Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND PATHAK
FIRST APPEAL NO. 214 OF 2004
BETWEEN:KAILASH NARAYAN S/O JAGANNATH PRASAD
BHARGAVA, AGED 58 YEARS, OCCUPATION
-TEACHER R/O ASHOK VIHAR COLONY, T.V.
TOWER KE PAS, SHIVPURI (MADHYA PRADESH)
…..APPELLANT
(BY SHRI D.K. AGRAWAL - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
2.
SMT. SHYAMLATA W/O BRIJMOHAN AGED 69
YEARS, OCCUPATION -HOUSEWIFE R/O A.B.
ROAD,
SHIVPURI
DFISTRICT
SHIVPURI
(MADHYA PRADESH)
CHATUR BIHARI (DEAD) THROUGH L.RS.
(A) RAJ BIHARI LAL SHRIVASTAVA S/O LATE SH.
CHATUR
BIHARI
LAL
SHRIVASTAVA
OCCUPATION – ADVOCATE R/O ADARSH
COLONY SHIVPURI (MADHYA PRADESH)
(B) KRISHNA BIHARIIAL SHRIVASTAVA S/O LATE
SHRI CHATUR BIHARI LAL SHRIVASTAVA OCC.CONTACTOR R/O ADARSH COLONY SHIVPURI
(M.P.)
(C) SMT. PADMA KHARE S/O LATE SHRI CHATUR
BIHARI LAL SHRIVASTAVA (W/O SHRI JAGDISH
PRASAD KHARE) OCC. HOUSE WIFE R/O MAHAL
COLONY SHIVPURI (M.P.)
(D) SAT. KUSUM LATA D/O LATE SHRI CHATUR
BIHARI LAL SHRIVASTAVA W/O SHRI JAGDISH
PRASAD) OCC.- HOUSE WIFE R/O AWASH VIKAS
COLONY JHANSHI (U.P.)
(E) SMT. POONAM SHRIVASTAVA D/O LATE SHRI
CHATUR BIHARI LAL SHRIVASTAVA (W/O SHRI
MAITHLISHARAN SHRIVASTAVA) OCC.-HOUSE
WIFE R/O SIPRI BAZAR JHANSI (U.P.)
3.
(F) SMT. MADHU SHRIVASTAVA D/O LATE SHRI
CHATUR BIHARI LAL SHRIVASTAVA (W/O SHRI
RAJ KUMAR SHRIVASTAVA) OCC. HOUSE WIFE
R/O NEAR PITAMBARA PEETH DATIA (M.P.)
(G) SMT. ALKA SHRIVASTAVA D/O LATE SHRI
CHATUR BIHARI LAL SHRIVASTAVA (W/O SHRI
BHUVNESHWAR SHRIVASTAVA) OCC.- HOUSE
WIFE R/O VIVEKANAND COLONY SHIVPURI
(M.P.)
ASHUTOSH S/O KAILASH NARAYAN SHARMA,
AGED 29 YEARS, R/O SADAR BAZAAR, TEKARI
DISTRICT SHIVPURI (MADHYA PRADESH)
…..RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI RAM KRISHNA SONI – ADVOCATE FOR
RESPONDENT NO.1 AND SHRI H.K. SHUKLA – ADVOCATE
FOR RESPONDENTS NO.2 AND 3)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
:
12-12-2023
Delivered on
:
17-01-2024
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This appeal having been heard and reserved for orders coming on for
pronouncement this day, delivered the following:-
JUDGMENT
1.
The instant appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 is preferred by the appellant/defendant No.1/tenant being
crestfallen by the judgment and decree dated 23-08-2004 passed by
II Additional District Judge, Shivpuri in Civil Suit No.13-A/1996
whereby the suit of the plaintiff/respondent No.1 has been decreed.
2.
Facts in brief are that plaintiff/respondent No.1 Smt. Shyamlata
along with her husband Brijmohan Das (since deceased) filed a suit
for
eviction
and
arrears
of
rent
against
the
present
appellant/defendant No.1. Initially, two defendants were arrayed as
parties in which defendant No.2 – Chatur Bihari Shrivastava was a
person who stood guarantor for payment of rent, therefore, arrayed
as defendant.
3.
The suit was filed by the plaintiffs with the allegations that they are
having two storey house at Sadar Bazaar Tekari, Shivpuri of
ownership and possession of plaintiffs, four corners of which are
mentioned in the plaint. Defendant No.1 (Kailash Narayan present
appellant) took the said house (except some portion) for residential
purpose on 01-05-1994 on rent of Rs.2300/- per month as per the
rent note dated 01-05-1994 and conditions contained therein.
Defendant No.2 -Chatur Bihari Shrivastava stood guarantor for
payment of rent.
4.
Appellant/defendant No.1 as per the agreement, paid rent till 15-041995 and thereafter stopped paying rent to the landlords. Receipt
for the rent was given by the plaintiffs to defendant No.1 and last
receipt is of 15-04-1995 for paying rent till March, 1995. Since 0104-1995 payment was not made. As per condition No.12 of the rent
note, some rooms which were in possession of plaintiffs were taken
by defendant No.1 with forcible possession and therefore, on report
of plaintiffs, police intervened and gave possession of the said
rooms to the plaintiffs.
5.
It is the allegation of plaintiffs that defendant No.1 without
permission from the plaintiffs used the house for the purpose of
school (commercial activities) and changed the use of tenancy
from residential to commercial. Plaintiffs wanted to live in house
because the house was situated in the center of city of Shivpuri
and is easily accessible, therefore, they have bona fide
requirement for personal use.
6.
Against defendant No.3 -Ashutosh (impleaded later) it was the
allegation of plaintiffs that Ashutosh is son of defendant No.1
and he colluded with defendant No.1 and by misrepresentation
defendant No.1 got his son adopted by plaintiffs by way of
registered Adoption Deed. Later on realising the mischief at the
hands of defendant No.1, for cancellation of said Adoption Deed,
a suit has been filed by the plaintiff before III Civil Judge Class
-II, Shivpuri. Defendant No.3 colluded with defendant No.1 to the
extent that he represented himself as landlord. Defendant No.1
also mentioned the fact in his reply to the notice that since
defendant No.3 is receiving rent w.e.f. 01-04-1995, therefore,
there is no arrears of rent exists and all rent has been duly paid to
landlord.
7.
According to plaintiff total arrears of rent between 01-04-1995 to
31-01-1996 (total 10 months) comes to Rs.23,000/- and with
interest its comes to Rs.24,265/- which plaintiff deserves to
receive from defendant No.1. On this ground also, eviction decree
be drawn against the defendants.
8.
Contesting defendant – Kailash Narayan/present appellant filed
his written statement and contested the case. According to
appellant/defendant No.1 right of recovery of rent lies with
plaintiffs as well as their son Ashutosh (defendant No.3 herein)
and since Ashutosh had the right to receive the rent, therefore,
rent has been received by him and defendant No.1 paid this rent
to defendant No.3. In the disputed house, one room is occupied by
defendant No.3 and some other rooms are occupied by the
plaintiffs. Use of the house is in possession of defendant No.1.
Since that part which is occupied by defendant No.3, a school is
being run and one room is occupied by defendant No.3, therefore,
defendant No.1 is not liable for payment of rent since payment
which is to be made to him, is to be determined, therefore,
provisional rent be fixed.
9.
Defendant No.1 raised the plea of Adoption Deed also by which
defendant No.3 who is biological son of defendant No.1 allegedly
adopted by plaintiff vide Adoption Deed dated 26-07-1994, the
date on which deed was registered. As submitted, since he is an
adopted son of plaintiff, therefore, as per Section 16 of the
Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, it would be
presumed that documents of adoption are proper till they are set
aside as per law.
10.
Since defendant No.1 has given rent to defendant No.3, therefore,
the case of arrears of rent does not arise. In special objections, it
has been mentioned by defendant No.1 that before the Rent
Controlling Authority, Shivpuri an application has been filed by
plaintiff against the defendants, therefore, present case is not
maintainable. Since plaintiff has filed another suit against
defendant No.3 for rescinding the Adoption Deed before the
competent civil Court, therefore, till the civil suit is decided, this
case is not maintainable.
11.
Defendant No.2 also filed formal written statement.
12.
Defendant No.3 Ashutosh also filed written statement and referred
the fact of adoption by the plaintiff. It is his submission that on
01-05-1994 house was given by plaintiff to defendant No.1 on
rent. On 26-07-1994 defendant No.3 went to the plaintiffs through
registered Adoption Deed as their son, therefore, he also had a
claim over the property. Since 01-05-1995, one room has been
taken by defendant No.3 for his personal use and defendant No.1
is running his school namely, Shakti Shikshan Sansthan.
13.
It is also submitted that defendant No.3 is receiving rent from
defendant No.1 and receipts are given accordingly. Rent by
defendant No.1 has been given to the plaintiff till 31-03-1995 and
since 01-04-1995 being owner of the house, defendant No.3 is
receiving the rent.
14.
He denied collusion with defendant No.1 and submits that
plaintiff has levelled the false allegation of collusion against him
and defendant No.1. He is validly adopted by the plaintiff.
Plaintiff No.1 Brijmohan has expired and he has all rights as son
and he is Karta of Hindu undivided family in which plaintiff
-Shyamlata is a member only. She cannot prosecute the civil suit
alone. Since adoption of son /daughter cannot be rescinded or set
side under Hindu Law and status of son cannot be terminated,
therefore, this suit is not maintainable till other case is decided
whereby plaintiff has filed a suit against defendant No.3 for
setting aside of Adoption Deed.
15.
Learned counsel for the appellant Shri Agrawal canvassed the
arguments in detail. It is submitted by learned counsel for the
appellant that written tenancy has been alleged from 01-05-1994
for 11 months, however document i.e. alleged Tenancy Agreement
has not been produced in evidence by the plaintiff. Entire
conclusions are unsustainable because trial Court misled and
misinterpreted Section 35 of the Indian Stamps Act, 1899
(hereinafter referred to as “the Stamps Act”) and ignored Sections
91 and 92 of Indian Evidence. In absence of “Material Facts” and
“Material
Particulars”,
suit
itself
was
not
maintainable.
Unstamped tenancy agreement neither in the shape of secondary
evidence is admissible nor contents of the said agreement can be
read in evidence even though stated in oral statement. He relied
upon (1971) 1 SCC 545 Jupudi Kesava Rao Vs. Pulavarthi
Venkata Subbarao and others.
16.
Once unstamped document of tenancy allegedly created on 05-051995 between the appellant/defendant No.1/tenant and defendant
No.3 was found inadmissible in evidence by the trial Court in
terms of Section 35 of the Stamps Act then alleged tenancy
agreement dated 01-05-1994 between the appellant and plaintiff
has also become inadmissible in evidence. No decree can be
passed on such inadmissible document even if the parties have
admitted existence of such document. He relied upon Yasoda
Amaal Vs. Janaki Ammal AIR 1968 Madras 264 (DB),
Mallappa Vs. Nalam Naga Shetty AIR 1919 Madras 833,
Alapati Achutaramana Vs. Nasireddi Jagannadham AIR 1933
Madras 117. Tenancy agreement dated 01-05-1994 neither
exhibited in evidence nor admitted in evidence because it was
never produced before the Court, therefore, there is no question of
applicability of Section 36 of the Indian Stamps Act and
relaxation of Section 36 of the Stamps Act
would not be
attracted. He relied upon the judgments of Apex Court in the
cases of 2009 (2) SCC 532, Avinash Kumar Chauhan Vs. Vijay
Krishna Mishra, (2018) 7 SCC 646 Shyam Narayan Prasad
Vs. Krishna Prasad and Ors., (2015) 14 SCC 341 Nanjappan
Vs. Ramasamy and Ors, (2015) 9 SCC 287 S.M. Asif Vs.
Virender Kumar Bajaj and (2008) 5 SCC 58 Vimlesh Kumari
Kulshrestha vs. Sambhajirao and another.
17.
Uncertainty of description of property is palpably proved.
Description of disputed property was not sufficiently elaborated
to identify the property in dispute. He refers the submission of
plaintiff (PW-1) in this regard to submit that in absence of clear
identification of property, trial Court erred in passing the
impugned judgment and decree. He relied upon 2020 (3) MPLJ
173 Satish Kumar Khandelwal Vs. Rajendra Jain.
18.
The ground for eviction under Section 12(1)(c) of the M.P.
Accommodation Control Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the
Act of 1961) as framed in issue No.6 was in fact abandoned by
the order dated 07-04-2003 by the trial Court. However
observations and findings in para 37 to 43 of the impugned
judgment has been recorded by the trial Court which resulted into
miscarriage of justice. The observations/findings of Court below
regarding collusion between defendant No.1 and 3 resulted into
miscarriage of justice. There was no collusion between the two
parties (defendant No.1 and 3) and still findings have been given.
19.
It is further submitted that once the adjudication over issue
No.2(c) was not pressed by the plaintiff and no evidence was led
by the plaintiff, trial Court committed serious error of law on
procedure in holding that rent of the arrears from 01-04-1995 and
non payment of rent by defendant No.1 to the plaintiff has
resulted in collusion between defendant No.1 to 3. Similarly
existence of document Ex-D/122 (consent letter of plaintiff No.1
Brijmohan Das in favour of defendant No.3) in which payment of
rent was permissible for defendant No.3 to receive and because
of that document, plea of arrears of rent does not stand to legal
scrutiny. Document dated 15-08-1994 Ex-D/122 is title document
in the case and was jointly executed by plaintiff No.1 -Brijmohan
Das and plaintiff's adopted son Ashutosh -defendant No.3. Trial
Court decided the suit without considering the said aspect and
caused illegality.
20.
Learned counsel for the appellant referred testimony
of the
appellant (DW-1) to submit that it was known to the plaintiff that
appellant used to run a school that too with the consent of the
plaintiff. According to him, adoption deed dated 26-07-1994 till
passing of the impugned judgment dated 23-08-2004, adoption
deed was in existence and was operative. Although thereafter trial
Court allowed the suit filed by the plaintiff and cancelled the
adoption deed vide impugned judgment dated 02-02-2005,
however said dissolution of adoption deed does not come in the
way of appellant as defendant No.1.
21.
According to learned counsel for appellant, findings are arrived at
without proper pleadings and necessary issues, therefore, same
cannot bind any of the parties to the suit.
22.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent No.1/plaintiff
who is contesting respondent in the case opposed the prayer and
supported the impugned judgment. According to learned counsel
for respondent No.1, the appellant -Kailash Narayan and
respondent No.3/defendant No.3 with collusion denied title of
respondent No.1. Once Ashutosh/defendant No.3 had no right
over the property, appellant Kailash Narayan cannot take shelter
on the ground that rent was paid to defendant No.3 Ashutosh.
Once the tenancy is admitted, the amount of rent is also admitted
thus, the appellant was bound to comply the provisions of Section
13(1) of the Act of 1961 as from the date of notice, appellant was
bound to deposit the rent before the trial Court.
23.
In the present case, appellant failed to comply the provisions of
Section 13(1) of the Act of 1961 and during pendency of the case
also he did not deposit the rent, therefore, the trial Court rightly
passed the impugned judgment and decree on the ground under
Section 12(1)(a) of the Act of 1961.
24.
It is further submitted that rent note dated 01-05-1994 is admitted
by the appellant in the written statement and in his deposition also
as DW-1 and rent note dated 01-05-1994 was filed along with
plaint as part of the plaint and in such rent note whole description
of the property was mentioned. Therefore, the submission of
appellant that description was not properly written lacks merits. It
is further submitted by learned counsel for respondent No.1 that
admitted facts need not to be required to be proved as per Order
XII Rule 2 A of the CPC and also as per Section 58 of the
Evidence Act. Once the rent note is admitted by the appellant as
DW-1 in his pleadings and deposition then in view of such
admission, the concerned document need not to be admitted in
evidence. When appellant/defendant No.1 admitted the said
document even during cross-examination also and never raised
the objection, therefore, at a later stage, it is not thus proper for
him to raise grievance at the time of final hearing of suit or at the
time of hearing of first appeal.
25.
Clear finding has been recorded by the trial Court regarding
collusion between the appellant and defendant No.3 Ashutosh
because Ashutosh was biological son of appellant and after
tenancy they forged the document of Adoption Deed in such a
fashion in which plaintiff had to go to the Civil Court for
cancellation of such Adoption Deed. Incidentally, vide judgment
dated 02-02-2005, the trial Court decreed the suit of respondent
No.1 and adoption deed was declared as void by the Court of
Civil Judge Class -I Shivpuri in case No.102-A/2002. Therefore,
collusion stood proved.
26.
According to learned counsel for respondent No.1, arguments
advanced by learned counsel for the appellant before this Court
are contrary to the record. Trial Court rightly passed the
impugned judgment and decree against the appellant under
Section 12(1)(a), 12(1)(c) and 12(1)(o) of the Act of 1961. He
relied upon 1996 (2) MPWN SN 143 Nand Kishore Vs.
Ramniwas, 2004(3) MPLJ 162 Devendra s/o Chandmal
Choudhary Vs. Warsilal s/o Diwanchandji Dua, 2005(2)
MPLJ 583 Meenamal Vs. Madan Mohan Agrawal, 2008(1)
MPLJ 349
Indira Kumari d/o Sagarmalji Jain, 2008(3)
MPLJ 239 Vraj s/o Baldev Prasad Sharma Vs. Ina Devnani
w/o Ramesh Devnani and others, 2009(3) MPLJ 445
Sahibram Dhindra Vs. Shivshankar Goyal and 2011 (1) MPLJ
675 Neelu Bai Vs. Phagumal s/o Ishwardas. Thus, prayed for
dismissal of this appeal.
27.
Counsel for respondent No.3, Ashutosh also advanced the
arguments and supported the arguments of appellant.
28.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the
record of the case.
29.
In the case in hand, appellant is taking exception to the judgment
and decree dated 23-08-2004 passed by II Additional District
Judge, Shivpuri in Civil Suit No.13-A/1996 whereby the suit of the
plaintiff (respondent No.1 herein) has been decreed and appellant
has been directed to evict the suit premises.
30.
This case has very peculiar factual contours. Initially, plaintiffs
filed a suit for eviction against defendant No.1/tenant. Later, on
the occasion of death of plaintiff No.1 Brijmohan, defendant No.3
Ashutosh tried to implead himself as plaintiff by moving an
application under Order XXII Rule 3 CPC but failed partly. Trial
Court declined to implead him as plaintiff, but impleaded him as
defendant No.3. As defendant No.3 also, he supported defendant
No.1, rather than plaintiff.
31.
Interestingly he claimed himself to be the adopted son of plaintiff
and for that he relied upon the adoption deed 26-07-1994
allegedly executed by the plaintiff
to adopt defendant No.3
Ashutosh. After being adopted allegedly, he should have lived
with the adopted parents (plaintiffs herein) and had to shoulder
the responsibility as their son, but he continued to align with
defendant No.1 and the whole pleadings and evidence revolves
round the collusion between defendant No.1 and defendant No.3
to frustrate the cause of plaintiff.
32.
Trial Court in a very candid manner discussed in details about
collusion and rightly held that because of the fraud perpetrated
over the plaintiff by the collusion of defendant No.1 and
defendant No.3, their evidence deserve to be discarded
evidence of plaintiff
and
was rightly appreciated. Although issue
No.6 which was framed earlier was deleted by order dated 07-042003 by trial Court but it had different tenor and texture of
collusion. It was regarding grabbing of property by collusion.
However, trial Court could always resort to facts regarding
collusion to arrive to its conclusion. Otherwise, it would have
been the travesty of justice and it would have amounted to
perpetuate fraud.
33.
In the case in hand, plaintiffs averred in relation to fraud being
perpetrated over them by defendant No.1 (and defendant No.3) in
relation to adoption deed. It is settled in law that fraud vitiates all
solemn proceedings. Here action of appellant suggests that he and
defendant No.3 played fraud over plaintiffs, initially by adoption
deed and later in their deposition.
34.
It is well settled principle of law that Fraud Vitiates Everything.
This principle has been dealt with by the Apex Court in its various
judgments viz. in the case of R. Ravindra Reddy Vs. H. Ramaiah
Reddy, (2010) 3 SCC 214, Badami Bai (D) Tr. L.R. Vs. Bhali,
(2012) 11 SCC 574, Uddar Gagan Properties Ltd. Vs. Sant
Singh, (2016) 11 SCC 378, K.D. Sharma Vs. SAIL, (2008) 12
SCC 481, Express Newspapers (P) Ltd. Vs. Union of India,
(1986) 1 SCC 133, DDA Vs. Skipper Construction, (2007) 15
SCC 601 and in the case of Jai Narain Parasrampuria Vs.
Pushpa Devi Saraf, reported in (2006) 7 SCC 756. In
Ravindra Reddy (supra), the Apex Court held as under:
R.
“39. As far as fraud is concerned, it is no doubt true,
as submitted by Mr Ramachandran, that fraud vitiates
all actions taken pursuant thereto and in Lord
Denning’s words “fraud unravels everything.......”
35.
This is the ground alone on which decree could have been passed.
Because this aspect has been discussed and held against
defendants by the trial Court in detail and different paragraphs of
impugned judgment. This Court affirms such finding and intends
to discuss it one by one, from para No.15 itself. When rent note
dated 01-05-1994 executed between plaintiff and defendant No.1
was admitted by defendant No.1 Kailash Narayan in his evidence
in different paragraphs, then to frustrate that evidence, defendant
No.3 moved an application under Section 35 of the Stamps Act to
submit that neither such document has been exhibited nor stamp
duty with penalty has been paid over the said document,
therefore, document is inadmissible in evidence. When defendant
No.3 happens to be the adopted son of plaintiff then if he goes
against the interest of his own parents, then it is the question
which required discussion and rightly discussed in detail by the
trial Court. Defendant No.3 is biological son of defendant No.1,
therefore,
it appears that to save his biological father from
eviction, he subterfuged the cause of plaintiff and her legitimate
claim. When trial Court did not consider the said plea then, a writ
petition was also filed vide Writ Petition No.857 of 2004 with the
prayer that defendant No.1 be removed as party defendant so
that defendant No.3 may proceed with trial. On close scrutiny, it
appears that collusion was writ large and they were playing with
the plaintiff.
Regarding collusion between defendant No.1 and defendant
No.3:
36.
It is worth mentioning the fact that adoption deed by which
defendant No.3 was allegedly tried to establish himself as
adopted son of plaintiff
was challenged by the plaintiff in
different proceedings by way of Civil Suit No.102-A/2002 RCS
and vide judgment dated 02-02-2005 adoption deed was declared
void by Civil Judge Class -I, Shivpuri. Appeal was preferred by
defendant No.3 and the said appeal No.53-A/2005 was also
dismissed vide judgment dated 24-03-2005. Thereafter, second
appeal was preferred vide Second Appeal No.464/2005 and the
same was also dismissed vide judgment dated 09-11-2005 and
thereafter Special Leave Petition (Civil) No.2941/2006 was
preferred and the same was also dismissed vide order dated 1702-2006. All the orders/judgments
were placed
on record,
therefore, it was not a case simplicitor of eviction. In fact it is a
case where plaintiffs were fighting for eviction of tenant (since
1996) in which collusion of defendant No.1 and defendant No.3
was established through their conduct.
37.
Very cleverly, defendant No.3 raised the plea that on 05-05-1995
a rent note was executed between defendant No.1 and defendant
No.3 which was not exhibited by the defendants but tried to rely
upon on the ground that rent was given by defendant No.1 to
defendant No.3 w.e.f. 01-04-1995 but the trial Court did not find
relationship of landlord and tenant between defendant No.1 and
defendant No.3 as established because it was tainted with
collusion. Without attornment, relationship of landlord -tenant
could not have been established. In para 19 of the impugned
judgment, this aspect has been discussed in detail. In para 21, 22
and 23 also the fact of collusion has been discussed in detail.
Trial Court
held that when the order dated 12-01-2004 was
passed by the Court directing defendant No.1 not to pay rent to
defendant No.3 but to be paid to the plaintiff then on 26-02-2004
defendant No.1 made an application before the trial Court with
the allegations that on 31-01-2004, defendant No.3 evicted him
from the suit premises. Reason shown was solemnization of
marriage of defendant No.3 and his consequent requirement of
space for his family.
38.
However, in his deposition, defendant No.3 makes a statement
that he does not remember about fixing of provisional rent which
is to be given to the plaintiff. Here the question arises when
defendant No.1 was already evicted as deposed by defendant
No.1 then why he was litigating with such vehemence against his
own biological son. Therefore, the plea of defendant No.1 gets
falsified. In paragraphs 27, 28 and 30 of the impugned judgment
the plea of fraud, collusion and misrepresentation of facts were
again discussed in detail. Trial Court categorically held that
defendant No.1 and defendant No.3 were making
false
statements on record just to frustrate the cause of plaintiffs.
Therefore, on the plea of fraud, collusion and misrepresentation
of facts, trial Court rightly appreciated the evidence available on
record and passed the impugned judgment. Defendants No.1 and
3 cannot be given premium to their mischief and collusion.
For that, any separate issue was not required to be framed. On
grounds available, element of Fraud and misrepresentation had to
be seen.
39.
One more fact deserves consideration is that against the judgment
and decree dated 23-08-2004, defendant No.3 preferred First
Appeal No.242/2004 but the same was dismissed because decree
was not at all against him. Preferring First Appeal when he did not
suffer any adversity, further smacked fraud and malice.
Regarding decree under Section 12(1)(a) of the Act:
40.
Plaintiffs in their plaint have specifically pleaded in para 3 that
on 01-05-1994 tenancy was created by the plaintiffs in favour of
defendant No.1 by way of rent note dated 01-05-1994 on
Rs.2300/- per month rent in which defendant No.2 stood as
guarantor. It was further averred in para 4 that rent till 31-031995 rent was paid by defendant No.1. On 15-04-1995 and
thereafter he stopped paying rent. Plaintiffs always used to give
receipts to the defendant No.1 for the rent deposited but after
01-04-1995 defendant No.1 never paid rent. Thereafter, plaintiffs
sent a registered AD notice to defendant No.1 and on 25-09-1995
notice returned back with the endorsement that defendant No.1
moved out of town. On 05-10-1995 again registered notice was
given which was received by defendant No.1 on 07-10-1995.
Those notices and rent receipts were duly exhibited. Since as per
the rent note, 11 months tenancy existed which was to be
renewed but neither it was renewed nor any rent was paid to the
plaintiffs. Therefore, arrears of rent accumulated and not paid.
41.
Incidentally, defendant No.1 admitted the fact about rent note but
made a specific pleading that biological son of defendant No.1
namely Ashutosh who is arrayed as defendant No.3 was adopted
by the plaintiffs
vide adoption deed dated 26-07-1994 and
therefore, he became the landlord by virtue of adoption deed.
From 01-04-1995 defendant No.1 started paying rent
to
defendant No.3 who according to defendant No.1 became
landlord of the house and therefore, he started giving him the
rent. That aspect has been duly considered by the trial Court
while considering issue No.1, 2(a) and 2(b). It is worth
mentioning the fact that while deciding issue No.2(a) and 2(b),
trial Court again discussed the fact of collusion because as
discussed earlier, this case suffers from peculiarity of collusion
between defendant No.1 and defendant No.3 in which defendant
No.3 misused the document or his position to the detriment of the
plaintiffs. Assertion of defendant No.1 that since 01-04-1995 he
started
paying rent to defendant No.3 lacks merits because
defendant No.3 had no authority to take rent from defendant
No.1.
42.
Tenancy in the present case started from 01-05-1994 and as per
the specific submission of defendant No.1, adoption of defendant
No.3 was undertaken on 26-07-1994 by way of adoption deed. It
means that when landlord tenant relationship established between
plaintiffs and defendant No.1 on 01-05-1994 at that time,
defendant No.3 Ashutosh was not in picture in any manner as
landlord, even if for a minute it is assumed that adoption deed was
valid. Therefore, at the time of establishment of landlord tenant
relationship on 01-05-1994 when defendant No.3 was not in
picture and thereafter Attornment was never done by plaintiffs
vis-a-vis Ashutosh (defendant No.3) then Ashutosh had no
authority to accept rent and in fact payment of rent to the
Ashutosh was amounting to denial of title to the plaintiffs about
their landlordship which would be discussed under different head
under Section 12(1)(c) of the Act.
43.
So far as arrears of rent is concerned it was never paid to the
plaintiffs. If intention of defendant No.1 would have been guided
by bona fide then he would have paid rent after the order dated
12-01-2004 passed by the Court directing the defendant No.1 to
pay rent to the plaintiffs but instead of paying rent, defendant
No.1 demonstrated that he removed his possession from the suit
property.
If defendant No.3 or plaintiffs
would have taken
possession from defendant No.1 then he certainly would have
lodged the report or filed any legal proceedings but he did not
prefer to do so. Therefore, it shows the wickedness of the mind
and it appears that arrears of rent caused dent to the case of
defendant No.1. Trial Court rightly passed the judgment on the
point of arrears of rent. Issues No.1, 2(a), 2(b) and 5 were
discussed in detail.
Regarding decree under Section 12(1)(c) of the Act.
44.
Defendant No.1 although admitted the contents of rent note and in
his examination-in-chief itself mentioned the fact that tenancy
started on 05-05-1995 @ Rs.2300/- per month with the plaintiffs.
In para 13 he admitted that he executed the rent note on 01-051994 in favour of plaintiffs. He reiterated this fact time and
again. Therefore, it is clearly established that he accepted the
plaintiffs as his landlord and therefore, submission of defendant
No.1 that he started giving rent to defendant No.3 from May,
1995 appears to be a step placing the landlordship in favour of
defendant No.3 thus denying title to plaintiffs. In effect, he did
so. He allegedly started paying rent to defendant No.3 and since
May, 1995 he never paid rent to the plaintiffs. When trial Court
issued the direction
plaintiffs
on 12-01-2004 to pay the rent
to the
then he raised the plea that he left the tenanted
premises. Whereas, he never vacated the premises which itself is
clear from the instant appeal preferred by him. If he would have
vacated the suit premises, then why he preferred this appeal, for
which no convincing answer was given by counsel for the
appellant.
45.
In para 19 of the impugned judgment, it was discussed by trial
Court and rightly so, that tenancy was given for residential
purpose only in 1994. In fact defendant No.1 himself pleaded and
admitted that a school “Shakti Shikshan Sansthan” was being run
since 1985 but this fact could not be proved by defendant No.1
that school was run prior to execution of rent note on 01-05-1994.
Therefore, after discarding the documents pertaining to school,
like its registration certificate etc. trial Court rightly held that
defendant No.1 changed the use of tenanted premises.
46.
When defendant No.1 did not pay arrears of rent and took the
plea that he is paying rent to defendant No.3 who was not
landlord in any manner then it amounts to placing the
title/landlordship in some other person and amounting to denial
of title to the plaintiffs. Element of collusion was also discussed
in detail in this issue, by trial Court. Therefore,
trial Court
rightly decreed the suit on the point of Section 12(1)(c) of the Act
also.
47.
At the cost of repetition, it is reiterated that submission of
defendant No.1 that rent note dated 01-05-1994 was not exhibited
or properly stamped, therefore, it cannot be read in evidence is a
misconceived argument. Defendant No.1 in his pleading
deposition as
and
DW-1 categorically admitted in different
paragraphs that rent note was executed between plaintiffs and
defendant No.1 vide rent note dated 01-05-1994 and tenancy was
created. Such admission does not require any document to be
exhibited. Defendant No.1 even accepted receiving of notice and
impliedly admitted that he never paid rent after May, 1995.
Payment of rent to defendant No.3 was no payment in the eyes of
law made to the landlord.
Regarding decree under Section 12(1)(o) of the Act.
48.
It was specifically pleaded by the plaintiffs that one platform
was constructed over which defendant No.1 runs school and said
platform was never given on rent. On the said platform, four
shops were constructed
in which two
shops were forcibly
occupied by defendants No.1 and 3. Police report was also made
in this regard and one private complaint was filed as well. An
application was also preferred before the Rent Controlling
Authority. Therefore, defendant No.1 and 3 were in unauthorized
possession of a portion of the accommodation not included in the
lease/rent note. Defendant No.3 in his own deposition admitted
the fact that on 01-05-1994 rent note was executed between the
plaintiffs and defendant No.1 and admitted that two shops are in
his possession and two shops are in possession of his mother. It
means that he took possession of the area which was not given
by the plaintiffs
to defendant No.1 as tenant. Deposition of
plaintiff Shyamlata (PW-1) remained unrebutted in this regard.
Therefore,
on
this count also, looking to the evidence of
defendants No.1 and 3, it is established that they were in
unauthorized possession of a portion of the accommodation not
included in the lease/rent note.
Accordingly, the suit of plaintiff is rightly decreed under
Section 12(1)(a), 12(1)(c) and 12(1)(o) of the Act.
49.
Judgments relied upon by learned counsel for the appellant are of
no help to him as they move in different factual realm and the
plea of collusion is such glaring in this case which over shadows
other aspects of the matter. Therefore, in those judgments relied
by appellant, peculiar factual matrix was not available. Beside
that, when existence of documents were specifically admitted
then trial Court did not err in concluding the existence of such
documents and its contents.
50.
In the conspectus of facts and circumstances of the case, the
judgment passed by the trial Court is hereby affirmed and suit of
respondent No.1/plaintiff is decreed under Section 12(1)(a), 12(1)
(c) and 12(1)(o) of the Act. Accordingly, the appeal preferred by
the appellant fails and is hereby dismissed.
51.
I.A.No.5155/2019 an application for recalling of order dated 3101-2019
at
the
instance
of
appellant/defendant
No.1,
I.A.No.3209/2020 an application for vacating stay at the instance
of respondent No.1/plaintiff, I.A.No.2223/2019, an application
under
Section
13(6)
by
respondent
No.1/plaintiff
and
I.A.No.206/2021, an application under Order XX Rule 26 of CPC
by the plaintiffs are also considered. Since the matter is decided
finally
by this Court
by the instant judgment
and
these
applications are primarily in respect of interim rent/vacating stay
etc. therefore, in view of the judgment passed by this Court, all
these applications stand disposed of in the light of the decision of
this Court reflected through this judgment. All these applications
stand closed.
52.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the trial Court for information
and necessary compliance.
(ANAND PATHAK)
JUDGE
Anil*
ANIL
KUMAR
CHAURASI
YA
CHAURASIYA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA
PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR, ou=HIGH
COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=8512f40a1a9eaa50b6802d068b5
1dae27e84c266b09d283f0799e67cdc7df5
0f, postalCode=474001, st=Madhya
Pradesh,
serialNumber=EC534CBB3B245F050119F
06F4A296DD83C765A1E2ACC6EC7D8BD
8CBCC9C2446E, cn=ANIL KUMAR
CHAURASIYA
Date: 2024.01.17 17:54:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review