The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. We are of the view, that the detention order in this case is vitiated by taking into account incidents so far back in the past as would have no bearing on the immediate need to detain him without a trial. The satisfaction of the authority is not in respect of the thing in regard to which it is required to be satisfied. Incidents which are stale, cease to have relevance to the subject-matter of the enquiry and must be treated as extraneous to the scope and purpose of the statute.” [15] Counsel contends that the detention order was issued after the accused was granted bail in the NDPS case registered against him. If the detaining authority had any apprehension that due to his release on bail he would again carry on illegal activities in trafficking of NDPS, the detaining authority should have challenged the bail order instead of issuing an order for preventive detention of the accused. Under the premises aforesaid, counsel of the petitioner has urged the court for quashing the detention order. [16] Appearing for the State, learned PP has argued that the detention order was issued against the petitioner since from his past conduct and antecedents, the detaining authority, on the basis of the materials placed before it, arrived at a subjective satisfaction that unless detained, the petitioner would continue to engage himself in nefarious activities in trafficking of NDPS. [17] Lear…
16. 12.2018 which was registered against the petitioner for commission of offence punishable under Sections 20(ii)(c) and 29 of NDPS Act. It is a settled law that the detention order must reflect the materials on the basis of which the detaining authority reached the subjective satisfaction about the need of preventive detention. In the instant case there is no reference in the detention order to the bail order granted by the trial court in favour of the accused in the said NDPS case. Moreover, undisputedly the only NDPS case registered against the accused which finds mention in the detention order dates back to 16.12.2018 and the detention order has been issued on 09.09.2021. As per the ratio decided by the apex court in the case of Sama Aruna(supra), incidents which are old and stale and in which detenue has been granted bail, cannot be said to have any relevance for detaining a citizen and depriving him of his liberty without trial. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the said judgment has succinctly held that detention order taking into account incidents which occurred far back in the past would have no bearing on the immediate need to detain a person without trial. [19] In view of the facts and circumstances stated above and the law laid down by the apex court in the case of Sama Aruna (supra), we find merit in the contention of learned counsel of the petitioner that the detention order…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(Crl.)No.10 of 2021
Kalam Miah S/O Lt. Sona Miah of Jalabazar, Yakubnagar, PSDharmanagar, North Tripura
-----Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.The Chairman, Advisory Board, PIT NDPS Act, 1988 represented
by the Secretary, Advisory Board, State of Tripura, Agartala, West
Tripura.
2.The Secretary of Home Department represented By State
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital
Complex, Agartala, Tripura West.
3.The Director General of Police, police Head Quarter Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura.
4.The Superintendent of Police, North Tripura, Dharmanagar.
5.The Dy. Inspector General of Police, Northern Range,
Kumarghat, Unakoti, Tripura.
-----Respondent(s)
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR.INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON’BLE MR.JSUTICE S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY
For the Petitioner(s)
WP(Crl)10/2021
:
Mr.B.Deb, Adv.
Mr.S.Rahman, Adv.
Ms.K.Ghosh, Adv.
For the Respondent(s) :
Mr. Ratan Datta, PP.
Date of hearing
:
Date of delivery
:
of Judgment
Whether fit for reporting:
01.06.2022
22.06.2022
YES/NO
JUDGMENT
(S.G.Chattopadhyay),J
[1]
The Petitioner has been detained under Section
3(1) of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988 (‘PIT NDPS Act’ in short)
by the order dated 09.09.2021 under No.F.15(9)-PD/
2021(P-VII)/2545 on the purported grounds of nefarious
activities in trafficking of NDPS and forming illegal business
ring for proliferation of such activities. By means of such
purported business which is grossly illegal, petitioner is
stated to have enmassed huge properties. It would appear
from the record that the detention order dated 09.09.2021
had
been
served
on
the
petitioner
on
24.09.2021.
Involvement of the petitioner in Dharmanagar P.S. case No.
2018 DMN191 dated 16.12.2018 registered under Sections
20(ii)(c) and 29 of the NDPS Act and the report of the
Director General of Police proposing preventive detention of
the petitioner were mainly considered by the detaining
authority for forming the opinion for detention. Pursuant to
the impugned detention order, petitioner Kalam Miah alias
WP(Crl)10/2021
Kala has been undergoing preventive
detention w.e.f
24.09.2021.
[2]
As stated, the detention order was issued on
09.09.2021 by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura
in the Home Department which was served on the detenue
on 24.09.2021 and he was detained on the same day i.e.
24.09.2021. Grounds of his detention are stated to be as
under:
“Grounds for detention Kalam Miah S/O Sona Miah of
Jalabazar,
Yakubnagar,
PSDharmanagar,
North
Tripura”
Following are the grounds for detention Kalam Miah
S/O Sona Miah of Jalabazar, Yakubnagar, PSDharmanagar, North Tripura under Section 3(1) of the
Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs &
Psychotropic Substances Act,1988.
[1] As per report of Director General of Police, Tripura,
the aforesaid Kalam Miah S/O Sona Miah of Jalabazar
,Yakubnagar, P.S –Dharmanagar, North Tripura was
involved in the following cases:(i)Dharmanagar PS Case No.2018DMN191 dated
16.12.2018 u/s 20(ii)(c)/29 of NDPS Act.
[2] Kalam Miah S/O Sona Miah of Jalabazar,
Yakubnagar, PS- Dharmanagar, North Tripura has
association with the smugglers of NDPS articles and
illicit drug traffickers in connection with Dharmanagar
WP(Crl)10/2021
PS Case No.2018DMN191
20(ii)(c)/29 of NDPS Act.
dated
16.12.2018
u/s
[3] He is a habitual offender and is continuously
involved in illegal business of NDPS especially in
Dharmanagar Sub-Divisional area and also actively
transporting contraband items. As a result of his illegal
activities there is a serious threat to the health and
welfare of the people of Dharmanagar Sub-Divisional
area specially the youths in particular. Kalam Miah is a
dreaded and hard-core criminal and despite being
arrested for the similar and other crimes on several
occasions, he has not restrained himself from illegal
trade of NDPS. Such kind of criminals are dangerous and
detrimental for the society where several youths are
falling prey to drug addiction without being aware of the
evil consequences. If this type of clandestine but
organized illegal business is carried on by Kalam Miah in
this part of the State, there is very possibility of further
deleterious effect to the youths group in adjoining area
and the whole state in general to in a large magnitude.
Drug addiction is a menace which completely destroy the
individual mentally and physically which usually lead the
drug user to resort to other crime like burglary, theft,
Crime Against Women etc.
[4]The person is still active in trafficking of NDPS
articles as revealed from field information but could not
be arrested red-handed again and issue of detention
order under PITNDPS will also help Police in initiating
financial investigation laid down under Chapter-V(A)of
NDPS Act.
[5]He was also involved in obstructing BSF personnel at
I.B Border areas in performing their duties. Besides, he
is actively helping cross border criminal in Yakubnagar
area under Dharmanagar Police Station.
(SARADINDU CHAUDHURI, IAS)
SECRETARY
HOME DEPARTMENT
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA”
WP(Crl)10/2021
[3]
Petitioner was apprised of his right to make
representation to the Central/State Government, detaining
authority as well as to the advisory Board. He submitted a
written
representation
to
the
detaining
authority
on
22.10.2021 claiming that he was falsely implicated in the
NDPS case. No contraband was seized from his possession.
He was not even spotted at the place of occurrence. He
claimed that he was entangled in the case falsely on the
basis of suspicion. He further claimed in his written
representation that police submitted a false report against
him to the detaining authority because most of the criminal
cases which were shown pending against him under various
provisions of IPC were already disposed of and he was
acquitted in those cases. He asserted that in the NDPS case
on the basis of which the detention order was issued
against him, no contraband was seized from his possession.
The contraband was allegedly seized from one Md.Helal Mia
as per the seizure list. He stated in his representation that
he was the sole bread winner of his family consisting of his
old and ailing mother, his wife and his minor nephew and
WP(Crl)10/2021
he was in extreme financial constraints due to the outbreak
of COVID-19 when a false case under NDPS Act was
registered against him.
[4]
The detention order was communicated to the
Central Government on 13.09.2021. It was referred to the
State Advisory Board under communication No.F.15(9)PD/2021(P-VII) dated 26.10.2021. State Advisory Board by
order dated 06.11.2021 asked the detaining authority for
producing the detenue before the Board on 12.11.2021 if
the detenue desired to exercise his right to be heard in
person.
[5]
Board,
Pursuant to the order of the State Advisory
detenue
was
produced
before
the
board
on
12.11.2021 when the statement of the detenue was
recorded by the State Advisory Board.
[6]
The State Advisory Board met on 29.11.2021
and after consideration of the materials placed before it,
came to the conclusion that the detention order was
WP(Crl)10/2021
sustainable since it was made consciously in consideration
of the materials placed before detaining authority.
[7]
Pursuant
to
the
Advisory
Board,
State
report
received
Government
by
03.12.2021 confirmed the detention order
from
order
in
the
dated
terms of
clause (f) of Section 9 of the PIT NDPS Act for a period of
01 year from the date of detention of the petitioner i.e.
from 24.09.2021. The said confirmation order was also
served on the detenue in Dharmanagar jail where he was
detained.
[8]
Aggrieved by his detention, the petitioner has
challenged the detention order by making this application
under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking issuance of a
Writ of Habeas Corpus commanding the respondents to
release him from detention.
[9]
We
have
advocate
appearing
heard
Mr.
Bhaskar
for
the
petitioner
Deb,
along
Mr.S.Rahman and Ms.K.Ghosh, learned advocates.
WP(Crl)10/2021
learned
with
Also
heard
Mr.
Ratan
Datta,
learned
PP
representing the State respondents.
[10]
The petitioner has challenged is detention order
mainly on the following grounds:
(i) The order of detention is vitiated by non
application of mind of the detaining authority.
(ii) The detaining authority has referred to the
NDPS case which was registered against the
petitioner in the year 2018 without any proof of
his involvement. No contraband was seized from
his possession in the said case in which he has
been already granted bail on 04.05.2019 and the
case has culminated into trial after filing of
charge sheet. The detaining authority considered
none of these facts, which indicates that the
detention order was issued without application of
mind.
(iii)
The
representation
of
the
petitioner
submitted to the detaining authority was rejected
by the detaining authority without assigning any
justifiable reason.
WP(Crl)10/2021
(iv) Non consideration of the bail order by the
detaining authority vitiated the detention order
for non application of mind.
[11]
Mr.B.Deb, learned counsel of the petitioner while
arguing in the case contended that the report of the DGP
was actually based on the report of the Superintendent of
Police in which the Superintendent of police proposed for
preventive detention of the accused on the ground of his
involvement in various cases registered for commission of
IPC offences as well as the only NDPS case.
[12]
Learned counsel of the petitioner contends that
the criminal cases registered for IPC offences cannot have
any connection with the detention order issued under
Section 3(1) of the PIT NDPS Act because the purpose of
preventive detention under Section 3(1) of the PIT NDPS
Act is to prevent a person from engaging in illicit traffic in
NDPS which is completely different from IPC offences.
[13]
Learned
counsel
of
the
petitioner
has
also
contended that admittedly only one case under NDPS Act
has so far been registered against the petitioner and that
WP(Crl)10/2021
too is based on mere suspicion because undisputedly no
contraband was seized from the possession of the petitioner
and more over this is a stale case which was registered in
the year 2018 in which the accused has already been
granted
bail
by
the
special
court
by
order
dated
04.05.2019.
[14]
Having referred to the decision of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in SAMA ARUNA Versus STATE OF TELENGANA
AND ANOTHER reported in (2018) 12 SCC 150, learned
counsel argues that in the said case, the Hon’ble Apex Court
has observed that incidents which are old and stale and in
which detenue has been granted bail, cannot be said to
have any relevance for detaining a citizen and depriving him
of his liberty without trial. Learned counsel has referred to
the following paragraphs of the said judgment of the apex
court which read as under:
“21. Incidents which are old and stale and in which
the detenu has been granted bail, cannot be said to
have any relevance for detaining a citizen and
depriving him of his liberty without a trial. This
Court observed the following in Khudiram Das v.
State of W.B (SCC p.92, para9):
WP(Crl)10/2021
“9.....The grounds on which the satisfaction is
based must be such as a rational human being
can consider connected with the fact in
respect of which the satisfaction is to be
reached. They must be relevant to the
subject-matter of the inquiry and must not be
extraneous to the scope and purpose of the
statute. If the authority has taken into
account, it may even be with the best of
intention, as a relevant factor something
which it could not properly take into account
in deciding whether or not to exercise the
power or the manner or extent to which it
should be exercised, the exercise of the power
would be bad. Partap Singh v. State of Punjab.
If there are to be found in the statute
expressly or by implication matters which the
authority ought to have regard to, then, in
exercising the power, the authority must have
regard to those matters. The authority must
call its attention to the matters which it is
bound to consider.”
22. We are of the view, that the detention order in
this case is vitiated by taking into account incidents
so far back in the past as would have no bearing on
the immediate need to detain him without a trial.
The satisfaction of the authority is not in respect of
the thing in regard to which it is required to be
satisfied. Incidents which are stale, cease to have
relevance to the subject-matter of the enquiry and
must be treated as extraneous to the scope and
purpose of the statute.”
[15]
Counsel contends that the detention order was
issued after the accused was granted bail in the NDPS case
registered against him. If the detaining authority had any
apprehension that due to his release on bail he would again
WP(Crl)10/2021
carry on illegal activities in trafficking of NDPS, the
detaining authority should have challenged the bail order
instead of issuing an order for preventive detention of the
accused.
Under the premises aforesaid, counsel of the
petitioner has urged the court for quashing the detention
order.
[16]
Appearing for the State, learned PP has argued
that the detention order was issued against the petitioner
since from his past conduct and antecedents, the detaining
authority, on the basis of the materials placed before it,
arrived at a subjective satisfaction that unless detained, the
petitioner would continue to engage himself in nefarious
activities in trafficking of NDPS.
[17]
Learned PP contended that the order of detention
along with the grounds thereof and the documents relied on
by the detaining authority for issuing the detention order
were communicated to the detenue and he was apprised of
his right to make representation against the detention
WP(Crl)10/2021
order. Nowhere in his representation, the detenue made
any complaint that he did not receive any document or he
was not apprised of his right to make representation.
Learned PP contended that the safeguards provided under
Article 22(5) of the Constitution were meticulously followed
by the detaining authority and therefore, the detention
order cannot be said to be illegal on any ground. Learned
PP, therefore, urged the court to reject the petition.
[18]
We have considered the submissions of learned
counsel representing the parties and perused the materials
placed before us. It has clearly emerged from the impugned
order of detention that the detaining authority mainly relied
on the involvement of the petitioner in Dharmanagar PS
Case
No.
2018DMN191
dated
16.12.2018
which
was
registered against the petitioner for commission of offence
punishable under Sections 20(ii)(c) and 29 of NDPS Act. It
is a settled law that the detention order must reflect the
materials on the basis of which the detaining authority
reached the subjective satisfaction about the need of
preventive detention. In the instant case there is no
WP(Crl)10/2021
reference in the detention order to the bail order granted by
the trial court in favour of the accused in the said NDPS
case. Moreover, undisputedly the only NDPS case registered
against the accused which finds mention in the detention
order dates back to 16.12.2018 and the detention order has
been issued on 09.09.2021. As per the ratio decided by the
apex court in the case of Sama Aruna(supra), incidents
which are old and stale and in which detenue has been
granted bail, cannot be said to have any relevance
for
detaining a citizen and depriving him of his liberty without
trial. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the said judgment has
succinctly held that detention order taking into account
incidents which occurred far back in the past would have no
bearing on the immediate need to detain a person without
trial.
[19]
In view of the facts and circumstances stated
above and the law laid down by the apex court in the case
of Sama Aruna (supra), we find merit in the contention of
learned counsel of the petitioner that the detention order is
vitiated for non consideration of relevant materials. As a
WP(Crl)10/2021
result, the petition stands allowed and the impugned
detention order is set aside.
[20]
The detenue be released forthwith unless his
detention is required in any other case.
Communicate the order to the Superintendent of
the jail where the petitioner is now detained.
[21]
In terms of the above, the case stands disposed
of.
Interim application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
[22]
Department’s file and case diary be returned
forthwith through learned PP.
(S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY),J
Saikat Sarma, PS-II
WP(Crl)10/2021
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY),CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review