.
53. Instead
of
generating
a
futile
exercise
by
directing
the
representation to be considered at the behest of a person who
has no locus standi, thereby giving rise to a new round of
litigation unnecessarily, the learned Tribunal was justified in
nipping the issue at the bud, since the claim of locus standi of
the petitioner Kalyan Das is frivolous even on the basis of the
materials before us.
54. Thus, we do not find any excessive exercise of jurisdiction or
illegality on the part of the Tribunal in passing the impugned
judgment.
55. Accordingly, WPLRT 209 of 2025 and WPLRT 220 of 2025 are
dismissed on contest without any order as to costs, thereby
affirming the impugned judgment of the Third Bench, West
Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal in O.A. No.778 of
2019 and O.A. No. 1012 of 2021 (LRTT).
56. Urgent photostat copies of this judgment, if applied for, be given
to the parties upon compliance of all requisite formalities.
(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
I agree.
(Supratim Bhattacharya, J.)
AD-03-04
AK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review