The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. In view of such authoritative pronouncement of the Constitution Bench of this Court, there can be no doubt that the principles of Constructive Res Judicata, as explained in explanation IV to Section 11 of the CPC, are also applicable to writ petitions. [14] Mr. Gautam, learned senior G.A further relies on another decision of the Hon’ble Supreme in the case of Samir Kumar Majumder vs. Union of India and others, (2024) 16 SCC 738 has observed as under:
34. This principle popularly known as the doctrine of constructive res judicata, based on the might and ought theory, has been recognized by this Court in several judgments. In Maharashtra Vikrikar Karamchari Sangathan vs. State of Maharashtra and another, (2000) 2 SCC 552, this Court held as under:“22. It was then contended on behalf of the appellants that neither the Recruitment Rules of 1971 nor the Seniority Rules of 1982 provided for carrying forward the vacancies falling in either category. In the absence of such rules which specifically provide for carrying forward the vacancies falling in either category, no such carry-forward rule could be implied either in the Recruitment Rules or in the Seniority Rules. This contention need not detain us any longer because such a contention was available to the appellants in the earlier proceedings, namely, Transfer Application No.822 of 1991 and the same was not put in issue. That not having been done, it must follow that such a contention is barred by the principles of constructive res judicata. Neither the contesting respondents nor the appellants ever raised this contention at any stage of the proceedings in Transfer Petition No.822 of 1991. It would, therefore, be too late to raise such a contention when the seniority list has been finalized pursuant to the judgment of MAT, Bombay Bench in Transfer Petition No. 822 of 1991.” [15] In…
04. 12.2024, directing the respondents to release the amounts which were withheld by them within two months, as indicated earlier in Para No.6 above. [17] Despite the relief as sought by the petitioner to grant him interest @ 9% per annum upon those withheld amounts, the Court did not grant such relief. The petitioner was satisfied with the judgment passed in the said previous writ petition and did not challenge the same in any appeal and the judgment reached the finality. [18] In terms of the said judgment, the department had already released all his post-retiral benefits, which were withheld by them, but without paying any interest on the same. Therefore, now the question arises whether the petitioner can be permitted again to raise the same issue of granting interest to him on those withheld amounts, which were released to him later on, in view of the principles of res-judicata. [19] In M. Nagabhushana (supra) as relied on by both the parties it is observed that the application of rule of res-judicata in India should be influenced by no technical considerations of form, but by the matter of substance within the limits allowed by the law. It has also been clarified that in the matter of res-judicata the public policy plays a significant role and the decision pronounced by the courts of competent jurisdiction shall be treated to be final, unless they are modified or reversed by th…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
TRHC010014902025
2026:THC:550
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.517 of 2025
1.
Kaizar Dev Barma
S/o- Late Samarendra Debbarma, R/O- Palace
Compound, Haradhan Sangha, P.O- Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, PIN - 799001
……… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
The State of Tripura
to be represented by the Secretary, Dept. of Industries
and Commerce, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat
Building, P.O- Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN799006
2.
The Director of Industries and Commerce,
Government of Tripura, Gurkhabasti, P.O- Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin – 799006
3.
The Additional Director,
Industries and Commerce, Govt. of Tripura, Gurkhabasti,
P.O- Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin – 799006
4.
The Principal Accountant General (A and E), Tripura,
PO- Kunjaban, Agartala - 799006, District- West Tripura
5.
The Sr. Accountants Officer,
O/o the Principal Accountant General (A and E), Tripura,
PO- Kunjaban, Agartala- 799006, District- West Tripura
…… Respondent(s)
For the petitioner (s)
:
For the Respondent (S)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Ms. A. Debbarma, Adv.
Mr. P. Gautam, Sr. G.A.
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Sr. Adv.
Mr. A. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
26.02.2026
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
:
30.04.2026
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
✔
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard learned counsel of both sides.
[2]
The petitioner on attaining the age of superannuation retired
from service on 31.01.2024 from the post of Additional Director (Industries
& Commerce), Department of Industries & Commerce, Government of
Tripura.
After
retirement,
he
submitted
one
representation
dated
05.02.2024 to the Secretary and Director, Department of Industries &
Commerce, Government of Tripura, Agartala, requesting sanction and
release of post-retiral benefits to him. When no step was taken, he also
submitted another reminder on 13.02.2024 in this regard.
[3]
According to the petitioner, on retirement, he became entitled
to get Rs.10,00,000 [Rupees Ten lakh] only as full and final settlement of
gratuity and the amount payable under Leave Encashment benefit apart
from his monthly pension. Thereafter, claiming the same, he submitted a
representation on 05.02.2024 seeking the release of such post-retiral
benefits and thereafter, his provisional pension amounting to Rs.78,150/[Seventy Eight thousand One hundred Fifty] only was released for the
period w.e.f. 01.02.2024 to 31.07.2024 and the final payment of GPF
Rs.55,256/- [Rupees Fifty Five thousand Two hundred Fifty Six] only was
also sanctioned. He again submitted another representation dated
26.02.2024 claiming other post-retiral benefits and he was informed that his
Gratuity and Leave Encashment were kept on hold till completion of the
departmental proceeding against him.
[4]
When he was in service, one FIR was registered against him
at NCC P.S bearing NCC P.S. Case No.2020 NCC 088, on 04.03.2020,
under Section 409 of IPC and Section 13 of the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988 which ultimately culminated into filing of charge-sheet. On that
ground, his gratuity, leave salary and other pensionary benefits were
withheld by the department and only provisional pension and the amount
payable from GPF account were released to him.
[5]
In such a situation, the petitioner filed WP(C) No.215/2024 with
the following reliefs:
“a) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other order/orders shall
not be issued whereby quashing and cancelling the letter, dated,
05.03.2024 issued by the Addl. Director, Industries & Commerce,
Govt. of Tripura.
b) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other order/orders shall
not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to cause release
of regular monthly pension, full & final payment of gratuity, leave
encashment benefit, provident fund benefit, group insurance
benefit in favour of the Petitioner, with 9% interest w.e.f.
01.03.2024 till payment is made.
And
Call for the records pertaining to the instant Writ Petition from the
custody of the Respondents and to make the rule absolute.”
[6]
On hearing the parties, a coordinate bench of this Court
disposed of the said case on 04.12.2024 with the following decisions and
directions:
“[7] After perusal of the record, this court is of the view that there
is no 2011 Financial Rules invoked when certain allegations in
2014 and 2015 were made against the petitioner and there is no
direct financial irregularity by not following certain procedure
construction has been made and also the vehicle which was under
his control was used, since the same are not attracting 2011
Financial Rules. This Court finds that the respondents are not
entitled to withhold the payment i.e, to be made to the petitioner.
[8] In view of the above observation, respondents are directed to
release the amount which are withheld by them on account of the
criminal case i.e, filed vide FIR No. 038 of 04.03.2020 within 2
months from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
Accordingly, the impugned order dated 05.03.2024 is set aside.
[9] With the above observation and direction, this present writ
petition stands allowed and accordingly, the same is disposed of.
As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall
stand closed.”
[7]
After such direction was issued by this Court, the department
make payment of Rs.12,01,305/- [Rupees Twelve lakh One thousand
Three hundred and Five] only as part payment of Leave Salary on
29.06.2024 and again Rs.7,52,445/- [Rupees Seven lakh Fifty One
thousand Four hundred Forty Five] only was also released on 30.01.2025
as rest amount of Leave Salary. Further, Rs.7,50,000/- [Rupees Seven lakh
Fifty thousand] only was sanctioned being 75% of full DCRG of
Rs.10,00,000/- [Rupees Ten lakhs] only in his favour and the rest amount
of Gratuity of Rs.2,50,000/- [Rupees Two lakh Fifty thousand] was released
on 20.03.2025.
The petitioner was also allowed to avail the benefit of
commutation of pension w.e.f. 20.03.2025.
[8]
It is now the grievance of the petitioner that after said judgment
was passed, all the post-retiral benefits were disbursed to the petitioner but
no interest on leave salary, gratuity and commutation of pension were
provided to him. Therefore, the present writ petition has been filed seeking
the following reliefs:
(i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or
direction/ directions of like nature shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to provide interest @ 9% per annum to
the Petitioner on Rs.7,52,445/- w.e.f. 01.03.2024, i.e. from the date
on which leave salary became payable till the date of payment, i.e.
30.01.2025.
(ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or
direction/ directions of like nature shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to provide interest @ 9% per annum to
the Petitioner on Rs. 12.01,305/- w.e.f. 01.03.2024, i.e. from the date
on which leave salary became payable till the date of payment, i.e.
29.6.2024.
(iii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or
direction/ directions of like nature shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to provide interest @ 9% per annum to
the Petitioner on Rs. 7,50,000/- w.e.f. 01.03.2024, i.e. from the date
on which Gratuity became payable till the date of payment, i.e.
30.01.2025
(iv) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or
direction/ directions of like nature shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to provide interest @ 9% per annum to
the Petitioner on Rs. 25,00,00/- w.e.f. 01.03.2024, i.e. from the date
on which Gratuity became payable till the date of payment, i.e.
20.03.2025
(v) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or
direction/ directions of like nature shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to provide interest @ 9% per annum to
the Petitioner on Rs.30,73,734/- w.e.f. 01.03.2024, i.e. from the date
on which commutation of pension became admissible till the date
of actual commutation of pension, i.e. 20.03.2025.
(vi) Make the rules absolute.
(vii) Call for records....”
[9]
Learned senior counsel, Mr. P. Roy Barman, submits that the
earlier writ petition was allowed by this Court which means that all the
reliefs as sought for by the petitioner were allowed, though in no specific
words or terms, the relief of granting of interest was mentioned in the said
judgment. However, for non-payment of such interest which the petitioner is
otherwise entitled, the present writ petition is filed as meanwhile the
limitation period for filing contempt petition was over.
[10]
Learned senior counsel, Mr. Barman, also submits that the
petitioner is, therefore, entitled to get the reliefs of interest as claimed by
him and non-granting of such interest in specific words or terms in the
previous writ petition will not bar his claim in the present writ petition and
the principles of res-judicata will not be applied in this contexts.
[11]
To support such contention, learned senior counsel, Mr. Roy
Barman, further relies on a decision of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in the
case of M. Nagabhushana vs. State of Karnataka and others, (2011) 3
SCC 408 and the paragraph nos.17 to 20 and 24 as relied by him, are
extracted hereunder:
17. It may be noted in this context that while applying the
principles of res judicata the court should not be hampered by any
technical rules of interpretation. It has been very categorically
opined by Sir Lawrence Jenkins that:
“… the application of the rule by courts in India should
be influenced by no technical considerations of form, but
by matter of substance within the limits allowed by law.”
(See Sheoparsan Singh v. Ramnandan Singh : (1915-16) 43
IA 91)
18. Therefore, any proceeding which has been initiated in breach
of the principles of res judicata is prima facie a proceeding which
has been initiated in abuse of the process of court.
19. A Constitution Bench of this Court in Devilal Modi v. STO :AIR
1965 SC 1150, has explained this principles in very clear terms:
“7. … But the question as to whether a citizen should
be allowed to challenge the validity of the same order by
successive petitions under Article 226, cannot be answered
merely in the light of the significance and importance of the
citizens' fundamental rights. The general principles
underlying the doctrine of res judicata is ultimately based
on considerations of public policy. One important
consideration of public policy is that the decisions
pronounced by courts of competent jurisdiction should be
final, unless they are modified or reversed by appellate
authorities; and the other principle is that no one should be
made to face the same kind of litigation twice over,
because such a process would be contrary to
considerations of fair play and justice (vide Daryao v. State
of U.P. : AIR 1961 SC 1457).”
20. This Court in AIMO case : (2006) 4 SCC 683 explained in clear
terms that principle behind the doctrine of res judicata is to
prevent an abuse of the process of court. In explaining the said
principle the Bench in AIMO case relied on the following
formulation of Somervell, L.J. in Greenhalgh v. Mallard : (1947) 2
All ER 255 (CA):
“39. .„I think that on the authorities to which I will refer
it would be accurate to say that res judicata for this
purpose is not confined to the issues which the court is
actually asked to decide, but that it covers issues or facts
which are so clearly part of the subject-matter of the
litigation and so clearly could have been raised that it
would be an abuse of the process of the court to allow a
new proceeding to be started in respect of them.‟”
(emphasis supplied in AIMO case )
The Bench in AIMO case also noted that the judgment of the Court
of Appeal in Greenhalgh was approved by this Court in State of
U.P. v. Nawab Hussain : (1977) 2 SCC 806.
…..
…..
…..
24. In coming to the aforementioned finding, this Court relied
on The Supreme Court Practice, 1995 published by Sweet &
Maxwell (p. 344). The relevant principles laid down in the aforesaid
practice and which have been accepted by this Court are as
follows: [K.K. Modi case : (1998) 3 SCC 573]
“43. … „This term connotes that the process of the
court must be used bona fide and properly and must not be
abused. The court will prevent improper use of its
machinery and will in a proper case, summarily prevent its
machinery from being used as a means of vexation and
oppression in the process of litigation. … The categories of
conduct rendering a claim frivolous, vexatious or an abuse
of process are not closed but depend on all the relevant
circumstances. And for this purpose considerations of
public policy and the interests of justice may be very
material.‟ ”
[Emphasis underscored]
[12]
Finally, learned senior counsel, Mr. Barman, submits that
neither the petitioner by this present writ petition is trying to reopen or reagitate any issue already decided by this Court, nor he is attempting to
abuse the process of Court, and therefore, the writ petition may be allowed
granting the reliefs as sought for by the petitioner.
[13]
On the other side, Mr. P. Gautam, learned senior G.A.
appearing for the state-respondents while arguing the case submits that the
writ petition is barred by the principles of res-judicata relying on the
aforesaid decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
M. Nagabhushana (supra), wherein paragraph Nos.21 & 22, referring to a
Constitution Bench decision, the followings were observed:
21. Following all these principles a Constitution Bench of this
Court in Direct Recruit Class II Engg. Officers' Assn. vs. State of
Maharashtra, (1990) 2 SCC 715 laid down the following principles:
"......an adjudication is conclusive and final not only as to the
actual matter determined but as to every other matter which
the parties might and ought to have litigated and have had
decided as incidental to or essentially connected with
subject-matter of the litigation and every matter coming into
the legitimate purview of the original action both in respect
of the matters of claim and defence. Thus, the principle of
constructive res judicata underlying Explanation IV of
Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure was applied to writ
case. We, accordingly, hold that the writ case is fit to be
dismissed on the ground of res judicata"
22. In view of such authoritative pronouncement of the
Constitution Bench of this Court, there can be no doubt that the
principles of Constructive Res Judicata, as explained in
explanation IV to Section 11 of the CPC, are also applicable to writ
petitions.
[14]
Mr. Gautam, learned senior G.A further relies on another
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme in the case of Samir Kumar Majumder
vs. Union of India and others, (2024) 16 SCC 738 has observed as
under:
34. This principle popularly known as the doctrine of constructive
res judicata, based on the might and ought theory, has been
recognized by this Court in several judgments. In Maharashtra
Vikrikar Karamchari Sangathan vs. State of Maharashtra and
another, (2000) 2 SCC 552, this Court held as under:“22. It was then contended on behalf of the appellants that
neither the Recruitment Rules of 1971 nor the Seniority
Rules of 1982 provided for carrying forward the vacancies
falling in either category. In the absence of such rules which
specifically provide for carrying forward the vacancies
falling in either category, no such carry-forward rule could
be implied either in the Recruitment Rules or in the Seniority
Rules. This contention need not detain us any longer
because such a contention was available to the appellants in
the earlier proceedings, namely, Transfer Application No.822
of 1991 and the same was not put in issue. That not having
been done, it must follow that such a contention is barred by
the principles of constructive res judicata. Neither the
contesting respondents nor the appellants ever raised this
contention at any stage of the proceedings in Transfer
Petition No.822 of 1991. It would, therefore, be too late to
raise such a contention when the seniority list has been
finalized pursuant to the judgment of MAT, Bombay Bench in
Transfer Petition No. 822 of 1991.”
[15]
In the case in hand as discussed above, when the gratuity, the
leave salary and other post-retiral benefits were withheld by the
department, the petitioner filed the previous writ petition for a direction to be
issued the respondents to release his monthly pension, full and final
gratuity, leave encashment benefit, provident fund benefit and group
insurance benefit in favour of the petitioner along with 9% interest
[emphasis laid] w.e.f. 01.03.2024 till the payment is made.
[16]
Learned Coordinate Bench of this Court after hearing both the
sides and considering the merit of the case, finally disposed of the same on
04.12.2024, directing the respondents to release the amounts which were
withheld by them within two months, as indicated earlier in Para No.6
above.
[17]
Despite the relief as sought by the petitioner to grant him
interest @ 9% per annum upon those withheld amounts, the Court did not
grant such relief. The petitioner was satisfied with the judgment passed in
the said previous writ petition and did not challenge the same in any appeal
and the judgment reached the finality.
[18]
In terms of the said judgment, the department had already
released all his post-retiral benefits, which were withheld by them, but
without paying any interest on the same. Therefore, now the question
arises whether the petitioner can be permitted again to raise the same
issue of granting interest to him on those withheld amounts, which were
released to him later on, in view of the principles of res-judicata.
[19]
In M. Nagabhushana (supra) as relied on by both the parties it
is observed that the application of rule of res-judicata in India should be
influenced by no technical considerations of form, but by the matter of
substance within the limits allowed by the law. It has also been clarified that
in the matter of res-judicata the public policy plays a significant role and the
decision pronounced by the courts of competent jurisdiction shall be treated
to be final, unless they are modified or reversed by the appellate
authorities.
[20]
In Greenhalgh vs. Mallard, (1447) 2 ALL ER-225, it was
observed by His Lordship, Somervell, L.J that the principles of res-judicata
is not confined to the issues which the Court was actually asked to decide,
but that it also covers issues or facts which are so clearly part of the
subject-matter of the litigation and so clearly could have been raised that it
would be an abuse of the process of the Court to allow a new proceeding to
be started in respect of them. Such observation has also been referred in
said M. Nagabhushana (supra). Thus, there is no doubt that the
applicability of res-judicata is required to be considered in a wider
magnitude.
[21]
In K.K. Modi vs. K.N. Modi and others, (1998) 3 SCC 573
also the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that it would be an abuse of the
process of the court and contrary to justice and public policy for a party to
re-litigate the same issue which had already been tried and decided earlier
against him. The re-agitation may or may not be barred as res judicata, but
if the same issue is sought to be re-agitated, it also amounts to an abuse of
the process of court.
[22]
In the present case, as discussed above, the petitioner in
specific terms made his claim for granting interest on the withheld amounts
of his post-retiral benefits in the previous litigation but the same was not
granted to him. Therefore, in the opinion of this Court, now under the colour
of a new cause of action based on the subsequent disbursement of such
benefits made to him by the respondents after the judgment of the previous
writ petition, the claim of granting interest again before the Court by filing a
fresh writ petition cannot be permitted to allow. It has become barred by the
principles of res-judicata in view of the Explanation-V of Section 11 of the
Code of Civil Procedure.
[23]
Considering thus, it is held that the present writ petition is
barred by the principles of res-judicata and accordingly, the same is
dismissed.
No order as to costs.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.04.30 17:04:18 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review