Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KABORAMB Digitally signed by
KABORAMBAM
AM
SANDEEP SINGH
SANDEEP Date: 2025.10.30
17:42:59 +05'30'
SINGH
Sl. No. 22
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (Crl.) No. 15 of 2025
Kakchingtabam Harinaran @ Bobo Sharma
Petitioner
Vs.
State of Manipur; & Ors.
Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
(ORDER)
(Order of the Court was made by M. Sundar, CJ)
30.10.2025
[1]
Mr. Chongtham Korouhanba Rajesh along with Mr. Chongtham
Genius Meitei, learned counsel for petitioner; Mr. Th. Vashum, learned
Government Advocate for respondent Nos. 1-5; and Mr. S. Vijayanand Sharma,
learned Sr. PCCG (Senior Panel Counsel for Central Government) for respondent
No. 6; are before us.
[2]
This Court, with the consent of all the afore-referred counsel took
up the main writ petition and heard out the same.
[3]
Captioned writ petition (‘WP' for the sake of brevity) has been filed
with a prayer seeking issue of a writ of habeas corpus inter alia by assailing ‘an
order of preventive detention dated 03.06.2025 bearing Reference No.
Cril/NSA/No. 7 of 2025 has been made by R2 (the District Magistrate, Kakching
District)’.
R2 (to be noted, R2 denotes 2nd respondent) shall hereon and
Page | 1
henceforth be referred to as ‘detaining authority’ for the sake of convenience and
clarity.
[4]
The afore-referred ‘detention order dated 03.06.2025’ which is
under challenge in the captioned WP shall be referred to as ‘impugned detention
order’ also for the sake of convenience and clarity. The impugned detention order
has been made by detaining authority in exercise of powers under Section 3 of
‘National Security Act, 1980 (Act No. 65 of 1980)’ [hereinafter ‘NSA’ for the sake
of brevity and convenience].
[5]
When the captioned matter was listed on 03.10.2025, the following
proceedings were made:
‘[1]
Mr. S. Vijayanand Sharma, learned senior PCCG for respondent
No. 6, expresses regret for missing the matter in the previous listing, but
he is present today. Mr. Chongtham Korouhanba Rajesh, learned counsel,
assisted by Mr. Chongtham Genius Meitei, learned counsel for the
petitioner; Mr. Th. Vashum, learned Government Advocate
for
respondent Nos. 1-5, are before us.
[2]
Two First Information Reports, one dated 22.04.2025 (‘1st FIR’ for
the sake of convenience) and another dated 04.05.2023 (‘2nd FIR’ for the
sake of convenience) both on the file of Hiyanglam Police Station,
Kakching District, constitute the substratum of the impugned detention
order that is under challenge.
[3]
The detention order is dated 03.06.2025. It bears reference No.
Cril/NSA/No. 7 of 2025 and it has been made by R2 (the District
Magistrate, Kakching District). R2 shall be referred to as ‘detaining
authority’ for the sake of convenience and clarity.
Page | 2
[4]
Mr. Chongtham Korouhanba Rajesh, learned counsel assisted by
Chongtham Genius Meitei, learned counsel for the petitioner, raises the
following grounds.
(i)
Writ petitioner sent a representation dated 24.06.2025 but
the same has not been considered by the Advisory Board.
To be noted, the report of the Advisory Board is dated
24.06.2025. It is further to be noted that while the impugned
detention order is dated 03.06.2025, the arrest pursuant to
the impugned detention order was on 07.06.2025 and three
weeks therefrom elapsed on 28.06.2025. Section 10 of NSA
and Article 22(4) come into play.
(ii)
Translated copy of the grounds of detention i.e., a copy
translated in the language which the detenu is conversant
with, has not been furnished to the detenu. To be noted, the
point argued is that the detenu is conversant with regional
language, Manipuri (Bengali script) but translated copy has
not been furnished.
(iii)
One of the documents relied on in the grounds of detention,
namely, newspaper report dated 17.10.2015 in Sangai
Express (Manipuri Regional Daily) is not legible.
(iv)
As regards 1st FIR, the writ petitioner has moved bail, this
has been adverted to in the grounds of detention for arriving
at subjective satisfaction but though the detenu has moved
bail qua the 2nd FIR also, the same has not been adverted
to in the detention order for arriving at subjective
satisfaction regarding imminent possibility of being enlarged
on bail.
[5]
Mr. Th. Vashum, learned State counsel, submitted to the contrary
and made the following submissions:
(i)
1st point is kept aside by Court for the present for
consideration later.
(ii)
As regards 2nd point, it is submitted that the detenu has
studied in English medium up to Grade 12. He is conversant
Page | 3
(iii)
(iv)
with English and therefore, the detention order and grounds
being made in English, a translated copy in regional
language, Manipuri (Bengali Script) is really not necessary
and that does not in any way hamper the right of the detenu
to make an effective representation. It is pointed out by
learned State Counsel that representation dated 24.06.2025
has been made by the detenu in clear English.
As regards the 3rd point, the local daily dated 17.10.2015 not
being clear, learned State counsel fairly accepted that that
it is not clear but submitted that though it is adverted to in
the grounds of detention, there is nothing in the
representation of the petitioner (representation dated
24.06.2025) to the effect that the annexure being illegible
has hampered/impaired the rights of the detenu to make an
effective representation.
As regards the 4th point, regarding the two bail petitions, it
was submitted by State Counsel that only one bail
application was pending and the detenu had been enlarged
on bail in the other bail applications.
[6] In the above scenario, as regards copy being illegible and question
as to the same impairing the rights of the detenu to make an effective
representation, learned counsel for the petitioner sought time to
produce case laws. Request acceded to.
List on 17.10.2025.’
[6]
The afore-referred proceedings made in the listing on 03.10.2025
shall now be read as an integral part and parcel of instant order. This also means
that short forms and abbreviations used in the proceedings dated 03.10.2025
shall continue to be used in the instant order.
[7]
A careful perusal of the afore-referred 03.10.2025 proceedings,
more particularly, paragraph 4 & 5 thereat will bring to light that writ petitioner
predicated his campaign against the impugned preventive detention order on
four points.
Page | 4
[8]
The response of the State counsel for three out of the four points
have also been captured in paragraph 5. As regards the first point turning Section
10 of NSA, learned State counsel produced the entire file before us, we had the
benefit of perusing the file and we find that there is compliance qua Section 10
of NSA as the detention order, grounds and report of the detaining authority
have been sent to the Advisory Board well within the statutorily prescribed three
weeks timeframe. This leaves this Court with the third ground which turns on
one of the documents relied on by the detaining authority, which has been
adverted to in the grounds of detention, namely, a newspaper report dated
17.10.2015 in Sangai Express (Manipuri Regional Daily) and copy of the same
being provided to detenu being not legible. This point has been raised with
specificity by writ petitioner in the grounds vide ground XIII in main paragraph
12, which reads as follows:
‘XIII. For that, some documents supplied to the detenu contained
irrelevant information or struck off which makes them not easily
understood. The documents are (i) Order rejecting the
representation of the detenu dated 01-07-2025, (ii) Confirmation
Order dated 07-07-2025 and copy of Manipuri Local daily" The
Sangai Express" dated 17/10/2015. The Order rejecting
representation dated 01-07-2025, it is stated that the detenu
submitted representation dated 12.05.2025 addressed to the Chief
Secretary requesting revocation of the detention order however,
this was not the case, the representation was submitted through
Superintendent of Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa on 24-06-2025. It is
the duty of the detaining authority to give the aforesaid documents
being clear or to be read easily or legible and able to read properly.
In the present case at hand, the detenu has been supplied with
illegible documents which is illegal and injustice in the eyes of law.’
The above grounds has been met by State in the affidavit-inopposition in the following manner:
Page | 5
‘26. That, with reference to Para No. 12 (XIII) of the Writ Petition, the
deponent begs to submit that the detenu was provided legitimate
documents which were read out clear to him for which he acknowledged
that he understood all the documents and tendered his signature.’
[9]
This Court had the benefit of perusing the impugned preventive
detention order and the grounds served on the detenu. To be noted, learned
counsel for writ petitioner placed the same before us. This Court also had the
benefit of perusing the same and there is no disputation that what has been
placed before this court is the copy of the detention order and the grounds of
detention as served on the detenu. A scanned reproduction of the afore-referred
17.10.2025 Sangai Express (Manipuri Regional Daily) as in the order served on
the detenu is as follows.
Page | 6
[10]
It is clear as daylight that the above is not clear. In other words,
the above newspaper report (which has been relied by the detaining authority in
the grounds of detention) as provided to the detenu, is not legible at all. It is
completely not readable.
[11]
While not disputing that the same is completely illegible and that
there is no material before this Court to demonstrate that legible copy (wrongly
mentioned as legitimate copy in affidavit-in-opposition) was provided, though not
urged in the affidavit-in-opposition, learned State Counsel, adverting to the
representation of the detenu dated 24.06.2025 submitted that the detenu has
not sought for a copy of the afore-referred said daily dated 17.10.2015 saying
that the same is not legible. We carefully considered this point.
[12]
Learned counsel for writ petitioner pressed into service State of
Manipur and Others Vs. Buyamum Abdul Hanan case law reported in
(2022) 19 SCC 509. To be noted Buyamum Abdul Hanan’s case arose from
the High Court of Manipur. In Buyamum Abdul Hanan’s case, this very point
i.e., point that one of the pages of the copy served on the detenu not being clear
and the detenu not having asked for the same in the representation arose for
consideration. This Court answered in the affirmative, the habeas corpus plea
and State carried to Hon’ble Supreme Court. Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Buyamum Abdul Hanan’s case after clarifying that Article 22(5) confers two
rights on the detenu i.e., one is right to be informed of the grounds on which the
order of detention has been made and second is a right to be afforded earliest
Page | 7
opportunity to make a representation against the order of detention. To be noted,
‘representation’ is necessarily effective representation. Reverting to the point that
the detenu has not sought for a clear copy of the document which is
admittedly/undisputedly illegible, Hon’ble Supreme Court dealt with this aspect
in Buyamum Abdul Hanan’s case and it was held that this point not being
raised before detaining authority will not take away the fundamental right
conferred by law on the detenu. This is articulated in paragraph 16 of Buyamum
Abdul Hanan’s case and the same reads as follows:
‘16. The learned Amicus Curiae appearing on behalf of Respondent 1
supported the order of the High Court and submitted that once it is
settled that the supply of legible copies of documents relied upon by the
detaining authority is a sine qua non for making an effective
representation to be a part of his fundamental right under Article 22(5)
of the Constitution and once this specific allegation was made by
Respondent 1 in the writ petition with facts and particulars and also the
pages which, according to him, were illegible and blurred and that has
deprived Respondent 1 in making an effective representation, denial
thereof was indeed in violation of Article 22(5) of the Constitution and
once the fundamental right has been infringed, even if it was not raised
before the detaining authority, that will not take away the fundamental
right conferred by law to Respondent 1 in assailing order of detention
as permissible to him under the law and once this fact remains
uncontroverted, no error has been committed by the High Court in
setting aside the order of detention.
(Underlining made by this Court for ease of reference)
[13]
In addition to case in Buyamum Abdul Hanan, learned counsel
for writ petitioner pressed into service a Division Bench judgment of this Court in
Page | 8
Buyamum Thoibi Begum Vs. Special Secretary (Home), Government of
Manipur, case being W.P. (Crl.) No. 15 of 2021 vide order dated 16.09.2021.
Thoibi Begum’s case is one where in a habeas corpus plea, this court placing
reliance on Manjit Singh Grewal @ Gogi Vs. Union of India and others
reported in 1990 (Supp.) SCC 59 dealt with a question of the copies of the
documents supplied being illegible and the issue of the same having been
considered by detaining authority. It may not be necessary to go into Thoibi
Begum’s case as in the case on hand, the detaining authority, in the grounds of
detention has specifically adverted to Sangai Express daily dated 17.10.2025.
This is evident from sub paragraph (h) of paragraph 3 of the grounds of
detention. Therefore, a copy of the document which is not legible at all and which
is completely/wholly not readable is one which has been specifically adverted to
in the grounds of detention by the detaining authority. Therefore, without even
referring to Thoibi Begum’s case, this Court has no difficulty in coming to the
conclusion that there is infraction of sanctus constitutional right which is vested
in the detenu vide Articles 22(4) and 22(5) of the Constitution. The right to
representation enshrined in Articles 22(4) and 22(5) have been repeatedly held
to be a very sanctus right qua a detenu who is detained pursuant to a preventive
detention order.
[14]
In the case on hand a document which is not clear/completely not
readable has been adverted to with specificity by the detaining authority in the
grounds of detention annexed to the impugned preventive detention order and
that by itself leads us to the conclusion that there is infraction of Articles 22(4)
Page | 9
and 22(5) warranting interference and on this ground, we dislodge the impugned
preventive detention order.
[15]
Before concluding, this Court deems it appropriate to write that in
the absence of material to demonstrate that legible copy was given to detenu (as
contended in affidavit-in-opposition) it is obvious that the copy given to detenu
could not have been read over and explained to him as the same is
wholly/completely not readable as alluded to supra.
[16]
Ergo, sequitur is, captioned writ petition is allowed. Impugned
preventive detention order dated 03.06.2025 bearing Reference No. Cril/NSA/No.
7 of 2025 which has been made by R2 (the District Magistrate, Kakching District),
approval of the same by State Government on 10.06.2025 and confirmation of
the same by the State Government on 07.07.2205 are set aside and the detenu,
Kakchingtabam Harinaran @ Bobo Sharma, aged about 38 years, S/o
Kakchingtabam Lalhari Sharma of Wabagai Makha Leikai, is directed to be set at
liberty forthwith, if not required in connection with any other case/cases. There
shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sandeep
P.S. I : Upload forthwith
P.S. II : All concerned will remain bound by this order as uploaded in
the official website of High Court
Page | 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review